welcome to the jovial kick-off meeting...kick-off: april 2016 instrumental design: october 2016...

29
Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting

Upload: others

Post on 22-Sep-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting

Page 2: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

JOVIAL Jovian Oscillations through radial Velocimetry ImAging

observations at several Longitudes

Page 3: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

JOVIAL Kick-off meeting • Objectives of the meeting

•Programme

•JOVIAL project overview • Context

• History of the project •Scientific objectives •Work programme •Organisation

2010, February 15th DSI Science Workshop - Observatoire de Nice 3 3 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 4: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Objectives of the meeting

• Definition of the scientific objectives • Position of the project in the scientific context • Organisation of the science groups • Technical organisation of the network • Identify key technical issues (telescope) • Task responsabilities and planning • Data policy

2010, February 15th DSI Science Workshop - Observatoire de Nice 4 4 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 5: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Kick-off agenda

5 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Monday, April 18th Observatoire de Nice, La Nef room

Presentation of the JOVIAL project Lunch

Science with JOVIAL

Tuesday, April 19th Observatoire de Nice, La Nef room

Mode physics Lunch

Instrument Session Other science/ complementary projects

Meeting Dinner Restaurant Les Pêcheurs

Page 6: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Kick-off agenda

6 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Wednesday, April 20th University of Nice, Fizeau building, Room Olivier Chesneau

Technical plans Visit of the laboratory and the instrument bench Lunch Organisation of the project Discussion Meeting end

Thursday, April 21th

Calern Observatory Visit of the observatory

Page 7: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

JOVIAL

• Observation strategy – Fourier imaging tachometer – Observation network

• Scientific goals

− Internal structure of giant planets by seismology

− Study of planetary atmosphere dynamics

7 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 8: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Internal structure of giant planets

• Only few constraints • Mass, radius • Gravitational moments • Heat flux • Surface composition

• Non uniqueness

• Initial conditions (formation) • Evolution (core erosion) • Equations Of State

Having access to the internal structure would give unique clues to formation and evolution of the Solar System

8

(see T. Guillot & M. Ikoma)

JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 9: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

R/Rjup

Wei

ghtin

g fu

nctio

ns

M J2

J4

J6

J8

H+-H2 transition

Core

JUNO will enter the jovian system in June Gravitational moments measurements directly probe the outer regions

Guillot, 2005

Gravitational moments

9 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

(see D. Durante)

Page 10: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Seismology of giant planets (see B. Mosser & J. Jackiewicz)

• As terrestrial seismology, asteroseismology allows the study of internal structure

• Modes frequencies depends on density (and rotation)

• Modes of different degrees penetrate to different depths

10 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

νobs - νtheoretical

Inversion method

ρobs - ρtheoretical

Page 11: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Mode types

11 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

• Following the main restoring force, modes could be of different types

• Acoustic modes or p modes • Gravity modes or g modes • Surface modes or f modes

Page 12: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Recent results in seismology of giant planets

• Jupiter • SYMPA project: 2000 – 2010 - Gaulme et al 2011

• Saturn

• Cassini - Hedman & Nicholson 2013

Open a new window on the interior of giant planets

12 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 13: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Detection of Jovian global oscillations

•Ground based observations with SYMPA

•Power excess in the range [800 – 3000] µHz

•~ 20 individual peaks with mean amplitude 30 cm/s ± 10 cm/s •Regularly spaced peaks: ∆ν0= 154.5 µHz ± 1.5 µHz

• Fundamental frequency good agreement with most models (mean density) Individual modes identification requires long continuous observation with good spatial resolution Gaulme et al, 2011

13 13 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 14: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Saturn • Density waves in Saturn rings (Hedman & Nicholson, 2013)

• Compatible with f-modes • Predicted by Porco & Marley 1991 • Cassini observations of stellar

occultations • Identification of azimutal number • Saturn f-modes have long life-time • Consequences on internal structure

to be studied – See Jim Fuller’s talk

14 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 15: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Project history

SYMPA project (2000-2010) Echoes proposal for JUICE mission Doppler Sismo Imager (R&T CNES 2009 -2013) 2014: JIVE in NM (NASA-EPSCOR)

2015: JOVIAL selection • ANR (Agence Nationale pour la recherche) white

program • 4 years project (2016 -2019) • 420 k€

15 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 16: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Probing internal structure

16

• Complete gravitational moments (JUNO)

• Measure the size of the core

• Investigate H-H2 transition

• Give internal rotation profile

16 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 17: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Wind speed measurement • Cloud-tracking is affected by cloud

deformation and waves • Doppler measurements give true

aerosol displacement • Complete High Angular Resolution

follow-up - See R. Hueso

17 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 18: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Best detection level: 1 bar

Top of the cloud (visible)

Resolved images and velocity maps

Detection of acoustic modes

18 10 December 2010 JPL Pasadena 18 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 19: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Mode excitation

• Few theoretical works • Estimation by Bercovici & Schubert

for Jupiter: 0.5 m/s • Energy in convection is sufficient • Solar mechanism would be

inefficient

• Other coupling mechanism ? • Kappa mechanism ? • Humid convection ?

See Ethan Dedrick’s talk

19 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 20: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Instrumental Concept

• JOVIAL is a Doppler Spectro-Imager – Mach-Zehnder Interferometer: – spectral FT at each point of the image – Measures the Doppler shift of reflected

solar lines

• Optimisation of mesurement stability, precision, resolution – Large Field Optique Adaptative – Simultaneous multi-sites observations – Noise level < 4 cm/s in 2 weeks

20 20 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 21: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

(1+v/c)

Fourier tachometer

σ spectrum S(σ)

detector FTS

telescope

interferogram TF

I(∆) =A(∆)e2iΠ∆σ0

σ0

21 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 22: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Telescope

AO Deformable mirror

Schack-Hartman Correlation WFS

Modular Optical Interface

Mach-Zehnder

Polarizer Cubes

Detector

Filter

Calibration & Alignement Unit

Transfer Optics

Thermal control

Output Optics

Telescope Tracking System

Acquisition & Control

Electronics, software Optics Mechanics

Interferometer Vacuum Enclosure

Thermic Key

OPD Modulation

Control Panel

Optical Bench and Mechanical Interface

Network Time

Server

Vacuum Pump

Bloc Diagramme

22 22 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 23: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Work programme

• Complete the DSI prototype at Calern with CIAO Adaptive Optics – See M. Carbillet & F. Martinache

• Study and realisation of two new MZ and vacuum tanks • Deliver MZ for JIVE in NM • Build a complete third instrument with AO • Develop data processing pipe-line • Achieve one or more observing runs on Jupiter and

Saturn

23 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 24: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

The JOVIAL network

Goal: Simultaneous observations from 3 sites Target: Duty-cycle > 50 % over two weeks Observatoire de Calern (France) • C2PU: 1 m telescope with DSI prototype New Mexico (USA) • Dunn Solar telescope (Sacramento Peak) Okayama Observatory (Japan) • Telescope de 1.88 m • Other options ?

24 24 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 25: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

The JOVIAL network

Possible evolutions • Larger telescopes • Additional instrument

– AO for JIVE

• Space mission (see O. Mousis)

– Saturn – Uranus

25 25 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 26: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Planning

26

Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations of Jupiter: May 2018 Data processing, first results: June 2019 Observations of Saturn: July 2019 Archiving, dissemination: December 2019

26 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 27: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Budget

• Instrument study and realisation: 215 k€

• Manpower - 3 years non-permanent 130 k€

• Logistics and missions: 45 k€

• Consumable: 30 k€

Total: 420 k€

27 27 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 28: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Organisation Management

OCA+IAS

Instrumental development

OCA

Optics

OCA

Mechanics

OCA

Thermal studies

IAS

Instrument Control

NMSU

AIV

OCA

Vacuum Tank Test

IAS

Integration and tests

OCA

Transport & Commissioning

OCA+NMSU

Observations

OCA+NMSU+EPS

Calern (France)

OCA

Okayama (Japan)

EPS

Apache Point (USA)

NMSU

Data processing

IAS

Image processing

OCA

Frequency

IAS

Wind speed maps

NMSU

Science

OCA

Mode physics and inversion

Jackiewicz

Interior model

Guillot

Atmosphere Morales

Formation of solar system

Ida

28 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting

Page 29: Welcome to the JOVIAL Kick-off meeting...Kick-off: April 2016 Instrumental design: October 2016 Integration and tests: June 2017 Delivery, commissioning: December 2017 Observations

Objectives of the meeting • Definition of the scientific objectives • Position of the project in the scientific context • Organisation of the science groups • Technical organisation of the network • Identify key technical issues (telescope) • Task identification and planning • Data policy • Choice of a logo

2010, February 15th 29 29 JOVIAL Kick-off Meeting