sesar maturity report executive summary · edition 04.01.00 sesar maturity report executive summary...

1 of 34

©SESAR JOINT UNDERTAKING, 2015. Created by SESAR IS for the SESAR Joint Undertaking within the frame of the SESAR Programme co-financed by the EU and EUROCONTROL. Reprint with approval of publisher and the source properly acknowledged.

SESAR Maturity Report Executive Summary

Document information

Edition 04.01.00

Abstract

The “SESAR Maturity Report Executive Summary” summarizes the progress of

Operational Focus Areas (OFA) and provides the baseline maturity status of

Operational Improvement (OI) steps within the programme.

This report intends to provide a shared and common reference for OI steps maturity

(SESAR maturity baseline). Baseline maturity is assessed using the latest information

available to the SJU, as captured through the Extended Release Strategy to cover

solutions and OI steps that will be addressed in SESAR 2020, Systems Engineering

Reviews, and ad-hoc assessments, e.g. OFA Coordinators feedback.

The Report is organised per Concept Storyboard Step (Step1, Step2, and Step3) and

structured per OFA and OI step. Edition 04 of this Report includes details on the

maturity of SESAR Solutions and their related OI steps using Dataset 14 as reference.

The “SESAR Maturity Report” reflects the current and known status of the overall

"SESAR maturity ". SESAR maturity is reviewed periodically by SJU after main Systems

Engineering Reviews. Following the same process, new versions of this SESAR Maturity

Report are issued, in order to update the current "SESAR maturity".

SESAR Members are invited to review the SESAR maturity baseline and in case of

variance, to provide evidence of the maturity of OI steps

Edition 04.01.00 SESAR Maturity Report Executive Summary

2 of 34


Authoring & Approval

Prepared By - Authors of the document.

Name & Company Position & Title Date

Mark Watson / Industrial Support ATM Performance Advisor 17/12/2015

Reviewed By - Reviewers internal to the project.


Alfredo Gomez / SJU Head of Release Management and Validation

17/12/2015

Approved for submission to the SJU By - Representatives of the company involved in the project.


Gianni Inzerillo / Industrial Support SESAR IS Director 17/12/2015

Document History

Edition Date Status Author Justification

01.00.00 18/04/2014 First Edition Mark Watson

Taking into account SJU comments, and renamed SESAR Maturity Report Executive Summary

02.00.00 23/09/2014 Second Edition Mark Watson

The first edition of this report was intended for OFA Coordinators, Work Package Leaders and Contribution Managers. Edition 2 is intended for general publication.

03.00.00 28/01/2015 Third Edition Mark Watson

Edition 3 integrates the outcomes of R5SE1, and includes analysis of the V&V Roadmap.

04.00.00 30/11/2015 Fourth Edition Mark Watson

Edition 4 integrates Release 4 outcomes plus Ad-hoc assessments. Maturity of SESAR Solutions added to the Report.

04.01.00 17/12/2015 Fourth Edition Mark Watson After feedback from SJU


3 of 34


Table of Contents

1 INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................................... 5

1.1 PURPOSE OF THE DOCUMENT ............................................................................................................... 5 1.2 INTENDED READERSHIP......................................................................................................................... 5 1.3 ACRONYMS AND TERMINOLOGY ........................................................................................................... 5 1.4 KEY PRINCIPLES ................................................................................................................................... 6 1.5 SESAR MATURITY REPORT CONTENTS .............................................................................................. 6 1.6 ASSUMPTIONS ....................................................................................................................................... 7

2 BACKGROUND ........................................................................................................................................... 8

2.1 MATURITY ASSESSMENT PROCESS...................................................................................................... 8 2.2 REPORT GENERATION .......................................................................................................................... 8

3 SESAR SOLUTION MATURITY ............................................................................................................. 10

3.1 SESAR1 SOLUTION SUMMARY .......................................................................................................... 10 3.2 SESAR 1 ............................................................................................................................................ 11 3.3 SESAR2020 ...................................................................................................................................... 14 3.4 ENABLING CAPABILITIES ..................................................................................................................... 18

4 PROGRESS OF OFA ............................................................................................................................... 20

4.1 STEP 1 ................................................................................................................................................. 20 4.2 STEP 2 ................................................................................................................................................. 21 4.3 STEP 3 ................................................................................................................................................. 22

5 OI STEP MATURITY ................................................................................................................................. 23

5.1 STEP 1 ................................................................................................................................................. 23 5.2 STEP 2 ................................................................................................................................................. 26 5.3 STEP 3 ................................................................................................................................................. 29

APPENDIX A MATURITY OF OI STEPS THAT CONTRIBUTE TO THE PCP ................................. 30

APPENDIX B OI STEPS (DS14) ............................................................................................................... 31

APPENDIX C SESAR SOLUTIONS (PIRM6.1) ...................................................................................... 32

APPENDIX D OPERATIONAL FOCUS AREAS (DS14) ....................................................................... 33


4 of 34


List of tables

Table 1: SESAR 1 Solutions Maturity ................................................................................................... 13 Table 2: SESAR2020 Solutions Maturity .............................................................................................. 18 Table 3: Step 1 OI step Maturity ........................................................................................................... 25 Table 4: Step 2 OI step Maturity ........................................................................................................... 28 Table 5: Step 3 OI step Maturity ........................................................................................................... 29

List of figures

Figure 1: Maturity Assessment Tool report generation ........................................................................... 9 Figure 2: SESAR Solution Delivery ....................................................................................................... 10 Figure 3: Step 1 OFA Progress ............................................................................................................. 20 Figure 4: Step 2 OFA Progress ............................................................................................................. 21 Figure 5: Step 3 OFA Progress ............................................................................................................. 22


5 of 34


1 Introduction

1.1 Purpose of the document

The SESAR Maturity Report Executive Summary summarizes the progress of Operational Focus Areas (OFAs) and the current baseline maturity of SESAR Solutions and Operational Improvement (OI) steps per Concept Storyboard Step within the SESAR programme.

1.2 Intended readership

The intended readers are the SESAR members, more specifically Project Managers (PjM), Work Package Leaders (WPL) and the OFA Coordinators.

1.3 Acronyms and Terminology

Term Definition

ATM Air Traffic Management

CI Configurable Items

DMT Definition Maturity Target

E-ATMS European Air Traffic Management System

MAT Maturity Assessment Tool

OFA Operational Focus Area

OI Operational Improvement

PCP Pilot Common Project

PIRM Programme Information Reference Model

PMP Programme Management Plan

SESAR Single European Sky ATM Research Programme

SJU SESAR Joint Undertaking (Agency of the European Commission)

SJU Work Programme The programme which addresses all activities of the SESAR Joint Undertaking Agency.

SESAR Programme The programme which defines the Research and Development activities and Projects for the SJU.

SE#1 Systems Engineering Review #1 (Definition)

SE#3 Systems Engineering Review #3 (Close Out)


6 of 34


1.4 Key Principles

This document is the "SESAR Maturity Report Executive Summary". The maturity is captured through Release Systems Engineering Reviews and ad-hoc assessments based on latest information available to the OFA Coordinators or the SJU.

Since this status was captured, for some OI steps, it may happen that maturity has changed compared to the results which are reflected in the “SESAR Maturity Report”. In this case, these new assessments results will feed next versions of the “SESAR Maturity Report”.

The “SESAR Maturity Report” is to be understood as reflecting the current and known status of the overall "SESAR maturity". It will more accurately reflect SESAR maturity over time, once new results are achieved within the Programme and assessments made available. SESAR maturity will be reviewed periodically by SJU after main Systems Engineering Reviews (on a basis of twice a year). Following the same process, new versions of this SESAR Maturity Report will be issued, in order to update the current "SESAR maturity ",

The “SESAR Maturity Report” provides a shared and common reference for SESAR Solutions and OI steps maturity (SESAR maturity baseline) and provides a controlled way to make this reference change.

The SESAR maturity baseline reported makes use of assessments that have been made available through Release Systems Engineering Reviews or have been provided by OFA Coordinators, as well as assumptions based on the information declared in the Validation and Verification Roadmap. SESAR Members are invited to review the SESAR maturity baseline and in case of variance, to provide evidence of the maturity of SESAR Solutions / OI steps.

1.5 SESAR Maturity Report Contents

The “SESAR Maturity Report” is constituted by five documents:

“SESAR Maturity Report Executive Summary” (this document), summarizing the progress of OFAs and the maturity of SESAR Solutions / OI steps;

Step 1 MAT report, providing a consolidated view of the Step 1 assessments (PDF);



“MAT Report Principles and Layout” presenting: the principles applied to determine the SESAR Solutions & OI Step Maturity and the resulting progress of OFAs; the layout of the MAT report; and user guidelines to help reading the MAT reports.

The results are issued from a Maturity Assessment Tool (MAT) that implements the SESAR maturity criteria

1 and has been developed to provide a consolidated view for each SESAR Solution and related

OI step(s), based on individual assessments performed by experts. MAT allows to determine SESAR Solution / OI step maturity at V1->V2, V2->V3 and V3->V4 transition

2 phases (European Operational

Concept Validation Methodology) and to compute progress of OFAs.

In this document:

Section 2 provides an overview of the maturity assessment process;

Section 3 summarizes the maturity status per SESAR Solution;

Section 4 summarizes the overall progress per OFA;

1 The SESAR Maturity Criteria guidance has been published (03/10/2012). A short guidance note and the criteria

themselves can be found in the Extranet Programme Library under Validation & Verification 2 In this Report, the transition criteria V1->V2 V2->V3, V3->V4 are referred as V1, V2 and V3


7 of 34


Section 5 summarizes the maturity status per OI step;

Appendix A summarizes the maturity of OI steps that contribute to the PCP;

Appendix B provides definitions of the OI steps;

Appendix C provides definitions of the SESAR Solutions;

Appendix D provides definitions of the Operational Focus Areas

1.6 Assumptions

The principles to assess SESAR Solution / OI step maturity are described in the document “MAT Report Principles and Layout”. However, for SESAR Solutions / OI steps declared to be in a particular validation phase (e.g. V3) and for which there were no assessments available from the previous validation phases, then it was assumed that previous validation phases were satisfactorily achieved (e.g. V1 and V2).


8 of 34


2 Background

2.1 Maturity Assessment Process

The assessment of SESAR Solutions / OI steps is based on SESAR Programme Management Plan (Edition 03.00.02). SESAR PMP provides a high level description of the process to assess and determine the degree of maturity of the SESAR concept definition.

Maturity assessment takes place along the Programme lifecycle on a yearly basis, as part of three Release management process:

Extended Release Strategy definition, to identify and plan the future activities needed for the SESAR Solutions / OI steps to achieve end of V3;

Release Systems Engineering Review 1, to confirm the V2 maturity of SESAR Solutions / OI steps using the results of the exercises preceding the proposed V3 exercises candidates;

Release Systems Engineering Review 3, to confirm the V3 maturity of SESAR Solutions / OI steps using the Release exercise results.

Maturity Assessment should also be undertaken by projects working on a given OFA along their development process.

3

2.2 Report Generation

The MAT report is generated using the following inputs (Figure 1):

The latest maturity assessments available to the SJU, providing an indication of the maturity of a SESAR Solution / OI step, and the completeness of an OFA, specifically:

o Release Systems Engineering Reviews;

o SESAR Solution / OI step assessments by OFA Coordinators;

o Setting up SESAR Solution / OI step(s) maturity assessment baseline, consolidating information provided in the V&V Roadmap, OFA Description Forms, and systems engineering data (OI step requirements/validation objectives), Extended Release Strategy.

The latest applicable integrated roadmap (DS14), providing the organization of the OFA and OI step.

Programme Information Reference Model (PIRM6.1) Configurable Items (CI) and Reports:

o Definition Maturity Target (DMT) Report4, providing a summary of the validation

exercises (past, present and future) that contributes to the validation of OI steps;

o CI#046 Validation Result, providing the B.05 performance assessment5.

o CI#064 and CI#065, providing the baseline reference for SESAR Solutions.

More detailed information on the report generation is provided in the document “MAT Report Principles and Layout”.

3 Progress in the maturity of an OI step is assessed at Release Systems Engineering Reviews, so there may be

an 18 month period (SE#1 to SE#3) where progress from V2 to V3 is not reported. .SESAR Members are invited to provide new ad-hoc assessments and visibility on the achieved maturity anytime between SE#1 and SE#3. 4 DMT Report generated 26 November 2015

5 B.05-D71 00.01.00


9 of 34


Figure 1: Maturity Assessment Tool report generation


10 of 34


3 SESAR Solution Maturity6

3.1 SESAR1 Solution summary

The evolution of the delivery of SESAR Solutions by the SESAR1 Programme is summarized in the following chart. The Release 5 SESAR Solutions are expected to be delivered at the end of the SESAR1 programme.

Figure 2: SESAR Solution Delivery

6 Appendix B provides definitions of the OI steps, Appendix C provides definitions of the SESAR Solution and

Appendix D provides definitions of the OFAs.


11 of 34


3.2 SESAR 1

Table 1 provides a summary of the maturity of SESAR Solutions that have already achieved or expected to achieve V3 maturity in the scope of SESAR1. SESAR Solutions highlighted in blue indicate that one or more contributing OI steps are covered by the Pilot Common Project.

SESAR Solution Package column denotes the Release that the SESAR Solution was delivered (green) or if validation is required or planned (amber);

Operational Improvement Step column identifies the OIs that contribute to the SESAR Solution.

Solution Coverage7 indicates if the SESAR Solution contains part of the OI step, or the full

OI step;

V1, V2 and V3 columns indicate if the validation phase is completed (green) or ongoing (amber);

OFA Solution Solution Title SESAR

Solution Package

OIs Solution Coverage

V1 V2 V3

OFA01.01.01 #55 Precision approaches using GBAS CAT II/III based on GPS L1

Release 4 AO-0505-A Full 1 2 3

OFA01.02.01

#01 RunWay Status Lights Release 5 AO-0209 Partial 1 2 2

#02 Airport Safety Nets for controllers: conformance monitoring alerts and detection of conflicting ATC clearances


#04 Enhanced Traffic Situational Awareness and Airport Safety Nets for the vehicle drivers

Release 5

AO-0105 Full 1 2 2

AO-0204 Full 1 2 2

#70 Enhanced Ground Controller Situation Awareness in all Weather Conditions


OFA01.03.01 #64 Time Based Separation Release 2 AO-0303 Full 1 2 3

OFA02.01.01

#09 Enhanced terminal operations with automatic RNP transition to ILS/GLS

Release 5 AOM-0605 Partial 1 1 2

#10 Optimised Route Network using Advanced RNP

Release 5 AOM-0404 Full 1 2 2

#11 Continuous Descent Operations (CDO) and Continuous Climb Operations (CCO)

Release 5

AOM-0702-A Full 1 1 2

AOM-0705-A Full 1 1 2

#51 Enhanced terminal operations with LPV procedures

Release 4 AOM-0605 Partial 1 1 2

#62 P-RNAV in a complex TMA Release 1 AOM-0603 Full 1 2 3

#103 Approach Procedure with vertical guidance (LPV)


#107 Point Merge in complex TMA Release 2 AOM-0601 Full 1 2 3

OFA03.01.03

#32 Free Route through the use of Direct Routing


#33 Free Route through Free Routing for Flights both in cruise and vertically evolving above a specified Flight Level


#65 User Preferred Routing Release 2 AOM-0500 Partial QW

1 1 2

7 The MAT PDF reports per Concept Storyboard Step provide additional information regarding the Solution

Coverage;


12 of 34



Solution Package


V1 V2 V3

OFA03.01.04 #37 Extended Flight Plan Release 5 AUO-0203-A Full 1 1 2

OFA03.02.01 #16 ASAS Spacing applications Remain behind and Merge behind

Release 5 TS-0105-A Full 1 1 2

OFA03.03.01

#27 MTCD and conformance monitoring tools Release 5 CM-0205 Full 1 2 2

CM-0207-A Full 1 2 2

#28

Automated Assistance to Controller for Seamless Coordination, Transfer and Dialogue through improved trajectory data sharing

Release 5 CM-0201-A Partial 1 1 2

#63 Multi Sector Planning Release 2 CM-0301 Full QW 1 2 3

#104 Sector Team Operations - En-route Air Traffic Organiser

Release 1

CM-0201 Full 1 2 3

CM-0202 Full 1 2 3

CM-0203 Full 1 2 3

CM-0205 Partial 1 2 2

OFA03.04.01

#60 Enhanced Short Term Conflict Alert (STCA) for Terminal Manoeuvring Areas (TMAs)

Release 1 CM-0811 Full 1 2 3

#69 Enhanced STCA with down-linked parameters

Release 3 CM-0807-A Full 1 2 3

OFA03.04.02 #105 Enhanced Airborne Collision Avoidance System (ACAS)

Release 1 CM-0803 Full 1 2 3

OFA04.01.01

#14 Departure Management integrating Surface Management constraints

Release 5 TS-0203 Full 1 2 2

#15 Integrated and throughput-optimised sequence of arrivals and departures


#53 Pre-Departure Sequencing supported by Route Planning


#54 Flow based Integration of Arrival and Departure Management


#106 DMAN Baseline for integrated AMAN DMAN

Release 1 TS-0202 Partial 1 2 3

OFA04.01.02

#05 Extended Arrival Management (AMAN) horizon

Release 4 TS-0305-A Full 1 2 3

#06 Controlled Time of Arrival (CTA) in Medium density / medium complexity environment


#08 Arrival Management into Multiple Airports Release 5 TS-0303 Full 1 2 2

#108 AMAN and Point Merge Release 2 TS-0102 Full 1 2 3

OFA04.02.01

#22 Automated Assistance to Controller for Surface Movement Planning and Routing

Release 5 AO-0205 Full 1 2 2

#23 D-TAXI service for CPDLC application Release 5 AUO-0308-A Full 1 1 2

#26 Manual taxi routing function Release 5 AUO-0603-A Full 1 1 2

#47 Guidance Assistance through Airfield Ground Lighting

Release 5 AO-0222 Full 1 1 2

#48 Virtual Block Control in LVPs Release 5 AO-0223 Full 1 1 2


13 of 34



Solution Package


V1 V2 V3

OFA05.01.01

#21 Airport Operations Plan and AOP-NOP Seamless Integration

Release 5

AO-0801-A Full 1 2 2

AO-0802-A Full 1 2 2

AO-0803 Full 1 2 2

AO-0804 Full 1 2 2

DCB-0309 Partial 1 2 2

DCB-0310 Full 1 2 2

#61 CWP Airport - Low Cost and Simple Departure Data Entry Panel

Release 1 DCB-0304 Full 1 2 3

OFA05.03.01 #31 Variable profile military reserved areas and enhanced (further automated) civil-military collaboration

Release 5

AOM-0202-A Full 1 2 2

AOM-0206-A Full 1 2 2

OFA05.03.03 #66 Automated Support for Dynamic Sectorisation


OFA05.03.04

#17 Advanced Short ATFCM Measures (STAM) Release 5 DCB-0308 Full 1 2 2

#18 CTOT and TTA Release 5 DCB-0208 Full 1 1 2

#19 Automated support for Traffic Complexity Detection and Resolution


CM-0104-A Full 1 1 2

OFA05.03.06 #56 Enhanced ATFM Slot Swapping Release 4 AUO-0101-A Full 1 2 3

#57 UDPP Departure Release 4 AUO-0103 Full 1 2 3

OFA05.03.07 #20 Collaborative NOP for Step 1 Release 5 DCB-0103-A Full 1 2 2

OFA06.03.01

#12 Single Remote Tower operations for medium traffic volumes

Release 5 SDM-0201 Partial 1 2 2

#13 Remotely Provided Air Traffic Service for Contingency Situations at Aerodromes

Release 5 SDM-0204 Full 1 2 2

#52 Remote Tower for two low density aerodromes

Release 4 SDM-0205 Full 1 2 3

#71 ATC and AFIS service in a single low density aerodrome from a remote CWP

Release 3 SDM-0201 Partial 1 2 2

ENB02.01.01 #46 Initial SWIM Release 5 IS-0901-A Full 1 1 2

ENB02.01.02 #34 Digital Integrated Briefing Release 5 IS-0205 Full 1 2 2

#35 MET Information Exchange Release 5 MET-0101 Full 1 2 2

ENB03.01.01 TMF

#67 AOC Data Increasing Trajectory Prediction Accuracy

Release 2 IS-0301 Partial QW

1 2 2

Table 1: SESAR 1 Solutions Maturity


14 of 34


3.3 SESAR2020

Table 2 provides a summary of the maturity of the OI steps that contribute to SESAR Solutions that will be addressed in SESAR2020. SESAR Solutions highlighted in blue indicate that one or more contributing OI steps are covered by the Pilot Common Project.

Solution Solution Title OIs V1 V2 V3

PJ.01-01 Extended Arrival Management with overlapping AMAN operations and interaction with DCB and CTA

TS-0109 1

TS-0305-B 1

PJ.01-02 Use of Arrival and Departure Management Information for Traffic Optimisation within the TMA

TS-0302-A 1 1

TS-0302-B 1 1

TS-0307 1 1

PJ.01-03 Dynamic and Enhanced Routes and Airspace

AOM-0606

AOM-0702-B 1

AOM-0705-B 1

AOM-0806 1 1

AOM-0807

PJ.01-05 Airborne Spacing Flight Deck Interval Management TS-0108 1

PJ.01-06 Enhanced Rotorcraft and GA operations in the TMA AOM-0104 1 1

AOM-0810 1 1

PJ.01-07 Approach Improvement through Assisted Visual Separation

AUO-0507 1 1

PJ.02-01 Wake turbulence separation optimization

AO-0304 1 1

AO-0306 1 1

AO-0310 1 1

AO-0323

AO-0325

AO-0327

AO-0328 1 1

AO-0329

PJ.02-02 Enhanced arrival procedures

AO-0308 1 1

AO-0319 1 1

AO-0320 1 1

AO-0321 1 1

AO-0322 1 1 2

PJ.02-03 Minimum-Pair separations based on RSP AO-0309 1 1

PJ.02-05 Independent Rotorcraft operations at the Airport AO-0316 1 1

PJ.02-06 Improved access into secondary airports in low visibility conditions

SDM-0301

PJ.02-08 Traffic optimisation on single and multiple runway airports

TS-0301

TS-0311

TS-0313

PJ.02-09 Enhanced Runway Condition Awareness AUO-0606

AUO-0704

PJ.02-11 Enhanced Terminal Area for efficient curved operation AOM-0607


15 of 34



PJ.03a-01 Enhanced Guidance Assistance to Aircraft and Vehicles on the Airport Surface Combined with Routing

AO-0206 1 2 2

AO-0215 1 2 2

AUO-0603-B

PJ.03a-03 Enhanced navigation and accuracy in low visibility conditions (LVC) on the airport surface

AUO-0613

PJ.03a-04 Enhanced Visual Operations

AUO-0404 1 1

AUO-0405 1 1

AUO-0406

AUO-0407

PJ.03a-09 Surface operations by RPAS AUO-0617

PJ.03b-01 Enhanced Airport Safety Nets for Controllers AO-0104-B

PJ.03b-03 Conformance monitoring safety net for Pilots AUO-0614 1 1

PJ.03b-05 Traffic alerts for pilots for airport operations AUO-0605 1 2 2

AUO-0615

PJ.03b-06 Safety support tools for runway excursions

AO-0107

AO-0216

AUO-0616

PJ.04-01 Enhanced Collaborative Airport Performance Planning and Monitoring

AO-0801-B 1

AO-0802-B 1

AO-0818 1

AO-0821 1

PJ.04-02 Enhanced Collaborative Airport Performance Management

AO-0813

AO-0819

AO-0820

AO-0822

AO-0823

DCB-0311

DCB-0312

PJ.05-02 Remotely Provided Air Traffic Service for Multiple Aerodromes

SDM-0207 1

PJ.05-03 Remotely Provided Air Traffic Services from a Remote Tower Centre with a flexible allocation of aerodromes to Remote Tower Modules

SDM-0208 1

SDM-0209 1

SDM-0210 1

PJ.06-01 Optimized traffic management to enable Free Routing in high and very high complexity environments.

AOM-0502 1 1

PJ.06-02 Management of Performance Based Free Routing in lower Airspace

AOM-0103

PJ.07-01 AU Processes for Trajectory Definition

AUO-0207 1

AUO-0208 1

AUO-0209 1

IS-0207

PJ.07-02 AU Fleet Prioritization and Preferences (UDPP)

AUO-0104 1 1

AUO-0105 1 1

AUO-0106

AUO-0107


16 of 34



PJ.07-03 Mission Trajectory Driven Processes

AOM-0303

AUO-0210 1 1 2

AUO-0211 1 1

AUO-0212 1

AUO-0213 1

AUO-0214 1

PJ.07-04 AU Trajectory Execution from FOC perspective AUO-0206

PJ.08-01 Management of Dynamic Airspace configurations

AOM-0206-B 1

AOM-0208-B 1 1

AOM-0805 1 1

AOM-0809 1 1

CM-0102-B 1 1

PJ.08-02 Dynamic Airspace Configuration supporting moving areas

AOM-0208-C

AOM-0209

PJ.09-01 Network Prediction and Performance

CM-0103-B 1 1

DCB-0211 1

DCB-0212 1

PJ.09-02 Integrated Local DCB Processes

CM-0104-B 1 1

CM-0302 1 1

DCB-0210 1

DCB-0213

PJ.09-03 Collaborative Network Management Functions

AUO-0108

DCB-0103-B 1

DCB-0214 1 1

DCB-0215 1 1

PJ.10-01a High Productivity Controller Team Organisation CM-0303 1

CM-0304

PJ.10-01b Flight Centred ATC CM-0200-B 1

CM-0200-C

PJ.10-01c Collaborative Control CM-0305 1 1

CM-0306 1

PJ.10-02a Improved Performance in the Provision of Separation

CM-0206 1 1

CM-0208-A 1 1

CM-0209 1 2 2

CM-0210 1 2 2

CM-0403-A 1 1

CM-0605

CM-0606 1 1

PJ.10-02b Advanced Separation Management

CM-0207-B 1

CM-0208-B

CM-0403-B

CM-0407

CM-0408

CM-0607

CM-0608

PJ.10-04 Ad Hoc Delegation of Separation to Flight Deck CM-0701


17 of 34



PJ.10-06 Generic' (non-geographical) Controller Validations SDM-0203

PJ.11-A3 ACAS for Commercial Air Transport specific operations – ACAS Xo

CM-0804

PJ.11-G1 Enhanced Ground-based Safety Nets adapted to future operations

CM-0805 1

CM-0806-B 1

CM-0806-C 1

CM-0807-B 1 1

PJ.14-01-01 CNS environment evolution

CNS-0001-B

CNS-0001-C

CNS-0002-B

CNS-0002-C

CNS-0003-B

CNS-0003-C

PJ.14-01-02 CNS Avionics integration

CNS-0001-B

CNS-0001-C

CNS-0002-B

CNS-0002-C

CNS-0003-B

CNS-0003-C

PJ.14-01-03 CNS Ground segment integration

CNS-0001-B

CNS-0001-C

CNS-0002-B

CNS-0002-C

CNS-0003-B

CNS-0003-C

PJ.14-02-01 FCI Terrestrial Data Link CNS-0001-B

CNS-0001-C

PJ.14-02-02 Future Satellite Communications Data link CNS-0001-B

CNS-0001-C

PJ.14-02-04 FCI Network Technologies incl. voice solutions and military interfacing

CNS-0001-B

CNS-0001-C

PJ.14-02-05 Development of new services similar to FIS-B to support ADS-B solutions for General Aviation

CNS-0001-B

CNS-0001-C

PJ.14-02-06 Completion of AeroMACS development CNS-0001-B

CNS-0001-C

PJ.14-03-01 GBAS CNS-0002-B

CNS-0002-C

PJ.14-03-02 Multi Constellation / Multi Frequency (MC/MF) GNSS CNS-0002-B

CNS-0002-C

PJ.14-03-04 Alternative Position, Navigation and Timing (A-PNT) CNS-0002-B

CNS-0002-C

PJ.14-04-01 Surveillance Performance Monitoring CNS-0003-B

CNS-0003-C

PJ.14-04-03 New use and evolution of Cooperative and Non-Cooperative Surveillance

CNS-0003-B

CNS-0003-C


18 of 34



PJ.17-01 SWIM TI Purple Profile for Air/Ground Advisory Information Sharing

IS-0901-B

PJ.17-02 SWIM TI Federated Identity Management IS-0901-B

PJ.17-03 SWIM TI Green profile for G/G Civil Military Information Sharing

IS-0901-C

PJ.17-07 SWIM TI Purple Profile for Air/Ground Safety-Critical Information Sharing

IS-0901-C

PJ.17-08 SWIM TI Common runtime registry IS-0901-B

PJ.18-01 Mission Trajectories

AOM-0304-A 1 1 2

AOM-0304-B

AUO-0215 1 1 2

AUO-0216 1

PJ.18-02 Integration of trajectory management processes in planning and execution

AUO-0205-A 1 1 2

AUO-0205-B 1 1

AUO-0217 1

AUO-0218 1

AUO-0219 1

AUO-0220 1

AUO-0221 1

AUO-0222 1

AUO-0223 1 1 2

AUO-0224 1 1

AUO-0225 1 1

AUO-0226 1 1

AUO-0227 1 1

AUO-0228 1 1

AUO-0303-B 1 1

AUO-0305

CM-0105-A 1 1

CM-0105-B 1

CM-0201-B

PJ.18-04 Management and sharing of data used in trajectory (AIM, METEO)

IS-0206 1 1

MET-0201 1 1

PJ.18-06 Performance Based Trajectory Prediction

IS-0301 1 2 2

IS-0302 1 2 2

IS-0303-A 1 1 2

IS-0305

Table 2: SESAR2020 Solutions Maturity

3.4 Enabling Capabilities

Future editions of the Maturity Report will include an assessment of the maturity of Technological Solutions based on Technology Readiness Level criteria (TRL). Technology that enables future SESAR Solutions, verified as feasible, safe and to provide Performance Improvements is considered to be a “Technological Solution”.

Four Technological Solutions have been initially proposed for Release 5:

Airport Surface Data Link (AeroMACS)


19 of 34


Hybrid Surveillance

ACAS Ground Monitoring System (RA downlink)

IRIS Precursor


20 of 34


4 Progress of OFA8

4.1 Step 1

Figure 3 summarizes the progress towards V3 maturity for all OI steps within an OFA for Concept Storyboard Step 1.

Figure 3: Step 1 OFA Progress

8 The principles applied to produce this view per OFA, based on the OI step assessment results, are described in

document “ MAT Report Principles and Layout”. The maturity assessment for all OI steps within the OFA

provides a measure of the progress of OFAs.


21 of 34


4.2 Step 2




22 of 34


4.3 Step 3




23 of 34


5 OI Step Maturity9

5.1 Step 1

Table 3 summarizes the assessed maturity for each OI step in Concept Storyboard Step 1.

OFA OIs V1 V2 V3

OFA01.01.01 AO-0505-A 1 2 3

OFA01.02.01

AO-0104-A 1 2 1.5

AO-0105 1 2 1.5

AO-0201-A 1 2 3

AO-0204 1 2 1.5

AO-0209 1 2 1.5

AUO-0605 1 2 1.5

OFA01.03.01

AO-0303 1 2 3

AO-0304 1 1

AO-0306 1 1

AO-0309 1 1

AO-0310 1 1

AO-0327

AO-0328 1 1

AO-0329

AUO-0703 1 2

OFA02.01.01

AOM-0104 1 1

AOM-0404 1 2 1.5

AOM-0603 1 2 3

AOM-0605 1 1 1.5

AOM-0606

AOM-0702-A 1 1 1.5

AOM-0705-A 1 1 1.5

AOM-0810 1 1

OFA03.01.03 AOM-0500 1 1 1.5

AOM-0501 1 1 1.5

OFA03.01.04

AOM-0303

AOM-0304-A 1 1 1.5

AUO-0203-A 1 1 1.5

AUO-0210 1 1 1.5

AUO-0211 1 1

AUO-0215 1 1 1.5

AUO-0223 1 1 1.5

AUO-0224 1 1

AUO-0225 1 1

AUO-0226 1 1

AUO-0227 1 1

AUO-0228 1 1

OFA03.02.01

AUO-0507 1 1

TS-0105-A 1 1 1.5

TS-0108 0.5

9 The principles applied to produce this view per OI step, based on the OI step assessment results, are described

in the document “ MAT Report Principles and Layout”. For a validation phase, green indicates that validation

is satisfactorily achieved and amber indicates that validation is ongoing.


24 of 34


OFA OIs V1 V2 V3

OFA03.03.01

CM-0201-A 1 1 1.5

CM-0205 1 2 1.5

CM-0207-A 1 2 1.5

CM-0209 1 2 1.5

CM-0210 1 2 1.5

CM-0301 1 2 3

CM-0303 1

CM-0306 1

CM-0403-A 1 1

CM-0605

OFA03.03.02

CM-0206 1 1

CM-0208-A 1 1

CM-0304

CM-0305 1 1

CM-0606 1 1

OFA03.04.01 CM-0807-A 1 2 3

CM-0811 1 2 3

OFA03.04.02 CM-0802 1 1 1.5

OFA04.01.01 TS-0202 1 2 3

TS-0308 1 2 3

OFA04.01.02

TS-0103 1 2 1.5

TS-0109 1

TS-0302-A 1 1

TS-0303 1 2 1.5

TS-0305-A 1 2 3

OFA04.02.01

AO-0205 1 2 1.5

AO-0206 1 2 1.5

AO-0215 1 2 1.5

AO-0222 1 1 1.5

AO-0223 1 1 1.5

AUO-0308-A 1 1 1.5

AUO-0603-A 1 1 1.5

CM-0105-A 1 1

OFA05.01.01

AO-0801-A 1 2 1.5

AO-0802-A 1 2 1.5

AO-0803 1 2 1.5

AO-0804 1 2 1.5

DCB-0304 1 2 3

DCB-0309 1 2 1.5

DCB-0310 1 2 1.5

OFA05.03.01 AOM-0202-A 1 2 1.5

AOM-0206-A 1 2 1.5

OFA05.03.03 CM-0102-A 1 2 3

OFA05.03.04

CM-0103-A 1 1 1.5

CM-0104-A 1 1 1.5

DCB-0208 1 1 1.5

DCB-0213

DCB-0308 1 2 1.5

OFA05.03.06

AUO-0101-A 1 2 3

AUO-0103 1 2 3

AUO-0108

OFA05.03.07 DCB-0103-A 1 2 1.5

OFA06.03.01 SDM-0201 1 2 1.5

ENB02.01.01 IS-0402

IS-0901-A 1 1 1.5


25 of 34


OFA OIs V1 V2 V3

ENB02.01.02 IS-0205 1 2 1.5

MET-0101 1 2 1.5

ENB03.01.01 TMF

AUO-0205-A 1 1 1.5

AUO-0303-A 1 1 1.5

IS-0301 1 2 1.5

IS-0302 1 2 1.5

IS-0303-A 1 1 1.5

Table 3: Step 1 OI step Maturity


26 of 34


5.2 Step 2


OFA OIs V1 V2 V3

OFA01.01.01 AO-0505-B

OFA01.01.02

AUO-0404 1 1

AUO-0405 1 1

AUO-0406

AUO-0407

OFA01.02.01

AO-0104-B

AO-0106

AUO-0607

AUO-0614 1 1

AUO-0615

AUO-0616

OFA01.03.01

AO-0216

AO-0307

AO-0308 1 1

AO-0311 1

AO-0316 1 1

AO-0319 1 1

AO-0320 1 1

AO-0321 1 1

AO-0322 1 1 1.5

AO-0323

AO-0324

AO-0325

AUO-0606

AUO-0704

SDM-0301

TS-0301

OFA02.01.01

AOM-0607

AOM-0702-B 0.5

AOM-0705-B 0.5

AOM-0806 1 1

OFA03.01.03 AOM-0502 1 1

OFA03.01.04

AOM-0304-B

AUO-0207 0.5

AUO-0208 0.5

AUO-0209 0.5

AUO-0212 0.5

AUO-0213 0.5

AUO-0214 0.5

AUO-0216 0.5

AUO-0217 0.5

AUO-0218 0.5

AUO-0219 0.5

AUO-0220 0.5

AUO-0221 0.5

AUO-0222 0.5

AUO-0305


27 of 34


OFA OIs V1 V2 V3

OFA03.03.01

AUO-0304 1 1

CM-0200-B 1

CM-0207-B 1

CM-0403-B

CM-0407

CM-0607

SDM-0203

OFA03.03.02

CM-0208-B

CM-0408

CM-0608

OFA03.04.01 CM-0806-B 1

CM-0807-B 1 1

OFA03.04.02 CM-0808 0.5 1

OFA04.01.01

DCB-0312

TS-0203 1 2 1.5

TS-0309 1 2 1.5

TS-0311

TS-0313

OFA04.01.02

TS-0302-B 1 1

TS-0305-B 0.5

TS-0307 1 1

OFA04.02.01

AUO-0308-B

AUO-0309

AUO-0603-B

AUO-0613

AUO-0617

AUO-0805

AUO-0806

CM-0105-B 1

OFA05.01.01

AO-0801-B 1

AO-0802-B 1

AO-0813

AO-0818 1

AO-0819

AO-0820

AO-0821 1

AO-0822

AO-0823

DCB-0311

OFA05.03.01

AOM-0204 1 2 3

AOM-0206-B 0.5

AOM-0208-B 1 1

AOM-0209

OFA05.03.03

AOM-0805 1 1

AOM-0807

AOM-0809 1 1

CM-0102-B 1 1

OFA05.03.04

CM-0103-B 1 1

CM-0104-B 1 1

CM-0302 1 1

DCB-0210 1

DCB-0211 1

DCB-0212 1

DCB-0214 1 1

DCB-0215 1 1


28 of 34


OFA OIs V1 V2 V3

OFA05.03.06

AUO-0104 1 1

AUO-0105 1 1

AUO-0106

AUO-0107

OFA05.03.07 DCB-0103-B 0.5

OFA06.03.01

SDM-0204 1 2 1.5

SDM-0205 1 2 3

SDM-0206

SDM-0207 1

SDM-0208 1

SDM-0209 1

SDM-0210 1

SDM-0211

SDM-0212

ENB02.01.01 IS-0901-B

ENB02.01.02

IS-0206 1 1

IS-0207

MET-0201 1 1

ENB03.01.01 TMF

AUO-0205-B 1 1

AUO-0206

AUO-0303-B 1 1

CM-0201-B



29 of 34


5.3 Step 3


OFA OIs V1 V2 V3

OFA01.02.01

AO-0107

AUO-0505

AUO-0506

AUO-0608

OFA01.03.01

AUO-0504

AUO-0705

AUO-0706

OFA03.01.04

AOM-0304-C

AUO-0203-C

AUO-0204-C

OFA03.02.03 CM-0501

OFA03.02.04

CM-0701

CM-0702 0.5

CM-0704

OFA03.03.01

CM-0200-C

CM-0604

SDM-0202

OFA03.04.01 CM-0805 1

CM-0806-C 1

OFA03.04.02 CM-0804

OFA04.02.01 AUO-0604

OFA05.03.01 AOM-0103

AOM-0208-C

OFA05.03.03 AOM-0803

OFA05.03.07 DCB-0103-C

ENB02.01.01

IS-0406

IS-0710

IS-0901-C

ENB02.01.02 MET-0301

ENB03.01.01 TMF

AUO-0302-C

AUO-0303-C

IS-0303-C

IS-0305



30 of 34


Appendix A Maturity of OI steps that contribute to the PCP

ATM Functionality ATM Sub-Functionality OIs Step V1 V2 V3

Extended Arrival Management and Performance Based Navigation in the High Density Terminal Manoeuvring Areas

Arrival Management extended to en-route Airspace

TS-0305-A S1 1 2 3

Enhanced Terminal Airspace using RNP-Based Operations

AOM-0605 S1 1 1 1.5

AOM-0603 S1 1 2 3

Airport Integration and Throughput

Departure Management Synchronised with Pre-departure sequencing

TS-0202 S1 1 2 3

AO-0801-A S1 1 2 1.5

Departure Management integrating Surface Management Constraints

TS-0203 S2 1 2 1.5

Time-Based Separation for Final Approach

AO-0303 S1 1 2 3

Automated Assistance to Controller for Surface Movement Planning and Routing

AO-0205 S1 1 2 1.5

Airport Safety Nets AO-0104-A S1 1 2 1.5

Flexible Airspace Management and Free Route

Airspace Management and Advanced Flexible Use of Airspace

AOM-0202-A S1 1 2 1.5

AOM-0206-A S1 1 2 1.5

CM-0102-A S1 1 2 3

Free Route

AOM-0500 S1 1 1 1.5

AOM-0501 S1 1 1 1.5

AOM-0502 S2 1 1

Network Collaborative Management

Enhanced Short Term ATFCM Measures

DCB-0308 S1 1 2 1.5

Collaborative NOP DCB-0103-A S1 1 2 1.5

Calculated Take-off Time to Target Times for ATFCM purposes

DCB-0208 S1 1 1 1.5

Automated support for Traffic Complexity Assessment

AUO-0203-A S1 1 1 1.5

CM-0103-A S1 1 1 1.5

Initial System Wide Information Management

Common Infrastructure Components, SWIM Technical infrastructure and Profiles, Aeronautical information exchange, Cooperative network information exchange

IS-0901-A S1 1 1 1.5

Meteorological information exchange MET-0101 S1 1 2 1.5

Flight information exchange CM-0201-A S1 1 1 1.5

Initial Trajectory Information Sharing (i4D) - Extended Projected Profile (EPP)

Initial Trajectory Information Sharing (i4D)

IS-0303-A S1 1 1 1.5


31 of 34


Appendix B OI Steps (DS14)

The attached Excel file provides the title and descriptions of all Step 1, Step 2 and Step 3 OI steps.

DS14 - OI Step Reference.xls


32 of 34


Appendix C SESAR Solutions (PIRM6.1)

The attached Excel file provides the title and descriptions of all SESAR1 and SESAR2020 SESAR Solutions.

SESAR Solution Reference PIRM6.1.xls


33 of 34


Appendix D Operational Focus Areas (DS14) OFA Title

OFA01.01.01 LVPs using GBAS

OFA01.01.02 Pilot enhanced vision

OFA01.02.01 Airport safety nets

OFA01.03.01 Enhanced Runway Throughput

OFA02.01.01 Optimised 2D/3D Routes

OFA03.01.03 Free Routing

OFA03.01.04 Business and Mission Trajectory

OFA03.02.01 ASAS Spacing

OFA03.02.03 ATSA-ITP

OFA03.02.04 ASEP

OFA03.03.01 Ground Based Separation Provision in En Route

OFA03.03.02 Ground Based Separation Provision in the TMA

OFA03.04.01 Enhanced Ground Based Safety Nets

OFA03.04.02 Enhanced ACAS Operations

OFA04.01.01 Integrated Arrival/Departure Management at Airports

OFA04.01.02 Enhanced Arrival & Departure Management in TMA and En Route

OFA04.02.01 Integrated Surface Management

OFA05.01.01 Airport Operations Management

OFA05.03.01 Airspace Management and AFUA

OFA05.03.03 Dynamic Airspace Configurations

OFA05.03.04 Enhanced ATFCM processes

OFA05.03.06 UDPP

OFA05.03.07 Network Operations Planning

OFA06.01.01 CWP Airport

OFA06.02.01 CWP En Route and TMA

OFA06.03.01 Remote Tower

ENB02.01.01 SWIM

ENB02.01.02 AIM/MET

ENB03.01.01 TMF

Trajectory Management Framework and System Interoperability with air and ground data sharing


34 of 34


-END OF DOCUMENT-

sesar maturity report executive summary · edition 04.01.00 sesar maturity report executive summary...

Documents