birds from ashes: the story of a flyash pond

1
126 101 48 78 93 32 10 3 3 197 131 76 121 136 56 25 4 74 Species Genera W.A. F.A. R M SR END Unique Species FA NMS References: 1.Grimmett R. et al. (1998) Birds of the Indian subcontinent. Oxford, UK 2. Dhadase S. et al. (2008): Flyash characterization, utilization and Government initiatives in India- a review. J. Sci. Ind. Res. 67:11-18. To understand similarity between both these systems Sorensen index was calculated. QS = 2C / (A+B) = 2(122)/(126+197) C = Number of species shared by the systems, A = Number of species in System I (FA), B = Number of Species in System II (NMS) QS = 0.75 This index value shows that there is moderately high similarity between both the systems(habitat diversity and space is not considered here). Line Transect; Point Count Study Period: From 2007 to 2011 Secondary data was obtained through interviews with locals and birdwatchers Distribution of Species Based on Residential Status A total of 7 mammalian (includes wild boar, fox & leopard), 9 reptilian (includes monitor lizard) and 23 Odonata species are known from flyash ponds. Other Taxa MATERIALS & METHODS Fly ash (FA) is coal combustion product, generated from coal based power generation. It is toxic in nature. Pollution due to FA is a universal problem , affecting human health and agriculture; directly and indirectly. Around 68% of power generation in Maharashtra is coal based, contributing to India’s annual FA production which is 112 metric tons plus. Many of the thermal power stations are located near important wildlife areas. FA Ponds of Nashik are situated around 1 km away from main power station and around 40 kms by road and ~20 kms by crow flight distance from Nandur-Madhyameshwar bird sanctuary (NMS) (Map 1) NMS is an ideal habitat for migratory birds. On the other hand FA ponds being toxic in nature, still act as breeding ground for many resident and several migratory birds. Information on such smaller toxic wetland systems is scarce in scientific literature . Our work shows that owing to the fact that FA is a toxic system, it has comparable species diversity with that of NMS and that if it is developed into an ecopark, it may provide alternative employment option for those affected by FA. INTRODUCTION Species Distribution : A Comparative Account W.A.: Wetland associated; F.A.: Forest associated; R: Resident; M: Winter migratory; PV: Passage visitor; S: Summer Visitor; SR: Scarce Records; END: Near threatened/Critically endangered Sorensen Index Birds from Ashes: The Story of a Flyash Pond Purushottam Patil 1 , Anand Billade 2 , Pankaj Koparde 3 1 Corresponding author : [email protected], Siddhant CoE, Chakan, Pune 2 Department of Applied Sciences, CoEP, Pune; 3 Department of Biodiversity, Garware College, Pune Distribution of Species Based on Scarce Records OBSERVATIONS & RESULTS NMS Species Distribution based on Residential Status FA Pond Species Distribution based on Residential Status FA Species Distribution based on Scarcity Records NMS Species Distribution based on Scarcity Records Flyash Pond Landscape Little Grebe Indian Grey Hornbill Eurasian Marsh Harrier Flyash Brick Factory DISCUSSION Weather is cloudy, I guess. Take it as a clue buddy! Coot Citrine Wagtail Rufous Tailed Lark Ruddy Shelducks Banded Kukri A Dead Representative: Civet Road kill Senegal Golden Dartlets Mating A Pocher Setting a Trap Black Winged Stilts Common Stonechat Shovelers Flying High An Ashiete Arachnid Desert Wheatear Map 1 It seems that although a toxic system, FA ponds represent a wetland ecosystem similar to NMS. Surprisingly, FA ponds have 3 unique bird species than NMS. Birds for People FA floods have ruined down fields which are nearby to FA deposition sites. This has resulted in the decrease of land prizes. Eco parks can be a good employment option for those affected by FA. If properly studied and managed then FA sites can be converted into eco parks for nature education, bird watching and scientific research. This may seem difficult but developing something on a potentially hazardous waste land can be of experimental use. FA pond system is of great research potential. Pond to Pond movement of migratory birds and factors affecting the choice of breeding ground are some of the most complex questions in bird migration which are not much resolved. Owing to the toxic nature of FA, these questions become much more complex than earlier thought! 24% 1% 70% M PV R 20% 1% 49% M PV R 60% 10% 30% Migratory Passage Resident 56% 12% 32% Migratory Passage Resident Lesser Whistling Teals Acknowledgements Dr. Mahesh Shindikar, Mr. Anil Mali, Prafull Sawarkar & Our Novice Efforts to Explore Wilderness

Upload: others

Post on 15-Oct-2021

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Birds from Ashes: The Story of a Flyash Pond

126

101

48

7893

32

10 3 3

197

131

76

121136

56

254

74

Species Genera W.A. F.A. R M SR END Unique Species

FA NMS

References: 1.Grimmett R. et al. (1998) Birds of the Indian subcontinent.Oxford, UK 2. Dhadase S. et al. (2008): Flyash characterization, utilizationand Government initiatives in India- a review. J. Sci. Ind. Res. 67:11-18.

To understand similarity between both these systems Sorensen index was calculated.

QS = 2C / (A+B) = 2(122)/(126+197)C = Number of species shared by the systems, A = Number of species in

System I (FA), B = Number of Species in System II (NMS) QS = 0.75

This index value shows that there is moderately high similarity between both the systems(habitat diversity and space is not considered here).

Line Transect; Point CountStudy Period: From 2007 to 2011 Secondary data was obtained through interviews with locals and birdwatchers

Distribution of Species Based on Residential Status

A total of 7 mammalian (includes wild boar, fox & leopard), 9 reptilian (includes monitor lizard) and 23 Odonata species are known from flyash ponds.

Other Taxa

MATERIALS & METHODS

Fly ash (FA) is coal combustion product, generated from coal based power generation.It is toxic in nature. Pollution due to FA is a universal problem, affecting human healthand agriculture; directly and indirectly.

Around 68% of power generation in Maharashtra is coal based, contributing to India’sannual FA production which is 112 metric tons plus. Many of the thermal power stationsare located near important wildlife areas.

FA Ponds of Nashik are situated around 1 km away from main power station and around40 kms by road and ~20 kms by crow flight distance from Nandur-Madhyameshwar birdsanctuary (NMS) (Map 1)

NMS is an ideal habitat for migratory birds. On the other hand FA ponds being toxic innature, still act as breeding ground for many resident and several migratory birds.Information on such smaller toxic wetland systems is scarce in scientific literature .

Our work shows that owing to the fact that FA is a toxic system, it has comparable species diversity with that of NMS and that if it is developed into an ecopark, it

may provide alternative employment option for those affected by FA.

INTRODUCTION

Species Distribution : A Comparative Account

W.A.: Wetland associated; F.A.: Forest associated; R: Resident; M: Winter migratory; PV: Passage visitor; S: Summer Visitor; SR: Scarce Records; END: Near threatened/Critically endangered

Sorensen Index

Birds from Ashes: The Story of a Flyash PondPurushottam Patil1, Anand Billade2, Pankaj Koparde3

1Corresponding author: [email protected], Siddhant CoE, Chakan, Pune2Department of Applied Sciences, CoEP, Pune; 3Department of Biodiversity, Garware College, Pune

Distribution of Species Based on Scarce Records

OBSERVATIONS & RESULTS

NMS Species Distribution basedon Residential Status

FA Pond Species Distribution basedon Residential Status

FA Species Distribution based on Scarcity Records

NMS Species Distribution based on Scarcity Records

Flyash Pond Landscape

Little GrebeIndian Grey Hornbill

Eurasian Marsh Harrier

Flyash Brick Factory

DISCUSSIONWeather is

cloudy, I guess.

Take it as a clue

buddy!

Coot Citrine Wagtail RufousTailed Lark

Ruddy Shelducks

Banded Kukri A Dead Representative: Civet Road kill

Senegal Golden Dartlets Mating

A Pocher Setting a Trap

Black Winged StiltsCommonStonechat Shovelers Flying High

An Ashiete Arachnid

Desert Wheatear

Map 1

It seems that although a toxic system, FA ponds represent a wetlandecosystem similar to NMS. Surprisingly, FA ponds have 3 unique birdspecies than NMS.

Birds for PeopleFA floods have ruined down fields which are nearby to FA deposition

sites. This has resulted in the decrease of land prizes. Eco parks can bea good employment option for those affected by FA. If properly studiedand managed then FA sites can be converted into eco parks for natureeducation, bird watching and scientific research. This may seem difficultbut developing something on a potentially hazardous waste land can beof experimental use. FA pond system is of great research potential. Pondto Pond movement of migratory birds and factors affecting the choice ofbreeding ground are some of the most complex questions in birdmigration which are not much resolved. Owing to the toxic nature ofFA, these questions become much more complex than earlier thought!

24%

1%

70%

M PV R

20%

1%49%

M PV R

60%10%

30%

Migratory Passage Resident

56%

12%

32%

Migratory Passage Resident

Lesser Whistling Teals

AcknowledgementsDr. Mahesh Shindikar, Mr. Anil Mali, Prafull Sawarkar &

Our Novice Efforts to Explore Wilderness