the spektator 21
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
1/28
Zpdktgtar 27 Edbrugry 2>7:
\aur rgrdhy pubhlsmd` cul`d ta wmgts mgppdoloc lo go` grauo` Blsmkdk
PMD
Rdstgurgot Cul`dPaurlst Igp Hgtdst Odws
Do`
Mlstary1ae
Pmd
p0
^hus6 Jmguvdolsts, `ajtars, jyjhlsts, strlppdrs
Bdhclgos, pub qulzzds go` staods tmgt spdgk...
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
2/28
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
3/28
Jaotdots
Pmls Iaotm
PM
D
ZpdktgtarPmd Zpdktgtar ls oaw aohlod gt www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk.ja.uk
Rdstgurgots, Bgrs, JhubsGhh tmd bdst bgrs go` jhubs lo tawo.
24
>=, lts bgsd ae apdrgtlaos wgs go a`ar-
aus ghd plt jghhd` Bddrhaacg. Oaw, wltm
odws ae tmd `rlokloc mahds iuhtlphd rdhajg-
tlaos go` dvdotugh `dilsd, wd rdjghh saideao` idiarlds ae tmd phgjd said rdedrrd`
ta sliphy gs Gotaos bgr.
Jlty Igp@aot cdt hast.
Pmd Rd` Hlcmt Cul`dAur aod-a rdvldw ae tmd jltys ogucmty
phgjds.
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
4/28
Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk
0 Pmls Iaotm
Kyrcyzstgo6 Hgbar Ilcrgots Crgpphdwltm Russlgo-Hgocugcd Rdqulrdidot Pmd Igyg wdrd wraoc. Za wdrd tmd prd`lj-
tlaos ae Ergojls Eukuygig, Mdcdh go` KgrhIgrx. Bdjgusd mlstary, lt wauh` sddi, odvdrdo`s.
Gs lt paurs earwgr`s (ar ls tmgt bgjk-wgr`s1) wltm g pauo`loc iaoataoy, lt aohygjjuiuhgtds iard wrlokhds, iard dodilds,iard hast mglrs go` crdy mglrs, iard jhattd`grtdrlds erai smgsmhyk egt, iard sphlttlocmdg`gjmds erai jacogj, iard jaup `dtgts- sujjdsseuh go` gbartlvd - iard mubrls, tmda`` brutgh rdjkaoloc wltm g trutm eardsmg`-awloc lsgstdr, g iaidotgry jahhgpsd, g ogplo tmd cuttdr.
Pmdo lt pljks ltsdhe up gcglo, rdwrlttdogo` rdbrgo`d`, but wltm tmd sgid pgrgoalggo` ilsphgjd` sdosd ae sdhe-lipartgojd ltghwgys mg`.
Pmd upsmat ae tmls ls tmgt dvdry sa aetdo,
gil`st tmd prahaocd` bauts ae sudrloc go`ajjgslaogh klo`odss tmgt muigos loflljt aoatmdr muigos, yau cdt g jaiphdtdhy erdd ls-sud ae Blsmkdks egvaurltd taurlst igcgzlod,wltm ghh tmd mghe-grsd` fauroghlsi, tgstdhdssmuiaur go` ajjgslaogh taurlst tlps tmgt do-tglhs. Oarighhy, hlkd tmls aod, lt grrlvds hgtdrtmgo lt ls suppasd` ta.
Pmd Zpdktgtar,gs said ae yau grd gwgrd, do-`urd` lts awo brusm wltm gpajghypsd bgjklo 2>77. But ear tmd iaidot gt hdgst, hlkd
Plotlo go` Jgptglo Mg``ajk, wd grd bgjk,ghbdlt wltmaut JCL ta siaatm avdr aur pmysl-jgh go` psyjmahacljgh flgws, go` ilous tmdogojlgh ilcmt ae g Ztdvdo Zpldhbdrc bhajk-
bustdr ta euo` aur rdsurrdjtlao. By tmd wgy,le yau grd dofayloc rdg`loc tmls `rass, Ztdvd,mgoc us g hlod gt d`ltarNtmdspdktgtar.ja.uk,go` wdhh clvd yau aur bgok `dtglhs. Pmgokslo g`vgojd, igtd.
Za wmgt `a wd mgvd tmls iaotm1 Sdhh,turo tmd pgcds, go` le yau grd g rdcuhgr rdg`-dr ae tmd Ogtlaogh Cdacrgpmlj, hawdr tmd dx-pdjtgtlao bgr g hltthd. Sd jaotloud ta bd tmdaohy Kyrcyzstgo-jdotrd` pubhljgtlao wrlttdolo Dochlsm by tmd pdaphd ear tmd pdaphd, butgs wltm Gidrljgo `diajrgjy, tmgt `adsotghwgys cugrgotdd goy iloliui stgo`gr`ae qughlty. Gs wd uo`drstgo` Ughdotlods `gymgs fust pgssd`, wd mgvd g haasd havd tmdid
tmls dplsa`d, haasd lo tmls sdosd dojai-pgssloc dvdrytmloc erai g hajgh edilolstshgidots gbaut hajgh ido, tmraucm strlp bgrrdvldws go` `gtloc cul`ds, gs wdhh gs tmlocstmgt mgvd oa jaojdlvgbhd raigotlj jaotdotwmgtsadvdr6 lipavdrlsmd` `ajtars, staod-cgzloc, crudhhloc igrgtmaos go` g rauo` upae odws tmgt odvdr mgppdod`.
Gt tmd rlsk ae sgyloc saidtmloc usd-euh, wd mgvd clvdo aur rdstgurgot cul`d ghljk ae pglot, sa bd surd ta jmdjk aut batmtmd gbrl`cd` vdrslao ao pgcds 20 & 24,go` tmd euhh aod gt www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk. Pmls ls vdry iujm g wark lo prac-rdss tmgt rdqulrds yaur loput sa wd wlhh
bd vdry crgtdeuh ae goy ilol-rdvldws, (4>-7>> war`s) yau jgo pravl`d, dspdjlghhy earolcmtjhubs slojd wd try ta bd maid bdeardlt cdts `grk tmdsd `gys. Gcglo, goy diglhsta d`ltarNtmdspdktgtar.ja.uk.
BLZMKDK, Edbrugry 7 (Durgslgodt.arc) - Kgoy-
bdk Bdkiurzgdv, :2, mgs g cagh tmls wlotdr. Maid
erai Iasjaw ta vlslt mls dh`drhy iatmdr lo sautm-dro Kyrcyzstgo, mds usloc tmd tlid ta idiarlzd
lrrdcuhgr Russlgo vdrbs.
Odw hdclshgtlao rdqulrloc tmd ilhhlaos ae Jdo-
trgh Gslgo ilcrgot hgbardrs lo Russlg ta spdgk Rus-
slgo ls warryloc Bdkiurzgdv. Gs mls egilhys iglo
brdg`wloodr ear tmrdd ydgrs, mds warkd` gs g
bus `rlvdr lo Iasjaw md koaws md mg` bdttdr
hdgro tmd hgocugcd.
Lts g tgsk tmgts oat sa dgsy ta gjjaiphlsm.
Gs g yauoc igo crawloc up lo past-Zavldt Kyr-
cyzstgo, md odvdr mg` tmd appartuolty ta hdgro
tmd hgocugcd prapdrhy, uohlkd idibdrs ae mls
iatmdrs cdodrgtlao. Iy bass tah` id go` atmdr
`rlvdrs wma aot spdgk Russlgo wdhh tmgt wltmaut
caa` Russlgo wd ilcmt hasd aur fabs, sgl` Bdk-iurzgdv, wma rdturos ta mls mgihdt ae Kgrgtgl,
odgr Asm, dgjm @djdibdr ear g iaotm ar twa.
To`dr Kyrcyzstgos Jaostltutlao, batm Rus-
slgo go` Kyrcyz dofay tmd stgtus ae ajlgh hgo-
cugcds. But tmd usd ae Russlgo ls eg`loc. Zlojd
lo`dpdo`dojd lo 7,>>> pdaphd, ar :> pdrjdot ae Kyrcyzstgos
gbhd-ba`ld` papuhgtlao, wark gbrag`. Igoy grd
sdgsaogh warkdrs hlkd Bdkiurzgdv; iast ca ta
Russlg. Pmdlr rdilttgojds, gjjar`loc ta tmd Sarh`
Bgok, tatgh tmd dqulvghdot ae :> pdrjdot ae Kyr-
cyzstgos C@ .
But wmdo ilcrgots grrlvd lo jltlds hlkd Ias-
jaw, Oavaslblrsk go` Zt. ^dtdrsburc, tmdy rdghlzd
tmgt Kyrcyzstgos `lhgpl`gtd` sjmaahs mgvd eglhd`
ta `dhlvdr g odd`d` sklhh6 tmd gblhlty ta spdgk Rus-
slgo. Bdkiurzgdv, wma mgs tmrdd jmlh`rdo go` g
wled lo Kgrgtgl, sgys tmgt lo Kyrcyzstgo lt ls `l-
juht ta o` g fab caa` doaucm ta edd` iy egilhy.
Bdkiurzgdv mapds aod `gy ta iavd mls egilhy
pdrigodothy ta Iasjaw.
Ao @djdibdr 7, tmd Russlgo Ed`drgtlao bd-
cgo rdqulrloc hgbar ilcrgots warkloc lo sdrvljd
lo`ustrlds smapkddpdrs, phuibdrs, go` strddt
jhdgodrs, ear dxgiphd ta pgss g Russlgo hgo-
cugcd tdst ta rdjdlvd wark pdrilts.
Zdvdrgh egjtars gdjt ilcrgtlao [aut ae Kyr-
cyzstgoY, lojhu`loc tmd pahltljgh sltugtlao, go`
pdaphds `dslrd ta pravl`d g bdttdr d`ujgtlao go`
euturd ear tmdlr jmlh`rdo, Uljtar Kmgrjmdoka, tmd
rst sdjrdtgry gt tmd Russlgo Dibgssy lo Blsmkdk,
tah` DurgslgOdt.arc. Pmd ouibdr ae pdaphd wlsm-
loc ta hdgvd ear tmd Russlgo Ed`drgtlao flujtugtds
`dpdo`loc ao tmd sdgsao go` pahltljgh dvdots lo
tmls jauotry.Sltm pavdrty lojrdgsloc gbaut : pdrjdot g
ydgr, aocaloc pahltljgh turbuhdojd, go` hltthd mapd
ear Kyrcyzstgos iarlbuo` djaoaiy, edw bdhldvd
tmd dxa`us wlhh shaw. Idgowmlhd, tmd Kyrcyz pgr-
hlgidots darts ta doearjd tmd usd ae tmd Kyrcyz
hgocugcd gt tmd dxpdosd ae Russlgo grd vldwd`
by igoy gs jauotdrpra`ujtlvd bdjgusd lt `adsoat dqulp yauoc Kyrcyz ear patdotlghhy warkloc
lo Russlg.
Lo rdjdot ydgrs, ear dxgiphd, Russlgo-spdgk-
loc dtmolj Kyrcyz I^s mgvd bddo mgrgssd` go`
pubhljhy smgid` by tmdlr jahhdgcuds ear oat
spdgkloc Kyrcyz. Russlgo spdgkdrs, dtmolj Kyrcyz
go` Russlgos ghlkd, sgy tmd darts ta `lsjaurgcd
tmd usd ae Russlgo tmrdgtdos ta hdgvd Kyrcyzstgo
lsahgtd`.
Pmd Russlgo Ed`drgtlao odd`s aur ilcrgots,
but lts gutmarltlds rdqulrd koawhd`cd ae tmd Rus-
slgo hgocugcd, Lrlog Kgrgiusmklog, go dtmolj
Russlgo I^ wma mgs haoc g`vajgtd` ear tmd rlcmts
ae Kyrcyzstgos wlo`hloc Russlgo-spdgkloc jai-
iuolty, tah` DurgslgOdt.arc. Za, tmdrd ls oatmlocsurprlsloc tmgt igoy jltlzdos ae Kyrcyzstgo mgvd
stgrtd` gttdo`loc Russlgo hgocugcd jaursds.
Gjrass tmd jauotry, erai rdiatd Bgtkdo
^ravlojd ta Blsmkdk, `digo` ear tmasd jhgssds ls
lojrdgsloc. Pmdsd `gys lo Bgtkdo, iard pdaphd
wma wgot ta ilcrgtd ta Russlg mgvd bdcuo hdgro-
loc Russlgo, Bdr`l Zg`lkav, tmd dxdjutlvd `lrdjtar
ae tmd Bgtkdo G`uht Prgloloc Jdotdr, go OCA, tah`
DurgslgOdt.arc. Aur ilcrgots odd` Russlgo hgo-
cugcd sklhhs.
Zg`lkav sgys tmgt stu`dots pgy :,>>> sais
(gbaut $5:) ear g tmrdd-iaotm jaursd. Aur jus-
taidrs mgvd tmrdd hdssaos g wddk, go` tmdy hdgro
oat aohy ta spdgk, but ghsa ta rdg` go` wrltd loRusslgo. Pmdlr iglo iatlvgtlao ls ta o` diphay-
idot lo Russlg, md sgl`.
Dvdo ao tmd strddts ae Blsmkdk, aojd g prd-
`ailogothy Russlgo-spdgkloc jlty, Russlgo ls
mdgr` egr hdss ta`gy tmgo lt wgs dvdo tmrdd ydgrs
gca. Ilcrgots erai rurgh grdgs aetdo `a oat spdgk
tmd hgocugcd gt ghh. Aod ae tmd rdgsaos wmy usd
ae tmd Russlgo hgocugcd mgs `djhlod` ls igss
ilcrgtlao, wmdo Russlgo spdgkdrs stgrtd` hdgv-
loc tmd jauotry gt tmd bdclooloc ae tmd s, Lcar
Zmdstgkav, go goghyst lo Blsmkdk, tah` DurgslgOdt.
arc.
Gjjar`loc ta cavdroidot stgtlstljs, tmdrd
wdrd > dtmolj Russlgos lo tmd jauotry lo
7
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
5/28
www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar
4Pmls Iaotm
BLZMKDK, Edbrugry 70 (Durgslgodt.arc)
G jgsd lovahvloc g pdt magr`dr go` plhedrd`
paajmds mgs bdjaid saidwmgt ae g jgusdjhbrd lo Kyrcyzstgo.
Ughdrl ^ahavolkav, g 45-ydgr-ah` pgrt-tlid
idjmgolj hlvloc lo go gpgrtidot lo Blsmkdks
72tm iljra-rdclao, jhglis tmgt fust bdeard tmd
Odw \dgr pahljd go` rdprdsdotgtlvds ae tmd
jlty pdst-jaotrah sdrvljd brakd lota mls ehgt go`
taak gwgy sdvdo `acs wmlhd md wgs gt wark.
Pmd jgolods, ^ahavolkav jaotdo`s, wdrd tmdo
brutghhy iur`drd`, `lspgtjmd` wltm cuosmats
gt tmd jlty `uip. Odlcmbars aeedr g `leedrdot
ogrrgtlvd, sgyloc ^ahavolkav magr`d` strgy
golighs. Pmd `acs jrdgtd` g oulsgojd wltm pra-
haocd` bgrkloc, go` tmdlr jaoelsjgtlao wgs fus-
tlelgbhd bdjgusd gutmarltlds wdrd gjtloc lo tmdpubhljs bdst lotdrdst, tmdy gssdrt.
Pmd lojl`dot mgs rglsd ` lrd giaoc goligh
rlcmts gjtlvlsts wma mgvd haoc gjjusd` tmd
Zmaatloc Zdrvljd warkloc aut ae tmd jltys
wgstd igogcdidot `dpgrtidot, Pgzghyk, ae
bdloc lomuigod, uogjjauotgbhd go` lovahvd`
lo tmd hajgh djaoaiy ear `ac-ml`d pra`ujts.
Pmd Blsmkdk Igyar s Aeeljd iglotglos tmgt
smaatloc strgy `acs ls g rdcrdttgbhd but jast-
deedjtlvd idgos ear tmd lipavdrlsmd` stgtd ta
pratdjt jltlzdos erai g 2>>,>>>-straoc strgy
papuhgtlao tmgt gutmarltlds jgooat geear` ta
stdrlhlzd, ar atmdrwlsd jaotglo.
Sltm rdcuhgr prdss rdparts ae strgys blt-
loc jmlh`rdo, edrgh `acs mgvd edw erldo`s lo
Blsmkdk. Gjjar`loc ta tmd Igyars Aeeljd,
Pgzghyk smat 72,0>5 `acs lo 2>72, ghh bgsd` a o
jltlzdos jaiphglots. Zmaatdrs rdjdlvd :>> sai
(gbaut $5.24) pdr `ac, jrdgtloc, said sgy, go
lojdotlvd ta klhh golighs tmgt grd oat odjdssgr-
lhy maidhdss.
Smlhd ^ahavolkav g`ilts md vlahgtd` g jlty
rdcuhgtlao tmgt hlilts twa `acs ta go gpgrt-
idot, md iglotglos tmgt aohy aod ae tmd `acs,
g mghe-pgrghyzd` iaocrdh md rdsjud`, wgs g
strgy. L mg` [aeeljlgh `ajuidotsY ear tmd atmdr
slx go` lotdo`d` ta clvd ghh ae tmdi gwgy gssaao gs L eauo` havloc maids, md sgl`.
Za egr, ^ahavolkavs wrlttdo stgtdidots
mgvd oat hd`, gs md mapds, ta g jrlilogh jgsd.
Md grcuds tmgt prasdjutars grd rdhujtgot ta
cdt lovahvd` bdjgusd g pahljd aeeljdr wgs ghsa
jaiphljlt lo tmd gjt, g jhgli vdrleld` by tmrdd
wltodssds.
@urloc g Edbrugry < vlslt ta ^ahavolkavs
gpgrtidot, g DurgslgOdt.arc jarrdspao`dot
sgw tmgt tmd `aar wgs `gigcd` go` lts hajk
brakdo praae, sgys ^ahavolkav, ae earjd`
dotry. Smdo jaotgjtd` ear jaiidot, Bahat
Kaykdh`lydv, mdg` ae Pgzghyks Zmaatloc Zdrv-
ljd g`ilttd` tmgt twa Pgzghyk stgeedrs mg` vls-ltd` tmd g``rdss eahhawloc g odlcmbars jai-
phglot, but `dold` brdgkloc go` dotdrloc6 Pmd
`aar wgs wl`d apdo go` tmd `acs wdrd ruo-
oloc grauo` tmd gpgrtidot bhajk.
Kyrcyzstgo6 Grd Blsmkdks @ac JuhhsGbaut ^daphd ar ^raelt1
Kaykdh`lydv, wmasd sdrvljd wgs dstgb-
hlsmd` lo 2>>=, sgys mls aeeljd mgs crawo usd`
ta jrltljlsi, but grcuds tmgt lt smauh` bd rd-`lrdjtd` tawgr` lrrdspaoslbhd `ac awodrs
wma pdrilt tmdlr jgolods ragi tmd strddts.
Lo g jauotry gs paar gs aurs, wd jgooat ge-
ear` ta edd` maidhdss pdaphd, hdt ghaod mausd
go` edd` muo`rd`s ae tmausgo`s ae maidhdss
`acs, md sgl`, g``loc tmgt md wgs skdptljgh
gbaut tmd vlgblhlty ae g sjmdid gooauojd`
by Uljd Igyar Uygjmdshgv Krgsldoka ao Fgou-
gry 2< ta jrdgtd g $:4>,>>>-g-ydgr smdhtdr go`
stdrlhlzgtlao sdrvljd.
@dspltd erljtlao bdtwddo Kaykdh`lydvs ae-
eljd go` goligh-rlcmts arcgolzgtlaos sujm gs
tmd Blsmkdk-bgsd` Rlcmt ta Hled g prlvgtdhy
euo`d` oao-praelt tmgt aeedrs stdrlhlzgtlao go`tdipargry smdhtdr sdrvljds ear strgys batm
gcrdd tmgt g smdhtdr apdrgtd` by tmd jlty wauh`
oat sahvd tmd `ac prabhdi.
Lo earidr Zavldt jauotrlds, wmgtdvdr jgo
bd stahdo ls stahdo, grcud` Ghhg Kabtsavg, aod
ae Rlcmt ta Hleds tmrdd eauo`drs. Lo g iuoljlpgh
smdhtdr ear strgy `acs tmls wauh` idgo stdgh-
loc iaody ear eaa`, iaody ear stdrlhlzgtlao go`
iaody ear id`ljlod tmdsd golighs wauh` fust
`ld g shaw `dgtm.
But goytmloc ls prdedrgbhd ta tmd jurrdot
juhhs, Kabtsavg g``s. Pmd klhhlocs liiuolzd
sajldty tawgr` jrudhty ta golighs wltmaut slc-
oleljgothy stdiiloc tmd crawtm ae tmd strgy
papuhgtlao. Iardavdr, smd bdhldvds vdstd` lo-
tdrdsts grd bdmlo` tmd smaatlocs6 Sd bdhldvd
[PgzghykY `lspasds ae g jdrtglo partlao ae tmd
ba`lds, go` sdhhs g partlao gs ml`ds go` idgt.
Zmd suspdjts said rdstgurgots grd jhldots.
Kaykdh`lydv strdouaushy loslsts tmd `ac
jarpsds grd `uipd` lo g sgoltgry plt gt tmd
iuoljlpgh hgo`elhh, go` palots ta tmd egjt tmgt
ae dlcmt igrksido warkloc lo mls tdgi iast
awo `acs tmdisdhvds, go` aohy aod `lshlkds
tmdi. Iardavdr, Kaykdh`lydv sgl`, oaod ae
tmd jltys ouidraus Kardgo rdstgurgots wauh`
dvdr gjjdpt strddt `acs gs idgt.Prg`drs gt Blsmkdks G hgid`lo Bgzggr jao-
elri tmgt `digo` ear `ac-ml`d pra`ujts, iast-
hy lo tmd eari ae il`rlee-wgriloc sgsmds (ear
tmd kl`odys) go` smad hlodrs, `ads dxlst. Vuhyg
Ogryobdkavg, wma sdhhs batm, sgys tmd kl`ody
wgridrs, wmljm rdtglh gt grauo` $:>, grd pgr-
tljuhgrhy papuhgr wltm mdr edhhaw trg`drs, wma
spdo` ghh `gy musthloc lo tmd jah`. Pmd ml`ds
rdtglo mdgt bdttdr tmgo edht, Ogryobdkavg dx-
phglod`. Atmdrs sdhh sabgjmoayd igsha `ac
alh wmljm ls tmaucmt ta trdgt jmdst loedjtlaos
go` tubdrjuhasls.
But wmlhd tghkloc up tmd wgritm ae mdr
wgrds, Ogryobdkavg jhglid` smd mg` oa l`dgwmdrd tmd ml`ds grd saurjd`. L `aot `dgh wltm
tmd skloodrs. Fust tmd il``hdido, smd sgl`.
But L koaw tmd `acs grd hajgh. Iast prabgbhy
tmdy grd hajgh strgys.
Iy Kyrcyzstgo
Kyrcyzstgo ls hlkd g sdgsmdhh hdet uo`lsjav-
drd` go` uokoawo uotlh pljkd` up. Getdr-
wgr`s lt tgkds g prailodot phgjd lo aods
maid, aeedrloc up tmd loliltgbhd sauo`
ae gutmdotlj Jdotrgh Gslgo bdguty wmdo
phgjd` odxt ta tmd dgr.
Zaid sgy tmd aohy wgy ta gval` g Kyr-
cyz jrlsls ls by tgkloc tmd rag` ta Igogs
Glrpart, go` mgvloc sddo twa rdvahutlaos
mdrd, L suppasd tmdy grd rlcmt. But tmd vdry
sgid pdaphd, wmdtmdr hajgh ar eardlco, grd
ghwgys idibdrs ae tmd L havd Blsmkdk go`
L havd Kyrcyzstgo craups ao vgrlaus sajlgh
odtwarks, go` eddh tmd jauotrys oastghclj
puhh oa igttdr wmdrd tmdy grd lo tmd warh`.
Lt ls ghsa sgl` tmgt tmd Kyrcyz pdaphd trust lo
oatmloc gt ghh but ghwgys mapd ear tmd bdst.
Go`, wltm g odgr 7>>% hltdrgjy rgtd go` tmd
mlcmdst lotdrodt pdodtrgtlao rgtd lo Jdotrgh
Gslg gjjar`loc ta Lotdrodtwarh`stgts.jai
(:0%), Kyrcyzstgo rdiglos aod ae tmd iast
loearid` go` patdot sajldtlds lo tmd rd-
clao. Pgkloc g tgxl rl`d goywmdrd lo tmd jlty,
yau grd hlkdhy ta bdjaid pgrty ta tmd hgtdst
pahltljgh casslp, gs wdhh gs crgo`dr tmdarlds
gbaut havd, hled, go` tmd warh`.
Lo Blsmkdk yauhh mgvd g mgr` tlid
elo`loc g bla-talhdt but yau igy ca aut lo
sdgrjm ae g il`olcmt sogjk go` cdt lt erai
go uogssuiloc idtgh klask. Lo tmd sprloc
yau ilcmt bd surprlsd` gt tmd slcmt ae kl`sphgyloc wltm tay smlps lo tmd jrystgh-jhdgr
chgjlgh wgtdr tmgt ehaa`s tmd jltys lrrlcgtlao
jgoghs. Lo suiidr yau ilcmt elo` tmd sgid
kl`s wghhawloc lo tmd blc eauotglos gt Ghg-
Paa Zqugrd go` odxt ta Ztgtd ^mlhmgriaolj
Le yaurd g waigo, yau igy elo` lt mgr`
ta wghk lo mddhs lo Blsmkdk, gs aojd autsl`d
tmd jdotrd, tmd sl`dwghks grd euhh ae mahds.
Le yaurd igo, yau igy fust jaiphlidot
waido wma stlhh igogcd ta `a lt lo spltd ae
ghh tmd abstgjhds.
Eloghhy, lo Kyrcyzstgo yauhh elo` aut tmd
idgoloc ae g pmrgsd Pmdrd ls oa sujm iu-
sdui gs ogturd, gs tmd ogturd Kyrcyzstgomgs ta aeedr ls uorlvghhd`! Go` tmd jhasdst
ogturd pgrk ls fust :> iloutds gwgy erai
tmd jlty jdotrd; goy jgb jgo tgkd yau tmdrd.
Pmd egiaus odvdr- erddzloc sdjao` hgrcdst
iauotgloaus hgkd lo tmd warh` ls fust tmrdd
maurs `rlvd erai Blsmkdk. Lo`dd`, tmd Kyr-
cyz jgpltgh ls tmd l`dgh bgsd, tmrawloc tmd
`aar apdo ao g jauotry euhh ae oao-Sl-El
spats wmdrd yau `rlok lo iauotglo vldws,
dibrgjd wghout trdds, go` tgstd kuilz, tmd
erult ae tmdfglhaa . Za hdgvd yaur pmaod slhdot
(tmdrds prabgbhy oa jaoodjtlao goywgy),
tgkd g brdgk erai tmd ig`odss go` fust bd
g Zpdktgtar!@log Pakbgdvg ls g Kyrcyz fauroghlst go`
earidr Rdclaogh D`ltar ae tmd Lostltutd ear Sgr
go` ^dgjd Rdpartloc (LS^R) ear Jdotrgh Gslg
lo Blsmkdk.
@LOG PAKBGDUG
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
6/28
Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk
5 Pmls Iaotm
@gtloc Dxpdrt ao @gtloc Dxpgts6 Lt wgs go D`ujgtlao, L suppasd!
BLZMKDK, Edbrugry 72, (Z^DKPGPAR) - Gmdg`
ae Ughdotlods @gy, Zpdktgtar gutmars Slostao
Ahsdo go` G`dhlod Bdhh tdgid` up wltm smgrp-
taocud`, sdgsaod` dx-pgt gtloc dxpdrt, GhtyoaiEhlrtavg, ta clvd yau hg`lds said jhuds gbaut tmd
typd ae dxpgt yau grd hlkdhy ta iddt ao raigotlj
dojauotdrs mdrd lo tmd ia`dro-`gy Bgbyhao ae
Blsmkdk. Wuljk pldjd ae g`vljd, clrhs; le yau grd
haakloc ear wloloc go` loloc, ca ta Ghigty.
Pypd G6 Dochlsm tdgjmdr
Sgcd6 $7,>>>/iaotm, 4>> sais/maur ear prlvgtd
sdsslaos.
Iast hlkdhy ta6 Liprdcogtd mls stu`dot.
GE sgys6 L idt typd G `urloc g :-iaotm lotdoslvd
hgocugcd jaursd gt tmd [sjmaah dhdtd`Y. Md mg` g
twa-ydgr bdgr` go` stlhh sidht ae mls iast rdjdot
cgp ydgr lo Lo`lg, but L havd` tmd wgy md tghkd`
gbaut `doltd go` lo`doltd grtljhds. Getdr g brldeflloc lo mls stloky `ariltary md brakd lt a, tdhhloc
id md wgs usd` ta clrhs mghe iy gcd. L wgs aohy 23
gt tmd tlid!
Pypd B6 Bgr awodr
Sgcd6 Goytmloc erai idcg iaody ta ilous
iaody.
Iast hlkdhy ta6Cdt yaur `rlok, bdjgusd md jgo.
GE sgys6 Pmls aod ls `doltdhy g `aubhd-d`cd`
swar`. Ao tmd aod mgo`, md ls ghwgys wmdrd tmd
pgrty ls gt; ao tmd atmdr mgo`, tmd pgrty odvdr erlj-
kloc staps. Le yau dvdr smgrd yaur hled wltm typd B
yauhh mgvd ta cdt usd` ta tmd tgstd ae ghkgzdhsdr
tgbhdts go` Dochlsm ery-ups, wmlhd lt wlhh ghwgys bd
taucm ta pdrsug`d mli ta ca ao mdghtm-liprav-loc mlkds lo tmd iauotglos. Odvdrtmdhdss, typd B
mgs g jdrtglo jmgri gbaut mli go` rdiglos go gt-
trgjtlvd tgrcdt iasthy ear bdot pahljdido go`
tgx lospdjtars.
Pypd J6 Pmd hajgh dx-pgt
Sgcd6 7>>>-7,4>> Duras/iaotmIast hlkdhy ta6 Rdeusd g phgtd ae stdgiloc mat bd-
smbgrigk wltm soabblsm `dedrdojd.GE sgys6 Oat rdghhy go dx-pgt but getdr spdo`locslx ydgrs lo Zwltzdrhgo` md jdrtglohy tmloks md ls. Lwgs gttrgjtd` ta typd J bdjgusd wd spakd g jai-iao hgocugcd gjjdothdss Dochlsm - go` sudrd`tmd smgrd` egtd ae warkloc g`ilo fabs wd wdrdvgsthy avdrqughld` ear gt tmd [lotdrogtlaogh ar-cgolzgtlao `dhdtd`Y. But mls Durapdgo glrs stgrtd`ta rub id up tmd wraoc wgy. Mls vldws ao cdo-`dr dqughlty dvdo dxtdo`d` ta sphlttloc tmd blhh,wmljm md jghhd` hg``ltlao,go` md dvdotughhy hdetmaid gcglo ear go IBG pracrgi lo Pdxgs. Md oawspdgks wltm g sautmdro `rgwh, yghh.
Pypd @6 Jaotrgjtar
Sgcd6 Doaucm ear g batthd ae Fgjk go` tmdo said.Iast hlkdhy ta6 Hdt a stdgi getdr g gy ae uojao-sjlaus pgrtljlpgtlao lo tmd cdapahltljgh igjmlog-tlaos ae tmd Igogs glr bgsd, gmdi, Prgoslt Jdotrd.GE sgys6Pypd @ wgs wlh`. Aur rst `gtd wgs vdryraigotlj. Md tld` id ta tmd baoodt ae mls pljkuptrujk go` ig`d havd ta id wltm Idtghhljgs Igs-tdr ae ^uppdts ghbui bhgstloc aut ae tmd stdrda.
Pmdo wd ravd aut lota tmd jauotrysl`d go` wdotcaedr muotloc. But L wgs saao put a mli by ha-jgh odws rdparts jaojdroloc mls gjtlvltlds gt tmdbgsd. Gppgrdothy tmdy palsao aur wgtdr, jursd aurtrg`ltlaos go` rulo aur hajgh waido! Sma wauh`mgvd tmaucmt1
Pypd D6 drigodot Ztu`dotSgcd6 Smgtdvdr md jgo sjgi a `dbt-rl``doSdstdro cavdroidots.Iast hlkdhy ta6 Ztl yau wltm tmd bgr blhh getdr mdssjgbbd` ghh yaur jlcgrdttds.
GE sgys6 L dofayd` iy tlid wltm tmls igo ae hdl-surd (`aot yau idgo hdgroloc1- d`.) go` md mg`jdrtglohy `aod mls rdsdgrjm, le yau koaw wmgt L
idgo! But lt wgs `ljuht ear us ta `lod gt tmd My-gtt ao mls ^m@ stlpdo` go` L jghhd` lt qults wmdomd stgrtd` sgvloc iaody ao `da`argot. Lt wgs god`ujgtlao, L suppasd!
Pypd E6 Kuitars Sled
Sgcd6 Mdr musbgo` mgs twa-tmlr`s ae tmd jauo-trys cah` lo mls cgrgcd.Iast hlkdhy ta6Earcdt wmljm jauotry smds lo.GE sgys6 By egr tmd bdst lo bd` ae tmd hat. Mdr wdhh-`rdssd` gppdgrgojds gt tmd Blsmkdk LotdrogtlaoghSaidos sajldty go` igoljurd` dxpgt jmlt-jmgt`lsculsd` g rgpgjlaus sdxugh gppdtltd. Hlkd mdrcrdd`y ilodr musbgo`, smd fust jauh`ot cdtdoaucm. Lt brakd iy mdgrt wmdo smd iavd` bgjk
ta wmdrdvdr lt wgs tmgt smd jgid erai, sgjrlj-loc aur tarrl`, pgsslaogtd gglr ear tmd jaiearts aetmd igrltgh igoslao. Zmd prailsd` ta rdidibdrid lo mdr wlhh. Slhh smd1
Pypd C6 Lo`dpdo`dot Paurlst Igc ubhlsmdr
Sgcd6Rgrdhy brdgks dvdo, ta bd maodst.Iast hlkdhy ta6 Cdt puojmd` lo tmd egjd by go-atmdr dxpgt.GE sgys6 Jmlsdhhd` caa` haaks, g egotgstlj sdhe-`dprdjgtloc sdosd ae muiaur go` `djdot koawh-d`cd ae tmd bdst phgjds ta dgt go` rlok lo Blsmkdk(iy losdrtlao d`.), Pypd D odvdrtmdhdss rgrdhy mg`tmd idgos ta tgkd id aut ta goy ae tmdi. Sgs mdtmd aod tmgt cat gwgy1 Aohy dvdr gs egr gs g htmy
uo`drcrauo` mavdh jghhd` Bddrhacg (sdd p25).Lo tmd do` L wgs haakloc ear iard phdgsgot sur-rauo`locs go` g blccdr ogojlgh jaiiltidot, saL `ltjmd` mli ear go lotdro warkloc gt tmd Plidsae Jdotrgh Gslg.
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
7/28
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
8/28
Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk
=
Aut & Gbaut
M\ @ADZ HAUDrdiglo aur egvaur-ltd subfdjt, `dspltd ghh tmd mdgrt-gjmd lt brlocs1 ^drmgps bdjgusd
saidtlids tmd ilsdrgbhd iaidotsgrd jaipdosgtd` ear by tmasd
uodxphglogbhd flgsmds ae fay go` wgritm wd eddhwmdo tmlocs ca wdhh lo rdhgtlaosmlps dvdo le tmasdiaidots grd rgrd go` flddtloc. Jdrtglohy uomgppyjauphds jgo bd eauo` dvdrywmdrd. Pmd qudstlaols wmgt igkds sujm jauphds stgy tacdtmdr `dspltdtmdlr uomgpplodss1 Lt igy bd ear tmasd rgrd fayeuhiaidots, ar lt ilcmtbd tmgt pdaphd cdtusd` ta dgjm atmdr go`grd sjgrd` ae jmgocd,ar ls lt saidtmloc dhsd1
L rdjdothy mg` go
uophgood` iddtloc
wltm iy erldo` Dhvlrgwma gskd` id ta falo mdr go` mdr erldo` ear `loodr.Lt wgs tmd rst tlid L idt Dhvlrgs erldo , g vdry oljd-haakloc yauoc waigo lo mdr tmlrtlds jghhd` Gl`gl.
Smlhd L wgs caloc tmraucm tmd idou Gl`gl wgs jai-phgloloc ta iy erldo` gbaut maw bg`hy hled wgs trdgt-loc mdr. Lt sddid` ta id tmgt tmls mg` bddo tmd taplj
ae jaovdrsgtlao ear qultd said tlid bdeard L grrlvd ,go` lt wgs prabgbhy tmd rdgsao Dhvlrg mg` gskd` idta falo tmdi smd wgs hlkdhy eddhloc avdrwmdhid .
Za oaw lt wgs twa ae us mdgrloc aut Gl`gls jai-phglots gbaut hled. Brldfly, mdr prabhdis jaojdrod`
mdr musbgo` wma ear igoy ydgrs mg` ig`d g mgbltae turoloc up dgrhy lo tmd iaroloc getdr autlocs tasguogs ar paah mghhs wltm mls (igrrld`) erldo`s, go`
tdhhloc Gl`gl ta kddp quldt gbaut lt wmdodvdr smdabfdjtd . Iard ta tmd palot, smd mg` mdgr` gbautar dvdo sddo mli lo tmd jaipgoy ae atmdr waido
erdqudothy, but gcglo, smd gppgrdothy mg` oa rlcmt tapratdst. Getdr ghh, md wgs g ighd, phus md pravl`d` ear
tmd egilhy! Pmd sg` stary jaotloud` ear avdr go maur,go` tmd glr wgs hhd` wltm sa iujm `dspdrgtlao tmgtlt wgs mgr` ta stgo . L oghhy dxprdssd` go aplolao
tmgt le L wdrd mdr L wauh` prabgbhy hdgvd, rgtmdr tmgostgy wltm saidaod wma mg` ig`d id uomgppydvdry gy ear sa haoc. Zmd sgl` smd wauh` odvdr hdgvd
bdjgusd smd mg` g jmlh` go` dspdjlghhy bdjgusd smdwgs ghrdg`y tmlrty-twa. Sma dhsd wauh` odd` id
dxjdpt iy musbgo . Go` tmasd waido grd ghh tdi-
pargry, fust pmysljgh; md waot `lvarjd id goywgy, gthdgst bdjgusd ae aur jmlh .
L wlsm L jauh` sgy mdr gttltu`d surprlsd` id. To-eartuogtdhy tmls sltugtlao ls taa typljgh lo hajgh hled tabd surprlsloc ar dvdo upsdttloc.
Igoy waido lo tmls jlty `a oat koaw tmdlrrdgh wartm. But maw grd tmdy suppasd` ta koawlt wmdo tmd ido tmdy iddt `a tmdlr bdst ta pravd
ta tmdi maw loslcoljgot tmdy grd go` maw dgs-lhy tmdy jgo bd rdphgjd`1 Jgo tmdsd waido bdbhgid`1 Le oat, `ads tmls idgo lt ls idos eguht1
But jgo ido bd bhgid` wmdo sujm bdmgvlaur lsdojaurgcd`1
^drmgps lt stgrts wltm tmd dogbhloc dovlrao-idot jrdgtd` by tmd egjt tmgt tmd ouibdr ae dhl-clbhd edighds slcoljgothy autwdlcms tmd ouibdr
ae dhlclbhd ighds. Lo tmdsdjao`ltlaos, maw passlbhdls lt ear g waigo ta rd-
od mdr sdgrjm jrltdrlg1Bgsljghhy, le g carcdaus
waigo ls `gtloc g oat-sacarcdaus igo dspltd mls
jmdgtloc go` lcoargojd,iast prabgbhy lt ls oat bdjgusd md ls g spdjlgh, dx-jhuslvd typd, but bdjgusd smd ls fust tryloc ta g`gptta tmd hajgh jaotdxt. Oaw jaosl`dr tmd appasltd6
le tmd ouibdr ae dhlclbhd ido wgs egr crdgtdr tmgotmd ouibdr ae dhlclbhd edighd rdsl`dots, wauh` Gl`-gl stgy wltm mdr jmdgtloc musbgo`1 Ar wauh` smd
mgvd dvdo igrrld` mli lo tmd rst phgjd1 Getdr ghhmd wauh` bd fust g ruo-ae-tmd-ilhh cuy wltm g rdpu-
tgbhd bdhhy, iglotglod` avdr tmd ydgrs by g hledhaocjaiiltidot ta dxtdoslvd bddr lotgkds avdr cgidsae blhhlgr`s, ar hauocloc lo tmd sguog.
Pmls dovlraoidot ls eurtmdr domgojd` byegilhy gttltu`ds go` sajldty gs g wmahd. Gppgr-dothy, wmdo g waigo cdts igrrld`, tmgts wmdo
smd bdjaids g oarigh idibdr ae sajldty. Pmgtswmdo smd o`s mdr phgjd lo tmd suo. Aojd smd ls
igrrld` smd ls bdttdr stgyloc lo igrrlgcd oa igt-tdr wmgt. Pahdrgojd ls wmgt hajgh waido grd vdrywdhh trglod` lo slojd jmlh`maa` (go` cudss wma
pravl`ds tmd trgloloc!). Atmdrwlsd6 Smgt wauh`pdaphd tmlok ae aur egilhy1, Pmlok ae tmd smgid!,ar, Sma wauh` gjjdpt yau getdr tmgt1
Lt haaks hlkd, gt hdgst ear tmd iast pgrt, tmdtahdrgojd smawo by hajgh waido ls g pra`ujt aetmdlr edgr ae bdloc hdet wltmaut g igo (slojd ido
grd edw lo ouibdr, go` le ilssd` grd quljkhy tgkdoby atmdr waido) ar by oat wgotloc ta lsgppalot
tmdlr egilhlds. But `ads mgvloc saidaod by yaur
sl`d rdghhy jaipdosgtds ear rdigloloc lssgtlsd`wltm hled1 Go` ls lt wartm bdloc uomgppy idrdhy lo
ar`dr ta phdgsd rdhgtlvds ar jaoeari ta sajldty1 Leg`gptloc ls iard g sgjrljd tmgo g jaiprailsd,jgo lt bd jaipgtlbhd wltm mgvloc g hled1
Flkg P, g yauoc Kyrcyz waigo wma warks
lo Blsmkdk, clvds mdr vldw ao hled go` havd
lo tmd jlty.
F\H@\V P.
S
Igos
Gbavd Rlcmt Egilhy dvdoloc lo, ar g olcmt lo tmd
sguog1(grjmlvd)
Bdhaw G rdputgbhd bdhhy `adsot stap g igo
erai hgo`loc g clrh wgy aut ae mls hdgcud lo tmd
Kyrcyz Rdpubhlj (grjmlvd)
Havd & Hled
G
Mdr prabhdis jaojdrod mdr mus-
bgo wma ear igoy ydgrs mg ig`d g
mgblt ae turoloc up dgrhy lo tmd iaro-
loc getdr autlocs ta sguogs
Sarh 1
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
9/28
www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
10/28
Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk
7> Pmd Odws Pmgt Odvdr Sgs
Z L CGVD gt tmd hlods lo Ourhgos egjd lt
sddis hlkd dgjm aod mah`s mls idia-
rlds go` mls wls`ai. Sd slp aur tdg,
rdvdrdotlghhy sdrvd` lo arogtd bawhs,
go` L rdfldjt ao tmd hgst edw wddks lo
iy hled, wmljm sddis sa smart go` dpmdidrgh lo
jaipgrlsao ta mls.
Getdr fust dsjgploc tmd wmlrhwlo` ae tmd uol-
vdrslty suiidr tdri, tmd mucd strdss ae dxgis
go` tmdo tmd dxmgustloc rauo` ae bghhs go` cgr-`do pgrtlds, iast ae iy erldo`s tmaucmt tmgt L wgs
jaiphdtdhy ig` ta bd fuiploc strglcmt lota iy
odxt jmghhdocd g suiidr lotdrosmlp wltm go
OCA lo Kyrcyzstgo. Iy iatmdr slts ao tmd bagr`
ae g juhturgh mdrltgcd jmgrlty lo Zuahk, sa smd
put id lo taujm wltm aod ae mdr gjquglotgojds
lo tmd Lotdrogtlaogh @dvdhapidot sjdod, Mdhiut
Mlokhdmaae, mdg` ae aod ae tmd bdst-koaw OCAs
aut mdrd lo Jdotrgh Gslg.
Avdr g jrgjkhloc pmaod hlod md tah` id tmgt
wltm iy Igstdrs `dcrdd, Ztrdoctmdoloc Cavdr-
ogojd tmraucm Loearigh Ztrujturds, L jauh` rdghhy
mdhp aut wltm tmdlr jaiiuolty docgcdidot pra-
crgi, wmljm lovahvd` bulh`loc fustljd jgpgjlty lorurgh Kyrcyzstgo tmraucm pgrtodrsmlps bdtwddo
stgtd ajlghs go` loearigh hdg`drs. Md ghsa sgl`
saidtmloc gbaut g yauoc eruhdlo brlcmtdoloc
up tmd ajd, go` mls `lvarjd, but L jauh`ot sdd
tmd rdhdvgojd ta `dvdhaploc fustljd strujturds lo
Kyrcyzstgo. ^drmgps lt cat hast lo trgoshgtlao md
ls Cdrigo, getdr ghh!
Za, getdr g wmlrhwlo` trlp tmraucm Blsmkdk, L
eauo` iysdhe lo rurgh Kyrcyzstgo, lotdrvldwloc g wdhh-
koawo hajgh curd, wl`dhy rdspdjtd` ear `lsputd gr-
bltrgtlao lo mls jaiiuolty - Ourhgo Jarhdaoav.
Ir Jarhdaoav, L gskd`, wltm iujm ae tmd
Kyrcyz stgtd strujturd lo rdtrdgt, jgo rdspdjtd`
loearigh hdg`drs sujm gs yaursdhe hh tmd cgp lo
fustljd pravlslao ta tmd jaiiuolty1Pmgt wd jgo `a, but pdaphd iust jaid ta us
wltm rdspdjt. Zaid pdaphd jaid ta id go` sgy
Ourhgo Jarhdaoav, yau iust clvd id fustljd. But
tmdy `aot gsk lo rdspdjt ar erldo`smlp. Pmdy `aot
dvdo tmlok ta jghh id bglkd.
L hlstdo jhasdhy, egsjlogtd` by mls stary. Sltm
blttdrswddt diatlaos Li rdilo`d` ae maw hltthd
lipartgojd wd phgjd ao rdspdjt lo tmd jaiiu-
olty lo aur awo mdjtlj Sdstdro hledstyhds.
Smdo L clvd g igo fustljd, Ourhgo jaotlouds,
tmdo said `gy, go` tmgt `gy igy odvdr jaid, L
igy jghh upao mli ta `a id g sdrvljd lo rdturo.
Pmgt ls maw md igy rdpgy id ear `aloc wmgt md
gsks ae id, koawloc tmgt L jgooat rdeusd g igo aotmd gy ae iy gucmtdrs brl`d-ogpploc.
Ear id, tmls wgs go losplrloc dxgiphd ae tmd
sajlgh jaotrgjt gt wark - dipawdrloc hajgh jai-
iuoltlds tmraucm rdjlprajgh fustljd ia`ghltlds.
L wgs pgrtljuhgrhy lotdrdstd` lo tmd wgy lo wmljm
loearigh fustljd strujturds syodrclsd` wltm stgtd
gjtars, go` L dxphard` tmls `yogilj wltm Ourhgo.
Pmd pahljd go` L iust ghh rlok erai tmd sgid
wdhh, md dxphglod`. Pmd iast lipartgot tmloc ls
tmgt dvdryaod iust cdt tmdlr jut. Atmdrwlsd iy
sao Ilkgdh wlhh mgvd ta cuo `awo Jmlde ae ^ahljd
IjJhuskav, tmdo iur`dr tmgt prastltutd ta kddp
tmd Zdogtar quldt.
L wgs lotrlcud` by tmls dxphgogtlao. L jauh`aohy gssuid tmgt Ourhgo wgs tghkloc gbaut smgr-
loc tmd bur`do ae fustljd pravlslao bdtwddo a-
jlgh go` loearigh hdg`drs, but L odd`d` ta dxphard
tmls lssud eurtmdr. L turod` ta Ir Mlokhdmaae ear
g`vljd.
\ds yds, md gssurd` id. Pmls sart ae tmloc ls
qultd oarigh lo Kyrcyzstgo. Pmls ls sdmr cutpraf-
djt, wltm hats ae zd egsmlaogbhd buzzwar`s. Pmd
Gidrljgos wlhh, maw yau sgy, cusm zdpgots wmdo
tmdy rdg` aur euo`loc prapasgh. Go` tmgt idgos
phdoty iard iaody ear Lotdrogtlaogh @dvdhap-
idot Gjtlao - tmd stdgks grd ao id!
Rdgssurd` by mls dotmuslgsi, L rdturo ta jao-
tdiphgtloc Ourhgos wlsd, wdgtmdr-waro egjd. L
edht hlkd iy g`vdoturd lo Kyrcyzstgo wgs fust bd-clooloc, go` L mg` igoy iard rdwgr`loc dxpd-
rldojds ta jaid. Sltm `aoar suppart ear pdaphd
hlkd Ourhgo, L edht surd tmgt lt jauh`ot bd haoc bd-
eard Kyrcyzstgo rdgpd` tmd rdwgr`s.
\au iust
Pmls wlotdr tmd rahd ae loearigh fustljd pra-
vl`drs lo Kyrcyz sajldty wgs iujm lo tmd
odws. Za, tmd Zpdktgtarmgs lovltd` g cudst
wrltdr, Idhlssg Ztaurbrl`cd, ta smgrd mdr
dxpdrldojds ao tmd subfdjt. Is Ztaurbrl`cd
mgs go IG lo Loearigh Cavdrogojd, go` ls
jurrdothy warkloc lo Kyrcyzstgo gs go lotdro
wltm tmd OCA Lotdrogtlaogh @dvdhapidot
Gjtlao.
G
@aoJarhdaoav6Jaid
Rdspdjtwltm
Gbavd Igrhao Brgo`a rdpartd`hy turod`
`awo adrs ta `a g Kyrcyz tgkd ao tmd
Ca`egtmdr(grjmlvd)
IDHLZZG ZPATRBRL@CD
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
11/28
www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar
77Pmd Odws Pmgt Odvdr Sgs
BLZMKDK, Edbrugry 72 (Zpdktgtar) Zdola-
rdprdsdotgtlvds ae tmd rdoawod` Bdhclgo Ti-
brdhhg Euo` ear Hdgroloc, Ztgoc, Mdr`loc go`
LP Prgloloc (BTEHZMLPP) surprlsd` rdpartdrs gt
g prdss jaoedrdojd ao Iao`gy by gooauojloctmgt tmd arcgolzgtlao wauh` bd wltm`rgwloc
euo`loc ear twa flgcsmlp prafdjts lo tmd jauo-
trys rdclaos.
Erai oaw ao wd wlhh bd eajusloc aur Du-
ras ao tmd pgrt ae Kyrcyzstgo tmgt odd`s lt iast,
sgl` BTEHZMLPPs Kyrcyzstgo jauotry `lrdjtar
Slhmdhi Ugo`drbaac6 Aur ajd lo Blsmkdk.
Ugo`drbaac dxphglod` tmgt prafdjts trgloloc
pgstarghlsts lo gtg-jaotrahhd` flajk igogcdidot
go` dojaurgcloc tmd rurgh uodiphayd` ta hlkd
BTEHZMLPPs Egjdbaak pgcd wauh` stlhh dxlst lo
ogid, but tmgt tmd euo`s arlcloghhy dgrigrkd` ear
tmdi wauh` bd rd`lrdjtd` tawgr`s Zdhe-Dorljm-
idot ^racrgis (ZD^s) ear jard BTEHZMLPP stg.Pmls ls pgrt ae aur ZZ@ [Zdhe-Zustglogblhlty
@rlvdY go` go lotdcrgh dhdidot ae aur haoc-tdri
CAPM-SBJ [Cdt tmd mdhh AuP ae Mdrd - Sltm Blc
JgsmY strgtdcy, sgl` Ugo`drbaac. Sd grd sljk ae
tmrawloc iaody wd jauh` bd spdo`loc ao aur-
sdhvds lota bhgjk mahds hlkd Ogryo, tmd jauotry
`lrdjtar g``d`.
@dputy @lrdjtar Ogtgsmg Ed`ardoka sgl`
liphdidotloc CAPM-SBJ wauh` rdqulrd g RG^
(Rgpl` G`gptgtlao ^mgsd) ear rurgh eahk wma
wauh` mgvd ta @DP (@a Dvdrytmloc Pmdisdhvds)
ao tmdlr pgtm ta jahhdjtlvd dipawdridot. Pmls
wlhh tdgjm vlhhgcdrs ta `dvdhap vltgh japloc strgtd-
clds, go` stgo` ao tmdlr awo twa eddt, sgl` Ed`a-rdoka, jhdgrhy dotmusd`. Aur eajus ear oaw ls ao
jgpgjlty-bulh`loc wltmaut brljks tmdsd cuys wlhh
rdghhy mgvd ta sloc ear tmdlr suppdr, smd `djhgrd`.
BLZMKDK, Edbrugry 7> (Zpdktgtar) - Getdr
caloc ao saidtmloc ae g bgo blocd lo rdjdot
iaotms, tmd Kyrcyz pgrhlgidot mgs vatd` ta phgjd
g iargtarlui ao phgjloc g iargtarlui ao tmlocs.
But jlvlh hlbdrty g`vajgtds grcud tmgt tmd I^s
mgvd gutmarltgrlgolsi lo tmdlr bhaa` go` tmgt tmdbgo ao bgos wlhh oat hgst iard tmgo g wddk.
Zpdgkloc ta tmd pgrhlgidotgry prdss jarps
ao Pmurs`gy, Pursuobdk Bgr uuhu, go uhtrg-jao-
sdrvgtlvd I^ oljkogid` tmd Bgo Bgrao by mu-
igo rlcmts gjtlvlsts, g`ilttd` tmgt tmd `djlslao
ta stap lhhdcghlzloc dvdrytmloc smauh` bd uo`dr-
staa` gs g brlde rdspltd rgtmdr tmgo g oa` ta lo`l-
vl`ugh erdd`ais.
Pmd bgo ao bgos ls iard ae g sjgrjlty ls-
sud tmgo goytmloc dhsd. Fust gs tmd warh` ls ruo-
oloc aut ae alh, sa tmd pgrhlgidot ls ruooloc aut
ae tmlocs ta bgo, Bgr uuhu dxphglod` sahdiohy.
I^s grd gergl` tmdy ilcmt hasd tmdlr rdgsao ta
dxlst, md jaoedssd`.
Rdstrljtloc rdstrljtlaos, hdcghlzloc mgr` rucs
Rgvsmgo Zvaba`av, g rgrd hlbdrgh valjd lo tmd
hdclshgturd gpphgu`d` tmd bgo ao bgos, jhgli-
Bdhclgo OCA Lotra`ujds Odw Gjraoyis, Juts @dvdhapidot Gl`
^ratdst gy ta Rlsdwltm Loflgtlao
^grhlgidot Uatds ta Bgo Bgooloc Ztu
Oatloc tmd egjt tmgt g odw plhat sjmdid
wauh` mdhp BTEHZMLPP buy g erdsm wgr`rabd ear
mls 2:-ydgr ah` prlvgtd sdjrdtgry, Ugo`drbaacghsa prailsd` tmgt euturd prdss jaoedrdojds
wauh` bd dgsldr ear fauroghlsts ta `lcdst.
Clvdo tmd ouibdr ae jaiphdx gjraoyis wd
usd, yau phdbs mgvd gbsahutdhy oa jmgojd ae uo-
`drstgo`loc goytmloc wd sgy. Za wd grd caloc ta
pra`ujd g @.@ [@dvdhapidot @ljtlaogryY ear aurkdy but hgrcdhy uod`ujgtd` stgkdmah`drs lo tmd
id`lg. Brussdhs mgs ghrdg`y phd`cd` euo`s ear
tmls, BTEHZMLPPs jauotry `lrdjtar jaojhu`d`.
loc tmgt tmd pgrhlgidot mg` bdjaid g hgucm-
loc stajk lo eardlco jauotrlds ear rdstrljtloc
liparts ae caa`s tmd jauotry mg` odvdr li-
partd` bdeard go` jrgjkloc `awo ao absahdtd
`dltlds.
Lo @djdibdr wd bhgjkhlstd` Jmlhdgobdde wltmaut tryloc ar tdstloc lt, go` lo spltd
ae tmd egjt tmgt wd `a oat mgvd goy rdhgtlaos
wltm tmls jauotry. Pmdo, wmdo tmd pgrhlgidot
rdjaovdod`, Bgr uuhu prapasd` g bgo ao tmd
ca` Gpahha, ear wmljm wd wdrd hgiaaod` by g
wdhh-koawo sgtlrljgh igcgzlod lo Crddjd, tmd
I^ jaiphglod` gt g pgrhlgidotgry mdgrloc.
Bgr uuhu gjkoawhd`cd` tmgt said ae tmd
bgos mg` bddo egjdtlaus but sgl` tmgt tmd
jurrdot tmgw lo rdstrljtlvd hdclshgtlao wauh`
prdpgrd tmd papuhgtlao ear iard idgoloceuh
jhgip`awos lo g edw iaotms tlid.
Jurrdothy I^s grd jaosl`drloc go gjt ta
hdcghlzd jrgjk jajglod. Le tmgt hgw ls pgssd`
tmdo tmd pubhlj wlhh uo`drstgo` tmd liid`l-
gtd odd` ta bgo tmd `ruc gs saao gs tmd deedjts
ae g``ljtlao kljk lo, Bgr uuhu sgl`. Lt ls, getdr
ghh, g mlcmhy `gocdraus substgojd.
s
Gbavd BTEHZMLPP grd stgcloc g strgtdclj rdtrdgt erai Kyrcyzstgos rurgh rdclaos (grjmlvd)
BLZMKDK, Edbrugry < (Zpdktgtar) - Ap-
pasltlao hdg`drs mdh` g kuruhtgl, ar pdaphds
gssdibhy ydstdr`gy ta `lsjuss tmd lojrdgs-
loc jasts ae pgyloc pdaphd ta gttdo` gotl-cavdroidot `diaostrgtlaos. Goghysts ds-
tligtd` tmgt tmd Kuruhtgl iust mgvd jast
jhasd ta 7,>>>,>>> sais lo phav, yurts go`
jgsm mgo`auts.
Zpdgkloc lo eraot ae g jraw` ae =4:
sdhhauts tmd appasltlao elcurd Pgijmlbdk
Kgsmlodv sgl` tmgt gt hdgst pgrt ae tmd jast
ae euo`loc pratdsts smauh` jaid aut ae tmd
stgtd bu`cdt lo tmd euturd.
Le tmd ^rdsl`dot wgots ta jaotloud eaah-
loc lotdrogtlaogh `aoars lota tmlokloc Kyr-
cyzstgo mgs g `diajrgtlj go` phurghlstlj pa-
hltljgh systdi, tmdo md smauh` stgrt pljkloc up
tmd tgb iard aetdo, Kgsmlodv jaiphglod`.
Gjjar`loc ta Kgsmlodv go` mls ghhy
Ig`dydiurav tmd jast ta tmd cavdroidot lo
bgjkraai pgyidots ta mght pratdsts wlhh ghsa
lojrdgsd gs tmd jast ae bgslj eaa`stus sagrs.
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
12/28
Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk
72 Aut & Gbaut
PZ OLOD LO PMD DUDOLOC gt tmd @rgcaos
@do jged lo Blsmkdk go` tmd goswdrs ae tmd
wddkhy Sd`ods`gy pub qulz grd bdloc rdg`
aut. Pdoslao go` tmd sidhh ae sjatjm grd lo
tmd glr. Sdrd twa palots bdmlo` tmd e***loc
Fdhhybdgos, sgys tmd clocdr-mdg`d` jgptglo ae Sd
Pmaucmt lt wgs g @lsja, lo rdedrdojd ta tmd tdgi
wmasd qulz wd grd igrkloc.
Jgptglo Clocdr, wmasd rdgh ogid mgs bddo ls-
culsd` ear edgr ae vlahdot rdprlsgh, tgkds pub qulz-
zds rgtmdr sdrlaushy. Go` md ls oat lo tmd hdgst blt
phdgsd` tmgt mls uobdgtdo ruo lo tmd Kyrcyz jgpltgh
ls jailoc ta go do` tmgoks ta tmd jhudhdss jrdw md
mgs gssdibhd` tmls dvdoloc go` tmd igjmlogtlaos
ae tmd Fdhhybdgos, wma mgvd cat dlcmt aut ae tmd
rst tdo qudstlaos rlcmt.
L tah` yau Kgmhugs iglo locrd`ldot wgs jae-
edd! \au ig`d id wrltd ilhk ear e***s sgkd, md rgc-
ds, koajkloc mls `lsgppalotidot bgjk wltm g smat
ae Faooy Sghkdrs Bhgjk Hgbdh. But tmd Sd Pmaucmt
lt wgs g @lsja eauo`dr lsot tmd aohy aod eddhloc
tmd mdgt. Pmd tgbhd gjrass erai us grd jhgiaurloc
ear fustljd6 Jgo wd mgvd mghe g palot ear Kardgo
pap slocdr1 ...Sd wark lo klhaidtrds, oat ilhds....Cmgog ls ghiast Ighgwl!
But Cmgog ls oat Ighgwl go` Ilkd Gtsapgrtmls,
awodr ae @rgcaos @do, ls oat mgvloc lt. G ri but
eglr qulzigstdr, Gtsapgrtmls ls Crdgt Brltglos dx-
maoargry jaosuh lo Kyrcyzstgo go` tmd dx-cgdr
ae Egtbays jged. @urloc mls slxtddo ydgrs lo tmd
Jdotrgh Gslgo jauotry md mgs wltodssd` twa rdva-
hutlaos, g mgo`euh ae jaup gttdipts go` jauothdss
gocry iddtlocs, but iast hlkdhy oatmloc jhasd ta
tmd eury balhloc up losl`d aur lojaosahgbhd jgptglo.
^ahgral`, ^ahgral`, ^ahgral`! Smgt jgidrg
wgs lovdotd` lo 7 mlt lo tmd TZ ar tmd TKlo wmljm tmd saoc tlthd GO@ bgo` ogid wdrd pgh-lo`raids15. Lo 7
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
13/28
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
14/28
Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk
70 Ba`y go` Zauh
L
E \AT HLUD LO K\RC\VZPGOgo` yau mgvd
Kyrcyz erldo`s yau ilcmt gt aod palot mgvd
gskd` tmdi wmdrd yau smauh` vlslt lo Kyr-cyzstgo. Jaosl`drloc tmd `lvdrslty ae tmd
jauotry, tmd phdtmarg ae iauotglo pgssds,
carcds, hgkds go` vghhdys, yau wauh` dxpdjt
vgrld` rdspaosds. Pmls ls rgrdhy tmd jgsd,
mawdvdr. Iard aetdo tmgo oat, tmdy wlhh rdspao`
by gskloc mgvd yau bddo ta Lssyk-Kuh ydt1 Aojd
yau loeari tmdi tmgt yau mgvd bddo ta Lssyk-Kuh
(L iysdhe mg` aohy bddo ta tmd sautm smard, go`
tmdo stappd` by tmd oartm ao iy wgy ta Kgrgkah
g edw tlids) tmdrd ls ghwgys g blt ae g pgusd wmlhd
tmdy tmlok ae goatmdr `dslrgbhd `dstlogtlao.
L hlkd Lssyk-Kuh go` tmd surrauo`loc iauo-
tglos (dspdjlghhy ao tmd sautmdro smard), but ta
id lt sddid` g blt avdrrgtd` (Ca` spgrd yaur
mdrdtljgh sauh- d`.) jaipgrd` ta tmd atmdr cdis
ae hdss rdputd hlttdrd` grauo` tmd Kyrcyz hgo`-
sjgpd. But wltm iy tlid lo Kyrcyzstgo jailoc
ta go do`, L wgs `dtdrilod` ta dxpdrldojd wmgt
dvdryaod dhsd mg` - ta eghh lo havd wltm tmd dgrh ae
Kyrcyzstgo. Egtd, lo lts wdlr` wgy, mg` prdsdotd`
id wltm go appartuolty ta `a fust tmgt.
L sgw iy erldo` Gogtahy aod `gy. Getdr dx-
jmgocloc tmd usugh ml, maw grd yaus go` tmd hlkd,
L jgsughhy braucmt up g jdrtglo bard`ai wltm hled
go` g `dslrd ta trgvdh iard grauo` tmd jauotry.
Md gskd` id le L wauh` bd lotdrdstd` lo ruooloc
grauo` Lssyk-Kuh. Iy mdg` rdilo`d` id tmgt L
mg`ot bddo tdrrlbhy gtmhdtlj mdrd lo Kyrcyzstgo
go` tmgt iy mgblt ae `rlokloc bddr iast `gys aetmd wddk wauh`ot sdrvd id wdhh ruooloc haoc
`lstgojds gt mlcm ghtltu`d. Iy mdgrt, mawdvdr, tmd
lrrgtlaogh mghe ae g egid` gotmrapaiarpmlj tgo-
`di, tah` id tmgt lt tmls wauh` bd g euo, pmysl-
jghhy go` diatlaoghhy dorljmloc dxpdrldojd. Pmd
hgst tlid L mg` ruo lo Blsmkdk L l` gbaut dlcmt hgps
gt tmd Zpgrtgk stg`lui bdeard lojurrloc Id`lghPlblgh Ztrdss Zyo`rai - smlo sphlots ta tmd hgyigo
- tmgt hgstd` ear tmd rdst ae tmgt wddk. Rdjkhdsshy, L
slcod` up ear tmd jmghhdocd.
Sd idt tmd wddk getdr ta `lsjuss aur phgos. L
eauo` aut tmgt lt wauh` bd g craup rdhgy rgjd, tmgt
blkds go` lotdrilttdot igrsmrutkg rl`ds wauh`
ghsa edgturd, go` tmgt wd wdrd rglsloc iaody ear
g hajgh arpmgogcd. Hdgroloc ae tmls wartmy jgusd
go` g edw kdy jaojdsslaos, L gjjdptd` L wauh`
rlcmteuhhy bd hgbdhd` g ydhhaw-hlvdrd` arpmgo-mgt-
dr le L bgjkd` aut oaw.
Aur tdgi jgptglo wgs g Cdrigo by tmd ogid
ae Igrtlo. To`dr mls Pdutaolj jaiigo` wgs Ba-
hat, g Kyrcyz cuy erai tmd Zautm, Gogtahy, g Rus-
slgo/Tkrglolgo erai Lssyk-Kuh, Lzgt erai Purkidol-
stgo, Pgmlr, g ^gilr Kyrcyz erai Pgflklstgo, Igrtlos
wled go` bgby, Pgmlrs clrherldo`, g jgidrgigo
go` mls rahhdrbhg`loc `gucmtdr, go` iysdhe. Sltm
aur iablhd idhtloc pat swltjmloc bgjk go` eartm
erai Russlgo ta Dochlsm ta Kyrcyz ta Cdrigo, tmd
oao-hloculsts giaocst us wdrd ghrdg`y flgccloc
bdeard tmd rgjd mg` dvdo stgrtd`.
(Gppgrdothy g `ajuidotgry wgs bdloc ig`d
gbaut tmd rgjd go` spdjljghhy aur craup, gh-
tmaucm tmd wmys go` wmgts ae tmls apdrgtlao
wdrd jaiphdtdhy hast ta id wd fust crligjd`
pdrla`ljghhy ear tmd jgidrgigo go` mls rahhdr-
bhg`loc `gucmtdr).
Pmd odxt `gy wd mdg`d` aut erai Blsmkdk lotmd dvdoloc, rst pljkloc up tmd jgidrg igo, go`
cdttloc said eaa` gt g jmglkmgog. L mg` iy hgst
bddr bdeard wd sdt aut - g Bghtlkg : go` wd saao
grrlvd` lo Bghykjmy wmdrd tmd ruooloc wauh`
Ar gt hdgst lt edht tmgt wgy ta Pmaigs Ahsdo,
wma blkd`, rgo, bussd` go` swdgtd` mls
wgy grauo` Kyrcyzstgos egvaurltd hgkd, gspgrt ae tmd Elrst Lotdrogtlaogh Lssyk-Kuh Rdhgy
Rgjd.
Muo`rd`
Pmd
RdhgyIardtmgo
Hgsts
PMAIGZ AHZDO
g
\dgrs
Gbavd Zmats ae Pmaigs eddt hdcs go` blkd grd
gppgrdothy iard sjdolj tmgo Lssyk-Kuh go` lts
surrauo`locs (ghh pmatas Pmaigs Ahsdo)
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
15/28
www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar
74Ba`y go` Zauh
jaiidojd go` jaojhu`d. L strdtjmd` go` wghkd`
gbaut, wgltloc ear 2 gi ta grrlvd sa wd jauh` cdt
caloc. Ruooloc cdodrghhy lsot `dsjrlbd` gs tmdiast euo gjtlvlty lo tmd warh`, go` ruooloc gt 2
gi - uohdss ogkd` ar hag`d` wltm `rlok - ls ghiast
odvdr `dsjrlbd` tmls wgy.
But tmdo wd sdt a. Igrtlo go` L wdrd ruo-
oloc, wmlhd Gogtahy wgs up eraot ao tmd blkd. Pmd
rag` wgs iasthy gbgo`aod`, lhhuilogtd` aohy by
igrsmrutkg hlcmt, wmlhd tmd jaah glr ao iy sklo
go` tmd sauo`s ae ogturd brakd up tmd faccloc
iaoataoy. Mghewgy tmraucm tmd rgjd L rdiavd`
iy Elrst Lotdrogtlaogh Lssyk-Kuh Rdhgy Rgjd smlrt
go` hdt tmd `gwo glr hljk gcglost iy tgttaad`
tmargx. Pmd jgidrg hiloc id pasd` g `lhdiig,
tmaucm. Maw ta haak jaah wmlhd ruooloc, rgtmdr
tmgo rdsdibhloc g wdgkhloc jhlocloc aota hled lt-
sdhe1 Ztlhh, L olsmd` iy rst vd ki stlot dxmlhgrgt-
d` go` jgid ta go uo`drstgo`loc ae tmd ruoodrs
mlcm ear tmd rst tlid. Sma wauh` bd wgtjmloc
tmls `ajuidotgry goywgy1
Pmdo L mltjmd` g rl`d lo tmd tdgis
ilolbus.
Gttdiptd` shddp lo tmd igrsmrutkgeahhawd`,
tmd suo rasd, go` Lssyk-Kuh bdjgid vlslbhd. Lotdr-
ilttdot soaazds prdvdotd` id erai sddloc ghh
tmd sautmdro smard tmgt iaroloc, but tmd pgrts L
wgs gwgkd ear wdrd qultd spdjtgjuhgr. Getdr ogp-
ploc lo tmd vgo hlkd g bgby, tmdrd wgs iard blk-
loc go` ruooloc gmdg`, tmls tlid lo euhh `gyhlcmt.
To`dr tmd chgrd ae `gy, tlid shawd` `awo. Mgvd L
rdghhy oat `aod iy vd ki stlot1 L wauh` gsk iy-sdhe1 Dvdotughhy tmd igrsmrutkg jgid ta id hlkd
go gocdh goswdrloc iy prgydrs, but Jgptglo Igr-
tlo, phgyloc tmd rahd ae tmd `dvlh, pappd` aut go`
loearid` id tmgt wmlhd L mg` caod g hltthd avdr
sdvdo ki gt tmgt palot, iy tdgiigtds tmaucmt L
smauh` `a goatmdr tmrdd wmlhd tmdy kljkd` bgjk.
Oaw wltm saidtmloc ta pravd go` g mdgvy hgydrae swdgt ao iy ba`y, L ig`d lt ta tdo - t lrd`, muo-
cry go` shlcmthy lrrltgbhd.
Hgtdr L jgucmt up wltm tmd igrsmrutkg , wmasd
`rlvdr L wgs earjd` ta wgkd up, go` md tah` id
tmgt tmd atmdrs wdrd `awo by tmd hgkd dofayloc g
strahh, mgvloc hast trgjk ae tlid go` id. Aojd wd
cgtmdrd` gcglo wd `l` said iard ruooloc go`
do`urd` g wlo`y blkd rl`d, bdeard grrlvloc gt tmd
arpmgogcd tmgt wd wdrd rglsloc iaody ear. G taur
ae tmd crauo`s dosud`, g iddt go` crddt wltm tmd
waido ruooloc tmd phgjd, g havdhy loodr ae phav,
go` g sdsslao wltm said ae tmd kl`s, wma L sdr-
dog`d` wltm iy kaiuz. Lt ig`d ear g oljd do` ta
tmd gy.
L wakd up tmgt iaroloc gt eaur, eddhloc hlkd
`dgtm.
Zaid bhgjk tdg wltm brdg` go` swddts gt
aur mastdh wauh` bd tmd prdhu`d ta tmd oartm-
dro mghe ae tmd rdhgy. Getdr g smart ogp lo tmd vgo,L rgo iy rst vd ki, pgssloc tmraucm g vlhhgcd
wmdrd tmd hajghs stgrd` gt tmd strgocd, tgttaad`
wmltd pdrsao ruooloc go` swdgtloc lo g wgy
tmgt wgsot euhhy oarigh. @dspltd tmd sjrutloy ae
Pmd rag` wgs iasthy gbgo-`aod`, lhhuilogtd` aohy byigrsmrutkg hlcmt, wmlhd tmd jaahglr ao iy sklo go` tmd sauo`s aeogturd brakd up tmd faccloc ia-oataoy
tmdlr gwkwgr` cgwkloc L ig`d g tlid ae gbaut
25 iloutds, lipravloc ao iy prdvlaus rdjar`
erai tmd `gy bdeard. Sd pgssd` tmraucm g mastae egilhlgr rdsart tawos bdeard `rlvloc tmd hgst
hdc tawgr`s Bghykjmy. L tmdo taak ta tmd blkd ear
tmd maid strglt, dvdo tmaucm egstdr eahks lo aur
tdgi jauh` prabgbhy mgvd lipravd` aur avdrghh
tlid. Pmd rag` lo Bghykjmy wgs buipy go` L edht
go lotdosd pdhvlj pglo tmgt L mg` odvdr bdeard dx-
pdrldojd` go` mapd ta odvdr dxpdrldojd gcglo. L
idt tmd igrsmrutkggo` wgltd` ear tmd jgidrg-
igo ta ca ta tmd olsmloc palot go` hi aur ogh
jahhdjtlvd ruo. Pmd pglo lo iy hdcs wmlhd ruooloc
tmgt hgst muo`rd` ar sa idtdrs wgs hlkd tmd eddhloc
ae jaojrdtd bdloc paurd` lota iy jghvds wmlhd
iy kodds wdrd bdloc puhhd` aut ae iy hdcs. Sd
rdgjmd` tmd do` ae aur rdhgy, tlrd`, mgppy, go`
euhh ae g sdosd ae gjjaiphlsmidot gs wd pasd` earabhlcgtary craup pmatas. Sd shawhy cat bgjk lota
tmd ilolbusds go` mdg`d` ao tawgr`s Blsmkdk,
stapploc ear g bltd ta dgt. Erld` hgib `uiphlocs
go` Grpg bddr mg` odvdr tgstd` sa caa`.
Le yau grd lo Kyrcyzstgo ear haoc doaucm, go`
tmd wdgtmdr ls oljd, yau rdghhy smauh` jmdjk aut
Lssyk-Kuh. Pmd sautmdro smard mgs lojrd`lbhd rd`
rajk iauotglos go` said gigzloc ogturd. Pmd
oartm ls hhd` wltm taurlst rdsarts go` mgs g iard
odtwarkd` eddh ta lt. L cudss tmgt getdr ruooloc go`
blkloc grauo` tmd hgkd L oaw mgvd g blccdr gpprd-
jlgtlao ear tmd dyd ae tmd Plgo-Zmgo, go` tmd sjdo-
dry jdrtglohy ig`d tmd pmysljgh tahh ae tmd dvdot
iard tahdrgbhd. Ghh lo ghh, iy g`vljd ta goy Kyrcyz-stgo vlsltar ls ta ca go` dxphard dvdry oaak ae tmls
clgot gqudaus trdgsurd, but ta pdrmgps wgri up
wltm g marsd rl`d ar g swli bdeard gttdiptloc ta
rdhgy grauo` tmd wmahd kgbaasm.
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
16/28
Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk
75 Ba`y & Zauh
MD K\RC\V RD^TBHLJ6 Ghiast twa
ydgrs ao getdr tmd Gprlh 2>7> rdvahutlao
go`
Go` oatmloc, sgys Id`dr, tmlrty-
twa. Dvdrytmloc bdjgid iard dxpdo-
slvd, tmgts ghh. Aohy aur sghgrlds stgyd` tmd sgid.Mls jahhdgcud, Gsgo, gcrdds. Sd mgvd ta wark twa,
tmrdd, igybd eaur fabs.
Lt ls oat uojaiiao ta mdgr tmls lo Kyrcyzstgo;
mawdvdr, wmgt ls uousugh ls tmgt tmdsd twa ido grd
batm mlcmhy qughld` id`ljgh spdjlghlsts, warkloc
lo aod ae Blsmkdks iast prdstlclaus maspltghs.
Id`dr mgs tmrdd fabs6 md ls g euhh-tlid rd-
sdgrjmdr lo tmd maspltgh, sdds prlvgtd pgtldots getdr
warkloc maurs, go` jao`ujts mdghtm jmdjks ear
go lotdrogtlaogh jaipgoy, sddloc grauo` twdhvd
jaipgoy diphaydds dgjm iaotm. Mls rdsdgrjm
pasltlao pgys mli $TZ7>> pdr iaotm, fust uo`dr
mghe tmd gvdrgcd iaotmhy wgcd lo Blsmkdk. Dvdo
jaiblod` wltm tmd iaody mls wled dgros wark-
loc gs g euhh-tlid id`ljgh tdjmoljlgo, tmls ls oatdoaucm ta rdot mls twa-raai, rdeurblsmd` Zavldt
gpgrtidot, go` ta edd`, jhatmd go` sdo` mls twa
yauoc jmlh`rdo ta sjmaah. But wltm mls twa g``l-
tlaogh fabs, go` warkloc twdhvd maur `gys, Id`dr
jgo igkd $TZ:>>-0>> pdr iaotm, sgvloc g hltthd
iaody ear go ajjgslaogh iavld tljkdt go` ear go
goough suiidr mahl`gy ta Hgkd Lssyk-kah.
G sighh sghgry brdd`s g jrdgtlvd go` `lvdrsd
dotrdprdodursmlp giaoc id`ljgh praedsslaoghs.
Aod `ajtar lo Id`drs `dpgrtidot mgs jaiigo-
`ddrd` tmd id`ljgh dqulpidot `aogtd` ta tmd
maspltgh. Tsloc tmls igjmlod, md jgo sdd etddo
rgtmdr tmgo tdo pgtldots pdr gy, go` dgjm pgtldot
pgys mli g hltthd dxtrg ear tmd prlvlhdcd. Pmls dog-bhds mli ta buy mls wgy aut ae tmd twa olcmt smlets
md ls abhlcd` ta wark pdr iaotm, pgyloc mls jah-
hdgcuds =>>-7>>> sai ($TZ75-27) ta tgkd mls smlet.
Goatmdr `ajtar mgs eauo` g pgtldot bgsd giaoc
arcgolzd` jrlid curds6 g wdghtmy craup, tmdy
jgo pgy mli iard. Atmdr `ajtars prdss maspltgh
pgtldots ear crgtltu`d `aogtlaos ae bdtwddo 4>>-
2>>> sai ($TZ77-02), go` aetdo bhgtgothy rdeusd
ta trdgt pgtldots wma a oat pravl`d uperaot jgsm
pgyidots.
@awo go ddrlhy quldt go` `lihy hlt jarrl`ar,
wghhs wgsmd` wltm tmgt `lstlojthy Zavldt bhud, wd
pgss g slco `djhgrloc tmgt `ajtars grd pramlbltd`
erai sddloc prlvgtd pgtldots. L aohy sdd prlvgtd
pgtldots getdr maurs, sgys Id`dr, go` sa, lts oatstrljthy earbl``do. L mgvd g caa` rdhgtlaosmlp wltm
tmd mdg` ae iy `dpgrtidot, wma jaosl`drs id g
vghugbhd `ajtar, go` md uo`drstgo`s tmgt L jgot
hlvd ao iy maspltgh sghgry ghaod. Za lts tahdrgtd`.
Go` tmdo tmdrd grd tmd oursds, warkloc earty-
maur wddks ear $TZ54 pdr iaotm.
L wao`dr wmgt tmdy `a ta igkd doaucm
iaody ta hlvd, Id`dr iusds. Pmdy mgvd jmlh`rdo,
go` igoy ae tmdi grd `lvarjd`.
@ddp lo tmd maspltgh, lo g spgrsdhy dqulppd`stg raai, twa yauoc oursds, Jmahpao go` Ghaog,
slt grauo` g tgbhd, Jmahpao euibhloc wltm g syrlocd
pgjkdt ao g haod idtgh trahhdy. Li oat mgppy wltm
tmd jao`ltlaos, sgys Ghaog, but L jgo bdgr lt.
Ghaogs slstdr warks gbrag`, sdo`loc iaody
bgjk ta mdr egilhy lo Kyrcyzstgo. Jauphloc tmls
wltm hliltd` ogojlgh suppart erai mdr pgrdots,
Ghaog jgo survlvd. Zmd go` Jmahpao mgvd jaosl`-
drd` warkloc autsl`d ae Kyrcyzstgo ghh oursds
mgvd but tmdsd yauoc waido wauh` aohy jao-
sl`dr lt g tdipargry grrgocdidot.
Igybd L wauh` wark ear vd ar tdo ydgrs
gbrag`, but L` `doltdhy rdturo. Gt tmd iaidot,
tmaucm, L odd` ta jaosl`dr iy aptlaos iard jgrd-
euhhy, Jmahpao sgys.Igoy `ajtars grd ghsa haakloc ear bdttdr hlvds
dhsdwmdrd. Haw pgy, jhgo rlvghry wltmlo tmd maspl-
tgh systdi, go` paar jao`ltlaos mgvd sdot igoy
`ajtars gbrag`. G 2>>= rdsdgrjm pgpdr pubhlsmd`
by tmd Sarh` Mdghtm Arcgolsgtlao rdpartd` tmgt
dlcmt pdrjdot ae mdghtm spdjlghlsts hdet Kyrcyzstgo
lo 2>>4, eahhawloc tmd sa-jghhd` Puhlp Rdvahutlao.
Pmdrd mgvd bddo oa eurtmdr ajlgh lovdstlcgtlaos
lota tmls pmdoaidoao, but godj`atgh dvl`dojd
succdsts tmd prabhdi ls crawloc, pgrtljuhgrhy ge-
tdr tmd Gprlh 2>7> rdvahutlao. Kgzgkmstgo go` Rus-
slg grd tmd iast papuhgr aptlaos ear liilcrgtlao,
wmdrd `ajtars jgo dgro g sghgry vd ta tdo tlids
crdgtdr tmgo lo Kyrcyzstgo. Mawdvdr, ruiar mgs lttmgt avdrt rgjlsi tawgr`s Kyrcyz jltlzdos lo Rus-
slgo go` Kgzgkmstgo igkds odw grrlvghs eddh uo-
`drvghud` go` uowdhjaid.
Ls lt bdttdr ta hdgvd Kyrcyzstgo ear g mgr` hled
lo Kgzgkmstgo1 Id`dr pao`drs. L wauh` `a lt ear
tmd sgkd ae iy jmlh`rdo!
But ear oaw, tmdrd ls said stgblhlty lo tmd
sltugtlao bdloc tdipargrlhy bdgrgbhd. Id`dr eddhs
abhlcd` ta jgrd ear mls pgtldots, tmdrd grd passlblhl-
tlds ae praiatlaos go` fabs tmgt mls pgrdots ar rdh-
gtlvds ilcmt bd gbhd ta grrgocd, go` md ls mdsltgot
gbaut upraatloc mls egilhy.
Id`dr slcms6 Dvdry gy L bdjaid iard pdssl-
ilstlj. Smgt ls tmd euturd ear id`ljgh praedsslaoghs
lo iy jauotry1
Pmd ogids usd` lo tmls grtljhd mgvd bddo
jmgocd` ta pratdjt tmd l`dotltlds ae tmd pdaphd lotdr-
vldwd`.
G@DHLOD BDHH
P
Gettdr bdloc taujmd` by tmd sauh-sdgrjmloc ae ha-jgh Blsmkdk `ajtars, tmd Zpdktgtars G`dhlod Bdhh`djl`d` ta tgkd g haak gt tmd atmdr sl`d, go` wdottghkloc ta g jauphd ae Blsmkdks pgtldots, jahhdjt-
loc tmd eahhawloc starlds
Zdrcdl, :76
G edw ydgrs gca L edhh a iy blkd go` sphlt iyjmlo apdo. L cat up, stgccdrd` grauo`, go` rd-ghlsd` tmgt L wgs qultd jhasd ta g ilhltgry maspltgh.L pusmd` iy blkd tawgr`s tmd maspltgh, mah`lociy jmlo tacdtmdr, go` gskd` tmd `ajtar ao jghhear mdhp.
Sd aot mgvd goytmloc ta mdhp yau, wgs mlsrdspaosd.\au mgvd ta ca ta Blsmkdk.
Jgot yau fust bgo`gcd id up1 L gskd`,jhdgrhy vdry `lstrdssd`.
Sdhh le yau buy lt yaursdhe wd jgo x yauup wltm said stljky tgpd, le yau wgot. Pmdo yau
odd` ta ca ta Blsmkdk.Getdr cdttloc g rahh erai g odgrby klask tmd
`ajtar wrgppd` iy mdg` up lo tgpd, but L wgs stlhhbhdd`loc eurlaushy. L cat ao iy blkd go` jyjhd`lota Blsmkdk ta g hajgh maspltgh lo iy grdg. Smdolt wgs iy turo, L wdot lota tmd `ajtars dxgilog-tlao raai. Md wgs slttloc tmdrd vdry jghihy. Lt wgsabvlaus tmgt L odd`d` urcdot surcdry ear iy jmlo,dvdo le sliphy ta stap tmd bhdd`loc. Gt tmgt stgcdlt wgs gbaut twa maurs slojd L` mg` tmd gjjl`dot.
Pmd `ajtar haakd` gt id go` sgl`, \au grdcaloc ta odd` g vdry dxpdoslvd apdrgtlao. Mdquatd` id tmd prljd. Ae jaursd L sgl` yds! L tah`mli L gssurd` mli tmgt L jauh` cdt tmd iaodyerai iy rdhgtlvds.
Getdr g blt ae `lsjusslao gbaut tmgt, tmd `aj-tar sgl`, But yau koaw, le yau aohy mgvd tmgt ap-drgtlao, yau wlhh mgvd g blc sjgr ao yaur jmlo eartmd rdst ae yaur hled. Za lo tmls jgsd, yau wlhh wgotg `ldrdot apdrgtlao, aod tmgt `adsot hdgvd goysjgr. Pmgt apdrgtlao wlhh jast Go` gcglo, mdquatd` id g prljd, gbaut `aubhd tmd prdvlausaod.
Abvlaushy L gcglo gcrdd`, go` aojd gcglo gs-surd` mli tmgt iy rdhgtlvds jauh` cdt tmd iaody.But tmd `ajtar sgt bgjk, stlhh jghi, go` sgl`, Sdhh,rst wd odd` ta wglt ear yaur rdhgtlvds ta jaid wltm tmd iaody. Pmdo wd jgo a tmd apdrgtlao.
But Li haasloc sa iujm bhaa`! L ydhhd`. Pmd`ajtar haakd` gt id.
\auvd cat gt hdgst twa iard maurs, md sgl .
Dhdog, 206
Smdo L wgs g jmlh` iy yauocdr slstdr, Vmdoyg,koajkd` aut g taatm, jgusloc bhaa` ta vlahdothyspurt erai mdr iautm. Aur pgrdots wdrdot gtmaid sa L `lhlcdothy taak Vmdoyg ta tmd hajghmaspltgh iysdhe. Sd wdrd twa hltthd clrhs slttloclo tmd wgltloc raai, go` dvdry tlid tmd `ajtarjgid pgst L jrld` aut ta mli, Iy slstdr ls bhdd`-loc g hat erai mdr iautm! ^hdgsd mdhp us! But tmd`ajtar wghkd` pgst, gcglo go` gcglo, go` taakoa oatljd. Vmdoyg wgs eddhloc gweuh go` eglot,go` g haoc tlid getdr wd grrlvd`, tmd `ajtar -
oghhy `djl`d` ta pgy said gttdotlao ta mdr. Mdapdod` mdr iautm go` wgs rdghhy smajkd` gtwmgt md sgw. Md sgl` ta id, Pmls ls rdghhy `go-cdraus! Zmds hast g hat ae bhaa`! Smy `l`ot yautdhh id tmls bdeard1!
Pmd Sgltloc Raai
aeJgsughtlds avdrty & ahltljsPmls wlotdr G`dhlod Bdhhtaak g wghk awo tmd mghhs ae said ae tmd Kyrcyz Jgpltghs o-dst id`ljgh lostltutlaos go` eauo` tmgt Cdarcd Jhaaody go` Mahaclj @lsjavdry Jl Baod
@dosltaidtdrs wdrd lo smart supphy. Ztlhh, Kyrcyzstgos avdrwarkd` uo`drpgl` `ajtars
grd `aloc wmgt tmdy jgo ta cdt by.
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
17/28
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
18/28
Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk
7= Eajus
DZZ PMGO G \DGRmg` dhgpsd` slojd aur
trgvdhs lo Purkdstgo go` wd wdrd ghrdg`ybgjk ao tmd rag`, lo sdgrjm ae goatmdrergcidot ae earcattdo mlstary. Pmls tlid,aur dstlogtlao wgs tmd mlcm-ghtltu`d mahy
phgjd ae Zglighuu-Pgsm. Aur taur odd`d` ta bdjgrdeuhhy phgood` gs wd wdrd mdg`loc tmraucmjauotry wmdrd tmd eddt ae ar`logry taurlsts rgrdhy
stdppd`. Lt iust bd sgl` tmgt wd sudrd` saidsighh lojl`dots `urloc aur taur but, ae jaursd,
wmgt ls go g`vdoturd wltmaut g `gsm ae strucchdgo` mgr`smlp1
Pmd rautd ta Zglighuu-Pgsm carcd, hast lo tmd
iu``hd ae tmd Plgo-Zmgo Iauotglos, wgs haoc go``digo`loc, dvdo ear tmd iast trglod` go` dxpd-rldojd` idibdrs ae tmd dxpd`ltlao. Getdr rdgjm-
loc Ogryo, wd strujk wdst ta Kgzgrigo lo Fghgh-Gbg` abhgst, g tawo sddilochy hast ta tmd warh`,
sdrvljd` odltmdr by phgod oar by trglo, go` hlokd`ta jlvlhlzgtlao aohy by g haoc go` wlo`loc rag`,aetdo hltthd bdttdr tmgo g `lrt trgjk. Pmls `lrt trgjk,
looltdhy ruttd` sa gs ta clvd tmd liprdsslao tmgtaod ls `rlvloc gjrass g odvdr do`loc wgsm-bagr`,wd odcatlgtd` ear twa muo`rd` klhaidtrds. Ao tmd
wgy, wd rdcuhgrhy pgssd` hajghs trgvdhloc tmd sgidrautd by buhhajks ar `aokdys go` jgrts g crudhloc
faurody tmgt tgkds sdvdrgh `gys. Erai tlid ta tlid,
wd ghsa dojauotdrd` tmd shlcmthy hdss trg`ltlaoghbut dvdr papuhgr Gu`l 7>>s, usughhy ae g 7s vlo-
tgcd, wmljm lotdrilttdothy bauojd` pgst gs tmdyavdrtaak us ao tmd haety, sdrpdotlod pgtm.
Bdjgusd ae tmd egiaus Igkigh cah` dh` oategr gwgy, Kgzgrigo ls g hltthd rdilolsjdot ae tmdearcattdo tawos ae tmd Slh` Sdst. @ud lo pgrt tatmd dxlstdojd ae tmd iloloc apdrgtlao, tmd sdtthd-
idot ls rdphdtd wltm lhhljlt pdrsaoghltlds, sighh tlid
Uhg`lilr ^dtrav rdjauots mls faurody ta
Zglighuu-Pgsm, tmd maid ae avdr 2>,>>>rajk rgwlocs. Sltm plhcrlis mgvloc vlsltd`
tmd sltd erai 2>>> B.J up uotlh tmd Il``hd
Gcds, Zglighuu-Pgsm ls uo`aubtd`hy g mdr-
ltgcd mlcmhlcmt ae chabgh slcoljgojd. Odv-
drtmdhdss, gs ^dtrav wauh` hdgro, o`loc g
hajgh tmgt jgo stlhh rdidibdr tmd rautd ls
saidtmloc ae g jmghhdocd.
H
UHG@LILR ^DPRAU & DHDOG CARBGJMDUG
maa`s go` uoprd`ljtgbhd xdoapmabds. Smdo wd
dotdrd` tmd tawo, aur bus gttrgjtd` tmd hajgh pa-hljds gttdotlao liid`lgtdhy. Getdr jgtjmloc upwltm us odgr aur cudst mausd, tmd jurlaus pgtrahwgs dvdotughhy pdrsug`d` tmgt aur lotdotlaos
wdrd bdolco, go` tmdy hdt us bd, but oat bdeardlssuloc eglr wgroloc gbaut tmd uoerldo`hlodss aetmd hajgh jrlilogh autt. Ghhdcd`hy, tmls iab mg`
g pdojmgot ear rabbloc jgrs wmdo stgtlaogry go`pdhtloc tmdi wltm staods wmdo iavloc.
Gs wd dxphard` tmd tawo wd edht tmd muo-cry cgzd ae tmd tawosido. Gt tlids tmd pavdrtygrauo` us wgs crlo`loc. Jaostgothy, wd gskd`
aursdhvds6 Smdrd `a pdaphd wark, maw `a tmdydgro tmdlr brdg`1 But wd mg` oa goswdr ta aurqudstlaos. Gjjar`loc ta g hajgh matdh praprldtrdss,
tmd tawo awd` lts hled ta Ighigk. Le oat ear tmgtilod, lt wauh` mgvd bddo tmd do` ae tmd warh`.
\dt erai saidwmdrd lo tmls tawo go` lts wrdtjm-d` surrauo`locs, wd mg` odd` ta o` aursdhvdsg cul`d.
Cul`d id ta oawmdrd
Lo tmd iaroloc, mgvloc mg` brdgkegst, wd cat smat
ae tmd ilsdrgbhd phgjd. Getdr javdrloc said flgtcrauo` wd grrlvd` lo Gtgl, oat egr erai tmd ilod-smget ltsdhe, go` docgcd` twa dotdrprlsloc yauoc
ido, Igigt go` Bgkyt, lo tmd jgpgjlty ae cul`ds.Getdr tmd vlhhgcd tmd rag` bdjgid stddpdr go` aur
trdk bdcgo lo dgrodst. Pmd sky wgs javdrd` wltmjhau`s, lt wgs jah`, go` lt sddid` rglo wgs lo tmd
glr. But sjgrjdhy mg` wd jhlibd` tmd Kdk-Grt pgss,wmdo tmd rglo jhau`s `lspdrsd` go` wd edht tmddgrhy Zdptdibdr suo ao aur egjds.
Odltmdr ae aur cul`ds grausd` g hat ae trust
`urloc tmd dgrhy maurs ae aur crdgt do`dgvar,
ZpdgktmdSmdoZtaods
Gbavd go` rlcmt Zglighuu-Pgsm mgs saidae tmd bdst pdtrachypms uo`dr tmd sky. Le
yau jgo o` tmd `giod` phgjd (ghh pmatas
Uhg`lilr dtrav. Zpdjlgh oatd6 Pmls grtljhd wgs
trgoshgtd` by Dhdog Carbgjmdvg)
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
19/28
www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar
7
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
20/28
Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk
2> Eajus
Gbavd Hajgh cul`ds grdot ghwgys gs loeari-
gtlvd ar koawhd`cdgbhd gs yau wauh` mapd.
Pmls aod, Igigt, mgs ghiast oa koawhd`cd
gt ghh
Gt vgrlaus tlids, sjldotlsts mgvd spdjuhgtd`
tmgt tmdsd hlods rdprdsdotd` iauotglo rgocdsgo` rlvdrs. But prdjlsdhy bdjgusd wd rdgjmd` tmdprdjlpljd by eaat wd bdc ta `ldr! Le tmdsd hlods
grd rlvdrs, wmy grd tmdy tmus rdprdsdotd`, said-tlids gs aod go` gt atmdr tlids tmrdd hlods1 Le
tmdy grd suiilts,tmdo wmy `a sjdodsae tlhhgcd hdvltgtd lotmd sky wmlhd tmd `lsj
ae tmd suo babs uo-`dr tmd iauotglo1
Go` wmy grd iauo-tglo rgocds pglotd` gsjhasd` hlods1 Pwlstloc
hlods grd dojauotdrd`ao tmd pdtrachypms ae Zglighuu-Pgsm iard ae-tdo tmgo goywmdrd dhsd. Smlhd tmdy grd by oa
idgos uolqud ta tmls Jdotrgh Gslgo mahy spat,wd jgo stgtd ear surd tmgt tmdy ajjur iujm hdss
erdqudothy lo tmd hawdr-sltugtd` sgojtugrlds, tmdpdtrachypms ae Lssyk-Kuhs Zkgzkg vghhdy, ear lo-stgojd. Igybd gojldot grtlsts pgssloc erai tmd
eaat up ta tmd suiilt sgw tmdsd hlods gs tmdlrwgy ta tmd sky, ta tmd suo, ta tmd aohy iauotglowmljm wgs ear tmdi tmd Zuo Iauotglo.
G crdgt ouibdr ae tmd sahgr slcos jaovlojd`us tmgt suo-warsmlp wgs tmd hdg`loc eari aerdhlclao ear g haoc tlid mdrd. Pmd suo juht ls dvl-
`dot lo jaiiao jlrjhds, swgstlkg-hlkd syibahsgo` iard abvlaus `dpljtlaos ae tmd suo. Lo`dd`,
dvdo golighs maros grd twlstd` lo tmd eari ae tmdsuo, go` g suo jmgrlat ghsa edgturds. But gbavd ghh,eartuod mdhpd` us ta o` tmgt rgrd ligcd wmljm
mgs bdjaid g jmdrlsmd` syibah ae ghh Kyrcyz
pdtrachypmys tmd suo bay wmasd haasd mglrsphgys aut hlkd sahgr rgys.
Jdoturlds pgssd`, pljturds `lsgppdgrd`erai tmd staods, but odw cdodrgtlaos ae plh-
crlis jhlibd` Zglighuu-Pgsm go` rdodwd` tmd
pljturds gs dvl`dojd ae tmd jaostgojy ae tmdlr
egltm. Go` g tmausgo` ydgrs hgtdr, wmdo tmd Zgkshlvd`, tmdy vlsltd` tmd sgojtugry go` g``d` li-gcds ig`d lo g egiaus goligh styhd, wl`dhy
sprdg` ghaoc tmd stdppd jgtthd-brdd`loc grdgae Durgslg erai Iaocahlg go` oartmdro Jmlog
ta tmd oartmdro BhgjkZdg rdclao. But tmdsdpljturds grd edw go`wd jgo suppasd tmgt
gt g jdrtglo palot,saidtlid getdr tmd
Braozd Gcd, tmd phgjdjdgsd` ta bd g sgojtu-gry. Odvdrtmdhdss tmd
hled mgsot `ld` gwgy.Pmdsd phgjds mgvd ghwgys bddo jaosl`drd` sg-jrd`. Lt wgs earbl``do ta `dstray pdtrachypms.
Ah`dr rdsl`dots tah` ae `ldrdot hdcdo`s gbauttmdsd iauotglos go` dvdo oaw tmdrd grd ah`
pdaphd ghlvd wma rdidibdr starlds ae `dvautsuo-warsmlppdrs jhlibloc tmd carcd, lsgppdgr-loc bdmlo` tmd :,>>>i Kucgrt pgss go` adrloc
up sgjrljlgh clets ta tmd ca`s.Aur wgy ta tmd suo wgs egr erai uolqud,
rgtmdr lt wgs tmd rdpdtltlao ae g trlp tmgt mgs bddo
ig`d ear ilhhdoolg. G stard ae koawhd`cd, Zgligh-uu-Pgsm jgo bd tmd sahutlao ta igoy ae tmd puz-zhds jaoodjtd` wltm tmd arlclos ae gojldot grt ao
tmd tdrrltary ae ia`dro Kyrcyzstgo, le go` wmdotmd jgrvlocs hdet by `ldrdot pdaphds - oaig`lj
typds erai tmd oartm, sdtthd` egridrs erai tmdsautm grd clvdo prapdr gttdotlao. Gs wltodssd`lo tmd sjdods `dpljtd` tmdrd, tmd vgrlaus plhcrlis
ta tmls phgjd `ldrd` batm lo tdris ae tmd `dltlds
tmdy warsmlppd` go` tmd wgy tmdy dgrod` tmdlrhlvdhlmaa`s. But le tmdy wdrd uoltd` by aod tmloc,
lt wgs tmd Zuo Iauotglo ltsdhe, g bdodvahdot mastta aod ae tmd dgrhldst go` iast do`urloc earis
ae muigo jaiiuoljgtlao.
Jdoturlds pgssd`, pljturds `lsgp-
pdgrd` erai tmd staods, but odw cdo-
drgtlaos ae plhcrlis jhlibd Zgligh-
uu-Pgsm go rdodwd tmd pljturds gs
dvl`dojd ae tmd jaostgojy ae tmdlr egltm
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
21/28
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
22/28
Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk
22 Rd` Hlcmt Cul`d
BlsmkdkBTRHDZWTD
Smdo lt jaids ta sdhhloc sdx
tmdrd grd edw jltlds tmgt brdgk
tmd ja`ds ae tmdlr awo sajldtys
jaosdrvgtlsi gs erdqudothy gs
tmd Kyrcyz jgpltgh, Blsmkdk. But
wmlhd tmd a`` hajgh wlhh smgid-
hdsshy tghk up mls sguog sdsslaos wltm yauoc
clrhs, tmd slhdot igfarlty ae ighd Blsmkdk rdsl-
`dots lo`uhcloc lo prastltutlao, ar lts sgedr sls-
tdr, strlptdgsd, tdo` ta kddp tmdlr g`vdoturds tatmdisdhvds.
Pmls sltugtlao hdg`s ta g rdgh gbsdojd ae `d -
jdot loearigtlao ao g burcdaoloc lo`ustry
aod ae edw lo tmd jauotry go` tmd `lihy rd`-hlt
jarodrs ae Blsmkdks olcmthled mgvd sa egr dsjgpd`
tmd Zpdktgtarspathlcmt. Totlh oaw, tmgt ls.
Lo tdris ae strlp jhubs Blsmkdk pghds lo jai-
pgrlsao ta g Udcgs, ^rgcud ar Bgockak, but ear
tmd blccdst hltthd jlty lo Jdotrgh Gslg, lt sparts
gt hdgst elvd vdouds tmgt bagst go liprdsslvd
spdjtrui ae ogtlaoghltlds, sdrvljds, go` gtia-
spmdrds. Lo ghh elvd yau wlhh elo` Kyrcyzstgos eg-
iaus ogturgh bdguty ao `lsphgy, but uohlkd tmd
iauotglo glr, lt jaids gt g pr ljd.
Dotrgojd ear tmdsd jhubs rgocds erai 4>>
ta 7>>> sai go` tmgts fust tmd bdclooloc ae
tmd `gigcd. ^rlvgtd `gojds jgo bd up ta $7>>
`ahhgrs ear 74 iloutds, pahd `gojdrs smaw yau
g edw sdjao`s ae havd ear oa hdss tmgo 7>>
sai, go` aetdo tmd clrhs wark yaur wghhdt ear
dxpdoslvd jajktglhs erai tmd bgr. Pmd bdst gj-
tlao iaody jgo buy wlhh jast odgr $74>, go`
`dpdo`loc ao tmd hajgtlao, wlhh usughhy jaoslst
ae twa clrhs ae yaur jmaasloc puttl oc ao g smaw
ear yau lovahvloc tdqulhg, wmlppd` jrdgi,
go` go grtleljlgh pmghhus, gppraprlgtdhy ogid`
Mdgvdo.
Smlhd dxpdrts lo tmd eldh` gcrdd tmgt Blsm-
kdk igy oat bd gs prljd jaipdtltlvd gs lt aojdwgs, rdcuhgtlao ls stlhh oawmdrd hlkd lt ls lo tmd
Toltd` Ztgtds. Mdrd yau wlhh cdt crdgt ilhhgcd
qughlty ae `gojd idgsurd` lo uolts ae taujmy-
Gs tmd `gy ae havdrs odgrs, Zpdktgtar Zhdgzd
Jarrdspao`dot F.R.R Brakdo mgs g`-
faurod` erai mls usugh jaiiltidots ta
clvd yau tmd Eruozd eddh`awo ao tmd jltys
mattdst go` oattdst strlp bgrs. @lsjhglidr6
tmls igcgzlod `ads oat lo goy wgy do`arsd
sdxlsi, edilolsi, egsjlsi, sajlghlsi ar goy
atmdr lsi tmgt gppdgrs ao lts pgcds.
F.R.R BRAKDO
eddhylo dxjmgocd ear tmd sais tmgt yau smdhh.
Za wltm tmd bgsljs avdr wltm, ao ta tmd lotl-
igtd `dtglhs6
Grbgt Pmd Blsmkdk Lostltutlao
(Kgrh Igrx/Vmucuhavskgyg)
Zltd6mttp6//bbs.kc/sdrvljds/jhubs/jhub-grbgt.mtih
Smdo L stgrtd` gskloc grauo` gbaut strlp jhubs
lo Blsmkdk, tmd elrst war` tmgt jgid aut ae iast
tgxl `rlvdrs iautms wgs Grbgt. Grbgt ls g Blsm-
kdk lostltutlao, go` mgvloc apdrgtd` ear sdvdrgh
ydgrs tmdyrd ao g pgr wltm @dilr Bgok gs aod ae
tmd edw buslodssds tmgt mgvd gjtughhy survlvd`
twa rdvahutlaos. Pmd strlp jhub ls g spdjlghlst
bgjkraai tmgt sigjks yau wltm g > sai edd
ao dotry. Zaidtlids yau cdt erlskd` by g `u`d
ao yaur wgy lo - g rdgh tur o aee - but Grbgts haety
javdr jmgrcd kddps lt spgrsdhy papuhgtd`, sa
yau waot mgvd ta warry gbaut jaipdtloc ear
g clrhs gttdotlao wltm taa igoy atmdr fgjkgssds.
Pmd wd dkdo`s grd cdodrghhy wmdo tmd jhub mgs
tmd bdst hlod up, but tmd suiidr jgo bd mlt go`
ilss, slojd g hat ae tmdsd clrhs trgvdh ta Lssyk-Kuh
gs pgl` jaipgoy.
Zmplhkg (Mlcm Mddh) - Hgst Rdsart Zhdgzd
(Uastak-4 bdeard Jhub Vdppdhlo ao Jmuy)
Hajgtd` lo tmd dgst ae Blsmkdk odgr tmd Lo`us-
trlgh Vaod, Zmplhkg ls lraoljghhy elhhd` wltm clrhs
erai tmd jauotrysl`d. Maspltgbhd, le saidwmgt
jagrsd, tmls dstgbhlsmidot ls oat ear elrst tlidrs
haakloc ta bd` tmdisdhvds lota Blsmkdks aajm-
ld-wghhg-wghhg sjdod.
@ahhs Pap @ahhgr ear Pap Zdrvl jd
(Carkavg/Zavldtskgyg gjrass erai Udeg Jdotdr)
Aod ae tmd bdst strlp jhubs lo Blsmkdk, wltm g
caa` ratgtlao ae clrhs, iasthy eardlco jhldotdhd
go` g 4>> jai dotrgojd edd. Lo go lo`ustry ae
mlt-go`-ilss, tmd jrid `d hg jrid ae Blsm-kdks strlp jhub jaooalssdurs jmaasd tmls phgjd
ear tmdlr shl`d go` crlo`. Ghiast goy olcmt ae
tmd wddk yau jgo jauot ao gt hdgst elvd clrhs.
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
23/28
www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar
2:
Kddp trgjk ae yaur `rloks, mawdvdr, slojd tmd
`gojdrs hlkd ta mlt yau up ear dxpdoslvd jajk-
tglhs. @dspltd tmd jast ae tmd `rlokloc go` tmd
`gojloc, yau `a cdt wmgt yau pgy ear padtry-
lo-iatlao pahd wark go` hats ae lotdrgjtlao.
Slok, wlok, ou`cd, ou`cd, go` ghh.
x]x Pmd Odw Kl` ao tmd Bhajk
(Igogs/Kldvskgyg hajgtd` rlcmt odxt ta @ailoa
Jhub)
Ztrgtdcljghhy phgjd` wltmlo stuibhloc `lstgojd
ae tmd Idtra pub L wgs ghwgys jurlaus wmy g
strlp jhub mg`ot spruoc up dgrhldr lo tmls grdg.
Dotrgojd ls 4>> sai go` bgsd` aee ae iy slochd
liprdsslao tmdrd, lt mgs tmd patdotlgh ta clvd
tmd `ahhs erai @ahhs g ruo ear tmdlr iaody. Lts
prljds grd odgr l`dotljgh ta tmd Carkavg clrh-
stap, but g huxurlaus UL^/Hgp `gojd raai
igkds lt g mlt lo iy baak. Iard ae g haakloc
phgjd tmgo g taujmloc phgjd, mawdvdr, go` uo-
hdss yau mgvd go dxtrg $4> spgrd, ar eddh brgvd
lo eraot ae bauojdrs tmgt grd quljk wltm tmdlr
mgo`s le yau grd jgrdhdss wltm yaurs, stljk ta
acchloc.
Go Todxpdjtd` @lsjavdry
Hltdrghhy, g `gy bdeard L wgs suppasd` ta turo lo
tmls grtljhd lo, g hled jmgocloc go` uodxpdjtd`
`lsjavdry taak phgjd tmgt L eddh mgs rglsd` tmd
bgr ear ghh strlp jhubs lo Blsmkdk. Lo tmd sighh
maurs ae g eglrhy gvdrgcd `ruokdo olcmt lo Rdtra
Idtra, iy erldo` go` L jghhd` lo aur blhh. Fust gs
wd stgo` up g pglr ae clrhs wghk lo wma sddi
vdry Gidrljgo lo tmdlr igoodrlsis go` vah-
uid. Aod ae tmdi wgs go dxtrdidhy gttrgjtlvd
rd` mdg`, wma jgucmt iy erldo`s gttdotlao, sa
wd wdot up ta ca tghk ta tmdi. Puros aut tmdy
wdrd gjtughhy Russlgo, but erldo`hy doaucm. Ge-
tdr iard `rloks tmdy jaovlojd` us ta stgy go`
mgoc aut.
Egst earwgr` gbaut go maur go` wdrd cdt-
tloc rlvdo ta g strlp jhub - L gssuid` @ahhs. But
upao `rlvloc pgst @ahhs go` stapploc lo tmd
uohlt, dipty pgrkloc hat ae g eurolturd stard,
L bdcgo ta sdosd eauh phgy, gssuiloc wd mg`
bddo sdt up go` tmgt tmdsd clrhs bayerldo`s
wauh` saao jaid go` rdhldvd us ae aur jgsm lo
g SmgiBgiPmgok\auIgi klo` ae wgy. Cul`-
d` `awo g `grk stglrwdhh lota g bgsdidot iy
spl`dr sdosds wdrd gbhgzd, iy smart Blsmkdk
dxlstdojd mgocloc ao g tmrdg`. But.
Pa iy gigzd idot tmd `aar ehuoc apdo ta
tmd ragr ae jhub iuslj, g bdgutleuh lotdrlar, wltmg shddploc sdjurlty cugr` go` oa javdr jmgrcd.
G rdgsaogbhy prljd` `rlok idou crddtd` us
ghaoc wltm g jg`rd ae yauoc waido wma bd-
cgo sliuhtgodaushy warkloc tmd pahds go`
aur uosuspdjtloc hgps wltmaut dvdo mgvloc ta
ehgsm tmd jgsm. Aur twa jaipgolaos saidmaw
kodw ghh tmd waido wma warkd` tmdrd - but
wd `l`ot gsk - wmy rulo g caa` tmloc1 Lt wgsot
uotlh gbaut =gi tmgt tmd pgrty eloghhy stappd`
go` ear iloliui dxpdosd wd mg` rdjdlvd`
maurs ae dotdrtgloidot go` hgp `gojds.
Tokoawo Pmd ^atdotlgh Cgid Jmgocdr
(Ml``do bdodgtm g eurolturd stard odgr tmd
Carkavg/Zavldtskgyg jrassloc)Mgvd yau dvdr wgotd` ta buy g odw jaeedd tg-
bhd go` tmaucmt tmgt tmd aod tmloc tmgt jauh`
rdghhy lipravd tmd dxpdrldojd wauh` bd le yau
wdrd wltmlo splttloc `lstgojd ae ogkd` wai-
do1 Sdhh, haak oa eurtmdr! Pmls jauh` bd g cgid
jmgocdr ear tmd strlp jhub sjdod ear sdvdrgh
rdgsaos6 tmd hgjk ae javdr jmgrcd, tmd odgr pdr-
edjt ogturd ae tmd jhub ltsdhe, go` tmd vghud ear
iaody. Pmls uoogid` lostltutlao edgturds eaur
stgcds, g euhh bgr, jaieartgbhd hdgtmdr jaujmds
go` g `djdot hlod up ae clrhs. Pmd pljk ae tmd
pgjk ls strglcmt aut ae Bgywgtjm, buxai go`
bhao`d lo g swddt spgo`dx autelt, wltm g wmlp
ae g mglr ehlp tmgt wlhh hdgvd yau eddhloc hlkd yau
stdppd` lo eraot ae g ego. L sdd`lhy rdjaiido`
tmls phgjd, dvdo ear tmasd wma grdot odjdssgrl-
hy egos ae strlp jh ubs lts g rdgh bhgst go` aod ae
tmd aohy trud ghh olcmt pgrty spats lo tawo.
6
Ear tmd Hg lds
Gbavd Zaid ae Blsmkdks bdst `gojdrs jgo
put Ahyiplj gtmhdtds ta smgid. Oat tmgt dl-
tmdr ae tmdsd grd erai Blsmkdk, ilo` (grjmlvd)
Rd` Hlcmt Cul`d
Fust ta strdss tmgt tmd Zpdktgtar ls go dqugh
appartuoltlds taurlst igcgzlod, wd wdot tatmd traubhd ae o`loc aut wmdrd hg`lds jgocdt tmdlr hh ae hgtd olcmt shdgzd gs wdhh. Gj-jar`loc ta aur saurjds gt Klocs Bgr(Cacah/Eruozd, www.klocs.kc, >3344>) tmdrd lsgt hdgst aod lostltutlao lo tmd jgpltgh tmgt mgsighd strlptdgsd.Smlhd tmd hajgh g`ilolstrgtar jauh` oat tdhhus wmdtmdr ar oat Kyrcyzstgos iast alhd`up stu`s `a tmd Euhh Iaoty ar oat, smd `l`jaori tmgt Hg`lds aohy dvdots tgkd phgjdgt hdgst twljd g iaotm go` tmgt dotry ear tmdeglrdr sdx ls erdd.
Pmgt ls lo jaotrgst ta go gvdrgcd olcmt gtKlocs, wmljm gjjar`loc ta aur igo F.R.R ls
goytmloc but jmdgp. Mdrds wmgt md mg` tasgy gbaut tmd spat6
Jurrdothy tmd mattdst odw jhub lo Blsmkdk,hhd` wltm tmd yauoc, lrrdspaoslbhd go` do-tlthd` jmlh`rdo ae Blsmkdks dhltd, yauhh bd surdta eddh aut jhgssd` lo goytmloc hdst tmgo yaurwdstdro odst. Pmd prljds grd mlcm but tmdiuslj go` gtiaspmdrd grd mgr` ta bdgt. Do-trgojd stgrts gt 7>>> jai go` iavds up eraitmdrd.
Eaa`-wlsd `lsmds grd prljy - 44> sais ear gsm go` idgt gssartl, but tmgt ls asdt by g:>% `lsjauot ao eaa` 7=.>>-2>.>> ao wddk`gys. Gs tmd Zpdktgtar wdot ta prdss avdr2,>>> pdaphd mg` hlkd` Klocs Egjdbaak pgcd- raucmhy7,=>> iard tmgo tmd ouibdr tmgtmgvd hlkd` aurs. Pmdy iust bd `aloc said-tmloc rlcmt!
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
24/28
Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk
20
PMD CTL@D
$ - Dxpdjt jmgocd erai :>> sai
$$ - Lo tmd rdclao ae :>>-4>> sai$$$ - Dxpdjt ta pgy iard tmgo 4>>
Jmlodsd
Mahhywaa`*(@ruzmbg/Zavldtskgyg)
Gs yau wauh` prabgbhy cudss, `djargtd` wltm
iavld pastdrs, pmatas ae jlodig ljaos go` g
buojm ae Gidrljgo kltsjm. Mahhywaa` ls papu-hgr wltm g yauocdr jraw` go` ls usughhy pgjkd`
erai il`-dvdoloc aowgr`s. G euo phgjd ear g edw
`rloks bdeard mdg`loc aee ta tmd jhubs. $
Idtra* (7::, Jmul)
Lo tmd liprdsslvd hajgtlao ae g earidr tmdgtrd, Idtra
rdiglos tmd prdilrd `rlokloc mahd ear dx-pgts. G
mlcm jdlhloc, g haoc bgr go` erldo`hy stg jaiphl-idot g caa` Pdx-Idx idou go` g wl`d sdhdjtlao
ae `rloks. Idtra ls aod ae tmd bdst bdts ear jgtjm-loc spartloc dvdots ao PU, ghtmaucm tmgoks ta tmd
ml`daushy hgtd kljka tlids ear Jmgiplaos Hdgcud
eaatbghh igtjmds, `aot jauot ao tmd stg wgltloc up
uohdss lts g blc aod. $$$
Idxljgo Jgotddog (Jmul 74=, odgr Bdtg Ztards)Gt lts bdst lo tmd suiidr gs saibrdra jhgssljs sdr-dog`d pd`dstrlgos `awo Jmul go` g ilxd` jraw`slts ao tmd parjm wgsmloc `awo tgjas wltm straocigrculrltg. Burrltas go` egfltgs grd iautm-wgtdrlocmdrd, go` haoc-mglrd` crloca typds wlhh bd chg` tamgvd tmdlr bddr sdrvd` wltm g hdiao, oat g strgw. $$
Ziaklds(@aodtskgyg/Fukddvg ^u`avklog)
Blsmkdks elrst go` aohy trg`ltlaogh Gidrljgobgrbdjud rdstgurgot sdrvds plt-siakd` spljy
bdde brlskdt, rlbs, park smauh`dr, hgib hdcs go`jmljkdo qugrtdrs. Sdhh wartm tmd trdk aut ta Ar-
ta-Zgl igrkdt lo tmd jaahdr mghe ae tmd jlty. Dofay
g rgocd ae jajktglhs go` splrlts, taa. $$
Hgo`gu (Igogs/Carky)
Egojy saidtmloc g hltthd `ldrdot1 Le yau jgo tah-
drgtd tmd grtmrltlj sdrvljd, Hgo`gu lsot g bg` spat
ear g park stdgk ar said atmdr Gridolgo juhlogry
caa`lds. Ghsa, trdgt yaursdhe ta said `djdot Grid-
olgo jaofgj wmlhst yaur mdrd, yauhh odvdr ca odgr
Blsmkdk jaofgj gcglo. Dvdr. $$
Bgrs go` Rdstgurgots
Gs tmd Zpdktgtlar ls stlhh `ustloc tmd jabwdbs alts smauh`drs go` rubbloc tmd shddp erai lts dyds
getdr lts ydgr-haoc doearjd` mlbdrogtlao, tmd cul`d
ls ydt ta cdt up ta euhh spdd`. Lo tmd idgotlid, tmls
gbrl`cd` cul`d smauh` kddp yau caloc uotlh sprloc.
Bd gwgrd tmgt ODS igy idgo odw ta tmd cul`d,rgtmdr tmgo tmd jgpltgh...
Gs dvdr, tmdrds g od hlod bdtwddo bgr go`
rdstgurgot lo Blsmkdk. ^hgjds iard sultgbhd ear
`rlokloc sdsslaos grdigrkd` wltm g stgr *
^rljd Cul`d(iglo jaursd, cgrolsm, bddr)
Gidrljgo/Idxljgo
Gridolgo
Jmujmugrg Macg (773, Jmul)
Sltm tmls Jmlodsd rdstgurgot, g hltthd aut ae tmd wgygo` rgrdhy vlsltd` by taurlsts, yau rdghhy eddh yau
grd cdttloc tmd rdgh `dgh. Rdqudst g(yaur awo
pdrsaogh Jmlodsd balhloc-pat) go` rgo`aihy sdhdjtg vgrldty ae uousugh Jmlodsd `dhljgjlds ta tmraw lo.
Bdwgrd, tmd spljy sgujd, ghtmaucm `dhljlaus, igy
hdgvd `dhljgtd staigjms lo said `lstrdss sdvdrgh
maurs hgtdr - jaosl dr tmd oat-spljy sgujd gs g sult-
gbhd ghtdrogtlvd $$
Eruozd
(Jmul/^rgv`g)Erdd sdidjmkl ls aod ae igoy rdgsaos ta jmdjk aut
tmls hlvdhy mgocaut, rgiid` wltm Jmlodsd gt huojm
go` `loodr tlid. Pmd idou ls dojyjhapd`lgj lo
sjapd, but le yaurd eddhloc bdwlh`drd`, fust palot
ta saidtmloc tgsty-haakloc ao g odlcmbaurloctgbhd hlkd wd `l`. $$
Jmlog Pawo ODS
(Arazbdkav/Paktacuh)
Apdo slojd hgst @djdibdr, tmls falot ls tmd rdgh
`dgh - twa idtrd tdrrgjatg wgrrlars dvdo edgturd lo
tmd `djar. ^rljldr tmgo tmd atmdr Blsmkdk Jmlodsd
spats but avdrwmdhilochy bdttdr. Sd grd maploc
tmgt tmdy x up go Dochlsm idou lo tlid ear sui-
idr, wmdo tmd aut`aar `djk wlhh bd ydt goatmdrsdhh. Ztrglcmt ta tmd tap ae tmd jhgss! $$$
Zmgahlo (Vmlbdk Vmahu/^raspdjt Ilr)
Pmls tl`y haakloc rdstgurgot stljks aut ear lts smddrrgocd ae arldotgh `lsmds go` lts hgrcd, rauo` tgbhds tmgt
igkd lt l dgh ear dxtdo`d` cgtmdrlocs. $$
(PdphLkhujmy vlhhgcd)
Saa`do jgblo hajgtd` by g rusmloc strdgi tmlrty ilo-
utds aut ae tawo. Pmd avdrprljd` eaa` ls iard tmgo
jaipdosgtd` ear by tmd jmlhhd` gtiaspmdrd go` wlh`
surrauo`locs. Matdh gjjaiia`gtlao ghsa gvglhgbhd.
Mdg` sautm ao Ghigtloskgyg go` kddp caloc. $$$
Bgrja`d* (Paktacuh/Zavldtskgyg, losl`d Iata)
G mlp lotdrlar go` go gar`gbhd buslodss huojm
mgvd ig`d Bgrja`d saidtmloc ae g matspat slojd
lt apdod` lo dgrhy 2>7>. Pmd phgjd jaids ta hled gt
olcmt wmdo : @Fs jaipdtd ear yaur gdjtlaos. $$
(^rgv`g/Kuhgtavg)
Bhao`dr ^ub ls tmd odw brdwdry-rdstgurgot ta try
aut. Jgvdroaus ydt jasy losl`d, tmdrds djdot bhuds
dvdry olcmt, hlvd ^rdildrsmlp Eaatbghh, Duracrub
go` g caa` sdhdjtlao ae ghds. Lo rdcgr` ta tmd hgttdrwd rdjaiido` @gtskl Zjmogdr. $$$
Bu``mg Bgr (Zavldtskgyg/Gkmuobgydvg)
Bu``mg bgr adrs g tgstd ae tmd Dgst losl`d g tgstdeuhhy
jaostrujtd` zdo hac jgblo. Pmd susml ls dxjdhhdot, go`
ear tmasd ao g bu`cdt, tmd stlr-ery oaa`hd lsmds igkd
go dxjdhhdot huojm. Rdjaiido`d ! $$$
Jgvd ODS (Carkavg, jhasd ta Zavldtskgyg)
Saw. Pa bd maodst wd grdot surd wmgt tmd eaa` ls
hlkd mdrd - wd spdot iast ae tmd dvdoloc supploc
iuhhd` wlod go` cgzloc gt tmd muo`rd`s ae waa`do
jrgods padtljghhy suspdo`d` erai tmd jdlhloc. Pmd
wlod ls `djdot, but tmd hgttdrr grd rdvahutlaogry by
Blsmkdks bgsd grtlstlj stgo`gr`s. $$
Jlty Iavld Bgr (By Ghg Paa Zqugrd ao Kldvskgyg)Iavlds aut`aar pgtla ls wdhh pasltlaod` ta pda-
phd-wgtjm ao Blsmkdks dqulvghdot ae tmd Jmgips-
Dhysdds. Ar`dr vdgh lo g pu-pgstry jgsloc wltm-
jrdgiy iusmraai sgujd - yau waot rdcrdt lt. $$$
Durapdgo / Lotdrogtlaogh
Jadd Mausd (:, Iaskavskgyg)
G prljy, but phdgsgot phgjd ta wmlhd gwgy go getdr-
oaao. Zlt lo tmd bgr grdg avdr g bddr ar hauocd lo tmd
glry oao-siakloc jaosdrvgtary. Gttdotlvd sdrvljd
go` g rderdsmloc sdhdjtlao ae sghg`s, g caa` phgjd
ear g hlcmt, mdghtmy huojm wmdo egt go` crdgsd grd
cdttloc yau `awo. $$$
^lotg ^ub* (Hdolo/Igogs)^lotg ^ub ls g brlcmt crddo hlcmtmausd ear tmd Zpdktg-
tar ao g mat `gy. Sltm g mast ae wdhh-kdpt ghds ao tgp,
tmd bdst crub mdrd ls pub crub wltm goy park ar hgib
`lsm rdjaiido`d`. $$
-
7/23/2019 The Spektator 21
25/28
www.tmdspdktgtar.ja.uk Edbrugry 2>7: Pmd Zpdktgtar
24Famooy ^ub * ODS(Paktacuh/Arazbgdvg)
G buzzloc jdotrghhy-hajgtd` jged papuhgr wltm g
iasthy yauocdr jhldotdhd, Faooy ^ub ls g caa`
phgjd ta hag` up ao aolao rlocs go` erdsm bddr bd-
eard iavloc ao ta g mukkg plpd hhd` wltm gbslotmd
hgtdr lo tmd dvdoloc. Hgst tlid wd jmdjkd`, tmd pub
mg` g rdsl`dot jgt, but slojd tmls jrdgturd sddis ta
rub said justaidrs up tmd wraoc wgy by tautloc
ear sjrgps.... $$$
Rassa ODS(Zmapakavg/Lvgoltsavg
Rassa idgos rd` lo Ltghlgo, go` tmls blstras `djar
ls hlkdhy ta igkd yau eddh hlkd yauvd stdppd` losl`d
go grtdry. Aojd swgipd` lo bhaa`-jahaurd` vdh-
vdt, mawdvdr, yau jgo ar`dr said tgsty erld` iaz-
zgrdhhg jmddsd bghhs go` g mghe-`djdot cauhgsm. G
bhgo` gherd`a pgstg go` tmd edjkhdss wgltloc stg
grd `rgwbgjks, but clvdo Rassa mgs aohy apdod`
rdjdothy lt ls prabgbhy wartm g smat. $$$
Zldrrg Jged ODS (Igogs 43)
G odw dxpgt egvaurltd go` wltm tmd Ztgrbujks-
stgo`gr` jgrgidh igjjmlgtas, tmd ta-`ld-ear Bdh-
clgo wgffds go` g iusmraai saup wmljm Zpdktg-
tarwrltdr Pmaigs Ahsao `dsjrlbds gs arcgsilj, lt
lsot `ljuht ta sdd wmy. Zlt wltm g craup ae igtds,
g hgptap ar tmd hgtdst japy ae Pmd Djaoailst go`
ligclod tmgt yau grd oat lo Blsmkdk. $$
(74, ^gohavg)
Pmd jaojrdtd iaostraslty ae tmd Russlgo Pmdgtrd jao-
jdghs aod ae Blsmkdks odst gttdipts gt g jasy bgsd-
idot bgr. Erldo`hy stg, g djdot idou go` g jahhdjtlao
ae ah` blts go` babs `djargtloc tmd wghhs igkd D`cgrs
go gttrgjtlvd ghtdrogtlvd ta tmd jltys iglostrdgi jges.
G bhuds bgo` phgys iast olcmts go` g plgolst g``s g ra-
igotlj gibldojd ao said Zuo`gy dvdolocs. $$
Bgrs, Rdstgurgots & Jhubs
Gaygig ( sais (>:72 47>3>3). Pdrlgkl jmljkdo, Ilsa saup, susml rahhs go` parklo clocdr sgujd grd ghh wdhh wartm g pmaod jghh. $$
Fgpgodsd
Kardgo
Kyuoc Bak Kuoc ODS (:>, Jmul), Uastak 4)Egilhy-ruo go` dxtrdidhy papuhgr giaoc g sighhjlrjhd ae dx-pgts, wma bdccd` us oat ta put lt lo mdrdear edgr ae ruloloc tmd sdjrdt - sarry cuys, tmd cgidls up. G sdgt gt tmd `ahhs mausd tgbhd ls g strljthysmadhdss dxpdrldojd go` jgo bd gwkwgr` ear tmd
haoc-hdccd`. $$
Jmaoc Cl Sao (774, Jmul), Uastak 4Gjrass tmd strddt erai Kyuoc Bak Kuoc, aur rdsl`dotKardgo tdhhs us tmls phgjd lsot bg` dltmdr. $$
Hdbgodsd
Rdclaogh/Jdotrgh Gslgo
HGzzurra (7>4, Lbrgliavg)Pmls ls g `dhlcmt, ghbdlt g prljy aod. Le tmd phgo ls tastljk ta Hdvgotlod trdgts tmdo HGzzurra mgs tmd euhhrgocd, but wd rdjaiido` `gbbhloc lo tmd sm gswdhh. Pmd crlhhd` traut, lo pgrtljuhgr, ls g wloodr. Gcaa` phgjd ta tgkd hgrcd pgrtlds. $$$
Bdlrut ODS (Zavldtskgyg/Id`dravg)Rdhajgtlao mgs ig`d Bdlrut iar gjjdsslbhd taBlsmkdks sautmdrodrs wltmaut gdjtloc tmd qughltyae tmd crub. Zlilhgr ta HGzzurra lo batm prljd go`idzzd, but sdrvljd g tg` sma``ldr.$$$
Lo`lgo
(Zavldtskgyg, appasltd tmd Mygtt)G vgrld` go` lotdrdstloc idou lojhu`loc od Lo`lgo
eaa` igkd tmls phgjd g rdgh trdgt. Ao il`wddk `gystmdrd grd ghsa sdvdrgh dxjdhhdot buslodss huojm dghsadrloc g saup, sghg`, iglo jaursd go` `dssdrt ear24>-:4> sai. G rdgh stgo` aut go` g Zpdktgtar eg-vaurltd! $$$
^lraca-Ua`klo (Kldv, 7>3)
Jhgssy rdstgurgot wltm g turo ae tmd 2>tm jdotury
gtiaspmdrd sdrvloc Russlgo spdjlghltlds. Mgvd yaur
tdg lo g clgot sgiavgr. $$$
Pgrgs Buhbg (Odgr tmd \uzmoly Uaratg ao Zavldtskgyg)
Hlkd ghh tmd Tkrglolgo rdstgurgots wdvd trld` lo
Blsmkdk, Pgrgs Buhbg sdrvds crdgt eaa`. Sd hlkd` tmd