fiction industry short essay
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/7/2019 Fiction Industry Short Essay
1/7
Sarah Pearson 20304366
Topic: Why do we read books?
Abstract: Reading has become popularised by such works as the Harry Potter
and Twilight series, to the point where even less literary novels have become the
subject of a cult mentality. The question is: are people reading the books
because theyre good, or because theyre popular? And how much of a
difference does it make?
It seems self-evident to say that there are many reasons that people read books.
However, sometimes those reasons can combine in ways that make it difficult to
discern the true source of the particular novel or series popularity. Is it the
marketing hype thats making a certain work rocket up the bestsellers list? Or is
it because the novels have been boosted by word of mouth? In truth, they both
function to get people reading, but when marketing gets a hold on a book with
grass-roots popularity, it becomes nearly impossible to tell where one type of
popular recognition ends and the other begins. Put simply: ...aggressive
marketing...describes a critical problem: the novels and the hype become
intertwined, resulting in analyses that fail to take into account the full complexity
of either.1 But the problematic nature of discerning marketing from text must
be attempted, as ...it is both realistic and necessary to separate the books fromthe marketing2, and furthermore the only way to elucidate the effect and
meaning of either is to look at both aspects, individually, as well as in concert.
Focusing mainly on the current phenomenon of J.K. Rowlings Harry Potterseries,
the past craze surrounding J.R.R. Tolkiens The Lord of the Rings, and with some
discussion of the most recent cult engulfing the vampire romance novels of
Stephenie Meyer, the aim of this essay will be to look at the way marketing and
popularity interact, and how these elements function to create readers and fan
bases well beyond the authors expectations.
When a novel begins attracting widespread reader attention, as Harry Potter and
the Philosophers Stone did in late 1998, selling 70,000 copies in the UK...3, the
world of marketing and merchandise often follows in its wake. For Rowling, the
film deal with Warner Brothers came even as the second novel hit shelves
1 Philip Nel, Is There a text in This Advertising Campaign?: Literature, Marketing and
Harry Potter, p.2362 Ibid, p.2373 Ibid. p.244
Page 1 of7
-
8/7/2019 Fiction Industry Short Essay
2/7
Sarah Pearson 20304366
throughout Britain.4 And it was this deal that turned ...the boy who lived5 into
the cultural monolith of spinoffs and product positioning we see today. The other
ingredient in creating the monster is todays technological saturation. Computer
games provide another outlet for spruiking films and the novels they are adapted
from, and a very effective one at that: the Nintendo Wii version ofHarry Potter
and the Half-Blood Prince currently ranks in the top ten of bestselling games.6 In
other words, the advancement of technology combined with the more pedestrian
popularity of the novels (i.e. prior to any movie deal) creates an avenue through
which marketing can stream, first diffusing among the novels, and then
exploding via the more visual media of movies, television, and computer games.
As Tammy Turner-Vorbeck points out, there are more than 400 different Harry
Potterrelated products on todays markets. 7 However it seems that Turner-
Vorbeck is only interested in seeing the insidious and at times monstrous aspects
of a world flooded with Harry Potter toys: The proliferation of these items is
blatant exploitation of the genuine excitement for childrens literature that stems
from childrens true interests.8 However, among the numerous Potter products
that she names, there are two that simply do not belong within the category:
the textbooks which the character of Harry Potter used in the...books and
movies...9 Turner-Vorbeck is of course referring to Fantastic Beasts and Where
to Find Them and Quidditch Through The Ages10
, which cannot really bedescribed as part of the wizarding wonderland of merchandise, because they
were written and sold for the purposes of charity. The two books raised $15.6
million pounds for Comic Relief, and contributed to the fight against poverty and
social injustice in Britain, Africa and around the world11. Furthermore, J.K.
Rowling is notorious in her resistance and deflection of the gargantuan
marketing phenomenon now surrounding her novels. [She] refused to allow her
characters to be shown drinking Coca-Cola... 12 Furthermore, Rowling said in an
interview. I can only say now to all of the parents out there that if the action
4 Ibid.5 J.K. Rowling, Harry Potter and the Philosophers Stone, p.186 Sunday Herald Sun, August 9, 2009, Playliftout, p.137 Turner-Vorbeck, cited in Heilman, Elizabeth E. (ed.) Critical Perspectives on HarryPotter, p.3348 Ibid.9 Ibid.10 Both Rowling, J.K., under pseudonyms Newt Scamander and Kennilworthy Whisprespectively
11 Nel, Philip, Is There a text in This Advertising Campaign?: Literature, Marketing andHarry Potter, p.24212 Ibid, p.241
Page 2 of7
-
8/7/2019 Fiction Industry Short Essay
3/7
Sarah Pearson 20304366
figures are horrible, just tell the kids: dont buy them!13 It is true that the
marketing of the Harry Potter series has become the focal point, shifting away
from the novels themselves, but this is the nature of a modern book cult:
bestselling novels attract marketing, and conglomerates such as Time Warner,
like moths to a flame. It also crucial to remember where Harry Potter, as well as
the recent prodigious success of the Twilightquartet of novels, all began: with
the books, in absence of the hype and all the marketing spin offs. For example,
Harry Potter and the Philosophers Stone was released in June 1997, but the
books caught on well before the hype began. The marketing didnt really take
over until 1999; the products didnt appear until the latter half of 2000; and the
first movie...didnt appear until November 2001.14 As for Twilight, author
Stephenie Meyers official website shows that the original novel in the serieswas
first conceived in June 200315 and published in 200516, however only the 2008
release of the film adaptation turned it into a burgeoning craze, in which stores
such as Supre market so-called placement tees to teenage girls.17 It is
important to take note of the gap between popular novel and movie marketing
madness; if it either mania was as deeply rooted in marketing as Tammy Turner-
Vorbeck intimates, then surely the novels and the films and products would not
have such clearly distinct origins.
The reason both the Harry Potterand Twilightseries are defined here as new
book related crazes is because they have one major predecessor in the form of
J.R.R. Tolkiens Lord of the Rings, which began in 196518 and was markedly
different from the way Meyer and Rowlings novels have been disseminated to
the public consciousness. According to J.S. Ryan, the cult of Tolkien:
...began with the moral piracy of Ace Books which, without payment of
royalties, published and estimated 100,000 copies of the trilogy. It was this event
which unleashed the Tolkien craze on the American University campuses. New
York subways were painted with runic slogans celebrating the chief characters in
the trilogy...saying that Gandalf lives and Bilbo is God19
13 Ibid.14 Ibid, p.24415 http://www.stepheniemeyer.com/twilight.html16 http://www.stepheniemeyer.com/bio.html17 http://www.supre.com.au/(eom1vg3olhu1kqaled1aoj45)/ShopOnline/Shop.aspx?
pid=2&cid=17&pageIndex=118 J.S. Ryan, Tolkien: Cult or Culture?, p.7519 Ibid, pp.75-6
Page 3 of7
http://www.stepheniemeyer.com/twilight.htmlhttp://www.stepheniemeyer.com/bio.htmlhttp://www.supre.com.au/(eom1vg3olhu1kqaled1aoj45)/ShopOnline/Shop.aspx?pid=2&cid=17&pageIndex=1http://www.supre.com.au/(eom1vg3olhu1kqaled1aoj45)/ShopOnline/Shop.aspx?pid=2&cid=17&pageIndex=1http://www.stepheniemeyer.com/bio.htmlhttp://www.supre.com.au/(eom1vg3olhu1kqaled1aoj45)/ShopOnline/Shop.aspx?pid=2&cid=17&pageIndex=1http://www.supre.com.au/(eom1vg3olhu1kqaled1aoj45)/ShopOnline/Shop.aspx?pid=2&cid=17&pageIndex=1http://www.stepheniemeyer.com/twilight.html -
8/7/2019 Fiction Industry Short Essay
4/7
Sarah Pearson 20304366
The first thing of note is of course that this cult had nothing to do with movies
and marketing, and in fact had its beginning in illegal publication, causing it to
conform more to the traditional connotations of the word cult, i.e. antithetical
to...consumer culture.20 Though blockbuster film adaptations did eventually
appear, this was almost 40 years after early Tolkien mania swept the United
States.21Although the films have certainly become a part of the Lord of the Rings
canon, the division of time has meant that this new incarnation has had less of
an all-consuming effect on the source text. The films and novels ofHarry Potter
and Twilightare far more deeply intertwined. However, The Lord of the Rings is a
good way to access the way in which novel and marketing interact, simply
because in this case, the two are nowhere near so tightly bound together. With
The Lord of theRings, it is far easier to discern ...cult audience practices as
existing both inside and outside the parameters of commodification and
consumer culture...22 With Twilightand Harry Potter, this is far more difficult to
see, particularly with the former, which is too newly come to craze status to be
easily broken down into more comprehensible parts. Potteron the other hand
has been around for over ten years and as such there is more evidence of cult
behaviour. For example: [q]uite a few [readers] feel that the fifth volume wasnt
up to scratch (a view, incidentally, shared by lots in the fanfiction community,who arent reluctant to excise [Harry Potter and the Order of the] Phoenixfrom
the canon)23 Indeed fan fiction is an excellent indicator of when cult practice
has become part of what is essentially a mainstream obsession. On
FanFiction.net, there are nearly 415,000 stories pertaining to the Potteruniverse,
and over 100,000 for Twilight24. It seems likely that this latter number will grow.
As Matt Hills puts it: [f]or the cult audience, the blockbuster does not burst
onto the cultural scene and then rapidly fade away: instead its appearance is
keenly anticipated...and then it lives on through fan interpretations, debates and
memories/memorialisations. 25 Essentially the fanomenon26 ofHarry Potter
20 Hills, Matt, in, Mathijs, Ernest (ed.) The Lord of the Rings: Popular Culture in GlobalContext, p.16021 Mathijs, Ernest, Popular Culture in Global Context: The Lord of the Rings Phenomenon,in ibid, p.322 Hills, Matt, in ibid. p.16223 Terego, Al, and Denim, Sue, in, Brown, Stephen, (ed.) Consuming Books: Themarketing and consumption of literature, p.15624 http://www.fanfiction.net/book/25 Hills, Matt, in, Mathijs, Ernest (ed.) The Lord of the Rings: Popular Culture in Global
Context, p.16226 Terego, Al, and Denim, Sue, in, Brown, Stephen, (ed.) Consuming Books: Themarketing and consumption of literature, p.151
Page 4 of7
http://www.fanfiction.net/book/http://www.fanfiction.net/book/ -
8/7/2019 Fiction Industry Short Essay
5/7
Sarah Pearson 20304366
has created a sort of mass cult-like fanbase. This is already occurring with the
Twilightseries. Followers of the latter set of novels can display their allegiance
with the aforementioned Supre T-shirts. Both groups show their vested interest
by going to see the film adaptations: Twilightmade 5.4 million dollars in its
opening week in Australia27, while for the recent release ofHarry Potter and the
Half-Blood Prince the figure was over $14 million.28 This shows that as yet, Potter
is the bigger franchise, which is not surprising since it has been building on itself
since the late 1990s.29
But there is a certain amount of tautology involved in the interaction of novel
and marketing. As has already been discussed, word-of-mouth is the key way by
which books gain popularity in the first instance, for instance: ...children told
each other about Harry simply because they thought it was a good book.30 It has
also been noted that this reputation acts as a beacon to conglomerates
searching for marketing and merchandising opportunities. As exploitative as this
influence can be, it also true that [c]laims of literary merit are closely linked to
individual taste and therefore nearly impossible to prove.31 In short, when the
books become popular enough to warrant mass marketing, films soon follow,
along with a host of products and often, tie-in covers on the original novels. This
last effect is important because it exemplifies the way this sort of cult grows andcontinues; i.e. the movies send readers back to the source material, either as
first time readers or as readers re-acquainting themselves with a favourite novel,
which then encourages them to watch the film adaptations a second, or even
third, time. In essence, the cycle creates that which is central to both marketing
and novel: interest. As Al Terego and Sue Denim show, [p]eople get sucked into
Potters parallel universe in a number of different ways. [...] Some are drawn in
by the films...others by family connection...others by the phenomenon itself
(whats all the fuss about?)32 When it comes to such marketing infused
franchises as Twilightand Harry Potter, it is this notion of fuss that is pivotal. It
is fuss, that is, the interest in what makes the books as well as the films so
popular, that is drawing the new readers and viewers in. And that is why it is
27 http://blogs.smh.com.au/entertainment/getflickd/2008/12/box_office_vamp.html28 http://blogs.smh.com.au/entertainment/getflickd/2009/07/29 Nel, Philip Is There a text in This Advertising Campaign?: Literature, Marketing andHarry Potter, p.24430 Nel p.244
31 Ibid, p.25832 Terego, Al, and Denim, Sue, in, Brown, Stephen, (ed.) Consuming Books: Themarketing and consumption of literature, p. 153
Page 5 of7
http://blogs.smh.com.au/entertainment/getflickd/2008/12/box_office_vamp.htmlhttp://blogs.smh.com.au/entertainment/getflickd/2009/07/http://blogs.smh.com.au/entertainment/getflickd/2008/12/box_office_vamp.htmlhttp://blogs.smh.com.au/entertainment/getflickd/2009/07/ -
8/7/2019 Fiction Industry Short Essay
6/7
Sarah Pearson 20304366
most important to look marketing hype and the source text as two sides of the
same coin. The two elements feed off one anothers unique ways of gaining the
attention, and love, of people en masse. Most crucially, this is regardless of the
insidious, and at times actively exploitative, nature of marketing and hype, or
the fallibility of word-of-mouth, based as it is around that most relative of terms,
good.
References:
Hard copy sources:
Brown, Stephen, (ed.) Consuming Books: The marketing and
consumption of literature, Routledge, New York, 2006:
Terego, Al, and Denim, Sue, Riddikulus! Consumer
Reflections on the Harry Potter phenomenon, pp.146-159
Heilman, Elizabeth E. (ed.) Critical Perspectives on Harry Potter,
Routledge, New York, 2009:
Turner-Vorbeck, Tammy, Pottermania: Good Clean Fun or
Cultural Hegemony?, pp.329-341
Page 6 of7
-
8/7/2019 Fiction Industry Short Essay
7/7
Sarah Pearson 20304366
Mathijs, Ernest (ed.) The Lord of the Rings: Popular Culture in Global
Context, Wallflower Press, London, 2006:
Mathijs, Ernest, Popular Culture in Global Context: The Lord
of the Rings Phenomenon, pp.1-19,
Hills, Matt, Realising the Cult Blockbuster: The Lord of the
Rings Fandom and Residual/Emergent Cult Status in the
Mainstream, pp. 160-171
Nel, Philip, Is There a text in This Advertising Campaign?: Literature,
Marketing and Harry Potter, from The Lion and the Unicorn 29
(2005), pp. 236-267, downloaded via Project Muse, August 6 2009
Rowling, J.K. Harry Potter and the Philosophers Stone, Bloomsbury
Publishing Plc, London, 1997 (as Scamander, Newt) Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them,
Obscurus Books, London, 2001
(as Whisp, Kennilworthy) Quidditch Through the Ages, Whizz Hard
Books, London, 2001
Ryan, J.S. , Tolkien: Cult or Culture?, University of New England,
Armidale, 1969, pp.75-92
Playliftout, Sunday Herald Sun, August 9, 2009, , p.13
Online sources:
http://www.stepheniemeyer.com/twilight.html Accessed 6 August,
2009
http://www.stepheniemeyer.com/bio.html Accessed 6 August, 2009
http://www.supre.com.au/
(eom1vg3olhu1kqaled1aoj45)/ShopOnline/Shop.aspx?
pid=2&cid=17&pageIndex=1 Accessed 9 August, 2009
http://www.fanfiction.net/book/ Accessed 9 August, 2009
http://blogs.smh.com.au/entertainment/getflickd/2008/12/box_office
_vamp.html Accessed 9 August, 2009
http://blogs.smh.com.au/entertainment/getflickd/2009/07/ Accessed
9 August, 2009
Page 7 of7
http://www.stepheniemeyer.com/twilight.htmlhttp://www.stepheniemeyer.com/twilight.htmlhttp://www.stepheniemeyer.com/bio.htmlhttp://www.stepheniemeyer.com/bio.htmlhttp://www.supre.com.au/(eom1vg3olhu1kqaled1aoj45)/ShopOnline/Shop.aspx?pid=2&cid=17&pageIndex=1http://www.supre.com.au/(eom1vg3olhu1kqaled1aoj45)/ShopOnline/Shop.aspx?pid=2&cid=17&pageIndex=1http://www.supre.com.au/(eom1vg3olhu1kqaled1aoj45)/ShopOnline/Shop.aspx?pid=2&cid=17&pageIndex=1http://www.fanfiction.net/book/http://blogs.smh.com.au/entertainment/getflickd/2008/12/box_office_vamp.htmlhttp://blogs.smh.com.au/entertainment/getflickd/2008/12/box_office_vamp.htmlhttp://blogs.smh.com.au/entertainment/getflickd/2009/07/http://www.stepheniemeyer.com/twilight.htmlhttp://www.stepheniemeyer.com/bio.htmlhttp://www.supre.com.au/(eom1vg3olhu1kqaled1aoj45)/ShopOnline/Shop.aspx?pid=2&cid=17&pageIndex=1http://www.supre.com.au/(eom1vg3olhu1kqaled1aoj45)/ShopOnline/Shop.aspx?pid=2&cid=17&pageIndex=1http://www.supre.com.au/(eom1vg3olhu1kqaled1aoj45)/ShopOnline/Shop.aspx?pid=2&cid=17&pageIndex=1http://www.fanfiction.net/book/http://blogs.smh.com.au/entertainment/getflickd/2008/12/box_office_vamp.htmlhttp://blogs.smh.com.au/entertainment/getflickd/2008/12/box_office_vamp.htmlhttp://blogs.smh.com.au/entertainment/getflickd/2009/07/