managing complexity | london business school
TRANSCRIPT
Security Guard
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Security Guard
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Security Guard
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Receptionist
IT Director
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns IT Director
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Security Guard
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Strategist
Security Guard
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Receptionist
IT Director
Operations Manager
Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality Control Sales Assista
nt
Strategist
Security Guard
Client Relatio
ns
Public Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
Account Manager
Com
mercial Director
Security Guard
Sales Assista
nt
Strategist
Security Guard
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality Control Sales Assista
nt
Strategist
Security Guard
Personal Assista
nt
Client Relatio
ns
Public Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Account Manager
Com
mercial Director
Sales Assista
nt
Strategist
Security Guard
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality Control Sales Assista
nt
Strategist
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Public Relatio
ns
Receptionist
Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Q
uality Control Sales Assista
nt
Strategist
Security Guard
Client Relatio
ns
Public Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Operations Manager
Account Manager
Com
mercial Director
Sales Assista
nt
Strategist
Public Relatio
ns Operations Manager
Account Manager
Com
mercial Director
Sales Assista
nt
Strategist
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Public Relatio
ns Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality ControlSales Assista
nt
Strategist
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Public Relatio
ns Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality ControlSales Assista
nt
Strategist
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Public Relatio
ns Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality ControlSales Assista
nt
Strategist
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Public Relatio
ns Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality ControlSales Assista
nt
Strategist
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Public Relatio
ns Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality ControlSales Assista
nt
Strategist
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Public Relatio
ns Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality Control
Strategist
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Operations Manager
Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality Control Security Guard
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Public Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality ControlSales Assista
nt
Strategist
Security Guard
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Public Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality ControlSales Assista
nt
Strategist
Security Guard
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Public Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality ControlSales Assista
nt
Strategist
Security Guard
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Public Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality ControlSales Assista
nt
Strategist
Security Guard
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Public Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality ControlSales Assista
nt
Security Guard
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Public Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality ControlSales Assista
nt
Strategist
Security Guard
Personal Assista
nt
Accountant
Client Relatio
ns
Public Relatio
ns
Marketing Executiv
e
Receptionist
IT Director
Operations Manager
Account Manager Head of Digital
Com
mercial Director
Q
uality Control
CFO
CEO
At the heart of organisational complexity is the battle between emergence and entropy.
Julian Birkinshaw charts the best way forward.
Are you managingcomplexity?
Are you managing complexity?
What is complexity?
It is easy to label big companies as overly complex. But what does this mean in practice?
When a small business receives payment for consulting work for a big “megafirm”, and it takes more than a year and a half to be paid, that’s complexity.
2
3
Are you managing complexity?
When companies become too complex to manage, they create costs for others.
Complexity is a double-edged sword. It is never easy separating out the complexity we value from the complexity we need to cut back on.
Two faced complexity
complexity
4
Inventing complexity
There are three processes underway that collectively determine the level of complexity experienced by people in the organisation.
Are you managing complexity?
5
Are you managing complexity?
The allocation of roles and responsibilities through some sort of top-down master plan.
Design process 1A
ccount
ManagerHead
of
Digital P
ublic
Relatio
ns
Marketing
ExecutiveC
lient
Relatio
ns
CEO
Operations
Manager
IT
Director
Com
mercial
Director
Are you managing complexity?
A bottom-up form of spontaneous interaction between well-intentioned individuals – known as self-organising. Under the right conditions, individual employees will come together to create effective action. The role of the leader is to foster ‘emergent’ order.
6
Emergent process 2
Security Guard
Receptionist
Head
of
Digital
IT
Director
Marketing
Executive
Strategist
IT Director
Client
Relatio
ns
7
Are you managing complexity?
The gradual trending of an organisational system towards disorder. Most companies are only semi-open to outside influences. The second law of thermodynamics comes into effect: a closed system will gradually move towards a state of maximum disorder – that is entropy.
Entropic process 3entropy
8
Are you managing complexity?
As organisations grow larger they become insular and complacent. Inefficiencies and duplications creep in. Employees become detached and disengaged. The organisation becomes aimless and inert.
The problem with entropyA
ccount
Manager
Receptionist
Security
Guard
Head
of
Digital
Com
mercial Director
Strategist
Public
Relatio
ns
Operations
Manager
9
Are you managing complexity?
More and more the leader’s job is to manage the social forces in the organisation. This can take very different forms.
So what can we do differently?
10
Are you managing complexity?
This is the equivalent of tidying your teenager’s room. It involves taking out layers of management, getting rid of old bureaucratic processes that are no longer fit for purpose, or replacing the old IT system.
Keeping entropy at bay 1
11
Are you managing complexity?
This is the equivalent of giving a bunch of bored teenagers a bat and ball to play with. It is about providing employees with a clear and compelling reason to work together to achieve some sort of worthwhile objective.
Inspiring emergent action 2
12
Are you managing complexity?
Leaders have to continually look for ways of bringing new perspectives into their company, and exposing internally focused procedures to external scrutiny.
Keep the company open and transparent 3
13
Are you managing complexity?
1.The art of managing complexity
It has to be tackled in a thoughtful and holistic way. Leaders need to think about both faces of complexity – the costs and the benefits.
Julian Birkinshaw ([email protected]) is Professor of Strategy and Entrepreneurship at London Business School and the author of Becoming a Better Boss (Jossey Bass, 2013).
The full article was published in London Business School Review Volume 26, Issue 3 2015.
Visit the website: www.london.edu/lbsr