multidisciplinary design optimization of wind energy systems · les+lifting line ( schito &...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
PO
LI
di M
I tecn
ico
lano
te
cnic
o la
no
MULTIDISCIPLINARY DESIGN OPTIMIZATION OF WIND ENERGY SYSTEMS
Carlo L. Bottasso Politecnico di Milano
2nd NREL Wind Energy Systems Engineering Workshop Broomfield, CO, 29-30 January 2013
![Page 2: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Outline
• Introduction and motivation • Approach:
- Constrained multi-disciplinary optimization by physics-based cost of energy (CoE) models - Multi-level analysis (1D spatial beams+2D sections, 3D FEM) - Comprehensive wind turbine simulation tools - Tool validation/calibration by wind tunnel testing
• Applications and results • Conclusions and outlook
![Page 3: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Outline
• Introduction and motivation • Approach:
- Constrained multi-disciplinary optimization by physics-based cost of energy (CoE) models - Multi-level analysis (1D spatial beams+2D sections, 3D FEM) - Comprehensive wind turbine simulation tools - Tool validation/calibration by wind tunnel testing
• Applications and results • Conclusions and outlook
![Page 4: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Pitch-torque control laws: - Regulating the machine at different set points depending on wind conditions - Reacting to gusts - Reacting to wind turbulence - Keeping actuator duty-cycles within admissible limits - Handling transients: run-up, normal and emergency shut-down procedures - …
- Annual Energy Production (AEP) - Noise - …
Holistic Design of Wind Turbines
- Loads: envelope computed from large number of Design Load Cases (DLCs, IEC-61400) - Fatigue (25 year life), Damage Equivalent Loads (DELs) - Maximum blade tip deflections - Placement of natural frequencies wrt rev harmonics - Stability: flutter, LCOs, low damping of certain modes, local buckling - Complex couplings among rotor/drive-train/tower/foundations (off-shore: hydro loads, floating & moored platforms) - Weight: massive size, composite materials (but shear quantity is an issue, fiberglass, wood, clever use of carbon fiber) - Manufacturing technology, constraints
- Generator (RPM, weight, torque, drive-train, …) - Pitch and yaw actuators - Brakes - …
GE wind turbine (from inhabitat.com)
![Page 5: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Holistic Design of Wind Turbines
There is a need for multi-disciplinary optimization tools, which must: • Be fast (hours/days) (on standard desktop hardware!) • Provide workable solutions in all areas (aerodynamics, structures, controls) for
specialists to refine/verify • Account ab-initio for all complex couplings (no fixes a posteriori) • Use fully-integrated tools (no manual intervention)
They will never replace the experienced designer! … but would greatly
speed-up design, improve exploration/knowledge of design space
Current approach to design: discipline-oriented specialist groups
Different simulation models
Lengthy loops to satisfy all requirements/constraints
(months)
Data transfer/compatibility among groups
![Page 6: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Holistic Design of Wind Turbines Focus of present work: integrated multi-disciplinary (holistic)
constrained design of wind turbines, i.e. optimal coupled sizing of: • Aerodynamic shape • Structural members (loads, aero-servo-elasticity and controls)
Constraints: ensure a viable design by enforcing all necessary design
requirements Figure of merit: physics-based model of the cost of energy Applications:
• Sizing of a new machine • Improvement of a tentative configuration • Trade-off studies (e.g. performance-cost) • Modifications to exiting models
![Page 7: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Outline
• Introduction and motivation • Approach:
- Constrained multi-disciplinary optimization by physics-based cost of energy (CoE) models - Multi-level analysis (1D spatial beams+2D sections, 3D FEM) - Comprehensive wind turbine simulation tools - Tool validation/calibration by wind tunnel testing
• Applications and results • Conclusions and outlook
![Page 8: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Optimization-Based Multi-Level Blade Design
Cost: AEP Aerodynamic parameters: chord, twist
Cost: Blade weight (or cost model if available) Structural parameters: thickness of shell and spar caps, width and location of shear webs
Cost: Physics-based CoE Parameters: Aerodynamic and structural
Controls: model-based (self-adjusting to changing design)
![Page 9: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Fully automated links
Mul
ti-le
vel a
naly
sis
Up-down fully automated links
Only weak up link (e.g. 3D root corrections)
![Page 10: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Blade: - Geometrically exact beam model - Span-wise interpolation
Blade: - ANBA 2D FEM sectional analysis - Compute 6x6 stiffness matrices
Blade: definition of aerodynamic & structural design parameters
Blade constraints: - Maximum tip deflection - Natural frequencies - Max stresses/strains (ANBA) - Fatigue (ANBA)
▶ Update blade mass & cost
Tower constraints: - Natural frequencies - Max stresses/strains - Fatigue
▶ Update tower mass & cost
Tower: - Geom. exact beam model - Height-wise interpolation
Tower: - Compute stiffness matrices
Tower: definition of structural design parameters
SQP optimizer
min cost subject to constraints
Update complete HAWT Cp-Lambda multibody model - DLCs simulation - Campbell diagram - AEP DLC post-processing: load envelope, DELs, Markov, max tip deflection
Aeroservoelastic-Level Optimization
![Page 11: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Multi-Level Optimization
![Page 12: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Webs + Web core + Spar caps + LE & TE reinforcements
Internal skin + Skin core + External skin
3D FEM Blade Modeling 3D CAD with solid and shell (with or without offsets) meshing directly from coarse-level model data:
= Complete model ⇒ Analyses
![Page 13: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Physics-based Cost Function Cost model (Fingersh at al., 2006):
𝑪𝑪𝑪 = 𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑪𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑭 ∗ 𝑰𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑰𝑪𝑭𝑰𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑰𝑪𝑪𝑰𝑭 𝑰
𝑨𝑪𝑨 𝑰 + 𝑨𝑭𝑭𝑨𝑭𝑰𝑨𝑰𝑭𝑨𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑭𝑪𝑭𝑰𝑭𝑭𝑰𝑭𝑰 𝑰
where 𝑰 = design parameters (at the moment for rotor and tower) When possible, avoid scaling relationships and compute cost item directly from model information Example:
• Detailed blade geometry ⇒ bill of materials ⇒ blade material cost • Detailed tower geometry ⇒ bill of materials ⇒ tower material cost • Torque ⇒ Gear-box mass (from mass scaling model) • Etc. …
Ideally this should be done for all major components (when not possible, use scaling relationships)
![Page 14: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
The Importance of Multi-Level Blade Design
Stress/strain/fatigue: - Fatigue constraint not satisfied at
first iteration on 3D FEM model - Modify constraint based on 3D
FEM analysis - Converged at 2nd iteration
Fatigue damage constraint satisfied
Buckling: - Buckling constraint not satisfied at first iteration - Update skin core thickness - Update trailing edge reinforcement strip - Converged at 2nd iteration
Peak stress on initial model
Increased trailing edge strip
ITERATION 1 ITERATION 0
ITERATION 1 ITERATION 0
ITERATION 1 ITERATION 0
ITERATION 1 ITERATION 0
Nor
mal
ized
str
ess
Fa
tigue
dam
age
inde
x
Th
ickn
ess
Tr
ailin
g ed
ge s
trip
thic
knes
s
Increased skin core thickness
![Page 15: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Outline
• Introduction and motivation • Approach:
- Constrained multi-disciplinary optimization by physics-based cost of energy (CoE) models - Multi-level analysis (1D spatial beams+2D sections, 3D FEM) - Comprehensive wind turbine simulation tools - Tool validation/calibration by wind tunnel testing
• Applications and results • Conclusions and outlook
![Page 16: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Comprehensive Wind Turbine Modeling Tools
![Page 17: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
• Rigid body • Geometrically exact beam • Revolute joint • Flexible joint • Actuator
ANBA (Anisotropic Beam Analysis) cross sectional model (Giavotto et al., 1983): • Evaluation of cross sectional stiffness (6 by 6 fully populated) • Recovery of sectional stresses and strains
Compute cross sectional stresses and strains
Compute sectional stiffness of equivalent
beam model
![Page 18: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Outline
• Introduction and motivation • Approach:
- Constrained multi-disciplinary optimization by physics-based cost of energy (CoE) models - Multi-level analysis (1D spatial beams+2D sections, 3D FEM) - Comprehensive wind turbine simulation tools - Tool validation/calibration by wind tunnel testing
• Applications and results • Conclusions and outlook
![Page 19: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Validation/Calibration of Modeling Tools by Wind Tunnel Testing
Wind tunnel testing: - Cons: Usually impossible to exactly match all relevant physics due to scaling + Pros: Better control/knowledge of conditions/errors/disturbances Much lower costs Does not replace simulation nor field testing, but works in synergy with them
Wind tunnel role is not limited to aerodynamics
Validated mathematical models Field (full-scale) testing Wind tunnel (scaled) testing
Upscaling
![Page 20: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Turbulence (boundary layer) generators
Wind Turbine Wind Tunnel Models
Wind tunnel model of the Vestas V90 wind turbine • Aeroelastically-scaled • Real-time individual blade pitch and torque control
Radius = 1m
Height = 1.78 m
![Page 21: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Applications: Aerodynamics and Beyond
LES+lifting line (Schito & Zasso 2012)
4D
WT 1 WT 2
φ
Aerodynamics ▶ Wake interference
conditions ▶
Emergency shutdown ▼ Floating wind turbine ▼
Individual blade pitch control ▼ Wind direction observer ▼
![Page 22: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Outline
• Introduction and motivation • Approach:
- Constrained multi-disciplinary optimization by physics-based cost of energy (CoE) models - Multi-level analysis (1D spatial beams+2D sections, 3D FEM) - Comprehensive wind turbine simulation tools - Tool validation/calibration by wind tunnel testing
• Applications and results • Conclusions and outlook
![Page 23: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Flow control devices: • TE flaps • Microtabs • Vortex generators • Active jets (plasma,
synthetic) • Morphing airfoils • …
Active Load Mitigation: Smart Blades
(Chow and van Dam 2007)
(Credits: Smart Blade GmbH)
(Credits: Risoe DTU)
(Credits: Risoe DTU)
However: complexity/availability/maintenance Really applicable offshore in the foreseeable future?
![Page 24: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Passive Load Alleviation by BTC Passive load alleviation: optimal blade design with Bend-Twist Coupling (BTC) Note: all designs satisfy exactly the same requirements
Assume fiber angle as design variable in skin and spar caps
Spar-caps: steep increase
Skin: milder increase
Spar-cap/skin synergy
Design trade-offs
+ Decreased load envelope and fatigue + Decreased actuator duty cycle
+ Decreased weight But same power
![Page 25: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Integrated Passive and Active Load Alleviation
Active load alleviation: Individual Blade pitch Control (IBC)
Significant life-time improvement, but large duty cycle increase (≈200%)
Integrated Passive-Active load alleviation: IBC of BTC blade
![Page 26: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
• Optimization-based design tools: enable automated design of wind
turbines with a-priori satisfaction of all desired design requirements
• Physics-base CoE: tries to avoid as much as possible scaling relationships in favor of direct sizing of each principal component
• Multi-level design: aeroservoelastic models for fast pre-design, followed by detailed FEM to capture local effects
• Computational cost: reasonable for an industrial environment (a couple of days to complete a design loop), using standard low cost computing hardware
• Outlook: - Working on multiple applications to build confidence in tools - Expand physics-based sizing of sub-systems (generator, nacelle, …)
Conclusions
![Page 27: Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Wind Energy Systems · LES+lifting line ( Schito & Zasso 2012) 4D WT 1 WT 2 ... • Multi-level design : aeroservoelastic models for fast](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022071116/5ffe4c0852c2ea5ac35a94a1/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Hol
istic
Des
ign
of W
ind
Turb
ines
POLITECNICO di MILANO POLI-Wind Research Lab
Acknowledgements
Work in collaboration with: M. Bassetti, P. Bettini, M. Biava, D. Boroni, F. Campagnolo, S. Calovi, S. Cacciola, A. Croce, F. Cadei, G. Campanardi, M. Capponi, G. Galetto, A. Gonzalez de Céspedes, F. Gualdoni, L. Maffenini, P. Marrone, M. Mauri, V. Petrovic, C.E.D. Riboldi, S. Rota, G. Sala, A. Zasso Funding provided by Vestas Wind Systems A/S, Clipper Windpower, Alstom Wind, DOE National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Italian Ministry of Education University and Research, partial support provided by Bachmann GmbH