s tudents with d isabilities and v ocational e ducation : b est p ractices for s erving s tudents in...
TRANSCRIPT
STUDENTS WITH DISABILITIES AND VOCATIONAL EDUCATION: BEST
PRACTICES FOR SERVING STUDENTS IN A COMPLIANT MANNER AND POSSIBLE
ENFORCEMENT ACTIONS
Jennifer Segal, Esq. [email protected] Brustein & Manasevit, PLLC
2
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
AGENDA Civil Rights Enforcement
U.S. Department of Education Office for Civil Rights
U.S. Department of Justices, Civil Rights Division IDEA Enforcement
Due Process Proceedings Case Studies: ensuring access to vocational
education programs for students with disabilities and appropriate IDEA transition activities
CIVIL RIGHTS ENFORCEMENT AGENCIES
• US Dept. of Education, Office for Civil Rights (OCR)
• US Dept. of Justice, Civil Rights Division (DOJ CRD)
3
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
OFFICE FOR CIVIL RIGHTS (OCR)
Department of Education, Office for Civil RightsMission: “To ensure equal access to education and to promote educational excellence throughout the nation through vigorous enforcement of civil rights”
4
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
OCR & CIVIL RIGHTS LAWS
1964: Title VI of the Civil Rights Act 1972: Title IX of the Education Amendments 1973: Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act 1975: The Age Discrimination Act 1990: Title II of the Americans with
Disabilities Act 2002: Boy Scouts of America Equal Access
Act, ESEA § 9525
5
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
OCR
Carries out mission through: Complaint Investigation and Resolution Proactive Enforcement: Compliance Reviews Monitoring of Resolution Agreements Technical Assistance
Affirmative Actions Required Data Collection Methods of Administration
6
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
OCR ORGANIZATION Washington, DC Headquarters 12 Enforcement Offices
7
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
US DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE (DOJ)
Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division Mission is to uphold the civil and
constitutional rights of all Americans, particularly some of the most vulnerable members of our society
8
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
DOJ CIVIL RIGHTS DIVISION
Enforces a broader range of statutes including: Title III of The Americans with Disabilities Act of
1990 Sections 504 and 508 of the Rehabilitation Act
of 1973 May enforce IDEA and Title II of the ADA
upon referral from other governmental agencies
9
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
DOJ CIVIL RIGHTS DIVISION
Headquarters in Washington, D.C. Division is made up of 11 sections including
the Educational Opportunities and Disability Rights sections
Disability Rights Section Activities: Enforcement Certification Negotiated Rulemaking Coordination Technical Assistance
10
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
OCR INVESTIGATION AND RESOLUTION: WHAT TO
EXPECT
CASE PROCESSING MANUAL (CPM)
Filing of the Complaint Investigation Early Complaint Resolution (ECR)
Mediation Process Mediators Independent of Investigation Outcomes:
Success ECR Agreement ECR not successful Return to Investigation
12
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
WAYS TO RESOLVE AN OCR CASE
ECR Agreement Section 302 Resolution Agreement
Reached during Investigation No OCR determination
Investigative Determination Insufficient Evidence Determination Non Compliance Determination
304 Resolution Agreement Enforcement Action
Monitoring
13
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
14
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
OCR CASE STUDIES
15
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
ENSURING VOCATIONAL EDUCATION PLACEMENT IS APPROPRIATE AND
FAPE
OCR investigation: Nordonia Hills City School District, Office for Civil Rights, Midwestern Division, Cleveland, 55 IDELR 81 (March 18, 2010) Student enrolled in new neighborhood high
school at beginning of school year Already had an IEP upon enrollment Her schedule allowed for half the day at home
school and half the day at a career and technical education program center
IEP team did not consider what accommodations were necessary for the student’s participation in the CTE program
16
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
NORDONIA HILLS CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT (CONT.)
OCR found District failed to comply with Section 504 because:
It did not reassess the student prior to her enrollment in the CTE program, which constituted a change in placement
Failed to hold an IEP meeting prior to enrollment in CTE program, invite CTE staff to IEP meeting, or consider what specific accommodations may be necessary for participation in CTE program
17
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
NORDONIA HILLS CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT (CONT.)
OCR found District’s grievance procedures: did not include information on where complaints
may be filed did not provide for adequate, reliable, and impartial
investigation of complaints, including the opportunity to present witnesses and other evidence
did not provide for reasonably prompt timeframes for the major stages of the complaint process; and
did not indicate that it would provide notice to the parties of the outcome of the complaint
18
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
APPLICABLE LEGAL STANDARDS (504 PLACEMENT DETERMINATIONS)
Section 504 places responsibility for ensuring FAPE on the School District
School districts must conduct an evaluation prior to any change in placement (34 CFR 104.35(a))
19
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
APPLICABLE LEGAL STANDARDS (504 PLACEMENT DETERMINATIONS)
Placement determinations must be made by a group of people “knowledgeable about the child, the meaning of the evaluation data, and placement options” (34 CFR 104.35(c))
20
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
APPLICABLE LEGAL STANDARDS (504 PLACEMENT DETERMINATIONS)
(CONT.)
Must draw upon information from a variety of sources, consider all significant factors relating to the learning process, including aptitude and achievement tests, teacher recommendations, physical condition, social or cultural background, and adaptive behavior (34 CFR 104.35(c))
21
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
APPLICABLE LEGAL STANDARDS (NOTICE OF NONDISCRIMINATION/GRIEVANCE PROCEDURES)
Prior to the beginning of each school year, recipients must advise students, parents, employees and the general public that all vocational opportunities will be offered without regard to race, color, national origin, sex, or handicap
Include a brief summary of program offerings and admission criteria; also the name, address and telephone number of Civil Rights/Section 504 Coordinator
34 C.F.R. § 100, App. B (IV)(O)
22
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
APPLICABLE LEGAL STANDARDS (NOTICE OF NONDISCRIMINATION/GRIEVANCE PROCEDURES)
The recipient must designate at least one person to coordinate efforts to comply with Section 504
The recipient must adopt grievance procedures that incorporate appropriate due process standards and provide for prompt and equitable resolution of complaints. 34 C.F.R. § 104.7
23
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
BEST PRACTICES
Upon students enrollment in District, hold IEP/504 meeting as soon as possible Determine whether student’s placement
constitutes change in placement and whether reevaluations are required
Make sure staff who are knowledgeable about the student and proposed placement are invited and attend (involve all necessary parties in scheduling)
Ensure District’s notice of nondiscrimination/grievance procedures are compliant and available
24
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
HARASSMENT BASED ON DISABILITY IN VOCATIONAL EDUCATION PROGRAMS
OCR investigation: Gilbert Public Schools, Office for Civil Rights, Western Division, Denver, 59 IDELR 84 (April 13, 2012). OCR found both District and CTE program
violated Section 504 CTE program administrators harassed District students
based on their disability, and the District failed to adequately redress the problem Technical school shut down a trade program only
after students with disabilities became the sole attendees
Unilaterally changed placement decisions for individual students with IEPs/504 plans
Made derogatory statements to students Retaliated against Complainant
25
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
When a District refers a student with a disability for services to an outside program, it continues to remain responsible for carrying out Section 504 requirements with respect to that student
Must ensure that nothing impedes 504 eligible students’ opportunity to equally participate in programs, activities, and benefits available to District’s other students
District has duty to investigate all 504 complaints
26
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
LEGAL REQUIREMENTS: HARASSMENT BASED ON DISABILITY
OCR would find a disability-based harassment violation under Section 504 when:
(1) a student is bullied/harassed based on a disability; (2) the bullying/harassment is sufficiently serious to create a hostile environment;
(3) District/school officials know or should know about it; and
(4) the District/school does not respond appropriately.
27
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
LEGAL REQUIREMENTS
Counselors must not direct or urge any student to enroll in a particular career or program, or measure or predict a student's prospects for success in any career or program based upon the student's race, color, national origin, sex, or handicap
Recipients may not counsel students with disabilities toward more restrictive career objectives than nondisabled students with similar abilities and interests
34 C.F.R. § 100, App. B (V)(B)
28
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
LEGAL REQUIREMENTS: ANTI-RETALIATION
Recipients are prohibited from retaliating against any individual for the purpose of interfering with any right or privilege protected under Section 504. See 34 CFR 104.61
29
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
BEST PRACTICES
Districts must maintain frequent communication with any outside placement (e.g., voc ed program, nonpublic placement)
Provide parents with copies of grievance procedures/notice of nondiscrimination upon enrollment/placement decision
Instruct program that disability discrimination, including harassment based on disability is prohibited
30
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
BEST PRACTICES (CONT.)
Include contract provision/certification related to disability and other civil rights laws and require attendance at IEP /504 meetings
Review admissions practices and policies for compliance
DUE PROCESS UNDER IDEA
32
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
DUE PROCESS COMPLAINTS
Allow parents/students to enforce the rights guaranteed under the IDEA Related to refusal or denial to initiate or change
the identification, evaluation, educational placement of the provision of a free appropriate public education (FAPE).
The alleged violation must have occurred within 2 years of the date of the complaint Some states have a 1 year statute of limitations
Each SEA must establish and maintain due process procedures
33
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLCDUE PROCESS COMPLAINT TIMELINE
Day Event
Day 1 Parent files complaint
Day 10 School files answer
Day 15 School files allegations of insufficiency of complaint – if any
Resolution Meeting
Day 20 Hearing Officer will make determination on allegations of insufficiency – if any
Day 30 End of resolution period – if complaint has not been resolved hearing goes forward
5 days prior to hearing date 5-day disclosures due
Day 45 Hearing Officer Decision issued
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLCRESOLUTION MEETINGS
Must occur within 15 days of notice of complaint. Attorney for the LEA cannot attend unless parent’s attorney
is also present If after reasonable efforts (documented), the LEA is unable to
obtain the participation of the Parent, the LEA may (at the end of the 30-day period), request that the hearing officer dismiss the parent’s due process complaint!
If LEA fails to schedule a resolution meeting, parent can ask for intervention!
Meeting notes are not confidential
Settlement agreement can be voided up to 3 days after it is signed
34
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
MEDIATION
Available for matters arising prior to or after the filing of due process complaint Not limited to issues raised in due process hearing; may
mediate any point in the dispute
Mediation is CONFIDENTIAL!
LEA cannot require mediation SEA responsible for selecting mediators, and it must be
on a random, rotational, or other impartial basis [ED does] not believe that a hearing officer can order
that the parties to a due process complaint engage in mediation.” (71 Fed. Reg. 46694 (Aug. 14, 2006))
35
36
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
HEARING OFFICER DETERMINATIONS
What relief can be granted when a FAPE violation is found?
Courts have broad discretion in fashioning relief for violations of the IDEA. Burlington Sch. Comm. v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359 (1985) Hold meetings Evaluations Placement
Private Schools Residential
Compensatory Education Tutoring Job coach Credit recovery
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLCATTORNEYS’ FEES
Attorneys’ fees and related costs may be awarded to “Prevailing Party”
However, Attorneys' fees may not be in any action for services performed subsequent to the time of a written offer of settlement to a parent if--
The offer is timely made The offer is not accepted within 10 days; andThe court or administrative hearing officer finds that the relief finally obtained by the parents is not more favorable to the parents than the offer of settlement.
37
DUE PROCESS CASE STUDIES
39
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLCIDEA CASE STUDIES AND TRANSITION SERVICES
Quick Refresher Transition services under IDEA means a
coordinated set of activities for a child with a disability that is – a results-oriented process focused on improving academic and functional
achievement to facilitate movement from school to post-school activities:
including postsecondary education vocational education integrated employment (including supported employment) continuing and adult education adult services independent living or community participation
40
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
QUICK REFRESHER (CONT.)
Is based on individual needs, taking into account, strengths, preferences, and interests and includes: Instruction related services community experiences development of employment and other post-school
adult living objectives, and (if appropriate) acquisition of daily living skills and
provision of a functional vocational evaluation. may be special education or an a related
services.
41
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
The IEP must include: 1. Appropriate measurable postsecondary goals
based upon age appropriate transition assessments related to training, education, employment, and, where appropriate, independent living skills
2. The transition services (including courses of study) needed to assist the child in reaching those goals
42
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
IDEA CASE STUDIES
Transition planning must address community living needs. Horizon Instructional Systems Charter School, 58
IDELR 145 (SEA CA 2012): “An LEA is not required to guarantee that a student
with a transition plan actually obtains a job in the community. However, in an appropriate case, an LEA must, as a transition service, ‘facilitate the movement’ of a disabled student to ‘integrated employment, including supported employment. . .’”
43
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
IDEA CASE STUDIES
Horizon Instructional Systems Charter School (Cont.): Hearing officer found denial of FAPE because student’s
transition plan failed to address needs for: Independent living skills (inadequate assessment –
not clear if student could write a check, make change, etc.)
Mobility training (student relied on parent for transportation, lacked goal in mobility, when goals was finally added, involved printing a bus route from a different neighborhood)
Community and employment experience (mock job or a simulation on campus was not sufficient )
44
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
IDEA CASE STUDIES
Transition planning must address community living needs. Dracut School Committee v. Bureau of Special
Education, 737 F.Supp.2d 35 (D. Mass 2010): Court found denial of FAPE because the IEP did not provide for any vocational training opportunities in the community. School internships on campus were not sufficient
45
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
IDEA CASE STUDIES
Student’s absence does not justify insufficient transition services: Reynolds School District, 115 LRP 3792 (OR SEA
2014): Hearing officer found that “a student’s absence [during assessment periods] does not constitute a good reason for failing to engage in transition planning as transition assessments are informal assessments that can happen any time based on student availability”
46
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
BEST PRACTICES Create transition services template for IEP
team which addresses each required element: Instruction, related services, community experiences,
development of employment and other post-school adult living objectives, and (if appropriate) acquisition of daily living skills and provision of a functional vocational evaluation
47
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
BEST PRACTICES (CONT.)
Provide training on use of template Take detailed notes as to why each transition service was selected – which goals will each service help to advance? How were the particular goals identified/drafted? Prior to concluding each IEP meeting, ask parent/student if they have any questions/concernsDocumentation
48
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
IDEA CASE STUDIES
Reasonable accommodations vs. fundamental or substantial modifications G.B.L. v. Bellevue School District, 2013 WL
594289 (W.D. Wash. 2013): Court found that parent’s request to limit a student’s
(with AHDH) homework to two hours per night was not reasonable. Noting that the assigned homework was an essential component of coursework in the gifted program and the student would be unable to keep up with class discussions if homework was limited
49
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLCUNDUE BURDEN OR FUNDAMENTAL ALTERATION Providers must take those steps necessary to
ensure that students with disabilities are not denied services or excluded because of the absence of auxiliary aids and services
UNLESS taking those steps would fundamentally alter the nature of services or program or would result in an undue burden Undue Burden = significant difficulty or expense*See Supplemental Educational Services Non-Regulatory
Guidance (June 13, 2005)
50
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
BEST PRACTICES Hold IEP meeting to discuss any questions
regarding appropriateness of requested accommodations/modifications
If accommodations/modifications denied, provide written explanation as to why accommodation would require a fundamental or substantial modification to program/standards – provide prior written notice!
Brainstorm alternative accommodations
51
Bru
stein
& M
anase
vit, P
LLC
DISCLAIMER
This presentation is intended solely to provide general information and does not constitute legal advice. Attendance at the presentation or later review of these printed materials does not create an attorney-client relationship with Brustein & Manasevit, PLLC. You should not take any action based upon any information in this presentation without first consulting legal counsel familiar with your particular circumstances.