case studies undp: association of manambolo natives, madagascar

Upload: undpenvironment

Post on 14-Apr-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: ASSOCIATION OF MANAMBOLO NATIVES, Madagascar

    1/12

    Equator Initiative Case StudiesLocal sustainable development solutions for people, nature, and resilient communities

    Madagascar

    ASSOCIATION OFMANAMBOLO NATIVES(FITEMA)

    Empowered live

    Resilient nation

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: ASSOCIATION OF MANAMBOLO NATIVES, Madagascar

    2/12

    UNDP EQUATOR INITIATIVE CASE STUDY SERIES

    Local and indigenous communities across the world are advancing innovative sustainable development solutions that wo

    or people and or nature. Few publications or case studies tell the ull story o how such initiatives evolve, the breadth

    their impacts, or how they change over time. Fewer still have undertaken to tell these stories with community practition

    themselves guiding the narrative.

    To mark its 10-year anniversary, the Equator Initiative aims to ll this gap. The ollowing case study is one in a growing ser

    that details the work o Equator Prize winners vetted and peer-reviewed best practices in community-based environmenconservation and sustainable livelihoods. These cases are intended to inspire the policy dialogue needed to take local succ

    to scale, to improve the global knowledge base on local environment and development solutions, and to serve as models

    replication. Case studies are best viewed and understood with reerence to The Power of Local Action: Lessons from 10 Years

    the Equator Initiative, a compendium o lessons learned and policy guidance that draws rom the case material.

    Click on the map to visit the Equator Initiatives searchable case study database.

    EditorsEditor-in-Chief: Joseph Corcoran

    Managing Editor: Oliver HughesContributing Editors: Dearbhla Keegan, Matthew Konsa, Erin Lewis, Whitney Wilding

    Contributing WritersEdayatu Abieodun Lamptey, Erin Atwell, Toni Blackman, Jonathan Clay, Joseph Corcoran, Larissa Currado, Sarah Gordon, Oliver Hughe

    Wen-Juan Jiang, Sonal Kanabar, Dearbhla Keegan, Matthew Konsa, Rachael Lader, Patrick Lee, Erin Lewis, Jona Liebl, Mengning Ma,

    Mary McGraw, Gabriele Orlandi, Brandon Payne, Juliana Quaresma, Peter Schecter, Martin Sommerschuh, Whitney Wilding, Luna Wu

    DesignOliver Hughes, Dearbhla Keegan, Matthew Konsa, Amy Korngiebel, Kimberly Koserowski, Erin Lewis, John Mulqueen, Lorena de la Pa

    Brandon Payne, Mariajos Satizbal G.

    AcknowledgementsThe Equator Initiative acknowledges with gratitude the Association o Manambolo Natives (FITEMA), and in particular the guidance a

    inputs o Ramaly Antoine (FITEMA President). All photo credits courtesy o FITEMA. Maps courtesy o CIA World Factbook and Wikiped

    Suggested CitationUnited Nations Development Programme. 2012. Association of Manambolo Natives (FITEMA), Madagascar. Equator Initiative Case Stu

    Series. New York, NY.

    http://equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/Power_of_Local_Action_Final_2013.pdfhttp://equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/Power_of_Local_Action_Final_2013.pdfhttp://equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/Power_of_Local_Action_Final_2013.pdfhttp://equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/Power_of_Local_Action_Final_2013.pdfhttp://equatorinitiative.org/index.php?option=com_winners&view=casestudysearch&Itemid=858
  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: ASSOCIATION OF MANAMBOLO NATIVES, Madagascar

    3/12

    PROJECT SUMMARYThe Association o Manambolo Natives (FikambanannyTeraki Manambolo - FITEMA) has used the reintroductiono an indigenous land use system to help conserve orestsand wetlands in the 7,500-hectare Manambolo Valley aorest corridor which joins the Andringitra and RanomaanaNational Parks while improving ood security or localcommunities. The valleys orests are home to a high numbero endemic species and also provide critical ecosystemservices to around 200,000 residents o ve neighbouringdistricts, including timber and non-timber orest products,

    water regulation, and watershed protection.

    The organization works on orest restoration through theestablishment o nurseries with local tree species, includingthe native Ravenea madagascariensis palm. The group hasalso constructed irrigation inrastructure and is guided in itswork by a commitment to the ull participation o its targetcommunities.

    KEY FACTS

    EQUATOR PRIZE WINNER: 2002

    FOUNDED: 1993

    LOCATION: Manambolo Valley, Madagascar

    BENEFICIARIES: 12 communities; 1,300 households

    BIODIVERSITY: 7,500-ha forest corridor

    3

    ASSOCIATION OF MANAMBOLO NATIVES(FITEMA)Madagascar

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    Background and Context 4

    Key Activities and Innovations 6

    Biodiversity Impacts 8

    Socioeconomic Impacts 8

    Policy Impacts 9

    Sustainability 10

    Replication 10

    Partners 10

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: ASSOCIATION OF MANAMBOLO NATIVES, Madagascar

    4/12

    4

    he Association o Manambolo Natives (Fikambananny Teraki

    Manambolo - FITEMA) is a community-based natural resource

    management initiative which reestablished a traditional, indigenous

    and use system in order to ensure the ecological connectivity o

    he Andringitra-Ranomaana orest corridor and the viability o its

    umerous ecosystem services. By helping local armers to double the

    roductivity o their rice elds, FITEMA has succeeded in preventing

    urther destruction o this important orest corridor, contributing to

    he protection o endemic biodiversity and to the ood security o

    ocal communities.

    A hotspot for biodiversity and endemic species

    Madagascar is a micro-continent which is home to thousands o ora

    nd auna species, approximately 80 per cent o which are unique

    o the island. The Malagasy moist orest eco-region is made up o

    orest ecosystems ranging rom sea level to 2,600 meters in altitude

    with typical habitats including littoral orests, lowland orests, mid-

    ltitude orests and mountain vegetation. The ora o this eco-

    egion comprises ve o the six amilies endemic to Madagascar and

    7 out o 209 known genera. The auna is composed o ancient and

    iversied lineages including at least one quarter o all primates in

    he world.

    he initiative is named or the Manambolo River, the main river

    riginating in the orest, which passes through the majority ohe villages where local people live. The Manambolo Valley is

    ocated between the Andringitra National Park to the south and

    anomaana National Park to the north. This 7,500 ha orest corridor

    rovides an unbroken chain o intact rainorest which is situated in

    ianarantsoa Province on the steep slopes o the Central Highlands.

    Due to anthropogenic deorestation, the majority o the remaining

    orests are located on the peaks. Nevertheless, the remaining ora

    ave retained their mid-altitude moist orest characteristics with a

    redominance o endemic species such as tree erns (cyathea spp.)

    nd ebony wood (albergia spp. and diospyros spp.) and many others.

    imilarly, the characteristic auna includes about hal o the ying

    mammals o Madagascar, thirteen species o lemurs, and 106 sp

    o birds.

    These remaining orests in the Manambolo Valley are o ca

    importance not only or the survival o endemic species but als

    the well-being o the local population or whom the orest prov

    essential services such as timber and non-timber orest prod

    water regulation and watershed protection. The lives o n

    200,000 people (living in the ve districts targeted by the initia

    depend on the sustainable management o the orests and o

    resources in this corridor. Most o the people living in this area

    subsistence armers who grow rice in the ooded and irrig

    lowlands and ood crops in the hills.

    Prior to the colonization o Madagascar by the French, the u

    natural resources in the Manambolo Valley was governed thro

    the traditional Dina system. The Dina is a system o rules

    regulations used in isolated regions o Madagascar to guide

    control resource use and community behavior. These rules w

    passed orally rom generation to generation over centuries.

    French colonial administration did not recognize the Dina a

    was replaced with the establishment o the Department o W

    and Forests which was charged with overseeing natural reso

    management. Having lost their status, the village elders ha

    legal avenue through which to manage the resources that

    traditionally been in their control, and overexploitation proceedan alarming rate both by villagers and by outsiders. In the mid 19

    villagers approached the World Wildlie Fund (WWF - now know

    the Worldwide Fund or Nature) seeking assistance. This led to

    creation o the Association o Manambolo Natives, or Fikamba

    Teraki Manambolo (FITEMA). WWF project personnel (who were

    living in the local community) acted as intermediaries to re-o

    communication between village residents and the Departme

    Water and Forests. The ultimate goal was to establish a harmon

    balance between human needs and the protection o na

    resources in the region. The project began helping local resid

    to re-establish and legalize the Dina in order to regain contr

    Background and Context

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: ASSOCIATION OF MANAMBOLO NATIVES, Madagascar

    5/12

    55

    heir resources through traditional management methods, whereby

    lders make decisions ater consulting their ancestors. This has been

    crucial component in project success, especially in terms o gaining

    opular support, as Madagascar is a country where ancestors are

    ighly venerated.

    inking the National Parks

    y this time, there were already many pressures on the regions

    orests, namely slash-and-burn agriculture, grazing, orest res, and

    legal timber and precious stone operations, which were causing

    he loss o this unique habitat or mid-altitude ora and auna. These

    ressures were exacerbated by inadequate technical supervision

    n the part o the Forest Service and the high illiteracy rate o the

    ocal people which orced them to depend on the orests to meet

    heir basic needs. These environmental problems were widespread

    hroughout the country, and the national government began to

    ecognize the high rate o deorestation taking place especially in

    nprotected areas and that there was a lack o continuity between

    xisting protected areas.

    n September 2003 at the World Parks Congress, the president Madagascar, Marc Ravalomanana, announced his ambitious

    Durban Vision which aimed to triple Madagascars protected areas

    rom two million to six million ha. WWF supported the government

    n identiying suitable locations or these new protected areas which

    ncluded the Ranomaana Andringitra Forest Corridor between the

    lready established Ranomaana and Andringitra National Parks.

    WWF was initially responsible or managing the park but thereater

    ranserred the management o this area to the National Association

    or the Management o Protected Areas (ANGAP) which has since

    ecome known as Madagascar National Parks (MNP).

    Reestablishing a traditional management system

    Malagasy law provides a legal ramework or the transer o all

    enewable natural resources to communities who meet the

    equirements as set out by law.WWF worked with FITEMA and

    overnment agencies to make the Dina system legally binding.

    Approval was sought rom relevant local authorities, nances

    were secured, social structures were created and the contract was

    pproved by the state. 1,000 ha o government orest land has

    ow been legally transerred to local residents or them to manage

    ndependently, through the signing o GELOSE (Gestion Locale

    ecurise) conventions with the Department o Water and Forests.

    As a result, the Dina system is now enshrined in the laws o the

    egion and government regulations are imposed only i the Dina is

    ot capable o resolving conicts.

    Now that Dina has become law, power has been given to

    communities to control resources eectively. The Dina ass

    sustainability by respecting key unctions o land managem

    including timing, quantity, requency and rights o usage. It con

    virtually all orest products including honey, wood, eels

    craysh. Outsiders can no longer use the orests resources u

    authorized by village elders and a system or equitable sharin

    resources within the valley has been implemented. As a result o

    reestablishment o the Dina system, Manambolo residents now

    a common vision or the use o the orest. Instead o being sim

    viewed as a source o rst-come-rst-served raw material, the

    is now regarded as an important aspect o local heritage, t

    managed or sustainable long term use.

    FITEMA was ounded in order to ensure the transer o reso

    management to local communities and to educate the local pe

    about the importance o biodiversity, with a ocus on lemurs,

    to actively involve them in its protection. In the beginning

    association ocused on the application o the management

    which was required by the transer and approved by the Forest Ser

    and established a program o ecological restoration. Since achie

    their initial objectives, FITEMA has implemented accompanmeasures which were meant to ensure the ood security o

    local communities through agroorestry, horticulture, the use

    cover crop system, an improved and intensive rice system, and

    establishment o a community granary in each village. In this

    FITEMA aims to reduce the dependence o target communitie

    orest products through the adoption o alternative livelihoods

    provide economic benets. Projects are implemented to incr

    armers agricultural production while discouraging detrim

    practices such as slash-and-burn agriculture. Local commun

    have thus been empowered to address their environmental conc

    while increasing their incomes, and the local Forest Service has

    given material and technical support which urther contribut

    the success o the project.

    Giving the communities a sense o responsibility over

    natural resources has been a central goal o FITEMA. The inten

    beneciaries include twelve grassroots communities, or 1

    households with an average o six persons per household,

    total o 32,000 targeted beneciaries. In addition to suppo

    the participating communities in a wide range o environm

    and social endeavors, FITEMA publicizes their activities in the w

    region and in the international community. Through its va

    projects, FITEMA aims to ensure that the needs o uture genera

    in terms ecosystem services will be met.

    We have decided to restore the forest, to no longer cut down the trees, putting a stop to erosio

    and protecting our water sources. Now we are using the area as a nursery for palm trees

    Ramaly Antoine, FITEMA President

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: ASSOCIATION OF MANAMBOLO NATIVES, Madagascar

    6/12

    6

    Key Activities and Innovations

    ITEMAs twelve community-based associations are engaged in

    orest management based on a simplied management plan which

    was established according to the Dina system, which governs

    pproximately three quarters o the country. Under this authority,

    8,809 ha o the Andringitra-Ranomaana orest (20 per cent o the

    orridor orest) is currently managed by local communities who

    re trained to sustainably use the land while increasing crop yields.

    his type o community management involves the monitoring

    nd patrolling o orest areas by the people independently or in

    ollaboration with the Forest Service.

    ITEMA has also promoted orest restoration through the

    stablishment o nurseries o local species in order to reduce thenvironmental pressures on these species while increasing the

    ervices rendered to the community. One endemic species o palmravenea madagascariensis) has been particularly targeted in these

    eorestation eorts as this species is widely used by the community

    or various purposes. Through targeting species that are deemed

    aluable by the communities, such as timber and other useul wood

    ypes and species consumed by lemurs, the project aims to enrich

    he orest and raise its value in the eyes o the local people. The

    project also ghts to stave o unwanted or invasive species.

    A focus on food security

    Additionally, FITEMA helps to increase agricultural productivity byworking with armers not only to improve existing arming practices

    but also to diversiy the crops produced. Traditionally, local armers

    ad been in the habit o using slash-and-burn techniques in the

    atural orests since their own elds were either insufcient in size

    or were not productive due to degraded soil quality. It was with this

    n mind that FITEMA began to conduct training to encourage the

    armers to use their land more intensively by rotating crops (rice-

    bean, peas-potatoes, chives) and also to restore soil quality through

    he use o cattle manure as ertilizer. The project also supports

    he management o 8.7 km o irrigation micro-inrastructure. This

    irrigation system is needed or the production o rice, the main st

    ood o Madagascar, a crop which requires a large amount o w

    As or the diversication o agriculture, FITEMA encourages

    production o citrus crops and market gardening. Non-agricul

    sources o income such as sh arming, artisanal products

    weaving are also targeted or diversication, in the hope o redu

    poverty and increasing the robustness o economic activity in

    buer villages.

    FITEMA also undertakes outreach and education activities in o

    to reduce environmental pressures (e.g. slash-and-burn, le

    poaching and overharvesting o palm trees) and to improve knowledge o existing laws and management rules. In order to

    awareness, FITEMA goes around to the villages, organizing meet

    putting up posters and showing lms to the people about the

    to protect the environment. In order to get children involved, FIT

    organizes drawing and poetry contests and teaches them si

    environmental lessons so that they can understand the relevan

    the environment to their daily lives.

    Innovative responses to deforestation

    There are several ways in which FITEMA has shown creativity

    innovation in overcoming challenges aced by the commun

    First o all, they have implemented a special cultivation sywhich has greatly improved local arming techniques. As mentio

    above, FITEMA trains armers in crop rotation and the produc

    and use o ertilizers. Additionally, FITEMA employs a type o n

    arming called cover crops. Ater minimally tilling the soil (wh

    necessary due to its compactness), it is covered with a layer o

    or dead plants, preerably with nitrogen-xing legumes, a me

    which helps to control weeds while increasing nutrients

    retaining moisture in the soil. Motivated armers are selected t

    trained in these techniques on plots provided by the commun

    These armers then pass their new knowledge onto others who

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: ASSOCIATION OF MANAMBOLO NATIVES, Madagascar

    7/12

    7

    o learn the new techniques. This system has been so successul that

    t is estimated that more than 85 per cent o local non-members

    ave adopted the improved methods, which can be attributed

    o transversal diusion, a process by which people copy their

    eighbors arming techniques.

    Additionally, FITEMAs success in orest restoration can be attributed

    o a transplantation method they developed using wild stock.

    nstead o having a nursery or orest plants, seedlings are collectedwild in other parts o the orest and replanted in the areas where

    eorestation is desired. The success rate o this restoration method

    as been above 80 per cent whereas there was little success in seed

    ermination attempts in the nursery.

    A third area in which FITEMA has shown innovation is in the plan

    oravenea, a plant whose trunk begins to develop ater 12 years

    is usable only ater 50-60 years. Farmers generally do not like wa

    50 to 6o years beore using any resource. In the case oravenea

    act that people have agreed to plant it knowing that it will b

    long beore they can reap the benets demonstrates FITEM

    success in bringing about a change in mentality. The reason

    species is targeted in particular is because its brous trunk

    withstand inclement weather (e.g. rain and high temperatures)can be used or a variety o purposes. For example, ravenea is use

    build granary walls to protect grains since rats are unable to pi

    its bers.

    If we have succeeded, it is, above all, due to the fact that we took into account the reality of th

    situation: We are bad at protecting the forest when our stomachs are empty.

    Sylvain Razafimandimby, Manambolo

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: ASSOCIATION OF MANAMBOLO NATIVES, Madagascar

    8/12

    8

    Impacts

    BIODIVERSITY IMPACTS

    Through community-based management and monitoring o the

    orest, external exploitation o local resources, deorestation, orest

    res and erosion have been virtually eliminated and armers have

    topped using slash-and-burn arming techniques altogether.

    Biodiversity conservation is being achieved through the protection o

    both orest and water resouces. Protecting this type o dense, humid,

    medium-altitude orest ecosystem has been particularly important

    s it constitutes the habitat o certain agship species including the

    ree ern (cyathea spp.), ebony (diospyros spp. and dalbergia spp.) and

    emur species such as hapalemur aureus, microcebus sp. and eulemur

    p. There has been an observed increase in the lemur population,s reported by armers who claim that whereas previously lemurs

    were rarely seen, ater implementing the restrictions, they now

    ometimes see groups o ve to seven lemurs at a time.

    ITEMAs ecological restoration plan has also been quite successul.

    This plan was based on assessments o restoration priority needs

    n the corridor, leading to the establishment o seedbeds or the

    groorestry system and nurseries or orest landscape restoration

    n target communities. Nurseries were implemented or uel

    wood production (16,000 plants), production o ruit trees (2,000

    ruits plants), and production o autochthonous plants or active

    estoration within natural orest (45,000 plants). O particular interest

    s the increase in the valuable species ravenea madagascariensis inhe orest - 16,000 have been successully planted since 1998.

    The participatory communication and environmental education

    plan has had an impact in terms o increasing public awareness o

    environmental issues. During the implementation o the project,

    he populations living within the vicinity o the orest corridor

    have become aware o the importance o biodiversity. Peer-to-peer

    exchanges have taken place and students o primary and secondary

    chools have begun to play a crucial role in the monitoring o lemurs

    nd other species. Ater receiving lessons on the liestyles o lemurs,

    they take periodic trips to the orest to observe and record cha

    in the numbers o lemurs in each observed group. At present

    student environmental club boasts 491 members who are act

    engaged in spreading awareness o the importance o biodive

    especially as it pertains to improving incomes that are depende

    orest ecological unctions.

    SOCIOECONOMIC IMPACTS

    Beore the initiative began, armers planted traditional crops o

    cassava, beans, Madagascar peanut and sweet potato. Almost

    these crops were destined or consumption. As a result o FITEprojects, local armers have been able to more than double

    agricultural output enabling them to sell a large percentag

    their harvest. This large increase in productivity can be attribut

    the adoption o new arming techniques, as promoted by FIT

    which include the introduction o more productive varietie

    rice, crop rotation and the use o compost to increase soil ert

    Improvements in the management o both irrigation m

    inrastructure and tanety (grass covered hills) have also taken p

    The irrigation micro-inrastructure allows almost all o the 2

    villagers in Ambalahosy to benet rom the availability o w

    throughout the year and to rerain rom slash-and-burn techni

    which had been destroying the orest. Approximately 115 ha o

    elds benet rom this improved rice cultivation system. Villahave noted that previously, their rice harvests ed them or

    seven months o the year, whereas it can now sustain them

    eleven months.

    Developing alternatives to deforestation

    FITEMA has also promoted new sources o income through

    introduction o non-traditional crops such as citrus crops

    potatoes, and the establishment o sh arming and beekee

    activities. Ater identiying potentially protable sectors, FIT

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: ASSOCIATION OF MANAMBOLO NATIVES, Madagascar

    9/12

    assists villagers in learning the required skills, provides material

    assistance and contributes to market development. For example,

    n the case o beekeeping, FITEMA distributed new, improved

    hives and trained villagers in modern extraction techniques to

    ncrease the output o honey. Collected honey provided a new

    ource o income, selling or a considerable amount in this region

    o Madagascar. Each community member has been able to choose

    one or more alternative income-generation activity according the

    availability o their land. Training has been oered to select groupswho are in turn expected to share this knowledge with others, with

    priority being given to single mothers and the elderly. FITEMA has

    also encouraged the local people to plant o-season crops (e.g.

    potatoes, beans and cabbage) in allow rice elds and participate

    n market gardening as a way o adapting to climate change and

    ncreasing soil ertility. Because o these diversication eorts, local

    evenue has been signicantly increased and ood security has been

    mproved. Along with the improved rice cultivation techniques, the

    o-season crops have successully reduced the lean period rom

    even months to three months.

    Collective action and mutual aid

    Another way in which FITEMA has improved ood security is by

    building a community granary in each village. Normally, each armer

    would have his own granary to stock excess rice or other crops.

    Farmers without a granary are orced to sell rapidly and at low prices

    during the harvest season, later acing ood security problems.

    n order to remedy this problem, the armers agreed to build a

    communal granary where everyone can stock their harvested

    crops (usually rice, peanuts and beans). The usage rules are decided

    on as a group, by the members who constructed it. Sometimes,

    he members buy the grains to stock and later resell them to the

    members (especially during the lean season) at a lower price than

    s asked or in the markets or by dealers. This system allows armerso buy grains at competitive prices and to bring in the revenue that

    heir associations need to unction.

    These income-generation and ood security projects have also

    contributed to compliance with environmental regulations. Whereas

    he local people had previously been dependent on the orest or

    heir daily needs, they now only go there rom time to time to collect

    ome ruit and mushrooms.

    Using the prize money rom the Equator Prize, which they won

    n 2002, FITEMA was able to build two classrooms or the public

    elementary school and establish a supply o drinking water or

    he village (about 1,400 people). The latter helps to reduce childmortality and to improve maternal as well as general health which

    ncreases worker productivity.

    FITEMA has had a positive impact on the communities social

    organization by promoting a sense o togetherness and respect

    or elders, and social conict has been reduced through working

    owards a common vision. These concepts have been supported by

    trengthening the capacity o members in the local ofces, many o

    whom were either illiterate or had attained only a very basic level

    o education. WWF provides support by either directly addressing

    their illiteracy or by providing reresher courses, and also g

    simple training sessions on how to manage an association,

    accounting books, draw up annual work plans and keep mee

    minutes. FITEMA has emphasized the participation o women w

    the association. Since 2008, the number o emale members

    doubled. The large number o women within the association

    improved their ability to orm social and cooperative groups, lea

    to an increased sense o empowerment and improved incomes

    POLICY IMPACTS

    When the protected area was established, the FITEMA commun

    were actively involved in inuencing changes in the boundari

    the new protected area, the Ranomaana-Andringitra orest cor

    Public consultation was required by law prior to the establishm

    o these boundaries, and the FITEMA communities were ab

    successully lobby to ensure that pre-existing management p

    be taken into consideration. For example, zones where commun

    already held the right to use the resources were maintained

    were not converted into conservation zones. Furthermore, t

    communities have contributed a great deal to the developmo the management plan o this protected area. Thanks to FIT

    and WWF Madagascar, the protected status o the Ranoma

    Andringitra orest corridor is now eective.

    In 2009, thanks to their successul management o orestry resou

    FITEMA obtained rom the Forest Service a renewal o their con

    to manage the orests or another ten years. The associat

    development plan and simplied management strategies help

    this regard.

    Two representatives o FITEMA are currently members o

    Federation o Community-based Organizations, an advisory bod

    decision-making regarding the management o the orest cor

    between two national parks, Ranomaana and Andringitra.

    9

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: ASSOCIATION OF MANAMBOLO NATIVES, Madagascar

    10/12

    10

    Sustainability and Replication

    SUSTAINABILITYDonors to the project have typically made only short-term

    nvestments and these donors have changed many times, creating

    elationship breakdowns between WWF and the grassroots

    ommunities. As a result, the project has been limited in its ability

    o consistently monitor changes in deorestation over time. This

    monitoring lies thereore with the Forest Service.

    Despite these challenges, a certain degree o sustainability has been

    chieved through the nature o certain project impacts such as

    mprovements in incomes and increased ood security which directly

    ect the local way o lie. Once these kinds o socioeconomicenets were perceived by the local people, the incentive structure

    hanged and people began to view conservation eorts more

    avorably, thus strengthening project sustainability.

    he main environmental benet which has been improved over

    me is the communities access to water or irrigation and drinking.

    urthermore, the communities have become increasingly aware o

    nvironmental issues thanks to FITEMAs awareness campaigns and

    o the dissemination o scientic ndings, rendering the project more

    ustainable. This has been seen by the act that, on the ew occasions

    when there was a breakdown in project activities, the momentum to

    onserve the orests was maintained by the local people themselves.

    Giving the communities this sense o responsibility has made thessociation eective and sustainable.

    he key components which make this project sustainable are

    nancial resources, human resources, training and capacity building,

    ommunity participation and awareness campaigns. Additional

    unding is needed, at least in the medium term, or replication and

    xpansion o the activity zone which would increase the target

    opulation.

    REPLICATIONWWF Madagascar works with a wide range o buer commun

    within the rainorest region and has been able to replicate

    FITEMA model in eight other sites, bringing the total numb

    people reached to around 100,000. In communities with which

    WWF has been working, there have been both strong and w

    points in terms o project accomplishments. They have ound

    exchanges between communities are oten the key to succe

    replication.

    FITEMA requently organizes armer-to-armer knowle

    exchanges, an activity that they have ound rewarding as it alcommunities to learn how others have been able to overcome

    challenges they are currently acing. It is particularly helpul to

    about the new techniques and approaches that others are usin

    combine biodiversity conservation with the ght against pover

    The main obstacle that FITEMA has experienced when attemp

    such exchanges is the nature o short term projects and nan

    with goals that can only be attained in the long term. To overc

    this challenge, two things are needed: long-term partnerships (

    technical and nancial) and community empowerment and

    revitalization o interest groups (youth, women and elders).

    Since 2002, twelve new grassroots community organizations been ormed in the Ranomaana-Andringitra orest corridor. In

    o these cases, a neighboring community was able to receive un

    or the establishment o a tourist route, thanks to FITEMAs succ

    PARTNERS

    The local population has been the most critical partner in ensu

    the overall success o the project. Traditional authorities -

    notables and elders - have been particularly important in t

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: ASSOCIATION OF MANAMBOLO NATIVES, Madagascar

    11/12

    Climate variability has been felt in our communities. They have caused disruptions in crop

    calendars. Adaptations to these variabilities are to increase crop varieties (rice, leafy vegetables

    cassava) and to plant them in off-seasons.

    Ramaly Antoine, FITEMA President

    1111

    the dissemination and acceptance o WWF messages among

    ommunity members. Mutual trust has been established between

    he two entities.

    ITEMA has also been ortunate to have support rom local, regional

    nd national governments. The Ministry o Environment and Forests

    as assisted in the coordination o activities under the management

    ranser o natural resources and has validated the development

    lans and supported the project and communities in the application existing laws and regulations. The regional government has been

    esponsible or the development o regional development plans that

    ake into account the specicities o the municipalities in which WWF

    works. The district chies and town mayors are the representatives

    the state in the remote areas where WWF is working. They have

    developed, with support rom WWF (especially with regard to

    protection o the environment), Communal Development Plans

    Technical assistance has been provided by the Multilocal Plan

    Committee and USAID who work in the same area and share

    same vision as WWF. Ecological and biological inventories have b

    conducted in the corridor by the Ecological Training Program w

    aimed to support claims o the importance o biodiversity thro

    scientic research.

    WWF Madagascar has beneted rom nancial support rom va

    donors (WWF Switzerland, WWF Germany, WWF Sweden, W

    France, WWF U.S. and government agencies) and experts rom

    WWF international network.

  • 7/27/2019 Case Studies UNDP: ASSOCIATION OF MANAMBOLO NATIVES, Madagascar

    12/12

    Click the thumbnails below to read more case studies like this:

    FURTHER REFERENCE

    Andriamalala, G., and Gardner, C.J. 2010. Lutilisation du dina comme outil de gouvernance des ressources naturelles : leons tir

    Velondriake. Tropical Conservation Science 3 (4) pp. 447-472.

    Equator Initiative

    Environment and Energy GroupUnited Nations Development Programme (UNDP)

    304 East 45th Street, 6th Floor

    New York, NY 10017

    Tel: +1 646 781 4023

    www.equatorinitiative.org

    The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) is the UNs global development network, advocating or change

    onnecting countries to knowledge, experience and resources to help people build a better lie.

    The Equator Initiative brings together the United Nations, governments, civil society, businesses and grassroots organizati

    o recognize and advance local sustainable development solutions or people, nature and resilient communities.

    2012 by Equator Initiative

    All rights reserved

    http://www.equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/com_winners/casestudy/case_1348164031.pdfhttp://www.equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/com_winners/casestudy/case_1348163487.pdfhttp://www.equatorinitiative.org/images/stories/com_winners/casestudy/case_1348151357.pdf