saad haj bakry, phd, ceng, fiee 1 economic evaluations saad haj bakry, phd, ceng, fiee p...
TRANSCRIPT
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE
1
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE
PRESENTATIONS IN NETWORK MANAGEMENTPRESENTATIONS IN NETWORK MANAGEMENT
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 2
Objectives / Contents
Cost / Expenditures
Benefits / Revenues
Background in Economics
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 3
Background in Economics
Evaluation Methods
Change of Value
Cost & Benefits
Basic Principles
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 4
Basic Principles Symbol Factor Criteria
C Cost / Expenditures
“Cost Reduction” (maintaining requirements / management)
B Benefits / Revenues
“Maximizing Benefits”(efficient use / charging policy)
E Cost-Effectiveness: E = B / C
t time Investigation time scale. Break-Even time: E = 1. Optimum Life: Maximum E
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 5
Types of Cost / BenefitsIssue Type Explanation
Estimation Problem
Tangible Can be quantified directly and assigned a monetary value: e.g. cost of equipment.
In-Tangible
Difficult to quantify and given monetary value: e.g. staff frustration
Operation / Time
Recurring Continue to occur through the life of the project: e.g. maintenance cost
Non-Recurring
Usually occur at the beginning of the project life and do not occur again:
e.g. initial investment.
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 6
Change of Value (with Time)
Factor ExplanationReference
Time / Year
t = 0 Reference time (year) for the evaluation of real worth values
Proportional Change of
Value
(positive or negative)
Effect of “inflation” Effect of “borrowing” Combined Effects: “discount rate”
Change:
v(t)
Real Worth v(t) = v RV(t) = V(t) / (1+v)t
V(t)
V(t)1)V(tv(t)
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 7
Evaluations: Cash Flow
-300
-250
-200
-150
-100
-50
0
50
100
Year(0)
Year(2)
Year(4)
Year(6)
Year(8)
Year(10)
Year(12)
Year(14)
Cost
Benefits
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 8
Evaluations: Investment State
-300-250-200-150-100
-500
50100150
Year(0)
Year(2)
Year(4)
Year(6)
Year(8)
Year(10)
Year(12)
Year(14)
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 9
Evaluations: Efficiency
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
Year(1)
Year(3)
Year(5)
Year(7)
Year(9)
Year(11)
Year(13)
Year(15)
Efficiency
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 10
Cost / Expenditures
Cost Management / Policy
Place
Network Operation
Network Structure
Staff
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 11
Network Structure
Access / Services Sub network:
Access Points Servers
Communications
Communications Sub network:
Switches Channels
Installation / Testing
Consulting: Planning (Legal, Technical,..) / Design
Capacity / BW = Cost
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 12
Place / Staff
TrainingLand
Building
Offices / Furniture
Lighting
Air-Conditioning
Water Cooling
Salaries
Other Staff Benefits
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 13
Network Operation
Monitoring & Control
Preventive Maintenance
Help-Desk: Fault Repair
Cost of Other Management Functions…
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 14
Cost Management / Policy
Contracts / SLAs: Service Level Agreements
Distribution of Cost / Criteria
Cost Reduction / Resource Sharing
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 15
Service Level Agreements: SLAs
Users: Associated with Different Internal Department
Internal SLAs
Internal IT Department: Computer Services / Intranet
External SLAs
Resources Suppliers Services Providers
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 16
Cost Distribution: Organization Intranet
Centralized• Cost is paid by “top management”
• Top level “overheads”
Distributed
• Cost is distributed among the departments of the organization
• “Distribution Criteria is needed.
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 17
Cost Distribution: Criteria
Criteria DescriptionShares Cost is distributed according to specified
weights of shares
Size Cost is distributed according to size: “employees” / “space”..
Profit Cost is distributed according to “profit” or “loss”
Use Cost is distributed according to traffic “generation” / “flow”
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 18
Cost Reduction
Equipment: Buy / Lease / Rent
Operation / Maintenance /
Staff: Considering SLAs
(Specialized Companies)
Sharing Resources
Balancing Demands and
Resources
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 19
Sharing Resources
Examples:• Long Distance Channels
• Management Software
• Information Services
• Staff
Advantages:Cost Sharing
Less Cost per Department
Capacity Utilization Cost Effectiveness
Problems: Increased Management Complexity / Control & Security / Performance Level
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 20
Benefits / Revenues
ManagementOf Revenues
Dimensions of Benefits
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 21
Dimensions of Benefits
TimeSaving Time
Increasing Productivity
GeographySaving Movement
Saving Space
Form: Enhancing Quality / Supporting Management Efficiency / Better Security
PROPER UTILIZATION
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 22
Management of Revenues
Tariff Policy Services Competitiveness Busy Period Issues
Management Cost v. Revenues Public Services of
Non-Urban Areas
Future Development: Cost of Expansion / Upgrading / Replacement
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 23
Conclusions
Cost / Expenditures
Evaluations: Use of Economic Principles
Benefits / Revenues
Interaction
Time / Progress
Efficient Management
Economic Evaluations
Saad Haj Bakry, PhD, CEng, FIEE 24
References General Network Planning, ITU-T
Telecommunications Management: Operation & Management of Networks, National Computing Centre (NCC) Training, UK.
R. Jamal-Aldeen, S.H. Bakry, A. Nouh, “Analysis of the cost-effectiveness of information networks with applications”, International Journal of Network Management, Vol. 100, No. 2, pp.91-101, March / April 2000.
Economic Evaluations