December 16, 2015

Ms. Stephanie L. Jonaitis Pepper Hamilton LLP 301 Carnegie Center, Suite 400 Princeton, NJ 08543-5276

Re: Second Appeal of Freedom of Information No. 14831

Dear Ms . .Tonaitis:

THE PORT AUTHORnY OF NY & NJ

FOi Administrator

This is in furtherance of our December 8, 2015 letter transmitting the decision of the Po1i Authority Freedom of Information Review Board (the "FIRB") in connection with the October 16, 2015 renewed appeal of your April 8, 2015 Freedom of Information request.

The FIRB remanded this FOI request to OSEC for immediate compliance with FIRB's July 31, 2015 decision. OSEC was required to set forth the specific and factual basis for withholding each and all of the challenged documents on the Exemption Log within (10) days of the order.

Material responsive to your request and available under the Code is attached. Certain portions of the material are exempt from disclosure as, among other classifications, intra-agency deliberative process.

Please refer to the above FOI reference number in any future correspondence relating to your request.

Very truly yours,

Danny Ng FOI Administrator

Enclosure

4 World Trade Centei; l Bth 1/oor 150 Greenwich Street New York, NY 7 0007 T 212 435 7548 F, 212 435 7555

Exemption Log for FOI Request #14831

The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (the "Port Authority") hereby propounds the underlying exemption log for such communications and/or documents responsive to the April 8, 2014 Freedom of Information Request submitted by Stephanie L. J onaitis on behalf of S.M. Electric Company, Inc.

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF

NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT( S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

1 9/17/2010 Michael Daniel Lochard and Raul Leonardo Bus Bar Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Wallace process. E-mail messages

among staff of PA and its contractor re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal Band efforts to address problems.

2 9/16/2010 Michael Daniel Lochard, Raul Leonardo, Bus Bar Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Wallace Herman Ret, Syed Ruda, Thomas referencing process. E-mail messages attachment

LaMarca, Dawn Haines, Nicholas attachments among staff of PA and its Simeonidis, Caesar Johnson, Frank WLCertTest contractor re: problems Radics, Sarah McKeon Report; ANSI with electrical

C37.50 LVPB infrastructure at EWR Production Test Terminal B and efforts to

address problems.

,., 9/7/2010 Michael Jeff Konen, Raul Leonardo, Eric Bus Bar Intra-agency deliberative E-mail .)

Wallace Winkler, Daniel Lochard process. E-mail messages among staff of PA and its contractor re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal Band efforts to address problems.

1

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF

NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

4 9/1/2010 HermanRet Michael Wallace, Daniel Lochard, EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Syed Huda, James Heitmann, Frank Discoloration of process. E-mail Radics, Thomas LaMarca, Raul Busbar- messages among staff of Leonardo, John McConkey, Leonid Resolution PA re: problems with Roytman, Sarah McKeon, Nicholas electrical infrastructure at Simeonidis, Caesar Johnson, Brian EWR Terminal B and Hegarty, Sherry Berty, Kevin Hogan, efforts to address Gregg Leggett, Stanley Sienkiewicz problems.

5 9/1/2010 Syed, Huda Michael Wallace, Daniel Lochard, EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Herman Ret, James Heitmann, Frank Discoloration of process. E-mail messages Radics, Thomas LaMarca, Raul Busbar- among staff of PA re: Leonardo, John McConkey, Leonid Resolution problems with electrical Roytman, Sarah McKeon, Nicholas infrastructure at EWR Simeonidis, Caeser Johnson, Brian Terminal B and efforts to Hegarty, Sherry Berty, Kevin Hogan address problems. Gregg Leggett, Stanley Sienkiewicz

6 9/1/2010 Michael Daniel Lochard, Herman Ret, Syed EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Wallace Huda, James Heitmann, Frank Discoloration of process. E-mail message attachment

Radics, Thomas LaMarca, Raul Busbar- to PA staff re: problems Leonardo, John McConkey, Leonid Resolution; with electrical Roytman, Sarah McKeon, Nicholas referencing an infrastructure at EWR Simeonidis, Caesar Johnson, Brian attachment VRH Terminal B and efforts to Hegarty, Sherry Berty, Kevin Hogan, Letter- address problems. Gregg Leggett, Stanley Sienkiewicz Remediation of

...

2

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

7 8/1/2010 HermanRet Michael Wallace, James Heitmann, EWR 264.00. - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Frank Radics, Nicholas Simeonidis, Bus Bar process. E-mail messages Raul Leonardo, Daniel Lochard, Discoloration among staff of PA re: Caeser Johnson, Brian Hegarty, John problems with electrical McConkey, Thomas LaMarca, Syed infrastructure at EWR Huda, Leonid Roytman, Sarah Terminal B and efforts to McKeon address problems.

8 7/29/2010 Michael James Heitmann, Frank Radics, EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Wallace Herman Ret, Nicholas Simeonidis, Bus Bar process. E-mail message attachment

Raul Leonardo, Daniel Lochard, Discoloration; to PA staff re: problems Caeser Johnson, Brian Hegarty, John referencing with electrical McConkey, Thomas LaMarca, Syed attachment infrastructure at EWR Huda, Leonid Roytman, Sarah Bus bar Terminal B and efforts to McKeon address problems.

9 7/26/2010 Michael Herman Ret, James Heitmann, Frank EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Wallace Radics, Nicholas Simeonidis, Caeser Bus bar process. E-mail message

Johnson, John McConkey, Syed Discoloration; to PA staff re: problems Huda, Sarah McKeon, Leonid referencing with electrical Roytman, Thomas LaMarca, Brian attachment infrastructure at EWR Hegarty, Raul Leonardo "Letter MW to Terminal B and efforts to

JK Busbar" address problems.

3

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

10 5/6/2010 Michael John McConkey, Leonid Roytman, EWR264.003- Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Wallace Nicholas Simeonidis, Raul Leonardo, Discoloration of process. E-mail message attachment

Sherry Berty, Daniel Lochard, Brian the to PA staff re: problems s Hegarty, Roger Prince BusBar(Large with electrical

File Due to infrastructure at EWR attachments); Terminal B and efforts to "this is sm address problems. Electric reponse to RE Letter" "RE Letter to GC" "Lucius Pitkin Report" "Siemen's SwitchGear Cut Sheet" "Siemen's Reponse to Discoloration Issue" two pictures of Discolored buss

11 9/16/2010 Raul Daniel Lochard EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Leonardo Discoloration of process. E-mail message attachment

Busbar- to PA staff re: problems Resolution; there with electrical is an attachment infrastructure at EWR "VRH Letter - Terminal B and efforts to Remediation of address problems. Bu ... "

4

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF

NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT( S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

12 7/19/2010 Daniel Daniel Nunez Letter to VRH Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Lo chard process. E-mail message

to PA staff re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal B and efforts to address problems.

13 9/17/2010 Michael Daniel Lochard, Raul Leonardo Bus bar Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Wallace process .. E-mail

messages among staff of PA and its contractor re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal B and efforts to address problems.

14 9/16/2010 Michael Daniel Lochard, Raul Leonardo, Bus bar Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Wallace Herman Ret, Syed Huda, Thomas referencing process .. E-mail attachment

LaMarca, Dawn Haines, Nicholas attachments messages among staff of s Simeonidis, Caesar Johnson, Frank "WLCertTestRe PA and its contractor re: Radics, Sarah McKean port.pdf; AJ\TSI pro bl ems with electrical

C37.50 LVPB infrastructure at EWR Production Terminal Band efforts to Tests.doc" address problems.

5

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

15 9/1/2010 Michael Daniel Lochard, Herman Ret, Syed EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Wallace Ruda, James Heitmann, Frank Discoloration of process. E-mail message attachment

Radics, Thomas LaMarca, Raul Busbar- to PA staff re: problems Leonardo, John McConkey, Leonid Resolution with electrical Roytman, Sarah Mckeon, Nicholas referencing infrastructure at EWR Simeonidis, Caesar Johnson, Brian attachment Terminal B and efforts to Hegarty, Sherry Berty, Kevin Hogan, "VRH Letter - address problems. Gregg Leggett, Stanley Sienkiewicz Remediation of

Bu ... " 16 7/29/2010 Michael James Heitmann, Frank Radics, EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o

Wallace Herman Ret, Nicholas Simeonidis, Bus Bar process. E-mail message attachment Raul Leonardo, Daniel Lochard, Discoloration to PA staff re: problems Caesar Johnson, Brian Hegarty, John with electrical McConkey, Thomas LaMarca, Syed infrastructure at EWR Huda, Leonid Roytman, Sarah Terminal B and efforts to McKeon address problems.

17 7/9/2010 Michael Herman Ret, John McConkey, Bus Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Wallace Leonid Roytman, Syed Huda, Brian Discoloration process. E-mail messages

Hegarty, James Heitmann, Nicholas Letter to PA staff and its Simeonidis, Frank Radics, Sarah contractor re: problems McKeon, Thomas LaMarca, Daniel with electrical Lochard, Caesar Johnson, John infrastructure at EWR Bullard Terminal B and efforts to

address problems.

6

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF

NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

18 7/6/2010 Michael John McConkey, Leonid Roytman, Bus Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Wallace Syed Huda, Brian Hegarty, James Discoloration process. E-mail messages attachment

Heitmann, Nicholas Simeonidis, Letter; among staff of PA and its s Frank Radics, Sarah McKeon, referencing contractor re: problems Herman Ret, Thomas LaMArca, attachments with electrical Daniel Lo chard, Caesar Johnson, "SFX69E.PDF; infrastructure at EWR John Bullard Attachment 10 - Terminal B and efforts to

Cool Amp.pdf' address problems.

19 5/21/2010 John Michael Wallace, Nichols EWR264.003- Intra-agency deliberative E-mail McConkey Simeonidis, Raul Leonardo, Sherry Discoloration of process. E-mail messages

Berty, Daniel Lochard, Brian the among staff of PA re: Hegarty, Roger Prince, Leonid BusBar(Large problems with electrical Roytman, Paul Rothman File Due to infrastructure at EWR

attachments); Terminal B and efforts to address problems.

20 4/28/2010 Michael Raul Leonardo, Daniel Lochard EWR-264.003 Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Wallace Copper Bus process. E-mail messages

Sample among staff of PA re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal B and efforts to address problems.

21 4/26/2010 Michael Raul Leonardo, Daniel Lochard Draft letter - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Wallace stained bus bar process. E-mail messages attachment

referencing among staff of PA re: attachment problems with electrical "rejected bus- infrastructure at EWR bars.doc" Terminal B and efforts to

address problems.

7

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

22 4/19/2010 Michael Herman Ret, Alex Alvarez, John EWR264.003- Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Wallace Bullard, Daniel Webber, Daniel South Substation process. E-mail messages

Lochard, Raul Leonardo, Frank SwitchGear Bus among staff of PA re: Radics, Ajit Haldipur, Leonid Discoloration problems with electrical Roytman, Carlos Perez, Caesar infrastructure at EWR Johnson, Nicholas Simeonidis, Roger Terminal B and efforts to Prince, Sherry Berty, Peter Parfinik, address problems. Thomas LaMarca, Brian Hegarty

23 4/8/2010 Michael Alex Alvarez, John Bullard, Herman EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Wallace Ret, Daniel Webber, Daniel Lochard, South Substation process. E-mail messages

Raul Leonardo, Frank Radics, Ajit SwitchGear Bus among staff of PA re: Haldipur, Leonid Roytman, Carlos Discoloration problems with electrical Perez, Caesar Johnson, Nicholas infrastructure at EWR Simeonidis, Roger Prince, Sherry Terminal B and efforts to Berty address problems.

24 4/5/2010 Michael Alex Alvarez, John Bullard, Daniel EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Wallace Webber, Herman Ret, Daniel South Substation process. E-mail message attachment

Lochard, Raul Leonardo, Frank SwitchGear Bus among staff of PA re: s Radics, Ajit Haldipur, Leonid Discoloration problems with electrical Roytman, Carlos Perez, Caesar referencing infrastructure at EWR Johnson attachments Terminal Band efforts to

"FW: Siemens address problems. Bus Discoloration" "South Substation Switch Gear B ... "

8

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

25 4/5/2010 Daniel Michael Wallace Siemens Bus Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Lo chard Discoloration process. E-mail messages attachment

Letter among staff of PA re: s referencing problems with electrical attachments infrastructure at EWR "Newark Terminal B and efforts to Airport-Bus address problems. discoloration. Pdf; C1260X-TR-253.pdf'

26 3/31/2010 HermanRet Michael Wallace, Ajit Haldipur, Syed South Substation Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Huda, Frank Radics, Caesar Johnson, Switch Gear Bus process. E-mail message attachment Raul Leonardo, Thomas LaMarca, referencing 3 among staff of PA re: s Peter Parfinik, Daniel Lochard photos problems with electrical

infrastructure at EWR Terminal B and efforts to address problems.

27 11/19/201 Daniel Herman Ret, Thomas LaMarca, Raul Siemens Intra-agency deliberative E-mail 0 Lo chard Leonardo Recertification process. E-mail message

Testing among staff of PA re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal Band efforts to address problems.

9

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF

NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT( S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

28 11/19/201 HermanRet Raul Leonardo, Daniel Lochard, Switchgear SA Intra-agency deliberative E-mail 0 Caesar Johnson, Michael Wallace, Schedule process. E-mail messages

Thomas LaMarca, Frank Radics among staff of PA re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal B and efforts to address problems.

29 11/19/201 HermanRet Michael Wallace Discolored Bus Intra-agency deliberative E-mail 0 process. E-mail messages

among staff of PA re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal B and efforts to address problems.

30 11/19/201 HermanRet Herman Ret, Michael Wallace, TB north sub NA Intra-agency deliberative E-mail 0 Daniel Lochard, Raul Leonardo, Syed - Bus Corrosion process. E-mail message

Huda, Thomas LaMarca, Joseph among staff of PA re: Balance, Frank Radics, James problems with electrical Heitmann, Nicholas Simeonidis, infrastructure at EWR Caesar Johnson Terminal Band efforts to

address problems.

31 11/19/201 Daniel Herman Ret, Caesar Johnson, Raul Siemens Intra-agency deliberative E-mail 0 Lo chard Leonardo, Thomas LaMarca Technician for process. E-mail messages

Switchgear SA among staff of PA re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal Band efforts to address problems.

10

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

32 11/19/201 HermanRet Daniel Lochard, Thomas LaMarca, Siemans Intra-agency deliberative E-mail 0 Raul Leonardo, Caesar Johnson Technician Site process. E-mail messages

Work among staff of PA re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal B and efforts to address problems.

,.,,., 11/18/201 Raul Daniel Lo chard, Caesar Johnson, Switchgear SA Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o .) .)

0 Leonardo Michael Wallace, Thomas LaMarca Schedule process. E-mail message attachment referencing among staff of PA re: attachment problems with electrical "20134 Five infrastructure at EWR Week Look for Terminal B and efforts to SA 2010-11-15 address problems. (SM Electric). pdf'

34 11/03/201 Daniel Herman Ret, Thomas LaMarca, Siemens ETU Intra-agency deliberative E-mail 0 Lo chard Robert Grassi, Peter Parfinik, Joseph Testing process. E-mail messages

Balance, Andrew Hreha among staff of PA re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal Band efforts to address problems.

35 9/28/2010 HermanRet Daniel Lochard, Raul Leonardo, Syed TB north sub NA Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Huda, Thomas LaMarca, Joseph - Bus Corrosion process. E-mail messages attachment Balance, Frank Radics, James referencing among staff of PA re: Heitman, Nicholas Simeonidis, attachment problems with electrical Caesar Johnson "IM GOO 142.jpg" infrastructure at EWR

Terminal Band efforts to address problems.

11

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF

NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

36 9/27/2010 Herman Ret Daniel Lochard TB north sub NA Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o referencing process. E-mail message attachment attachment between staff of PA re: "IM GOO 142.jpg" problems with electrical

infrastructure at EWR Terminal B and efforts to address problems.

37 9/20/2010 Leonid Herman Ret, Syed Huda Bus bar Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Roytman referencing process. E-mail messages attachment

attachments among staff of PA and its s "WLCertTestRe contractor re: problems port.pdf; ANSI with electrical C37.50 LVPB infrastructure at EWR Production Terminal B and efforts to Tests.doc" address problems.

38 9/20/2010 Syed Huda HermanRet Bus bar Intra-agency deliberative E-mail process. E-mail messages among staff of PA and its contractor re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal B and efforts to address problems.

12

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF

NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

39 9/1/2010 Herman Ret Michael Wallace, Daniel Lochard, EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Syed Huda, James Heitmann, Frank Discoloration of process. E-mail messages Radics, Thomas LaMarca, Raul Busbar- among staff of PA and its Leonardo, John McConkey, Leonid Resolution contractor re: problems Roytman, Sarah McKeon, Nicholas with electrical Simeonidis, Caesar Johnson, Brian infrastructure at EWR Hegarty, Sherry Berty, Kevin Hogan, Terminal B and efforts to Gregg Leggett, Stanley Sienkiewicz address problems.

40 9/1/2010 SyedHuda Michael Wallace, Daniel Lo chard, EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Herman Ret, James Heitmann, Frank Discoloration of process. E-mail messages Radics, Thomas LaMarca, Raul Busbar- among staff of PA and its Leonardo, John McConkey, Leonid Resolution contractor re: problems Roytman, Sarah McKeon, Nicholas with electrical Simeonidis, Caesar Johnson, Brian infrastructure at EWR Hegarty, Sherry Berty, Kevin Hogan, Terminal B and efforts to Gregg Leggett, Stanley Sienkiewicz address problems.

41 9/1/2010 Michael Daniel Lochard, Herman Ret, Syed EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Wallace Huda, James Heitmann, Frank Discoloration of process. E-mail message attachment

Radics, Thomas LaMarca, Raul Busbar- among staff of PA and its Leonardo, John McConkey, Leonid Resolution contractor re: problems Roytman, Sarah McKeon, Nicholas referencing with electrical Simeonidis, Caesar Johnson, Brian attachment infrastructure at EWR Hegarty, Sherry Berty, Kevin Hogan, "VRH Letter - Terminal B and efforts to Gregg Leggett, Stanley Sienkiewicz Remediation of address problems.

Bu .. "

13

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF

NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

42 8/1/2010 HermanRet Michael Wallace, Jam.es Heitmann, EWR264.003- Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Frank Radics, Nicholas Simeonidis, Bus Bar process. E-mail messages Raul Leonardo, Daniel Lochard, Discoloration among staff of PA and its Caesar Johsnon, Brian Hegarty, John contractor re: problems McConkey, Thomas LaMarca, Syed with electrical Huda, Leonid Roytman, Sarah infrastructure at EWR McKeon Terminal B and efforts to

address problems.

43 7/29/2010 Michael James Heitmann, Frank Radics, EWR264.003- Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Wallace Herman Ret, Nicholas Simeonidis, Bus Bar process. E-mail message attachment

Raul Leonardo, Daniel Lochard, Discoloration among staff of PA and its Caesar Johnson, Brian Hegarty, John referencing contractor re: problems McConkey, Thomas LaMarca, Syed attachment with electrical Huda, Leonid Roytman, Sarah "Bus bar. pdf' infrastructure at EWR McKeon Terminal Band efforts to

address problems.

44 7/9/2010 Michael Herman Ret, John McConkey, Bus Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Wallace Leonid Roytman, Syed Huda, Brian Discoloration process. E-mail message

Hegarty, James Heitmann, Nicholas Letter among staff of PA and its Simeonidis, Frank Radics, Sarah contractor re: problems McKeon, Thomas LaMarca, Daniel with electrical Lo chard, Caesar Johnson, John infrastructure at EWR Bullard Terminal B and efforts to

address problems.

14

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

45 7/9/2010 HermanRet Michael Wallace, John McConkey, Bus Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Leonid Roytman, Syed Huda, Brian Discoloration process. E-mail messages Hegarty, James Heitmann, Nicholas Letter among staff of PA and its Simeonidis, Frank Radics, Sarah contractor re: problems McKeon, Thomas LaMarca, Daniel with electrical Lochard, Caesar Johnson, John infrastructure at EWR Bullard Terminal Band efforts to

address problems.

46 6/15/2010 Michael John McConkey, Syed Huda, Ajit LLE- Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Wallace Haldipur, Frank Radics, Herman Ret, Equipment process. E-mail messages attachment

James Heitmann, Nicholas Storage among staff of PA re: s Simeonidis, Roger Prince, Brian referencing problems with electrical Hegarty, Sarah McKeon, Caesar attachments infrastructure at EWR Johnson, Thomas LaMarca "DSCF3174.JPG Terminal Band efforts to

' address problems.

DSCF3157.JPG" 47 6/8/2010 Michael Nicholas Simeonidis, Frank Radics, EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o

Wallace James Heitmann, Brian Hegarty, John LetterVRH process. E-mail message attachment McConkey, Herman Ret, Leonid regarding among staff of PA re: Roytman Sieman's Busbar problems with electrical

referencing infrastructure at EWR attachment Terminal B and efforts to "DOC100607.pd address problems. f'

48 6/8/2010 Herman Ret HermanRet South Substation Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Switch Gear Bus process. E-mail messages attachment referencing among staff of PA re: s attachments problems with electrical "IMG _ 0086.jpg; infrastructure at EWR IMG _ 0080.jpg; Terminal Band efforts to IMG_0087.jpg" address problems.

15

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

49 6/1/2010 Thomas HermanRet South Sub Bus Intra-agency deliberative E-mail LaMarca Discoloration process. E-mail messages

among staff of PA re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal Band efforts to address problems.

50 5/24/2010 Michael Frank Radics, Herman Ret EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Wallace Discoloration of process. E-mail messages

the BusBar among staff of PA re: (Large File due problems with electrical to attachments) infrastructure at EWR

Terminal Band efforts to address problems.

51 5/21/2010 John Michael Wallace, Nicholas EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Mc Conkey Simeonidis, Raul Leonardo, Sherry Discoloration of process. E-mail messages

Berty, Daniel Lochard, Brian the BusBar among staff of PA re: Hegarty, Roger Prince, Leonid (Large File due problems with electrical Roytman, Paul Rothman to attachments) infrastructure at EWR

Terminal Band efforts to address problems.

16

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

52 5/12/2010 Michael Herman Ret, Frank Radics, Sarah EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Wallace McKeon Discoloration of process. E-mail messages attachment

the BusBar among staff of PA re: s (Large File due problems with electrical to attachments) infrastructure at EWR referencing Terminal Band efforts to attachments "this address problems. is SM electric response to RE letter; RE Letter to GC; Lucius Pitkin Report; Sieman's SwitchGear Cut Sheet"

53 5/12/2010 HermanRet Michael Wallace Discolored Bus Intra-agency deliberative E-mail process. E-mail message among staff of PA re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal B and efforts to address problems.

54 4/19/2010 Michael Herman Ret, Alex Alvarez, John EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Wallace Bullard, Daniel Webber, Daniel South Substation process. E-mail messages

Lochard, Raul Leonardo, Frank SwitchGear Bus among staff of PA re: Radics, Ajit Haldipur, Leonid Discoloration problems with electrical Roytman, Carlos Perez, Caesar infrastructure at EWR Johnson, Nicholas Simeonidis, Roger Terminal B and efforts to Prince, Sherry Berty, Peter Parfinik, address problems. Thomas LaMarca, Brian Hegarty

17

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF

NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

55 4/19/2010 HermanRet Herman Ret, Michael Wallace, Alex EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Alvarez, John Bullard, Daniel South Substation process. E-mail messages Webber, Daniel Lochard, Raul SwitchGear Bus among staff of PA re: Leonardo, Frank Radics, Ajit Discoloration problems with electrical Haldipur, Leonid Roytman, Carlos infrastructure at EWR Perez, Caesar Johnson, Nicholas Terminal B and efforts to Simeonidis, Roger Prince, Sherry address problems. Berty, Peter Parfinik, Thomas LaMarca

56 4/14/2010 HermanRet Michael Wallace, Alex Alvarez, John EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Bullard, Daniel Webber, Daniel South Substation process. E-mail messages Lochard, Raul Leonardo, Frank SwitchGear Bus among staff of PA re: Radics, Ajit Haldipur, Leonid Discoloration problems with electrical Roytman, Carlos Perez, Caesar infrastructure at EWR Johnson, Nicholas Simeonidis, Roger Terminal B and efforts to Prince, Sherry Berty, Peter Parfinik, address problems. Thomas LaMarca

57 4/8/2010 Michael Alex Alvarez, John Bullard, Herman EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Wallace Ret, Daniel Webber, Daniel Lochard, South Substation process. E-mail messages

Raul Leonardo, Frank Radics, Ajit SwitchGear Bus among staff of PA re: Haldipur, Leonid Roytman, Carlos Discoloration problems with electrical Perez, Caesar Johnson, Nicholas infrastructure at EWR Simeonidis, Roger Prince, Sherry Terminal B and efforts to Berty address problems.

18

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF

NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

58 4/5/2010 Michael Alex Alvarez, John Bullard, Herman EWR 264.003 - Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Wallace Ret, Daniel Webber, Daniel Lochard, South Substation process. E-mail message attachment

Raul Leonardo, Frank Radics, Ajit SwitchGear Bus among staff of PA re: s Haldipur, Leonid Roytman, Carlos Discoloration problems with electrical Perez, Caesar Johnson referencing infrastructure at EWR

attachments Terminal B and efforts to "FW: Siemens address problems. Bus Discoloration .. ; South Substation Switch Gear B ... "

59 4/5/2010 Daniel Michael Wallace Siemens Bus Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Lo chard Discoloration process. E-mail messages attachment

Letter among staff of PA re: s referencing problems with electrical attachments infrastructure at EWR "Newark Terminal B and efforts to Airport-Bus address problems. discoloration. pdf ; C1260X-TR-253.pdf'

60 3/31/2010 HermanRet Michael Wallace, Ajit Haldipur, Syed South Substation Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Huda, Frank Radics, Caesar Johnson, Switch Gear Bus process. E-mail message attachment Raul Leonardo, Thomas LaMarca, referencing among staff of PA re: s Peter Parfinik, Daniel Lochard attachments problems with electrical

"IMG _ 0086.jpg; infrastructure at EWR IMG_0080.jpg; Terminal Band efforts to IMG_0087.jpg" address problems.

19

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

61 3/17/2010 Daniel Herman Ret, Thomas LaMarca, Siemens Bus Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Lochard Caesar Johnson, Raul Leonardo, Discoloration process. E-mail messages attachment

Sherry Berty Letter among staff of PA re: s referencing problems with electrical attachments infrastructure at EWR "Newark Terminal B and efforts to Airport-Bus address problems. discoloration. pdf ; C1260X-TR-253.pdf'

62 7/18/2013 HermanRet Michael Wallace, Caesar Johnson, Terminal B Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Daniel Lochard, Raul Leonardo, South Sub process. E-mail messages Virginia Trubek, Kenneth Dulski, among staff of PA re: Jacqueline MCCarthy, James problems with electrical Heitmann infrastructure at EWR

Terminal Band efforts to address problems.

63 2/16/2012 Michael Caesar Johnson Daniel Lo chard, Terminal B Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Wallace Daniel Nunez, Joseph Balance, South Sub process. E-mail messages

Robert Grassi, Andrew Hreha, among staff of PA re: Thomas LaMarca, Daniel Nunez, problems with electrical Sherry Berty, Gregg Leggett, Peter infrastructure at EWR Parfinik, Herman Ret, Nicholas Terminal Band efforts to Simeonidis address problems.

20

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF

NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

64 6/29/2011 HermanRet Caesar Johnson, Nicholas Terminal B - NB Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Simeonidis, James Heitmann, Frank Switchgear process. E-mail messages attachment Radics Corrosion among staff of PA re:

referencing problems with electrical attachment "Site infrastructure at EWR Investigation-6- Terminal Band efforts to 14-11.docx" address problems.

65 6/24/2011 Somnath HermanRet Terminal B - NB Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Mukherjee Switchgear process. E-mail messages attachment

Corrosion among staff of PA re: referencing problems with electrical attachment "Site infrastructure at EWR Investigation-6- Terminal Band efforts to 14-11.docx" address problems.

66 6/6/2011 HermanRet James Heitmann, Fran.1<: Radics Terminal B - NB Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Switchgear process. E-mail message attachment Corrosion among staff of PA re: s referencing problems with electrical attachments "TB infrastructure at EWR NB Switchgear Terminal B and efforts to 6-2011 2.jpg; TB address problems. NB Switchgear 6-2011 3.jpg; TB NB Switchgear 6-2011 4.jpg; TB NB Switchgear 6-2011.jpg"

21

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

67 4/4/2011 Daniel Herman Ret, Daniel Nunez, Caesar SA insp Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Lo chard Johnson, Peter Parfinik, Joseph process. E-mail messages

Ballance among staff of PA re: problems with electrical infrastructure at EWR Terminal B and efforts to address problems.

68 4/4/2011 Daniel Herman Ret, Frank Radics, Michael SA insp Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Lochard Wallace, Nicholas Simeonidis, Peter process. E-mail messages

Parfinik, Joseph Balance, James among staff of PA re: Heitmann, Caesar Johnson, Daniel problems with electrical Nunez infrastructure at EWR

Terminal B and efforts to address problems.

69 4/4/2011 HermanRet James Heitmann, Frank Radics, SA insp Intra-agency deliberative E-mail Michael Wallace, Nicholas referencing process. E-mail messages Simeonidis, Peter Parfinik, Joseph attachment among staff of PA re: Ballance, Daniel Lochard, Herman "DSCF0552.jpg" problems with electrical Ret infrastructure at EWR

Terminal B and efforts to address problems.

70 3/31/2011 HermanRet Daniel Lochard, James Heitmann, SA insp Intra-agency deliberative E-mail w/o Frank Radics, Michael Wallace, referencing process. E-mail messages attachment Nicholas Simeonidis, Peter Parfinik, attachments among staff of PA re: s Joseph Balance "DSCF0554.jpg; problems with electrical

DSCF0552.jpg" infrastructure at EWR Terminal Band efforts to address problems.

22

ITEM BASIS FOR TYPE OF

NUMBER DATE AUTHOR(S) RECIPIENT(S) SUBJECT WITHHOLDING DOCUMENT

71 3/15/2011 :E:ric \\TilliaJll Michael \\Tallace, Ajit Haldipur, :E:\VR-264.003, Intra-agency deliberative :E:-mail w/o s@URSCorp Brian Hegarty, Caesar Johnson, Switchgear SA process. :E:-mail messages attachment .corn Daniel Lochard, Daniel Nunez, Frank Test Reports aJ11ong staff of PA and its s

Radics, Herman Ret, JaJ11es referencing contractor re: problems Heitmann, Michael Rakhlin, Nicholas attachments with electrical Sirneonidis, Sornnath Mukherjee, "DOCI 10204.pd infrastructure at :E:\VR Pat_ Spina@URSCorp.com, f; Switchgear SA Terminal B and efforts to Michael_ Collins@URSCorp.com Retest Submittal address problems.

Merno.Docx"

23

Leonardo, Raul

From: Sent: To: Cc:

Subject:

Letter MW to JK 8-9-201- busba ...

Wallace, Michael Monday, August 09, 2010 4:07 PM Leonardo, Raul; Lochard, Daniel; Ret, Herman; LaMarca, Thomas Huda, Syed; Mcconkey, John; Roytman, Leonid; Simeonidis, Nicholas; Johnson, Caesar; Haines, Dawn; Hegarty, Brian; Radics, Frank; Heitmann, James EWR 264. 003 - LLE - Busbar - Letter to VRH

Ret, Herman

From: Sent: To:

Tracking:

IMG_0080.jpg

Herman Ret

Ret, Herman Sunday, May 30, 2010 12:54 PM Ret, Herman

Recipient

Rel, Herman

IMG_0088.jpg

Newark Liberty International Airport 973-961-6144

Read

Read: 5/30/2010 1 :50 PM

Ret, Herman

From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject: Attachments:

Mike/Raul

Konen, Jeff [J.Konen@vrhcorp.com] Thursday, May 27, 2010 9:31 AM Wallace, Michael; Leonardo, Raul Winkler, Eric Bus Bar discoloration 20100527091323142.pdf

Attached please find correspondence from Siemens addressing the bus discoloration issue.

SIE.MENS

May 27, 2010

S.M. -Electric Newark-Airport US Route 1. Terminal B Modernization Newark, NJ· 07114

Attn: Don Sapanara

RE: Bus. Discoloration

In.reference to the ·noted Siemens Bus Discoloration matter we offer the following:

Siemens has exceed~d the specification for this project by-supplying silver plated bus bars: The. project specification calls for only the joints to be silver plated which is standard UL-891-2005 Clause 8.8.1.1.5. It is common practice for most manufacturers like Siemens to provide complete silver plated bus bars fo·r commercial considerations. The purpose of the silver plating is to reduce oxidation in the joint. It is inside 'the joint, around the bolt, where the current transfer takes place. In the case of the bus in question, the silver plating has oxidized in are1=1s outside the joints where it is exposed to oxygen. The joint itself is not exposed to oxygen and therefore the._silver plating in the joint will not· oxidize and.remain intact. ·

We cannot determine the cause of the discoloration of the bus after it has left our factory. The bus· discoloration .in ql,.lestion has only occurred'to the expos~d, non-critical portion of the bus, and·will not impede or affect the performance of the bus. The· silver plating inside the joints will remain intact. If is a common occurrence for a certain. level of discoloration to form on equipment outside factory conditions. This.·noted discoloration or oxidation will not affect.the performance of this equipment and can go untreated-as a result. · ·

.. . , .· Siemens wiU stand b¥ its factory warranty per the terms and conditions of this contract.

• __ .,,_ • ...!:.'•

Sincerely, .

Harry W. Josten . Switchgear Development Manager Siemens Industry, Inc

Siemens Industry; Inc. 170 Wood Ave South lselln, NJ 08830 · - ·-· ·-· -· ... --·