s sssssssfsd
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/27/2019 s Sssssssfsd
1/3
Megha Majumder
Federalism in the United States
Federalism is a form of government in which the power to make decisions concerning major
decisions is divided between the national government and other governmental units, like state
governments. On one hand, there is the concept of federalism. On the other hand, there exists the
concept of a confederation, in which states, for example, are dominant and hold more power than the
national government. Throughout the 20th century, the power of the federal government has increased
through numerous court decisions. While a lot of recent political debates have focused on returning
power to the states, the relationship between the federal government and the states has been argued
over for most of the history of the United States, particularly among the issues of secession,
nullification, and voting rights.
Secession is defined as the formal separation from an alliance or federation. In 1860, Lincoln's
election brought the Southern states of South Carolina, Georgia, Florida, Alabama, Mississippi, Texas,
Louisiana, Virginia, Arkansas, North Carolina, and Tennessee to the point of secession and put the
government of the United States in a precarious position. Lincoln had to choose whether he should he
allow peaceful secession or whether he should force the rebels to stay apart of the Union. This itself is
an example of federalism because the states felt that they had a right to secede from the Union and
wished to do so, but Lincoln felt that the federal government was the one to make the final decision,
and he decided that he would not stand for secession, that united they would stand, and divided they
would fall. The South had a few reasons for secession. For example, they did not want Lincoln to be in
office in the first place; this angered many Southerners. Secondly, they did not want slavery to become
-
7/27/2019 s Sssssssfsd
2/3
non-existent. Thirdly, they believed that the policies of Lincoln, a Republican president, including
protective tariffs and free homesteads in the west would prevent the South from prospering. Despite
Lincoln's nay on the matter of secession, southern states seceded anyway, which caused Lincoln to
employ force because the South was denying the democratic principle that formed the basis of the
Union. It was the most serious secession movement in the United States and was defeated when the
Union armies defeated the Confederate armies in the Civil War, from 1861 through 1865.
The concept of nullification is that individual states refuse to enforce certain federal laws which
they may find to be unconstitutional, and that the states, not the national government, should have the
final word on the interpretation of the Constitution. Nullification is an example of federalism, and it
became a highly-debated issue, particularly during the late 18th century, when the Anti-Federalist first
came up with the idea of nullification, which was in 1789. At this time, the Virginia and Kentucky
Resolutions were passed, giving nullification rights to the States. This practice was discarded when
Federalists came into power and took positions in the federal government. The nullification theory
came iinto being when the economic depression of the 1820s occurred, mainly affecting Southern
states like South Carolina. The state of South Carolina wished to override the Tariff of 1828, or the
Tariff of Abominations, claiming that nullifying a federal law was constitutional if of the states did
not agree with it. However, the federal government at this time did not stand for that, and introduced
the force bill, which allowed the President to use force to keep the Union together and to reinstate the
fact that federal government's power surpassed that of the state's in matters regarding the interpretation
of the constitution.
The issue of voting rights was another highly-debated controversy involving federalism,
because both the federal government and state governments felt that they had the power to decide the
-
7/27/2019 s Sssssssfsd
3/3
procedures by which elections are run and who was eligible to vote. A prime example of this
controversy in the history of the United States involves the Voting Rights Act of 1965, which relates to
federalism because it put the federal government in charge of the voting procedures in numerous states,
most of which were in the South. This outraged those states, but it was still established that the federal
government had greater power over the states regarding voting rights. In the 1960s, it was found that
many Southern states had been using voting rules to keep African Americans from voting, such as the
literacy test and the Grandfather Clause. The Voting Rights Act of 1965 tried to stop this by taking the
power to set up voting arrangements away from those states and giving it to the federal government.
This is why this law relates to federalism; it took a power away from the state governments, restricting
their power over voting rights, and gave it to the federal government.
Conclusively, federalism is the division of power in a nation, between the federal government
and smaller political units, such as the state governments. The history of the United States involves
much controversy concerning the concept of federalism, and time and time again, it has been
established that the federal government has more power regarding secession, nullification (both of
which were outlawed), and voting rights than the state governments through various Supreme Court
decisions. Even today, the subject of federalism is widely debated, but Lincoln's words, as of yet, have
remained true (and have been proven countless times in America's history): United we stand, Divided
we fall.