bootstrap methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 the dual bootstrap fix the background on one sample...

22
Bootstrap Methods 1

Upload: others

Post on 15-Aug-2020

8 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

Bootstrap Methods

1

Page 2: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

2

Page 3: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

3

Page 4: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

4

Page 5: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

5

Page 6: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

6

Page 7: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

7

The best one !!!

The non parametricSampling methods

Up to 2006

Page 8: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

8

Non parametric Bootstrap

Page 9: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

9

Page 10: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

10

Page 11: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

11

Page 12: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

14

Page 13: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

15

Page 14: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

16

Bootstrap of B1 and Bi data

Trimmed mean 50%Correlation between measurementsWeighted resampling Int(1/s2) timesThe error on measurements is not considered

Scope of the analysis: to test wether errors only or the data itself are unreliable

Page 15: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

17

Page 16: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

18

Results

Bootstrap:

Standard analysis:

1.36.03.1

3.818.85

22

9.33.05.1

6.806.86

22

Some data areunreliable

Page 17: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

19

Page 18: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

20

Useful when the two samples are signal and background....

Page 19: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

21

The dual Bootstrap

Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signalwith another sample to avoid biases !!

Repeat on bootstrap samples (dual bootstrap)

Page 20: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

22

Page 21: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

23

A word on the permutation tests

Page 22: Bootstrap Methodsrotondi/bootstrap.pdf · 21 The dual Bootstrap Fix the background on one sample and calculated the peak signal with another sample to avoid biases !! Repeat on bootstrap

24

Conclusions•Poissonian Counting: most of the tests do not consider the error on background andoverestimate the signal. Often true (mean) valuesand measured values are improperly confused.

•Binomial counting: a general theory there existsand should be applied.

•The errors should be calculated by MC methodsand the procedure checked with MC toy models

•Nonparametric Bootstrap methods should be usedalso by physicists