Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409549 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 1

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409549 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 2

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409549 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 3

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409549 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 4

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409549 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 5

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409549 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 6

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409549 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 7

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409549 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 8

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409549 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 9

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409549 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 10

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409549 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 11

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409549 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 12

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409549 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 13

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409549 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 14

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409553 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 1

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT

Leonard Green Clerk

100 EAST FIFTH STREET, ROOM 540 POTTER STEWART U.S. COURTHOUSE

CINCINNATI, OHIO 45202-3988 Tel. (513) 564-7000

www.ca6.uscourts.gov

Filed: February 23, 2009

Mr. Thomas L. Auth Jr.

Mr. Gregory B. Friel

Caryn A. Gordon

Mr. John E. Heikkila

Ms. Cheryl L. Hill

Ms. Karen K Kuchek

Mr. Ronald Scott Lederman

Mr. Dirk C. Phillips

Jeffrey and Cheryl Zibbell

Re: Case No. 08-1553 , Jeffrey Zibbell, et al v. Jennifer Granholm, et al Originating Case No. : 07-00096

The Court issued the enclosed (Order/Opinion) today in this case.

Sincerely yours,

s/Kathryn Kasner Case Manager Direct Dial No. 513-564-7014 Fax No. 513-564-7096

Case: 08-1553 Document: 00615409553 Filed: 02/23/2009 Page: 2

cc: Mr. Ronald C. Weston

Enclosure

Mandate to issue