wind resource assessment - wind...

42
Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little [email protected] Renewable Energy Innovation 20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 1

Upload: others

Post on 01-Jun-2020

13 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Wind Resource Assessment

Matthew Little

[email protected]

Renewable Energy Innovation

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 1

Page 2: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Overview

• Wind Power

• Wind Energy

• Wind Speed and its characteristics

• Initial wind resource analysis

• Detailed site assessment

• Detailed wind resource analysis

• Estimating annual energy production

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 2

Page 3: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Wind

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 3

Wind is movement of air due to

thermal effects causing pressure differences

Page 4: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Wind Power

Power, P = 1/2 ρ A v3

ρ = air density (1.22kg/m3)

A = Swept area

v = Wind velocity

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 4

Page 5: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Wind Energy

Energy = Power x Time

So annual wind energy is average wind speed at the site x hours in year

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 5

Page 6: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Wind Speed

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 6

• Wind resource is highly variable and site specific

Page 7: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Average Wind Speed

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 7

Page 8: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Average Wind Speed

• The most useful factor to use to assess the wind resource at a particular site

• Usually given in m/s

• Monthly or yearly

• Cubic relationship between wind speed and energy generation

• An increase of wind speed from 6m/s to 7m/s gives a 58% increase in energy production.

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 8

Page 9: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Suitable Wind Speeds

Generally annual average

>4.5m/s is required for SWT

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 9

Page 10: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Wind SpeedProbability Distribution

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 10

Wind is typically a Weibull Distribution

Page 11: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Shape Parameter

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 11

Shape parameter – called ‘K’

If K factor is not known for a site use:

•K = 2 for inland locations

•K = 3 for sea coasts

•K = 4 for islands

Page 12: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Wind Energy Distribution Graph

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 12

Page 13: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Wind Rose

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 13

Page 14: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Seasonal Variation

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 14

Page 15: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Inter-Annual Variation

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 15

Page 16: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Log Law

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 16

Page 17: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Log Law

• V = velocity to be calculated at height Z

• Z = height above ground level for velocity v

• Vref = known velocity at height Zref

• Zref = reference height where vref is known

• Z0 = roughness length in the current wind direction

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 17

Page 18: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Roughness Length

Depends

upon the

topology

of the area

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 18

Page 19: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Altitude Effect

• Air density reduces at higher altitudes.

• This affects power in the wind

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 19

Page 20: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Temperature and Humidity Effects

• Higher temperatures reduce the air density

• Higher temperatures reduce the power available

• Increased humidity reduces air density

• Higher humidity reduces the power available

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 20

Page 21: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Wind Resource Assessment

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 21

Page 22: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Limitations

• Cost of data-logging

• Local data hard/impossible to find

• Gaps in data

• Variation in topology

• Inaccuracy in data

• Data-logging time period

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 22

Page 23: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Initial Resource Assessment

• IRENA• http://irena.masdar.ac.ae/

• NASA• https://eosweb.larc.nasa.gov/sse/

• 3 TIER• http://www.vaisala.com/en/energy/support/Resources

/Pages/Free-Wind-And-Solar-Resource-Maps.aspx

• NREL• http://www.nrel.gov/wind/international_wind_resourc

es.html20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 23

Use online resources and data as an initial check

Page 24: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Initial Resource Assessment

• Review any available reports/literature

• Check for other factors (access, grid infrastructure, protected areas etc).

• The desk-based research will give an indication of suitable areas for more investigation

• Can use GIS methods to review data

Do any areas look suitable?

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 24

Page 25: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 25

Page 26: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Initial Site Visit

• Found some suitable locations

• Arrange a site visit

• Good to have a previous relationship with the community

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 26

Page 27: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Anecdotal Evidence

• Discussion with the local community

• Interview a representative proportion

• Trying to get a fair view of weather conditions

But…

• Be careful of general comments

• Be careful of over-enthusiastic assessment

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 27

Page 28: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Observation

Look for local signs of high wind speeds

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 28

Page 29: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Topology

• Perhaps hills or mountains funnel the wind?

• Are there local obstructions such as trees or houses close by?

• Can the prevailing wind direction be assessed?

• Is the site near the sea?

• How many meters above sea level is the site?

• What is the local terrain?

• Look for initial sites to place the wind turbine.

• Check land ownership issues.

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 29

Page 30: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Topology

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 30

Page 31: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Topology

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 31

Page 32: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Data Logging

• Monitor a site with data-logging equipment

• Need to take data for as long as possible

• Typically 6 months or more is best

• Ensure calibrated accurate monitoring equipment

• This can be an expensive taskNote: additional presentation on data-logging systems

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 32

Page 33: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Review Data

• Analyse data recorded

• Adjust for seasonal variation

• Adjust for inter-annual variation (if possible)

• Adjust for turbine hub height

• Find average wind speed

• Find wind speed probability distribution curve

We can then:

• Find annual energy production

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 33

Page 34: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Annual Energy Production

With an average wind speed estimate, we can perform some calculations about the annual

energy production (AEP).

• Using manufacturers data and tables

• Power Curve Method

• Swept Area Method

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 34

Page 35: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

AEP –Manufacturers Data

• Use estimates from manufacturers

• Sales data –sometimes over estimated or ideal data.

• Might not take into account shape factor

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 35

Page 36: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

AEP – Power Curve Method

• Use a power curve and wind speed data

• Multiply together at each wind speed to give energy distribution graph

• Integrate area under energy distribution to find total energy

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 36

Page 37: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

AEP – Swept Area Method

Energy = 1/2 ρ A v3 * efficiency * time

• A = Swept area

• ρ = Air density (adjust for altitude)

• v = Annual average wind speed

• Use efficiency value of around 0.25

• Time is hours in a year = 8760 hours

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 37

Page 38: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Summary

• Accurate knowledge of wind resource is essential for assessing a site for SWT

• Small variations in wind speed can make a big difference to energy calculations

• Difficult to obtain accurate data

• Find as much data and information as possible

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 38

Page 39: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Worked Example

• Site is: Mchinji : 13°49′ S 32°54′ E

• Data collected:

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 39

Page 40: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Worked Example

• Data from NASA website:

• Need to find scale factor

• Then extrapolate data

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 40

Page 41: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Worked Example

• Then need to adjust for inter-annual variation:

• Data from previous years (from 10m height):

• The data for May this year is 4.4m/s

• Calculate the adjustment factor for inter-annual variation.

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 41

Page 42: Wind Resource Assessment - Wind Empowermentwindempowerment.org/.../2016/03/Wind-Resource-Assessment-WE-C… · Wind Resource Assessment Matthew Little matt@re-innovation.co.uk Renewable

Questions?

20-22/1/16 CEM Wind & Solar Training, Lilongwe, Malawi 42