dust to gold dust pdf
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
1/23
Suggestions By V.I.G.Menon,CEOYahovan Centre For Excellence,
Chennai,India
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
2/23
The Osmotic Model Of theCriminal Justice System
S = Society P = Prisons
Low Intensivity: System with Low Incarceration Rate
High Intensivity: System with High Incarceration Rate
CJS (the criminal Justice System ) = The membrane which sends
people to Prison
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
3/23
The CJS Process :Intensivity& the Buildup
Law Enforcement
AdjudicationCorrection
SocietyOffendersSlow Release
Pretrial Incarceration
Undertrials
Sentenced
The Red Arrows Indicate High Absorption Rateand the Blue Arrowshows Slow Release RateCausing Excessive Prison Buildup
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
4/23
The Osmotic Model Of aBiasedCriminal Justice System
S = Society
with
about
10 %
Red Dots
P = Prisons with80% Red Dots
CJS (the criminal Justice System ) = The membrane which sends
people to Prison
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
5/23
Two Issues For the US CJS
Issue No 1: High Intensivity Causing
High Incarceration Rate
Issue No 2.: High Selectivity Causing
distorted Prison Population Distribution
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
6/23
Issue 1.Intensivity:Potential Causes
Why More ofOur Citizens
are inPrisonsComparedwith
another
Country ?
A.Our People are More Criminallydisposed
B.The CJS (Criminal Justice System) is hyper sensitive
Remember :These are the Only Possible Fundamental Causes
CJS (the criminal Justice System ) = The membrane which sendspeople to Prison
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
7/23
Issue1. Causal Analysis As there are only two fundamental
causes ,we list themA. Our People are More Criminally disposed
A is not tenable since by circular reasoning it will imply the Govt also
is voted and run by such Citizens Thus we conclude
B.The CJS (Criminal Justice System) is hyper
sensitive We will Analyse this factor B in Later slides while
we take up Issue 2 in the Next Slide
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
8/23
Why MoreReds are
in thePrison
thoughthey are aMinority?
C.Reds are More Criminally disposed
D.The CJS (Criminal Justice System) is a
biased filer
Issue 2 .Selectivity:Potential Causes
Remember :These are the Only Possible Fundamental Causes
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
9/23
Issue 2. Causal Analysis
As there are only two fundamentalcauses here again ,we list them
C. Reds are More Criminally disposed
Possible, we will Analyse this factor Later Thus we conclude
D.The CJS (Criminal Justice System) is a
biased filter
Possible again, and we will Analyse this factor too
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
10/23
Why highincarcera-tion Rate ?
E..Higher Inflow (into Prisons)
F.Slower Release From Prisons
Issue 1 .IntensivityProcess Factors
Remember :These are the Only Possible Fundamental Causes
G.Low Reabsorption Of theReformed
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
11/23
Another Look at Issue1.Process Analysis OfIntensivity
Law Enforcement
Adjudication
Correction
SocietyOn ReleaseOr On Parole
Pretrial Incarceration
UndertrialsSentenced
Low Reabsorption Of the Reformed
Offenders &
Repeat Offenders
Prison IndustryThriving OnHuge Buildup
Wrong Social
ProgrammingOf the Officers
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
12/23
Why highincarcera-tion Rate ?
E..Higher Inflow (into Prisons)
F.Slower Release From Prisons
Issue 1 .IntensivityProcess Factors
G.Low Reabsorption Of theReformed
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
13/23
Issue 1.IntensivityFunctional Analysis Of Potential CauseB:
:CJS is Hyper Sensitive
CJS
isHyper
Sensitive
Law Enforcementis Hyper Sensitive
AdjudicationProclivity forIncarceration
Correctional
Errors,
Delays &Holdups
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
14/23
Issue 2.SelectivityFunctional Analysis Of Potential CauseC:
Reds( Some Minorities?) are More Criminally disposed
RedsAre
More
CriminallyDisposed
Poor Social /GovtSupport Network
(Social Cause)
Poverty(Material Cause)
LowEducation
(Intellectual Cause)
High Levels
Of Mental Disorders(Emotional /Spiritual
Causes)
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
15/23
Issue 2.Functional Analysis
PotentialCauseD.The CJS is a biased filter
CJSis
Selective
Law Enforcementis Selective
AdjudicationSelectivity forIncarceration
Of CertainMinorities
Correctional
Selectivity inDetention &
Retention
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
16/23
CURING THE DISEASEThe Mission Design Inputs
Deliverable I.Reduced Intensivity Of the CJS
Drivers: (A)Reduced Inflow into Prisons(B) Reduced Retention Capacity in the Prisons(C) Increased Release Rate From the Prisons(D) Increased Reabsorption By the Society
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
17/23
Deliverable II.Reduced Selectivity Of the CJS
Drivers : (A)Reduced Labileness of the Minorities to Crimes(B) Reduced Labileness Of CJS for Minority Incarcerations
CURING THE DISEASEThe Mission Design Inputs
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
18/23
Missions-A Matrix approach
Management Mission
Support Mission
Core Mission
Culture Mission
PublicFamily Of the
Culprits
Victims/Affected
Correction
Adjudication
Enforcement
SocietyCJS Apparatus
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
19/23
Missions In Brief:Culture Mission
Should Aim to Bring Down Crime-
Proneness Of Society,Culture Of Respectfor Victims and their Families,Concern Forthe Offenders Family,Rehabilitation and
Reabsorption of the Redeemed intoSociety,Involvement Of Spiritual Leaders
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
20/23
Identifying & Operationalising CJS
Reforms to Address Intensiveness andSelectivity
Missions In Brief:Core Mission
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
21/23
Involving, Media, Local Governments,
Religious Bodies,NGOS for HarmoniousReduction Of Lability,Intensiveness andSelectivity
Missions In Brief:Support Mission
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
22/23
Missions In Brief:Management Mission
Formulating Vision and Creating Timeframes at All
Levels
Identifying ,Developing and deploying
Nation,State,District,County wide Mission Leaders
Identifying Electoral, Legislative,AdministrativeIssues & interfaces for debottlenecking the Missions
Creating and Managing the
Physical,Intellectual,Social and SpiritualResourcebase for the Mission Deployment
-
8/9/2019 Dust to Gold Dust PDF
23/23
Vision , Mission & Processes Vision
CoreCulture Support Mgmt
Federal
Processes
State andLocalProcesses