the spektator issue 17
TRANSCRIPT
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 1/28
_p`h tdtkr ℗4= Fdy :544
Ykur fkltbcy muin` tk wbdt’s bdpp`lilm il dln drkuln Jisbh`h
^ B @
Z`stdurdlt Muin`^kurist Fdp ]bdt’s Kl. .
Ucus1
Dpkodcyps`1
Dgt`r tb`
_tkri`s grkf tb` _tiohs
Fissikl tk tb` Fksqu`
_dvilm Udrh Dtd-^urh
Cig` il tb` _`fipdcdtilsh Ukcymkl
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 2/28
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 3/28
Oklt`lts
^bis Fkltb
Kut & Djkut
B
@
_p`h tdtkr^b` _p`htdtkr is lkw klcil` dt www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
.ok.uh
Z`stdurdlts, Jdrs, OcujsDcc tb` j`st jdrs dln ocujs il tkwl.
Oity FdpNkl’t m`t ckst. :0
:7
::
>
]bdt’s Kl^b` pioh kg tb` `lt`rtdilf`lt cistilms.
^b` Muin`
^b` OdccKlo` b`drn, tb` Iscdfio odcc tk prdy`r is
gkr`v`r ilmrdil`n kl tb` f`fkry. N`llisH``l swdps `dmc` bult`rs gkr fu`zzils ds
b` tri`s tk fflln kut fkr` djkut tb` dzdldln tb` muys wbk silm it.
Gkous
L`ws dln Wi`ws]` wdlt`n tk j` d jit fkr` upj`dt witb
kur rkuln-up tbis fkltb, sk w`’v` mkl`
gkr pkst-rikt r`luf`rdtikl, tb` jrin`
hinldppilm n`jdt` dln prkjc`fs il tb`
ckodc pr`ss.
45
47
42
^b` _p`htdtkr Fdmdzil` is dvdicdjc` dt ckodtikls tbrkumbkut Jisbh`h, ilocunilm1 (^rdv`c Dm`loi`s) Dnv`ltur` _`cc`r, Dh-_di rdv`c, Odrcskl ]dmklcit, O`c`stidc Fkultdils, @oktkur, Mcdvtkur,Hyrmyz Oklo`pt,
Hyrmyz rdv`c, Fuzd, LkviLkfdn (Jdrs & Z`stdurdlts) Okwjky, Bkccywkkn, F`trk, L`w Ykrh Uizzd, Lk4, :x:, Jkuc`vdrn, Okst``bkus`, Nkhd, Gdtjky’s, Gkur _`dskls, Civ` Jdr, Ckulm` Jdr,F`ri, Ldvimdtkr, _tdry @nmdr’s W`rdlnd, Dnridtiok, Oyockl`, Nkco` Witd, _dltd Fdrid, Mkcn`l Jucc (Odsilks) @urkpd, Mkcn`l Nrdmkl, RK (Bkt`cs) Nkstuh, Bydtt, Mkcn`l Nrdmkl, Bkcindy, Dcpi-
list (@fjdssi`s dln Krmdlisdtikls) b` PL juicnilm, b` Df`riodl jds`, b` M`rfdl @fjdssy, b` Nutob Oklsucdt`, ODFU Dcd-tkk, LOOZ, b` Jisbh`h Kp`rd & Jdcc`t _koi`ty.
KL B@ OKW@Z1 b` _`fipdcdtilsh Ukcymkl’s fyst`ri`s
dr` y`t tk j` ulckoh`n (drobiv`)
_dvilm Udrh Dtd-^urhJisbh`h wds gkrf`rcy dfklm tb` tkp
tw`lty mr``l`st oiti`s il tb` P__Z. Lkw,
oity koidcs dln jusil`ss typ`s bdv` ul-
sorupuckus pcdls gkr tb` oity’s pdrhs dln
tr``s. ]b`l Dgtdlnic Akrkj`hkv gkuln kut
djkut kl` dtt`fpt tk ‒n`v`ckp’ d str`tob
kg Udrh Dtd- urh kl Dhbuljd`vd st, b`
j`mdl fkjicizilm tb` ckodc okffulity.
^b` _p`htdtkr Fdmdzil`
Gkuln`r1 ^kf ]`ccilms
Fdldmilm @nitkr1 Obris Ziohc`tkl
(`nitkrEtb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh)
_tdst writ`rs1 Zkj`rt Fdrhs (rfdrhsEtb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh), N`llis H``l
(n`llish``lEtb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh),Bkccy Fy`rs, @vdl Bdrris,
Udtrioh Jdrrkw, Udv`c Hrkpkthil, Dcio`Adlvril, _`rm`y Wysktshy
Mu`st Okltrijutkr1 Odcvil Ur``o`
Mu`st Drtist1 Uiok Ziohc`tkl
N`siml1 Dc`hd Ocdir`
Dnv`rtisilm Fdldm`r1 Irild Hdsyfkvd
(`fdic1 dnv`rtis`Etb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh)
^bis fkltb’s issu` is n`niodt`n tk kurmkkn gri`lns B dln @cis`
Fdrri`n il Istdljuc :?.50.44
www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
]dlt tk okltrijut` ds d gr``cdlo`
writ`r; Uc`ds` okltdot1`nitkrEtb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
_tkri`s grkf tb` _tiohs^b` _p`htdtkr bds j``l Kut & Djkut gkr
kv`r twk dln-d-bdcg y`drs lkw. ]` tdh`
d ckkh dt skf` kg tb` ilt`r`stilm gkch w`
bdv` f`t dcklm tb` wdy.
7
Dgt`r tb` Dpkodcyps`^kf ]`ccilms ilt`rvi`ws nkouf`ltdry-
fdh`r Dltbkly Jutts djkut d Hdzdhb
okffulity tbdt civ`s l`dr tb` nisjdln`n
_`fipdcdtilsh Ukcymkl - d klo` lktkrikus
_kvi`t dtkfio t`stilm gdoicity.
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 4/28
Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
> ^bis Fkltb
JI_BH@H, Fdy :4 (ZG@/ZC) - Dctbkumb jrin` hin-
ldppilm is koidccy d orif` il Hyrmyzstdl, g`wods`s r`dob tb` okurtrkkf Hyz Hkrmkl Ilstitut`,
dl Hyrmyz LMK tbdt odfpdimls tk `cifildt` tb`prdotio`).
_kf` :55 p`kpc` tkkh tk tb` str``ts il d
lkrtb`rl Hyrmyz prkvilo` `drci`r tbis w``h tkprkt`st tb` cklmstdlnilm prdotio` kg jrin` hin-
ldppilm.
^b` oustkf -- il wbiob silmc` ykulm f`lhinldp tb`ir jrin` kg obkio` dln pr`ssur` tb`f
tk dmr`` tk fdrridm` -- is lkt ulokffkl il Hyr-myzstdl.
Jut jrin` hinldppilm bds r`o`ltcy okf` ul-n`r sbdrp oritioisf il tb` O`ltrdc Dsidl okultry
dgt`r twk hinldpp`n jrin`s okffitt`n suioin`il d fdtt`r kg fkltbs.
^b` si t` kg tbis w``h’s rdccy, tb` lkrtb`rl Is-syh-Huc Urkvilo`, is bkf` tk tb` twk suioin` vio-
tifs -- W`l`rd Hdsyfdci`vd dln Lurzdt Hdcyhkvd,jktb :5-y`dr-kcn stun`lts.
^b` rdccy, nujj`n –_prilm witbkut ^b`f,‖wds krmdliz`n jy ckodc wkf`l’s LMKs dln ktb`r
dotivists dln b`cn il tb` tkwl kg H drdhkc. Nurilmtb` prkt`st pdrtioipdlts odcc`n kl dutbkriti`s
dln okffulity c`dn`rs tk put dl `ln tk tb` kcntrdnitikl.
Jrin` hinldppilm is koidccy d orifildc kg-g`lo` il Hyrmyzstdl, wb`r` tb` orifildc okn`
stipucdt`s d fdxifuf tbr``-y`dr priskl t`rf gkrjrin`-hinldppilm.
Il r`dcity, bkw`v`r, g`w ods`s r`dob tb`
okurtrkkf, dln tbks` wbk dr` tri`n gkr jrin`-hinldppilm usudccy wdch dwdy dgt`r pdyilm d
sfdcc ffll`.–Klo` jrin`-hinldppilm wds obdrdot`r-
istio fkstcy tk rurdc dr`ds, jut it bds j`okf`win`spr`dn `v`rywb`r`, ilocunilm tb` odpitdc,
Jisbh`h,‖ sdys Mdzjuju Jdjdydrkvd, gkuln`r kgHyz Hkrmkl Ilstitut`, d lklmkv`rlf`ltdc krmdl-
izdtikl tbdt odfpdimls tk `cifildt` tb` trdnitiklkg jrin`-hinldppilm il Hyrmyzstdl.
–Kur r`s`drob`s ilniodt` tbdt j`tw``l 72dln =0 p`ro`lt kg fdrridm`s il Hyrmyzstdl tdh`
pcdo` witb jrin` hinldppilm.‖Jdjdydrkvd sdys `oklkfio bdrnsbip is kl`
kg fdly r`dskls j`biln tb` r`o`lt ris` kg jrin`hinldppilm, ds fdly gdfici`s try tk dvkin pdyilm
nkwri`s dln w`nnilm `xp`ls`s. Jut it is jy lkf`dls tb` klcy fktivdtikl.
–It is `lokurdm`n jy pdr`lts kg tb` jkys,‖ Jd-jdydrkvd sdys. –Dln skf`tif`s, jkys dr` dgrdin
kg dshilm tb` mircs’ p`rfissikl. ^b`y tbilh it’s`dsi`r aust tk hinldp b`r, j`odus` tb`y dr` dgrdin
fdyj` sb` wicc r`gus`.–Dlktb`r r`dskl is tbdt `v`l ig tb`r` is d cdw,
it’s lkt j`ilm ifpc`f`lt`n. _ilo` tb` hinldp-
p`rs mk ulpulisb`n, jrin`-hinldppilm is bdp-p`lilm dmdil dln dmdil.‖
Bkw It’s Nkl`
Dookrnilm tk tb` trdnitikl, wb`l d Hyrmyz fdl,usudccy il bis tw`lti`s, wdlts tk m`t fdrri`n gkr
tb` fflrst tif`, b` piohs d jrin` dln stdrts tk dr-rdlm` b`r hinldppilm.
^b` fdl dln bis gri`lns s`iz` tb` ykulmwkfdl il str``ts, skf`tif`s usilm vikc`lo`,
Jrin` Hinldppilm1 d ^rdnitikl kr d Orif`;
dln gkroijcy nriv` b`r tk tb` odptkr’s gdficybkf`. ^b` r`st is c`gt tk g`fdc` r`cdtiv`s kg tb`
fdl, wbk try tk p`rsudn` tb` hinldpp`n wkf-dl tk fdrry b`r odptkr.
^b` wkfdl is put uln`r `lkrfkus pr`s-sur`, ilocunilm pbysiodc vikc`lo`, jut il tb`
fdakrity kg ods`s, tb` odptkr r`grdils grkf rdp`,
Jdjdydrkvd sdys.Ig tb` wkfdl fflldccy dmr``s tk fdrridm`, tb`
gdficy kg b`r pkt`ltidc busjdln puts d wbit` h`r-obi`g kl b`r b`dn, dln dshs b`r tk writ` d c`tt`r
tk b`r pdr`lts. ^b`y tdh` tb` c`tt`r tk tb` jrin`’sgdficy tk dsh tb`ir ndumbt`r’s bdln il fdrridm`
dln drrdlm` d quioh w`nnilm o`r`fkly.]bic` tb` mrkkf’s r`cdtiv`s tdh` pdrt il
–obkksilm‖ dln drrdlmilm tb` hinldppilm kgtb`ir gutur` ndumbt`r-il-cdw, tb` pkt`ltidc jrin`
dln b`r gdficy nk lkt usudccy hlkw tb` odptkrskr tb`ir ilt`ltikls ultic dgt`r tb` hinldppilm
tdh`s pcdo`.Fdly jrin`s gkcckw trdnitikl dln sifpcy do-
o`pt tb`ir gdt`. Jut skf` kg tb` fdrridm`s jkrlgrkf jrin`-hinldppilm gdcc dpdrt dln gkr skf`
-- cih` tb` twk ykulm stun`lts il Issyh-Huc -- tbisodl jrilm d trdmio `ln.
–_b` ]dsl’t Z`dny gkr Fdrridm` _k I Hin-ldpp`n B`r‖
Hdcyhkvd’s doqudiltdlo`, Pcdl, klo` dsh`nb`r ig sb` wdlt`n tk fdrry bif. Hdcyhkvd dln
b`r pdr`lts r`gus`n tb` fdrridm` prkpksdc jut
tb`y ninl’t pr`niot Pcdl wkucn lkt tdh` lk gkrdl dlsw`r.
Cdt` kl` `v`lilm il Lkv`fj`r :545, Hdcyh-kvd ‒s pdr`lts odf` bkf` grkf d nill`r pdrty
tk fflln tb`ir ndumbt`r bdn mkl` fissilm. Ndyscdt`r, tb`y gkuln kut tbdt Hdcyhkvd bds j``l
hinldpp`n jy Pcdl, wbk wds lkw dshilm tb`irp`rfissikl tk oklnuot d fdrridm` o`r`fkly.
^b` pdr`lts jrkumbt Hdcyhkvd jdoh bkf`.
Jut uln`r oklstdlt pr`ssur`s grkf r`cdtiv`s, Hd-cyhkvd dln b`r pdr`lts `v`ltudccy doo`pt`n tb`
fdrridm` prkpksdc. ^b` fdrridm` ninl’t cdst cklm - Hdcyhkvd
okffitt`n suioin` aust gkur fkltbs cdt`r.N`spit` tb` kutokf`, Pcdl s``s lktbilm
wrklm il bis dpprkdob tk fdrridm`.
–]` w`r` gri`lns witb Lurzdt gkr tbr`` y`drsj`gkr` kur fdrridm`. I wdlt`n tk fdrry b`r, jut
sb` dcwdys pkstpkl`n it. U`rbdps sb` wdsl’tr`dny,‖ Pcdl tkcn ZG@/ZC’s Hyrmyz _`rvio`.
Pcdl nk`sl’t bkcn bifs`cg r`spklsijc` gkr biswig`’s suioin`.
–]` civ`n dcrimbt, w` w`r` gri`lncy,‖ b` sdys.–^k tbis pkilt, I nkl’t uln`rstdln wbdt pkssijcy
okucn bdv` mkl` wrklm.‖Dutbkriti`s sdy tb`y bdv` cdulob`n d prkj`
iltk Hdcyhkvd’s ods` jut it is uloc`dr wb`tb`rPcdl wicc j` obdrm`n witb hinldppilm.
Krmdliz`rs kg tkndy’s rdccy il Hdrdhkc odcc`nkl dutbkriti`s tk `lgkro` `xistilm cdws tk pul-
isb f`l wbk kpt gkr hinldppilm ds d f`dls kgffllnilm d wig`.
Il d t`drguc dnnr`ss tk pdrtioipdlts, W`l`rdHdsyfdci`vd’s gdtb`r, Kh`l, sdin bis ndumbt`r’s
hinldppilm ruil`n bis gdficy’s cig`.I odcc kl ykulm f`l tk r`grdil grkf hinldp-
pilm, b` sdin. –I nkl’t wisb dly ykulm mir c tk okf-fit suioin` il tb` gutur`. Fy wig` ni`n sunn`lcy
fflv` y`drs dmk, dln tbdt’s wby fy ndumbt`r XW`l-
`rdV wds cih` d fktb`r tk fy ykulm`r hins.‖Djdz Ayrmdcj`hkv, d :5-y`dr-kcn fdl wbk
dcsk akil`n tb` rdccy, sdys lkt dcc Hyrmyz f`l sup-pkrt tb` hinldppilm trdnitikl.
It’s d wdy gkr ils`our` f`l tk m`t mircs, Ayr-mdcj`hkv sdys. –]bk usudccy hinldps d wkfdl;
Muys witb lk s`cg-oklffln`lo`8 wbk dr` dgrdintbdt d mirc nk`sl’t cih` bif.‖
–I wdlt tk fdrry il d lkrfdc wdy,‖ b` dnns.
Djkv` Jrin` hinldppilms dr` okffklpcdo` il Hyrmyzstdl’s r`mikls (Hyz Hkrmkl ilstitut`)
GDZDLMI_ LDAIJPCCDB
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 5/28
www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr
0^bis Fkltb
JI_BH@H, Fdy 4: (@urdsidL`t.krm) - Hyrmyz akur-ldcists okv`r dl dlti-Jdhiy`v rdccy il Fdrob :545.Gkcckwilm tb` kust`r kg gkrf`r Hyrmyz Ur`sin`lt
Hurfdlj`h Jdhiy`v, tb` Ktuljdy`vd mkv`rl-f`lt ocdifs tbdt tb` l`ws f`nid is lkw djc` tkkp`rdt` witb mr`dt`r gr``nkf ‟ d gr``nkf skf`kjs`rv`rs sdy is spdwlilm obduvilistio dln rdoiststkri`s il tb` Hyrmyz-cdlmudm` pr`ss.
Z`o`lt n`v`ckpf`lts il Hyrmyzstdl dr`nispcdyilm tb` ndrh sin` kg d gr`` pr`ss. _ilo`Hyrmyzstdl `fjdrh`n kl its `xp`rif`lt il pdr-cidf`ltdry-styc` n`fkordoy il :545, d g`w akur-ldcists bdv` fdn` okff`lndjc` `stkrts tk gucfflcctb` trdnitikldc wdtobnkm gulotikl kg d gr`` pr`ss.Jut suob jrimbt spkts dr` j`ilm fdrr`n jy d ris`il obduvilistio dln rdoist rb`tkrio il tb` Hyrmyz-cdlmudm` pr`ss, dcklm witb r`o`lt vikc`lt dttdohsdmdilst akurldcists.
Dnnr`ssilm akurldcists dt d Fdy ? o`c`jrd-tikl kg ]krcn Ur`ss Gr``nkf Ndy, Ur`sin`lt ZkzdKtuljdy`vd prdis`n b`r mkv`rlf`lt’s f`nidr`okrn1 –Gr``nkf kg tb` pr`ss is tb` fdil dobi`v`-f`lt kg tb` r`pujcio. Lk akurldcist bds j``lgkro`n tk `` tb` okultry, lk kl` bds j``l puttk tb` dnfilistrdtiv` mrilnstkl`, dln lk kl` bdsj``l dttdoh`n,‖ Ktuljdy`vd sdin, r`g`rrilm tk tb`p`rikn gkcckwilm tb` okccdps` kg Hurfdlj`h Jdhi-y`v’s dnfilistrdtikl il Dpric kg :545.
Dgt`r dssufilm pkw`r, tb` l`w mkv`rlf`ltcigt`n fkst Jdhiy`v-`rd okltrkcs kl jrkdnodstdln prilt f`nid kutc`ts, cdulob`n ilv`stimdtiklsiltk prikr djus`s, dln pc`nm`n tk iltrknuo` puj-
cio okltrkc kv`r tb` fdil mkv`rlf`lt rdnik dlnt`c`visikl jrkdnodstilm okfpdly. Cdst fkltb,fkr`kv`r, pdrcidf`lt dpprkv`n d r`skcutikl tbdtn`-orifildciz`n n`gdfdtikl dln cij`c. Dctbkumbtb` f`dsur` djkcisb`n adic t`rfs gkr tbks` gkulnmuicty kg cij`c, it nin dcckw gkr d st``p ilor`ds` ilffll`s dmdilst akurldcists il oivic dotikls.
N`spit` suob ifprkv`f`lts, kjs`rv`rs sdytb`r` dr` fdly r`dskls tk r`fdil oklo`rl`ndjkut Hyrmyzstdl’s f`nid `lvirklf`lt. Gkr kl`,
akurldcists dr` –dgrdin tk writ` kl pkcitiodc issu`sdln kgt`l `fpcky s`cg-o`lskrsbip,‖ Еcfds YsfdlHdc`t, dl Ksb-jds`n gr``cdlo` akurldcist, tkcn@urdsidL`t.krm. _`cg-o`lskrsbip j`odf` dl dout`issu` dgt`r skutb`rl Hyrmyzstdl wds oklsuf`n
jy vikc`lt `tblio ocdsb`s il Aul` :545, Hdc`t sdin.Bulnr`ns kg p`kpc`, fkstcy Pzj`hs, ni`n il tb`vikc`lo`.
Il r`o`lt w``hs, fdly Hyrmyz-cdlmudm` l`wskutc`ts bdv` xpckr`n tb` xtr`f` cifits kg nitk-ridc gr``nkf, pujcisbilm drtioc`s `xpr`ssilm obdu-vilistio dln x`lkpbkjio vi`ws. Il kl` ilstdlo` kgbdt`-sp``ob, d Fdy 44 okff`ltdry pujcisb`n jytb` Hyrmyz-cdlmudm` l`wspdp`r @c _kzy -- trdls-cdt`n iltk Zussidl jy tb` m`zitt`r.krm w`jsit`-- jcdf`n A`ws gkr fkst kg tb` okultry’s ourr`ltprkjc`fs.
–Gr``nkf kg `xpr`ssikl bds r`v`dc`n tb`ktb`r sin` kg tb` okil8 it turl`n kut tbdt akurldc-ists dr` cdohilm r`spklsijicity dln prkg`ssikldc
`tbios. Nu` tk ilor`ds`n okfp`titikl gkr sodlndc-kus fdt`ridcs, akurldcists dr` pujcisbilm ulv`ri-ffl`n gdots. F`nid kutc`ts dr` t``film witb dlti-_`fitio vi`ws, `sp`oidccy tb` Hyrmyz-cdlmudm`kl`s,‖ sdin Nildrd Ksburdbulkvd, tb` nir`otkr kg
JI_BH@H, Fdy 4> (@urdsidL`t.krm) - wk fkltbs
dgt`r pdssilm d n`ffloit-pcdmu`n junm`t, Hyr-myzstdl’s pdrcidf`lt bds df`ln`n it, r`dcckodt-ilm djkut $4:.9 ficcikl tk okfp`lsdt` tbks`wbk ckst r`cdtiv`s il cdst Aul`’s `tblio vikc`lo`il Ksb dln Adcdc-Djdn. ]bic` tb` `stkrt s``fsokff`lndjc` kl its gdo`, tb` pkcitiodc pr`ssur`surrkulnilm it dln tb` ifpc`f`ltdtikl prko`sstk okf` jktb rdis` nkujts djkut bkw gdir dlntrdlspdr`lt tb` pdykuts wicc j`.
Pln`r d n`or`` siml`n jy Urif` Filist`rDcfdzj`h Dtdfjdy`v, fdn` pujcio Fdy 45,gdfici`s kg Hyrmyzstdli oitiz`ls hicc`n il tb`ocdsb`s wicc r`o`iv` d kl`-tif` pdyf`lt kg 4ficcikl skfs (djkut $:4,055)8 gdfici`s kg tb`fissilm wicc dcsk okcc`ot d ficcikl skfs8 tbks`
wbk sustdil`n s`rikus jknicy ilauri`s -- ds n`-t`rfil`n jy `xp`rts il gkr`lsio f`nioil` -- wiccm`t 455,555 skfs8 dln tbks` wbk r`o`iv`n –c`ssmri`vkus jknicy bdrf‖ - nittk tb` koidc nidmlk-sis - wicc m`t 05,555 skfs.
B`r` dr` twk kg tb` jimm`st obdcc`lm`s tk dl`quitdjc` okfp`lsdtikl prko`ss1
Koidc r`okrn h``pilm dln gkr`lsio `xp`r-tis` dr` lktkrikuscy w`dh. Dgt`r tb` str``t rikts kgDpric :545, tb` n`dtb tkcc wds djkut kl`-fflgtb tb`lufj`r hicc`n il Aul` dln sticc kl` p`rskl r`m-ist`r`n ds n`dn - jy tb` stdt`’s gkr`lsio `xp`rts- turl`n kut tk j` dciv` dln w`cc dln nrivilm dodj il Zussid. ^b` fdl’s gdficy r`o`iv`n 4 fic-cikl skfs il okfp`lsdtikl, wbiob, jy tb` tif`
b` wds gkuln, bdn dcr`dny j``l sp`lt. ]bk ci`sjuri`n uln`r bis ldf` r`fdils ulhlkwl. Ds gkrtbks` hicc`n il Aul`, d g`w nkz`l jkni`s bdv`l’tj``l in`ltiffl`n oklocusiv`cy. Fkr`kv`r, nisor`p-dloi`s il jkny okults p`rsist. ]bic` tb` cdt`st
Hyrmyzstdl1 D Gr`` Ur`ss J`m`ts Bdt` _p``ob
Hyrmyzstdl tk Udy Ksb Wiotifs’ Gdfici`s1 Odl It J` Nkl` Gdircy;
tb` Okdcitikl gkr N`fkordoy dln Oivic _koi`ty, ilokff`lts odrri`n jy tb` :>.hm l`ws dm`loy klFdy ?.
–^b` f`nid odl s`rv` `vic purpks`s,‖ @nicJdisdckv, d Hyrmyz oivic skoi`ty dotivist dln Ktul-jdy`vd’s gkrf`r obi`g kg stdst, tkcn @urdsidL`t.krm.–^b`r` dr` fdly `xdfpc`s wb`l l`wspdp`rs dr``xdo`rjdtilm `xistilm pkcitiodc t`lsikls dln odst-ilm tblio filkriti`s ds `l`fi`s.‖
_kf` kg tb` Hyrmyz-cdlmudm` l`wspdp`rsokltdililm obduvilistio dln x`lkpbkjio oklt`ltdr` j`ilm prilt`n dt d pujcisbilm bkus` kp`r-dt`n jy tb` F`nid _uppkrt O`lt`r Gkulndtikl(F_OG). ^b` F_OG is d okff`roidc `ltity tbdtwds gkuln`n il :55?. Ilitidc gulnilm gkr tb` F_OGodf` grkf tb` P_ _tdt` N`pdrtf`lt. Dookrnilmtk tb` gkulndtikl’s w`jsit`, tb` F_OG’s _up`rvi-skry Okffitt`` is b`dn`n jy Fdrtil Odccdldl, d
f`fj`r kg tb` @urkp`dl Udrcidf`lt.Kl Dpric :9, tb` Urks`outkr M`l`rdc’s ko`
wdrl`n f`nid kutc`ts tk stkp pujcisbilm fdt`ridctbdt iloit`s ilt`r-`tblio dlifksity. Jut tb` bdt`-fflcc`n drtioc`s okltilu` tk dpp`dr. Fdly kjs`rv`rssusp`ot tbdt fuob kg tb` okltrkv`rsidc okv`rdm`is j`ilm `lokurdm`n dln guln`n jy pkcitioidlswitb dl `y` kl tbis gdcc’s pr`sin`ltidc `c`otikl.
@oklkfios fdy j` d jim pdrt kg tb` prkjc`f. ^b` prkcklm`n jkut kg pkcitiodc ilstdjicity tbdtj`mdl witb Jdhiy`v’s kust`r tkkh d tkcc kl fdly
f`nid kutc`ts, odusilm d pr`oipitkus nrkp il dnr`v`lu`. F`nid kutc`ts il skutb`rl Hyrmyzstdlw`r` `sp`oidccy bdrn bit, witb fkst `xp`ri`lo-ilm dpprkxifdt`cy d 05-p`ro`lt ckss il ilokf`.Ds tb`y strummc` tk r`okv`r, l`wspdp`rs dr` `s-p`oidccy vucl`rdjc` tk n``p-pkoh`t`n pkcitioidlsdln w`dctby `ltr`pr`l`urs, wbk odl kst`r fflldl-oidc r`ci`g il r`turl gkr n`sir`n okv`rdm`.
–It is lk s`or`t tbdt tb`s` ndys fkst f`nidkutc`ts r`pr`s`lt tb` ilt`r`sts kg pkw`rguc pkciti-oidls. I nkujt tbdt akurldcists wicc j` l`utrdc Xnur-ilm tb` `c`otikl odfpdimlV. ^b`y wicc n`g`ln tb`ilt`r`sts kg pkcitioidls wbk pdy tb`f,‖ sdin dl Ksb
akurldcist sp`dhilm kl oklnitikl kg dlklyfity.J`ykln tb` prkgusikl kg bdt`-sp``ob dln
odcufly il tb` pr`ss, s`v`rdc suspioikus dttdohsdmdilst akurldcists bdv` koourr`n il r`o`lt w``hs.Gkr ilstdlo`, Kl Fdy 4, Aycnyz J`hjd`vd, d okr-r`spkln`lt gkr Zussid’s Ilt`rgdx l`ws dm`loy, wdsdssduct`n il Ksb. _b` is oklvilo`n sb` wds lkttb` viotif kg d rdlnkf orifildc dot, jut wds il-t`ltikldccy tdrm`t`n j`odus` kg b`r prkg`ssikldcdotiviti`s.
DCI_B@Z HBDFINKW
LD^D_BD Y@GIFKW
r`pkrt`n mkv`rlf`lt `stifdt` put tb` n`dtb
tkcc dt >:=, dl ilt`rldtikldc stuny r`c`ds`n Fdy? put it dt >=5.]icc `tblio Hyrmyz dln `tblio Pzj`hs m`t
`qudc doo`ss tk okfp`lsdtikl; Dtdfjdy`v’s ili-tidc dmr``f`lt tk tb` pdykuts odf` dgt`r d sfdccjut vkoig`rkus prkt`st jy `tblio Hyrmyz gdfici`sjrdlnisbilm dlti-Pzj`h sckmdls. ^b` mrkup mktbimb-prkfflc` suppkrt grkf bis pkt`ltidc pkcitiodcrivdc, Dtd-Aurt pdrty c`dn`r Hdfobyj`h dsbi`v, dpdrcidf`lt n`puty hlkwl gkr bis Hyrmyz-o`ltriorb`tkrio dln oklsin`rdjc` ockut il tb` okultry’s`tbliodccy nivin`n skutb. ]itb pr`sin`ltidc `c`o-tikls aust fkltbs dwdy, ourryilm gdvkr dfklmskutb`rl`rs is h`y tk Dtdfjdy`v’s pkcitiodc df-jitikls.
Fkr` ifpkrtdltcy, r`cdtikls j`tw``l `tblioPzj`hs dln ckodc koidcs il tb` skutb r`fdiltkxio. Wdrikus rimbts mrkups bdv` sdin tbdt, silo`Aul`’s vikc`lo`, Pzj`hs bdv` bdn cifit`n doo`sstk skoidc s`rvio`s dln bdv` j``l obrkliodccyfistr`dt`n jy tb` austio` syst`f. D stdrh, r`o`lt`xdfpc` is oit`n il tb` ilt`rldtikldc stuny f`l-tikl`n djkv`, hlkwl ds tb` Hyrmyzstdl IlquiryOkffissikl (HIO) r`pkrt1 It gkuln tbdt Pzj`hsfdn` up => p`ro`lt kg tbks` hicc`n il Aul` jut=9 p`ro`lt kg tbks` obdrm`n witb orif`s r`cdt`ntk tb` vikc`lo`. ]icc tb` sdf` koidcs pdrty tk tb`fisodrridm` kg austio` j` il obdrm` kg bdlnilm kuttb` pdp`rwkrh l``n`n gkr okfp`lsdtikl;
@lsurilm tb` okfp`lsdtikl prko`ss is gdir
dln ifpdrtidc wicc j` tkumb. Dln oklsin`rilmtbdt tb` mkv`rlf`lt pusb`n tbrkumb tb` jicc tkfdh` pdyf`lts il tif` gkr Aul`’s kl`-y`dr dlli-v`rsdry, tb`r`’s r`dskl tk wkrry tbdt tbis tbkrlyprkjc`f mkt sbkrt sbrigt
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 6/28
Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
7 Kut & Djkut
BDN GIZ_^ _@@L tb` M`l`rdc mdzilm st`rlcykut kg d jiccjkdrn jy d fktkrwdy l`dr fybkus`. Lkw I wds sittilm il bis ko`, sippilmt`d.It wds dutufl dln Hyrmyzstdl wds pr`pdr-
ilm gkr pdrcidf`ltdry `c`otikls. ^w`lty-s`v`lpdrti`s w`r` odfpdimlilm gkr tb` okultry’s dtt`l-tikl, pcdst`rilm tb`fs`cv`s sbdf`c`sscy kltk jusstkps, cdfppksts dln, ig sp`oidccy usb, s`v`l-stkrydpdrtf`lt jckos. Dfinst d bkst kg skuln jit`s, kl`stuoh il fy filn gkr its sb``r sifpcioity1 –_trklm du-tbkrity - p`do`guc okultry.‖
It wds ds ig tbis pdrty bdn fiss`n d UZ trioh.]b`r` wds tb` r`g`r`lo` tk –tb` p`kpc`‖, tb` v`rs`grkf d jymkl` jdrn, tb` bkrs`s, fkultdils dlnwdt`rgdccs; Z`pcdoilm pkpucist ifdm`ry w`r` mrif-ckkhilm ficitdry f`l, cdp`cs djcdz` witb f`ndcs,j`dny y`s sodllilm pdss`rsjy.
–Db y`s, tb` `x-HMJ muys,‖ d akurldcist gri`ln kgfil` jri`g`n f`. –Lk-kl` hlkws fuob djkut tb`f.I nkl’t tbilh tb`y wicc m`t vkt`s. b`y’r` gdr tkk sodry.‖
–]` fdn` tb` HMJ piss il tb`ir pdlts,‖ tb` m`l-`rdc okrr`ot`n f`, wb`l I turl`n up dt bis pdrty BTtk dsh bif djkut bis odfpdiml pcdtgkrf. B` bdnj``l pdrt kg dl `cit` _kvi`t sp`oidc gkro`s ulit, b`tkcn f`, s`rvilm il Dgmbdlistdl, ^daihistdl dln gur-tb`r dffl`cn.
^b` bdjits kg s`rvio ni`n bdrn. ^b` m`l`rdcckulm`n il bis ko` il odfks dln drfy jkkts,wbic` sujkrnildt`s spkrtilm jucc`t prkkg v`sts pd-trkcc`n tb` okrrinkrs kutsin` bis ill`r sdlotuf.
–I j`ci`v` il krn`r,‖ b` sdin, –j`odus` tb` dct`rld-tiv` is obdks.‖ B` bdn s``l wbkc` okultri`s nisskcv`j`gkr` bis `y`s, b` dnn`n - it wdsl’t d pr`tty simbt.
Lkw, dgt`r d suff`r kg pkcitiodc turfkic wbiob bdnc`gt Hyrmyzstdl t``t`rilm kl tb` jrilh kg nisskcutikl,b` bdn n`oin`n tk gkrf d pdrty witb ktb`r cih`-filn`n ilnivinudcs8 f`l kg drfs dln bklkur.
^b` m`l`rdc bdn n`spis`n tb` kust n Jdhi vocdl, wbkf b` r`g`rr`n tk ds –pkcitiodccy dln fkr-
Idccy okrrupt‖, jut b` ninl’t odr` fuob gkr f``tilmsdln r`vkcutikls itb`r. –]` j`ci`v` il mivilm p`kpc`tb`ir nimlity jdoh, il fdhilm cdws f`dl skf`tbilmdmdil, il stkppilm tb` ruc` kg tb` fkj,‖ b` tkcn f`fflrfcy.
F``tilm tbis gkrf`r okffdlnk fdn` f`r`dciz` bkw rdniodccy fy kwl pkcitiodc j`ci`gs bdnobdlm`n silo` fkvilm tk Jisbh`h. Il dnkc`so`lo`,fy b`rk`s bdn j``l r`vkcutikldri`s8 utkpidls cih`Fdk Q`nklm dln Zkj`spi`rr`, wbk pculm`n tb`irldtikls iltk vikc`lt odtdocysfs, spkutilm sckmdlsds tb`y w`lt. Jut civilm il d okultry wb`r` vikc`ltodtdocysfs w`r` r`mucdr gdots kg cig`, dldroby bdnckst dcc its rkfdlo`. Hyrmyzstdl, it s``f`n, l``n`nd fflrf bdln - tb` m`l`rdc wds tb` fdl tk prkvin` it.
^b` Adickk Ldtikldcist
–]bdt dr` yku tdhilm piotur`s kg;‖]` w`r` il d pdrh il Jy`ckvknshky`, d sfdcc
prkviloidc tkwl twk bkurs grkf tb` odpitdc, wb`r`
w` bdn drriv`n tk ilt`rvi`w ckodc koidcs. D stdtu`kg C`lil wds okv`r`n il fkss, j`lob`s nkttilm tb`pdrh w`r` kv`rmrkwl witb w``ns, dln d ldrrkwoklor`t` wdchtbrkumb bdn r`c`lt`n, nisskcvilm iltk`drtb. Dcc kv`r tb` wkrcn bufdl s`ttc`f`lts w`r`r`dobilm kut iltk ldtur`, jut il Jy`ckvknshky`, tb`wicn`rl`ss wds fflmbtilm jdoh. Fy gri`ln wds odptur-ilm tb` fkf`lt witb bis odf`rd.
–I nkl’t hlkw wby yku’r` tdhilm pbktks,‖ tb`vkio` okltilu`n. –^b`r ’s lktbilm tk s`` b`r . ^b`pdrh is wicn, cih` tb` p`kpc` tbdt civ` l`dr it.‖
_b` wds il b`r sixti`s, il ldtikldc nr`ss witbmkcn`l t``tb. –]bk civ`s jy tb` pdrh;‖ w` dsh`n._b` ckw`r`n b`r vkio`. –Yku hlkw. Pzj`hs, Pimburs,Hyrmyz grkf Ksb.‖ _b` m`stur`n tk d l`imbjkurbkkntb` ktb`r sin` kg d oklor`t` wdcc. ^b` Ksb Hyrmyzw`r` pdrtioucdrcy pdilguc gkr b`r.
–^b`y odcc tb`fs`cv`s Hyrmyz,‖ sb` biss`n jit-t`rcy, ds twk v`ic`n wkf`l wdch`n pdst us, obdttilmdwdy tk kl` dlktb`r. –Jut ckkh dt tb`f!‖
OBZI_ & UIOK ZIOHC@^KL
_tiohs
_tkri`s
Civilm dln writilm il Hyrmyzstdl `lsur`s
yku f``t d niv`rs` rdlm` kg tbkumbt-
prkvkhilm gkchs. ]bic` skf` kg tb` wkrcn’s
fkr` uliqu` obdrdot`rs bdv` dcr`dny
jrimbt`l`n tb` _p`htdtkr’s twk tkl` pdm`s
witb tb`ir pr`s`lo`, ktb`rs aust fiss`n tb`
out. ^bis fkltb w` ckkh skf` kg tb` p`k-pc` tbdt bdv` ilspir`n, tkuob`n kr sodrr`n
us kv`r tb` y`drs.
grkf tb`
Djkv` Bkw fdly `y`s bdtb Hyrmyzstdl;
(dcc iccustrdtikls jy Uiok Ziohc`tkl)
^bis pdm` dln l`xt Obdrdot`r sh`tob`s il krn`r
kg dpp`drdlo`. Obdrdot`rs dr` fflotikldc Dly
sificdrity tk r`dc p`kpc` is pur`cy okiloin`ltdc
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 7/28
www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr
=Kut & Djkut
–D r`dc Hyrmyz wkfdl rin`s kp`l-gdo`n, tk-wdrns tb` sul.‖ _b` ifdmil`n b`rs`cg kl d st``n dssb` spkh . –Ckkh dt tb` wdy I nr`ss,‖ sb` sdin auji-cdltcy. –I’f grkf dcds, d pur` Hyrmyz!‖
_b` tdch`n s`ltif`ltdccy kg tb` cdlnsodp`s kg
b`r bkf`cdln, wb`r` yurts sfkh`n dln r`dc Hyrmyz- tb` fkst bkspitdjc` ldtikl il tb` wkrcn - dcwdysw`cokf`n kutsin`rs. Jut skkl tb` tirdn` ordlh`nup dmdil.
Fkn`rl Hyrmyz mircs –nr`ss`n cih` wkf`l grkfFksokw‖, sb` sdin, ykulm f`l grkf tb` _kutbwkr` –stilhy j`drns‖, dln Issyh-Huc ldtiv`s w`r` dcsksouf, bdvilm ilsuct`n b`r nurilm d r`o`lt bkcindyil tb` r`mikl.
^b` wkfdl h`pt rdfjcilm, r`o nilm iltk odri-odtur`. Dl iln`oipb`rdjc` wkrcn wds ocksilm il klb`r, dln sb` bdn lktbilm tk fflmbt it kst witb, `xo`ptd vdmu` in`d kg wbdt d Hyrmyz sbkucn ckkh cih` dlnwbdt pdrt kg tb` okultry tb`y sbkucn civ` il. _b`ninl’t r`dn tb` Turdl, sb` oklg`ss`n, dln C`lil wdsodh`n il jrykpbyt`s lkw. _b` ckkh`n tkwdrns tb`stdtu` witb d fixtur` kg cklmilm dln r`s`ltf`lt.
–@v`rykl` `cs` hioh`n tb` Zussidls kut,‖ sb`jc`dt`n. –Dln w` c`t tb`f stdy. Yku’cc l`v`r fflln dgri`lnci`r p`kpc` tbdl us.‖ Jut –us‖ wds m`ttilm sfdcc-`r dcc tb` tif`.
Hyrmyzstdl’s Hkr`dls
^b`r w`r` tbr`` Hkr`dls, kl` grkf daihistdl, kl`grkf Pzj`histdl dln kl` grkf Hyrmyzstdl. ^b`ybdn f`t dob ktb`r il d stdt` mucdm.
Ploc` Fdx dln uloc` Mrimkriy bdn drriv`n dtuloc` Wdlyd’s bkus` gkr d surpris` o`c`jrdtikl ‟ bis75tb jirtbndy pdrty. Wdlyd’s wig , Fdrid, bdn ilvit`ntb`f s`or`tcy. Wdlyd wds kv`rwb`cf`n witb vknhddln fktikl.
Fdrid dln Wdlyd bdn j``l mr`dt gri`lns grkftb` j`millilm kg fy tif` il Hyrmyzstdl. Fdrid wdsd gdltdstio okkh dln dcwdys bdn skf`tbilm n`ci-oikus gkr f` tk try wb`l I odf` kv`r. Wdlyd obdil-
sfkh`n, pcdy`n skcitdir` dln tdch`n gkktjdcc. Ktb`rHkr`dls tb`y iltrknuo`n f` tk w`r` dcwdys civ`cydln ilt`r`stilm. Mrimi dln Fdx w`r` lk `xo`ptikls.
@dob Hkr`dl jkdst`n kg tb` mckri`s kg tb`okultri`s _tdcil bdn n`pkrt`n tb`ir pdr`lts tk. –Pz-
j`histdl is d niouct pcdo` lkw, jut it wds dcwdystb` mr`dt`st O`ltrdc Dsidl r`pujcio,‖ drmu`n Mrimkriy.Fdx sdin tbdt ^daihs w`r` d uliqu` p`kpc`, tb` j`stil tb` wkrcn, jdr Hkr`dls kg okurs`. –_k wby nin ykujktb fkv` tk Hyrmyzstdl il tb` `ln;‖ n`fdln`nWdlyd. It wds dcc m`ttilm d jit oklgusilm.
Ds d ykulm limbt mr`w kcn, uloc` Wdlyd wds puttk j`n, dln Mrimkriy pdss`n kut uprimbt. I wds c`gttdchilm tk Fdx, tb` Hkr`dl grkf ^daihistdl. B` bdnc`gt tb` okultry wb`l oivic wdr j`mdl il tb` 4995s,b` sdin, ffllm`rilm d tdttkk kl bis bdln. Okfpdr`n tktbdt, v`l tb` mucdm wds dsy.
B` spkh` Zussidl dln ^daih, jut lk Hkr`dl. Idsh`n bif ig tb`r` wds dlytbilm jdr jckkn okll`ot-ilm bif tk bis nistdlt bkf`cdln.
–I sticc `dt nkms, ig tbdt’s wbdt yku f`dl,‖ b` r`-pci`n mruy. brkumb tb` jcur kg vknhd I sdw Fdridwilo . Fdly kg Hyrmyzstdl’s dpprkxifdt`cy =5,555Hkr`dls bdn cklm dmk s`v`r`n tbis oucildry cilh tktb`ir dlo`stkrs.
–Fy j`st gri`ln, Fdcih, wds Fuscif,‖ Fdx okl-tilu`n. –Kl` limbt b` dln bis wig` odf` rkuln tkfy bkus`. I okkh`n tb`f nkm skup - tb`y ckv`n it.Jut wb`l Fdcih gkuln kut wbdt it wds, b` `w iltkd rdm . ]` ninl’t sp`dh gkr fkltbs.‖ B` pdus`n tknrdil bis vknhd mcdss.
–^b`l, kl` ndy, bis wig` pbkl`n f` up. _b`j`mm`n f` tk fdh` p`do`, ilvit` tb`f rkuln dlnokkh up nkm skup dmdil. _b` sdin w`’n dcc pr`t`ln
w` ninl’t hlkw wbdt it wds.‖ ^b` xpcdldtikl, b` sdin, wds sifpc`. Fdcih bdnsust`r`n grkf okumbilm fflts bis wbkc` cig`. b`y bdntri`n `v`rytbilm8 trdnitikldc r`f`ni`s, prdy`rs, sbd-fdls, tb` wkrhs. Jut tb` klcy tbilm tbdt our`n bisokumb wds Fdx’s nkm skup. –Nkm skup is fkr` us`-
guc tbdl r`cimikl,‖ Fdx oklocun`n. –I’cc `dt it ultic tb`ndy I ni .‖
^b` Zimbts N`g`ln`r
–I’v` aust wdch`n kut kg d pr`sin`ltidc rkuln tdjc ,‖
sb` dllkulo`n ds sb` stkrf`n iltk tb` rkkf. –]`tkcn tb`f, ig okrrupt stkkm`s grkf tb` gkrf`r dn-filistrdtikl dr` mkilm tk j` pr`s`lt, tb`l w` wkl’tj .‖
^b` wkfdl I wds ilt`rvi`wilm tbdt dgt`rlkklwds d v`t`rdl kg Hyrmyz oivic skoi`ty, tb` sokurm`kg ldtikldc mkv`rlf`lts grkf tb` Dhdy`v `rd kl-wdrns. Jdoh wb`l tb`y w`r` f`fj`rs kg tb` kppk-sitikl, sb` bdn put dcc b`r gkrfindjc` `l`rmi`s iltkn`g`lnilm jim ldf`s suob ds Zksd Ktuljdy`vd dlnKfurj`h ^`h`jdy`v. Lkw tb`y w`r` il pkw`r, sb`wds rdicilm dmdilst tb`f.
–^bdt’s aust bkw it is il tbis okultry,‖ sb` okltil-u`n. –^b` kuts j`okf` tb` ils dln stdrt j`bdvilmcih` tb` kl`s j`gkr` tb`f.‖ _tkppilm tk tdh` d rdr`
jr`dtb, sb` j`mdl dl ilv`otiv` dmdilst tb` pdrcid-f`lt. –]` LMKs bdn bkp`n gkr d fkr` oklstruotiv`r`cdtiklsbip witb cdwfdh`rs tbis tif` rkuln,‖ sb`sdin. –Jut s``ilm tb` typ` kg tbilms tb`y’r` nisouss-ilm il tb`r`, w` uln`rstdln it’s mkilm tk j` fflv`fkr` y`drs kg us t`ccilm tb`f1 ‒Yku’r` wrklm, yku’r`wrklm, yku’r` wrklm!’‖
Mkv`rlf`lt wds d juccy, dln it wds b`r akj tkjuccy jdoh. Il gdot, sb` wds dcfkst d mkv`rlf`lt ilb`rs`cg, witb ilt`r`sts rdlmilm grkf `nuodtikl pkci-oy tk oklnitikls il f`ltdc b`dctb ilstitutikls, tr`dt-f`lt kg filkriti`s dln priskl`rs’ rimbts.
Il :55=, nurilm d prkt`st dmdilst tb` Jdhi`v dn-filistrdtikl, sb` bdn obdil`n b`rs`cg tk tb` mdt`s kgtb` ]bit` Bkus`, il bkrrkr dt tb` gkrf`r pr`sin`lt’socdfpnkwl kl p`rskldc dln pkcitiodc gr``nkfs.
–^b` pkcio` ninl’t hlkw wbdt tk nk witb f` ‟I wds dcr`dny il odptivity,‖ sb` cdumb`n. –@v`ltudccytb`y gkuln d wdy kg tdhilm kl` pdir kg bdlnousts kstf` dln puttilm dlktb`r pdir kl.‖
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 8/28
Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
2
–I sp`lt tw`cv` bkurs il d o`cc, tdchilm tk tb` adic-`r, d mkkn fdl. B` tkcn f` b` okucnl’t uln`rstdlnwby illko`lt oitiz`ls w`r` j`ilm tbrkwl il priskldln orifildcs w`r` sittilm il tb` ]bit` Bkus .‖
–I dsh`n bif ig b` bdn `v`r tdh`l d jrij ,‖ sb`okltilu`n. –B` sdin b` bdn klo`, jut tbdt b` bdn
j``l sk nismust`n witb bifs`cg, b` r`pkrt`n it tktb` nuty ko`r - tb` nuty ko`r ninl’t v`l odr`!‖
–I uln`rstkkn tb`l tbdt tb` fflrst jdrri`r tkobdlm` is ilnist`r`lo ,‖ tb` dotivist surfis`n. –^bdt’swby I t`cc fy okcc`dmu`s1 Gimbtilm okrruptikl dln il-
austio is cih` fflmbtilm d nilksdur. Yku bdv` tk hioh it dg`w tif`s j`gkr` it v`l lktio`s yku!‖
^b` Nrulh`l Bkus`fdt`
–]kl’t yku bdv` fflgty fkr` mrdfs witb f`;‖ ^urndcipc`dn`n.
Dcokbkcisf is `ln`fio il fdly pdrts kg tb`gkrf`r _kvi`t Plikl, sk I wds dcwdys cih`cy tk try it dtskf` pkilt. Bdvilm d dtfdt` wbk cit`rdccy gkro`nf` tk nrilh vknhd dt `v`ry kppkrtulity ninl’t b`cp
f` il r`sistilm its ilsipin cur`. –^b` Zussidls g****n`v`rytbilm up,‖ scurr`n ^urndci il d gdficidr r`grdil, dsw` cil`n up vknhd sbkts. It wds t`l ‒k’ ockoh il tb`fkrlilm dln I wds rullilm cdt` gkr fy cdlmudm`c`sskl.
–J`gkr` tb` Zussidls drriv`n, w` Hyrmyz civ`n ilbdrfkly tkm`tb`r. ]` nrdlh hyfyz dln jkzk dlnw`r` oklt`lt aust j`ilm tipsy. Jut tb`y iltrknuo`nus tk vknhd. Wknhd isl’t cih` tbks` nrilhs. Wknhd isn`struotiv`.‖
I bdn witl`ss`n its n`struotikl fflrst bdln. ^ur-ndci, d bult`r grkf tb` fkultdilkus prkvilo` kgLdryl, wds d fklst`r dgt`r d g`w rkulns kg bis gd-vkurit` tippc`. Z`o`lt ul`fpckyf`lt bdn nriv`lbif tk tb` nrilh. I bdn c`ss kg dl `xous`, jut bis
koodsikldc obdrisfd dln fkr` gr`qu`lt t`ln`loytkwdrns pbysiodc iltifindtikl wds fktivdtikl`lkumb. I cih`n bis nrulh`l stkri`s, tkk.
–Jdoh wb`l I us`n tk wkrh gkr Zysp`h...‖ Jut b`bdn l`v`r hlkwl Zysp`h, d n`o`ds`n Hyrmyz orif`
ckrn. –I us`n tk **** tbis Gr`lob wkfdl...‖ Jut b`bdn l`v`r f`t dly Gr`lob wkf`l `itb`r. –I us`n tkj` djc` tk sokr` grkf tb` okrl`r dm, `v`ry tif`,‖b` sdin. Jut d gkktjdccilm shicc cih` tbis wkucn bdv`fdn` bif wkrtb ficcikls kg pkulns tk d riob ocuj,dln bdvilm pcdy`n witb bif, I hl`w b` wds us`c`ss.
Y`t b` okucn nrilh. Kl` ndy, bkf` dckl`, ^ur-ndci mkt sk wr`oh`n tbdt b` jkumbt d sb``p’s b`dngrkf tb` jdzddr, s`t it tk jkic, dln prkfptcy pdss`nkut. Gkr tb` l`xt fflv` ndys tb` dt wr`dh`n kg jurltfuttkl. _ic`ltcy, w` sdt `dtilm sb``p’s jrdil kltkdst wdsb`n jdoh witb vknhd sbkts gkr jr`dhgdst.
Jut tb` gul bdn tk `ln skf`wb`r`. Fy civ`rwds j`millilm tk r`s`lt ^urndci’s ifpksitikls. Dni`t oklsistilm fkstcy kg our`n fflsb dln sfkh`nob``s` ‟ _kvi`t nrilhilm doo`sskri`s ‟ wds wr`dh-ilm bdvko kl fy stkfdob. Fy cig` wds j`millilmtk firrkr bis.
Cuohicy, tb` prkjc`f skcv`n its`cg. Kl` Grindy, ^urndci w`lt witb d gri`ln tk tb` fksqu`. B` r`-turl`n d nist`r`lt fdl. b` gkcckwilm w``h, ds ig jy
nivil` r`wdrn, b` gkuln d l`w akj ifpkrtilm sordpf`tdc grkf Obild.
D s`cg-rimbt`kus wkrsbipp`r r`pcdo`n d wdr-jcilm dcokbkcio kv`rlimbt. B` tbr`w d sdusdm` Ibdn jkumbt grkf tb` sbkp kut kg tb` wilnkw.–Yku hlkw, yku ]`st`rl`rs bdv` mkt d l`rv`,‖ b`tkcn f`, pkst-r`bdjicitdtikl. –Okfilm tk kur okul-try dln fdhilm mkkn Fuscifs nrilh vknhd dln `dtpkrh. Yku sbkucn j` dsbdf`n kg ykurs`cg.‖ It wdstif` tk fflln d l`w dt dmdil.
^b` Z`oyoc`rs
B` sdt kl d fdh`sbigt j`lob witb bis wig` dln doimdr`tt`, dtkp d pcdt`du kg bkus`bkcn wdst`. Il dputrin gkr`mrkuln, d tdic prktrun`n grkf d jkx okl-
tdililm c`gtkv`r odh`. It j`cklm`n tk d rdt.–]`cokf` tk tb` oity nufp!‖ akh`n @clur. ^b`
rdts b`r` mkt jimm`r `v`ry y`dr, b` dnn`n. _k nintb` nufp its`cg. Jisbh`h’s mkrknshdyd svdchd wdslktkrikus ds dl `lvirklf`ltdc bdzdrn ‟ dl `x-
pdlnilm cdlnfflcc tbdt wds rdpincy or``pilm tkwdrnstb` oity. D ckodc cdh` bdn dcr`dny j``l n`strky`n jymrkuln s``p grkf tb` sit`. Cdy`rs kg pcdstio jdmsdln jkttc`s or`dt`n d fili-mr``lbkus` `st`ot jytrdppilm b`dt grkf tb` sul, odusilm tb` nufp’sob`fiodc juch tk sfkh` dln sfkucn`r. Guf`s rks`
up iltk tb` shy grkf its fdss il tkxio okcufls.Jut tb` nufp dcsk g`n v`rfil, jirns kg pr`y
dln `v`l p`kpc`. @clur dln bis wig` Luradld, `ok-lkfio fimrdlts grkf tb` _kutb, bdn j``l civilmdln wkrhilm tb`r` ds sodv`lm`rs gkr t`l y`drs, s`cc-ilm nisodrn`n pcdstio dln ocktb`s tk tb` oity’s jd-zddrs gkr rkumbcy $45 d ndy. ^b`y s`lt tb` fkl`yjdoh tk tb`ir gdficy `v`ry w``h, jut bdn fiss`nkut kl fuob kg tb`ir kstsprilm’s obicnbkkn.
–Kg okurs` it’s bdrn j`ilm dwdy. Jut tb`y civ`witb tb`ir mrdlnfktb`r dln mrdlngdtb`r. ^b`y mktk d lio` sobkkc, tb`y bdv` fkl`y gkr gkkn dlnocktb`s,‖ @clur sdin. –Yku m`t us`n tk it.‖
D p`rskl okucn m`t us`n tk dcfkst dlytbilmwkrhilm dt tb` nufp. It wds dl ulgkrmivilm, stdrh,
Ndrwilidl wkrcn. ^b` ykulm f`l wbk okcc`ot`nf`tdc dln `c`otrios tb`r` n`g`ln`n t`rritkry witbjrut` gkro`. _odv`lm`rs bdn j``l hlkwl tk nisdp-p`dr dgt`r vikc`lt drmuf`lts ‟ tb`r` wds d trkv` kgr`gus` gkr tb`f tk nisdpp`dr iltk.
–It’s lkt sdg` gkr ykulm mircs,‖ @clur sdin, ilniodt-ilm d fflgt``l y`dr-kcn sodv`lm`r tb`y bdn dnkpt`ngkr tb` w``h. –B`r gdtb`r bds prkjc`fs sk w` dr`ckkhilm dgt`r b`r. Yku s``, skf`tbilm strdlm` isbdpp`lilm dt tb` nufp. ^b` p`kpc` dr` m`ttilmfkr` dmmr`ssiv` `v`ry ndy.‖
Dsh`n djkut tb` pkcio`, b` cdumb`n ru`guccy.–^b`y nkl’t okf` nkwl b`r` ‟ wby wkucn tb`y;Yku dnfitt`n ykurs`cg8 yku okucn bdrncy fflln d tdxitk tdh` yku!‖
–Lk,‖ tb` sodv`lm`r simb`n, sbdhilm bis b`dnds b` stujj`n kut bis oimdr`tt` kl tb` r`fldlts kgd t`c`visikl. –]b`r` tb` nufp j`mils, tb` mkv`rl-f`lt `lns.‖
^b`y w r` civilm il d stdt` kg ldtur .
Kut & Djkut
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 9/28
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 10/28
Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
45 Kut & Djkut
OKPCN B@DZ I^ grkf fy dpdrtf`lt d g`w
tif`s d ndy. It odf` tk f` il tb` ndrhl`ss
kg fkrlilm dln tb` ndrhl`ss kg limbt. ]b`l
I b`drn it, I wkucn kp`l fy wilnkws dlntb` skulns wkucn fflcc tb` rkkf. D fdl wds
silmilm. It wds strdlm` dln ldsdc, cih` d jdmpip`,
dln tb` lkt`s wkucn rdr`cy stdy il kl` pcdo` gkr
cklm, sbigtilm up dln nkwl tb` sodc` witb d pcdil-
tiv` r`stc`ssl`ss. @v`ry ndy it wds tb` sdf`, dln
I c`drl`n its rbytbfs cih` d gdvkrit` pk`f. It gkc-
ckw`n f` drkuln tkwl, pc`dnilm tk f` dt tb`
jdzddr dln tb` okrl`r odgé. It wds il d cdlmudm` I
okucnl’t uln`rstdln, jut skf` wkrns w`r` gdfic-
idr. – Dccdbu Dhjdr ,‖ tb` fdl sdlm, – Dccdbu Dhjdr.‖
Mkn is mr`dt, b` wdlt`n f` tk hlkw. B` wds odcc-
ilm f` tk bis fksqu` gkr prdy`r.
I ninl’t tbilh Mkn wds mr`dt ‟ I tbkumbt b`
wds d gdirytdc`. ^b` stdrhl`ss kg bis tb`f` sklm,
tbkumb, c`gt f` odptivdt`n, dln fy ouriksity
pusb`n f` tk c`drl fkr`, ig lkt djkut sdvilm fy
skuc tb`l djkut tb` silm`r dln tb` sklm.
^b` o`ltrdc fksqu` kg Jisbh`h wds nkwl tb`
str``t grkf f`, surrkuln`n jy sin`wdch stdccs dln
f`l w`drilm shuccodps. Dt tb`ir stdccs, tb` f`l
w`r` bdwhilm d pdlkpcy kg Iscdfio pdrdpb`rldcid1
dfuc`ts gkr r`dr vi`w firrkrs, prdy`r pdfpbc`ts,
bkcy wdt`r grkf F`ood, dln pcdstio-wrdpp`n
stiohs ‟ fiswdhs - us`n jy skf` Fuscifs tk oc`dl
tb`ir t``tb. Dt tb` grklt mdt`s, wkf`l b`cn kut
tb`ir bdlns il n`stitutikl, s``hilm obdrity. I kg-
g`r`n kl` d okil dln ckkh`n dt fy trdlscdtkr @rt-
djycny witb b`sitdtikl. _k nk w` aust mk il; ]kl’t
tb`y lktio` tb` b`dtb`l; Aust mk, b` sdin, `v`ry-tbilm wicc j` ffll`.
Grkf dorkss tb` okurtydrn d sfdcc fdl il
rkj`s j`ohkl`n us gkrwdrn. D gucc-mrkwl j`drn
wds nrdp`n dorkss bis adw cil` dln t``tb sbkt kut
dt gully dlmc`s. ^b`y w`r` drrdlm`n il d sfic`.
– Dssdcdf Dcc`ihuf‖ b` sdin il mr``tilm. I nin ds I
bdn c`drl`n dln r`pci`n jdohwdrns ‟ – Dcc`ihuf
Dssdcdf!‖ ^b` fdl wds ldf`n _uc`ifdl, dln b`wds d fuccdb. @rtdjycny j`mdl `xpcdililm fy visit
tk bif, jut b` wds stkpp`n djruptcy il fin-s`l-
t`lo`. _uc`ifdl turl`n tk f` dln sdin skf`tbilm.
–B` wdlts yku tk r`oit` d prdy`r gkr bif,‖ fy trdls-
cdtkr `xpcdil`n. _ur`, I sdin, wby lkt. _k _uc`ifdl
sdin d g`w wkrns il Drdjio dln I r`p`dt`n, g``cilm
tb` strdlm` skulns nrip kv`r fy tklmu`. ]` w`lt
tbrkumb d g`w cil`s cih` tbis dln tb`l fy ilitidtikl
wds okfpc`t`. ^b` fuccdb bdln`n f` d strilm kg
prdy`r j`dns, us`n gkr r`oitilm tb` lil`ty-lil`
ldf`s kg Dccdb. –D migt,‖ b` sdin.
J`gkr` I okucn dsh bif wbdt I bdn aust r`oit`n,
_uc`ifdl cdulob`n iltk d s`rfkl. –Mkn is mr`dt!‖
b` sdin. –Mkn is v`rytbilm. b` dppc`s, tb` c`dv`s,
tb` tr``s. ^b`r` is lktbilm jut Mkn.‖ It s``f`n
j`dutiguc tk f` tbdt `v`rytbilm drkuln bif b`cn
suob nivil` simlifflodlo`. I wisb`n I g`ct it tkk. B`
w`lt kl, dln @rtdjycny nin bis j`st tk trdlscdt`.
–]by nk`s ykur bdir mrkw cklm, jut ykur `y`cdsb-
`s nkl’t;‖ I ckkh`n dt fy trdlscdtkr dln tb`l tb`
fuccdb, tb` fuccdb dln tb`l fy trdlscdtkr. @rtdj-
ycny sbrumm`n dln tb` fuccdb ninl’t `cdjkrdt` -
tb`r` wkucn j` lk dlsw`r tk tb` rinnc`. Fdl bif-
s`cg bdn fyst`ri`s, I suppks` b` wds sdyilm, tbdt
klcy Mkn okucn `xpcdil. I ifdmil`n fy `y`cdsb`s,
kv`rmrkwl, odsodnilm nkwl tk fy tk`s.
_uc`ifdl nir`ot`n us dorkss tb` okurtydrn tk
tb` ifdf’s ko`, wb`r` w` tkkh kst kur sbk`s
dln `lt`r`n. Dlktb`r fdl il d j`drn dln shucc-odp sdt dt d n`sh, mudrnilm d b`dvy wkkn`l nkkr.
]` wkucn bdv` tk wdit. Ktb`r p`kpc` kw`n il,
dshilm gkr dppkiltf`lts, dln @rtdjycny wbis-
p`r`n tb`ir r`qu`sts tk f` tk f`. Fkstcy, p`kpc`
^b` fu`zzil’s tbrkdty ilvitdtikl tk prdy r
odl skf`tif`s skuln d tdn kut kg pcdo` il
Jisbh`h, d pkst-_kvi`t odpitdc witb fkr` od-
silks tbdl bkcy pcdo`s. Gkr fdly j`ci`v`rs,
bkw`v`r, tb` oity’s o`ltrdc fksqu` is d v`ri-
tdjc` fdml`t, dln tb` dzdl, tb` sklm kg cig`
its`cg. ^b` _p`htdtkr ’s N`llis H``l b`dns
tkwdrns Jisbh`h’s lkisi`st fildr`t il s`drob
kg tb` fdl j`biln tb` odcc.
Odcc^b`
N@LLI_ H@@L
I
Djkv` D fildr`t dt Jisbh`h’s o`ltrdc fksqu`
(Fkshkvshdyd/Mkmkc). Il tb` `rd kg pkw`rguc
sp`dh`r syst`fs tb` dzdl is sulm grkf tb` if-
df’s wditilm rkkf, jut nurilm tb` jcdohkuts
kg tb` Jdhi`v `rd, tb` fildr`t sdw quit` d ckt
kg dotikl (dcc pbktks N`llis H``l)
Djkv` Zimbt Aisdl kl fu`zzil nuty
Gdr Zimbt M`la`j`h tb` fuccdb tdh`s dzdlodccilm il bis strin`. –Ig yku hlkw bkw tk sdy
d prdy`r, yku hlkw bkw tk silm dzdl,‖ b` sdin
L`xt Udm` Oustkf fdn` Itdcidl b``cs cil` up
l`xt tk gdh` dnninds sl`dh`rs. Dcc g``t dr`
`qudc il tb` `y`s kg Dccdb.
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 11/28
www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr
44Kut & Djkut
okf` b`r` gkr b`dcilm, b` sdin, b`dcilm gkr dio-
tikls witbkut our`s. Dcokbkcisf wds tb` jimm`st
prkjc`f. Oklv`ltikldc dv`lu`s prkvin`n cittc`
suoo`ss ‟ r`bdj ocilios b`r` wkucn miv` yku nrumsdln ti` yku tk d j`n. _k p`kpc` odf` dln dsh`n
gkr prdy`r. D fuccdb wkucn okf` tk ykur bkus`
s`v`l ndys il d rkw dln r`dn tb` Turdl tk tb`
diot`n, fy trdlscdtkr t`stiffl`n.
D ckt kg pdr`lts wkucn tdh` tb`ir obicnr`l
b`r`, tkk, ig tb`y w`r` sioh. ^b`r` wds d j`ci`g
dfklmst tb` Hyrmyz tbdt d sioh obicn fdy j` dg-
iot`n witb d ours` - tbdt bis –ldf` is tkk strklm
gkr bif.‖ O`rtdil ldf`s
bdn pkw`r, @rtdjycny
okltilu`n il d busb`n
vkio`, dln skf` hins
w`r` tkk w`dh tk j`dr
tb` jurn`l. G`w pdr-
`lts, gkr xdfpc`, wkucnldf` tb`ir hin Fdlds,
dgt`r tb` win`cy-wkr-
sbipp`n ldtikldc b`rk
kg Hyrmyzstdl, j`odus`
it wds tkk cih`cy tb` hin wkucn m`t sioh dln ni`.
Ig d hin nin m`t sioh, tb` pdr`lts wkucn tdh` bif
b`r` dln dsh tb` fuccdb gkr d ldf`-obdlm`. B`
wkucn sdy d prdy`r dln mrdlt bif d l`w ldf`.
^b`y sticc fimbt odcc tb` hin Fdlds, jut j`gkr` tb`
`y`s kg mkn b` wds dcr`dny skf`jkny nist`r`lt.
Dgt`r t`l filut`s kg wditilm-rkkf wbisp`r-
ilm, w` w`r` usb`r`n il tk tb` ko` kg tb` ifdf.
B` sbkkh fy bdln dln kst`r`n f` d s`dt, m`lu-
il`cy pc`ds`n tk s`` d gkr`iml`r. ]` tkcn bif fystkry ‟ bkw I civ`n nkwl tb` str``t, bkw I b`drn
tb` odcc, bkw I wdlt`n tk f``t tb` silm`r. B`
lknn`n dln tkcn us it wds pkssijc`. ^b`l, witb-
kut prkfptilm, b` w`lt iltk d s`rfkl, aust cih`
_uc`ifdl. –Iscdf is tb` r`cimikl kg jrktb`rbkkn,‖
b` sdin, –tb` r`cimikl kg Dccdb. b` r`cimikl kg hiln-
l`ss. ^b` r`cimikl kg pur`l`ss dln bdrfkly.‖ I
wkucn lkn j`tw``l r`v`cdtikls, dln b` wkucnsdy –Dbbb‖ witb uln`rstdlnilm, j`gkr` fkvilm kl
tk bis l`xt pkilt. B` wds obdrisfdtio, dln wkucn
us` fy ldf` gr`qu`ltcy cih` I wds dl kcn gri`ln.
–Iscdf is tb` r`cimikl kg gr``nkf, N`llis. Yku odl
j`ci`v` il it kr lkt. It is up tk yku.‖
]` dsh`n bif tk t`cc us fkr` djkut tb` odcc
tk prdy`r. It wds sulm jy d fdl odcc`n d fu’dnnil,
kr fu`zzil. Giv` tif`s d ndy b` wkucn silm kut
il Drdjio, gkr tb` fflrst
fdl tk fdh` tb` odcc
odcc`n it tbis wdy. Mkn
is mr`dt, b` wkucn sdy,
dln I df tb` witl`ss tk
bis mr`dtl`ss. Fubdf-
fdn is tb` cdst f`s-s`lm`r kg Mkn. Okf`
tk prdy`r. Okf` tk wkr-
sbip. –]by;‖ tb` ifdf
dsh`n rb`tkriodccy. –Il
tb` Turdl, it sdys prdyilm h``ps yku dwdy grkf
sil. Okf` tk bdppil`ss.‖
^b` ifdf okucn klcy c`otur` gkr sk cklm. B`
wds d jusy fdl, sk b` pdss`n us kltk dlktb`r
fuccdb. M`la`j`h c`n us iltk d cklm bdcc okdt`n il
odrp`ts, dln w` sdt nkwl witb c`ms orkss`n tk okl-
tilu` kur nidckmu`. ^b` odcc tk prdy`r, b` tkcn us, is
odcc`n dzdl. ^b`r` dr` fflv` prdy`rs d ndy, dln `dob
kl` is s`t tk d o`rtdil tif`, n`t`rfil`n witb pr`oi-
sikl jy d odc`lnriodc obdrt. ^b` fflrst kl` is j`gkr`ndwl, tb` s`okln kl` dt finndy, wb`l tb` sul
r`dob`s its bimb`st pkilt8 tb` tbirn il tb` `v`lilm,
wb`l ykur sbdnkw is twio` ykur b`imbt, dln tb`
gkurtb odcc is dt tb` r`nl`ss kg suls`t.
‒Bis vkio` rdlm kut kv`r jckohs.Bulnr`ns kg `drs wkucn b`dr bisodcc. D tru` Fuscif, b` bdn tkcn us,
wkucn stkp dlytbilm tb`y w`r`nkilm dln cist`l. b`l tb`y wkucnokf`, dln tb`y wkucn prdy’
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 12/28
Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
4: Kut & Djkut
tbilm.‖ _kf`tbilm wds ilsin` bif tbdt mdv` bif
tb` vkio` kg Jicdc, skf` skrt kg nivil` ilspirdtikl
tbdt c`dlt bis vkio` j`duty. ^b`r` w`r` lil` ktb`rfuccdbs dt tb` fksqu` wbk s`rv`n ds fu`zzils,
dln tb`y wkrh`n il sbigt pdtt`rls. ^b`y bdn dcc
c`drl`n tb` odcc dt tb` fdnrdssdb, dcklm witb sorip-
tur` dln sk gkrtb. It wds pdrt kg jdsio trdililm.
M`la`j`h tkcn us tb` dzdl gkr tb` dgt`rlkklprdy`r wkucn j` odcc`n il dl bkur, sk w` tkkh kst
gkr culob dln odf` jdoh d jit `drcy, `dm`r tk s``
it sulm up ocks`. ]bic` w` wdit`n, w` wdtob`n ds
tb` fuccdbs nin tb`ir ktb`r nuti`s, s``ilm visitkrs
dln r`dnilm tb`f prdy`rs witb d jizdrr` ilt`lsity.
^b`y wkucn obdlt Drdjio il d skucguc nrkl` dln
spcit up tb` v`rs`s witb gkro`guc wbistc`s, jckw-
ilm tb` mkkn mrdo` kg tb` Turdl kltk tb` gdo`s kg
tb`ir oci`lts. It skuln`n cih` d kur`tt`’s tio, kr cih`
tb`y w`r` pkss`ss`n.
Dlktb`r skuc il tb` rkkf s``f`n tk j`
pkss`ss`n jy skf`tbilm fkr` silist`r. D pdc`-
gdo`n mirc rdl il oiroc`s dln sor`df`n, sor`df`n
tbdt sb` wds dgrdin kg b`r fktb`r. ^b` fkf bdnjrkumbt b`r b`r` j`odus` tb` mirc wds sioh, dln
sb` wkucnl’t m`t j`tt`r. It wds oc`dr tb` mirc wds
f`ltdccy icc. _b` rkoh`n jdoh dln gkrtb dln ori`n,
okumbilm dln spittilm kut tb` sdf` gkro`guc wbis-
tc`s, wbic` tb` fuccdb odcf`n b`r skgtcy witb prdy`r.
–Zdhbfdt ,‖ sb` sdin, –Zdhbfdt .‖ ^bdlh yku. Cdt`r,
sb` rdl ulokltrkccdjcy drkuln tb` okurtydrn witb dgrimbt`lilm cifp. B`r fktb`r wds ups`t8 tb` prdy`rs
bdnl’t wkrh`n. _b` mr`w ifpdti`lt dln wbdoh`n
b`r n`fkl-pkss`ss`n ndumbt`r witb d purs`.
^b` tif` gkr prdy r bdn okf`. I bdn ifdmil`n
us ocifjilm tb` tdcc fildr`t dln wdtobilm kur fu-
`zzil silm kut kv`r tb` oity, jut tb` dm` kg tb` fdl-
pkw`r`n odcc wds bistkry b`r`. M`la`j`h bdn tkcn
f` tb`y klcy nin tbdt wb`l tb`r` wds lk `c`otrio-
ity, gkr lkw tb`y bdn ckunsp`dh`rs. Il tb` ifdfs’
wditilm rkkf, Adisdl, tb` fu`zzil gkr tb` ndy,
kp`l`n up d jkx kl tb` wdcc dln tkkh kut d fiork-
pbkl`. B` turl`n tkwdrns F`ood, wbiob f`dlt b`
gdo`n d okuob dln d wdcc. J`sin`s us, tb`s` ulil-
spirilm kja`ots wkucn j` bis iff`nidt` duni`lo`.
]b`l tb` dzdl stdrt`n up tbkumb, bis vkio` rdlmkut kv`r jckohs dln jckohs. Bulnr`ns kg drs wkucn
b`dr bis odcc. D tru` Fuscif, b` bdn tkcn us, wkucn
stkp dlytbilm tb`y w`r` nkilm dln cist`l. ^b`l
tb`y wkucn okf`, dln tb`y wkucn prdy.
Adisdl bdn priskl tdttkks kl bis bdlns dln b`
sdlm cih` d wkuln`n skuc. Bis `y`s w`r` ocks`n
dln b` b`cn d ffllm`r il bis `dr, sk b` okucn b`dr bis
tbrkdt buf il bis b`dn. ^b` odcc skuln`n fkr` sil-
o`r`, fkr` r`dc, witbkut tb` ckunsp`dh`rs’ r`v`rj.
^bis is bkw it wkucn skuln wb`l Jicdc sdlm it. Aust
tb` fdl, dln bis vkio`, dln bis t`stdf`lt 1
Dccdbu Dhjdr
Dsb-bdn dl cd icdbd iccd ccdb/ Dsb-bdnu dlld
Fuĭdffdndl rdsucuccdb/ Bdyyd ‒dcd-sdcdbb/ Bdyyd‒dcd ‒c-gdcdb /DccĄbu dhjdr/ Cd icdbd iccdccdb...
Mkn is mr`dt, b` sdlm, okf` tk prdy`r. Okf`
tk wkrsbip. B` sdlm, dln it wds j`dutiguc, dln
tb`y odf`.
^b` fflgtb dln fflldc prdy`r, b` sdin, is dl bkur dln
d bdcg cdt`r, il tb` ndrhl`ss kg limbt. ^b` fkrlilm
prdy`r is fkst gdvkr`n jy Dccdb, gkr klcy tb` guccygditbguc wdh` gkr bif grkf tb`ir sc``pilm. ^bis `drcy
jirn dzdl bds d sp`oidc dnn`lnuf1 –Urdy`r is j`tt`r
tbdl sc``p.‖
^b` fflrst fdl `v r tk sbkut tb` dzdl, M`la`j`h
tkcn us, wds dl Dgriodl fdl ldf`n Jicdc, d okf-
pdlikl kg Fubdffdn’s. B` sdlm it ckuncy dln
j`dutiguccy, jut tb` ktb`rs il tb` l`imbjkrbkkn
w`r` a`dckus. Ig b` okucn nk it, wby okucnl’t tb`y;
_k kl` fdl rks` `drcy kl` ndy gkr tb` fflrst dzdl
dln sbkut`n iltk tb` jcdohl`ss kg tb` ndwl. B`
sbkut`n dln sbkut`n, jut tb` sul r`gus`n tk ris`.
Klcy dgt`r Jicdc tkkh tk tb` fildr`t dln sdlm tb`
odcc bifs`cg wkucn tb` sul okf` kut kg binilm.
Jicdc is silo` r`f`fj`r`n ds tb` mkngdtb`r kg dcc
fu`zzils, tb` pdtrkl sdilt kg prdy`r odccilm. ^b` fuccdb okltilu`n, rdohilm bis jrdil gkr
fkr` fu`zzil fytbkckmy. Kl Aunmf`lt Ndy, b`
sdin, tb` l`ohs kg tb` wkrcn’s fu`zzils wicc mrkw
cklm, sk tbdt tb`y dr` tdcc`r tbdl dcc tb` r`st. It is
tb`ir l`oh, b` s``f`n tk j` sdyilm, tbdt syfjkc-
iz`s tb`ir mr`dtl`ss, gkr it is grkf tbis l`oh tbdt
okf`s gkrtb tb` bimb`st prdis`s kg Mkn. Dln kl
tbis ndy, b` w`lt kl, dlyjkny il tb` vioility kg
tb`ir odcc wicc j` sdg` grkf fdrdunilm n`fkls.
^b` oiroufg`r`lo` kg tb` sklm wkucn prkvin` d
sdg` bdv`l, d jc`ss`n spdo` il tb` bdlns kg Mkn.
I dsh`n M`la`j`h bkw b` c`drl`n tk silm tb`
odcc, jut b` sbrumm`n kst fy qu`stikl cih` I wds
dshilm bkw b` c`drl`n tk sp`dh. Ig yku hlkw bkwtk sdy d prdy`r, b` sdin, yku hlkw bkw tk silm dzdl.
^b` odcc is f`ckniodccy okfpc`x dln tb` sbigtilm
f`cisfd wkucn s``f tk fdh` it t`obliodccy ni-
ouct. Y`t kur fuccdb nisdmr``n1 –It’s lkt d niouct
‒Klcy dgt`r Jicdc tkkh tk tb`fildr`t dln sdlm tb` odcc bifs`cgwkucn tb` sul okf` kut kg binilm.Jicdc is silo` r`f`fj`r`n ds tb`mkngdtb`r kg dcc fu`zzils, tb` pd-trkl sdilt kg prdy`r odccilm’
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 13/28
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 14/28
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 15/28
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 16/28
Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
47 Gkous
Il dnnitikl tk j`ilm kl` kg tb` j`stpcdo`s il Jisbh`h tk cks` ykur culob kl
d G`rris wb``c, Udrh Dtd-^urh is bkf` tkd surprisilmcy jrkdn drrdy kg wicncig`._k, wb`l Jisbh`h ckodcs gkuln kut tbdttb` pdrh’s tr``s w`r` m`ttilm obkpp`nnkwl tk fdh` wdy gkr nujikus oklor`t`n`v`ckpf`lts, tb`y sprdlm iltk dotikl.Odcvil Ur``o` r`pkrts kl bkw dotivisf,skoidc f`nid dln tb` Urks`outkr M`l`rdcsdv`n tb` ndy.
^ _^DZ^@N ]I^B D UBKL@ ODCC. D gri`ln
rdlm Dgtdlnic Akrkj`hkv tk jri`g bif kl
skf` ulusudc dotivity il d sfdcc s`otikl kgUdrh Dtd-^urh, ckodt`n il tb` _kutb O`ltrdc
s`otikl kg Jisbh`h, aust kst Dhbuljdy`vd
str``t. Ldf`n dgt`r tb` gkuln`r kg fkn`rl ^ur-
h`y, H`fdc Dtd-^urh, tb` pdrh is d cdrm` wkkn`n
`xpdls` witb sbdn`n wdchwdys, d s`otikl kg
odrlivdc-styc` rin`s, d stdtu` kg Dtd-^urh, d fklu-
f`lt tk tb` Hyrmyz ficitdry wbk ni`n il tb` _k-
vi`t wdr il Dgmbdlistdl, dln d lktdjcy uln`v`c-
kp`n t`rritkry str`tobilm w`stwdrns. ^bis scio`
kg wicn`rl`ss witbil tb` pdrh cifits r`pr`s`lts d
sfdcc zkl` kg wicncig` wb`r` n``r okf` tk mrdz`,
jirns silm, dln d bkst kg trdnitikldccy lkl-urjdl
or`dtur`s r`fdil r`cdtiv`cy ulnisturj`n. Pltic
r`o`ltcy.
^b` pbkl` odc c dc`rt`n Akrkj`hkv tk tb` gdot
tbdt p`kpc` bdn j``l jurlilm dln outtilm nkwl
tr``s il tb` w`st`rl s`otikl. Akrkj`hkv bdn j``l
suoo`ssguc il obdcc`lmilm dl `drci`r dtt`fpt dt
icc`mdc juicnilm kl skf` pdrhcdln s`t dsin` gkr
d obicnr`l’s spkrts dr`d `cs`wb`r` il Jisbh`h il
:559. Bis dotivisf il tbdt ilstdlo` pr`v`lt`n d
bimb-ris` dpdrtf`lt juicnilm grkf `f`rmilm il
d pdrh dr`d us`n jy tb` l`imbjkrbkkn’s ykutb,
dln `drl`n Akrkj`hkv d r`putdtikl ds skf`kl`
odpdjc` kg sdvilm mr``l j`ct grkf tb` rutbc`ss
dnvdlo` kg oklor`t`. (N`tdics kg tbdt odfpdiml
dr` kl Gdo`jkkh, okltdot tb` _p`htdtkr gkr cilh).
^wk y`drs nkwl tb` cil`, d fkr` fdakr pdrh il
Jisbh`h wds j`ilm tbr`dt`l`n.
Akrkj`hkv j`mdl bis krmdlizdtikldc wkrh.
Psilm Gdo`jkkh dln ktb`r skoidc f`nid, b` mdtb-
`r`n d mrkup kg p`kpc` wbk w`r` oklo`rl`n
djkut tb` pdrh dln krmdliz`n d oc`dl-up `stkrt il
tb` w`st`rl s`otikl tbdt ilocun`n tb` r`pcdltilm
kg tr``s wb`r`v`r wkkncdln bdn j``l n`strky`n.
B` rdis`n fkl`y grkf ilnivinudcs, gkulndtikls,
dln ktb`r skuro`s tk juy sdpcilms tk pcdlt. ^b`l,
kl Fdrob 42, :544, wbic` tb`r` wds sticc slkw kl
tb` mrkuln, d mrkup kg vkcult``rs mdtb`r`n tk
oc`dl up trdsb dln n`jris dln pcdlt l`w tr``s.
Dcc tbis dotivity `drl`n tb` odfpdiml dtt`ltikl
grkf tb` ckodc pr`ss, wbk odf` dln tkkh pbktks,
r`pkrtilm kl tb` situdtikl dt tb` pdrh.@v`ry w``h`ln gkr djkut d fkltb, Akrkj`-
hkv dln vkcult``rs bdv` j``l f``tilm kl _dt-
urndys tk try dln jrilm dtt`ltikl tk pcdll`rs’ `g-
gkrts tk n`strky tb` ultrdff`c`n j`duty il tb`
ODCWIL UZ@@O@
Dtd-^urh _dvilmUdrh
w`st`rl s`otikl kg tb` pdrh.
Dookrnilm tk d Fdrob drtioc` tbdt dpp`dr`n
kl tb` w`jsit` kg ckodc l`ws dm`loy, :>.hm,–Hyrmyz fkl`yjdms put tb`ir `y`s kl tb` pdrhs
X...V il tb` oity. Fucti-y`dr oklig`r dln n`oinukus
tr``s kg Dtd-^urh Udrh w`r` out. Z`stdurdlts,
privdt` r`sin`lo`s dln fucti-stkry juicnilms tk
dpp`dr il tb`ir pcdo`. Icc`mdc oklstruotikl issu`s
w`r` rdis`n fdly tif`s, jut dcwdys r`fdil`n
bdlmilm il tb` dir.‖
^b`s` cdln n`dcs il tb` w`st`rl s`otikl dcsk
turl`n kut tk bdv` j``l nkl` kst tb` r`okrn
dln uln`r tb` tdjc`. ^b`r` dr` `stifdt`s tbdt
kut kg :5,555 tr``s tbdt `xist`n il :555, l`drcy
4?,555 tr``s bdv` j``l out nkwl.
Kl Dpric 4>, :544, ckodc f`nid il Jisbh`h
r`pkrt`n tbdt tb` Urks`outkr M`l`rdc’s Ko` kg
Hyrmyzstdl bdn cdulob`n dl ilv`stimdtikl iltk
tb` icc`mdc dssimlf`lt kg Udrh Dtd-^urh’s w`st-
`rl s`otikl tk ilnivinudcs dln okrpkrdt` mrkups
il vikcdtikl kg `xistilm cdws mkv`rlilm pdrhcdln
us`. ^b` Urks`outkr M`l`rdc wds r`pkrt`n tk
bdv` ilitidt`n orifildc dotikls dmdilst koidcs
il tb` Jisbh`h Fdykr’s Ko` gkr vikcdtikl kg twk
s`otikls kg tb` orifildc okn`. ^b` pr`ss r`c`ds`
grkf tb` Urks`outkr M`l`rdc’s ko` ilniodt`n
tbdt tb`y bdn kp`l`n d ods` nu` tk –dcdrfs‖
rdis`n il tb` f`nid djkut tb` situdtikl il tb`
w`st`rl s`otikl kg Udrh Dtd-^urh.
Jy us` kg Gdo`jkkh dln ktb`r sit`s, dln jy
dc`rtilm tb` ckodc pr`ss dln t`c`visikl, it s``fs
tbdt tbis 44.? b`otdr` dr`d kg pdrhcdln fdy bdv`
j``l sdv`n grkf gurtb`r ndfdm`. L`v`rtb`c`ss,
wkrh kl r`bdjicitdtilm tb` dr`d okltilu`s witb
sujjktlihi (okffuldc wkrh ndys) dllkulo`n
vid tb` _dv` Udrh Dtd-^urh nisoussikl jkdrn kl
Gdo`jkkh.
Nurilm d r`o`lt visit tk tb` dr`d tb` dutbkr
kg tbis pi`o` odl oklfflrf simls kg l`w mrkwtb
kg sdpcilms pcdlt`n il Fdrob. ^b` _UD t`df’s
nivisikl kg cdjkur s``f`n tk j` `st`otiv`, tkk.
]bicst kl` jdln kg vkcult``rs pcdlt`n fkr`
tr``s il tb` dr`d, ktb`rs pioh`n up pcdstio jkt-
tc`s, oups, kcn spkrts skohs, dln pcdstio jdms. It
s``fs tbdt d okfjildtikl kg d fkjic` pbkl`,
skoidc f`nid, dln dl dc`rt`n ckodc pr`ss dln rd-nik odl b`cp fkjiciz` strdt`mio vkcultdry dotikl
il Jisbh`h. Lkt quit` dl –Drdj _prilm‖ tb`l, jut
d Jisbh`h sprilm witb `lkumb okffulity spirit
tk pr`s`rv` h`y `lndlm`r`n mr``l spdo`.
Djkv` D sujjktlih (_kvi`t-styc` oc`dl-up)
krmdliz`n jy Odptdil Ucdl`t-typ`, Dgtdlnic
Akrkj`hkv (Odcvil Ur``o`)
J`ckw D n``r il o`ltrdc Jisbh`h, dppdr`ltcy
(Dgtdlnic Akrkj`hkv)
I
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 17/28
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 18/28
Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
42 Gkous
L DPMP_ :9, 49>9, tb` fflrst luoc`dr
t`st jy tb` _kvi`t Plikl wds oklnuot-`n dt d gdoicity kl tb` r`fkt` lkrtb-`dst`rl st`pp` kg tb` kcn Hdzdhb __Z.
^b` t st sit , hlkwl ds tb _`fipdcdt-ilsh Ukcymkl, wkucn mk kl tk witl`ss
>07 `xpcksikls kv`r its gkrty-y`dr `xist`lo , tktdc-cilm dl stifdt`n l`rmy quivdc`lt kg :5,555 Birk-sbifd jkfjs. ^b` ckodc p`kpc` j`odf` ulwittilm
muil`d pims, `xpks`n tk rdnidtikl sk tbdt soi`ltistsokucn kjs`rv` its `st`ots kl tb` bufdl jkny. Lkw,tw`lty-twk y`drs dgt`r tb` Ukcymkl g`cc sic`lt, kohs
kg sb``p mrdz` il midlt rdnikdotiv` jkfj ordt`rsdln il tb` wkrst st`ot`n dr`ds dcfkst kl` il tw`l-
ty obicnr`l dr` jkrl witb jirtb n`g`ots. ^b` _p`htdtkr r`o`ltcy f`t fflcffdh`r Dl-
tkly Jutts, nir`otkr dln prknuo`r kg Dgt`r tb`
Dpkodcyps`, d l`w nkouf`ltdry kl tb` _`fi-pdcdtilsh t`st gdoicity, tk quiz bif djkut bis `x-
p`ri`lo`s il tb` Ukcymkl dln tb` okls`qu`lo`sgkr tbks` wbk sticc civ` il tb` gdcckut zkl`.
]b`l nin yku fflrst b`dr djkut tb` _`fipdc-
dtilsh Ukcymkl, dln wbdt fdn` yku wdlt tk
fdh` d fflcf djkut it;
It wds wb`l I wds t`dobilm @lmcisb il Wkcmkmrdnjdoh il :555. I wds ilt`r`st`n il dcc tb` kcn _kvi-`t nisdst`rs - tb` Drdc _`d, Ob`rlkjyc dln sk kl. I
bdn aust s``l Dlnr`i drhkvshy’s _tdch`r dln wdsr`dccy ilt`r`st`n il mkilm tk kl` kg tb`s` –zkl`s‖wbiob, il fy ifdmildtikl, s``f`n cih` pdrdcc`c
uliv`rs`s. ]bdt wkucn cig` j` cih` tb`r`; ]b`lI fflldccy nin m`t tk _`fipdcdtilsh (dcsk hlkwl ds
_`f`y), I hl`w lktbilm djkut tb` jirtb n`g`ots.
I `xp`ot`n d ckt kg rdnidtikl dln d ckt kg odlo`rs.]bdt I gkuln wds lk rdnidtikl dln lkt tbdt
fdly odlo`rs. ]bicst I wds tb`r` I f`t Nr. Luf-dmdfj`tkv wbk j`odf` kl` kg tb` fflcf’s fdilobdrdot`rs. B` wds tdchilm djkut m`l`tio pdss-
pkrts dln m`ttilm v`ry wkrh`n up kv`r tb` in`d
tbdt tb` rdnidtikl ndfdm` wds pdssilm tbrkumbtb` m`l`rdtikls. I r`dcis`n tbdt tbis wds d stkry
tbdt l``n`n tk j` tkcn, sk I tbr`w fys`cg iltk it.
Nin yku bdv` dly oklo`rls gkr ykur kwl
b`dctb wbicst yku w`r` wkrhilm kut tb`r`;
Kl fy fflrst visit tk tb` Ukcymkl jdoh il :557, I wdsrdtb`r l`rvkus. I tkkh witb f` d suppcy kg surmi-
odc gdo`fdshs grkf @lmcdln. Jut, wb`l It odf`nkwl tk it, I g`ct rdtb`r run` fflcfilm il d fdsh skI skkl mkt rin kg tb`f. Fy h`y oklo`rl wds tbdt
kl fy fflrst trip tb` Hdzdhb oustkfs ifpkuln`nfy M`im`r okult`r dln I bdn lk wdy kg hlkwilm
wbiob pcdo`s w`r` rdnikdotiv` dln wbiob w`r`lkt. It wds fdn` wkrs` jy tb` gdot tbdt tb` fkstndlm`rkus gkrf kg rdnidtikl tb`r` - tb` pcutkli-
uf - odllkt j` pioh`n up jy d stdlndrn M`im`rokult`r dt dcc. Lkt hlkwilm wb`r` tb` rdnidtikl
wds dln, kg okurs`, lkt j`ilm djc` tk sf`cc krg``c it, I stdrt`n tk j`okf` ilor`dsilmcy pdrdlkindjkut tb` rdnidtikl. ^b` ckodc Hdzdhbs w`r` h``l
tk kst`r f` tb` ckodc our`-dcc, vknhd. Fdly kg tb`b`rn`rs sw`dr it is wbdt bds j``l h``pilm tb`fdciv` dln is mkkn gkr dlytbilm grkf stkfdob
jums tk rdnikdotiv` f`dt.Hdzdhbs dr` d bkspitdjc` p`kpc` sk I wds
kgt`l miv`l tb` fkst pr`stimikus (r`dn1 c`dst dp-
p`tisilm) jits kg dl dlifdc tk `dt. I fimbt bdv`gkuln jrdil dln `y`s niouct dt tb` j`st kgtif`s jut hlkwilm tb`y w`r` b`rn`n kl d rd-
nikdotiv` t`st-sit` fdn` it `v`l fkr` triohy tkgkro` nkwl.
Bdvilm s``l tb` fflcf, I m`t tb` ifpr`ssikl itwds kgt`l dl ulokfgkrtdjc` sbkkt gkr yku!
Y`s, dfklmst ktb`r nioucti`s, wb`l I w`ltjdoh il :559 tk okltilu` fflcfilm, slkw wds `v`-rywb`r`. Il kl` wdy I wds mcdn j`odus` it f`dlt
^b` _p`htdtkr tdchs tk Dltkly Jutts djkut
bis l`w fflcf, Dgt`r tb` Dpkodcyps , wbiob
ilv`stimdt`s cig` il d gkrf`r _kvi`t Luoc`dr
t`stilm gdoicity - tb` _`fipdcdtilsh Ukcy-
mkl.K^KF ]@CCILM_
Dgt`r
Dpkodcyps`
tb`
Djkv` ^b` cdrm`st kg tb` jkfj ordt`rs. Il tktdc
>07 luoc`dr t`sts w`r` odrri`n kut il tb` Ukcy-
mkl (dcc pbktks okurt`sy kg Dltkly Jutts)
Djkv` rimbt Nr. Lurfdmdfj`tkv’s wkrh n`dc-
ilm witb n`gkrf`n obicnr`l bds c`n bif tk prk-
pks` tb` in`d kg d m`l`tio pdsspkrt, n`siml`n
tk pr`v`lt tbks` dt rish kg pdssilm kl m`l`tio
oklnitikls grkf mivilm jirtb. Dgt`r tb` Dpkod-
cyps `xpckr`s tb` `tbiodc okliot j`tw``l d
fktb`r’s rimbt tk bdv` obicnr`l, dln d obicn’srimbt tk d b`dctby, bdppy, gucfflcc`n cig`
Djkv` gdr rimbt Jijimuc witb b`r busjdln dln
fflrst obicn
HDQDHB_^DL
^B@
UKCYMKL
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 19/28
www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr
49Gkous
lk fkr` rdnikdotiv` nust, jut it dcsk turl`n kut
tk j` kl` kg tb` okcn`st wilt`rs il r`o`lt y`drsdln tb` f`roury wds nkwl tk ->:±O dt tif`s. I
sp`lt djkut d fkltb civilm il tb` viccdm` kr kltb` gdrfs wb`r` tb` klcy tkic`ts dr` kutsin`, sk Ibdv` skf` vivin f`fkri`s kg wdtobilm tb` stdrs
oiroc` dt limbt wbic` sckwcy gr``zilm tk n`dtb!Dcsk, tb` kutnkkr pdrt kg tb` fflcfilm wds
pr`tty fuob d kl`-fdl sbkw witb lk trdlscdtkr
kr or`w, sk tbis fdn` gkr skf` ilt`r`stilm fucti-tdshilm! ]b`l _`rih Xtb` sb`pb`rnV dln I rkn`kl bkrs`jdoh kut tk kl` kg tb` ordt`rs, I wds
tryilm tk bkcn tb` odf`rd witb kl` bdln, dlnbkcn tb` r`imls kg tb` bkrs` witb tb` ktb`r. I wds
dcsk tryilm tk tbilh kg qu`stikls, dln dcc tb` tif`fflmbtilm tk h``p fy bdlns grkf mkilm lufj. Dtkl` pkilt I g`cc kst, jut tbdlhguccy fy odf`rd sur-
viv`n tb` tufjc`.
^b` fdil ldrrdtiv` tbdt ruls tbrkumbkut tb`fflcf is tbdt kg Jijimuc. `cc us d cittc` djkut b`r.
^b` fflcf gkcckws Jijimuc’s pr`mldloy up ultic
tb` jirtb kg b`r obicn. Jijimuc wds jkrl witb dstimfd kg tb` `y`s, wbiob f`dls tbdt tb`y dr`gurtb`r dpdrt tbdl lkrfdc. Nr. Lurfdmdfj`tkv
odcc`n b`r d –grimbtguc gdo`‖ dln dnvis`n b`r tkt`rfildt` b`r pr`mldloy. Jijimuc, bkw`v`r, wdsn`t`rfil`n tk r`sist tbis dnvio` dln w`lt kl tk
miv` jirtb dlywdy.
Nin Nr. Lurfdmdfj`tkv dnvis` b`r dmdilst
mivilm jirtb il ods` sb` pdss`n kl b`r oklni-
tikl;
Y`s. Il bis kpilikl tb`r` wds d v`ry bimb obdlo`
tb` obicn wkucn j` jkrl witb Nkwl sylnrkf`,dln dcsk witb d sificdr `y` n`g`ot. Dln tbis is p`r-
g`otcy r`dskldjc` wb`l yku uln`rstdln tbdt b`s``s obicnr`l witb bkrrifflo n`gkrfiti`s `v`ry ndy.Dln b` dcsk s``s tb` wdy tb`y dr` kgt`l r`a`ot`n
jy tb`ir pdr`lts dln `ln up nufp`n il stdt` kr-
pbdldm`s tbdt strummc` tk okp`. Bis ‒m`l`tio pdss-pkrt’ in`d wds n`siml`n tk pr`v`lt tbks` cih`cy
tk pdss kl n`gkrfiti`s grkf mivilm jirtb. It is tbisqu`stikl kg ffllnilm d jdcdlo` j`tw``l tb` rimbtkg d obicn tk d b`dctby bdppy dln gucfflcc`n cig`, dln
tb` rimbt kg d fktb`r tk bdv` obicnr`l wbiob ci`sdt tb` b`drt kg tb` fflcf. Cdt`r, bkw`v`r, tb` nko-tkr j`mdl tdchilm djkut prkt`otilm tb` –b`dctb kg
tb` m`l`tio pkkc kg Hdzdhbs–, wbiob is kjvikuscy dfuob fkr` silist`r dttitun`.
]ds Jijimuc’s oklnitikl dotudccy dst`otilm b`r
b`dctb;
Lk, jut d ckt kg p`kpc` tbkumbt sb` wds r`tdrn`nj`odus` sb` wkucnl’t sp`dh, `sp`oidccy djkut
tb` suja`ot kg b`r dpp`drdlo` dln b`r pr`mldl-oy. Jut I cdt`r fflmur`n kut tbdt tbis wds aust b`r
okpilm f`obdlisf. Dln it’s p`rg`otcy r`dskl-
djc` tbdt ig yku dr` p`st`r`n djkut skf`tbilmdcc ykur cig` yku `ln up n`oinilm tk imlkr` it. Jut
b`r sic`lo` bdn j``l fisilt`rpr`t`n.
Dln wbdt bdpp`l`n il tb` `ln, wds tb` jdjy
b`dctby;
Y`s, il tbis ods` Nr. Lurfdmdfj`tkv wds prkv`nwrklm. Jut tb`r` w`r`, kg okurs`, fdly ktb`r ods-
`s wb`r` tb` fktb`r dln obicn w`r` lkt sk cuohy.
Bkw nin it g``c fflcfilm tb` jirtb;
Dotudccy, I wds r`dccy wkrri`n tbdt Jijimuc
wkucnl’t c`t f` fflcf tb` jirtb! I trdv`c`n jdoh tk_`fipdcdtilsh grkf @lmcdln `sp`oidccy gkr tbdt
dln mkt tb`r` tbr`` w``hs `drcy aust il ods`. Itturl`n kut sb` wds d w``h kv`rnu` dln I wds skwkrri`n tbdt sb` wkucn aust bdv` tb` jdjy dln
lkt t`cc f` djkut it. I wds fflldloilm tb` trip cdrm`cykl fy or`nit odrn dln d g`w nklkrs sk
D pdss`lm`r kl d aufjk a`t wicc j` `xpks`n tkc`v`cs kg rdnidtikl mr`dt`r tbdl tbks` gkuln il
tb` jkfj ordt`rs kg _`fipdcdtilsh, sk bkw odlw` sdy witb dly oklviotikl tbdt rdnidtikl dotu-
dccy odus`s m`l`tiodccy ilb`rit`n jirtb n`g`ots; ^b` sifpc dlsw`r is tbdt w` odllkt. Il tb`gkcckwilm sbkrt drtioc` I wicc v`ltur` tk kutcil`
jri`y tb` tbr`` fdil drmuf`lts kg tbis bimbcyobdrm`n n`jdt .
Drmuf`lt 41 Zdnidtikl nk`s lkt odus` ilb`r-it`n m`l`tio ndfdm`
Dl `xt`lsiv` stuny gkuln lk `vin`lo` kg dlyilor`ds` il jirtb n`g`ots il Birksbifd dln Ldmd-sdhi. ^b`r`gkr`, rdnidtikl nk`s lkt odus` ilb`r-
it`n jirtb n`g`ots.Bkw tb`l odl w` xpcdil tb` c`vdt`n jirtb n`-g`ots il _`fipdcdtilsh; _kf` soi`ltists sp`ou-
cdt` tbdt it okucn okf` grkf ckw c`v`cs kg gkciodoin il tb` ni`t kg pr`mldlt wkf`l. Gkcio doinn`ffloi`loy is prkv`l tk odus` c`vdt`n jirtb n`-
g`ots dln tb` Hdzdhb ni`t is f`dt-ilt`lsiv` kw-ilm tk v`m`tdjc`s dln mr``ls mrkwilm pkkrcy kl
tb` nusty st`pp` il tb` _`fipdcdtilsh r`mikl.
Drmuf`lt :1 U`rbdps rdnidtikl odus`s ilb`r-it`n ndfdm` il bufdls
Odl gkcio doin n`ffloi`loy r`dccy j` odusilm suobbimb c`v`cs kg jirtb n`g`ots (up tk kl` il tw`lty
jirtbs); Dr` suob r`sucts r``otiv` kg ktb`r
b rinnc kg
ZdnidtiklDL^KLY JP^^_
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 20/28
Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
:5 GkousGrkf c`gt tk rimbt Jijimuc’s fktb`r, dcsk dg-
iot`n witb tb` sdf` oklnitikl8 Jirs`lj`h
tb` sb`pb`rn nkwlilm dlktb`r nks` kg ‒dlti-
rdnidtikl’ vknhd8 Dltkly Jutts sbkktilm dt
tb` cdrm`st ordt`r il tb` _`fipdcdtilsh Ukcy-
mkl
r`mikls il Hdzdhbstdl; _dncy, tbis is j`ykln
tb` jkulns kg fy r`s`drob sk I odllkt sdy. Jutwbdt Is oc`dr is tbdt tb` pr`s`lo` kg iklisilmrdnidtikl il tb` viccdm`s dln tb`ir `lvirkls is dc-
fkst lic, `xo`pt gkr dr`ds drkuln tb` ordt`rs dlno`rtdil wdt`r skuro`s. ^bis f`dls tb`r` is gdr tkk
cittc` rdnidtikl drkuln tk odus` jirtb n`g`ots. Igrdnidtikl is tk jcdf`, tb`l it odl’t okf` grkf tb`pr`s`lt. It wkucn bdv` tk okf` grkf tb` pdst,
witb tb` f`fkry kg tb` jcdsts j`ilm odrri`ntbrkumb tb` m`l`rdtikls jy m`l`tiodccy ilb`r-it`n NLD ndfdm`.
Odl w` c`drl dlytbilm grkf Ob`rlkjyc;D r`o`lt stuny il tb` Cdlo`t bds gkuln `c`vdt`nrdt`s kg jirtb n`g`ots il kl` dr`d l`dr Ob`rlk-
jyc wb`r` tb`r` bdn j``l simlifflodlt rdnidtiklokltdfildtikl. Oritios sdy tbdt d silmc` stuny
bimbcimbtilm klcy kl` r`mikl nk`s lkt oklsti-tut` prkkg kg d okll`otikl j`tw``l rdnidtikldln jirtb n`g`ots. Bkw`v`r, ds Phrdil` nk`s lkt
sust`r tb` dmrioucturdc privdtikls kg Hdzdhbstdl’snusty st`pp`, tb` r`sucts nk s``f tk odst nkujtkl tb` _`fipdcdtilsh gkcio doin tb`kry.
Jut bkw tk `xpcdil tb` `xt`lsiv` stuny il
Birksbifd dln Ldmdsdhi wbiob gkuln lk cilh tkjirtb n`g`ots; Kl` dlsw`r prkpks`n is tbdt tb`Adpdl`s` viotifs w`r` `xpks`n tk bimb c`v`cskg rdnidtikl grkf tb` jkfj dsb dln iff`ni-
dt` dgt`rfdtb jut gkr d r`cdtiv`cy sbkrt p`rikn kgtif`. _`fipdcdtilsh viotifs, dln tk d c`ss`r `x-t`lt tbks` dt Ob`rlkjyc, bdv` j``l `xpks`n tk
fuob ckw`r nks`s, jut gkr gdr cklm`r p`rikns kgtif`. ^b` nist`r`lt fdll`rs kg irrdnidtikl, ocdif
skf` soi`ltists, okucn f`dl tb` Birksbifd dlnLdmdsdhi r`sucts nk lkt prkv` dlytbilm il tb`ods` kg _`fipdcdtilsh.
Dcsk, skf` p`kpc`, dir st`wdrn`ss`s gkr `x-dfpc`, dr` okltiludccy `xpks`n tk ckw nks`s kgrdnidtikl kv`r fdly y`drs ds pdrt kg tb`ir akj.
^b` rdnidtikl kl dirpcdl`s drkuln tb` cdtitun` kg@urkp` (it ilor`ds`s tb` gurtb`r yku y tkwdrnstb` pkc`s) is drkuln ?55 fiorkZk`ltm`ls wbiob
is drkuln tw`lty tif`s wbdt yku odl `xp`ot tk
fflln wbic` kl tb` mrkuln dln dotudccy `xo``ns
tb` rdnidtikl c`v`cs I f`dsur`n kl tb` jim ordt`ril _`fipdcdtilsh il wilt`r.
]b`tb`r tbis puts yku kst yilm prkjdjcy n`-
p`lns kl wb`r` yku m`t ykur ilgkrfdtikl grkf. ^b` Ndicy Fdic tbis Dpric oit`n twk _odlnildvidl
stuni`s ocdifilm tbdt dir st`wdrn`ss`s dr` stdtisti-odccy fkr` cih`cy tk miv` jirtb tk jdji`s witb Nkwlsylnrkf` tbdl wkf`l il ktb`r odr``rs, dln dcsk
twio` ds cih`cy tk n`v`ckp jr`dst odlo`r. Bkw`v`r,d :557 JJO Bkrizkls nkouf`ltdry pcdys nkwltb` ndlm`rs jy oitilm nist`r`lt stuni`s.
]bic` tb` `pin`fikckmiodc `vin`lo` kl tb`mrkuln dln il tb` shy ckkhs iloklocusiv , wbdtdjkut cdj t`sts; Lkjkny bds sbkwl tbdt rdnid-
tikl odus`s ilb`rit`n ndfdm` il bufdls uln`rokltrkcc`n oklnitikls j`odus` kg `tbiodc oklsin-
`rdtikls. Bkw`v`r, Urkg. Yuri Nujrkvd bds lk suobqudcfs witb bufjc` fio . Dt tb` Pliv`rsity kgC`io`st`r wb`r` b` is b`dn kg tb` m`l`tios n`pdrt-
f`lt, b` xpcdil`n tk f` tbdt bis r`sucts sbkw tbdttb` futdtikl rdt` nk`s ilor`ds` il tb` kstsprilm kgirrdnidt`n fio . ^bis summ`sts tbdt skf`bkw tb`
f`fkry kg pdr`ltdc irrdnidtikl trdv`cs nkwl tk
cdt`r m`l`rdtikls dln fdh`s tb`f ulstdjc . Urkg.Nujrkvd’s r`sucts dr` firrkr`n jy sificdr stuni`soklnuot`n il tb` P_, Odldnd dln Adpdl.
Ig, ds skf` suppks`, tb` `st`ots kjs`rv`n
il fio` dr` tru` il bufdls, tb`l tbis ilb`rit`nm`l`tio ilstdjicity odus`n jy rdnidtikl okucn j`j`biln tb` jirtb n`g`ots il _`fipdcdtilsh. Urkg.
Nujrkvd wds, bkw`v`r, dt pdils tk str`ss tbdt soi-`lo` odllkt y`t `xpcdil tb`s` r`sucts1 –]` nkl’t
hlkw bkw it wkrhs. ]`’r` wkrhilm bdrn lkw try-ilm tk dldcys` tb` f`obdlisfs uln`rcyilm tbisjizdrr` pb`lkf`lkl.‖
Drmuf`lt ?1 Zdnidtikl n`ffllit`cy odus`s ilb`r-
it`n m`l`tio ndfdm`
Dt tb` fkf`lt klcy tbks` pkw`r`n jy j`ci`gdln lkt soi`ltifflo trdililm odl sdy tbdt rdnid-tikl oklocusiv`cy odus`s jirtb n`g`ots nkwl tb`
m`l`rdtikls il bufdls.
it wds sup`r rishy. ]b`l Jijimuc’s sist`r rdlmf` dt 4df I wds r`dccy wir`n. I fflcf`n grkf j`bilnJijimuc’s b`dn dln wb`l tb` jdjy wds jkrl, it
odf` kut c`ms fflrst. b`r` wds skf` r`dc nrdfd witbtb` nkotkr t`ccilm Jijimuc tk pusb urm`ltcy ds bdrnds sb` okucn, j`odus` tb` bdcg-jkrl obicn okucnl’t
jr`dtb . ]b`l tb` obicn odf` kut it wds cih` d mr`ynkcc. ^b`y tkkh it tk d tdjc` dln stdrt`n scdppilm it
kl tb` jdoh dln usilm kxym`l, jut lktbilm wdsbdpp`lilm. ^b` lurs`s w`r` sdyilm tbdt tif` wds
rullilm kut gkr bif. ^b`l, dfdzilmcy, tb` obicn austjurst iltk cig` dln stdrt`n sor`dfilm.
]bdt bdpp`ls tk tb` obicnr`l jkrl witb djlkr-
fdciti`s kr n`gkrfiti`s;
_kf`tif`s tb` fktb`rs h``p tb`f. _kf`tif`stb`y g``c tbdt tb`y nkl’t bdv` tb` fkl`y, kr tb`y
g``c d s`ls` kg sbdf`. Kr skf`tif`s obicnr`l dr` aust tkk bkrrifflodccy n gkrf`n tk ckkh dgt`r. _k tb`y
`ln up il krpbdldm`s. Kl` is odcc`n tb` Bkus` KgObicnr`l. b`y stdy tb`r` ultic tb`y dr` d g`w y`drskcn, tb`l tb`y mk kst tk tbis ktb`r krpbdldm` il Dy-
dmuz Xd oity tk tb` skutb kg _`fipdcdtilshV..
Nin yku visit tb` krpbdldm`s;
Y`s, I visit`n jktb. ]b`l I w`lt kut tk Dydmuz, itwds quit` `drcy kl il tb` fflcfilm, j`gkr` fy filn
bdn dnaust`n tk it, dln `v`rytbilm wds quit`sbkohilm dln l`w. I wds jr`dhilm nkwl il t`drsnurilm kl` ilt`rvi`w witb tbis mirc wbk bdn Nkwl
sylnrkf` dln d b`drt n`g`ot. b`y sdin tb`y ninl’tbdv` `lkumb fkl`y tk m`t dl kp`rdtikl gkr b`r. Icdt`r gkuln kut tbdt tb`y nin m`t tb` fkl`y gkr tb`
kp`rdtikl, jut tbdt tb` mirc ni`n dlywdy. Fdly kgtb` hins I ilt`rvi`w`n tb`l dr` lkw n`dn, wbiob Ifflln v`ry ups`ttilm.
Dlktb`r obdrdot`r tb` fflcf gkcckws is Jirs`lj`h
tb` sb`pb`rn. `cc us d cittc` djkut bif.
Jirs`lj`h is aust d lkrfdc Hdzdhb sb`pb`rn, wbkbdpp`ls tk civ` rimbt l`xt tk tb` cdrm`st jkfj
ordt`r il tb` Ukcymkl. bdt’s wb`r` bis gdrf is. b`f`dt is tb`l skcn il _`fipdcdtilsh, dln lkjknyhlkws it’s j``l mrdz`n kl d rdnikdotiv` ordt`r!
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 21/28
www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr
:4GkousPlgkrtuldt`cy, fdly akurldcists dln
kpilikl fdh`rs gkrm`t tb` soi`lo` dln qukt`
wbdt`v`r fflts tb`ir j`ci`gs. ^b`y s`` rdnidtikl,tb`l d n`gkrf`n obicn, dln tbdt’s it. Filnfdn` up. Lk soi`lo` kr ckkhilm dt tb` lu-
dlo`s. ^b`r` dr` p`kpc` jkrl witb Jijimuc’s`y` stimfd il @lmcdln, wb`r` tb`r` bds l`v`r
j``l dly f`dlilmguc rdnidtikl `xpksur`, gkrilstdlo`. b` sifpc` gdot is tbdt lk-kl` hlkwstb` dlsw`r tk tb` ilb`rit`n m`l`tio ndfdm`
qu`stikl.
Odl tb` rinnc` j` skcv`n;
_k, sbkrt kg irrdnidtilm p`kpc` il okltrkcc`noklnitikls, odl w` m`t tk tb` jkttkf kg rd-nidtikl fyst`ry; Urkg. Nujrkvd wdch`n f`
kv`r tk d orykm`lio gr``z`r dln sfic`n. ]bdtwds il tb`r`, I dsh`n. B` kp`l`n it `xoit`ncy.
Wdpkur jicckw`n kut tk tb` kkr dln dfin tb`fist w`r` r`v`dc`n rkw upkl rkw kg t`st tuj`s,sbililm jckkn-r`n uln`r tb` cdj’s ukr`so`lt
cimbtilm. ^b`s` w`r` sdfpc`s odr`guccy okc-
c`ot`n dln ckmm`n grkf m`l`rdtikls kg oitiz`lscivilm (dln dcsk lkw n`o`ds`n) il tb` viccdm`s
drkuln tb` _`fipdcdtilsh t`st-sit` dln trdls-pkrt`n b`r` tk j` grkz`l ultic soi`lo` okucn
fdh` us` kg tb`f.Yuri odl jdr`cy okltdil bis `xoit`f`lt.
^b` m`l`tios t`oblkckmy is okfilm. Dcr`dny,
yku odl s`qu`lo` skf`kl`’s NLD il c`ss tbdltw`lty-gkur bkurs. Lkw tb` prkg`sskr is wdit-ilm gkr tb` gulnilm tk okf` tbrkumb tk nk d
prkp`r m`l`tio dldcysis kl dcc tbis jckkn. Jutsdncy, lk-kl` is mivilm Yuri tb` fkl`y tk nk
tbis vitdc r`s`drob.Kv`r il Hdzdhbstdl wb`r` d o`rtdil fucti-
jiccikldir` Ur`sin`lt dln bis hc`ptkordtio gdf-
icy bdv` pc`lty kg kic fkl`y tk spcdsb drkuln,Nr Jkris Mdciob wbk is n`puty b`dn kg tb`_`fipdcdtilsh Ilstitut` kg Zdnidtikl F`ni-
oil`s is jusy jkkhilm d s`okln ocdss trdil tioh-`t gkr d tw`cv` bkur akurl`y dorkss tb` st`pp`tk mk tk d oklg`r`lo` il –l`drjy‖ Hdrdmdlnd.
^ir`n kg p`rgkrfilm tb` sdf` trioh gkr visitilm akurldcists, Nr Mdciob mrufpicy fdrob`n f`
kutsin` il tb` slkw tk sbkw f` bis gr``z`rgucc kg jckkn sdfpc`s sificdr tk Yuri’s. Jut b`bdn gkrmktt`l tb` h`ys. ^b` r`n t`fp`rdtur`
C@N kl tb` grklt kg tb` gr``z`r r`dn d st`dnyfilus 4>5 n`mr``s O`csius - –Lkwb`r` l`drokkc `lkumb tk h``p tb`f ulspkict gkr fuob
cklm`r,‖ sdys Nr Mdciob. ]bic` Urkg. Nujrkvd
wdlts tb` fkl`y tk rul bis jckkn tbrkumb`xp`lsiv` m`l`tio s`qu`lo`rs, dcc Nr Mdciobwdlts is d n`o`lt gr``z`r.
Il tbdt gr``z`r, Nr Mdciob sdin, w`r` jckkn
sdfpc`s kg obicnr`l, pdr`lts, mrdlnpdr`ltsdln mr`dt mrdlnpdr`lts. ^b` mrdlnpdr`ltsr`o`iv`n tb` jim cklm t`rf nks` kg rdnidtikl
il tb` n`odn`s wb`l tb` P__Z `xpckn`n tb`wkrst kg tb` t`st-sit`’s >07 s`pdrdt` jkfjs,jut tb` obicnr`l j`ilm jkrl lkw dln tb`ir
pdr`lts bdn lkt s``l dly rdnidtikl kg simliffl-odlo`. Bds tb` rdnidtikl ndfdm` j``l pdss`n
nkwl; ]` wkl’t hlkw ultic tb`s` sdfpc`sdr` s`qu`lo`s dln dldcys`n. Jut ig tbdt kl`gr``z`r mk`s, tb`l prio`c`ss m`l`tio sdfpc`s
kg cklm n`dn Hdzdhb oitiz`ls, il wbks` jckknci`s tb` h`y tk tb` fyst`ry, wicc j` ckst. Ig Urkg.Nujrkvd’s gr``z`r mk`s ds w`cc, w` fimbt l`v-
`r hlkw tb` dlsw`r.
]bdt nk`s b` tbilh djkut civilm sk ocks` tk
suob dl kfilkus cdlnfdrh;
k bif it’s aust pdrt kg tb` ndicy vi`w kut kg tb` wil-nkw. B` tdh`s bis sb``p up tb`r`, aust klo` d w``h
tbkumb, j`odus` b` sdys b` m`ts d b`dndob` ig b`mk`s up tb`r` tkk kgt`l. It’s wkrs` il tb` suff`r
tbkumb. B` sdys tb` wiln wbips up tb` nust dlnjckws it tkwdrns bis okttdm` - dln tbis nust is gucc kgndlm`rkus rdnikdotiv` isktkp`s.
Jut b` stdys tb`r`;Y`db. B` sdys b ’s p`rg`otcy ffll . ^bdt s``fs tk j`
tb` tbilm - gkr us it’s sbkohilm wb`l w` mk tb`r`dln s`` it. Dln gkr tb` nkotkrs wbk n`dc witb it dln
its `st`ots `v`ry ndy, it’s sbkohilm. Jut gkr p`kpc`wbk mrkw up tb`r , its aust d jdohmrkuln tk tb`ircig . Dln I dsh`n tb`s` qu`stikls1 –]by nk yku
stdy;–, –]by dr`l’t yku fkr` wkrri`n;– Jut tb`y austsdy –]bdt’s tb` pkilt il wkrryilm fkr` wb`l w`tbilh tb` rdnidtikl is ilsin` kur jckkn, ilsin` kur
m`l`s; ]` odl’t sodp` grkf tbis ours` dlywdy.‖
]bdt nk tb` kcn`r p`kpc` r`f`fj`r djkut tb`
t`sts;
It’s m`l`rdccy tb` sdf` stkry1 b`y’n s`` d jim dsb
kg cimbt dln tb`y’n dcc rul kutsin` tb`ir bkus`s tkwdtob tb` jim fusbrkkf. _kf`tif`s tb` _kvi`tskcni`rs wkucn okf` kv`r dln t`cc tb`f tk stdln
kutsin` tb`ir bkus`s dln ckkh dt tb` fusbrkkfs.I l`v`r r`dccy mkt tk tb` jkttkf kg wb`tb`r tbiswds j`odus` tb` sujs`qu`lt `drtbqudh`s wkucn
hlkoh tb`ir bkus`s nkwl, kr, ds wds summ`st`n iltb` fflcf, tbdt it wds pdrt kg d silist`r `xp`rif`lt.
I’f ilocil`n tk j`ci`v` it’s d jit kg jktb.
Bkw fuob nin tb`y hlkw;
Kb, tb`y hl`w v`ry cittc`. ^b`y hl`w tbdt tb` mkv-`rlf`lt wds nkilm skf`tbilm kut tb`r`, jut tb`yninl’t hlkw wbdt. Dln tb`y ninl’t hlkw tbdt it bdn
dly ifpciodtikls kl tb`ir b`dctb . Kl` wkfdl wbkbdn d v`ry, v`ry n`gkrf`n obicn tkcn f` tbdt it wdsklcy wb`l sb` sdw tbdt `v`ry ktb`r obicn il tb`
dr`d wds jkrl bkrrifflodccy n`gkrf`n, tbdt sb` hilnkg put twk dln twk tkm`tb`r.
^b`r` is sur`cy d mr`dt n`dc kg dlm`r dln jitt`r-
l`ss dfklmst tb` ckodc p`kpc`;
Ckodc p`kpc` nk g``c jitt`r, y`s. It is cih` tb`y bdv`j``l tr`dt`n ds muil`d pims twio` lkw. Girst witb
tb` luoc`dr jkfjs, tk s`` wbdt wkucn bdpp`l.Dln lkw p`kpc` mk kv`r tb`r` tk nk tb`ir nkotkr-
dt`s, kr tk nk cittc` akurldcistio pi`o`s djkut tb`irsust`rilm. N`spit` dcc tbis, pr`oikus cittc` fkl`y issp`lt kl tb` r`mikl jy tb` mkv`rlf`lt, dln tb`
gkr`mil din tb` akurldcists prkfis` bds l`v`r r`-
dccy fdt`ridcis`n.Il tb` bkt`c wbiob I stdy`n il _`fipdcdtilsh
I f`t d fflcffdhilm mrkup wbk bdn n`oin`n tbdtJ`rih - d ckodc fdl witb bum` dp-cih` tufkurs
kl bis gdo` - sbkucn stdr il d sbkrt nrdfd. It ckkhscih` tb` fflcffdh`rs bdv` nkl` d r`fdh` kg @n-wdrn _oisskrbdlns - jut witb d r`dc p`rskl wbk
is v`ry vucl`rdjc`. I f`t J`rih klo`. B`’s d jcilnmuy wbk’s sk jkr`n tbdt b`’n prkjdjcy nk fksttbilms tk dcc`vidt` tb` fklktkly kg bis cig` dln
`drl d jit kg odsb. Is it `xpckitdtikl jy d mrkup kgfflcf stun`lts kut tk juicn up tb`ir sbkwr``c, krd tkuobilm fflcf tbdt wicc jrilm r`dc bkp` tk tbis
p`rskl’s cig`; Dgt`r tb` dpkodcyps`, I bkp`, is lkt`xpckitdtiv` ds w`’r` r`dccy tryilm tk juicn up d
pr`s`lo` gkr it dln pusb tbilms pkcitiodccy. Jut tkskf` `xt`lt kr dlktb`r it is `xpckitdtiv`.
]icc yku `v`r j` djc` tk sbkw Dgt r tb` Dpkod-cyps il Hdzdhbstdl;
Lk. ^b` p`kpc` I f`t dmr``n tk j` fflcf`n sk cklm
ds it wkucnl’t j` jrkdnodst il Hdzdhbstdl. ^b`cdst tbilm Jijimuc wdlts is ktb`r viccdm`rs mdwp-
ilm dt b`r mivilm jirtb dln tb` nkotkr odccilm b`rm`l`tiodccy ilg`rikr. Gkr tbis r`dskl, tb` fflcf fustl`v`r j` sbkwl pujciodccy il Hdzdhbstdl.
Dgt`r tb` Dpkodcyps` bds its tb`dtriodc pr`fi`r` dt
C`io`st`r _qudr`’s Urilo` Obdrc`s Oil`fd il Cklnkl kl
44tb Fdy :544. It wicc tb`l j` sor``l`n il vdrikus oil-`fds drkuln tb` PH, j`gkr` j`ilm jrkdnodst kl PH t`c-
`visikl obdll`c Fkr`> il Aucy. Yku odl pr`-krn`r NWNs
dln m`t n`tdics kg tb` cdt`st sor``lilms vid tb` w`jsit`
www.dgt`rtb`dpkodcyps`fkvi`.okf
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 22/28
Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
::
^B@ MPIN@Jisbh`h cig`Jdrs
Nulmdl
$ - @xp`ot obdlm` grkf 405 skf
$$ - D cittc` kv`r :05 sbkucn nk tb` tr ioh
$$$ - @xp`ot tk pdy il tb` r`mikl kg ?05
$$$$ - D orisp 055 (kr fkr`) l``n`n il tbis akilt
Obil`s`Dh-Jdtd (452, Ijrdifkvd)
^bis pcdo` fust s`rv` up pr`tty dutb`ltio nisb`s
ds it’s dcwdys gucc kg Obil`s` pcdyilm fdb-aklm dln
wdvilm tb`ir obkpstiohs djkut. _fkhy dln stusty,
jut il d lio` wdy. $
Bkccywkkn*(Nruzbjd/_kvi`tshdyd)
Ds yku wkucn prkjdjcy mu`ss, n`okrdt`n witb
fkvi` pkst`rs, pbktks kg oil`fd iokls dln d
julob kg Df`riodl hitsob. Bkccywkkn is pkpu-cdr witb d ykulm`r orkwn dln is usudccy pdoh`n
grkf fin-`v`lilm klwdrns. D gul pcdo` gkr d g`w
nrilhs j`gkr` b`dnilm kgg tk tb` ocujs. $$$
F`trk* (4??, Obui)
Il tb` ifpr`ssiv` ckodtikl kg d gkrf`r tb`dtr`, F`trk
r`fdils tb` pr`fiâr` nrilhilm bkc` gkr `x-pdts. D
bimb o`icilm, d cklm jdr dln gri`lncy stdst okfpci-f`lt d mkkn ^`x-F`x f`lu dln d win` s`c`otikl
kg nrilhs. F`trk is kl` kg tb` j`st j`ts gkr odtob-ilm spkrtilm `v`lts kl ^W, dctbkumb tbdlhs tk tb`
bin`kuscy cdt` hiohkst tif`s gkr Obdfpikls C`dmu`
gkktjdcc fdtob`s, nkl’t okult kl tb` stdst wditilm up
ulc`ss it’s d jim kl`. $$$
F`xiodl Odlt``ld (Obui 402, l`dr J`td _tkr`s)Dt its j`st il tb` suff`r ds skfjr`rk ocdssios s`r-`ldn` p`n`stridls nkwl Obui dln d fix`n orkwnsits kl tb` pkrob wdsbilm nkwl tdoks witb strklmfdrmuiritd. Jurritks dln gdaitds dr` fkutb-wdt`rilmb`r`, dln cklm-bdir`n mrilmk typ`s wicc j` mcdn tkbdv` tb`ir j``r s`rv`n witb d c`fkl, lkt d strdw.$$$
_fkhi`’s (Nkl`tshdyd/Auh``vd Uunkvhild)
Jisbh`h’s girst dln klcy trdnitikldc Df`riodl
jdrj`ou` r`stdurdlt s`rv`s pit-sfkh`n spioyj``g jrish`t, rijs, pkrh sbkucn`r, cdfj c`ms dln
obioh`l qudrt`rs. ]`cc wkrtb tb` tr`h kut tk Kr-
tk-_di fdrh`t il tb` okkc`r bdcg kg tb` oity. @laky
d rdlm` kg okohtdics dln spirits, tkk. $$$
Cdlndu (Fdlds/Mkrhy)
Gdloy skf`tbilm d cittc` nist`r`lt; Ig yku odl tkc-
`rdt` tb` drtbritio s`rvio`, Cdlndu isl’t d jdn spkt
gkr d pkrh st`dh kr skf` ktb`r Drf`lidl oucildry
mkkni`s. Dcsk, tr`dt ykurs`cg tk skf` n`o`lt Drf`-
lidl oklado wbicst ykur b`r`, yku’cc l`v`r mk l`dr
Jisbh`h oklado dmdil. @v`r. $$$
r`stdurdltsdln
Bui Fil (Z ckodt n tk tb Bkt c Nkstuh)
D gkrf`r gdvkurit`, w` bdv` j``l tkcn tbdt Bui Fil
bds lkw r`ckodt`n tk tb` Bkt`c Nkstuh. Dppdr`ltcy
tb` f`lu bds j``l r`vdfp`n dln tb` prio`s il-
or`ds`n. b` _p`htdtkr wicc j` ob`ohilm it kut skkl.
]` bkp` tb`y sticc s`rv` tb` sp`oidc Nulmdl t`d, ds
it’s rdtb`r mkkn.
^b`r`’s d ffll` cil` j`tw``l ‒jdr’ dln ‒r`stdurdlt’ il
Jisbh`h. Ucdo`s fkr` suitdjc` gkr nrilhilm s`ssikls
dr` fdrh`n witb d stdr *
Urio` Muin` (fdil okurs` dln d mdrlisb)
(0, M`rz`ld)
Nkl ykur j``r nrilhilm trkus`rs dln b`dn nkwltk Jisbh`h’s tdh` kl d Jdvdridl-styc` j``r bdcc. ^b`y
jr`w tb`ir kwl stust - suob d r`ci g grkf tb` ilsipin
jicm` tbdt’s lkrfdccy skcn ds cdm`r. Okfpcif`lt ykur
pilt witb d pcdt` kg M`rfdl sdusdm` witb sdu`rhrdut.
$$$
(Fksokw/_kvi`t)Dotudccy dl Dustridl, jut sujsuf`n iltk kur M`rfdl
s`otikl il tb` ldf` kg Dlsobcuss.W`ld is d ordohilm cit-
tc` pcdo` tk p`kpc`-wdtob kv`r skf` mr`dt @urkp`dl
nisb`s dln d mcdss kg ffll` Dustridl wil . Ig yku ninl’t
hlkw Dustrid bdn ffll` wil`s, yku odl ob`oh iltk tb`
dnakililm sbkp tk j`mil ykur vitioucturdc `nuodtikl.
Wi lld is sp`cc`n КАЖЕ il Zussidl. Gr`` ]i-Gi. $$$
Df`riodl/F`xiodl
Drf`lidl
M`rfdl
(^`pcIhcuoby viccdm`)]kkn`l odjil ckodt`n jy d rusbilm str`df tbirty fil-
ut`s kut kg tkwl. ^b` kv`rprio`n gkkn is fkr` tbdl
okfp`lsdt`n gkr jy tb` obicc`n dtfkspb`r` dln wicn
surrkulnilms. Bkt`c dookffkndtikl dcsk dvdicdjc .
B`dn skutb kl Dcfdtilshdyd dln h``p mkilm. $$$$
Jdodrni* (^kmkckh Fkcnk 4=/4)
@cit` ckulm` jdr dstdir witb s`pdrdt` rkkfs gkr nil-
ilm, ndloilm dln wbicilm tb` limbt dwdy sfkhilm
buhhdb pip`s. Prjdl mrkkv`s pcdy`n dt d r`dskl-
djc` vkcuf` dln d gucc f`lu tbdt ilocun`s d rdlm`
kg tdsty pcdtt`rs. $$$$Jdrokn`* (^khtkmuc/_kvi`tshdyd, ilsin` ‒Fktk’)
D bip, oc`dl ilt`rikr, gdst wi-ffl dln dl dstkrndjc`
jusil`ss culob bdv` fdn` Jdrokn` skf`tbilm kg
d bktspkt silo` it kp`l`n il `drcy :545. ^b` pcdo`
okf`s tk cig` dt limbt wb`l ? NAs okfp`t` gkr ykur
dst`otikls witb dl drrdy kg jdlmilm tul`s. $$
(Urdvnd/Hucdtkvd)
Jckln`r Uuj is tb` l`w jr`w`ry-r`stdurdlt tk try
kut. Odv`rlkus y`t oksy ilsin`, tb`r`’s n`o`lt jcu`s
`v`ry limbt, civ` Ur`fi`rsbip Gkktjdcc, @urkmruj
dln d mkkn s`c`otikl kg dc`s. Il r`mdrn tk tb` cdtt`rw` r`okff`ln ‒Ndtshi _obldst`r’. $$$$
Junnbd Jdr (_kvi`tshdyd/Dhbuljdy`vd)
Junnbd jdr kst`rs d tdst` kg tb` @dst ilsin` d tdst`guccyoklstruot`n z`l ckm odjil. b` susbi is `xo`cc lt, dln
gkr tbks` kl d junm`t, tb` stir-gry lkknc` nisb`s fdh`
dl `xo`cc`lt culob. Z`okff`ln`n! $$$$
Odptdil L`fk’s (4>, ^kmkckh Fkcnk)
_fdcc ldutiodccy tb`f`n r`stdurdlt witb d s`c`otikl
kg vkodtiv`cy ldf`n nisb`s ilocunilm ‒Gisb grkf tb`
sbip’s jky’ dln ‒^klmu` grkf tb` jkdtswdil’s wig`’.
Oksy wkkn`l ilt`rikr dln pkrtbkc` styc` wilnkws
or`dt` dl uln`rwdt`r ckm odjil `xp`ri`lo`. _pirits,
okohtdics dln d mkkn jusil`ss culob. $$$
Okst` Bkus` (9, Fdlds & ^kmkckh Fkcnk/Zyshuckvd)
^r`dt ykurs`cg tk skf` kg tb` ffll`st okst ` dln odh`s
Jisbh`h bds tk kst`r dt kl` kg tbr`` ‒Okst`` Bkus`s’8
oksy jkutiqu` odgés witb d @urkp`dl dvkur. Ourcup dln r`dn d jkkh, kr aust nrkp il gkr d odst`il` bit
dln d obkokcdt` fflx. $$$
Oksfk Jdr* (_kvi`tshd/Fkshkvshdyd)
Jkdrn tb` sw``t sf`ccilm `c`vdtkr, dso`ln tk tb`
tkp-kkr Oksfk Jdr dln spcdsb tb` odsb witb ykur
g`cckw gr``-sp`lnilm oksfklduts. @c`mdlt ilt`rikr,
pcusb skgds, gdloy nrilhs dln pr`tty wditr`ss`s.
Buzzdb! $$$$
Orkstili (494, Djnrdbfdlkvd)_itudt`n ilsin` tb` Bydtt, tbis is d akilt tk j` r`-s`rv`n gkr d jusil`ss culob kr fdrridm` prkpksdcklcy. Ob`g ^dl`r @rn`fir s`rv`s up fkutb-wdt`r-ilm ilt`rldtikldc ousil`, jut dt d prio`. $$$$$
(Mkrhy/^ylystdlkvd)Mcdfkrkus WIU okfpc`x ilocunilm d r`stdurdlt, jdrdln odsilk. D n`o`ndltcy n`okrdt`n dln p`roucidr-cy ln`drilm bkfdm` tk tb` lktkrikus jdlh rkjj`r- w`’r` sur` b` wkucn dppr`oidt` it. $$$$
Ilt`rldtikldc
Fifilk (:=, Hi`vshdyd)
Fifilk is lio , oksy dln s`rv`s up jkwc-guccs kg st`df-
ilm, b`drty M`krmidl gdr` witb pkf`mrdldt` s``ns
d-pc`lty. ]` r`okff`ln tb` hadnadpuri, hbilhdci dln
dlytbilm tbdt’s s`rv`n il d pkt. ]dtob kut gkr Ploc` Ak`
dt tb` nkkr. $$$$
M`krmidl
Obuobudrd Bkmd (44=, Obui)
]itb tbis Obil`s` r`stdurdlt, d cittc` kut kg tb` wdy
dln rdr`cy visit`n jy tkurists, yku r`dccy g``c yku
dr` m`ttilm tb` r`dc n`dc. Z`qu`st d рмпм (ykur kwl
p`rskldc Obil`s` jkicilm-pkt) dln rdlnkfcy s`c`otd vdri ty kg ulusudc Obil`s` n`ciodoi s tk tbrkw il.
J`wdr , tb` ‒spioy’ sduo , dctbkumb n`cioikus, fdy
c`dv` n`ciodt` stkfdobs il skf` nistr`ss s`v`rdc
bkurs cdt`r - oklsin`r tb` ‒lkt-spioy’ sduo` ds d suit-
djc` dct`rldtiv` $$
Grulz`
(Obui/Urdvnd)Gr`` s`f`obhi is kl` kg fdly r`dskls tk ob`oh kut
tbis civ`cy bdlmkut, rdff`n witb Obil`s` dt culob
dln nill`r tif`. ^b` f`lu is `loyockp`nido il
t`rfs kg sokp`, jut ig yku’r` g``cilm j`wicn`r`n,
aust pkilt tk skf`tbilm tdsty-ckkhilm kl d l`imb-
jkurilm tdjc` cih` w` nin. $$
U`hilm Nuoh I & II
(_kvi`t/Nruzbjd & Obui/^km. Fkc.)
Bum` pkrtikls tk g``n `v`l tb` jimm`st kg mcut-
tkls dln dl @lmcisb cdlmudm` f`lu tbdt prkvin`s
pc`lty kg dfusilm trdlscdtikls. $$
_bdkcil (Qbij`h Qbkcu/Urksp`ot Fir)
^bis tiny ckkhilm r`stdurdlt stiohs kut gkr its sb` rrdlm` kg kri ltdc nisb`s dln its cdrm , rkuln tdjc`s
tbdt fdh` it in`dc gkr `xt`ln`n mdtb`rilms. $$
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 23/28
www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr
:? (Obui/^ylystdlkvd)
Oiviciz`n, gri`lncy odg` jdlm il tb` finnc` kg tkwldln d pkpucdr `x-pdt f``tilm pkilt. _`lsijc` spktgkr oklv`rsdtikl, jut ig yku’r` dckl` tb`r`’s d fili-cijrdry tk p`rus` (dctbkumb cit`rdry ocdssios dr` tbilkl tb` mrkuln). Ob`oh kut tb` Df`riodl pdlodh`sgkr jr`dhgdst, tkp fdrhs. $$$
Gkur _`dskls (447d, ^ylystdlkvd)Kl` kg tb` pksb`st pcdo`s tk `dt kut il Jisbh`h. @c-`mdlt, y`t fkn`rl ilt`rikr dln pkcit` s`rvio`. Mr`dtpcdo` tk spcdsb kut kl d sp`oidc koodsikl kr aust gkrtb` b`cc kg it. $$$$
Gky`r (:=, @rhilnih )Gky`r is dl `xo`cc`lt pcdo` tk `laky dl `v`lilmokohtdic kr ob`oh ykur iljkx witb d oup kg okst``.Gr`` ]i-Gi, mkkn n`s`rts dln jcu`s kl u`sndys.$$$
Mristkl (Fiorkr`mikl =)D oksy ckm-odjil dstdir witb d cdrm` f`dt-rkdstilmo`ltrdc fflr`pcdo`. Kl kl` nisturjilm koodsikl tb`wditilm stdst w`r` djkut ds pc`sdlt ds d julobkg obdvs, jut bkp`guccy tbdt wds d pdssilm pbds`.
Filijus`s 490 dln 445 tdh` yku rimbt pdst it ds ykub`dn kut tk tb` fkultdils. $$$
(Ds`ljdi r`mikl, l`xt tk Oity Ocuj)]` wdtob`n d jdln odcc`n Ciquin Odotus pcdy b`r`dln dnfir`n tb` kcn _kvi`t pdrdpb`ldcid bdlmilmkl tb` wdccs. C`lil fdh`s dl dpp`drdlo` kutsin`tb` jkms dln yku odl m`t _p`htdtkr gdvkurit` W`l-shky` kl tdp. Mkkn j``r sldohs dln tb` jurm`rsdr`l’t jdn itb`r. Lio` gkr d ‒tb`f`’ limbt kut. $$$
(4=9, ^khtkmucd)Dl uln`rmrkuln kdsis kg okkc. Adf is d odg` witb dgucc f`lu, hdcidls (sbisbd pip`s) dln d ckulm` jdrdtfkspb`r`, kp`l ticc ?df . $$$$
Aufdlai (J`biln tb` oirous)It’s strdlm`. bis pcdo` is n`okrdt`n witb gdh` aulmc`gkcidm` dln is jds`n kl d ordp hins’ fflcf y`t sticc skrtkg wkrhs. Yku dcsk m`t tk rkcc d pdir kg Aufdlai nio`j`gkr` yku krn`r gkr tb` obdlo` tk wil d sp`oidc s`-or`t priz` - w` cih` tbis. $$$
(Hucdtkvd/Urdvnd) ^w`lty-gkur bkur spkrts jdr witb civ` fusio dtw``h`lns. Uc`lty kg c`dtb`r okuob`s prkvin` tb`in`dc pcdo` tk sip okohtdics wbicst wdtobilm tb`Obdfpikls c`dmu` dt tbr`` il tb` fkrlilm. $$$$
(??2d, Grulz`)Kl` kg kur gdvkurit` pcdo`s tk nrilh il tb` _uff`r-tif`, wb`l w` odl dstkrn it. Kutnkkr jdcokly-ouf-t`rrdo` bimb djkv` tb` str``t witb sckuob-okuob`sdln ffll` vi`ws kg tb` oirous - wbiob yku odl skf`-
tif`s sf`cc il bkt w`dtb`r. Lio`. $$$
(45?, Fkshkvshdyd)
D prioy, jut pc`dsdlt pcdo` tk wbic` dwdy dl dgt`r-
lkkl. _it il tb` jdr dr`d kv`r d j``r kr ckulm` il tb`
diry lkl-sfkhilm okls`rvdtkry. Dtt`ltiv` s`rvio`
dln d r`gr`sbilm s`c`otikl kg sdcdns, d mkkn pcdo`
gkr d cimbt, b`dctby culob wb`l gdt dln mr`ds` dr`
Jdrs, Z`stdurdlts & Ocujs
^
B @
_p`h tdtkrGiln tb` j`st jdrs il tkwl witb tb` _p`htdtkr dln tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
.ok.uh
Nkco` Witd (447d, Dhbuljd`vd)Oksy Itdcidl r`stdurdlt witb sficilm wditr`ss`s s`rv-ilm xo`cc`lt pizzd. Dcsk s`rv`s sdcdns dln @urkp`dlouisil`. _fdcc t`rrdo` kutsin` gkr suff`rtif` nil-ilm. $$
Oyockl` (4?7, Obui)_fdrt Itdcidl r`stdurdlt witb pcusb ilt`rikr, oi`lt,pkcit` s`rvilm stdst dln d wdrf dtfkspb`r` tk dc-c`vidt` Jisbh`h’s wilt`r obiccs. Udstd nisb`s stdln kutdfklm d f`lu kg trdnitikldc Itdcidl gdvkurit`s. $$$
Dkydfd (9?, khtkmucd)@c`mdlt susbi akilt gr`qu`lt`n jy s`rikus ckkhilmsuit`n-typ`s oklocunilm tb`ir cdt`st nknmy n`dcs. ^b` gkkn’s `xo`cc`lt tbkumb - ig yku odl sordp` tk-m`tb`r `lkumb skfs. $$$$
Gusikl (W`gd O`ltr`, _kvi`tshdyd/Mkrhkvd) ^dh kut is gr`` kl krn`rs kv`r >05 skfs (5?4: 045=5=). `ridhi obioh`l, Fisk skup, susbi rkccs dln pkrhil milm`r sduo` dr` dcc w`cc wkrtb d pbkl` odcc. $$$
Adpdl`s`
Hkr`dl
_dltd Fdrid (:4=, Obui)Ucusb Hkr`dl r`stdurdlt kst`rilm @dst`rl gdvkurit`s,ilocunilm `xoitilm Hkr`dl jdrj`ou`s wb`r` yku m`ttk okkh ykur kwl nill`r, pcus dl `xt`lsiv` @urk-p`dl f`lu. $$$
(F`n`rkvd/^yldstdlkvd) ^bis gkrf`rcy skpbistiodt`n cdin jdoh sbisbd pip`)jdr bds fkv`n tk d l`w ckodtikl dln, jy tb` ckkhskg tb` jdtb il tb` tkic`ts, fdy sticc j` uln`r n`v`c-kpf`lt. ^br`` kkrs, WIU rkkfs, hdciydls dpc`lty.$$$
J`irut (_b`vob`lhk/Grulz`)Lkw il d l`w ckodtikl, J`irut okltilu`s tk s`rv` l-tioilm C`jdl`s` mkkni`s ilocunilm gdcd`, bufus,dln tdsty cittc` f`dt pi` tbilms. $$$
C`jdl`s`
Z`mikldc/O`ltrdc Dsidl
Dnridtiok (:49, Obui)Z`pkrt`ncy sust`rilm gkcckwilm tb` n`pdrtur` kgits Itdcidl ob`g, ]dct`r, dctbkumb w` bdv` j``l tkcntbdt tb` skup is sticc xo`cc`lt. $$$$
Itdcidl
Fkcnkvdl
Fkcnkvd Z`stdurdlt (Hi`vshdyd/^urusj`hkvd)Ig it’s j``l d wbic` silo` yku cdst w`lt kut gkr dFkcnkvdl, tbis wkkn`l pdl`c`n, sturny-tdjc`n `d-t`ry fdy j` tb` dlsw`r tk ykur prdy`rs. Dcsk, tb`Fkcnkvdl @fjdssy is l`xt nkkr sbkucn yku odr`
tk c`drl fkr` djkut tb` wkrcn’s gdvkurit` junm`t-wil` xpkrtilm okultry. $$$
Ilnidl (_kvi`tshdyd, kppksit` tb` Bydtt)
D vdri`n dln ilt`r`stilm f`lu ilocunilm ffll` Ilnidlgkkn fdh` tbis pcdo` d r`dc tr`dt. Kl finw``h ndystb`r` dr` dcsk s`v`rdc xo`cc`lt jusil`ss culob n`dcskst`rilm d skup, sdcdn, fdil okurs` dln n`ss`rt gkr:05-?05 skf. D r`dc stdln kut dln d _p`htdtkr gd-vkurit`! $$$$
(W`gd O`ltr`, _kvi`tshdyd/Mkrhkvd)It’s kl tb` tbirn kkr (ig yku okult mrkuln kkr dstb` fflrst). D ob`dp`r v`rsikl kg ^b` Bkst, ig yku odl
j`dr tb` gdh`-gkltdil`, skuc suohilm lvirkls kg tbis ^urhisb-juict fdcc. b` v`m tdjc` jirydli is mkkn gkrndys wb`l yku dr` g``cilm kst f`dt, wbic` tb` fichyobdi t`d is dutb`ltio, ig d cittc` sw``t. $$
m`ttilm yku nkwl. $$$$
(40, Udlfflckvd)
^b` oklor t` fklstrksity kg tb` Zussidl ^b dtr okl-
o`dcs kl` kg Jisbh`h’s ffll`st dtt`fpts dt d oksy jds`-
f`lt jdr. Gri lncy stdst, d n`o`lt f`lu dln d okcc`otikl
kg kcn jits dln jkjs n`okrdtilm tb` wdccs fdh` @nmdr’s
dl dttrdotiv` dct`rldtiv` tk tb` oity’s fdilstr`df odgés.
D jcu`s jdln pcdys fkst limbts dln d pidlist dnns d rk-
fdltio dfji lo` kl skf` _ulndy v`lilms. $$$
Uiltd Uuj* (4??, Obui)
Jrkumbt tk yku jy tb` sdf` gkchs tbdt kwl tb` j`st
nrdumbt j``r sbkps il tb` oity, Uiltd Uuj is d jrimbt
mr``l siml`n cimbtbkus` gkr tb` _p`htdtkr kl d bkt
ndy. ]itb d bkst kg w`cc-h`pt dc`s kl tdp, gkkn-wis`
w` r`okff`ln okfpc`f`ltilm d lio` ‒Mr``h’ sdcdnwitb dly kg tb` nisb`s grkf tb` pkrh pdm` kl tb`
f`lu, dcc kg wbiob dr` `xo`cc`lt. Z`okff`ln`n! $$$
P Fdzdyd (J`biln ‒Qdhs’ kl _kvi`tshdyd)
Ukssijcy O`ltrdc Dsid’s klcy rdjjit tb`f`n r`stdurdlt.
N`so`ln iltk tbis uln`rmrkuln wdrr`l dln tuoh il.
Dcsk ob`oh kut tb` gdiry-cimbt dnkrl`n dmsbip sist`r-rdjjit-r`stdurdlt il Ds`ljdi fiork r`mikl. $$$
(Fiorkr`mikl =)
Gil`cy pr`s`lt`n nisb`s, r`dskldjcy prio`n j``r (75
skf) m`luil`cy gri lncy dln dtt`ltiv` s`rvio` dln civ`
fusio grkf 2-isb kl fkst `v`lilms. N`ffllit`cy wkrtb
tb` tr`h kut tk tb` sujurjs ( t`cc ykur tdxi nriv`r tk turl
c`gt dt tb` yuzbliy vkrktd dln b`dn tkwdrns Ds`ljdi
gkr djkut 4.0hf) $$$
(:7, Ckmvil`lhk)
^bis pcdo is d l`w gr`` wi-ffl bkl`y pkt gkr `x pdts.
_t`dh is dcwdys dnvisdjc` wb`l `dtilm dt dl dpp`lnix
tk d jutob`r’s, dln tb` sirckil b`r` is `xo`ptikldc. Dcsk,
`laky @lmcisb jr`dhgdsts, obips tbdt dr`l’t okcn dln ck-odc ndrh dc` Obuishikl tdp. Z`okff`ln`n! $$$
J`ccd Itdcid (Hi`vshdyd/H.Dhi`v)
Dnridtiok’s gkrf`r Itdcidl ob`g, ]dct`r, bds fkv n
bkf`s dln is lkw s`rvilm d prdotiodccy in`ltiodcrdlm` kg nisb`s dt tbis spkt aust j`biln Kotkj`r oil-
`fd. @laky tb` j`st pizzd il tkwl, mlkooi dln ktb`r
typiodc Itdcidl lufj`rs, tdsty jusil`ss culob`s grkf
:55 skfs. $$$$
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 24/28
Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
:> Jdrs, Z`stdurdlts & Ocujs
Ocujs ^b`r` dr` skf` Jisbh`h kcn-bdlns wbk sdy tbdt
tbilms dr`l’t wbdt tb`y us`n tk j` wb`l it okf`s tk
limbtcig` il Jisbh`h. ^b`y tdch kg c`m`lndry limbts kg
odrldm`, vkfit, dln n`jduob`ry - n`cimbts tbdt okl-
t`fpkrdry Jisbh`h strummc`s tk kst`r.Lkt sk, w` sdy. dh` ykur pioh grkf tb` cist j`ckw dln
w`’r` sur` tb`r`’s sticc `lkumb odrldm`, vkfit dln
n`jduob`ry il tkwl tk h``p `v`rykl` bdppy.
Urkfzkld (47, Obkcpkl-Dtilshdyd)
www.prkfzkld.hm
Urkfzkld’s gdr-ulm ckodtikl sdncy f`dls d tdxi
rin` kr d cklm wdch bkf` dr` il krn`r dt tb` `ln
kg d limbt. L`v`rtb`c`ss, tbis tr`lny civ` fusio
v`lu` bds d ckt mkilm gkr it1 mkkn jdlns, dl `xt`l-
siv` f`lu, dln d bip ilnustridc ilt`rikr g`dturilm,
strdlm`cy, d wiln tull`c gdl, fdh` tbis kl` kg tb`
j`st limbts kut il Jisbh`h. ^u`sndy is Adzz limbt.
Zkoh kr jcu`s jdlns lkrfdccy pcdy dt tb` w``h-
`lns. (Fusio obdrm` :55-?05 skf)
@sok-jdr (Mkrhkvd, :55 f @dst kg ^dsb Zdjdt)
Ldf`n dgt`r tb` ilgdfkus Okckfjidl okodil`
jdrkl, stdgg dr` ulcih`cy tk jdsb d cil` kut gkr yku
kl drrivdc. ]bdt yku wicc m`t is n`o`lt tul`s fkst
limbts il d ‒pr`-pdrty’ spkt jrkumbt tk yku jy tb`
or`dtkrs kg tb` W`gd o`ltr`’s W`rdlnd. $$$
Q`pp`cil (>?, Obui)
Q`pp`cil is il tb` sdf` v`il ds tb` kcn ^`quicd
Jcu`s jut lkt quit` sk spit dln sdwnust. Kl tb`
limbts w`’v` visit`n, tb`r`’s j``l d cil` up kg ykulm
rkoh kr pulh jdlns struttilm tb`ir stust, b`dvi`r
j`dts s``f tk mk nkwl j`st witb tb` ykulm Zus-
sidl orkwn. Gucc r`stdurdlt f`lu.(@ltrdlo` obdrm` 455-405 skf)
Drjdt (9, Hdrc Fdrhs)
^`c. 04:59>8 04:52=
_fdrt ‒`cit ’ ocuj pkpucdr witb d scimbtcy kcn`rorkwn. _trip jdr dln r`stdurdlt il sdf` juicnilm.
(@ltrdlo` obdrm` :55/?05 skf finw``h, ?05/>05
skf Gri/_dt. _trip jdr =55 skf)
Oity Ocuj (20/4, Qbuh`y`vd-Uunkvhild)
^`c. 04404?8 045024
_k `xocusiv` it fdh`s tb` _p`htdtkr orkwn g``c cih`
ob`dp souf jdms, Oity Ocuj is kl` kg tb` pksb-
`st ocujs il tkwl. M`t pdst tb` ‒gdo` okltrkc’ (umcy
p`kpc` j`wdr`) dln sp`ln ykur `v`lilm witb mdlm-
st`r typ`s, c`ob`rkus nipckfdts, Hdzdhb jusil`ss-
f`l dln d pkss` kg ykulm riob hins wbk dcc s``f tk
bdv` stuni`n il Cklnkl. (@ltrdlo` obdrm`1 mircs :55/
jkys ?55, Gri/_dt mircs ?55/jkys 055
Mkcn`l Jucc (Obui/^kmkckh Fkcnk) ^`c. 7:54?4
D Jisbh`h ilstitutikl. Gucc kg `x-pdts dln tkurists cit`r-
dccy `v`ry limbt kg tb` w``h. Cklm jdr, gri`lncy stdst,
ob`dpisb j``r, `v`rykl`’s bdppy. (@ltrdlo` obdrm`
Xmircs/jkysV gr``/>55 finw``h, 405/>55 Gri/_dt. ‒Gkr-
`iml`rs’ gr``.)
Z`trk F`trk (:>, Fird)
www.r`trkf`trk.hm
Jrimbt, bdppy, 25’s hitsob jdr, tb` NA spils bis r`o-
krns grkf ilsin` tb` grklt kg d W] odfp`r vdl. Kl`
kg tb` fkst pkpucdr pcdo`s gkr pkst-:df pdrtyilm.
(@ltrdlo` obdrm`1 :55/?55 skf finw``h, ?05/>05
skf Gri/_dt. Z`s`rv` gkr :55 skf)
Limbt
Uirkmkst-Wknhil (Hi`vshdyd/^kmkckh Fkcnk)
Ocdssy r`stdurdlt witb d turl kg tb` :5tb o`ltury
dtfkspb`r` s`rvilm Zussidl sp`oidciti`s. Bdv` ykur
t`d il d midlt sdfkvdr . $$$
Hbutkrydlhd (Jkhkljd`vd/Isdlkvd)
Pldssufilm, tk put it ficncy, kl tb` kutsin`, tbis
pcdo` is d r`v`cdtikl kl tb` ilsin`. N`cioikus gkkn,
r`dskldjc` s`rvio`, Phrdilidl jrdss jdln fusio
kl tb` on pcdy`r. ]` ckv it! $$$
^drds Jucjd (L`dr tb Yuzbliy Wkrktd kl _kvi tshdyd)Cih` dcc tb` Phrdilidl r`stdurdlts w`’v` tri`n il
Jisbh`h, drds Jucjd s`rv`s mr`dt gkkn. ]` cih`n tb`
pktdtk pdlodh`s witb odvidr, tb` n`cioikus skups
dln gr`sb sdcdns. $$$
(_kvi`tshdyd/C`v kcstky jrinm`)
^w`lty-gkur bkur akilt tbdt’s d mkns`ln gkr tbks`
wbk m`t ordvilms gkr cdmfdl kr fdlti dt gkur il
tb` fkrlilm. _kf`tif`s sfkhilm isl’t dcckw`n,
skf`tif`s it is, bkw`v`r tb` gkkn dln prio`s dr`
oklstdltcy pr`tty mkkn. Okfgy jkktb styc` s`dts tk
nim ykurs`cg iltk dgt`r d b`dvy limbt. $$
Drzu-I (^kmkckh Fkcnk, l`xt tk tb` stdniuf)
Kst`rs d b`drty s`c`otikl kg Hyrmyz dln @urkp`dl
nisb`s dln d bkf`cy dtfkspb`r`. ^b`r`’s dcsk d
mr`dt kutnkkr t`rrdo` dln ldtikldc gdvkrkuit Drpd
kl nrdumbt. $$
N`r`vydsbhd* (Zyshuckvd, j`biln Nvkr`ts _pkrtd)
Dtfkspb`rio nrilhilm odjil tbdt s`rv`s d rdlm` kg
O`ltrdc Dsidl dln Zussidl ouisil , ds w`cc ds dl if-
pr`ssiv` drrdy kg pivk. ]`cc wkrtb it kl gkktjdcc limbts,
wb`l tb` ckodcs dr` rdtb`r rkwny. $
Gdizd I (Aij`h Akcu/Urksp`ot Fird)
Ukssijcy tb` j`st pcdo` tk fulob trdnitikldc mruj il
tkwl. ^b`ir gri n p`cf`lidln fdlti dr` sk mkkn tbdt
tb`y bdv` kgt`l rul kut jy supp`r-tif . _dv` dl
dpp`tit` dln mk `drcy. _cimbtcy fkr` upfdrh`t sist`r
r`stdurdult kl F`n`rkvd/^yldstdlkvd. $
Gkr`c (Wkr`ltskvhd viccdm`)
^w lty filut`s kutsin` kg Jisbh h, Gkr c is d fflsb-
jds`n ‒r`cdxdtikl o`ltr ’ s`t dfklmst jdjjcilm
str`dfs dln kst`rilm ffll` v`iws kg tb` fkultdils. Gisb
ykur kwl trkut kut kg d pkkc dln bdv` it n``p gdt gri n
gkr ykur pc`dsur . Klcy sdcdns, jr`dn, t`d dln auio` dr`
skcn kl sit` jut yku dr` w`cokf` tk jrilm dly jkkz`
kr mdrlisb yku n`sir , it’s dcsk pkssijc` tk r`lt d JJT.
k m`t tb`r` tdh` d tdxi tk Wkr`ltskvhd viccdm` dln, ig
ykur tdxi nriv`r nk`sl’t hlkw tb` `xdot ckodtikl, dsh d
gri lncy viccdm`r. ^rkut is 255skf/hick $$$
(Dcfdtilhshkyd/Obui)
@xo`cc`lt cittc` stkcyvd ( odlt``l) gucc kg tb` tif`c`ss
r`mikldc gdvkurit`s. J`ilm dl Pimbur r`stdurdlt its m`rkcdmfdl kr cdmfdl pd Pimburshi pdrtioucdrcy stdln kut.Lk sfkhilm, sit, `dt dln c`dv . $
Adcdcdjdn (^kmkckh Fkcnk/Hi vshdyd)
Jdsiodccy tb` ob`dp`st gkkn (tbdt wkl’t miv` yku mut
rkt) il tb` o`ltr` kg tkwl. ]bic` it sbkucn stdln kut gkr
its gr`sb cdmfdl, Adcdcdjdn is skf`tif`s kv`rckkh`n.
Urkjdjcy dt its j`st il suff`r, wb`l tb` sbdsbcyh
fdst`rs dlhilm tb` `ltrdlo` kst`r tb`ir or`dtikls
strdimbt tk mu`sts sittilm dt @dst`rl-styc` tdjc`s ‟ orkss
ykur c`ms dln s`` bkw cklm j`gkr` ordfp s`ts il. $
^uj`it`ihd (Fkshkvshdyd/^urusj`hkvd)
Bdrn tk sp`cc jut mr`dt tk `dt dt. ^b` f`lu is w`cc
j`ykln tb` trdnitikldc O`ltrdc Dsidl sokp`, witb lknstk Obild, Adpdl dln @urkp , tkk. ]` cih`n tb` Obil`s`
obioh`l, tb` susbi dln tb` sbdsbcyh . $$$
Civ fusio dcsk okffkl dt _tdry @nmdr’s, J`dtc`s
Jdr, Gky`r dln Jckln`r Uuj (s` ‒r`stdurdlts’)
Zussidl/Phrdilidl
Nishkhcujs
Civ` Fusio
^urhisb
B`dv`l (Grulz`/Urdvnd - il tb` Bkt`c Nkstuh)
Ds B`dv`l is gkuln ilsin` d bkt`c it is surprisilmcy
uls``ny. Il gdot it stdlns kut gkr j`ilm d jdstikl kg
tb` w`cc-nr`ss`n (ig kl` is m`l`rkus). ^url up il tdtty
a`dls dln d t-sbirt dln yku fdy g``c d cittc` kut kg
pcdo`8 tb`l dmdil, yku fdy lkt miv` d sbit. ^djc`s jy
tb` ndlo`kkr okst 4555 skf jut ilocun` nrilhs uptk tbis vdcu`. (@ltrdlo` obdrm` :55->55 skf)
Gir` & Io` (^ylystdlkvd/@rhilnih)
D scimbtcy mritti`r v`rsikl kg Mkcn`l Jucc. Dmdil, gkr-
`iml`rs odl kgt`l m`t il gkr gr``. Ukpucdr tbrkumbkut
tb` w``h. (@ltrdlo` ‒gkr`iml`rs’ gr``)
Mvkzn (]`st`rl sin` kg tb` Ubicbdrfklid)
Gkr`iml`rs gkr gr``, urjdl mrkkv`s dln doo`ptdjc`
prio`s dt tb` jdr. ‒Mvkzn’ f`dls ‒ldic’ il Zussidl, jut
yku’v` prkjdjcy mkt d j`tt`r obdlo` dt tb` Mkcn`l
Jucc. Its dcfkst cih` tb` orkwn grkf Ubdrdkb bdv` fi-
mrdt`n. (@ltrdlo` ‒gkr`iml`rs’ gr``)
Ucdtiluf (@dst sin` kg tb` Ubicbdrfklid)
dh` d s`dt dt tb` sldzzy ?75 n`mr`` jdr dln nk
jdttc` witb skf` kg Hyrmyzstdl’s fkst oklvividc
‒`cit ’ gkr mkcn-nimmilm t`fptr`ss`s. (@ltrdlo`
obdrm` >55-055 skf)
_w``t _ixti`s (Fkckndyd Mvdrnid/Hi`vshdyd)
Civ` okv`r jdlns fkst limbts. Gucc f`lu, pkpucdr
witb d ykulm`r orkwn. $$
(477, _kvi`tshdyd)
D mkkn kutnkkr t`rrdo` dln skf` b`drty gkkn, juttb` Hdrdkh` styc` orkkl`rs wbk prkvin` `v`lilm
`lt`rtdilf`lt dr` dl doquir`n tdst`. $$
Buzur (Hi`vshdyd/^kmkcuh Fkcnk,)
Oklvividc prkpri`tkr Dci ocdifs tk bdv` _t`v`l M`r-
rdrn’s :550 Obdfpikl’s C`dmu` willilm Civ`rpkkc
sbirt. Ig yku nkl’t j`ci`v` tbdt, j`civ` il gr`` c`pyksb-
hd dln mkkn, dstkrndjc` ^urhisb ouisil`. $$
Hkldh (_kvi`tshdyd/Mkrhkvd)
^bis ^urhisb akilt us`n tk j` ‒Z`stdurdlt Odf`ckt’
b`lo` tb` iloklmrukus suits kg drfkur il tb` jdoh
rkkf, dln tb` rdtb`r ordppy odstc` gdodn . Bkw`v`r,
tb` gkkn is kgt`l mr`dt, tb` sdcdns dr` cdrm` dln gr`sb,
dln tb` stdst dr` dcwdys pc`dsdlt. Z`okff`ln`n!
(Dln lkw kp`l :> bkurs d ndy) $$
Kadh (Kl @rhilnih j`tw``l Fkshkvshdyd, khtkmucd)
^ obliodccy dl ‒Dz`rjdiadlidl’, jut nkl’t c`t tbis gdot
ruil tb` j`st vdcu` h`jdjs il tkwl. ^b` f`lu is
cifit`n dln ig ykur Zussidl is tkk, aust sdy ‒h`jdj’ dln
skf`tbilm ob`dp dln tdsty wicc drriv`. $
Dppc` (:2, Fdlds)
Gdt, kcn, c`ob`rkus gkr`iml`rs lkt w`cokf`, tbis
pcdo` is gkr d ykulm`r okkc`r orkwn. Fuctipc` jdrs,
cdrm` ndlo` kkr, gri`lncy dtfkspb`r`. ^bursndy
usudccy d jim limbt. (@ltrdlo` obdrm` 455-?55 skf)
Qdpkryzbid (9, Urksp`ot Fird)
Z`o`ltcy kp`l`n, Qdpkryzbid is d okssdoh d-
vkur`n r`stdurdult il d vdrlisb-so`lt`n ckm odj-
il. B`drty rustio nisb`s dln d bkf`cy dtfkspb`r`.
^b` f`nkvuhbd is r`okff`ln`n! $$$
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 25/28
www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr
:0Fdp
H i ` v s h d
y d
^ k h t k
m u c d
^ k h t k
m u c d
^ k h t k
m u c d
F k s h k v s h d
y d
F k s h k
F k s h k v s h d
y d
H i ` v s h d
y d
Fd ld s d v`.
Fd ld s d v`.
C v d ^ k c s t k m k
C v d ^ k c s t k
m k
C v d k c s t k
m
k
F k c k nd yd M vd r
A i j ` h
A k c u
A i j
`
A u f d j ` h
H k`l h k zk vd
Isdlk vd
. D j n
y f k f u l k v
@ l
m ` c s d
Z y
s
h u c k v d
F i o b d ` c G r u l z `
_ p
d r t d h
s t d n i u f
F i o b d ` c G r u
l
z `
D j n
y f k f u l k v
d
J d ` t k v d
A u f d j ` h
@ r h i l
O i r o u s
^ y l y s td lk
vd
Zd z zd h k vd
Zd z zd h k vd Krk z j h k vd
Krk z j h k vd
J k h k l j d ` v d
y d j c k
m u
^
J k h k l
Ckm v il`l h k
Isdlk vd Isdlk vd
y l y s td lk vd
D. P s l jd vd
@ c jd vd
Gd t id lk vd
_ bk pk h k vd
_ bk pk h k vd
M k m k c y d
M k m k c y dK
m k
l j d ` v d
^kmk ck h Fk cnk
@ r h i ln i h
_ K W @ _ HD YD
U r d v n d
U r d v n d
_ K W @ _ HD YD
_ K W @ _ HD YD
O b u i
O b u
i
O b u i
F k c k nd yd M vd r n i
d
Fd ld s d v`.
H i ` v s h d
y d
^ B @ F K P L ^ D I L _
Lkr tb
N vkr ts
_pkr td
7
2
0>
:
=
?
47
459
44
4:
4?
40
4>
42
4
:0
:7
:>
:=::
49
:5
:4
:?
4=
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 26/28
Fdy :544 ^b` _p`htdtkr www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
:7
Fdy 42tb
@nuodtikl gdir
_pkrts Udcdo` (Grulz`/ kmkcuh Fkcnk)
Juy p`loics, ruc`rs dln sobkkc uligkrfs dtnisokult prio`s
Fdy :4st
Civ` Fusio G`stivdc ‒Uucs`’
Dppc` Ocuj (Fdlds/ khtkmucd)
Udrt kg tb` Dumustd ilitidtiv` dt tb` Dppc` ocujwbuob bds dcr`dny jrkumbt tkp NAs grkf tb`Phrdil` dln Zussid. Jisbh`h’s tr`lns`tt`rs jufp
dln mriln tk tb` gulhi`st mrkkv`s il tkwl.@ltrdlo`1 :55 skfs
Fdy ::ln
^b` Cklm`st Ndlo` il Cig`
Zussidl Nrdfd b`dtr`
Ilt`rldtikldc ndlo` g`stivdc witb d oduodsus(Drf`lidl/M`krmidl) dvkur p`gkrf`n jy
tb` Hdzdhb-Hyrmyz Or`dtiv` Okcc`otiv`. _kulnsulusudc, dt dly rdt`.
^`c1 7:-40-02
Fdy :0
Hl``s up gkr Mrdnudt`s
Kl tb` squdr` kutsin` Hilkt`dtr Zkssiyd
Akil Jisbh`h’s sobkkc mrdnudtikl ocdss kg :544 dstb`y aiv` tb` `v`lilm dwdy tk civ` fusio kl Obuiprkf`ldn`. _tdrts dt 49.55.
Aul` 0tb
Ndlo` G`stivdc
Jisbh`h Bufdliti`s Pliv`rsity (Fdlds :=)Urkmrdff` wicc g`dtur` pkpndloilm, j`ccyndloilm dln str``t ndloilm il tb` gdux-Zkfdl
okckss`uf `lvirkls kg tb` JBP. J`mils dt 44.55,rkulns kst dt 4>.55.
`fdic C`ri[dErdfjc`r.ru gkr n`tdics
Aul` 44tb
^b` Mr`dt Bkt ]dt`r _witob kl!
D r`p`dt kg cdst y`dr’s `v`lt wbiob mkt rdv`r`vi`ws. Dlludccy, Jisbh`h dutbkriti`s out bktwdt`r il tb` oity tk r`pdir tb` dm`ilm OBU
ilgrdstruotur`, r`nuoilm lkl-jkic`r kwl`rstk sbkw`rs witb wkhs, sduo`pdls, h`ttc`s dlnktb`r hitob`lwdr` it`fs. ^bis y`dr tb`y out it kl
Fdy 44tb, dln prkfis`n r`pdirs wkucn cdst lkcklm`r tbdl d fkltb. C`ts s``.
.
Fdy 42tb - ?4st ^PH Ndt`s gkr Fdy @lt`rtdilf`lt Nir`otkry
Fdp1 Ckodtikl muin`
4. J`ccd Itdcid
:. F`trk Jdr (Df`riodl Uuj)
?. F`xiodl Odlt``ld>. Qdpkryzbidl Limbts
0. Okst` Bkus (I)7. Wis-d-Wis
:4. _tdry @nmdrs::. _PF N`pdrtf`lt _tkr`
:?. Adf
:>. Fifilk:0. Drdjiod
:7. Jckln`r Uuj:=. W@GD sbkppilm O`ltr`
4>. L`w Ykrh Uizzd40. Uiltd Uuj
47. Ldtikldc Fus`uf
4=. Ldvimdtkr42. _hy Jdr
49. Gky`r:5. Gdtjky’s
=. J`td _tkr`s _up`rfdrh`t2. N`r`vydsbhd
9. Oyockl`
45. Okst`` Bkus (II)44. Dnridtiok
4:. _dltd Fdrid4?. Gdizd
^b` Uupp`t b`dtr`
_kvi`tshdyd/Fioburild
U`rgkrfdlo`s kl _ulndys dt 44155df.
Zussidl Nrdfd b`dtr`
^ylystdlkvd, 4:: (_itudt`n il Kdh Udrh)
^`c.1 77:5?:, 7:40=4
Bkurs1 Fkl-_ul, 45155-42155
^ioh`ts ?5-455 skf
Ckodc dln ilt`rldtikldc pcdys il Zussidl.
^b` Okls`rvdtkry
Adltksb`vd, 440
^`c1 >=90>:
Oklo`rts jy stun`lts dln prkg`sskrs.
Hyrmyz _tdt` Ubicbdrfklio
Obui Urksp`ot, :0?
^`c1 :4::7:, :4::?0
Bkurs1 4=155-49155 il suff`r
^ioh`ts1 =5-455 skf (skf`tif`s fuob fkr` gkrsp`oidc p`rgkrfdlo`s)
^b`r` dr` twk oklo`rt bdccs g`dturilm ocdssiodc,
trdnitikldc Hyrmyz, dln pkp oklo`rts dln d vdri`ty
kg sbkws.
Kp`rd Jdcc`t b`dtr`
_kvi`tshdyd/Djnyfululkvd
^`c1 77 40 >2
Bkurs1 4=155-49155
^ioh`ts1 405-755 skf
^ioh`ts gkr p`rgkrfdlo`s s`cc kut v ry quiohcy dln
it is l`o`ssdry tk jkkh d s`dt il dnvdlo`.
Gkr dcc tb` Jisbh`h kp`rd, jdcc`t dln oklo`rt cistilms,
ob`oh kur gr`qu`ltcy upndt`n ]bdt’s Kl cistilms dt1
www.tb`sp`htdtkr.ok.uh
Civ` upndt`s
Fdy :5tb-:=tb
^rip tk tb` cdh`s Hdrd-_uu dln H`c-Jdsby
Ilgk1
^b Hdrd-_uu cdh is situdt`n dt tb zkl kg ^dhtd-cyh rdlm , djkut :555 f djkv s`d c`v c, il tb ckw`rr`dob`s kg tb Hdphd-^dsb riv`r. ^b c`lmtb kg tb cdh`
is djkut 7.0 hf, tb wintb is 4.0-: hf, dv`rdm n`ptbdjkut 95 f. ^b sbkr`s dr n`ls cy kv`rmrkwl jy ti`l-sbdl spruo , drobd, rkwdl, jdrj`rry dln ktb`r nist`r`ltjusb`s. ^b cdh ’s ocifdt is wdrf, nry & t`fp`rdt .^b suff`r’s t`fp`rdtur is ::-:> n`mr` djkv z`rk,il limbt is 2-4> n`mr``s djkv z`rk. ]iln oklnitikls dr`fkn`rdt .
Urkmrdf1
4st ndy ‟ Jisbh`h ‟ Obiobhdl vdcc`y, kv`rlimbt stdydt it8 :ln ndy ‟ Hdrd-_uu cdh , kv`rlimbt stdy8 ?rn ndy- Hdrd-_uu cdh , d ocifj tk tb` pdlkrdfio suffitDcdfpdsy ?=0: f8 >tb ndy ‟ Hdrd-_uu cdh` trdlsg`rtk H`c-Jdsby cdh` (Hdphd-^dsb), kv`rlimbt stdy8 0tbndy ‟ ^r`hhilm drkuln tb` cdh , kv`rlimbt stdy8 7tbndy ‟ Z`turl tk Hdrd-_uu cdh , kv`rlimbt stdy8 =tbndy ‟ N`pdrtur` tk Jisbh`h.
Fdy :4st-::ln
H`h-Fkyluh Mkrm` bihilm `xp`nitikl
^wk ndys bih` drkuln tb` H`h-Fkylkh mkrm`. Kv`r-limbt stdy l`xt jy tb` spruo` gkr`st. ^r`h tk H`h-Fkylkh cdh . ^b` c`lmtb kg tb` bih` is djkut :5 hf.
Fdy :2tb
Ndy trip tk _khucuh mkrm` (J`cdmkhd)
Wisit d ckodc wdt`rgdcc dln r`turl tk Jisbh`h. Lkl odt-`mkriodc trip suitdjc` tk dcc dm`s dln djiciti`s.
Fdy :9tb
Ndy trip tk tb` Dcdf`nil mkrm`
]dch il tb` pdlkrdfd kg tb` Jcdoh Gilm`r dln Dfdl- kk U`dhs. Bih` tk ckodc wdt rgdcc dln kp`l dir pio-lio. Wisit ckodc sprilm. rip gkr wdch`rs kg dcc dm`s dlndjiciti`s. Nistdlo` 4: hf. ^rdlspkrt dln krmdlizdtiklilocunilm oklsuctdtikl dln muin` gkr d mrkup kg 40oksts :25 skf (^PH f`fj`rs ::5 skf).
Fdy :9tb
Zdgtilm kl tb` Obu riv`r
Zdgtilm dt tb` Jkkf mkrm` (odt`mkry :-?) dcklm tb`Obu riv`r, nurdtikl : ‟ :,0 bkurs, :0 hf. 4>55 skfsp`r p`rskl.
Mrkups f``t tb` ^bursndy j`gkr` tb` w``h`ln kgn`pdrtur . Odcc (5?4:) 957 440 kr `fdic us dt tr`hE`codt.hm. ]`j sit 1 bttp1//www.tr`h-hyrmyzstdl.okf
]itb tb r`o`lt r c ds kg tb Ilt`rldtikldc Okffissikl’s
ilv`stimdtikl iltk cdst y`dr’s Aul vikc lo , oity jr`dhs ilKsb dln Adcdc-Djdn dr lkt dnvisdjc . Bkw`v`r, tdhilm d
n`tkur kst tb Ksb rkdn dln b`dnilm tkwdrns tb v`rndlt
Cdh _dry Ob c h o`rtdilcy is. bis m`f kg Hyrmyzstdl tdh`sdl dm tk m`t tk jut is o`rtdilcy wkrtb tb bduc. Okltdot
ckodc trdv c dm`loy Lkvi Lkfdn gkr n`tdics (5009 00> 002).
_p`htrdc ^rdv`c
]bdt’s Kl
Hyrmyz Z`pujcio, Jisbh`h, Obui dv. >D, Ko` D> ^ c.1 +997 (?4:) 95 74 40, 95 74 ?9`-fdic1 tr`hE`codt.hm,w`jsit`1 www.tr`h-hyrmyzstdl.okf, www.tuh.hm
^r`hhilm Plikl kg Hyrmyzstdl
Ndt`s gkr _uff`r
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 27/28
7/21/2019 The Spektator Issue 17
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/the-spektator-issue-17 28/28