the us experience case studies and examples from the ftc ...€¦ · amy ralph mudge...

57
Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience – Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond presented for Canadian Institute’s Annual Advertising & Marketing Law Conference January 24, 2017

Upload: others

Post on 24-May-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

Amy Ralph Mudge

AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com

The US Experience – Case Studies and

Examples from the FTC and Beyond

presented for

Canadian Institute’s Annual Advertising & Marketing Law

ConferenceJanuary 24, 2017

Page 2: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Page 3: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Common Ground 2014

Page 4: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Canada Rocks!

Page 5: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

2017

Page 6: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

2017

Page 7: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond
Page 8: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond
Page 9: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Canada Rocks!

Page 10: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

FTC -- a Year Ago and Today

Page 11: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

New FTC?

Page 12: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

Health Claims

Doctor, Doctor

Thompson Twins

Page 13: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Supple LLC (stipulated order)

Page 14: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Aura Lab, Inc. (stipulated order)

Page 15: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Prevagan Complaint (1/9/17)

Page 16: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond
Page 17: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Mars Petcare US, Inc. (consent order)

Page 18: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Green Marketing

Page 19: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Volkswagen Group of America (stipulated order)

Page 20: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

ABS Consumer Products (consent order)

Beyond Coastal (consent order)

Erickson Marketing Group (consent order)

Trans-India Products (consent order)

California Naturel (Commission Opinion)

Page 21: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Safety Claims

Page 22: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

General Motors (consent order)

Page 23: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

CarMax (Proposed Consent Order)

Page 24: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Endorsements and Social Media

Page 25: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Smart Click Media LLC (stipulated order)

Page 26: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Supple LLC (stipulated final judgment)

Page 27: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Warner Bros. Home Entertainment, Inc. (consent order)

Page 28: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Warner Bros. Home Entertainment, Inc. (consent order)

This video is sponsored by Warner Brothers.

Page 29: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Warner Bros. Home Entertainment, Inc. (consent order)

No one reads this far into the description.What are you doing snooping around.

Page 30: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Lord & Taylor, LLC (consent order)

Page 31: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond
Page 32: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Native Advertising

Page 33: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Lord & Taylor, LLC (consent order)

Page 34: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Consumer Reviews

Page 35: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Consumer Review Fairness Act of 2016

Page 36: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Consumer Perception

Page 37: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Page 38: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Data Security/Privacy

Page 39: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Ashley Madison (stipulated order)

Page 40: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

ASUSTeK Computer Inc. (consent order)

Page 41: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond
Page 42: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

United States v. Inmobi PTE Ltd., (stipulated order)

Page 43: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond
Page 44: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond
Page 45: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Education/Business Opportunity

Page 46: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

DeVry Education Group (stipulated order)

Page 47: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Trump University (NY Attorney General Settlement)

Page 48: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Herbalife International of America, Inc. (stipulated

order)

Page 49: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Consumer Financial Issues

Page 50: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

FTC v. AMG Services, Inc. (order)

Page 51: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Western Union (stipulated order)

Page 52: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Page 53: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Made in U.S.A.

Page 54: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

Chemance, Inc. (Stipulated Order)

Page 55: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

2016 Look Back in US Consumer Protection

Enforcement

• Health Claims

• Green Marketing

• Safety Claims

• Endorsements/Social Media

• Native Advertising

• Consumer Reviews

• Consumer Perception

• Data Security/Privacy

• Education/Business Opportunity

• Consumer Financial Issues

• Made in USA

Page 56: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

© 2016 Venable LLP

2017 Predictions

• FTC: Refocus on hard core fraud, return to economic harm

analysis

• Back to basics with health claims

– Continued tagalong with broad review of marketing practices

• Renewed focus on survey evidence to support implied claims

• Made in USA may be reexamined

• Privacy/data security application to new technology albeit not

new ground

• CFPB: ????

• State AGs more activist

• Class actions increase

• Lanham Act cases on the rise

Page 57: The US Experience Case Studies and Examples from the FTC ...€¦ · Amy Ralph Mudge AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com The US Experience –Case Studies and Examples from the FTC and Beyond

Amy R. Mudge

Partner

Venable LLC

202.344.4743

[email protected]

AllAboutAdvertisingLaw.com

Questions?