Under Secretary for Management

Border Security Status Report Third Quarter, Fiscal Year 2016

April 3, 2017 Fiscal Year 2016 Report to Congress

April 3, 2017

Executive Summary

DHS secures our Nation’s air, land, and sea borders to prevent illegal activity while facilitating lawful travel and trade. The Department’s border security and management efforts focus on three interrelated goals: effectively securing U.S. air, land, and sea borders; safeguarding and streamlining lawful trade and travel; and disrupting and, in coordination with other federal agencies, dismantling transnational criminal and terrorist organizations.

Through the unprecedented deployment of personnel, technology, and infrastructure, the U.S. border never has been more secure. The integration of intelligence and enforcement capabilities through intergovernmental task forces and partnerships has facilitated better information sharing, leading to the increased interdiction of drugs, weapons, and currency. By focusing on the highest threats and rapidly responding, DHS has strengthened security across all U.S. borders while facilitating international travel and trade.

Highlights for FY 2016 Q3 compared to last quarter FY 2016 Q2:

• U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) Border Patrol (BP) apprehensions increased 36 percent in FY 2016 Q3 (114,723) compared to FY 2016 Q2 (84,631).

• CBP BP apprehensions of Mexicans increased 14 percent in FY 2016 Q3 (55,372) compared to last quarter (48,553). Apprehensions of non-Mexicans increased 65 percent in FY 2016 Q3 (59,351) compared to last quarter (36,078) (Tables 2 and 3).

• The number of DHS removals increased 19 percent in FY 2016 Q3 (95,428) compared to FY 2016 Q2 (80,516).

• The number of DHS returns decreased 3 percent in FY 2016 Q3 (26,648) compared to FY 2016 Q2 (27,403).

The report includes figures and tables on the following topics:

• Apprehensions, administrative arrests, and inadmissible aliens • Notices to appear • Criminal arrests • Legal entries • Detention • Removals and returns • Worksite enforcement and E-Verify • Seizures – drugs, weapons, and currency • U. S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and CBP staffing • Violence against CBP agents and officers • Stonegarden grants

ii

Border Security Status Report

Table of Contents I. Legislative Requirement ..................................................................................................... 1

II. Background......................................................................................................................... 2 A. Overview of Congressional Mandate ........................................................... 2 B. Data Presented ............................................................................................ 2

III. Results/Analysis.................................................................................................................. 3 A. Data Trends ................................................................................................ 3 B. Apprehensions, Administrative Arrests, and Inadmissible Aliens (Figures 1–4

and Tables 1–4) .......................................................................................... 4 Figure 1. CBP BP Apprehensions: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ........................................ 4 Table 1. CBP BP Apprehensions by Sector: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ......................... 5 Table 2. CBP BP Apprehensions of Mexican Nationals by Sector: FYs 2012 to

2016 Q3................................................................................................................ 6 Table 3. CBP BP Apprehensions of Non-Mexican Nationals by Sector: FYs 2012 to

2016 Q3................................................................................................................ 7 Figure 2. ICE HSI Administrative Arrests: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ........................... 8 Figure 3. ICE ERO Administrative Arrests: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 .......................... 9 Figure 4. Aliens Determined Inadmissible by CBP Office of Field Operations (OFO):

FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3........................................................................................... 10 Table 4. Aliens Determined Inadmissible by CBP OFO Field Office: FYs 2012 to

2016 Q3 ................................................................................................................ 11 C. Unique Individuals Apprehended by CBP BP (Figure 5) .............................. 12

Figure 5. Apprehensions from IDENT by CBP BP: FYs 2009 to 2015 ................... 12 D. Notices to Appear Issued (Figures 6–9) and USCIS Fraud Cases Referred to

ICE (Figure 10) .......................................................................................... 13 Figure 6. NTAs Issued by USCIS: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ........................................ 13 Figure 7. NTAs Issued by CBP BP: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ...................................... 14 Figure 8. NTAs Issued by CBP OFO: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ................................... 14 Figure 9. NTAs Issued by ICE ERO: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 .................................... 15 Figure 10. USCIS Fraud Cases Referred to ICE for Criminal Investigation: FYs 2012

to 2016 Q3............................................................................................................ 16

iii

E. Criminal Arrests (Figures 11–13) ................................................................ 17 Figure 11. ICE HSI Criminal Arrests: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ................................... 17 Figure 12. ICE ERO Criminal Arrests: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 .................................. 18 Figure 13. CBP OFO Criminal Arrests: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ................................ 18

F. Legal Entries (Figure 14 and Table 5) ......................................................... 19 Figure 14. Legal Entries of Citizens and Noncitizens: FYs 2013 to 2016 Q3 .......... 19 Table 5. Legal Entries to the United States by Citizens and Noncitizens by CBP OFO

Field Office: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 .................................................................... 20 G. Detention (Figures 15–17 and Tables 6–8) .................................................. 21

Figure 16. Average Daily Population (ADP) of Aliens in ICE Detention: FYs 2012 to

Figure 17. Average Length of Stay (in days) for Aliens Released from Detention:

Figure 15. Initial Admissions to ICE Detention Facilities: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ... 21

2016 Q3................................................................................................................ 22 Table 6. ADP of Aliens Detained in IGSA Facilities by State: FY 2016 Q3 ........... 23 Table 7. ADP of Aliens Detained in Service Processing Centers: FY 2016 Q3 ....... 24 Table 8. ADP of Aliens Detained in Contract Facilities: FY 2016 Q3 ..................... 24

FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3........................................................................................... 25 H. Removals and Returns (Figure 18) .............................................................. 26

Figure 18. DHS Removals and Returns: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ................................ 26 I. Worksite Enforcement and E-Verify (Figures 19–24) .................................. 27

Figure 21. ICE Worksite Criminal Arrests—Owners/Employers: FYs 2012 to

Figure 22. ICE Worksite Administrative Arrests—Employees/Other: FYs 2012 to

Figure 19. Worksite Enforcement—Criminal Fines: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ............. 27 Figure 20. Worksite Enforcement—Civil Fines: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3................... 28

2016 Q3................................................................................................................ 29

2016 Q3................................................................................................................ 30 Figure 23. Employers Newly Registered in E-Verify: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 .......... 31 Figure 24. E-Verify Employer Queries: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q2 ................................ 32

J. Seizures—Drugs, Weapons, and Currency (Tables 9–11)............................. 33

Table 10. Drug, Weapon, and Currency Seizures by CBP OFO: FYs 2014 to

Table 11. Drug, Weapon, and Currency Seizures by ICE HSI: FYs 2014 to

Table 9. Drug, Weapon, and Currency Seizures by CBP BP: FYs 2014 to 2016 Q3 33

2016 Q3................................................................................................................ 33

2016 Q3 ................................................................................................................ 33 K. U.S. Customs and Border Protection Staffing (Figure 25 and Tables 12–15) 34

Figure 25. CBP BP Agents and CBP Officers: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ...................... 34 Table 12. CBP BP Agents by Sector: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 .................................... 35 Table 13. CBP OFO Officers by Field Office: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ...................... 36 Table 14. ICE ERO Agents by Area of Responsibility: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ........ 37 Table 15. ICE HSI Agents by Special Agent in Charge Jurisdiction: FYs 2012 to

2016 Q3 ................................................................................................................ 38 K. Violence against CBP and ICE HSI Agents and Officers (Tables 16–18) ..... 39

Table 16. Violence against CBP BP Agents: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3 ......................... 39 Table 17. Violence against CBP OFO Officers: FYs 2011 to 2016 Q3.................... 40 Table 18. Violence against ICE HSI Agents: FYs 2011 to 2016 Q3 ........................ 41

L. Stonegarden Grants (Table 19) .................................................................... 42

iv

Table 19. Stonegarden Grant Program: FYs 2010 to 2016 ....................................... 42

IV. Appendices.......................................................................................................................... 43

Table B1. U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) Office of Border Patrol (OBP)

Table B2. CBP OBP Apprehensions of Mexican Nationals by Sector: FYs 2003 to

Table B4. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Homeland Security

Table B5. ICE Enforcement Removal Operations (ERO) Administrative Arrests:

Table B6. Aliens Determined Inadmissible by CBP Office of Field Operations (OFO)

Table D1. Notices to Appear (NTA) Issued by U.S. Citizenship and Immigration

Table F1. Legal Entries, Citizens and Noncitizens Admitted: FYs 2003 to

Table F2. Legal Entries, Citizens and Noncitizens Admitted by CBP OFO Field

Table F2. Legal Entries, Citizens and Noncitizens Admitted by CBP OFO Field

Table G3. ADP of Aliens Detained in Intergovernmental Service Agreement (IGSA)

Table G3. ADP of Aliens Detained in IGSA Facilities by State: FYs 2010 to

Table G3. ADP of Aliens Detained in IGSA Facilities by State: FYs 2010 to

Table G3. ADP of Aliens Detained in IGSA Facilities by State: FYs 2010 to

Table I1. Worksite Enforcement—Judicially Ordered Amount of Criminal Fines,

Appendix A. Glossary ...................................................................................... 43 Appendix B. List of Abbreviations/Acronyms................................................... 45 Appendix C. Data Tables.................................................................................. 46

Apprehensions by Sector: Fiscal Years (FY) 2002 to 2016 Q3 .......................... 46

2016 Q3 ................................................................................................................ 48 Table B3. CBP OBP Apprehensions of Non-Mexican Nationals by Sector: FYs 2003

to 2016 Q3............................................................................................................ 50

Investigations (HSI) Administrative Arrests: FYs 2008 to 2016 Q3 .................. 52

FYs 2008 to 2016 Q3........................................................................................... 53

Field Office: FYs 2005 to 2016 Q3 .................................................................... 54

Services (USCIS): FYs 2003 to 2016 Q3 ........................................................... 57 Table D2. NTAs Issued by CBP OBP: FYs 2005 to 2016 Q3 .................................. 58 Table D3. NTAs Issued by CBP OFO: FYs 2005 to 2016 Q3 .................................. 59 Table D4. NTAs Issued by ICE ERO: FYs 2009 to 2016 Q3................................... 60 Table D5. USCIS Fraud Cases Referred to ICE: FYs 2005 to 2016 Q3................... 61 Table E1. ICE HSI Criminal Arrests: FYs 2008 to 2016 Q3 .................................... 62 Table E2. ICE ERO Criminal Arrests: FYs 2008 to 2016 Q3 .................................. 63 Table E3. CBP OFO Criminal Arrests: FYs 2008 to 2016 Q3 ................................. 64

2016 Q3 ................................................................................................................ 65

Office: FYs 2003 to 2016 Q3............................................................................... 66

Office: FYs 2003 to 2016 Q3 (continued) ........................................................... 67 Table G1. Initial Admissions to ICE Detention Facilities: FYs 2008 to 2016 Q3.... 68 Table G2. ICE Average Daily Population (ADP): FYs 2002 to 2016 Q3 ................ 69

Facilities by State: FYs 2010 to 2016 Q3 ........................................................... 70

2016 Q3 ................................................................................................................ 71

2016 Q3 ................................................................................................................ 72

2016 Q3 ................................................................................................................ 73 Table H1. DHS Removals and Returns: FYs 2003 to 2016 Q3 ................................ 74

Forfeitures, and Restitutions: FYs 2004 to 2016 Q3 .......................................... 75 Table I2. Worksite Enforcement Final Orders of Civil Fines: FYs 2004 to 2016 Q3 76

v

Table I3. ICE Worksite Arrests—Owners/Employers: FYs 2005 to 2016 Q3 ......... 77 Table I4. ICE Worksite Arrests—Employees/Other: FYs 2005 to 2016 Q3 ............ 78 Table I5. Employers Registered in E-Verify: FYs 2002 to 2016 Q3 ........................ 79 Table I6. E-Verify Employer Queries: FYs 2002 to 2016 Q2 .................................. 80 Table J1. Drug, Weapon, and Currency Seizures by CBP OBP: FYs 2009 to

2016 Q3 ................................................................................................................ 81 Table J2. Drug, Weapon, and Currency Seizures by CBP OFO: FYs 2009 to

2016 Q3 ................................................................................................................ 82 Table K1. CBP BP Agents by Sector: FYs 2002 to 2016 Q3 ................................... 83 Table K2. CBP Officers by Field Office: FYs 2003 to 2016 Q3 .............................. 86 Table L1. Violence against CBP OBP Agents by Sector: FYs 2007 to 2016 Q3 ..... 89 Table L2. OFO Violence against Agents by Field Office: FYs 2010 to 2016 Q3 .... 91

vi

I. Legislative Requirement

This report has been prepared pursuant to the direction in Senate Report 114-68 accompanying the Fiscal Year (FY) 2016 Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Appropriations Act (P.L. 114-113).

Senate Report 114-68 states:

The Committee continues its requirement that the Department submit quarterly Border Security Status reports, as directed in prior years. In an era of supposed Government transparency, this data should be readily available to the Committee and the public.

1

II. Background

A. Overview of Congressional Mandate

This Border Security Status Report (BSSR) includes data for the third quarter of FY 2016. The BSSR is a revised version of the Secure Border Initiative report, which last was released with data through FY 2010.

The original Quarterly Status Report on the Department of Homeland Security’s Border Security Performance and Resources was provided in 2006 in response to a letter from the House Appropriations Committee. The data series included in the BSSR overlaps with many of those in prior border security performance and resources reports; however, the BSSR excludes detailed program descriptions, accomplishments, and resource information. The list of data series provided in this report was reviewed with committee staff and is described in Section B.

B. Data Presented

There are 25 figures and 19 tables in the body of the report and 32 tables in the appendix that provide data on the enforcement-related activities listed below. This report provides data on the following categories of border security and immigration enforcement-related activities.

• Apprehensions, administrative arrests, and inadmissible aliens • Notices to appear (NTA) • Criminal arrests • Legal entries • Detention • Removals and returns • Worksite enforcement and E-Verify • Seizures – drugs, weapons, and currency • Staffing • Violence against U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) agents and officers • Stonegarden grants

Note that some data for previous fiscal years have been shifted to the appendix.

2

III. Results/Analysis

The Office of Immigration Statistics (OIS) compiles the BSSR from data received from DHS Components. The compilation of these data shows specifics and trends as shown below.

A. Data Trends

• CBP Border Patrol (BP) apprehensions increased 36 percent in FY 2016 Q3 (114,723) compared to FY 2016 Q2 (84,631).

• CBP BP apprehensions of Mexicans increased 14 percent in FY 2016 Q3 (55,372) compared to last quarter (48,553). Apprehensions of non-Mexicans increased 65 percent in FY 2016 Q3 (59,351) compared to last quarter (36,078) (Tables 2 and 3).

• The number of DHS removals increased 19 percent in FY 2016 Q3 (95,428) compared to FY 2016 Q2 (80,516).

• The number of DHS returns decreased 3 percent in FY 2016 Q3 (26,648) compared to FY 2016 Q2 (27,403).

The figures and tables in this section include notes about the data sources and, where applicable, descriptions of changes in definitions over time or in data compared to past reports. Quarterly data, when not included in the Results/Analysis section, are provided in the appendix (see IV. Appendix C. Data Tables). The data included in this report were provided by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), CBP, and U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) and may differ from data reported by each Component because of differences in data compilation or reporting practices. Moreover, Component systems frequently are “living,” meaning that such systems accept corrections, modifications, and new entries for a period of time. As a result, data provided to OIS are a snapshot as of a specific date, and numbers retrieved on a subsequent date may differ from those originally provided.

3

B. Apprehensions, Administrative Arrests, and Inadmissible Aliens1 (Figures 1–4 and Tables 1–4)

Figure 1. CBP BP Apprehensions: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Source: DHS, CBP BP, Enforcement Integrated Database (EID), July 2016. See Appendix Table B1 for quarterly totals.

1 An administrative arrest refers to the arrest of an alien who is charged with an immigration violation under section 212 or 237 of the Immigration and Nationality Act. Administrative arrests conducted by BP traditionally have been referred to as apprehensions and this convention is used in the following BP charts and tables. Administrative arrest data are provided for CBP BP, ICE Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), and ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO).

4

Table 1. CBP BP Apprehensions by Sector: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Border Patrol sector 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

YTD Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 YTD Q1 Q2 Q3 Total Apprehensions 364,768 420,789 486,651 337,117 77,713 76,883 91,854 90,667 303,534 104,180 84,631 114,723 Big Bend, TX1 3,964 3,684 4,096 5,031 870 1,016 1,378 1,767 5,045 2,062 1,462 1,521 Blaine, WA 537 360 272 282 113 61 50 58 191 68 67 56 Buffalo, NY 1,143 796 741 291 97 60 49 85 144 26 53 65 Del Rio, TX 21,720 23,510 24,255 19,013 3,282 3,994 6,111 5,626 17,920 5,856 5,333 6,731 Detroit, MI 950 650 647 637 252 107 152 126 489 150 148 191 EL Centro, CA 23,916 16,306 14,511 12,820 2,716 3,248 3,602 3,254 13,710 3,707 4,180 5,823 EL Paso, TX 9,678 11,154 12,339 14,495 2,749 3,188 4,261 4,297 17,464 5,503 4,702 7,259 Grand Forks, ND 418 469 767 789 237 192 153 207 331 105 123 103 Havre, MT 102 37 91 64 11 19 10 24 32 10 7 15 Houlton, ME 41 88 45 32 11 10 3 8 22 7 5 10 Laredo, TX 44,872 50,749 44,049 35,888 8,183 8,733 9,582 9,390 27,906 9,390 8,547 9,969 Miami, FL 2,509 1,738 2,034 1,752 283 316 414 739 2,343 815 699 829 New Orleans, LA 474 500 950 849 313 192 185 159 513 181 143 189 Ramey, PR 702 154,453 958 557 163 143 108 143 512 142 159 211 Rio Grande Valley, TX 97,762 924 256,393 147,257 34,532 29,799 40,455 42,471 131,405 48,070 32,383 50,952 San Diego, CA 28,461 27,496 29,911 26,290 6,337 7,453 6,673 5,827 23,419 6,306 8,139 8,974 Spokane, WA 317 299 269 190 49 50 36 55 145 29 22 94 Swanton, VT 702 531 506 341 74 52 65 150 179 63 50 66 Tucson, AZ 120,000 120,939 87,915 63,397 16,174 16,678 16,729 13,816 51,707 17,955 15,966 17,786 Yuma, AZ 6,500 6,106 5,902 7,142 1,267 1,572 1,838 2,465 10,057 3,735 2,443 3,879

1 Known as Marfa, Texas, before 2012. Source: DHS, CBP BP, EID, July 2016. See Appendix Table B1 for quarterly totals.

5

Table 2. CBP BP Apprehensions of Mexican Nationals by Sector: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Border Patrol sector 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

YTD Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 YTD Q1 Q2 Q3 Total Apprehensions 265,755 267,734 229,178 188,122 45,267 49,412 49,693 43,750 148,355 44,430 48,553 55,372 Big Bend, TX1 3,417 3,174 3,164 2,177 549 599 551 478 2,063 599 720 744 Blaine, WA 270 106 58 67 37 14 12 4 29 14 5 10 Buffalo, NY 607 370 294 137 51 28 17 41 50 11 26 13 Del Rio, TX 12,404 14,005 10,196 10,874 2,044 2,838 3,158 2,834 10,618 2,689 3,739 4,190 Detroit, MI 673 479 431 427 167 74 91 95 350 117 109 124 EL Centro, CA 22,511 15,141 12,511 11,320 2,399 3,003 3,242 2,676 10,373 2,782 3,300 4,291 EL Paso, TX 8,915 10,092 9,904 10,677 2,247 2,687 2,987 2,756 10,091 2,741 3,247 4,103 Grand Forks, ND 306 337 532 563 162 133 117 151 227 67 91 69 Havre, MT 54 62 51 46 7 13 6 20 11 5 2 4 Houlton, ME 8 1 5 1 . . . 1 7 4 . 3 Laredo, TX 31,742 32,772 26,540 25,766 6,073 6,730 6,757 6,206 19,693 6,276 6,436 6,981 Miami, FL 831 388 277 273 31 45 77 120 507 170 180 157 New Orleans, LA 277 262 465 394 133 99 82 80 272 78 94 100 Ramey, PR - 3 - 1 . . . 1 . . . . Rio Grande Valley, TX 47,823 57,624 63,468 48,173 11,555 11,428 13,229 11,961 34,620 10,233 10,816 13,571 San Diego, CA 27,307 26,223 27,871 24,269 5,932 7,042 6,135 5,160 19,045 5,185 6,721 7,139 Spokane, WA 266 237 219 153 40 46 29 38 109 24 19 66 Swanton, VT 122 80 75 43 20 6 7 10 14 7 2 5 Tucson, AZ 102,303 101,092 68,870 48,916 12,870 13,536 12,301 10,209 37,515 12,530 12,186 12,799 Yuma, AZ 5,919 5,286 4,247 3,845 950 1,091 895 909 2,761 898 860 1,003

- Represents zero.

1 Known as Marfa, Texas, before 2012. Source: DHS, CBP BP, EID, July 2016. See Appendix Table B2 for quarterly totals.

6

Table 3. CBP BP Apprehensions of Non-Mexican Nationals by Sector: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Border Patrol sector 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

YTD Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 YTD Q1 Q2 Q3 Total Apprehensions 99,013 153,055 257,473 148,995 32,446 27,471 42,161 46,917 155,179 59,750 36,078 59,351 Big Bend, TX1 547 510 932 2,854 321 417 827 1,289 2,982 1,463 742 777 Blaine, WA 267 254 214 215 76 47 38 54 162 54 62 46 Buffalo, NY 536 426 447 154 46 32 32 44 94 15 27 52 Del Rio, TX 9,316 9,505 14,059 8,139 1,238 1,156 2,953 2,792 7,302 3,167 1,594 2,541 Detroit, MI 277 171 216 210 85 33 61 31 139 33 39 67 EL Centro, CA 1,405 1,165 2,000 1,500 317 245 360 578 3,337 925 880 1,532 EL Paso, TX 763 1,062 2,435 3,818 502 501 1,274 1,541 7,373 2,762 1,455 3,156 Grand Forks, ND 112 132 235 226 75 59 36 56 104 38 32 34 Havre, MT 48 26 40 18 4 6 4 4 21 5 5 11 Houlton, ME 33 36 40 31 11 10 3 7 15 3 5 7 Laredo, TX 13,130 17,977 17,509 10,122 2,110 2,003 2,825 3,184 8,213 3,114 2,111 2,988 Miami, FL 1,678 1,350 1,757 1,479 252 271 337 619 1,836 645 519 672 New Orleans, LA 197 238 485 455 180 93 103 79 241 103 49 89 Ramey, PR 702 921 958 556 163 143 108 142 512 142 159 211 Rio Grande Valley, TX 49,939 96,829 192,925 99,084 22,977 18,371 27,226 30,510 96,785 37,837 21,567 37,381 San Diego, CA 1,154 1,273 2,040 2,021 405 411 538 667 4,374 1,121 1,418 1,835 Spokane, WA 51 62 50 37 9 4 7 17 36 5 3 28 Swanton, VT 580 451 431 298 54 46 58 140 165 56 48 61 Tucson, AZ 17,697 19,847 19,045 14,481 3,304 3,142 4,428 3,607 14,192 5,425 3,780 4,987 Yuma, AZ 581 820 1,655 3,297 317 481 943 1,556 7,296 2,837 1,583 2,876 1 Known as Marfa, Texas, before 2012.

Source: DHS, CBP BP, EID, July 2016. See Appendix Table B3 for quarterly totals.

7

Figure 2. ICE HSI Administrative Arrests: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Source: DHS, ICE HSI, EID Arrest Guide for Law Enforcement (EAGLE) July 2016. See Appendix Table B4 for quarterly totals.

8

Figure 3. ICE ERO Administrative Arrests: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: Includes arrests under the 287(g) program. Source: DHS, ICE ERO, ICE Integrated Decision Support (IIDS), July 2016. See Appendix Table B5 for quarterly totals.

9

Figure 4. Aliens Determined Inadmissible by CBP Office of Field Operations (OFO): FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: Data include all aliens seeking admission at a port of entry found inadmissible, including those turned away at a port of entry or conditionally permitted to enter the United States. Source: DHS, CBP OFO, EID, July 2016. See Appendix Table B6 for quarterly totals.

10

Table 4. Aliens Determined Inadmissible by CBP OFO Field Office: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Field office 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

Total Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Total Q1 Q2 Q3 Total 193,609 203,962 223,253 253,509 60,450 61,313 61,193 70,553 200,378 67,972 66,330 66,076

Atlanta, GA 7,984 8,363 10,439 8,144 2,241 2,105 1,945 1,853 5,245 1,776 1,623 1,846 Baltimore, MD 3,613 3,119 2,882 2,367 583 552 685 547 843 322 233 288 Boston, MA 4,821 4,984 4,534 5,115 1,583 1,229 1,061 1,242 2,583 629 1,327 627 Buffalo, NY 14,050 13,422 13,114 11,871 3,089 2,552 2,817 3,413 8,572 2,885 2,948 2,739 Chicago, IL 2,449 2,172 2,302 4,348 795 914 1,279 1,360 2,793 758 980 1,055

Detroit, MI 6,743 6,554 6,096 5,989 1,447 1,384 1,501 1,657 3,803 1,226 1,244 1,333 El Paso, TX 6,955 7,852 10,170 12,071 2,841 2,696 2,945 3,589 16,202 3,739 4,611 7,852 Houston, TX 12,706 10,909 10,447 11,185 2,036 2,822 3,181 3,146 7,176 2,497 2,293 2,386 Laredo, TX 28,005 31,764 38,978 52,136 11,330 11,317 12,649 16,840 49,933 18,774 17,935 13,224 Los Angeles, CA 3,928 3,905 4,070 5,735 1,258 1,381 1,532 1,564 4,323 1,313 1,491 1,519

Miami, FL 7,593 8,686 12,193 17,687 3,790 4,551 4,419 4,927 13,973 5,144 4,307 4,522 New Orleans, LA 20,204 21,012 21,199 20,550 5,933 6,005 4,476 4,136 11,649 4,341 4,058 3,250 New York, NY 4,912 4,647 4,614 4,319 954 959 1,295 1,111 3,397 1,111 1,161 1,125 Portland, OR 1,166 1,402 1,116 1,636 187 397 456 596 1,177 250 445 482 Pre-Clearance 1 8,559 9,692 10,700 10,788 2,718 2,822 2,562 2,686 6,274 2,094 2,148 2,032

San Diego, CA 26,889 25,698 32,577 40,403 10,856 10,004 9,133 10,410 33,181 11,163 9,732 12,286 San Francisco, CA 9,832 14,949 14,062 15,858 3,375 4,298 3,375 4,810 11,624 3,535 4,555 3,534 San Juan, PR 1,984 2,071 1,368 1,673 360 513 408 392 1,688 464 427 797 Seattle, WA 10,529 9,316 9,140 8,036 1,908 1,561 2,040 2,527 5,148 1,713 1,606 1,829 Tampa, FL 2,941 3,173 3,919 3,847 1,003 939 945 960 2,636 951 903 782

Tucson, AZ 7,612 9,991 8,910 9,349 2,063 2,233 2,381 2,672 7,889 3,143 2,239 2,507 Unknown 134 281 423 402 100 79 108 115 269 144 64 61 Note: Data include all aliens seeking admission at a port of entry determined inadmissible, including those turned away at a port of entry or conditionally permitted to enter the United States.

1 Refers to field offices abroad. Source: DHS, CBP OFO, EID, July 2016. See Appendix Table B6 for quarterly totals.

11

C. Unique Individuals Apprehended by CBP BP (Figure 5)

With the Automated Biometric Identification System (IDENT), fingerprint records can be matched, making it possible to count both the unique number of individuals apprehended and the total number of apprehensions (see Figure 5). Because of data collection procedures, data are tabulated at the end of the fiscal year.

Figure 5. Apprehensions from IDENT by CBP BP: FYs 2009 to 2015

2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Apprehensions (Age

D. Notices to Appear Issued (Figures 6–9) and USCIS Fraud Cases Referred to ICE (Figure 10)

NTAs order aliens to appear at a civil immigration removal proceeding before an immigration judge with the Department of Justice’s Executive Office for Immigration Review. This section includes NTAs issued by USCIS, CBP BP, CBP OFO, and ICE ERO, as well as the number of applications referred to ICE for investigation under suspicion of fraud by USCIS.

Figure 6. NTAs Issued by USCIS: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: Data refer to I-862 NTAs only. See USCIS Policy Memorandum dated November 7, 2011, titled “Revised Guidance for the Referral of Cases and Issuance of Notices to Appear (NTAs) in Cases Involving Inadmissible and Removable Aliens.” Source: DHS, USCIS, Performance Analysis System, Performance Reporting Tool, and Refugee, Asylum, and Parole System, July 2016. See Appendix Table D1 for quarterly totals.

13

Figure 7. NTAs Issued by CBP BP: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Source: DHS, CBP BP, EID, July 2016. See Appendix Table D2 for quarterly totals.

Figure 8. NTAs Issued by CBP OFO: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Source: DHS, CBP OFO, EID, July 2016. See Appendix Table D3 for quarterly totals.

14

Figure 9. NTAs Issued by ICE ERO: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: FY 2013 data include NTAs issued by both ICE ERO and ICE HSI. Data in this report do not

include NTAs reissued to an alien on the same date.

Source: DHS, ICE ERO, IIDS, January 2016. See Appendix Table D4 for quarterly totals.

15

Figure 10. USCIS Fraud Cases Referred to ICE for Criminal Investigation: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: Data shown represent the number of benefit applications filed with USCIS that subsequently were referred to ICE under suspicion of criminal fraud activity by USCIS’s Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate. Source: DHS, USCIS Fraud Detection and National Security Data System, July 2016. See Appendix Table D5 for quarterly totals.

16

E. Criminal Arrests (Figures 11–13)

Criminal arrests refer to individuals (both aliens and U.S. citizens) who are arrested for violation of a federal and/or a state criminal law. Criminal arrests may be for felony or misdemeanor charges. Criminal arrest data are provided for ICE HSI, ICE ERO, and CBP OFO.

Figure 11. ICE HSI Criminal Arrests: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Source: DHS, ICE HSI, Seized Assets and Case Tracking System (SEACATS), July 2016. See Appendix Table E1 for quarterly totals.

17

Figure 12. ICE ERO Criminal Arrests: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Source: DHS, ICE ERO, SEACATS July 2016. See Appendix Table E2 for quarterly totals.

Figure 13. CBP OFO Criminal Arrests: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: Criminal arrests at the ports of entry may be for narcotics violations and seizures (e.g., unlawful possession and/or smuggling of narcotics), immigration-related prosecutable violations (e.g., reentry after removal, alien smuggling), and any other crime involving prohibited items or commodities. Source: DHS, CBP OFO, SEACATS, July 2016. See Appendix Table E3 for quarterly totals.

18

F. Legal Entries (Figure 14 and Table 5)

Legal entries refer to the number of entries of U.S. citizens and noncitizens into the United States lawfully. Individual U.S. citizens and noncitizens may be counted more than once during a reporting period. Individuals denied entry at air, land, or sea ports are excluded from these data.

Figure 14. Legal Entries of Citizens and Noncitizens: FYs 2013 to 2016 Q3

Note: Numbers are rounded to millions. Source: DHS, CBP OFO, Operations Management Reporting (OMR), July 2016. See Appendix Table F1

for quarterly totals.

19

Table 5. Legal Entries to the United States by Citizens and Noncitizens by CBP OFO Field Office: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Field office 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

Total Total Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Total Q1 Q2 Q3 Total 351.1 361.5 374.2 382.6 93.1 89.2 96.0 104.3 282.3 94.0 92.0 96.4

Atlanta, GA 6.3 6.5 8.3 6.7 1.5 1.6 1.9 1.8 5.2 1.5 1.7 1.9 Baltimore, MD 5.7 5.9 7.1 6.0 1.3 1.2 1.6 1.9 3.9 1.3 1.2 1.4 Boston, MA 10.6 10.6 11.3 11.0 2.3 1.7 2.4 4.6 6.1 2.1 1.7 2.3 Buffalo, NY 23.2 22.6 23.8 18.5 4.8 3.5 5.0 5.2 12.3 4.3 3.4 4.6 Chicago, IL 5.9 6.3 8.2 7.8 1.4 1.7 1.8 2.9 5.1 1.5 1.8 1.9 Detroit, MI 17.8 17.9 21.0 17.2 4.3 3.6 4.1 5.3 11.2 3.9 3.5 3.9 El Paso, TX 26.6 27.9 37.7 31.0 8.1 7.7 8.0 7.3 24.9 8.5 8.1 8.3 Houston, TX 8.6 8.9 11.6 12.9 2.3 2.6 2.7 5.3 8.3 2.7 2.8 2.8 Laredo, TX 50.6 53.1 67.8 53.3 14.4 13.4 14.0 11.6 43.8 14.9 14.5 14.3 Los Angeles, CA 10.2 10.3 13.8 12.6 2.8 2.8 3.1 3.9 9.5 3.1 3.1 3.4 Miami, FL 16.6 17.1 23.5 17.3 4.7 5.4 4.4 2.9 15.0 5.0 5.5 4.5 New Orleans, LA 1.0 1.0 1.3 3.8 0.2 0.3 0.2 3.0 0.7 0.2 0.3 0.3 New York, NY 19.5 20.1 24.4 18.9 4.7 4.5 5.5 4.2 15.6 5.0 4.8 5.7 Portland, OR 1.8 2.0 2.2 4.0 0.3 0.3 0.7 2.7 1.4 0.3 0.3 0.7 Pre-Clearance 1 15.4 16.0 20.5 24.1 4.2 4.3 4.6 10.9 13.5 4.4 4.4 4.7 San Diego, CA 64.1 65.5 84.9 66.1 18.7 18.1 18.5 11.0 55.8 19.1 18.3 18.4 San Francisco, CA 9.4 10.0 12.6 10.7 2.5 2.6 2.8 2.8 8.6 2.7 2.8 3.0 San Juan, PR 4.8 4.7 6.7 6.7 1.3 1.6 1.2 2.7 3.2 1.0 1.5 0.8 Seattle, WA 25.5 26.4 30.0 22.0 5.7 4.8 6.1 5.3 14.7 4.8 4.3 5.6 Tampa, FL 5.3 5.2 6.8 7.4 1.4 1.4 1.4 3.2 4.5 1.4 1.6 1.5 Tucson, AZ 22.1 23.5 30.0 24.7 6.3 6.2 6.2 6.0 19.0 6.5 6.3 6.2 1 Refers to field offices abroad. Note: Numbers are rounded to millions. Source: DHS, CBP OFO, OMR, July 2016. See Appendix Table F2 for quarterly totals.

20

G. Detention (Figures 15–17 and Tables 6–8)

Removable aliens who are apprehended by CBP and ICE and are determined to warrant custodial supervision are placed in detention facilities that are managed by ICE ERO. Aliens detained by ICE are housed in local or state government facilities under Intergovernmental Service Agreements (IGSA), contract detention facilities, ICE-owned facilities (Service Processing Centers), and Bureau of Prisons facilities.

Figure 15. Initial Admissions to ICE Detention Facilities: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: Initial admissions refer to the number of individuals whose initial placement into a detention facility began within the reporting period. These totals may include aliens currently in ICE detention. Beginning in 2010, data exclude detainees held in facilities dedicated to housing aliens in the Mexican Interior Repatriation Program (MIRP), the Department of Health and Human Services Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR), and the U.S.

Marshals Service. Source: DHS, ICE, IIDS, July 2016. See Appendix Table G1 for quarterly totals.

21

Figure 16. Average Daily Population (ADP) of Aliens in ICE Detention: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: Beginning in 2010, data exclude detainees held in facilities dedicated to housing aliens in the MIRP, the Department of Health and Human Services ORR, and the U.S. Marshals Service. Source: DHS, ICE, IIDS, July 2016. See Appendix Table G1 for quarterly totals.

22

Table 6 lists the ADP of aliens detained in IGSAs facilities by state from FY 2016 Q3.

Table 6. ADP of Aliens Detained in IGSA Facilities by State: FY 2016 Q3

State/Territory

Short-term

Facilities

Longterm

Facilities Total IGSAs

Alabama Alaska Arizona Arkansas California Colorado Connecticut Delaware District of Columbia Florida Georgia Guam Hawaii Idaho Illinois Indiana Iowa Kansas Kentucky Louisiana Maine Maryland Massachusetts Michigan Minnesota Mississippi

1 -1 3 0 0 ---1 4 --0 2 1 --2 3 0 --2 0 -

318 0

2,333 -

4,042 17

---

415 1,619

5 -9

385 51

102 48

142 1,890

1 281 495 274 239

-

319 0

2,334 3

4,042 18

---

415 1,623

5 -9

387 52

102 48

145 1,893

1 281 495 277 239

-

State/Territory

Short-term

Facilities

Longterm

Facilities Total IGSAs

Missouri Montana Nebraska Nevada New Hampshire New Jersey New Mexico New York North Carolina North Dakota Ohio Oklahoma Oregon Pennsylvania Puerto Rico Rhode Island South Carolina South Dakota Tennessee Texas Utah Vermont Virginia Washington West Virginia Wisconsin Wyoming

0 0 0 --0 0 -6 --1 0 1 --2 --

83 0 -4

11 0 -1

109 2

106 400 83

1,357 803 234

-3

193 153 11

983 --

36 0 7

5,896 190

0 629

-7

390 0

109 2

106 400 83

1,357 803 234

6 3

193 154 11

985 --

38 0 7

5,979 190

0 633 11 7

390 1

Zero represents ADP of less than 1 day. - represents a value of N/A. Note: IGSA data include dedicated and nondedicated IGSA facilities that were inspected by ICE. Short-term

facilities accommodate stays of less than 72 hours. Long-term facilities accommodate stays of 72 hours or more. Source: DHS, ICE, IIDS, July 2016. See Appendix Table G3 for FYs 2009–2014 totals. Detail may not sum to

total because of rounding.

23

Tables 7 and 8 list the ADP of aliens detained in each ICE Service Processing Center and contract detention facility during FY 2016.

Table 7. ADP of Aliens Detained in Service Processing Centers: FY 2016 Q3

2016 Service Processing Average Daily Batavia, NY 518 El Paso, TX 812 Florence, AZ 527 Miami, FL 549 Port Isabel, TX 1,093 Source: DHS, ICE, IIDS, July 2016.

Table 8. ADP of Aliens Detained in Contract Facilities: FY 2016 Q3

2016 Contract Facilities Average Broward Transitional Denver, CO Elizabeth, NJ Houston, TX Pearsall, TX San Diego, CA Tacoma, WA

601 471 294 900

1,713 812

1,382 Source: DHS, ICE, IIDS, July 2016.

24

Figure 17. Average Length of Stay (in days) for Aliens Released from Detention: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: Initial admissions refer to the number of individuals whose initial placement into a detention facility began within the reporting period. These totals may include aliens currently in ICE detention. Beginning in 2010, data exclude detainees held in facilities dedicated to housing aliens in the MIRP, the Department of Health and Human Services ORR, and the U.S. Marshals Service. Source: DHS, ICE, Enforcement Case Tracking System (ENFORCE) Alien Detention Module, July 2016.

25

H. Removals and Returns (Figure 18)

Alien removals refer to inadmissible or deportable aliens who have been removed on the basis of an order of removal, whereas alien returns refer to inadmissible or deportable aliens who have been confirmed to have departed the United States without an order of removal. This report includes fiscal year removals effectuated and returns conducted by both CBP and ICE. An alien who is removed has administrative or criminal consequences placed on subsequent reentry owing to the fact of the removal.

Figure 18. DHS Removals and Returns: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: Removals and returns include data from both ICE and CBP. Removals and returns in this report refer to the year that the events occurred. Differences in prior time periods are due to the updating of the data series. Source: DHS, ICE, ENFORCE Alien Removal Module, ICE EID, July 2016. See Appendix Table H1 for quarterly totals.

26

I. Worksite Enforcement and E-Verify (Figures 19–24)

Worksite arrest statistics are shown for employers who are charged by ICE HSI with violations related to the employment of unauthorized aliens, and employees who are charged with a variety of crimes including identity theft, fraud, tax violations, or other related crimes. Worksite fines are reflected in Figures 19 and 20 below.

The number of employers registered for E-Verify and the number of queries each year also are provided below. For the purposes of the E-Verify program, each query represents one new hire.

Figure 19. Worksite Enforcement—Criminal Fines: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: Numbers are displayed in millions (U.S. dollars). The FY 2016 Q2 and Q3 value is 0. Source: DHS, ICE, Significant Incident Notification System (SENS), July 2016. See Appendix Table I1 for quarterly totals.

27

Figure 20. Worksite Enforcement—Civil Fines: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: Numbers are displayed in millions (U.S. dollars). Source: DHS, ICE, SENS, July 2016. See Appendix Table I2 for quarterly totals.

28

Figure 21. ICE Worksite Criminal Arrests—Owners/Employers: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: Data are not cumulative and represent the number of arrests made in a given fiscal year. Source: DHS, ICE, Treasury Enforcement Communication System (TECS), July 2016. See Appendix Table

I3 for quarterly totals.

29

Figure 22. ICE Worksite Administrative Arrests—Employees/Other: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: Data are not cumulative and represent the number of arrests made in a given fiscal year. Source: DHS, ICE, TECS, July 2016. See Appendix Table I4 for quarterly totals.

30

Figure 23. Employers Newly Registered in E-Verify: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: Data are not cumulative and represent the number of newly registered employers in a given fiscal year or period. Source: DHS, USCIS, Verification Information System (VIS), July 2016. See Appendix Table I5 for quarterly totals.

31

Figure 24. E-Verify Employer Queries: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q2

Note: Query counting method eliminates duplicates and queries closed in error. Numbers trail one quarter. Source: DHS, USCIS, VIS, July 2016. See Appendix Table I6 for quarterly totals.

32

J. Seizures—Drugs, Weapons, and Currency (Tables 9–11)

This section provides data on drug, weapon, and currency seizures by CBP BP, CBP OFO, and ICE HSI for FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3.

Table 9. Drug, Weapon, and Currency Seizures by CBP BP: FYs 2014 to 2016 Q3

Fiscal Year/Quarter 2014 2015 2016

Total Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 YTD Q1 Q2 Q3 Cocaine 2,065.89 5,089.49 442.66 3,122.29 642.54 882.01 1,927.98 663.51 761.23 503.24 Heroin 274.73 234.80 66.68 58.69 50.95 58.48 180.33 74.57 53.04 52.72 Marijuana 872,060.80 697,771.59 187,059.40 194,354.79 157,704.51 158,652.89 493,947.55 192,416.65 167,039.23 134,491.67 Methamphetamine 1,782.61 2,922.59 522.47 664.47 542.06 1,193.59 2,608.27 862.26 883.62 862.39 Currency $7.99 $4.74 $0.90 $0.79 $1.41 $1.65 $2.62 $0.97 $0.97 $0.68 Weapons 517 375 126 100 72 77 318 133 81 104

Note: Drug data are measured in kilograms (kg). Currency is measured in U.S. dollars and displayed in millions.

Weapons refer to firearms. Source: DHS, CBP BP, EID, July 2016. See Appendix Table J1 for quarterly totals.

Table 10. Drug, Weapon, and Currency Seizures by CBP OFO: FYs 2014 to 2016 Q3

Fiscal Year/Quarter 2014 2015 2016

Total Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 YTD Q1 Q2 Q3 Cocaine 18,721.08 17,346.80 3,413.56 5,487.53 3,597.64 4,848.07 19,155.10 8,657.95 3,816.62 6,680.53 Heroin 1,956.24 2,499.08 452.12 657.06 696.56 693.34 1,392.37 449.77 440.92 501.68 Marijuana 198,647.92 273,385.53 55,409.03 81,892.69 69,005.21 67,078.60 193,474.79 56,207.12 78,798.41 58,469.26 Methamphetamine 8,744.43 11,603.39 3,147.89 3,072.59 2,846.52 2,536.39 11,942.49 3,594.20 3,789.33 4,558.96 Currency $81.49 $76.06 $20.38 $17.71 $21.99 $15.99 $46.36 $13.67 $16.08 $16.62 Weapons 6,458 1,268 99 484 159 526 709 373 112 224

Note: Drug data are measured in kg. Currency is measured in U.S. dollars and displayed in millions. Weapons refer to firearms. Source: DHS, CBP OFO, BorderStat, July 2016. See Appendix Table J2 for quarterly totals.

Table 11. Drug, Weapon, and Currency Seizures by ICE HSI: FYs 2014 to 2016 Q3

Fiscal Year/Quarter 2014 2015 2016

Total Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 YTD Q1 Q2 Q3 Cocaine 83,711.59 103,227.64 28,538.17 17,008.18 24,591.50 33,089.78 72,597.95 28,570.75 21,878.54 22,148.65 Heroin 3,831.34 3,027.28 647.91 678.82 899.67 800.87 1,820.23 619.59 565.30 635.34 Marijuana 902,852.52 406,414.21 82,694.36 123,726.81 127,539.97 72,453.07 251,759.93 90,569.63 98,342.80 62,847.49 Methamphetamine 12,949.80 13,617.68 3,953.54 3,685.32 3,019.56 2,959.26 12,517.25 3,850.77 3,906.49 4,759.99 Currency $722.08 $437.99 $106.82 $143.43 $93.86 $93.88 $301.99 $75.04 $130.06 $96.88 Weapons 19,895 13,994 2,187 3,149 2,815 5,843 446,692 54,796 194,050 197,846

Note: Drug data are measured in kg. Currency is measured in U.S. dollars and displayed in millions. Weapons refer to firearms, ammunition, and explosives. Source: DHS, ICE HSI, SEACATS, July 2016.

33

K. U.S. Customs and Border Protection Staffing (Figure 25 and Tables 12–15)

Tables 12 and 13 show the number of CBP agents and officers on board by sector/field office at the end of each reporting period, while Figure 25 shows the servicewide totals for FYs 2012 through 2016 Q3.

Figure 25. CBP BP Agents and CBP Officers: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Note: BP agent staffing refers to all GS-1896 Series BP agents, and GS-1801 BP agent re-employed annuitants. Officer staffing refers to all GS-1895 CBP officers. Source: DHS, CBP BP, Human Resources Management Consolidated Personnel Reporting Online, June 2013, and DHS, CBP OFO, Human Resources Management Consolidated Personnel Reporting Online, July 2016.

34

Table 12. CBP BP Agents by Sector: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Border Patrol sector 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Total Nationwide 21,394 21,391 20,824 20,702 20,492 20,403 20,183 20,162 20,003 19,951

Total Sectors 20,946 20,979 20,421 20,286 20,062 19,959 19,675 19,858 19,703 19,646 Big Bend, TX 1 693 623 585 566 554 555 546 557 547 531 Blaine, WA 323 315 313 310 304 296 296 298 298 298 Buffalo, NY 311 297 288 290 288 287 280 283 285 284 Del Rio, TX 1,655 1,598 1,534 1,541 1,530 1,566 1,537 1,526 1,495 1,479 Detroit, MI 413 410 405 403 405 411 412 416 413 413 El Centro, CA 1,168 1,141 1,071 1,066 1,051 1,028 997 980 975 950 El Paso, TX 2,718 2,631 2,516 2,482 2,454 2,406 2,343 2,287 2,253 2,235 Grand Forks, ND 199 189 186 188 182 182 173 169 176 179 Havre, MT 208 192 163 166 161 162 168 172 171 173 Houlton, ME 200 202 192 193 198 196 192 190 188 189 Laredo, TX 1,879 1,803 1,783 1,771 1,748 1,691 1,653 1,662 1,641 1,674 Miami, FL 92 92 95 93 90 90 105 103 100 104 New Orleans, LA 72 62 62 64 63 64 66 67 62 66 Ramey, PR 60 59 60 60 59 59 42 45 43 38 Rio Grande Valley, TX 2,546 3,086 3,059 3,028 2,983 3,007 3,042 3,095 3,103 3,094 San Diego, CA 2,623 2,572 2,540 2,516 2,488 2,463 2,420 2,406 2,385 2,368 Spokane, WA 246 247 244 240 238 235 229 226 227 232 Swanton, VT 306 304 299 292 284 291 294 291 288 295 Tucson, AZ 4,176 4,135 4,042 4,041 4,034 4,038 3,962 3,955 3,924 3,892 Yuma, AZ 954 911 855 844 822 809 802 787 779 805 Special Ops Group 2 104 110 129 132 126 123 116 115 123 118 OBP Headquarters 219 212 215 204 214 219 232 228 227 229

Other CBP Offices 3 229 200 188 212 216 225 276 304 300 305 Note: Staffing refers to all GS-1896 Series BP agents, and GS-1801 BP agent re-employed annuitants. 1 Known as Marfa, Texas, before 2012. 2 Special Operations Group was included as part of Office of Border Patrol (OBP) Headquarters totals until FY 2010

Q4.

3 Includes Office of Training and Development, Office of the Commissioner, Office of International Affairs, and Office of Intelligence and Investigative Liaison. Source: DHS, CBP, Human Resources Management Consolidated Personnel Reporting Online, July 2016. See Appendix Table K1 for quarterly totals.

35

Table 13. CBP OFO Officers by Field Office: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Field office 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016

Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Total Nationwide 21,790 21,843 22,060 22,409 22,547 22,816 22,947 23,006 22,943 22,941

Total Field Offices (subtotal) 21,091 21,088 21,245 21,570 21,678 21,948 22,022 22,069 22,013 22,002 Atlanta, GA 753 754 765 772 765 765 763 762 759 744 Baltimore, MD 556 547 560 592 617 616 612 615 605 597 Boston, MA 856 833 843 850 856 866 866 867 850 856 Buffalo, NY 1,133 1,092 1,113 1,144 1,150 1,181 1,182 1,178 1,172 1,163 Chicago, IL 646 669 688 731 754 763 759 770 778 772 Detroit, MI 1,097 1,091 1,090 1,095 1,096 1,133 1,144 1,165 1,155 1,154 El Paso, TX 1,264 1,279 1,265 1,275 1,273 1,282 1,282 1,277 1,273 1,274 Houston, TX 814 790 820 897 909 902 904 912 903 891 Laredo, TX 2,263 2,316 2,303 2,287 2,274 2,278 2,276 2,279 2,278 2,280 Los Angeles, CA 1,361 1,345 1,382 1,458 1,474 1,471 1,461 1,450 1,431 1,428 Miami, FL 1,614 1,619 1,643 1,659 1,651 1,712 1,707 1,714 1,705 1,693 New Orleans, LA 227 229 236 238 233 228 236 235 232 233 New York, NY 1,835 1,900 1,925 1,998 2,052 2,150 2,195 2,218 2,249 2,245 Portland, OR 178 173 169 164 165 166 165 175 173 176 Pre-Clearance 1 473 498 534 562 569 569 565 541 554 589 San Diego, CA 1,981 1,987 1,989 1,929 1,904 1,892 1,896 1,905 1,906 1,928 San Francisco, CA 856 838 833 838 877 895 912 911 913 918 San Juan, PR 412 410 409 408 406 419 418 422 417 414 Seattle, WA 1,426 1,377 1,369 1,378 1,376 1,381 1,394 1,396 1,396 1,390 Tampa, FL 401 395 394 407 411 421 425 423 418 417 Tucson, AZ 945 946 919 888 866 858 860 854 846 840

Headquarters 488 562 615 329 320 324 332 331 328 327 National Targeting Center2 N/A N/A N/A 304 306 307 383 397 391 404 Other CBP Offices 211 193 200 206 243 237 210 209 211 208

1 Refers to field offices abroad. 2 OFO Headquarters includes Cargo & Conveyance Security. The National Target Center now is reported separately from OFO Headquarters. Note: Staffing refers to all GS-1895 CBP officers. Source: DHS, CBP, Human Resources Management Consolidated Personnel Reporting Online, July 2016. See

Appendix Table K2 for quarterly totals.

36

Table 14. ICE ERO Agents by Area of Responsibility: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

This information is For Official Use Only (FOUO)/Law Enforcement Sensitive (LES) and will be transmitted to the Committees in a manner pursuant to limitations placed upon sharing of FOUO/LES information.

37

Table 15. ICE HSI Agents by Special Agent in Charge Jurisdiction: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

This information is FOUO/LES and will be transmitted to the Committees in a manner pursuant to limitations placed upon sharing of FOUO/LES information.

38

K. Violence against CBP and ICE HSI Agents and Officers (Tables 16–18)

Tables 16 and 17 show the number of assaults and incidences of violence against CBP and ICE HSI agents and officers.

Table 16. Violence against CBP BP Agents: FYs 2012 to 2016 Q3

Fiscal Year/Quarter Total Nationwide 2011 Q1 171 2011 Q2 195 2011 Q3 170 2011 Q4 139

2011 Total 675 2012 Q1 186 2012 Q2 127 2012 Q3 134 2012 Q4 108

2012 Total 555 2013 Q1 92 2013 Q2 118 2013 Q3 124 2013 Q4 134

2013 Total 468 2014 Q1 79 2014 Q2 116 2014 Q3 104 2014 Q4 74

2014 Total 373 2015 Q1 109 2015 Q2 109 2015 Q3 63 2015 Q4 97

2015 Total 378 2016 Q1 81 2016 Q2 110 2016 Q3 126

2016 Total 317 Source: DHS, CBP BP, EID, July 2016. See Appendix Table L1 for quarterly totals.

39

Table 17. Violence against CBP OFO Officers: FYs 2011 to 2016 Q3

Fiscal Year/Quarter Total Nationwide 2011 Q1 21 2011 Q2 27 2011 Q3 24 2011 Q4 44

2011 Total 116 2012 Q1 39 2012 Q2 42 2012 Q3 57 2012 Q4 51

2012 Total 189 2013 Q1 50 2013 Q2 52 2013 Q3 64 2013 Q4 39

2013 Total 205 2014 Q1 29 2014 Q2 30 2014 Q3 26 2014 Q4 31

2014 Total 116 2015 Q1 7 2015 Q2 20 2015 Q3 27 2015 Q4 31

2015 Total 85 2016 Q1 21 2016 Q2 25 2016 Q3 18

2016 Total 46 Source: DHS, CBP OFO, BorderStat, July 2016. See Appendix Table L2 for quarterly totals.

40

Table 18. Violence against ICE HSI Agents: FYs 2011 to 2016 Q3

Fiscal Year/Quarter Total Nationwide 2011 Q1 1 2011 Q2 10 2011 Q3 5 2011 Q4 5

2011 Total 21 2012 Q1 7 2012 Q2 5 2012 Q3 2 2012 Q4 7

2012 Total 21 2013 Q1 3 2013 Q2 3 2013 Q3 5 2013 Q4 7

2013 Total 18 2014 Q1 2 2014 Q2 6 2014 Q3 8 2014 Q3 3

2014 Total 19 2015 Q1 4 2015 Q2 2 2015 Q3 7 2015 Q4 3

2015 Total 16 2016 Q1 4 2016 Q2 0 2016 Q3 1

2016 Total 5 Source: DHS, ICE HSI, SEACATS, July 2016.

41

L. Stonegarden Grants (Table 19)

Operation Stonegarden funds are provided to enhance cooperation and coordination among local, tribal, territorial, state, and federal law enforcement agencies in a joint mission to secure the U.S. borders. The states and territories eligible for the program may border Canada, Mexico, or international waters. The totals in the chart below reflect the amount appropriated to the Department from Congress and how it was distributed.

Table 19. Stonegarden Grant Program: FYs 2010 to 2016

State/Territory 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Total Alabama Arizona California Florida Idaho Louisiana Maine Michigan Minnesota Mississippi Montana New Hampshire New Mexico New York North Dakota Ohio Pennsylvania Puerto Rico Texas U.S. Virgin Islands Vermont Washington

$60,540,000 -

$13,883,735 $12,710,302

$870,000 $187,086

-$1,120,267 $1,388,838

$543,168 -

$1,455,356 -

$4,015,517 $3,314,591

$548,913 $332,100

-$330,000

$17,550,446 -

$324,204 $1,965,477

$54,890,000 -

$12,378,728 $10,326,313

$250,000 -

$319,102 $1,008,082

$794,084 $588,095

-$1,211,112

$95,000 $3,841,538 $2,647,647

$526,949 $657,593 $95,000

$218,063 $17,770,977

-$330,254

$1,831,463

$46,600,000 $48,043

$9,550,184 $7,826,241

$250,000 $48,763

$400,000 $882,833 $747,363 $538,440

-$794,432 $90,000

$3,139,233 $2,428,472

$499,407 $646,125 $92,500

$655,530 $15,688,632

-$315,106

$1,958,696

$55,000,000 $155,206

$12,005,449 $9,425,732

$954,977 $49,121 $96,538

$924,422 $766,193 $596,623

-$960,059 $182,333

$3,146,501 $1,707,382

$637,406 $754,422 $177,396 $835,259

$19,422,318 -

$491,358 $1,711,305

$55,000,000 $99,923

$12,415,661 $9,334,826

$872,116 $30,322

$269,274 $514,929 $401,105 $388,389 $50,115

$617,420 $99,333

$2,647,317 $1,284,299

$433,149 $423,268 $74,007

$809,572 $23,124,196

-$200,460 $910,319

$55,000,000 $150,000

$11,700,000 $9,300,000 $1,150,084

$31,700 $242,436 $860,557 $760,063 $516,672 $70,000

$935,028 $130,000

$3,000,000 $1,702,405

$621,673 $755,000 $115,000

$1,007,344 $20,000,000

$130,136 $301,994

$1,519,908

$55,000,000 $150,000

$11,800,000 $9,400,000 $1,315,000

$25,178 $345,000 $800,111 $739,236 $471,872 $180,000 $877,630 $123,760

$2,700,000 $1,664,686

$586,833 $700,763 $109,480

$1,180,000 $20,100,000

$130,000 $250,498

$1,349,953 - Represents zero. Source: Federal Emergency Management Agency, Grant Programs Directorate, August 2016.

42

IV. Appendices

Appendix A. Glossary

Administrative Arrest – The arrest of an alien who is charged with removability under the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA).

Average Daily Population – Average daily detention population for the months included in the reporting period.

Average Length of Stay in Detention – The mean length of stay in detention from the time of initial admission to the time of release for those aliens released during the reporting period. Aliens in detention at the end of the reporting period are excluded from the calculation.

Consequence Delivery System – A CBP-developed system that guides management and agents through a process that is designed to evaluate each subject apprehended by the Border Patrol and to identify the most appropriate consequence based on the individual’s crossing history. The Consequence Delivery System initially was implemented in the Tucson Sector in January 2011 and now is deployed across the Southwest Border.

E-Verify – An Internet-based system administered by USCIS in partnership with the Social Security Administration that allows employers to verify the employment eligibility of workers electronically.

Deportable Alien under INA 237 – An alien in and admitted to the United States subject to any grounds of deportability specified in section 237 of the INA, 8 U.S.C. § 1227. This includes any alien illegally in the United States, regardless of whether the alien entered the country by fraud or misrepresentation or entered legally but subsequently violated the terms of his or her nonimmigrant classification or status.

Inadmissible Alien – An alien seeking admission to the United States, or who is present without being inspected and admitted or paroled, who is subject to one or more grounds of inadmissibility described in section 212 of the INA, 8 U.S.C. § 1182.

Removals – The compulsory and confirmed movement of an inadmissible or deportable alien out of the United States based on an order of removal. Ineligibility to remain in the United States is based on grounds of inadmissibility under INA § 212 or deportability under INA § 237. An alien who is removed has administrative or criminal consequences with respect to subsequent reentry owing to the fact of the removal. This report includes removals effectuated by both ICE and CBP.

Returns – The confirmed movement of an inadmissible or deportable alien out of the United States not based on an order of removal. Ineligibility to remain in the United States is based on grounds of inadmissibility under INA § 212 or deportability under INA § 237. An alien waives

43

his or her right to a formal proceeding and chooses to depart the United States and return to his or her home country in lieu of removal proceedings. This report includes returns effectuated by both ICE and CBP.

Queries – For the purposes of the E-Verify program, each query represents one new hire.

Seizure – Taking physical possession and/or control of property, merchandise, or other articles from the possession or control of an individual or establishment.

Violence against CBP BP Agents – Any assault directed at a BP agent in the performance of or with a nexus to their official duties, including, but not limited to, rockings, shootings, vehicular assaults, other physical assaults, and any other threat of bodily harm or death, while engaged in or on account of border enforcement activities.

Violence against CBP OFO Officers – Physical threats or elevated use of force occurring in reaction to a legitimate or perceived threat to OFO personnel. Along with physical assaults, violent incidents involve vehicles being operated in a manner that posed a risk or harm or the use or intended use of a deadly weapon.

287(g) Program – A state and local cross-designation program authorized by INA § 287(g). This program provides specific officers of participating state and local law enforcement agencies with the necessary delegation of authority, training, and resources to perform certain functions of an immigration officer under the direction of ICE.

44

Appendix B. List of Abbreviations/Acronyms

ADP Average Daily Population BP Border Patrol BSSR Border Security Status Report CBP U.S. Customs and Border Protection DHS U.S. Department of Homeland Security EAGLE EID Arrest Guide for Law Enforcement EID Enforcement Integrated Database ENFORCE Enforcement Case Tracking System ERO ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations FOUO For Official Use Only FY Fiscal Year HSI ICE Homeland Security Investigations ICE U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement IDENT Automated Biometric Identification System IGSA Intergovernmental Service Agreement IIDS ICE Integrated Decision Support INA Immigration and Nationality Act kg kilogram LES Law Enforcement Sensitive MIRP Mexican Interior Repatriation Program NTA Notice to Appear OBP Office of Border Patrol OFO CBP Office of Field Operations OIS Office of Immigration Statistics OMR Operations Management Reporting ORR Office of Refugee Resettlement PAS Performance Analysis System Q1 First quarter of a Fiscal Year (October–December) Q2 Second quarter of a Fiscal Year (January–March) SBI Secure Border Initiative SEACATS Seized Assets and Case Tracking System SENS Significant Incident Notification System TECS Treasury Enforcement Communication System USCIS U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services VIS Verification Information System

45

Appendix C. Data Tables

Table B1. U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) Office of Border Patrol (OBP) Apprehensions by Sector: Fiscal Years (FY) 2002 to 2016 Q3

Big EL Grand Fiscal Year/Quarter

Total Apprehensions

Bend, TX 2

Blaine, WA

Buffalo, NY

Del Rio, TX

Detroit, MI

Centro, CA

EL Paso, TX

Forks, ND

Havre, MT

Houlton, ME Laredo, TX

2002 955,310 11,392 1,732 1,102 66,985 1,511 108,273 94,154 1,369 1,463 432 82,095 2003 931,557 10,319 1,380 564 50,145 2,345 92,099 88,816 1,223 1,406 292 70,521 2004 1,160,395 10,530 1,354 671 53,794 1,912 74,467 104,399 1,225 986 263 74,706 2005 1,189,031 10,536 1,000 406 68,504 1,793 55,790 122,691 754 948 233 75,330 2006 1,089,096 7,520 809 1,518 42,630 1,282 61,457 122,264 517 567 175 74,845 2007 876,803 5,537 749 2,190 22,919 902 55,882 75,464 500 486 95 56,716 2008 723,865 5,389 950 3,338 20,763 960 40,964 30,311 542 426 81 43,663 2009 556,032 6,357 844 2,672 17,082 1,157 33,520 14,998 472 283 60 40,571 2010 463,382 5,288 673 2,422 14,694 1,669 32,562 12,251 543 290 56 35,287 2011, Total 340,252 4,036 591 2,114 16,144 1,531 30,191 10,345 468 270 41 36,053

2011 Q1 71,437 947 147 560 2,584 430 5,786 2,014 113 85 8 6,257 2011 Q2 98,069 1,089 154 512 4,430 429 8,476 3,044 117 62 11 9,914 2011 Q3 97,487 1,158 134 508 5,001 331 9,745 3,100 93 61 12 10,264 2011 Q4 73,259 842 156 534 4,129 341 6,184 2,187 145 62 10 9,618

2012, Total 364,768 3,964 537 1,143 21,720 950 23,916 9,678 418 102 41 44,872 2012 Q1 70,099 889 155 261 3,524 293 5,045 1,843 120 48 5 7,534 2012 Q2 101,294 1,196 145 268 5,367 224 6,553 2,588 72 24 2 12,189 2012 Q3 110,124 997 110 256 7,394 260 7,534 2,551 95 19 10 13,597 2012 Q4 83,251 882 127 358 5,435 173 4,784 2,696 131 11 24 11,552

2013, Total 420,789 3,684 360 796 23,510 650 16,306 11,154 469 88 37 50,749 2013 Q1 81,390 807 104 220 4,642 187 4,036 2,466 71 6 16 10,201 2013 Q2 110,659 1,156 84 147 6,611 152 4,541 2,982 86 8 3 13,811 2013 Q3 127,898 1,046 84 205 6,805 134 4,707 3,237 127 21 9 14,988 2013 Q4 100,842 675 88 224 5,452 177 3,022 2,469 185 53 9 11,749

2014, Total 486,651 4,096 272 741 24,255 647 14,511 12,339 767 91 45 44,049 2014 Q1 98,326 817 56 149 4,533 152 3,257 2,468 140 30 9 9,231 2014 Q2 116,334 1,245 74 170 6,470 124 3,993 3,151 176 13 7 11,681 2014 Q3 172,031 1,191 82 199 8,905 175 3,997 3,836 199 26 16 13,800 2014 Q4 99,960 843 60 223 4,347 196 3,264 2,884 252 22 13 9,337

2015, Total 337,117 5,031 282 291 19,013 637 12,820 14,495 789 64 32 35,888 2015 Q1 77,713 870 113 97 3,282 252 2,716 2,749 237 11 11 8,183 2015 Q2 76,883 1,016 61 60 3,994 107 3,248 3,188 192 19 10 8,733 2015 Q3 91,854 1,378 50 49 6,111 152 3,602 4,261 153 10 3 9,582 2015 Q4 90,667 1,767 58 85 5,626 126 3,254 4,297 207 24 8 9,390

2016, Total 303,534 5,045 192 140 17,920 489 13,710 17,465 331 32 22 27,904 2016 Q1 104,180 2,062 68 26 5,856 150 3,707 5,503 105 10 7 9,390 2016 Q2 84,631 1,462 68 49 5,333 148 4,180 4,703 123 7 5 8,545 2016 Q3 114,723 1,521 56 65 6,731 191 5,823 7,259 103 15 10 9,969 2016 Q4

46

Table B1. CBP OBP Apprehensions by Sector: FYs 2002 to 2016 Q3 (continued)

Rio New Grande San

Fiscal Year/Quarter

Livermore, CA 1

Miami, FL

Orleans, LA

Ramey, Valley, PR TX

Diego, CA

Spokane, WA

Tucson, Swanton, VT AZ

Yuma, AZ

2002 4,371 5,143 4,665 835 89,927 100,681 1,142 1,736 333,648 42,654 2003 3,565 5,931 5,151 1,688 77,749 111,515 992 1,955 347,263 56,638 2004 1,850 4,602 2,889 1,813 92,947 138,608 847 2,701 491,771 98,060 2005 X 7,243 1,358 1,619 134,161 126,915 279 1,936 439,105 138,430 2006 X 6,033 3,053 1,435 110,520 142,110 184 1,544 392,101 118,532 2007 X 7,121 4,018 548 73,429 152,464 338 1,119 378,332 37,994 2008 X 6,021 4,303 572 75,484 162,390 341 1,282 317,724 8,361 2009 X 4,429 3,527 418 60,992 118,712 277 1,042 241,667 6,952 2010 X 4,651 3,171 398 59,766 68,565 356 1,422 212,202 7,116 2011, Total X 4,401 1,509 642 59,243 42,447 293 815 123,285 5,833

2011 Q1 X 1,191 496 139 10,602 11,057 80 189 27,616 1,136 2011 Q2 X 1,277 393 145 14,524 12,167 59 184 38,977 2,105 2011 Q3 X 958 344 170 17,864 10,614 67 156 35,489 1,418 2011 Q4 X 975 276 188 16,253 8,609 87 286 21,203 1,174

2012, Total X 2,509 474 702 97,762 28,461 317 702 120,000 6,500 2012 Q1 X 704 136 213 15,999 6,760 75 126 24,767 1,602 2012 Q2 X 585 106 169 21,845 7,688 63 125 39,604 2,481 2012 Q3 X 522 102 203 32,855 7,836 82 202 34,074 1,425 2012 Q4 X 698 130 117 27,063 6,177 97 249 21,555 992

2013, Total X 1,738 500 924 154,453 27,496 299 531 120,939 6,106 2013 Q1 X 512 170 125 23,808 5,641 86 85 26,890 1,317 2013 Q2 X 316 108 340 34,133 7,439 51 108 36,692 1,891 2013 Q3 X 362 89 137 50,252 8,011 74 152 35,527 1,931 2013 Q4 X 548 133 322 46,260 6,405 88 186 21,830 967

2014, Total X 2,034 950 958 256,393 29,911 269 506 87,915 5,902 2014 Q1 X 402 163 301 42,902 6,462 74 114 25,748 1,318 2014 Q2 X 519 248 197 54,461 8,395 71 68 23,316 1,955 2014 Q3 X 563 288 257 104,580 8,336 58 121 23,747 1,655 2014 Q4 X 550 251 203 54,450 6,718 66 203 15,104 974

2015, Total X 1,752 849 557 147,257 26,290 190 341 63,397 7,142 2015 Q1 X 283 313 163 34,532 6,337 49 74 16,174 1,267 2015 Q2 X 316 192 143 29,799 7,453 50 52 16,678 1,572 2015 Q3 X 414 185 108 40,455 6,673 36 65 16,729 1,838 2015 Q4 X 739 159 143 42,471 5,827 55 150 13,816 2,465

2016, Total X 2,344 513 512 131,402 23,420 144 178 51,714 10,057 2016 Q1 X 815 181 142 48,070 6,306 29 63 17,955 3,735 2016 Q2 X 700 143 159 32,380 8,140 21 49 15,973 2,443 2016 Q3 X 829 189 211 50,952 8,974 94 66 17,786 3,879 2016 Q4

X Not applicable. - Represents zero.

1 Livermore sector closed September 30, 2004. 2 Known as Marfa, Texas, before 2012. Source: U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS), CBP OBP, Performance Analysis System (PAS), Enforcement Integrated Database (EID), July 2016.

47

Table B2. CBP OBP Apprehensions of Mexican Nationals by Sector: FYs 2003 to 2016 Q3

Fiscal Year/Quarter 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011, Total

2011 Q1 2011 Q2 2011 Q3 2011 Q4

2012, Total 2012 Q1 2012 Q2 2012 Q3 2012 Q4

2013, Total 2013 Q1 2013 Q2 2013 Q3 2013 Q4

2014, Total 2014 Q1 2014 Q2 2014 Q3 2014 Q4

2015, Total 2015 Q1 2015 Q2 2015 Q3 2015 Q4

2016, Total 2016 Q1 2016 Q2 2016 Q3 2016 Q4

Big EL Grand Total Bend, Blaine, Buffalo, Del Rio, Detroit, Centro, EL Paso, Forks, Havre, Houlton, Laredo,

Apprehensions TX 2 WA NY TX MI CA TX ND MT ME TX 882,141

1,084,888 1,023,888

981,069 808,773 661,792 503,379 404,365 286,154 61,199 86,234 81,609 57,112

265,755 54,441 80,014 76,223 55,077

267,734 55,466 76,621 79,256 56,391

229,178 52,927 61,745 65,533 48,973

188,122 45,267 49,412 49,693 43,750

148,355 44,430 48,553 55,372

9,513 9,789 9,568 6,792 5,002 4,754 5,570 4,754 3,621

845 1,010 1,051

715 3,417

763 1,048

841 765

3,174 679

1,039 908 548

3,164 634

1,057 935 538

2,177 549 599 551 478

2,063 599 720 744

777 772 505 484 518 641 525 376 314 74 91 61 88

270 92 63 74 41

106 33 21 26 26 58 13 18 17 10 67 37 14 12 4

29 14 5

10

208 235 221 959

1,271 1,615 1,314 1,143

938 268 228 226 216 607 154 150 144 159 370 96 70

105 99

294 77 67 74 76

137 51 28 17 41 50 11 26 13

45,836 43,996 37,275 30,359 16,285 14,917 12,820 10,593 11,697 2,093 3,757 3,498 2,349

12,404 2,224 3,664 3,961 2,555

14,005 2,793 4,679 4,013 2,520

10,196 2,126 3,312 2,809 1,949

10,874 2,044 2,838 3,158 2,834

10,618 2,689 3,739 4,190

1,685 1,387 1,327

945 686 664 881

1,196 1,031

293 273 220 245 673 216 146 179 132 479 141 120 93

125 431 99 85

109 138 427 167 74 91 95

350 117 109 124

91,408 73,867 54,836 60,714 55,270 40,161 32,601 31,704 29,474 5,652 8,325 9,526 5,971

22,511 4,875 6,237 6,984 4,415

15,141 3,767 4,317 4,354 2,703

12,511 2,865 3,613 3,320 2,713

11,320 2,399 3,003 3,242 2,676

10,373 2,782 3,300 4,291

86,246 100,849 117,789 117,540 72,293 29,136 13,885 11,194 9,633 1,913 2,835 2,881 2,004 8,915 1,656 2,428 2,330 2,501

10,092 2,297 2,716 2,915 2,164 9,904 1,983 2,586 3,009 2,326

10,677 2,247 2,687 2,987 2,756

10,091 2,741 3,247 4,103

1,007 966 580 382 337 361 311 388 294 72 76 53 93

306 90 57 60 99

337 52 68 84

133 532 92

124 136 180 563 162 133 117 151 227 67 91 69

1,180 51 62,777 813 87 62,228 807 76 54,543 510 58 59,145 409 17 44,833 378 12 34,402 208 10 31,834 184 6 27,957 167 5 29,131 54 1 5,142 32 2 8,851 39 - 8,111 42 2 7,027 54 8 31,742 28 - 5,463 8 - 9,666

11 5 9,423 7 3 7,190

62 1 32,772 2 1 6,707 5 - 9,827

16 - 9,250 39 - 6,988 51 5 26,540 18 1 5,207 6 3 7,546

16 - 7,891 11 1 5,896 46 1 25,766 7 . 6,073

13 . 6,730 6 . 6,757

20 1 6,206 11 7 19,693 5 4 6,276 2 . 6,436 4 3 6,981

48

Table B2. CBP OBP Apprehensions of Mexican Nationals by Sector: FYs 2003 to 2016 Q3 (continued)

Rio New Grande San

Fiscal Livermore, Miami, Orleans, Ramey, Valley, Diego, Spokane, Swanton, Tucson, Yuma, Year/Quarter CA 1 FL LA PR TX CA WA VT AZ AZ 2003 2,061 2,431 4,357 - 63,179 109,995 877 251 342,339 55,963 2004 854 1,873 2,339 3 66,644 136,905 772 457 483,419 96,633 2005 X 2,324 983 1 54,333 124,956 173 391 426,440 136,760 2006 X 1,614 1,840 2 58,279 140,830 107 340 382,637 117,532 2007 X 1,612 2,631 - 51,973 151,142 287 284 366,540 37,383 2008 X 1,566 2,922 - 55,410 160,814 297 271 305,455 8,016 2009 X 1,858 2,269 2 45,052 117,219 260 168 230,045 6,547 2010 X 1,837 1,941 2 40,732 67,259 316 157 195,921 6,705 2011, Total X 1,529 897 3 38,353 41,281 234 162 111,974 5,416

2011 Q1 X 426 319 1 6,999 10,803 59 32 25,086 1,067 2011 Q2 X 445 239 - 10,087 11,898 48 39 36,015 1,983 2011 Q3 X 354 187 1 11,454 10,306 53 38 32,269 1,281 2011 Q4 X 304 152 1 9,813 8,274 74 53 18,604 1,085

2012, Total X 831 277 - 47,823 27,307 266 122 102,303 5,919 2012 Q1 X 274 81 - 8,896 6,500 64 24 21,552 1,489 2012 Q2 X 205 73 - 11,750 7,411 60 29 34,746 2,273 2012 Q3 X 182 68 - 15,175 7,527 65 38 27,864 1,292 2012 Q4 X 170 55 - 12,002 5,869 77 31 18,141 865

2013, Total X 388 262 3 57,624 26,223 237 80 101,092 5,286 2013 Q1 X 142 95 2 10,132 5,438 63 14 21,816 1,196 2013 Q2 X 91 63 1 13,758 7,181 43 9 30,905 1,708 2013 Q3 X 71 42 - 18,161 7,658 57 27 29,887 1,589 2013 Q4 X 84 62 - 15,573 5,946 74 30 18,484 793

2014, Total X 277 465 - 63,468 27,871 219 75 68,870 4,247 2014 Q1 X 78 86 - 11,863 6,012 62 19 20,586 1,106 2014 Q2 X 88 109 - 14,810 8,033 59 28 18,764 1,437 2014 Q3 X 47 133 - 20,653 7,697 46 12 17,550 1,079 2014 Q4 X 64 137 - 16,142 6,129 52 16 11,970 625

2015, Total X 273 394 1 48,173 24,269 153 43 48,916 3,845 2015 Q1 X 31 133 . 11,555 5,932 40 20 12,870 950 2015 Q2 X 45 99 . 11,428 7,042 46 6 13,536 1,091 2015 Q3 X 77 82 . 13,229 6,135 29 7 12,301 895 2015 Q4 X 120 80 1 11,961 5,160 38 10 10,209 909

2016, Total X 507 272 0 34,620 19,045 109 14 37,515 2,761 2016 Q1 X 170 78 . 10,233 5,185 24 7 12,530 898 2016 Q2 X 180 94 . 10,816 6,721 19 2 12,186 860 2016 Q3 X 157 100 . 13,571 7,139 66 5 12,799 1,003 2016 Q4

X Not applicable. - Represents zero.

1 Livermore sector closed September 30, 2004. 2 Known as Marfa, Texas, before 2012. Source: DHS, CBP OBP, PAS, EID, July 2016.

49

Table B3. CBP OBP Apprehensions of Non-Mexican Nationals by Sector: FYs 2003 to 2016 Q3

Fiscal Year/Quarter 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011, Total

2011 Q1 2011 Q2 2011 Q3 2011 Q4

2012, Total 2012 Q1 2012 Q2 2012 Q3 2012 Q4

2013, Total 2013 Q1 2013 Q2 2013 Q3 2013 Q4

2014, Total 2014 Q1 2014 Q2 2014 Q3 2014 Q4

2015 Total 2015 Q1 2015 Q2 2015 Q3 2015 Q4

2016 Total 2016 Q1 2016 Q2 2016 Q3 2016 Q4

Big EL Grand Total Bend, Blaine, Buffalo, Del Rio, Detroit, Centro, EL Paso, Forks, Havre, Houlton, Laredo,

Apprehensions TX 2 WA NY TX MI CA TX ND MT ME TX 49,758 75,466

165,143 108,027 68,030 62,073 52,653 59,017 54,098 10,238 11,835 15,878 16,147 99,013 15,658 21,280 33,901 28,174

153,055 25,924 34,038 48,642 44,451

257,473 45,399 54,589

106,498 50,987

148,995 32,446 27,471 42,161 46,917

155,179 59,750 36,078 59,351

848 792 968 728 535 635 787 534 415 102 79

107 127 547 126 148 156 117 510 128 117 138 127 932 183 188 256 305

2,854 321 417 827

1,289 2,982 1,463

742 777

623 599 495 325 231 309 319 297 277 73 63 73 68

267 63 82 36 86

254 71 63 58 62

214 43 56 65 50

215 76 47 38 54

162 54 62 46

341 414 185 559 919

1,723 1,358 1,279 1,176

292 284 282 318 536 107 118 112 199 426 124 77

100 125 447 72

103 125 147 154 46 32 32 44 94 15 27 52

4,408 9,891

31,229 12,271 6,634 5,846 4,262 4,101 4,447

491 673

1,503 1,780 9,316 1,300 1,703 3,433 2,880 9,505 1,849 1,932 2,792 2,932

14,059 2,407 3,158 6,096 2,398 8,139 1,238 1,156 2,953 2,792 7,302 3,167 1,594 2,541

683 557 466 337 216 296 276 473 500 137 156 111 96

277 77 78 81 41

171 46 32 41 52

216 53 39 66 58

210 85 33 61 31

139 33 39 67

1,021 744 954 743 612 803 919 858 717 134 151 219 213

1,405 170 316 550 369

1,165 269 224 353 319

2,000 392 380 677 551

1,500 317 245 360 578

3,337 925 880

1,532

2,722 3,573 4,902 4,724 3,171 1,175 1,113 1,057

712 101 209 219 183 763 187 160 221 195

1,062 169 266 322 305

2,435 485 565 827 558

3,818 502 501

1,274 1,541 7,373 2,762 1,455 3,156

225 229 174 135 163 181 161 155 174 41 41 40 52

112 30 15 35 32

132 19 18 43 52

235 48 52 63 72

226 75 59 36 56

104 38 32 34

256 218 7,807 158 173 12,504 141 157 20,787 57 117 15,700 77 78 11,883 48 69 9,261 75 50 8,737

106 50 7,330 103 36 6,922 31 7 1,115 30 9 1,063 22 12 2,153 20 8 2,591 48 33 13,130 20 5 2,071 16 2 2,523 8 5 4,174 4 21 4,362

26 36 17,977 4 15 3,494 3 3 3,984 5 9 5,738

14 9 4,761 40 40 17,509 12 8 4,024 7 4 4,135

10 16 5,909 11 12 3,441 18 31 10,122 4 11 2,110 6 10 2,003 4 3 2,825 4 7 3,184

21 15 8,213 5 3 3,114 5 5 2,111

11 7 2,988

50

Table B3. CBP OBP Apprehensions of Non-Mexican Nationals by Sector: FYs 2003 to 2016 Q3 (continued)

Rio New Grande San

Fiscal Livermore, Miami, Orleans, Ramey, Valley, Diego, Spokane, Swanton, Tucson, Yuma, Year/Quarter CA 1 FL LA PR TX CA WA VT AZ AZ 2003 111 3,617 746 1,697 15,006 1,659 161 1,602 5,295 712 2004 72 2,573 566 1,813 26,432 1,770 152 2,243 8,792 1,419 2005 X 4,919 375 1,618 79,828 1,959 106 1,545 12,665 1,670 2006 X 4,419 1,213 1,433 52,241 1,280 77 1,204 9,464 1,000 2007 X 5,509 1,387 548 21,456 1,322 51 835 11,792 611 2008 X 4,455 1,381 572 20,074 1,576 44 1,011 12,269 345 2009 X 2,571 1,258 416 15,940 1,493 17 874 11,622 405 2010 X 2,814 1,230 396 19,034 1,306 40 1,265 16,281 411 2011, Total X 2,872 612 639 20,890 1,166 59 653 11,311 417

2011 Q1 X 765 177 138 3,603 254 21 157 2,530 69 2011 Q2 X 832 154 145 4,437 269 11 145 2,962 122 2011 Q3 X 604 157 169 6,410 308 14 118 3,220 137 2011 Q4 X 671 124 187 6,440 335 13 233 2,599 89

2012, Total X 1,678 197 702 49,939 1,154 51 580 17,697 581 2012 Q1 X 430 55 213 7,103 260 11 102 3,215 113 2012 Q2 X 380 33 169 10,095 277 3 96 4,858 208 2012 Q3 X 340 34 203 17,680 309 17 164 6,210 133 2012 Q4 X 528 75 117 15,061 308 20 218 3,414 127

2013, Total X 1,350 238 921 96,829 1,273 62 451 19,847 820 2013 Q1 X 370 75 123 13,676 203 23 71 5,074 121 2013 Q2 X 225 45 339 20,375 258 8 99 5,787 183 2013 Q3 X 291 47 137 32,091 353 17 125 5,640 342 2013 Q4 X 464 71 322 30,687 459 14 156 3,346 174

2014, Total X 1,757 485 958 192,925 2,040 50 431 19,045 1,655 2014 Q1 X 324 77 301 31,039 450 12 95 5,162 212 2014 Q2 X 431 139 197 39,651 362 12 40 4,552 518 2014 Q3 X 516 155 257 83,927 639 12 109 6,197 576 2014 Q4 X 486 114 203 38,308 589 14 187 3,134 349

2015 Total X 1,479 455 556 99,084 2,021 37 298 14,481 3,297 2015 Q1 X 252 180 163 22,977 405 9 54 3,304 317 2015 Q2 X 271 93 143 18,371 411 4 46 3,142 481 2015 Q3 X 337 103 108 27,226 538 7 58 4,428 943 2015 Q4 X 619 79 142 30,510 667 17 140 3,607 1,556

2016 Total X 1,836 241 512 96,785 4,374 36 165 14,192 7,296 2016 Q1 X 645 103 142 37,837 1,121 5 56 5,425 2,837 2016 Q2 X 519 49 159 21,567 1,418 3 48 3,780 1,583 2016 Q3 X 672 89 211 37,381 1,835 28 61 4,987 2,876 2016 Q4

X Not applicable. - Represents zero.

1 Livermore sector closed September 30, 2004. 2 Known as Marfa, Texas, before 2012. Source: DHS, CBP OBP, Performance Analysis System, EID, July 2016.

51

Table B4. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) Administrative Arrests: FYs 2008 to 2016 Q3

Fiscal Year/Quarter Arrests 2008 31,123 2009 21,251 2010 18,290 2011, Total 16,261

2011 Q1 3,284 2011 Q2 4,540 2011 Q3 4,082 2011 Q4 4,355

2012, Total 15,937 2012 Q1 3,195 2012 Q2 4,290 2012 Q3 4,235 2012 Q4 4,217

2013, Total 11,996 2013 Q1 2,839 2013 Q2 2,920 2013 Q3 3,591 2013 Q4 2,646

2014, Total 11,626 2014 Q1 2,384 2014 Q2 3,057 2014 Q3 3,429 2014 Q4 2,756

2015, Total 7,288 2015 Q1 1,862 2015 Q2 1,806 2015 Q3 2,070 2015 Q4 1,550

2016, Total 3,936 2016 Q1 1,229 2016 Q2 1,276 2016 Q3 1,431 2016 Q4

Source: DHS, ICE, HSI EID Arrest Guide for Law Enforcement EAGLE, July 2016.

52

Table B5. ICE Enforcement Removal Operations (ERO) Administrative Arrests: FYs 2008 to 2016 Q3

Fiscal Year/Quarter Arrests 2008 288,811 2009 311,920 2010, Total 314,915

2010 Q1 74,002 2010 Q2 76,025 2010 Q3 84,158 2010 Q4 80,730

2011, Total 322,093 2011 Q1 74,326 2011 Q2 80,592 2011 Q3 83,762 2011 Q4 83,413

2012, Total 290,622 2012 Q1 73,048 2012 Q2 74,944 2012 Q3 73,447 2012 Q4 69,183

2013, Total 229,698 2013 Q1 60,644 2013 Q2 54,513 2013 Q3 59,228 2013 Q4 55,313

2014, Total 181,719 2014 Q1 50,375 2014 Q2 47,303 2014 Q3 45,060 2014 Q4 38,981

2015, Total 125,509 2015 Q1 33,246 2015 Q2 30,067 2015 Q3 32,303 2015 Q4 29,893

2016, Total 81,146 2016 Q1 27,222 2016 Q2 26,155 2016 Q3 27,769 2016 Q4

Note: Many of the aliens arrested by ERO formerly were incarcerated in federal, state, and local prisons and jails. They are identified, processed, and prepared for removal under the Criminal Alien Program. Source: DHS, ICE, ICE Integrated Decision Support (IIDS), July 2016.

53

Table B6. Aliens Determined Inadmissible by CBP Office of Field Operations (OFO) Field Office: FYs 2005 to 2016 Q3

Fiscal Year/Quarter 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011, Total 2011 Q1 2011 Q2 2011 Q3 2011 Q4 2012, Total 2012 Q1 2012 Q2 2012 Q3 2012 Q4 2013, Total 2013 Q1 2013 Q2 2013 Q3 2013 Q4 2014, Total 2014 Q1 2014 Q2 2014 Q3 2014 Q4 2015, Total 2015 Q1 2015 Q2 2015 Q3 2015 Q4 2016, Total 2016 Q1 2016 Q2 2016 Q3 2016 Q4

Atlanta, Baltimore, Boston, Buffalo, Chicago, Detroit, El Paso, Houston, Total GA MD MA NY IL MI TX TX

251,109 207,610 202,025 222,788 223,897 229,406 212,249 54,867 52,510 53,667 51,190

193,609 46,316 47,489 48,912 50,889

204,113 49,075 51,231 49,448 54,359

223,459 50,666 53,355 61,277 58,161

253,509 60,450 61,313 61,193 70,553

200,378 67,972 66,330 66,076

6,175 4,254 3,905 7,529 8,002 9,163 8,726 2,182 2,400 2,154 1,990 7,984 1,822 2,283 1,916 1,963 8,376 1,902 2,202 2,135 2,137

10,457 2,455 2,613 2,814 2,575 8,144 2,241 2,105 1,945 1,853 5,245 1,776 1,623 1,846

4,054 2,039 2,006 2,231 2,428 2,775 3,108

612 831 921 744

3,613 724 990

1,095 804

3,120 659 848 774 839

2,882 662 738 764 718

2,367 583 552 685 547 843 322 233 288

4,091 3,045 3,347 4,087 4,650 4,716 5,205 1,089 1,203 1,160 1,751 4,821 1,284 1,015 1,052 1,468 4,984 1,414 1,435

956 1,179 4,536 1,301 1,053

910 1,272 5,115 1,583 1,229 1,061 1,242 2,583

629 1,327

627

49,655 37,488 28,945 21,369 18,683 17,763 15,712 3,953 3,398 3,881 4,480

14,050 3,678 3,042 3,421 3,909

13,425 3,456 3,040 3,153 3,776

13,127 3,234 2,891 3,390 3,612

11,871 3,089 2,552 2,817 3,413 8,572 2,885 2,948 2,739

6,201 3,675 2,874 3,599 3,536 3,219 2,553

685 575 664 629

2,449 610 530 625 682

2,173 588 501 535 548

2,303 597 540 594 572

4,348 795 914

1,279 1,360 2,793

758 980

1,055

11,844 9,689 4,426 10,403 8,713 3,512 8,546 8,370 3,641 7,748 7,912 12,061 7,428 7,712 16,428 7,398 7,898 18,963 7,250 6,909 19,5321,748 1,835 5,4201,788 1,624 5,2411,784 1,786 4,9391,888 1,664 3,928 6,743 6,955 12,7061,666 1,517 3,7681,816 1,685 3,0451,580 1,851 3,0261,575 1,901 2,867 6,564 7,900 10,9101,418 1,852 2,8061,668 1,746 2,3871,663 1,866 2,6021,815 2,436 3,115 6,110 10,214 10,4471,520 2,033 2,8121,435 2,384 2,9801,565 2,582 2,7781,590 3,215 1,877 5,989 12,071 11,1851,447 2,841 2,0361,384 2,696 2,8221,501 2,945 3,1811,657 3,589 3,146 3,803 16,202 7,1761,226 3,739 2,4971,244 4,611 2,2931,333 7,852 2,386

54

Table B6. Aliens Determined Inadmissible by CBP OFO Field Office: FYs 2005 to 2016 Q3 (continued)

Fiscal Year/Quarter 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011, Total 2011 Q1 2011 Q2 2011 Q3 2011 Q4 2012, Total 2012 Q1 2012 Q2 2012 Q3 2012 Q4 2013, Total 2013 Q1 2013 Q2 2013 Q3 2013 Q4 2014, Total 2014 Q1 2014 Q2 2014 Q3 2014 Q4 2015, Total 2015 Q1 2015 Q2 2015 Q3 2015 Q4 2016, Total 2016 Q1 2016 Q2 2016 Q3 2016 Q4

Los New San San Laredo,

TX Angeles,

CA Miami,

FL Orleans,

LA New

York, NY Portland,

OR Pre-

Clearance 1 Diego,

CA Francisco,

CA 32,576 8,526 13,069 162 14,990 620 8,338 45,552 4,910 30,686 4,372 8,085 182 6,113 576 10,922 47,932 2,914 30,765 6,962 6,842 331 5,723 1,117 10,613 49,456 3,418 26,635 12,148 7,765 12,293 6,834 1,401 8,388 47,125 7,305 21,877 11,724 7,032 18,153 11,268 988 7,865 42,017 6,880 24,441 8,556 9,163 19,162 9,918 899 9,539 40,014 6,279 25,790 6,695 6,896 20,855 6,892 1,892 8,586 33,719 6,9576,674 2,194 1,601 6,344 1,902 207 2,265 8,466 1,1446,015 2,077 1,712 4,834 1,893 379 2,335 8,841 1,3046,155 1,181 1,717 5,045 1,958 682 2,089 8,737 2,5206,946 1,240 1,866 4,632 1,139 624 1,897 7,675 1,986

28,005 3,928 7,593 20,204 4,912 1,166 8,559 26,889 9,8326,167 895 1,772 4,881 1,136 319 2,038 6,810 1,6986,540 929 1,857 5,882 1,288 134 2,269 6,736 1,8837,695 902 2,072 5,117 1,331 319 2,170 6,910 1,8397,603 1,202 1,892 4,324 1,157 394 2,082 6,433 4,412

31,781 3,905 8,687 21,012 4,650 1,402 9,695 25,632 14,9587,775 988 2,095 5,991 1,066 252 2,268 5,636 3,7347,831 1,119 2,315 6,125 1,056 271 2,536 6,104 4,2207,691 932 1,982 4,248 1,251 460 2,505 6,855 3,0538,484 866 2,295 4,648 1,277 419 2,386 7,037 3,951

38,978 4,065 12,195 21,202 4,614 1,115 10,700 32,543 14,0639,210 907 2,488 3,713 1,108 182 2,430 7,269 3,1978,727 960 3,467 4,536 1,098 206 2,813 7,337 3,548

10,875 1,034 2,948 8,199 1,222 329 2,645 8,836 3,49510,166 1,164 3,292 4,754 1,186 398 2,812 9,101 3,823 52,136 5,735 17,687 20,550 4,319 1,636 10,788 40,403 15,85811,330 1,258 3,790 5,933 954 187 2,718 10,856 3,37511,317 1,381 4,551 6,005 959 397 2,822 10,004 4,29812,649 1,532 4,419 4,476 1,295 456 2,562 9,133 3,37516,840 1,564 4,927 4,136 1,111 596 2,686 10,410 4,810 49,933 4,323 13,973 11,649 3,397 1,177 6,274 33,181 11,62418,774 1,313 5,144 4,341 1,111 250 2,094 11,163 3,53517,935 1,491 4,307 4,058 1,161 445 2,148 9,732 4,55513,224 1,519 4,522 3,250 1,125 482 2,032 12,286 3,534

55

Table B6. Aliens Determined Inadmissible by CBP OFO Field Office: FYs 2005 to 2016 Q3 (continued)

Fiscal San Seattle, Tampa, Tucson, Year/Quarter Juan, PR WA FL AZ Unknown 2005 2,008 11,383 2,008 10,531 301 2006 1,501 10,338 1,260 9,450 150 2007 2,674 10,605 3,396 8,268 221 2008 4,247 10,867 3,778 7,110 356 2009 4,754 9,080 4,501 8,377 514 2010 5,458 10,738 4,100 8,735 509 2011, Total 2,927 10,651 3,144 7,951 299 2011 Q1 1,181 2,452 771 1,984 158 2011 Q2 878 2,415 662 2,024 81 2011 Q3 592 2,717 872 2,052 61 2011 Q4 276 3,066 837 1,891 41 2012, Total 1,984 10,529 2,941 7,612 134 2012 Q1 275 2,612 635 1,939 70 2012 Q2 286 2,406 884 1,948 41 2012 Q3 804 2,597 710 1,846 34 2012 Q4 619 2,914 712 1,879 97 2013, Total 2,071 9,343 3,173 9,991 361 2013 Q1 471 2,062 453 2,061 127 2013 Q2 501 2,074 975 2,209 68 2013 Q3 679 2,300 581 3,159 68 2013 Q4 420 2,907 1,164 2,562 98 2014, Total 1,375 9,195 3,919 8,951 468 2014 Q1 429 2,259 745 2,031 84 2014 Q2 299 2,348 1,163 2,123 96 2014 Q3 341 2,155 1,086 2,635 80 2014 Q4 306 2,433 925 2,162 208 2015, Total 1,673 8,036 3,847 9,349 402 2015 Q1 360 1,908 1,003 2,063 100 2015 Q2 513 1,561 939 2,233 79 2015 Q3 408 2,040 945 2,381 108 2015 Q4 392 2,527 960 2,672 115 2016, Total 1,688 5,148 2,636 7,889 269 2016 Q1 464 1,713 951 3,143 144 2016 Q2 427 1,606 903 2,239 64 2016 Q3 797 1,829 782 2,507 61 2016 Q4

1 Refers to field offices abroad. Note: Data include all aliens found inadmissible, including those turned away at a port of entry or conditio