patrick le boeuffrbr: toward some practical experimentation in elag?1 elag seminar, prague, 6 june...
TRANSCRIPT
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 1
FRBR: toward some practicalFRBR: toward some practicalexperimentation in ELAG?experimentation in ELAG?
ELAG Seminar, Prague, 6 June 2001
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 2
I. Context
ELAG FRBR
"not only of a high theoretical value,but also a practical one;making it possible to integrate digital resources with "traditional" material"
Susanna Peruginelli, Florence, January 2000:
FRBR =
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 3
I. Context
• Implementation problems?
Experimentation is required!
• Cataloguers’ comfort• (catalogue production devices)
• Users’ comfort• (OPAC devices)
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 4
I. Context
A new database New data to feed it
Paula Goossens’ Guidelines
Principles:
• Just XML
• New creations• No MARC structure
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 5
I. Context
• 4 bibliographic families so far not enough!
• They exist only on paper…
• Here are three of them:
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 6
II. Three examplesa) a "unicellular" family
(a very common case, especially for National Bibliographic Agencies)
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 7
IBNF 1999-53277
FRBNM001-I001
M"Ma vie: 1912-1980"
only available publication (1998)
FRBNM001
W"Ma vie: 1912-1980"
FRBNW001
E"Ma vie: 1912-1980"only available version
FRBNW001-E001
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 8
a) a "unicellular" family: comments
• Much redundancy: the same title three times!• Cataloguers shouldn’t have to type the same data several times• Once they’ve typed the title of a work, the catalogue production system should provide them with a "by default" proposal:
which they would change only when necessary
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 9
II. Three examplesb) "Boris Godunov"
The Pushkin play, the libretto, the opera, etc…
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 10
Wstudy aboutthe opera
Борис Годунов
FRBNW006W
Борис Годунов:opera
FRBNW002W
Борис Годунов:libretto
FRBNW003W
Борис Годунов:tragedy
FRBNW004W
illustrations forthe play
Борис Годунов
FRBNW005W
introduction tothe play
Борис Годунов
FRBNW007
SADA COM
EFrench
translation
E001E
1869version
E001E
1872version
E002E
Rimsky-K'sarrangement
E003E
Frenchtransl. by
O. Lanceray
E002E
Englishtranslation
E003E
definitivestate
E001E
originaltext
E001
A1997
recording
A001
A1997
recording
A001
A1962
recording
A001
Mca. 1922
publication
FRBNM010
M1998
release
FRBNM002
M1996
re-release
FRBNM003
M1980
publication
FRBNM004
M1937
publication
FRBNM005
M1926
publication
FRBNM006
M1910
publication
FRBNM007
M1982 (Paris)publication
FRBNM008
M1927
publication
FRBNM011
M1982 (NYC)publication
FRBNM009
I
I001
I
I001
I
I001
I
I001
I
I001
I
I001
I
I001
I
I002
I
I001
I
I001
I
I001
REP
E002E
Russian text1872 version
E001E
Russian text1869 version
COM
ERussian text
ed. byP. Lamm
E003E
Frenchtransl. by
Lily Denis
E004E
French tr.by Delinesand Laloy
E005
COM
COM
EFrench
transl. byA. Baranoff
E004E001E
Russiantext
SUP
TRA
TRA
TRA
TRA
TRA
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 11
II. Three examplesc) Coronelli’s "Terrestrial Globe"
A 3D cartographic materialwhich may also exist as a 2D cartographic material,which has been photographed,and about which there are electronic resources,(on CD-ROM and on the Web),and manuscript resources…
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 12
W"Le Globe terrestre"
by Vincenzo Maria Coronelli
FRBNW008
EGlobe version
FRBNW008-E001
EPlate version
FRBNW008-E002
MProduced by[?] in 1688
FRBNM012
MPublished byNolin in 1690
FRBNM013
MPublished byNolin in 1699
FRBNM014
IFine Arts Museum
in Lille
FRBNM012-I001
ITexas Tech University
in Lubbock, Texas
FRBNM012-I002
IBNF Ge CC 1273(5)
FRBNM013-I001
IBNF Ge DD 2987(82)
from "CollectionD'Anville"
FRBNM014-I001
IBNF MDC 12 005713
FRBNM015-I001
IBNF Clair. 1054
fol. 180
FRBNM016-I001
IBNF Ge D 26032
FRBNM017-I001
MPublished byBibliothèquenationale de
France in 1999
FRBNM015
M
FRBNM016 M
FRBNM017
M
FRBNM018
W"Coronelli, les globes de Louis
XIV" : CD-ROM aboutCoronelli's "Globe terrestre"
and "Globe céleste"
FRBNW009
WCoronelli's contract for
producing his "Globe terrestre"for Louis XIV
FRBNW010
WAnonymous photograph
of Coronelli's "Globeterrestre" in Lille Museum
FRBNW011
WInformation from the
Texas Tech Uni-versity's Web site
FRBNW012
E
FRBNW009-E001
EDraft
FRBNW010-E001
E
FRBNW011-E001
E
FRBNW012-E001
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 13
III. Future developments
• More than just 4 bibliographic familiesAre there any volunteers?
• A place, a computer, a software,and the database is done!
An opportunity: the VisualCat structure from the Danish Bibliographic Centre (thanks to Poul Henrik Jørgensen!)
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 14
III. Future developments
• Two main focuses:– Ergonomics of the catalogue production system– OPAC issues
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 15
IV. Some reflections on OPACs
Last year Dan Matei said:
"We must get rid of traditional "Author / Title / Subject" OPACs!"
– Would it really benefit our patrons?– How could this be achieved?
A proposal (not an answer!):
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 16
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 17
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:Person or Corporate Body
Person onlyCorporate Body only
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 18
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Work
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 19
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Work
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
WorkMonograph only
Periodical onlySeries onlyExpression
PerformanceManifestation
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 20
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Work
Object
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 21
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Work
Object
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
ObjectMusic instrument and/or voice
Scientific instrumentItem
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 22
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Work
Object
Concept
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 23
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Work
Object
Concept
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
ConceptPlaceEvent
Form/Genre
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 24
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Work
Object
Concept
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Date of manifestation (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 25
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Work
Object
Concept
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Date of manifestation (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Date of manifestationDate of work
Date of expressionDate of performance
Date of event
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 26
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Work
Object
Concept
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Date of manifestation (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Place of manifestation (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 27
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Work
Object
Concept
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Date of manifestation (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Place of manifestation (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Place of manifestationPlace of performance
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 28
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Work
Object
Concept
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Date of manifestation (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Place of manifestation (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Language of expression (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 29
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Work
Object
Concept
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Date of manifestation (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Place of manifestation (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Language of expression (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Language of expressionLanguage of performance
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 30
Person or Corporate Body (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Work
Object
Concept
(and, or, and not)
Type of responsibility:
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
(and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Date of manifestation (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Place of manifestation (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Language of expression (and, or, and not)
Phrase Word
Mathematical data Phrase Word
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 31
Person
Works
Parent works
Sibling works
Contributions
Expressions
Manifestations
Works
Expressions
Manifestations
Type of resp-onsibility
Author…
TranslatorAdaptor…
Publisher…
Owner of item…
Corporate Bodies(membership)
Subjectrelations
Works
Corporate BodiesEvents
Conferences Exhibitions…
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 32
V. Conclusion
• We need:
– Imagination– Volunteers– Funds
Patrick Le Boeuf FRBR: toward some practical experimentation in ELAG? 33
Täna väga!Täna väga!
Go raibh maith agat!
Go raibh maith agat!
Děkuji!
Děkuji!Dank U
wel!Dank U
wel!
Grazie!
Grazie!
Takk fyrir!Takk fyrir!
Köszönöm!
Köszönöm!Ευχαριστ
ώ!Ευχαριστ
ώ!Danke schön!Danke schön!
Gracinhas!
Gracinhas!
Diolch yn
fawr!
Diolch yn
fawr!Trugare
z deoc’h!
Trugarez
deoc’h!Kiitos
!Kiitos
!Hvala
!Hvala
! Gràcies!
Gràcies!
Благодаря!
Благодаря!Eskerrik
asko!Eskerrik
asko! Merci!
Merci!
Mulţumesc!
Mulţumesc!
Obrigado!
Obrigado!
Dziękuję!
Dziękuję!
Tusen
takk!
Tusen
takk!Gracia
s!Gracia
s!
Mange tak!Mange tak!
Hvala lepa!
Hvala lepa!
Дякую!
Дякую!
Ďakujem!
Ďakujem!
Спасибо!
Спасибо!
Thanks!
Thanks!
Tack så
mycket!
Tack så
mycket!