mountain wave study at wind farm site in eastern rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and...

16
September 14, 2012 Mountain Wave Study at a Wind Farm Site in the Eastern Rocky Mountains Dr. Philippe Beaucage Dr. Jeff Freedman Senior Research Scientist Lead Research Scientist Daniel W. Bernadett Chief Engineer Dan Michaud Meteorologist Dr. Michael C. Brower Chief Technical Officer

Upload: others

Post on 23-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

September 14, 2012

Mountain Wave Study at a Wind Farm Site in the Eastern Rocky MountainsDr. Philippe Beaucage

Dr. Jeff Freedman

Senior Research Scientist

Lead Research Scientist

Daniel W. BernadettChief Engineer

Dan MichaudMeteorologist

Dr. Michael C. BrowerChief Technical Officer

Page 2: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

Introduction

SiteWindCoupled mesoscale‐microscale model

CFDRANS model

CFD:     Computational Fluid DynamicsRANS:  Reynolds‐average Navier‐Stokes

SM4

SM3

SM2

SM1

Page 3: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

Motivation

Terrain Elevation Map

Monthly Average Wind Speeds

Is it real? (a) Are the measurements reliable?  If it is real:  (b) which atmospheric mechanism is responsible?

(c) what is the periodicity of the responsible phenomenon?

Page 4: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

Local Wind Rose

1 year: 2010‐2011 1 month: January 2011

Page 5: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

Project Area: Eastern Rocky Mountains

Looking towards southwest

Page 6: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

Inter‐Mast Correlations (Wind Speeds)

SM5 wind speed (81m Vector)  SM5 wind speed (81m Vector) 

SM5 wind speed (81m NRG)  SM5 wind speed (81m NRG) 

SM9 wind speed (57.6m

 Riso

e) 

SM9 wind speed (57.6m

 NRG

SM9 wind speed (57.6m

 Vector) 

SM9 wind speed (57.6m

 NRG

R2 = 0.79

R2 = 0.79

R2 = 0.78

R2 = 0.78

Page 7: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

Mountain Meteorology

Possible meteorological phenomena causing downslope winds during the winter season:

Katabatic Winds 

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katabatic_wind

Mountain Waves 

meted.ucar.edu

Hydraulic Flows

Whiteman (2000)

Page 8: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

Advanced Regional Prediction System (ARPS)

• Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP) model (Xue et al. 2000, 2001)

• Fully compressible, non‐hydrostatic Navier‐Stokes equations– Conservation of mass, momentum and energy

• Complete suite of physics parameterization schemes

• Initial and boundary conditions provided by the North‐American Mesoscale (NAM) model analyses

Page 9: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

ARPS Mesoscale Model Simulations

Four representative cases during winter 2011:

Case 1: 01 Jan 2011, 0:00 LSTto 03 Jan 2011, 12:00 LST 

Case 2: 20 Jan 2011, 0:00 LST to 24 Jan 2011, 0:00 LST

Case 3: 06 Feb 2011, 12:00 LST to 08 Feb 2011, 0:00 LST 

Case 4: 09 Feb 2011, 0:00 LST to 14 Feb 2011 0:00 LST

Dynamical downscaling:• x = 12 km → 4 km → 1 km → 400 m• 34 vertical levels (6 in the first 200 m)

Page 10: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

Horizontal Wind Speed Map at 80‐m Height

Page 11: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

Time Series of Wind Speeds at SM9

SM9 Observations and ARPS Simulations for January 20 to 23, 2011

Page 12: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

Vertical Cross‐Section of Virtual Potential Temperature

Page 13: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

Vertical Cross Sections

Page 14: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

Geopotential Height Anomaly Maps

Show a normal flow regime in January 2011 at upper levels (left) and near the surface (right) over the Eastern Rocky mountains (from NCEP/NCAR reanalysis data).

Anomaly map at 250 mb Anomaly map at 925 mb

Page 15: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

Conclusions

The project area is well situated for the generation and persistence of mountain wave‐induced downslope winds.

• Sonic and cup anemometers were shown to have reliable measurements;

• Numerical simulations indicated that ARPS is very accurate in capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height;

• ARPS simulations also showed that mountain waves were responsible for the increase in wind speeds on the lee side of the mountain (due to a stable boundary layer);

• The winter of 2010‐2011 was a typical winter according to the surface and upper level anomaly maps (based on the NCEP/NCAR reanalysis).

Page 16: Mountain Wave Study at Wind Farm Site in Eastern Rocky ...€¦ · capturing the magnitude and phase of the downslope winds at hub height; • ARPS simulations also showed that mountain

Albany, New York  |  Barcelona, Spain  |  Bangalore, India  |  awstruepower.com |   +1 877‐899‐3463©2012 AWS Truepower, LLC

Thank you

Contact  info•Dr. Philippe Beaucage: [email protected]

Selected ReferencesLilly, D.K. (1978). “A severe downslope windstorm and aircraft turbulence event induced by a mountain wave”. J. Atmos. Sci. vol. 33, pp. 59‐77.  Doyle, J.D. et al. (2000). “An intercomparison of model‐predicted wave breaking for the 11 January 1972 Boulder windstorm”. Mon. Wea. Rev., vol. 128, pp.901‐914.Xue, M., K. K. Droegemeier, and V. Wong (2000). “The Advanced Regional Prediction System (ARPS) ‐ A multiscale nonhydrostatic atmospheric simulation and prediction tool. Part I: Model dynamics and verification”. Meteor. Atmos. Physics., vol. 75, pp. 161‐193.Chow, F.K, R.L. Street (2009). “Evaluation of Turbulence Closure Models for Large‐Eddy Simulation over Complex Terrain: Flow over Askervein Hill”. J. Appl. Meteor. and Clim., vol. 48, pp. 1050‐1065.