leavers and remainers - true tribes or trite tropes...
TRANSCRIPT
BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
britainthinks.com
Leavers and Remainers: True Tribes or Trite Tropes?Cordelia Hay, Research Director, BritainThinks
MRS IMPACT 2017
2BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
Immediately after the Referendum vote, the big story was ‘divided Britain’…
On the grounds of age…
3BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
Geography…
4BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
And class…
5BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
6BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
But the data suggests that the ‘real’ story is far more
complicated…
7BritainThinks | Private and Confidential Data from Resolution Foundation analysis
8BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
Some leavers are ‘left behind’
• Nothing to lose• Economically and culturally
challenged by immigration
Data from Resolution Foundation analysis
9BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
But a great deal aren’t ‘left behind’• Driven by desire for greater sovereignty• Driven by practical ‘cutting red tape’ argument• Culturally challenged by immigration
Data from Resolution Foundation analysis
There are some big values which unite these previously divergent groups
10BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
31%
26%
22%
20%
20%
19%
69%
74%
78%
80%
80%
81%
Globalisation
Feminism
Environmentalism
Social liberalism
Immigration
Multiculturalism
Referendum vote among those who see each of the following as a force for ill…
Leave Remain
62%
60%
62%
68%
79%
71%
38%
40%
38%
32%
21%
29%
Globalisation
Feminism
Environmentalism
Social liberalism
Immigration
Multiculturalism
Referendum vote among those who see each of the following as a force for good…
Leave Remain
Data from Lord Ashcroft Polls
And the biggest predictor of all is how you feel about the death penalty…
11BritainThinks | Private and Confidential Data from British Electoral Survey & Eric Kaufmann, LSE
12BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
The new labels of ‘Leavers’ and ‘Remainers’ give these
sociodemographically diverse groups a sense of belonging…
13BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
“The Trump rally was the most fun I have had in years. Trump would say. ‘What am I going to
build?’ and we would say ‘A wall!’… It was fun to lighten up, to cheer along with everyone else, just like back in high school, when we would cheer that our teams were definitely going to
win, even when they were bad”
“When I heard we had ‘gone Brexit’ I felt like England had won the World Cup!"
This is echoed across the pond…
Much of this is about defining yourself against what you aren’t rather than what you are…
14BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
“The ‘big people’, they think that it’s a united country, because they don’t know about our lives… their daily
shop probably cost what our weekly shop costs.”Man, Leave voter, Harlow
“‘Them’… they don’t get our lives, they don’t live in our shoes. The working lower class
voted out, and the upper class voted in because they’ve got the money and they
have more to lose. It affects them more than it affects you. People with money. They’re panicking more that we’re out [of the EU].”
Woman, Leave voter, Harlow
Qualities that Leavers are most likely to associate with Remainers:
‘Out of touch’ ‘Establishment’No. 1 No. 2 No. 3
‘Liberal’
Much of this is about defining yourself against what you aren’t rather than what you are…
15BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
Qualities that Remainersare most likely to associate with Leavers:
‘Ignorant’ ‘Stuck in the past’No. 1 No. 2 No. 3
‘Bigoted’
“I love the idea of diversity in Britain and I embrace it, but I feel that these days
there’s quite an undercurrent of xenophobia, and that makes me feel that
Britain is broken. An undercurrent of intolerance.”
Woman, Remain voter, Leamington Spa
“I’m still appalled that we ever had the vote personally, I still can’t believe they gave the public the chance to vote on it. Most people
don’t know enough and don’t pay any attention to the facts. These are the same
people that chose Boaty McBoatface.”Man, Remain voter, Leamington Spa
The more we talk about and reinforce these divides, the more real they become
16BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
In the 1960s…
82%of the public identified with a political party
In 2005…
51%of the public identified with a political party
In 2017…
66%felt that their EU Ref vote is more important than their chosen political party
“Deterritorialisation...sometimes...creates exaggerated and intensified senses of criticism or attachment to politics in the home state. Deterritorialisation, whether of Hindus, Sikhs, Palestinians, or Ukranians, is now at the core of a variety of global
fundamentalisms, Islamic and Hindu fundamentalism...” Arjun Appadurai on deterritorialisation (1990)
Data from British Electoral Survey & New Statesman coverage of ‘leaked’ Labour polling
Leavers and Remainers are (often negatively defined) social
constructs that are fast hardening into two ‘tribes’
17BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
18BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
19BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
What next for researchers, brands and campaigners in a world of two (trite) ‘tribes’?
#1 Pay closer attention to values (not value)
20BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
Economic competence used to be the best predictor of electoral outcomes (bar ’97):
1992 1997 2001 2005 2010 2015
Most trusted party on the economy before UK General Elections
Conservative Labour Lib Dem
But as sociodemographically heterogeneous groups coalesce around (the rejection of) common values, from multiculturalism to environmentalism to feminism, we need to be
smarter than this in understanding what drives opinion
#2 Work harder than ever to communicate your message
21BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
Either ‘tribe’ might represent some (quick win) opportunities:
“We will defend the Britain we love…(and of course we’ll oppose the expansion of
Heathrow too)”
But they pose some real challenges too as voters and consumers increasingly view the world through their ‘tribal’ lens, often when you least expect it…
Whether you’re trying to talk about workers’ rights…
…restaurant closures… …or, er, sludge…“Who is behind all this? What’s in it for them? Why does this ‘scientist’ want me to know
about this?”
#3 Beware an oversimplification of the story
22BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
“We’ve got to stop this madness, cut all that
red tape and regulation and take the reins!”
The Vote Leave campaign used a big, capacious message to appeal to a wide cross-section of voters:
“I don’t recognise my country any more with
all this immigration – we just can’t cope.”
But this means that – even among Leavers – there is a huge divide to bridge, with underlying tensions between clamping down on immigration and making the UK
open for global business
#4 Check yourself
23BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
Before elite split -consensus
After elite split –partisan divergence
By talking about these divides, are we all guilty of making them (more) real?
The impact of ‘elite’ cues on public opinion is well documented:
Adapted from Zaller, J; University of California, 1992 – based on 1990 NES
BritainThinks | Private and Confidential
britainthinks.com
Leavers and Remainers: True Tribes or Trite Tropes?Cordelia Hay, Research Director, BritainThinks
MRS IMPACT 2017