8/3/2019 MN Attorney General Letter

1/2

October14,2011

AttorneyGeneralLoriSwanson

1400BremerTower

445MinnesotaStreet

St.Paul,MN55101

RE:ProposedAcquisitionofT-MobileUSA,Inc.byAT&TInc.

DearAttorneyGeneralSwanson:

TheundersignedorganizationsstronglysupportthedecisionoftheDepartmentof

Justiceandthebi-partisangroupofeight(8)attorneysgeneral1tofilesuittoblock

theproposedacquisitionofT-MobileUSA,Inc.byAT&TInc.(the"Proposed

Transaction").Weurgeyoutoconclude--astheattorneysgeneralfromseven

statesandPuertoRicohave--thattheProposedTransactionisharmfulto

competition,consumersandthepublicinterestandiscontrarytoantitrustlaws.

WeurgeyoutosupportandparticipateinthelawsuittoblocktheProposed

Transaction.

WeappreciatethecommentsyoumadeshortlyaftertheProposedTransactionwas

announcedwhereyouacknowledgedthedetrimentofexcessiveconcentration.We

furtherappreciatetheeffortsyourofficehasundertakentoexaminetheimpactsof

thetransactionbyreviewingdocumentsandcoordinatingwithotherstate

attorneysgeneral.

Thepurposeoftheantitrustlawsistopreventmergersthatreducecompetition,

andAT&T'sproposedpurchaseofitscompetitorT-Mobilemustbeevaluated

againstthespiritofthoselaws.ThisProposedTransactionharmscompetitionand

thecommunitymembersthattheundersignedgroupsrepresent.Wealldependonourwirelessdevicesdailytoconductbusiness,connectwithourfamiliesandhelp

usinemergencysituations.Thepotentialnegativeimpactonwirelessmarketsin

1In addition to the U.S. Department of Justice, the Attorneys General of California, Illinois,

Massachusetts, New York, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Puerto Rico and Washington are plaintiffs in

Civil No.11-01560 (ESH) in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia.

8/3/2019 MN Attorney General Letter

2/2

Attorney General Lori Swanson

October 14, 2011Page 2

Minnesotaandnationally,beingdominatedbytwoverticallyintegratedsuppliers

(post-mergerAT&TandVerizon)withnearly80%ofwirelesscustomersand

revenues,istoogreat.Amongothernegativeresults,amergerofthismagnitude

wouldleadtohigherwirelessprices,harminnovationandcausejoblosseswhichno

Minnesotacanafford.

YoursupportandparticipationtoblocktheProposedTransactionisneeded.

Minnesotashouldsendastrongsignalthatcompetitionandinnovationisthebest

waytogrowoureconomyandthenationsantitrustlawsmustbeenforced.

Thanksforyourconsiderationandattentiontoourrequestthatyoujointheother

attorneysgeneralseffortstostoptheProposedTransaction.

Sincerely,

amaliadeloney,CenterforMediaJustice

NielRitchie,LeagueofRuralVoters

JanisLane-Ewart,KFAI,FreshAir,Inc.

LauraWatermanWittstock,FirstPersonRadio

AndyDriscoll,TruthToTell

DanielleMkali,MainStreetProject

ElaineSalinas,MIGIZICommunications,Inc.

DukeGomez-Schempp,People'sPressProjectChristopherMitchell,InstituteforLocalSelfReliance

ChakaMkali,HOPECommunityDevelopmentCorporation

ErickBoustead,LineBreakMedia