Internet Governance Forum (IGF) in Athens

How to manage global net society?

AP-Star MeetingFeb 25 2007

Izumi Aizu

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 2

What is Internet Governance?

1.Management of OperationResource management on Domain Name, IP Address, Root Server, and Communication infrastructure

2. Management of Use of InternetFreedom of Speech/expression,harmful & illegal contents, copyright, security

3. Management of Societal activities by using the InternetDigital Divide, Convergence of Broadcast and Telecom, Long-tail booming business, game addiction etc.

DNS IPAddress

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 3

Internet Governance Forum （ IGF ）

Outcome of WSISMulti-stakeholder process

Government, Private sector, Civil Society on equal footing

Multistakeholder Advisory Group (Nominated by UN SG Annan)

Five year mandate to be reviewed

First IGF in Athens: Oct 30 – Nov2 2006

www.intgovforum.org

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 4

IGF Preparation ProcessFeb 16-17: First Consultation meeting

Hosted by Nitin Desai, WGIG ChairSecretariat – Markus KummerBased on WGIG experience

Open QuestionnaireMultistakeholder Advisory Group (MAG)

Named by UN SG Annan, 46 peopleNomination accepted

May 19: Second Consultation meetingMay 22-23: MAG Meeting

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 5

First IGF MeetingOct 30 – Nov 2, 2006, AthensHosted by Greek Government, as

formal UN Conference

www.igfgreece2006.gr

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 6

IGF MeetingVenue: a resort hotel on coast sideParticipants, more than expected

1500 registered, (800 was original plan)Half – from Greece

Greece Minister

Utsumi ITU SGNatasha PrimoCS Speaker

ICT MinisterFrom EgyptPlenary Session

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 7

ObservationFewer participants from developing countries

Less support from donor countries/organization – less participation from Private sector & Civil Society

No political negotiation, less incentive from developing country governments

Many ICANN people: Chairman Vint Cerf, CEO Paul Twomey, Sharil GAC Chair,

Regional bodies: RIR, NIR, JPNIC, JPRS

Delegation from Japan by KeidanrenHeaded Murakami NRI President, Fujitsu, Hitachi,

Microsoft, JPNIC, JPRS, JISA

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 8

Overall Theme:Internet Governance for DevelopmentOpennessAccessSecurityDiversity

No discussion around ICANN/DNS policy mattersMany governments expected to use

“enhance cooperation” as a separate process

Private Sector/CS did not push

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 9

Plenary and Workshops

PlenaryMultistakeholder Policy Dialogue - Setting

the SceneOpennessSecurityDiversityAccess

Workshops36 workshops organized by MSH

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 10

Internet Resource issues

Iran government tried to discuss – rejected by the Moderator at opening plenary

Brazil said “We have special interest on Internet Core Resource Management for the next meeting in Rio

US Head said – “It was great – no major problem emerged” and left on the second day

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 11

Infrastructure Security Workshop

Hosted by VeriSignDNSSEC as main themePanel

Christina Arida, Advisor, ICT Initiative, National Telecom Regulatory Authority, Gov. of Egypt

Lars-Johan Liman, Senior System Specialist, Autonomica 　 　 I Root Server Operator

Izumi Aizu, Institute for HyperNetwork Society, Kumon Center, Tama University

-Henrik Kaspersen, Chairman of the Cybercrime Convention

Brian Cute, Vice President, VeriSign Inc. 　 (Moderator)

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 12

Infrastructure Security WS

Root server and と DNSSECAnycastDESSECImportance of Infrastructure

Investment by GovernmentImportance of International

Cooperation: CoCImportance of Individual User

participation

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 13

Workshop on Security

“Global Culture for Cyber Security”Hosted by China Emphasized the Importance of

International cooperation

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 14

Overall Achievement

Free and candid dialogue- well received by almost all participants

Many activities behind the scenesSpecific Projects emerging

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 15

Dynamic Coalitions

The StopSpamAlliance joint initiative to gather information and

resources on combating spamMembers

APEC CNSAITULondon Action PlanOECDSeoul-Melbourne MoU

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 16

The Dynamic Coalition on Privacy Address emerging issues of internet privacy protection such as digital identities, the

link between privacy and development, and the importance of privacy and anonymity for freedom of expression. It aims at developing a set of recommendations for the IGF to consider.

Individuals from: American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) , Amnesty International, Association for Progressive Communication (APC), Associazione per la Libertà nella Comunicazione Elettronica Interattiva 　 (ALCEI), Center for Communications & Policy Research, India, Centre de Recherche Informatique et Droit, Facultés Universitaires, Notre-Dame de la Paix, Computer Professionals for Social Responsibility (CPSR) – Peru, Computer Professionals for Social Responsibility (CPSR) - USA, Council of Europe (to be confirmed), Cyberlaw Asia, Danish Human Rights Institute, Deutsche Vereinigung für Datenschutz (DVD), Digital Rights Ireland, Electronic Frontier Finland, Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC), European Digital Rights (EDRi), Foundation for, Information Policy Research (FIPR), Government of France, Foreign Ministry, Hellenic Data Protection Authority, Identity Commons Working Group on Identity Rights Agreements, Imaginons un réseau Internet solidaire (IRIS), France, Independent Centre for Privacy Protection in Kiel, Internet Service Providers' Association of South Africa, IP Justice, Italian Internet Governance Advisory Committee, Japan Computer Access for Empowerment (JCAFE), Kuwait Information Technology Society (KITS), LSE Information Systems Group, Metamorphosis Foundation, Microsoft, Net Dialogue of Harvard's Berkman Center and Stanford's Center for, Internet and Society, Netzwerk Neue Medien (NNM), North American Consumer Project on Electronic Commerce (NACPEC), Office of the OSCE Representative on Freedom of the Media, Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, Privacy and Identity Management in Europe (PRIME) Project, Privacy International, Privaterra, SAP, University of Bremen, Collaborative Research Center ”Transformations of the State”, WISeKey, World Bank, World Press Freedom Committee, WSIS Civil Society Working Group on Privacy and Security, WSIS Human Rights Caucus

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 17

Dynamic Coalition on Open Standards (IGF DOCS)

The IGF Dynamic Coalition on Open Standards (IGF DCOS) will frame and define the most urgent problems related to open technology standards and application interoperability and suggest straightforward, workable solutions that can be implemented by all stakeholders.

Government Brazil, Rogério Santanna World Wide Web Consortium, Daniel Dardailler Sun Microsystems, Susy Struble Free Software Foundation Europe, Georg Greve Civil Society Consumer Project on Technology, Jamie

Love IP Justice, Robin Gross Yale Information Society Project, Laura DeNardis Bibliotheca Alexandrina, Professor Magdy Nagi.

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 18

Dynamic Coalition on the Internet Bill of Rights

To explore the concept of an "Internet Bill of Rights", a globally agreed to document that states the rights and duties of individual users of the Internet.

An international meeting on the subject will be convened in Italy in 2007. It is suggested that an "Internet Bill of Rights" becomes one of the main themes for the next IGF meeting in Brazil.

Members: Brazilian Government Ministry of CultureCentre for Technology and Society of Getulio Vargas

Foundation School of Law (Rio de Janeiro)Government of Italy, Ministry of Reform and Innovation in

the Public AdministrationIP JusticeSocietà Internet (ISOC Italy)

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 19

A2K@IGF Dynamic Coalition To support and expand Access to Knowledge (A2K) and

promote freedom of expression. Members

Egypt's Library of Alexandria (Biblotheca Alexandrina)IP Justice Sun Microsystems CPTech GoogleIP Academy of Singapore Council of EuropeFree Software Foundation EuropeElectronic Frontier FoundationMember of European Parliament Marco CappatoKuwait Information Technology SocietyComputer Professions for Social Responsibility - PeruInternational Federation of Library AssociationAssociation of Progressive ComputingElectronic Information for LibrariesSouth Centre Innovation, Access to Knowledge and Intellectual

Property ProgrammeYale Law School Information Society Project

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 20

The Way Ahead2007 　 Brazil Rio, in Nov

Feb 13 – First Consultation Meeting in Geneva Waiting for new SG’s direction

2008 India2009 　 Egypt2010 　 Azerbaijan or LithuaniaHigh interest from developing countries

Like “Olympic Games” started from Athens

2006/9/21 インターネットガバナンス 21

Need for Outreach

Build Awareness and Capacity in developing countries

AP Community can serveHelp educate policy makers on

technical/policy mattersOrganize regional meetings, workshopsOrganize workshops at Rio