july 30, 2015 1 mcec nts richard m. lerner, et al. richard m. lerner, rachel m. hershberg, jun wang,...
TRANSCRIPT
July 30, 2015 1MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Richard M. Lerner, Rachel M. Hershberg, Jun Wang, et al.
Promoting Character Through BSA Cub Scout Programs: The Sample Case of the Cradle of Liberty Council
“Character and Merit Project” (CAMP)
July 30, 2015 2MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Acknowledgements
July 30, 2015 3MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
IARYD Research TeamBrian M. Burkhard, M.S.
Robey B. Champine, M.S., M.P.H.
Paul A. Chase, Ph.D.
Kaitlin A. Ferris, Ph.D.
Rachel M. Hershberg, Ph.D.
Lacey J. Hilliard, Ph.D.
Richard M. Lerner, Ph.D. (Principal Investigator)
Caroline Stack, B.A.
Jun Wang, Ph.D.
Daniel J. A. Warren, M.A.
July 30, 2015 4MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Research Aims of CAMP• Do BSA programs promote character development among participating youth?
• If so, how do BSA programs promote such character development?
July 30, 2015 5MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Study Design Measured multiple groups five times
between 2012 and 2014 Quantitative and qualitative methods
were used Used the structure of BSA for initial data
collection:
Council Adult Leaders Scouts
July 30, 2015 6MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Participating Districts
ContinentalGeneral Nash
LafayetteBaden-Powell Washington
Roosevelt
ScoutReach
TriuneConestogaMinquas
Constellation
Northern
July 30, 2015 7MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
CAMP Participants with Quantitative Data.
Total Youth in Study: 2650• Total BSA Youth: 1787
• Non-ScoutReach: 1524
• ScoutReach: 263
• Total Comparison Group Youth:
863
July 30, 2015 8MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
We Developed a NEW Measure of Character
The Assessment of Character in Children and Early Adolescents (ACCEA).
ACCEA works well with Scouts, non-Scout boys, and non-Scout girls. Also works well with ethnic minority youth from low-income communities (for example, ScoutReach participants)
July 30, 2015 9MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
The ACCEA Measure of CharacterAttributes Definitions/Sample Items
Obedience
Participants’ self-reported levels of positive conduct or behavior (emphasizing behaving in accordance with rules for conduct).
“I act the way I am supposed to.”
ReverenceParticipants’ religious activities.“I like to read or listen to stories from my religion.”
CheerfulnessHow often participants experienced positive feelings.“I am happy.”
KindnessA participant’s quality of being friendly, generous, and considerate to others.“When my friends are upset, I try to make them feel better.”
ThriftinessParticipants’ effective use of goods and services, and restraint in acquiring them, to achieve longer-term goals.“I save my money for something special.”
Hopeful Future Expectation
Participants’ possession of a positive outlook about their life in the future. “I will have a happy family.”
TrustworthinessA participant’s perception of whether others believe they can place their trust in him or her. “I can be counted on to tell the truth.”
HelpfulnessParticipants’ ability to provide assistance or to be useful.“I help people in my family.”
July 30, 2015 10MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
DID BSA PROGRAM PARTICIPATION PROMOTE
CHARACTER DEVELOPMENT ACROSS THE FIVE TIMES OF
DATA COLLECTION?
July 30, 2015 11MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Time 1: No difference between Scouts and non-Scouts.
Time 5: Scouts reported significant increases in cheerfulness, helpfulness, kindness, obedience, trustworthiness, and hopeful future expectations.
BUT Non-Scout boys reported no significant increases
in any of the character attributes.
July 30, 2015 12MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
What values do Scouts and non-Scouts consider as the
most important?
July 30, 2015 13MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Scouts are significantly more likely than non-Scouts to embrace other-oriented values, including helping others, and doing the right thing.
July 30, 2015 14MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
How Does BSA Program Participation Promote
Character Development?
• Intensity• Duration• Engagement
July 30, 2015 15MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Intensity High Intensity = “Almost Always”
Participates
“Exemplar Scouts” (54%): “Almost always” participated in weekly meetings and weekend activities
“Non-Exemplar Scouts” (46%): “Sometimes” or “rarely” participated in weekly meetings and weekend activities
July 30, 2015 16MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Time 1: No significant differences in character attributes between Exemplar and Non-Exemplar Scouts.
Time 4: Exemplar Scouts were significantly higher in kindness, thriftiness, trustworthiness, helpfulness, hopeful future expectation, academic competence, intentional self-regulation, and connection to nature.
Intensity and Character Development
July 30, 2015 17MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
The number of months each participant had been involved in Scouting when data were collected.
Duration represents persistent involvement in a YD program over time.
Duration
July 30, 2015 18MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Scouts who have remained in the program longer reported having higher levels of trustworthiness, school competence, intentional self-regulation, and hopeful future expectation.
Duration and Character Development
July 30, 2015 19MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Youth interest, enjoyment, and commitment to the program.
• Individual engagement
• Pack-level engagement
Engagement
July 30, 2015 20MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Individual-level engagement was significantly associated with cheerfulness, hopeful future expectation, helpfulness, kindness, and intentional self-regulation.
Pack-level engagement enhanced the effects of individual engagement on character development, especially for highly engaged youth.
Engagement and Character Development
July 30, 2015 21MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Program Participation and the Character Development of
ScoutsIntensity
Duration
Engagement
Character development
July 30, 2015 22MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Findings about ScoutReach Youth
• Higher levels of engagement associated with higher religious reverence, cheerfulness, intentional self-regulation, kindness, thriftiness, hopeful future expectation, trustworthiness, and helpfulness.
July 30, 2015 23MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
Conclusions and Next Steps
Scouting positively impacts youth character development, particularly for Scouts with longer duration, greater intensity, and higher engagement in the program.
We need to “dig deeper” into the ways in which BSA programs promote character among ScoutReach youth.
July 30, 2015 24MCEC NTSRichard M. Lerner , et al.
THANK YOU !