value at risk studies of industrial security portfolio by naman swaroop
DESCRIPTION
A METHODOLOGY FOR OPTIMIZING PORTFOLIO RISK USING CRYSTAL BALLby naman swaroop, contact 9358423378 for assistanceTRANSCRIPT
Value at Risk
A PRESENTATIONON
VALUE AT RISK (VaR) STUDIES OF INDUSTRIAL SECURITIES PORTFOLIO
A METHODOLOGY FOR OPTIMIZING PORTFOLIO RISK USING CRYSTAL BALL
PRESENTED BYNAMAN SWAROOP
057515Mob:9358423378
Value at Risk
INTRODUCTION
For Investors, risk is about the odds of losing money.
What is my worst case scenario?How much could I lose in a really bad month?
Value at Risk
INTRODUCTION
“VAR summarizes the worst case loss over a target horizon with a given level of confidence.”
- Philippe Jorion
“Value at risk measures the worst case expected loss that an institution can suffer over a given time interval under normal market conditions at a given confidence level. It assesses this risk by using statistical and simulation models designed to capture the volatility of assets in a portfolio.”
-Cormac Butler
Value at Risk
INTRODUCTION
A portfolio is a bundle or combination of individual assets or securities.
VaR of a portfolio is simply
σ X z σ:standard deviation of portfolio z: z score value at a given confidence. eg:2.33 @ 99%
Value at Risk
VaR CALCULATION METHODS
Three methods:
1. HISTORICAL METHOD2. VARIANCE-COVARIANCE METHOD3. MONTE-CARLO SIMULATION
Value at Risk
MONTE CARLO METHOD(MCS) Historical/Implied
Data
Model parameters
FUTURE PRICES
Full Valuation
Securities Model
Portfolio Positions
Distribution Of values
STOCHASTIC
MODEL
Value at Risk
CRYSTAL BALL (CB)& MCS
CB WORKING MODEL
Value at Risk
PROBLEM IDENTIFICATION
How investors can lower the risk in their equity investment portfolio by sensible diversification ?
Value at Risk
OBJECTIVES
• To calculate the Value at Risk of the industrial securities portfolio, so that, the investor can invest in modified Sensex portfolio by choosing similar alternative securities within ‘A’ group securities in terms of volatility with his own level of risk taking ability.
• To understand the awareness of institutional investor and the technique used by those to manage risk adjusted return.
Value at Risk
NEED OF THE STUDY
An investor invests on the basis of his risk taking ability. This study is to develop a methodology to measure or to calculate the possible loss in worst case. If the investor is ready to take that much of the risk, then only he will invest in that portfolio.
Value at Risk
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY• NATURE OF THE STUDY: Analytical Study• SAMPLING TECHNIQUE: Judgmental Sampling (Sensex)
• SAMPLE• Primary Data: A web based questionnaire was developed for
professionals working in the field of Risk Management.• Sample Size : 3
• Secondary Data: The secondary data (share prices) is collected from www.bseindia.com
• SOFTWARE USED FOR STATISTICAL CALCULATIONMS Excel 2003Crystal Ball 5.1 Student Edition
Value at Risk
ANALYSIS
ASSUMPTIONS– Dividend is not taken into consideration.– The Scrip’s rate of return follows a normal
distribution.– The holding period for VaR calculation is one
day.
Value at Risk
ANALYSIS
• STEP ONE– Data Adjustment
– Capital Gain(P1-P0) / P0
– Average Rate of Return– Standard Deviation (Volatility)– Correlation Matrix
BAJAJAUTO(dummy data)
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
1 176 351 526 701 876 1051 1226 1401 1576 1751
Observations
pri
ce
BAJAJAUTO
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
1 176 351 526 701 876 1051 1226 1401 1576 1751
Observations
Pri
ce
ADJUSTMENT
Value at Risk
ANALYSIS
• STEP TWO– Sorting– Formation of Portfolio
Portfolio 1 Portfolio 2 Portfolio 3 Small Standard Deviation Medium Standard Deviation High Standard Deviation GLAXO RANBAXY IPCL BAJAJAUTO GRASIM INFOSYSTCH ABB DRREDDY BPCL HINDALC0 SUNPHARMA SatyamAdj SBIN ONGC SAIL RELIANCE ORIENTBANK WIPRO HDFCBANK DABUR HCLTECH ACC GAIL VSNL CIPLA BHEL ZEETELE SIEMENS MTNL ICICIBANK
Value at Risk
ANALYSIS• STEP 3
– Portfolio Values are inserted– Crystal Ball is invoked
• STEP 4– Assumptions, Decision Variables & Forecast Cells
are defined.– MODELLING EQUATION
Value at Risk
ANALYSIS
• STEP 5– SIMULATION– The Crystal Ball generates the descriptive
statistics.
Demonstration
Value at Risk
FINDINGS
QUESTIONNAIRE
NAME DESIGNATION ORGANISATION SWAMI DAYAL FINANCIAL ANALYST /
CREDIT OFFICER DENA BANK
NISARG A. DESAI MARKET RISK ANALYST
ICICI BANK LIMITED
SACHIN BANSAL MANAGER - RISK ANALYTICS
CREDIT SUISSE
1
2
3
Value at Risk
FINDINGS
QUESTIONNAIRE: Financial Institutional Investors• Measuring risk is one of the crucial activities carried out by
these financial institutions.• These institutions have group of experts for the purpose of
calculating VaR.• As per the response from the designed questionnaire we
have seen the that , Value at Risk is being used by the financial institutions. It is very specialized field of activity, utilized by experts.
• For the purpose of calculation of VaR, they are using almost all possible method of calculations.
Value at Risk
FINDINGS
• PORTFOLIO ANALYSISVaR is calculated at
99% confidence95% confidence
Value at Risk
FINDINGS:VaR @ 99 %
PORTFOLIO 1
VALUE @
RISK
Value at Risk
FINDINGS:VaR @ 99 %
PORTFOLIO 2
VALUE @
RISK
Value at Risk
FINDINGS:VaR @ 99 %
PORTFOLIO 3
VALUE @
RISK
Value at Risk
FINDINGS:VaR @ 95 %
Value at Risk
FINDINGS: MODIFIED PORTFOLIO
We Repalced ICICI with PNB in portfolio 3 and run the simulation.
VALUE @ RISK
Value at Risk
FINDINGS: TABLE OF RESULTS
PORTFOLIO STANDARD DEVIATION
MINIMUM (Rs)
MAXIMUM (Rs)
MEAN (Rs)
PORTFOLIO 1 2,959.92 -9,032.22 10,638.20 204.54 PORTFOLIO 2 3,042.05 -8,474.52 10,712.97 221.81 PORTFOLIO 3 5,676.53 -17,278.36 20,330.57 393.11 PORTFOLIO 3* 4,867.49 -14,254.34 17,327.22 685.78
Modified Portfolio
Value at Risk
RECOMMENDATIONS
While maintaining the return it is possible to reduce the VaR in a portfolio by substituting with a less volatile security from a group instead of most volatile sensex security.
Such improvement in the risk adjusted return on capital (RAROC) can be achieved in each of the 3 above mentioned portfolios.
It is for each institutional investor to restructure his equities portfolio in accordance with his objectives using the tools and techniques that have been demonstrated in this project work.
Value at Risk
CONCLUSION
The methodology used to optimize the portfolio risk by measuring value at risk of the portfolio is very useful in real life situation also, as it is based on Monte Carlo Simulation. An investor can easily identify his preferred portfolio by knowing the worst case loss. The calculations are based on real life data; hence it presents a true picture of calculations and behavior of portfolio value.
Value at Risk
LIMITATIONS
Crystal Ball
Time and hardware restrictions made it extremely difficult to examine a large number of equity substitutions for observing there effect on risk and return .
Value at Risk
LIMITATIONS
Questionnaire
Number of responses to the questionnaire was very small owing to the necessity of inviting responses from experts in this area of specialization. Moreover this time of the year the expert are tied-up with preparation of annual accounts for the year ended 31st march and so getting responses from them was extremely difficult.
Value at Risk