13th ksczma meeting proceedings - karnataka.gov.in ksczma... · s/o haji byari for reconstruction...

Proceedings of the 13th meeting of Karnataka State Coastal Zone Management

Authority (KSCZMA) held on 30th January, 2016 at 11:00 AM at Room No. 253, 2nd

Gate, M.S. Building under the chairmanship of Additional Chief Secretary to

Government, Forest, Ecology & Environment Department.

Members present: As per the list enclosed.

The Chairman welcomed the members present. All the files were placed before the Authority for

perusal and the subjects were deliberated as per the Agenda.

13.1 Confirmation of the proceedings of the previous KSCZMA meeting held on

15.12.2015.

13.2 Action Taken Report on the proceedings of the previous KSCZMA meeting held on

15.12.2015.

Action Taken Report at Annexure – I was perused and the Authority noted the action taken.

While discussing about the Action Taken Report regarding preparation of State Coastal

Zone Management Plan, the Secretary to Government (Ecology & Environment) explained the

process involved in preparation of CZMP Maps and its approval by MoEF. Further, it was

informed that the stage of preparation of CZMP Maps will be sought from NCSCM, Chennai. It was

also informed that the Cadastral Village Maps of 369 Villages of coastal districts of Karnataka have

been furnished to NCSCM on 07.01.2016, and action has been taken to obtain balance village

maps of 93 villages from ICT Centre, Aranya Bhavan, Malleshwaram, Bengaluru for onward

submission to NCSCM. At this stage, professor Sri. Sridhara, representing Karnataka Remote

Sensing Application Centre, Bengaluru was requested to furnish the Cadastral Maps of 93 Villages

if available with them for further necessary action.

The Authority after deleberations and discussion decided to seek further 6 months

extension of time for using the already approved CZM Plan as its validity is expiring on

31.01.2016 as per the MoEF Notification dated:31.03.2015.

13.3 Ratification of provisional NOC issued by the Regional Director (Environment)

with the approval of the DCZMCs.

The KSCZMA during the meeting held on 11.06.2014 had taken a decision to authorize

the Regional Directors (Environment) of the coastal districts to issue provisional NOC for

construction/reconstruction/repair of dwelling units in CRZ II and CRZ III (200-500 mts area)

and outside the CRZ limits with the approval of the concerned DCZMCs and subsequently to

place the proposals for ratification of the action taken (Government letter No. FEE 236 CRZ

2013 dated. 18.08.2014).

In the Government letter No.FEE 236 CRZ 2013, Dated:18.08.2014 detailed procedure

to process the application seeking CRZ Clearance for reconstruction / repairs of dwelling units

in CRZ II and CRZ III (200-500 mts area) with approval of concerned DCZMCs was issued to all

Proceedings of the 13th KSCZMA Meeting

of 29

the three Regional Directors of Mangalore, Udupi and Uttara Kannada Districts. Accordingly, the

Regional Directors after issuing provisional CRZ Clearance submitted proposals for ratification

as per Annexure II, III and IV respectively.

The Authority after examining the ratification proposals instructed the Regional

Directors to consider to issue provisional CRZ Clearance to those cases which are urgent in

nature after getting approval from concerned DCZMCs with proper justification for urgency in

future and other proposals are to be submitted to the Authority after obtaining approval of

concerned DCZMCs. It was further instructed to Regional Directors that photos with GPS

readings of the buildings/projects are to be taken before and after construction of buildings and

the same has to be brought to the notice of the Authority. All the three Regional Directors were

instructed to record the plinth area in Sq. ft in all ratification cases in future.

The Authority after discussion, decided to accord ratification for the action taken by

concerned Regional Directors with the above instructions. Further, the Authority decided to

issue proper CRZ Clearance for the proposals listed in Annexure II, III and IV.

13.4 Construction / Re-construction and Conversion of Residential Buildings:

13.4.1 Request for issue of NOC from Smt. Sadiyamma Marakalthi D/o Bacchi Marakalthi for

reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 18/28 of Parampalli Village, Udupi

Taluk, Udupi District (FEE 36 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Sadiyamma Marakalthi D/o Bacchi Marakalthi has requested to issue NOC for

reconstruction of residential house at 18/28 of Parampalli Village, Udupi Taluk, Udupi District. The

Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported that project site is at

jurisdication of 150 mts from HTL of River (as per CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-I.

The distance from HTL of river is 35 mts.

The Regional Director (Environment) has submitted the proposal along with application in

the prescribed format, RTC, Survey map of the site, tax assessment extract for the year 1978-79,

Certificate from Saligrama Municipality for change of door no. dated: 05.11.2015, approved CZMP

sheet, draft digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and

proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 16.01.2016. The plinth area is about 576 Sq.ft. The DCZMC

recommended the proposal for issue of NOC in the DCZMC meeting held on 16.01.2016.

As per the provisions under the Para 3 (i) (e) of the CRZ Notification 2011 reconstruction,

repair works of dwelling units of local communities including fishers in accordance with local town

and country planning regulations are allowed activities. Hence, the proposal has been submitted for

deliberation and consideration of the authority.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt.

Sadiyamma Marakalthi D/o Bacchi Marakalthi for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 18/28

of Parampalli Village, Udupi Taluk, Udupi District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC.


of 29

13.4.2 Request for issue of NOC from Smt. Ameenabi W/o Late. Hussain Saheb for

reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 250/7A of Kodavoor Village, Udupi


Smt. Ameenabi W/o Late. Hussain Saheb has requested to issue NOC for reconstruction of

residential house at 250/7A of Kodavoor Village, Udupi Taluk, Udupi District. The Regional Director

(Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported that project site is at jurisdication of

150 mts from HTL of River (as per CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-I. The distance from

HTL of river is 80 mts.



approved CZMP sheet, draft digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos

of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 16.01.2016. The plinth area is about 500

Sq.ft. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of NOC in the DCZMC meeting held on

16.01.2016.

As per the provisions under the Para 3 (i) (e) of the CRZ Notification 2011 reconstruction,

repair works of dwelling units of local communities including fishers in accordance with local town

and country planning regulations are allowed activities. Hence, the proposal has been submitted for

deliberation and consideration of the authority.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Smt.

Ameenabi W/o Late. Hussain Saheb for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 250/7A of

Kodavoor Village, Udupi Taluk, Udupi District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC.

13.4.3 Request for issue of NOC from Sri. Mahammed Ismail S/o Ibrahim for reconstruction

of residential house at Sy. No. 47/2B of Navunda Village, Kundapura Taluk, Udupi

District (FEE 34 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Mahammed Ismail S/o Ibrahim has requested to issue NOC for reconstruction of

residential house at 47/2B of Navunda Village, Kundapura Taluk, Udupi District. The Regional

Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported that project site is at

jurisdication of 500 mts from HTL of Sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The distance from HTL of sea is 75

mts.



Certificate from Navunda Grama Panchayath for change of door no. dated: 24.11.2015, approved

CZMP sheet, draft digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old

house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 16.01.2016. The plinth area is about 56 Sq.mtr.

The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of NOC in the DCZMC meeting held on 16.01.2016.

As per the provisions under the Para 8 III CRZ III A (ii) of the CRZ Notification 2011, the

above proposal is a permissible activity. Hence, the proposal has been submitted for deliberation and

consideration of the authority.


of 29

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri.

Mahammed Ismail S/o Ibrahim for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 47/2B of Navunda

Village, Kundapura Taluk, Udupi District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC.

13.4.4 Request for issue of NOC from Sri. Suleman S/o Haji Byari for reconstruction of

residential house at Sy. No. 109/9A of Parampalli Village, Udupi Taluk, Udupi District

(FEE 33 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Suleman S/o Haji Byari has requested to issue NOC for reconstruction of residential

house at 109/9A of Parampalli Village, Udupi Taluk, Udupi District. The Regional Director


500 mts from HTL of Sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The distance from HTL of sea is 185 mts.



Certificate from Saligrama Municipality for change of door No. dated: 04.12.2015, approved CZMP

sheet, draft digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old house and

proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 16.01.2016. The plinth area is about 476 Sq.ft. The DCZMC





The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Suleman

S/o Haji Byari for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 109/9A of Parampalli Village, Udupi

Taluk, Udupi District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC.

13.4.5 Request for issue of NOC from Sri. Mahabala Poojary S/o Akkamma Poojarthy for

reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 171/4P6 of Kumbhashi Village,

Kundapura Taluk, Udupi District (FEE 32 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Mahabala Poojary S/o Akkamma Poojarthy has requested to issue NOC for

reconstruction of residential house Sy. No. 171/4P6 of Kumbhashi Village, Kundapura Taluk, Udupi

District. The Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported that

project site is at jurisdication of 500 mts from HTL of Sea. It is classified as CRZ-III. The distance from

HTL of sea is 80 mts.



Certificate from Kumbhashi Grama Panchayath for change of door no. dated: 15.09.2015, approved

CZMP sheet, draft digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction, photos of old

house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 16.01.2016. The plinth area is about 476 Sq.ft. The

DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of NOC in the DCZMC meeting held on 16.01.2016.


of 29





Mahabala Poojary S/o Akkamma Poojarthy for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 171/4P6

of Kumbhashi Village, Kundapura Taluk, Udupi District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC.

13.4.6 Request for issue of NOC from Sri. Ramachandra Hebbar S/o Late. Narayana Hebbar

to develop horticulture activity at Sy. No. 250/5 of Kumbhashi Village, Kundapura


Sri. Ramachandra Hebbar S/o Late. Narayana Hebbar has requested to issue NOC for

excavation of soil for land development at Sy. No. 250/5 of Kumbhashi Village, Kundapura Taluk,

Udupi District. The Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported

that project site is at jurisdication of 500 mts from HTL of Sea. It is classified at CRZ-III. The distance

from HTL of sea is 220 mts.


the prescribed format, RTC, Survey map of the site, approved CZMP sheet, draft digitized CRZ map

showing the area of proposed excavation of soil, photos of old house and proceedings of DCZMC

meeting held on 16.01.2016. Area is 2.03 Acres. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of

NOC in the DCZMC meeting held on 16.01.2016. Since this activity is a land reclamation activity, as

per para 3(iv) of CRZ Notification 2011, this activity is a prohibited activity. But DCZMC has

recommended the proposal to KSCZMA for clearance.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided not to issue CRZ clearance to Sri.

Ramachandra Hebbar S/o Late. Narayana Hebbar to develop horticulture activity at Sy. No. 250/5 of

Kumbhashi Village, Kundapura Taluk, Udupi District as the activity was found to be of land reclamation

which is not a permissible activity as per Para 3 (iii) of CRZ Notification, 2011.

13.4.7 Request for issue of NOC from Sri. Gopi Narayan Vaidya for reconstruction of

residential house at Sy. No. 13/14 of Horbag Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada


Sri. Gopi Narayan Vaidya has requested to issue NOC for reconstruction of residential house

at Sy. No. 13/14 of Horbag Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. The Regional Director


100 mts from HTL of River (as per CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The distance

from HTL of river is 35 mts.


the prescribed format, Site inspection report, Sy. Map of the site, Plinth Area & Ownership letter,

R.T.C. of the site, 1981-82 year Tax Assessment Receipt PDO letter, 2011-12 year Tax Assessment

Receipt, CZMP sheet, draft digitized map showing the proposed area of construction, Photo’s of old

house, Sewage disposal Certificate and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016. The


of 29

plinth area is 351.50 Sq.ft. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of NOC in the DCZMC

meeting held on 07.01.2016.




The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Gopi

Narayan Vaidya for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 13/14 of Horbag Village, Kumta

Taluk, Uttara Kannada District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC.

13.4.8 Request for issue of NOC from Sri. Ramachandra Ganapathi Naik for reconstruction

of residential house at Sy. No. 60/1/5 of Aghanashini Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara

Kannada District (FEE 15 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Ramachandra Ganapathi Naik has requested to issue NOC for reconstruction of

residential house at Sy. No. 60/1/5 of Aghanashini Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District.

The Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported that project site

is at jurisdication of 100 mts form HTL of River (as per CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-

III. The distance from HTL of river is 80 mts.



R.T.C. of the site, 1984-85 year Tax Assessment Receipt, 2014-15 year Tax Assessment Receipt,

CZMP sheet, draft digitized map showing the proposed area of construction, photo’s of old house,

Sewage disposal Certificate and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016. The plinth area

is 360 Sq.ft. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of NOC in the DCZMC meeting held on

07.01.2016.





Ramachandra Ganapathi Naik for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 60/1/5 of Aghanashini

Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC.

13.4.9 Request for issue of NOC from Sri. Somashekhar Sannappa Naik for reconstruction of

residential house at Sy. No. 285/1A+1B of Nadumaskeri Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara


Sri. Somashekhar Sannappa Naik has requested to issue NOC for reconstruction of residential

house at Sy. No. 285/1A+1B of Nadumaskeri Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. The


jurisdication of 150 mts from HTL of River (as per CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III.

The distance from HTL of river is 70 mts.


of 29



R.T.C. of the site, 1990 year KEB Bill Receipt, 2015-16 year Tax Receipt, CZMP sheet, draft digitized

map showing the proposed area of construction, Photo’s of old house, Sewage disposal Certificate

and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016. The plinth area is 180 Sqm. The DCZMC






Somashekhar Sannappa Naik for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 285/1A+1B of

Nadumaskeri Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC.

13.4.10 Request for issue of NOC from Sri. Sukru Beerappa Harikantra for reconstruction of

residential house at Sy. No. 250/A of Kagal Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada


Sri. Sukru Beerappa Harikantra has requested to issue NOC for reconstruction of residential

house at Sy. No. 250/A of Kagal Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. The Regional Director



from HTL of river is 10 mts.



R.T.C. of the site, 1988-89 year Tax Receipt, 2014-15 year Tax Receipt, CZMP sheet, draft digitized

map showing the proposed area of construction, photo’s of old house, Sewage disposal Certificate

and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016. The plinth area is 252 Sq.ft. The DCZMC





The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Sukru

Beerappa Harikantra for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 250/A of Kagal Village, Kumta

Taluk, Uttara Kannada District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC with a condition that Sewage

Disposal arrangement should be made before starting reconstruction.

13.4.11 Request for issue of NOC from Smt. Anuradha Avalla for construction of residential

house at Sy. No. 31/2 of Baad Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District (FEE 59

CRZ 2016).

Smt. Anuradha Avalla has requested to issue NOC for construction of residential house at Sy.

No. 31/2 of Baad Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. The Regional Director



of 29

500 mts from HTL of Sea (as per CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The distance from

HTL of sea is 325 mts.


the prescribed format, Copy of NOC issued, Site inspection report, Sy. Map of the site, Plinth Area,

R.T.C. of the site, CZMP sheet, draft digitized map showing the proposed area of construction, Sewage

disposal Certificate and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016. The plinth area is

146.26 Sq.ft.

As per the provisions under the Para 8 III CRZ III B (vii) of the CRZ Notification 2011

construction or reconstruction of dwelling units so long it is within the ambit of traditional rights

and customary uses such as existing fishing villages and goathans. Building permission for such

construction or reconstruction will be subject to local town and country planning rules with overall

height of construction not exceeding 9mts with two floors (ground + one floor). Hence, the above

proposal is a permissible activity. But DCZMC has recommended to reject the proposal on the

grounds that the applicant is not a local resident and is not bound by the Local Town And

Municipal Regulations as per Para 8 III CRZ III B (vii) of the CRZ Notification 2011. It is further

stated that the applicant is a resident of New Delhi and hence, the proposal is not eligible for

issue of NOC.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided not to issue CRZ clearance to Smt.

Anuradha Avalla for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 31/2 of Baad Village, Kumta Taluk,

Uttara Kannada District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, as the applicant is not a local

resident.

13.4.12 Request for issue of NOC from Sri. Pradeep Narayana Shetty, Madadolakara for

construction of residential house at Sy. No. 622/2 of Bailoor Village, Bhatkal Taluk,

Uttara Kannada District (FEE 58 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Pradeep Narayana Shetty, Madadolakara has requested to issue NOC for construction of

residential house at Sy. No. 622/2 of Bailoor Village, Bhatkal Taluk, Uttara Kannada District.


the prescribed format, Sy. Map of the site, R.T.C. of the site, CZMP sheet, draft digitized map showing

the proposed area of construction, Photo of the old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held

on 07.01.2016.








Municipal Regulation as per Para 8 III CRZ III B (vii) of the CRZ Notification 2011. It is further

stated that the applicant is a resident of Dandeli and hence, the proposal is not eligible for

issue of NOC.


of 29


Pradeep Narayana Shetty, Madadolakara for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 622/2 of

Bailoor Village, Bhatkal Taluk, Uttara Kannada District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC, as

the applicant is not a local resident.

13.4.13 Request for issue of NOC from Sri. Tejeshear Singh Dunna for construction of

residential house at Sy. No. 75/2 of Baad Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada


Sri. Tejeshear Singh Dunna has requested to issue NOC for construction of residential house

at Sy. No. 75/2 of Baad Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. The Regional Director


500 mts form HTL of Sea (as per CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The distance from

HTL is 200.54 mts from Sea.


the prescribed format, Copy of NOC issued, Site Inspection Report, Sy. Map of the site, Plinth area,

R.T.C. of the site, CZMP sheet, draft digitized map showing the proposed area of construction, Sewage

disposal certificate copy and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016.








Municipal Rules as per Para 8 III CRZ III B (vii) of the CRZ Notification 2011. It is further

stated that the applicant is a resident of Dandeli and hence, the proposal is not eligible for

obtaining NOC. It is further reported by the RD that construction of the building has already

been started without obtaining prior CRZ Clearance and hence it is also a case of violation.

Hence a direction may be issued to stop the work and not to proceed with further construction

under section 5 of EP Act. Further, credible action may be taken as per the section 19 of EP Act.


Tejeshear Singh Dunna for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 75/2 of Baad Village, Kumta

Taluk, Uttara Kannada District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC. Further, the concerned

Regional Director was instructed to issue Showcause Notice and to conduct spot mahajar for taking

credible action as per the section 19 of EP Act regarding violation.

13.4.14 Request for issue of NOC from Smt. Nirmala Rajesh Kamath for construction of

residential house at Sy. No. 134/6, 134/5 and 134/2 of Kodibhag Village, Karwar

Taluk, Uttara Kannada District (FEE 60 CRZ 2016).

Smt. Nirmala Rajesh Kamath has requested to issue NOC for construction of residential house


of 29

at Sy. No. 134/6, 134/5 and 134/2 of Kodibhag Village, Karwar Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. The

Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported that project site is

classified as CRZ-II. The distance from HTL is 345 mts from Sea.


the prescribed format, Sy. Map of the site, Plinth area, R.T.C. of the site, draft digitized map showing

the proposed area of construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016.

As per the provisions under the Para 8 II CRZ II (i) of the CRZ Notification 2011 buildings

shall be permitted only on the landward side of the existing road, or on the landward side of existing

authorized structures and as per Para 8 II CRZ II (ii) of the CRZ Notification 2011 buildings

permitted on the landward side of the existing and proposed roads or existing authorized structures

shall be subject to the existing local town and country planning regulations including the ‘existing’

norms of Floor Space Index or Floor Area Ratio: Provided that no permission for construction of

buildings shall be given on landward side of any new roads which are constructed on the seaward

side of an existing road.

The proposal is recommended for rejection since, there is no authorized constructions or

existing road which are constructed before 1990 on seaward side of the proposed construction.


Nirmala Rajesh Kamath for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 134/6, 134/5 and 134/2 of

Kodibhag Village, Karwar Taluk, Uttara Kannada District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC.

13.4.15 Request for issue of NOC from Sri. Venkataramana Jattappa Naik for construction of

residential house at Sy. No. 192/2 of Gude Angadi Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara


Sri. Venkataramana Jattappa Naik has requested to issue NOC for construction of residential

house at Sy. No. 192/2 of Gude Angadi Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. The Regional

Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported that project site is classified as

CRZ-III. The distance from HTL of sea is 180 mts.


the prescribed format, Sy. Map of the site, R.T.C. of the site, draft digitized map showing the proposed

area of construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 19.06.2015. The plinth area is

901.66 Sq. ft.

As per the provisions under the Para 8 III CRZ III A (ii) of the CRZ Notification 2011 No

construction shall be permitted within NDZ except for repairs or reconstruction of existing

authorized structure not exceeding existing Floor Space Index, existing plinth area and existing

density and for permissible activities under the notification including facilities essential for

activities; Construction/reconstruction of dwelling units of traditional coastal communities including

fisherfolk may be permitted between 100 and 200 metres from the HTL along the seafront in

accordance with a comprehensive plan prepared by the State Government or the Union territory in

consultation with the traditional coastal communities including fisherfolk and incorporating the


of 29

necessary disaster management provision, sanitation and recommended by the concerned State or

the Union territory CZMA to NCZMA for approval by MoEF.

The proposal is recommended by DCZMC for rejection since, the place of building lies in NDZ

area.


Venkataramana Jattappa Naik for construction of residential house at Sy. No. 192/2 of Gude Angadi

Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC.

13.4.16 Request for issue of NOC from Smt. Girija Nagesh Moger for reconstruction of

residential house at Sy. No. 19A of Shirali-I Village, Bhatkal Taluk, Uttara Kannada


Smt. Girija Nagesh Moger has requested to issue NOC for construction of residential house at

Sy. No. 19A of Shirali-I Village, Bhatkal Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. The Regional Director

(Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported that project site is classified as CRZ-III.

The distance from HTL of sea is 110 mts.


the prescribed format, Sy. Map of the site, R.T.C. of the site, plinth area, tax paid receipt of 1988-89 to

2013-14, sewage disposal certificate, photo of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on

19.06.2015. The plinth area is 61.18 Sq. mt. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of NOC

in the DCZMC meeting held on 19.06.2015.










the Union territory CZMA to NCZMA for approval by MoEF. Hence, the above proposal is a

permissible activity.

It is reported by Regional Director (Environment) that during inspection it is observed that

the applicant has laid foundation for construction of new building beside the old building and hence

the proposal is recommended for rejection as the applicant has violated the provisions of the CRZ

Notification 2011. Action as per the section 19 of EP Act to be initiated for not taking prior CRZ

clearance.


Girija Nagesh Moger for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 19A of Shirali-I Village, Bhatkal

Taluk, Uttara Kannada District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC. Further, the concerned


of 29



13.4.17 Request for issue of NOC from Smt. Madevi Manjunath Moger for reconstruction of

residential house at Sy. No. 21/1A2B of Shirali-I Village, Bhatkal Taluk, Uttara


Smt. Madevi Manjunath Moger has requested to issue NOC for construction of residential

house at Sy. No. 21/1A2B of Shirali-I Village, Bhatkal Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. The Regional




the prescribed format, Sy. Map of the site, R.T.C. of the site, tax paid receipt of 1970-71 to 2013-15,

plinth area, sewage disposal certifiate, photo of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held

on 19.06.2015. The plinth area is 22.42 Sq. mt.
















clearance.


Madevi Manjunath Moger for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 21/1A2B of Shirali-I Village,

Bhatkal Taluk, Uttara Kannada District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC. Further, the

concerned Regional Director was instructed to issue Showcause Notice and to conduct spot mahajar for

taking credible action as per the section 19 of EP Act regarding violation.

13.4.18 Request for issue of NOC from Smt. Nagaratna Ganapati Moger for reconstruction of

residential house at Sy. No. 76/1 of Shirali-I Village, Bhatkal Taluk, Uttara Kannada


Smt. Nagaratna Ganapati Moger has requested to issue NOC for construction of residential


of 29

house at Sy. No. 76/1 of Shirali-I Village, Bhatkal Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. The Regional




the prescribed format, Sy. Map of the site, R.T.C. of the site, plinth area, tax paid receipt of 1988-89 to

2014-15, sewage disposal receipt, draft digitized map showing the proposed area of construction,

photo of old house and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 19.06.2015. The plinth area is 39 Sq.

mt.
















clearance.


Nagaratna Ganapati Moger for reconstruction of residential house at Sy. No. 76/1 of Shirali-I Village,

Bhatkal Taluk, Uttara Kannada District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC. Further, the

concerned Regional Director was instructed to issue Showcause Notice and to conduct spot mahajar for

taking credible action as per the section 19 of EP Act regarding violation.

13.5 Other construction / reconstruction projects including Industries :

13.5.1 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Raftar Terminals Private Limited for the

storage of Acetic acid, MEG (Mono Ethylene Glycol), Naptha Motor Spirit at Sy. No.

46/1(P), 47/1(P), 47/2(P), 47/3(P), 47/7(P1), 47/7(P2), 47/8(P), 47/13(P),

47/14(P), 47/15, 47/16(P), 47/3P, 47/9(P), 47/10(P), 47/7(P3) of Thannirubhavi

Village, Mangalore (FEE 364 CRZ 2015).

M/s Raftar Terminals private Limited has requested CRZ clearance for the storage of Acetic

acid, MEG (Mono Ethylene Glycol), Naptha Motor Spirit at Thannirubhavi village. The Regional

Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported that project site is at distance

of 150 mts from river & 500 mts from sea (as per CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ III.

The Distance from HTL is Approximately 205mts from HTL of sea, & approximately 150 mts from

HTL of river.


of 29

The Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the site and reported that the area falls

under CRZ-III as per approved Coastal Zone Management Plan 1996. The proposal was placed in

DCZMC meeting held on 29-06-2015. The committee after discussions, deferred the case and decided

to re-inspect the site with committee members. Accordingly the committee inspected the spot on 30-

06-2015 and submitted a report for having violated the Para 3(iv) of CRZ Notification 2011. Para

3(iv) says “Land reclamation, bunding or disturbing the natural course of seawater” is prohibited

activity. But again on 09.10.2015, the committee members inspected the site and after detailed

verification, it is found that:-

1. The said area is not at all coming under the natural course of sea water and not

disturbing the natural course of seawater. Hence no voilation is noticed.

2. The said area is adjacent to the G.M.R foundation project which is being executed long

back where CRZ clearance has been obtained.

3. This land belongs to KIADB Industrial area, which is purchased on lease by M/s Raftar

Terminals private Limited.

4. In this area no Mangroves species is found.

5. The project involves storage of petrolium products i.e Naptha, Motor Spirit, Acetic acid

and Mono Etylene Glycol (MEG).

The Regional Director (Environment) has submitted the proposal for the storage of Acetic

acid, MEG (Mono Ethylene Glycol), Naptha Motor Spirit at Thannirubhavi village, submitted by M/s

Raftar Terminals private Limited, along with the application in the prescribed format, checklist,

Form-I, survey sketch of site. Karnataka Industrial Areas Development Board possession certificate,

material safety data sheet satellite image (10 Ms radius), tank farm facility layout, pipeline facility

layout, site location showing the survey numbers, contour of the Site, green area, overall area and

used area, connectivity map, pipeline road corridor, storm water layout, fire fighting layout, water

NOC, fire NOC, MESCOM NOC, aerial view of the site, CRZ map and report by IRS, Anna University,

geotechnical investigation report, risk assessment study report, copy of challan about payment of

processing fees, CZMP of the proposed site, google map, inspection report of Regional

Director(Environment), proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 29-06-2015 & 16-11-2015. The

DCZMC recommended the proposal to issue NOC in the DCZMC meeting held on 16-11-2015 with a

condition that, the storage of Acetic acid & MEG were not there in the Annexure II of the Notification,

and they have to take necessary permission for the storage of the same from the concerned

department.

The area falls under CRZ-III as per approved Coastal Zone Management Plan. As per Para 8 III

CRZ III (iii) and (e) of the CRZ Notification 2011, the above project is a permissible activity except for

the storage of Acetic acid & MEG, for which permission may have to be obtained from the MoEF.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations had decided to send a team of officers

consisting of Sri. A. Ramesh, SEO dealing with Hazardous Waste, concerned EO of Mangalore from

KSPCB and RD, Mangalore to inspect the site and to get a report from them at the earliest before

coming to final decision regarding giving CRZ clearance for the storage of Acetic acid, MEG (Mono

Ethylene Glycol), Naptha, Motor Spirit, at Thannirubhavi Village, Mangalore.

As per the decision of the Authority, the above team inspected the spot on 07.01.2016 and


of 29

has submitted its report on 16.01.2016. In this report it is recommended that the project can be

considered for storage of motor Spirit and Naphtha and laying pipelines after taking into considering

all the aspects indicated in the report. However thje project proponent in his representation dated

14.01.2016 requested to permit the storage of Naphtha and motor spirit only.

The Authority after detailed delebrations and discussion, decided to take up site inspection

keeping in view the location of the project and sensitivity of the area and the subject is deferred.

13.5.2 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Sri. V. Mahesh Kamath for setting up of Yacht

School at Sy. No. 78/36, Kolchi Kambla Estuary, Bappanadu Village, Mangalore (FEE

10 CRZ 2016).

Sri. V. Mahesh Kamath has requested CRZ Clearance for setting up of Yacht School at Sy. No.

78/36, Kolchi Kambla Estuary, Bappanadu Village, Mangalore.

The Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported that

project site is classified as CRZ-I. The distance from HTL of river is 60 mts.

The proposed activity involves the Yachting lessons and Sailboat rides and the site is on the

landward side of Kolchi Kambla road (10 ft. width), which later joins N.H. 66 at a distance of around

3 Kms. The proposed structure is a pre-fabricated bolt-on type temporary structure without the

need to dig foundation. The details are as follows:

Description Built up

area (Sq. ft)

Cost (in

lakhs) a) Port-a-cabin building housing office, Boat shed,

equipment storage, classroom 1620 11.00

b) 2 No. wash rooms 50 0.50

c) Fencing etc., LS 1.00

d) Water tower, POL Storage, Water purufication system LS 1.00

Total 13.50

The Regional Director (Environment) has submitted the proposal along with the application

in the prescribed format, checklist, Form-I, Survey sketch of site, R.T.C, Project Report, Google

images, location of the site, inspection report, copy of challan about payment of processing fees,

CZMP of the proposed site and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 12.01.2016.

The DCZMC recommended the above proposal related to water sports activity to issue NOC

in the meeting held on 12.01.2016.

The area falls under CRZ-I as per approved Coastal Zone Management Plan. As per the

provisions under Para 8 I CRZ I (ii) (b) of the CRZ Notification 2011 construction of dispensaries,

schools, public rainshelter, community toilets,bridges, roads, jetties, water supply, drainage,

sewerage which are required for traditional inhabitants living within the biosphere reserves are

permitted after obtaining approval from concerned CZMA. Hence, the above project is a permissible

activity.


of 29

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. V.

Mahesh Kamath for setting up of Yacht School at Sy. No. 78/36, Kolchi Kambla Estuary, Bappanadu

Village, Mangalore as per the recommendation of the DCZMC.

13.5.3 Request for issue of NOC from Assistant Director, Fisheries Department, Udupi for

construction of II Stage Fishing port at Hejamadi Kodi, Udupi District (FEE 30 CRZ

2016).

Assistant Director, Fisheries Department, Udupi has requested to issue NOC for construction

of II Stage Fishing port at Hejamadi Kodi, Udupi District. The Regional Director (Environment) has

inspected the proposed site and reported that project site is classified as CRZ-I, III and IV. The G.P.S.

Co-ordinates are as follows:

Northern Side: N 130 05’ 16.8’, E 740 46’ 21.2’.

Southern Side: N 130 04’ 33.7”, E 740 46’ 35.2’.

The project comprises of the following principle components.

i. Provision of safe landing and berthing facilities for Mechanised Fishing Vessesls

(MFVs) to operate throughout the fishing season.

ii. Constructing of shore-based establishments and organisation of distribution and

marketing arrangements for prawn and fish products through the Fishery Terminal

Organisation (FTO) to be setup.

It is proposed to construct training walls of length 692 mts on northern side and 781 mts on

southern side at Hejmadikodi, Fish Landing Centre under this project.


the prescribed format, RTC, Survey map of the site, project report, approved CZMP sheet, draft

digitized CRZ map showing the area of proposed reconstruction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting

held on 16.01.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of NOC in the DCZMC meeting

held on 16.01.2016.

As per the provisions under the Para 3 (i) (a) of the CRZ Notification 2011, the above project

proposal is a permissible activity. Hence, the proposal has been submitted for deliberation and


The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Assistant

Director, Fisheries Department, Udupi for construction of II Stage Fishing port at Hejamadi Kodi, Udupi

District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC.

13.5.4 Request for issue of NOC from M/s Agrawal Industries Corporation Ltd, Karwar Port

Installation, Bhu devi temple road for construction of Liquid Storage Tank Terminal

for storage of Molasses, Edible Oil and Bitumen at Sy. No. 21A1/21A/1&21A2/149K

of Goudwada, Baithkol Village, Karwar Taluk (FEE 4 CRZ 2016).

M/s Agrawal Industries Corporation Ltd, Karwar Port Installation, Bhu Devi Temple road has

requested to issue NOC for construction of Liquid Storage Tank Terminal to store Molasses, Edible


of 29

Oil and Bitumen at Sy. No. 21A1/21A/1&21A2/149K of Goudwada, Baithkol Village, Karwar Taluk.

The storage capacity of the tank terminal is 20000-22000 KL and there are 3 dedicated pipeline link

of 1.3 Km length each from Karwar Port. The Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the

proposed site and reported that project site is at jurisdication of 150 mts from HTL of River (as per

CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The distance from HTL of sea is 30.22 mts.

The G.P.S. readings is N 140 47’ 39.7’,

E 740 06’ 30.0’.


the prescribed format, Site inspection report, approved CZMP map sheet, draft digitized map

showing the proposed area of construction, R.T.C. of the site, Project layout, EIA report and

proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for

issue of NOC in the DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016, for the storage of edible oils excluding

Molasses and Bitumen.

As per the provisions under the Para 8 III CRZ III A (iii) (e) of the CRZ Notification 2011

facilities for receipt and storage of petroleum products and liquefied natural gas as specified in

Annexure-II are permitted and as per Para 8 III CRZ III B (iv) of the CRZ Notification 2011 provision

is there for storage of non-hazardous cargo such as, edible oil, fertilizers, food grain in notified ports.

But, as per Para 8 III CRZ III A (i) of the CRZ Notification 2011. The NDZ shall not be applicable in

such area falling within any notified port limits. The storage of Bitumen and Molasses are not

included in Annexure-II of the CRZ Notification 2011. Subsequently the project proponent in his

representation submitted on 10.12.2015, stated that Bitumen and Molasses are non hazardous and

also not listed as per Hazardous Raw Material Notification 2000 and its amendments thereof.

Further he has also stated that the committee has accorded similar permissions in the past for the

following parties at Karwar Port for CRZ III terminals:

Sl.

No

Terminal Owner Clearance

Date

1 M/s Kassel Exports Private Ltd 22.08.2006

2 M/s Konkan Storage Pvt. Ltd 31.07.2006

3 M/s United Storage & Tank Terminal Ltd 28.01.2008

4 M/s Tropicana Liquid Storage Tank Terminal Ltd (Formerly M/s Mysore

Mercantile Co. Ltd.,)

18.03.2008

The Authority after deliberations and discussion decided to issue CRZ Clearance to store edible

oils only subject to clarifications from the Port Authorities whether the project area is a part of notified

port area or not.

13.5.5 Request for issue of NOC from Dr. Raviraj Gajanan Kadle, Ashwinidhama

Panchakarma Centre Kadle for construction of Ayurvedic Medical Care at Sy. No. 562,

497/2A, 497/2B, 498/1, 498/3A, 564/6A1B, 496/3A & 499/2 of Kadle of

Hollangadde Village, Kumta Taluk (FEE 6 CRZ 2016).

Dr. Raviraj Gajanan Kadle, Ashwinidhama Panchakarma Centre Kadle has requested to issue

NOC for construction of Ayurvedic Medical Care at Sy. No. 562, 497/2A, 497/2B, 498/1, 498/3A,


of 29

564/6A1B, 496/3A & 499/2 of Kadle of Hollangadde Village, Kumta Taluk. The total floor area is

9516 Sq. ft. (less than 20000 Sq. mt.). The Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the

proposed site and reported that project site is at jurisdication of 100 mts from HTL of River (as per

CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The minimum distance from HTL of sea is 160 mts

and maximum distance from HTL of sea is 205 mts. The G.P.S. readings are as follows:

Northern Side: N 140 26’ 28.5’, E 740 23’ 02.7’.

Southern Side: N 140 26’ 26.8”, E 740 23’ 04.6’.


the prescribed format, Site inspection report, approved CZMP map sheet, draft digitized map

showing the proposed area of construction, R.T.C. of the site, Project report, Registration certificate

of establishment, Karnataka State Pollution Control Board Certificate, Agreement copy with Bio

medical waste disposal facility, Hubli Electricity Supply Company Ltd., Certificate, 2011 Hospital Tax

Receipt, 2014-15 Tax Receipt, Registration copy of the ayurvedic medical care facility under the

Rules of Government of Karnataka and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016. The

DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of NOC in the DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016.

As per the provisions under Para 4 (ii) (b) of the CRZ Notification 2011 construction

activities relating to projects of Department of Atomic Energy or Defence requirements for which

foreshore facilities are essential such as, slipways, jetties, wharves, quays; except for classified

operational component of defence projects. Residential buildings, office buildings, hospital

complexes, workshops of strategic and defence projects in terms of EIA notification, 2006 and as per

Para 8 III CRZ III A (iii) (j) of the CRZ Notification 2011 construction of dispensaries, schools, public

rain shelter, community toilets, bridges, roads, provision of facilities for water supply, drainage,

sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-station which are required for the local

inhabitants may be permitted on a case to case basis by CZMA. As per Para 8 III CRZ III B (viii) of the

CRZ Notification 2011 Construction of public rain shelters, community toilets, water supply

drainage, sewerage, roads and bridges are permissible and CZMA may also permit construction of

schools and dispensaries for local inhabitants of the area for those panchayats, the major part of

which falls within CRZ if no other area is available for construction of such facilities.

But, it is observed from the DCZMC meeting proceedings that the construction activity of the

project has been taken up before obtaining prior CRZ Clearance and hence it becomes violation.

Action as per section 19 of EP Act 1986 and as per MoEF Memorandum dated: 12.12.2012 credible

action has to be initiated for not taking prior CRZ clearance.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided not to issue CRZ clearance to Dr.

Raviraj Gajanan Kadle, Ashwinidhama Panchakarma Centre Kadle for construction of Ayurvedic

Medical Care at Sy. No. 562, 497/2A, 497/2B, 498/1, 498/3A, 564/6A1B, 496/3A & 499/2 of Kadle of

Hollangadde Village, Kumta Taluk as per the recommendation of the DCZMC. Further, the concerned


credible action as per the section 19 of EP Act regarding violation. The Authority directed the

concerned to bring the proposal before the Authority after taking credible action.


of 29

13.5.6 Request for issue of NOC from President, Belkonda Fisheries Co-operative Society

Ltd., for construction of Ice Plant at Sy. No. 291 of Kasarkod Village, Honnavar Taluk

(FEE 5 CRZ 2016).

President, Belkonda Fisheries Co-operative Society Ltd., has requested to issue NOC for

construction of Ice Plant at Sy. No. 291 of Kasarkod Village, Honnavar Taluk. The Regional Director



from HTL of sea is 375 mts. The G.P.S. reading is N 140 16’ 31.5’, E 740 25’ 52.3’ distance from river

HTL is 35.10 mts.


the prescribed format, Site inspection report, R.T.C. of the site, Village Sy. Map & K.D.T Annexure,

Construction of Plant Plan, CZMP sheet, Project Report and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on

07.01.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of NOC in the DCZMC meeting held on

07.01.2016.

As per the provisions under the Para 8 III CRZ III A (iii) (l) of the CRZ Notification 2011

facilities required for local fishing communities such as fish drying yards, auction halls, net mending

yards, traditional boat building yards, ice plant, ice crushing units, fish curing facilities and the like

are permitted.


project has been taken up before obtaining prior CRZ Clearance and hence it becomes violation. As

per MoEF Memorandum dated:12.12.2012 credible action has to be taken regarding violation before

considering the proposal for CRZ clearance.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided not to issue CRZ clearance to

President, Belkonda Fisheries Co-operative Society Ltd., for construction of Ice Plant at Sy. No. 291 of

Kasarkod Village, Honnavar Taluk as per the recommendation of the DCZMC. Further, the concerned



13.5.7 Request for issue of NOC from Panchayat Development Officer, Kasarkod Panchayat

for construction of Over Head Tank (OHT) at Sy. No. 291 of Kasarkod Village,

Honnavar Taluk (FEE 7 CRZ 2016).

Panchayat Development Officer, Kasarkod Panchayat has requested to issue NOC for

construction of Over Head Tank (OHT) at Sy. No. 291 of Kasarkod Village, Honnavar Taluk. The



The distance from HTL of sea is 263 mts. The G.P.S. reading is N 140 16’ 28.9,

E 740 25’ 49.3’


the prescribed format, Site inspection report, R.T.C. of the site, Project Report, CZMP sheet and


of 29

proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for

issue of NOC in the DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016.

As per the provisions under the Para 8 III CRZ III A (iii) (j) of the CRZ Notification 2011

construction of dispensaries, schools, public rain shelter, community toilets, bridges, roads,

provision of facilities for water supply, drainage, sewerage, crematoria, cemeteries and electric sub-

station which are required for the local inhabitants may be permitted on a case to case basis by

CZMA.


project has been taken up before obtaining prior CRZ Clearance and hence it becomes violation. As

per MoEF Memorandum dated:12.12.2012 credible action has to be taken regarding violation before

considering the proposal for CRZ clearance.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Panchayat

Development Officer, Kasarkod Panchayat for construction of Over Head Tank (OHT) at Sy. No. 291 of

Kasarkod Village, Honnavar Taluk as per the recommendation of the DCZMC. Further, it was directed

to issue a warning letter to the proponent that no constructions in CRZ area is to be taken up without

prior clearance from the Authority in future.

13.5.8 Request for issue of NOC from Sri. C. K. Shivakumar, Sharda Krupa, P&T Colony,

Hassan for construction of Beach Resort Cottage & Nature Cure Centre at Sy. No.

13/4, 13/5+6, 13/7, 22 & 12 of Bastigalamigthe Village, Bhatkal Taluk (FEE 8 CRZ

2016).

Sri. C. K. Shivakumar, Sharda Krupa, P&T Colony, Hassan has requested to issue NOC for

construction of Beach Resort Cottage & Nature Cure Centre at Sy. No. 13/4, 13/5+6, 13/7, 22 & 12 of

Bastigalamigthe Village, Bhatkal Taluk. The total floor area is 9516 Sq. ft. (less than 20000 Sq. mtr.).

The Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported that project site

is at jurisdication of 100 mts from HTL of River (as per CZMP approved 1996). It is classified as CRZ-

III. The distance from HTL of sea is 250 mts. The G.P.S. reading is N 130 57’ 18.1,

E 740 33’ 08.6’


the prescribed format, Site inspection report, EIA report, approved CZMP map sheet, draft digitized

map showing the proposed area of construction, R.T.C. of the site and proceedings of DCZMC

meeting held on 07.01.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of NOC in the DCZMC

meeting held on 07.01.2016.

As per the provisions under the Para 8 III CRZ III B (i) of the CRZ Notification 2011

development of vacant plot in designated areas for construction of hotels or beach resorts for

tourists or visitors is subject to the conditions as specified in the guidelines at Annexure-III are

permissible. As per Annexure-III prior approval of MoEF in designated areas of CRZ-II and III for

occupation of tourist or visitors for construction of beach resorts or hotels has to be obtained.

But, it is observed from the DCZMC meeting proceedings that the proponent has not

submitted NOC from Karnataka State Pollution Control Board/Central Pollution Control Board.


of 29

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to recommend the proposal to MoEF

for issue of CRZ clearance to Sri. C. K. Shivakumar, Sharda Krupa, P&T Colony, Hassan for construction

of Beach Resort Cottage & Nature Cure Centre at Sy. No. 13/4, 13/5+6, 13/7, 22 & 12 of

Bastigalamigthe Village, Bhatkal Taluk.

13.5.9 Request for issue of NOC from Joint Director of Fisheries Harbours, Malpe Udupi for

construction of Training Walls Groynes for development of Fish Landing Centres at

Alvekodi & Tenginagundi Village, Bhatkal Taluk, Uttara Kannada District (FEE 13

CRZ 2016).

Joint Director of Fisheries Harbours, Malpe Udupi has requested to issue NOC for

construction of Training Walls Groynes for development of Fish Landing Centres at Alvekodi &

Tenginagundi Village, Bhatkal Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. The Regional Director (Environment)

has inspected the proposed site and reported that project site is inside the Sea. It is classified at CRZ-

IV. The G.P.S. readings are N 140 01’ 37.2’,

E 740 29’ 47.3’


the prescribed format, Site inspection report, EIA report, Project report, approved CZMP map sheet,

draft digitized map showing the proposed area of construction, and proceedings of DCZMC meeting

held on 07.01.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of NOC in the DCZMC meeting

held on 07.01.2016.

As per the provisions under the Para 4 (i) (f) of the CRZ Notification 2011 construction and

operation of ports and harbours, jetties, wharves, quays, slipways, ship construction yards,

breakwaters, groynes, erosion control measures are permitted activities.

It is observed from the DCZMC meeting proceedings that the proponent has not submitted

NOC from Karnataka State Pollution Control Board/Central Pollution Control Board, Project layout,

R.T.C and has not paid the processing fee.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Joint

Director of Fisheries Harbours, Malpe Udupi for construction of Training Walls Groynes for

development of Fish Landing Centres at Alvekodi & Tenginagundi Village, Bhatkal Taluk, Uttara

Kannada District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC with a condition that the proponent should

submit NOC from Karnataka State Pollution Control Board/Central Pollution Control Board, Project

layout, R.T.C and to pay the processing fee immediately.

13.5.10 Request for issue of NOC from Skyline Aquatech Exports Private Limited for

construction of Hatchery at Sy. No. 13/1 of Gudeangadi Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara


Skyline Aquatech Exports Private Limited has requested to issue NOC for construction of

Hatchery at Sy. No. 13/1 of Gudeangadi Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District. The Regional

Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported that project site is at



of 29

The distance from HTL of sea is 50 mts. The G.P.S. readings is N 140 28’ 08.6’,

E 740 22’ 23.9’.


the prescribed format, Site inspection report, Sy. Map in site, 1991-92 construction of building

permission Registar copy, 2014-15 Tax receipt copy, R.T.C. of the site, approved CZMP map sheet,

draft digitized map showing the proposed area of construction, Project report and proceedings of

DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of NOC in the

DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016.

As per the provisions under the Para 3 (iii) of the CRZ Notification 2011 Setting up and

expansion of fish processing units including warehousing except hatchery and natural fish drying in

permitted areas are prohibited activities. Hence, hatchery and fish drying activities are permissible

activity.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Skyline

Aquatech Exports Private Limited for construction of Hatchery at Sy. No. 13/1 of Gudeangadi Village,

Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District as per the recommendation of the DCZMC.

13.5.11 Request for issue of NOC from M/s Konkan Storage System Private Limited, Sea Bird

Road for storage of Caustic Soda at Sy. No. 27A, 27C & 27D of Baithkol Village, Karwar


M/s Konkan Storage System Private Limited, Sea Bird Road has requested to issue NOC for

storage of Caustic Soda at Sy. No. 27A, 27C & 27D of Baithkol Village, Karwar Taluk, Uttara Kannada

District. The Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported that

project site is at jurisdication of 500 mts from HTL of Sea (as per CZMP approved 1996). It is

classified as CRZ-III. The distance from HTL of sea is 250 mts. The G.P.S. readings are N 140 47’ 38.9’,

E 740 06’ 42.0’.

Ministry of Environment and Forest, Government of India has accorded Environmental

Clearance under the CRZ Notification, 1991 for establishment of storage tank terminal for M/s

Konkan Storage System Private Limited for storage of Petroleum products, molasses and edible oil

vide letter No. 11-32/2006-IA-III, dated:31.07.2006.


the prescribed format, Site inspection report, Sy. Map in site, Project report, Lease Agreement,

approved CZMP map sheet, Registration copy of the M/s Konkan Storage System Pvt., Ltd., under the

rules of Government of Karnataka, NOC from Government of India, MoEF, New Delhi for storage of 6

terminal tanks for storage of Petroleum products, edible oil & Molasses, draft digitized map showing

the proposed area of construction and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016. The

DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of NOC in the DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016

considering Caustic Soda as a raw product in the manufature of fertilizers.

As per the provisions under the Para 3 (ii) (b) of the CRZ Notification 2011 facilities for

receipt and storage of petroleum products and liquefied natural gas as specified in Annexure-II


of 29

appended to this notification and facilities for regasification of Liquefied Natural Gas (hereinafter

referred to as the LNG) in the areas not classified as CRZ-I (i) subject to implementation of safety

regulations including guidelines issued by the Oil Industry Safety Directorate in the Ministry of

Petroleum and Natural Gas and guidelines issued by MoEF and subject to further terms and

conditions for implementation of ameliorative and restorative measures in relation to environment

as may be stipulated by in MoEF. Provided that facilities for receipt and storage of fertilizers and raw

materials required for manufacture of fertilizers like ammonia, phosphoric acid, sulphur, sulphuric

acid, nitric acid and the like, shall be permitted within the said zone in the areas not classified as

CRZ-I (i). In this provision Caustic Soda is not mentioned specifically as a raw material required for

manufacture of fertilizers. Hence, this may be recommended to MoEF for CRZ clearance at NCZMA.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to refer the proposal to MoEF for

further needful action regarding the issue of CRZ clearance to M/s Konkan Storage System Private

Limited, Sea Bird Road for storage of Caustic Soda at Sy. No. 27A, 27C & 27D of Baithkol Village,

Karwar Taluk, Uttara Kannada District.

13.5.12 Request for issue of NOC from Mysore Mercantile Co., Ltd., for setting up

Warehousing facility of 26088 KL Liquid Cargo Terminal with connecting pipeline

from jetty to storage tank at Sy. No. 1379 of Baad-III (Aligadda) Village, Karwar


Mysore Mercantile Co., Ltd., has requested to issue NOC for setting up Warehousing facility of

26088 KL Liquid Cargo Terminal with connecting pipeline from jetty to storage tank to store

Molasses, Edible Oil, Plam Oil, Kerosene, Aviation Fuel, High Speed Diesel, Lubrication Oil, Furnace

Oil, Low Sulphar Heavy Stock at Sy. No. 1379 of Baad-III (Aligadda) Village, Karwar Taluk, Uttara

Kannada District. The Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and

reported that project site is at jurisdication of 100 mts from HTL of River (as per CZMP approved

1996). It is classified as CRZ-III. The distance from HTL of sea is 305 mts. The G.P.S. readings are N

140 48’ 01.0’, E 740 07’ 22.3’.


the prescribed format, Site inspection report, R.T.C. of the site, Project report, EIA Report, approved

CZMP map sheet, draft digitized map showing the proposed area of construction and proceedings of

DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue of NOC in the

DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016 for the storage of all other products except Molasses.

As per the provisions under the Para 8 III CRZ III A (iii) (e) and Para 8 III CRZ III B (ii) of the

CRZ Notification 2011 facilities for receipt and storage of petroleum products and liquefied natural

gas as specified in Annexure-II; and as per Para 8 III CRZ III B (iv) of the CRZ Notification 2011

storage of non-hazardous cargo such as, edible oil, fertilizers, food grain in notified ports are

permissible. The storage of Molasses is not included in Annexure-II of the CRZ Notification 2011.

However the project proponent in his representation dated 25.01.2016 has requested to accord NOC

including the product ‘Molasses’ as it is a non hazardous in nature.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue of CRZ clearance to Mysore

Mercantile Co., Ltd., for setting up Warehousing facility of 26088 KL Liquid Cargo Terminal with


of 29

connecting pipeline from jetty to storage tank for storage of Edible Oil, Plam Oil, Kerosene, Aviation

Fuel, High Speed Diesel, Lubrication Oil, Furnace Oil, Low Sulphar Heavy Stock at Sy. No. 1379 of Baad-

III (Aligadda) Village, Karwar Taluk, Uttara Kannada District subject to clarification from the Port

Authorities whether the project area is a part of notified port area or not.

13.5.13 Request for issue of NOC from Sri. Sadanand Jatti Harikantra for construction of Fish

drying yards & net mending yards at Sy. No. 572/2, 572/3 of Hollangadde Village,

Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District (FEE 9 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Sadanand Jatti Harikantra has requested to issue NOC for construction of Fish drying

yards & net meding yards at Sy. No. 572/2, 572/3 of Hollangadde Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara

Kannada District. The Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and

reported that project site is at jurisdication of 150 mts from HTL of River (as per CZMP approved

1996). It is classified at CRZ-III. The distance from HTL of sea is 195.31 mts. The G.P.S. readings are N

140 26’ 38.3’, E 740 23’ 01.2’.


the prescribed format, Site inspection report, Sy. Map of site, R.T.C. of the site, Plinth area, CZMP map

sheet, draft digitized map showing the proposed area of construction, Sewage disposal Certificate

and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for

issue of NOC in the DCZMC meeting held on 07.01.2016.

As per the provisions under the Para 8 III CRZ III A (iii) (l) of the CRZ Notification 2011

facilities required for local fishing communities such as fish drying yards, auction halls, net mending

yards, traditional boat building yards, ice plant, ice crushing units, fish curing facilities and the like

are permissible. Hence, the above project is a permissible activity.


Sadanand Jatti Harikantra for construction of Fish drying yards & net mending yards at Sy. No. 572/2,

572/3 of Hollangadde Village, Kumta Taluk, Uttara Kannada District as per the recommendation of the

DCZMC.

13.6 Additional subjects with permission of the chair.

The Regional Director, Mangalore directly submitted the following proposals in the meeting for

considerationof the Authority.

13.6.1 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Sri. Prakash Kamath S/o Venkatesha Kamath

and Smt. Latha Kamath W/o Prakash Kamath for construction of residential house

(A Block) at Sy. No. 28/1A(P) of Hosabettu Village in Mangalore City Corporation Limits

(FEE 73 CRZ 2016).

Sri. Prakash Kamath S/o Venkatesha Kamath and Smt. Latha Kamath W/o Prakash Kamath has

requested to issue NOC for construction of residential house (A Block) at Sy. No. 28/1A(P) of Hosabettu

Village in Mangalore City Corporation Limits. The project site is at distance from HTL of Sea is 340 mts.

It is classified at CRZ-II. The G.P.S. readings are N 120 58’ 24.0’, E 740 48’ 01.0’.


of 29

The Regional Director (Environment) has submitted the proposal along with application in the

prescribed format, Site inspection report, Sy. Map of site, R.T.C. of the site, Plinth area, CZMP map sheet,

draft digitized map showing the proposed area of construction, Sewage disposal Certificate and

proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 28.01.2016. The DCZMC recommended the proposal for issue

of NOC in the DCZMC meeting held on 28.01.2016. The plinth area is 163.20 Sq. mt (G+1).

As per the provisions under the Para 8 II CRZ II (i) of the CRZ Notification 2011 buildings shall

be permitted only on the landward side of the existing road, or on the landward side of existing

authorized structures and as per Para 8 II CRZ II (ii) of the CRZ Notification 2011 buildings permitted

on the landward side of the existing and proposed roads or existing authorized structures shall be

subject to the existing local town and country planning regulations including the ‘existing’ norms of

Floor Space Index or Floor Area Ratio: Provided that no permission for construction of buildings shall

be given on landward side of any new roads which are constructed on the seaward side of an existing

road. Hence, the above project is a permissible activity.

The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to issue CRZ clearance to Sri. Prakash

Kamath S/o Venkatesha Kamath and Smt. Latha Kamath W/o Prakash Kamath for construction of

residential house (A Block) at Sy. No. 28/1A(P) of Hosabettu Village in Mangalore City Corporation Limits

as per the recommendation of the DCZMC.

13.6.2 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from Mr. Isaac Vas M/s. Jyothi Advertisers for

temporary (dismantle able) eco friendly structure for the purpose of restaurant with

permit room for tourists visiting panambur beach (FEE 74 CRZ 2016).

Mr. Isaac Vas M/s. Jyothi Advertisers has requested to issue NOC for temporary (dismantle

able) eco friendly structure for the purpose of restaurant with permit room for tourists visiting

panambur beach. The Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported

that project site is at jurisdiction of CRZ is 500 mts from HTL of Sea and 100 mts from HTL of River.

The distance from HTL of Sea is approximately 60 mts. It is classified at CRZ-II. The G.P.S. readings are

N 120 56’ 16.80’, E 740 48’ 16.10’. The area is inside the municipal limits of Mangalore City Corporation.


prescribed format, Site inspection report, Sy. Map of site, Site plan and building plan, Agreement, Copy

of challan about payment of processing fees, CZMP map sheet, Google map, Inspection report of

Regional Director (Environment) and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 28.01.2016. The DCZMC


The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to recommend the proposal to MoEF as

per Annexure-III of the CRZ Notification, 2011 for issue of CRZ clearance to Mr. Isaac Vas M/s. Jyothi

Advertisers for temporary (dismantle able) eco friendly structure for the purpose of restaurant with

permit room for tourists visiting panambur beach.


of 29

13.6.3 Request for issue of CRZ Clearance from The Commissioner of Police, Mangaluru City,

Mangaluru for construction of Police Parade Ground, DCP Office Complex, CDP

residence and Plice Research Centre at Sy. No. 2(P)2 and 52(P) of Bengre Village (FEE

75 CRZ 2016).

The Commissioner of Police, Mangaluru City, Mangaluru has requested to issue NOC for

construction of Police Parade Ground, DCP Office Complex, CDP residence and Plice Research Centre at

Sy. No. 2(P)2 and 52(P) of Bengre Village. The Regional Director (Environment) has inspected the

proposed site and reported that project site is at jurisdiction of CRZ is 500 mts from HTL of Sea and

100 mts from HTL of River. It is classified at CRZ-II. The G.P.S. readings are N 120 53’ 09.9’, E 740 48’

54.8’.


prescribed format, Site inspection report, Sy. Map of site, Site plan and building plan, Estimate,

Agreement, Copy of challan about payment of processing fees, CZMP map sheet, Google map, Inspection

report of Regional Director (Environment) and proceedings of DCZMC meeting held on 28.01.2016.


The Authority after discussion and deliberations decided to defer the proposal of the issue of CRZ

clearance to The Commissioner of Police, Mangaluru City, Mangaluru for construction of Police Parade

Ground, DCP Office Complex, CDP residence and Plice Research Centre at Sy. No. 2(P)2 and 52(P) of

Bengre Village as the proposal requires detailed examination. Further, the concerned Regional Director

was instructed to get the opinion of the Forest Department on the status of the land.


Mangaluru for construction of City Armed Reserve Police Quarters at Sy. No. 3(P)2 of

Bengre Village (FEE 77 CRZ 2016).


construction of City Armed Reserve Police Quarters at Sy. No. 3(P)2 of Bengre Village. The Regional

Director (Environment) has inspected the proposed site and reported that project site is at jurisdiction

of CRZ is 500 mts from HTL of Sea and 100 mts from HTL of River. The distance is approximately 25

mts to 30 mts from HTL of River and 180 mts from HTL of Sea. It is classified at CRZ-II. The G.P.S.

readings are as follows:

North: N 120 53’ 9.40’, E 740 49’ 4.30’.

South: N 120 53’ 1.66’, E 740 49’ 4.53’







clearance to The Commissioner of Police, Mangaluru City, Mangaluru for construction of City Armed

Reserve Police Quarters at Sy. No. 3(P)2 of Bengre Village as the proposal requires detailed examination.


of 29

Further, the concerned Regional Director was instructed to get the opinion of the Forest Department on

the status of the land.


Mangaluru for construction of Police Ration Canteen & Community Centre at Sy. No.

3/(P)1 of Bengre Village (FEE 76 CRZ 2016).


construction of Police Ration Canteen & Community Centre at Sy. No. 3/(P)1 of Bengre Village. The


jurisdiction of CRZ is 500 mts from HTL of Sea and 100 mts from HTL of River. The distance is

approximately 125 mts from HTL of River and 115 mts from HTL of Sea. It is classified at CRZ-II. The

G.P.S. readings is N 120 53’ 10.00’, E 740 49’ 00.65’.







clearance to The Commissioner of Police, Mangaluru City, Mangaluru for construction of Police Ration

Canteen & Community Centre at Sy. No. 3/(P)1 of Bengre Village as the proposal requires detailed

examination. Further, the concerned Regional Director was instructed to get the opinion of the Forest

Department on the status of the land.

13.7 The Authority after deliberation and discussion decided to hold the Authority meeting

on last Saturday of every month for speedy disposal of the cases and if last Saturday

happens to be a holiday, then the meeting will be held on last Friday of the month after

approval of new CZMP Maps / extension of validity for using already approved plans

from MoEF.

The meeting ended with thanks to the Chair.

Sd/-

(Mahendra Jain)

Additional Chief Secretary to Government,

Forest, Ecology & Environment Department &

Chairman, Karnataka State Coastal

Zone Management Authority.

No. FEE 236 CRZ 2013

Special Director (Technical Cell)

& Secretary, KSCZMA

Forest, Ecology and Environment Department.


of 29

Meeting of the 13th Karnataka State Coastal Zone Management Authority (KSCZMA) held

on 30th January, 2016 at 11:00 AM at Room No. 253, 2nd Gate, M.S. Building under the

chairmanship of Additional Chief Secretary to Government, Forest, Ecology &

Environment Department.

LIST OF MEMBERS/OFFICERS PRESENT

1. Sri Mahendra Jain, IAS.,

Chairman, KSCZMA &

Additional Chief Secretary to Government,

Department of Forest, Ecology & Environment,

M S Building, Bangalore – 560 001

In Chair

2. Additional Chief Secretary to Government,

Tourism Department,

Vikasa Soudha Bangalore. Leave of Absence

3. The Additional Chief Secretary to Government,

Industries and Commerce Department,

Vikasa Soudha, Bangalore Leave of Absence

4. Sri. Ramachandhra, IFS,

Secretary to Govt. (Ecology & Environment)

Forest, Ecology and Environment Department

Bangalore- 560 001.

Present

5. Sri. S.Shanthappa, IFS.,

Member Secretary,

Karnataka State Pollution Control Board,

No. 49, Parisara Bhavan, Church Street,

Bangalore- 560 001.

Present

6. Director,

Environment Management and Policy Research Institute (EMPRI),

Hasiru Bhavana', Doresanipalya Forest Campus,

Vinayaka Nagara Circle, J. P. Nagar, 5th Phase, Bangalore-560 076.

Present

7. Director,

Fisheries Department. Present

8. Dr. Shridhara, Scientist,

Karnataka State Remote Sensing Application Centre, KSRSAC,

Department of IT, BT, S&T, 6th Floor, Multi Storied Building,

Bangalore- 560 001.

Present


of 29

9. Dr. B.K. Shivaprasad Rai,

Consultant Surgeon and former Commandant of Home Guards,

Shourya, Martin Pais Road, Hat Hill,

Bejai Post, Mangalore-575004.

Leave of Absence

10. Dr. Subba Rao,

Professor Department of Applied Mechanics and Hydraulics,

National Institute of Technology, Karnataka,

Suratkal, Manalore.

Leave of Absence

11. Dr. Gangadhara Gowda

Professor and Head,

Aquatic Environment Management Department,

College of Fisheries, Mangalore.

Present

12. Dr. K.S. Jayappa

Professor,

Department of Marine Geology,

Mangalore University,

Mangala Gangothri, Mangalore.

Present

13. Sri Vijayakumar, IFS.,

Special Director (Technical Cell)

and Secretary,

Karnataka State Coastal Zone Management Authority,

Forest, Ecology and Environment Department.

Present

Invities Present:

14. Regional Director (Environment),

Forest, Ecology & Environment Department,

Corporation Commercial Complex,

I Floor, Lalbagh, Mangalore-575 003.

Present



1st Floor, C Block, Rajathadri,

District Administrative Centre,

Manipal- 576104, Udupi District.

Present



Meera Building, I Floor, Kajubagh, Karwar,

Uttara Kannada District.

Present

** ***** **

13th ksczma meeting proceedings - karnataka.gov.in ksczma... · s/o haji byari for reconstruction...

Documents