chatham rock phosphate marine consent application hearing ... · chatham rock phosphate – marine...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 1 Thursday 25 September 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett, Amy Selvaraj,
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
Q June and Peter Jackson
EPA Mihi
1
9.12am Mr Neil Walters DMC Mihi 1
9.16am Break with Tea, coffee and
2
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
biscuits.
9.24 Chair DMC House Keeping - OPENING_STATEMENT OF CHAIR AT WELLINGTON HEARING
2
9.25am Sharon Goodall Hearing Manager
EPA House Keeping 2
9.28am Chair HouseKeeping Opening Statement 3
9.40am James Winchester CRP Opening Statement - OPENING SUBMISSIONS FOR CHATHAM ROCK PHOSPHATE LIMITED
- CASEBOOK FOR CHATHAM ROCK PHOSPHATE LIMITED
6
11.08am Morning Break 39
11.26am James Winchester CRP Opening Statement Continued
39
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
12.22pm Chair DMC Questions 59
12.23pm Jeremy Prebble The Crown Opening Statement Crown Opening Submissions 59
1.02pm Lunch 71
2.10pm Jeremy Prebble The Crown Opening Statement Continued
72
2.32pm DMC DMC Questions 78
2.35pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Opening Statement Opening Representation on behalf of Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu
80
3.35pm DMC DMC Questions 105
3.40pm Afternoon Break 106
3.56pm Kirsty Woods Te Ohu Kai Moana Trustee Ltd
Opening Statement Opening Statement of Kirstin Woods on behalf of Te Ohu Kai Moana Trustee Ltd
106
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
4.03pm DMC House Keeping 110
4.07pm Adjourned 110
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 2 Friday 26 September 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett, Amy Selvaraj,
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.01am Chair DMC House Keeping 111
9.05am Duncan Currie Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Opening Statement Opening Submissions KASM Greenpeace and DSCC
112
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.54am DMC DMC Questions 133
10.07am Jo Appleyard Deepwater Group Opening Representation
Opening Representation on behalf of Deepwater Group Ltd
136
10.50am DMC DMC Questions 154
10.52am Morning Break 155
11.18am Chair DMC House Keeping - 155
11.21am Peter Anderson Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated
Opening Representation
Legal Submission on behalf of the Royal & Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated.
155
11.52am DMC DMC Questions 170
11.53am Rob Enright Environmental Defence Society
Opening Representation
Opening Submission of Counsel for the Environmental Defence Society
170
12.24pm Nicola de Wit Environmental Defence Society
Opening Representation
180
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
Continued
12.49pm DMC DMC Questions 189
12.54pm Lunch 190
2pm DMC 191
2.01pm James Winchester Chatham Rock Phosphate Opening Representation
191
2.05pm Chris Castle Chatham Rock Phosphate Evidence Executive Summary of Evidence
192
2.20pm DMC DMC Questions 198
2.31pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Questioning
203
2.41pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 209
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
2.47pm Robin Falconer Chatham Rock Phosphate Evidence Evidence 211
2.59pm DMC DMC Questions 215
3.04pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 217
3.08pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Questioning
219
3.11pm Ray Wood Chatham Rock Phosphate Evidence Presentation, Photos & 2 Videos
220
3.36pm Afternoon Break 228
3.52pm DMC DMC Questions 229
4.03pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Questioning
234
5
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
4.15pm Jo Appleyard Deepwater Group Questioning 241
4.42pm Jeremy Prebble The Crown Questioning 253
4.48pm James Winchester Chatham Rock Phosphate Questioning 256
4.49pm DMC House Keeping 257
4.52pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Oral Submission
258
4.53pm Jo Appleyard Deepwater Group 259
4.54pm DMC House Keeping 261
4.58pm Adjourned 261
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 3 Monday 29 September 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett, Andrew Crosland
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.00am Chair DMC House Keeping 263
9.11am Linda Sanders CRP Executive Summary of Evidence
Executive Summary Presentation
265
9.17am DMC DMC Questions 269
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.21am Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 270
9.37am Maui Solomon Hokotehi Moriori Trust (HMT)
Questioning 278
10.18am DMC DMC Questions 293
10.21am Ruby Hazen Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Questioning
294
10.22am Katrin Berkenbusch
Deepwater Group,
Ngai Tahu,
Ngati Kahungunu &
Te Ohu Kaimoana
Executive Summary of Evidence
Short summary of evidence for the EPA hearing on 29 September 2014
295
10.34am DMC DMC Questions 309
11.13am Morning Break 313
11.33am DMC Five minute break due to power failure
313
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
11.38am Duncan Currie Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Questioning -
313
11.47am James Winchester CRP Questioning 316
12.39pm DMC DMC Questions 336
12.41pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 338
12.43pm Lunch Break 339
1.14pm Dan Govier Deepwater Group,
Ngai Tahu,
Ngati Kahungunu &
Te Ohu Kaimoana
Summary of Evidence for CRP Hearing 29 September 339
1.55pm DMC DMC Questions 343
2.10pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 349
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
2.21pm DMC House Keeping 353
2.29pm Adjourned 354
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 4 Tuesday 30 September 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett, Andrew Crosland
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.00am Chair DMC House Keeping 355
9.02am Dr Thomas Hourigan
The Crown Evidence 355
9.15am DMC DMC Questions 358
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
10.02am James Winchester CRP Questioning 369
10.39am Duncan Currie On behalf of EDS Questioning 379
11.03am DMC House Keeping 386
11.08am Morning Break 387
11.30am Dr John Leathwick The Crown Evidence Maritime Rules – Part 22: Collision Prevention
387
11.33am DMC
DMC Questions 388
11.54pm James Winchester CRP Questioning Novel Methods for the design and evaluation of marine protected areas in offshore waters.
394
12.10pm DMC DMC Questions 400
12.12pm Duncan Currie On behalf of EDS Questioning 401
12.19pm Lunch Break 403
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
1.19pm DMC House Keeping 404
1.21pm Prof. Les Watling Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated
Evidence - Summary of Evidence - Introduction to the
Physics of Cohesive Sediment in the Marine Environment: Chapter
- PowerPoint Presentation
404
1.40pm DMC DMC Questions 411
2.09pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 420
2.34pm Duncan Currie On behalf of EDS Questioning 431
2.42pm Dr David Thompson
CRP Evidence Summary of Evidence 435
2.50pm DMC DMC Questions 438
3.03pm Peter Anderson Forest & Bird Questioning 443
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
3.13pm Jeremy Prebble
The Crown Questioning 448
3.30pm Afternoon break 455
3.48pm Jeremy Prebble
The Crown Questioning continued.
455
4.05pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 463
4.12pm Dr Graeme Taylor The Crown Evidence Graeme Taylor’s Power Point Presentation
465
4.36pm DMC DMC Questions 474
4.45pm James Winchester CRP Questioning Email from MPI 479
5.00pm Peter Anderson Forest & Bird Questioning 485
5.07pm Eleanor Jamieson The Crown House Keeping 488
5.08pm DMC House Keeping 489
5
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
5.09pm Adjourned 489
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 5 Wednesday 1st
October 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett, Andrew Crosland
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.00am Chair DMC House Keeping 490
9.02am Dr Jeremy Spearman
CRP Evidence 490
9.15am DMC DMC Questions 494
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
10.04am Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 509
10.20am Duncan Currie Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Questioning
514
10.41am DMC DMC Questions 521
10.42am Sander Steenbrink CRP Evidence - PowerPoint Presentation
- Building with Nature Thinking, acting and interacting differently 05 02 Building with Nature Thinking, acting and interacting differently
521
10.55am DMC DMC Questions 524
11.09am Morning Break
529
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
11.33am DMC DMC Questions 529
11.42am Duncan Currie Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Questioning - Haveeru Online - Environmental problems arise from Boskalis land projects
- Environmental Impact of K.Thulusdhoo Reclamation Project
532
12.09pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 541
12.16pm DMC House Keeping 543
12.17pm Lunch Break 544
1.15pm Jamie Lescinski CRP Evidence - PowerPoint Presentation
544
1.35pm DMC DMC Questions 551
1.53pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition
Questioning 557
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
Incorporated, KASM
2.07pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 562
2.26pm DMC DMC Questions 570
2.28pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning Continued
571
2.46pm Eleanor Jamieson The Crown Questioning 577
3.04pm Afternoon Break 584
3.27pm Gerard Van Raalte CRP Power Point Presentation
Video :ChathamDeep Trail_0003
584
3.48pm DMC DMC Questions 591
5
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
4.24pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Questioning
604
4.38pm Eleanor Jamieson The Crown Questioning 611
4.51pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 616
4.55pm James Winchester CRP Supplementary Questions
617
4.57pm DMC House Keeping 618
4.59pm Dougal Greer DMC Evidence 618
5.12pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Questioning
623
5.14pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 625
6
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
5.19pm Dr Scott Nodder CRP Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 627
5.35pm DMC DMC Questions 632
5.50pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 637
5.58pm Eleanor Jamieson The Crown Questioning 640
6.04pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Questioning
642
6.08pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 644
6.010pm DMC House Keeping 645
6.15pm Adjourned 645
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 6 Wednesday 2nd
October 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.00am Chair DMC House Keeping 646
9.03am Dr Peter Longdill The Crown Evidence Summary of Evidence 646
9.19am DMC Questioning 652
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.45am
Ruby Haazen
Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Questioning 660
9.49am James Winchester CRP Questioning 662
10.12am Dr Diane Jones CRP Evidence 670
10.19am DMC Questioning 673
10.29am Ben Williams Deep Water Group Questioning 676
10.36am Jeremy Prebble The Crown Questioning 679
10.42am
Ruby Haazen
Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Questioning 681
10.43am Emeritus Professor Arthur Popper
CRP Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 681
11.05am DMC Questioning 690
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
11.20am
Ruby Haazen
Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Questioning 696
11.23am Ben Williams Deep Water Group Questioning 698
11.28am Lunch Break
12.31pm Dr Ian Tuck CRP Evidence PowerPoint Presentation with Video
699
12.47pm DMC Questioning 705
12.57pm Ben Williams Deep Water Group Questioning 708
1.01pm Dr Alison MacDiarmid
CRP Evidence Summary of Evidence 710
1.07pm DMC Questioning 712
1.21pm DMC House Keeping 718
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
1.24pm Adjournment 718
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 7 Friday 3rd
October 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett, Andrew Crosland
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.00am Chair DMC House Keeping 719
9.03am Dr Judith Hewitt CRP Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 719
9.12am DMC Questioning 722
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.32am Neil Walters On behalf of Stephen Christensen for Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu
Questioning 729
9.40am Ruby Haazen
Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition Incorporated, KASM
Questioning 732
9.43am Jeremy Prebble The Crown Questioning 734
9.53am Peter Anderson Forest & Bird Questioning 737
9.59am James Winchester CRP Questioning 740
10.01am Mr J A (Sandy) Bartle
Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society
Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 741
10.27am DMC Questioning 750
10.42am James Winchester CRP Questioning 757
11.06am Morning Break 767
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
11.32am Dr Leigh Bull DMC Evidence 768
11.33am DMC Questioning 768
11.50am Hamish Harwood CRP Questioning 775
12.05pm Peter Anderson Forest & Bird Questioning 780
12.22pm Morgan Slyfield DMC Questioning 787
12.28pm James Winchester CRP Hearing logistics 789
12.29pm Jeremy Prebble The Crown Clarification 789
12.30pm Adjournment 790
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 8 Friday 14th
October 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett, Andrew Crosland
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.02am DMC House Keeping 791
9.06am Dr Ngaire Phillips Deepwater Group, Ngai Tahu, Ngati Kahungunu & Te Ohu Kaimoana
Evidence Summary of evidence 792
9.18am DMC Questioning 796
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.49am James Winchester CRP Questioning 809
10.14am Assoc Prof Barrie Peake
Greenpeace, KASM, DSCC Evidence Evidence 820
10.27am DMC Questioning 824
10.43am Hamish Harwood CRP Questioning 829
10.54am Duncan Currie Greenpeace, KASM, DSCC Questioning 833
10.59am James Winchester CRP Questioning 835
11.00am Morning Break 836
11.23am Dr Louis Tremblay EPA Evidence 836
11.29am DMC Questioning 838
11.50am Hamish Harwood CRP Questioning 845
11.52am Dr Alec McKay CRP Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 846
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
12.05pm DMC Questioning 851
12.33pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace, KASM, DSCC Questioning 861
12.38pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 863
12.39pm Lunch Break 864
1.46pm Dr David Bull CRP Evidence Summary of Evidence 864
2.00pm DMC Questioning 868
2.11pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace, KASM, DSCC Questioning 873
2.15pm Dr Nikolaus Hermanspahn
CRP Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 875
2.33pm DMC Questioning 879
2.56pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace, KASM, DSCC Questioning 886
3.13pm Dr Ross Jeffree DMC Evidence 893
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
3.17pm DMC Questioning 895
3.35pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace, KASM, DSCC Questioning 901
3.39pm Hamish Harwood CRP Questioning 903
3.43pm Afternoon Break 905
4.00pm David Santillo Greenpeace, KASM, DSCC Evidence 905
4.12pm DMC Questioning 908
4.21pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 911
4.28pm DMC House Keeping 914
4.29pm Adjournment 914
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 9 Wednesday 15th
October 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) Mr David Hill (Member) Mr Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Ms Gen Hewett
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.01am DMC House Keeping 915
9.02am James Winchester CRP House Keeping 915
9.03am Paul Kennedy CRP Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 915
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.20am DMC Questioning 920
10.01am Duncan Currie Greenpeace, KASM, DSCC Questioning 936
10.28am Morning Break 948
10.46am Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 948
11.01am James Winchester CRP Questioning 954
11.04am Dr Matt Pinkerton CRP Evidence Summary of Evidence
PowerPoint Presentation 955
11.35am DMC Questioning 967
12.07pm Lunch Break 982
1.00pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace, KASM, DSCC Questioning 982
1.16pm Jeremy Prebble The Crown Questioning 990
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
1.22pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 993
1.24pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 993
1.27pm Duncan Currie Questioning 994
1.29pm Jeremy Prebble The Crown House Keeping 995
1.30pm Dr Beth Fulton The Crown Evidence 996
1.41pm DMC Questioning 1000
1.52pm Hamish Harwood CRP Questioning 1005
1.56pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace, KASM, DSCC Questioning 1006
2.00pm James Winchester CRP House Keeping 1008
2.02pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu House Keeping 1009
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
2.04pm Afternoon Break 1010
2.31pm DMC House Keeping 1010
2.34pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu House Keeping 1010
2.36pm Peter Clough CRP Evidence Summary of Evidence 1011
2.53pm DMC Questioning 1019
3.32pm Jo Appleyard Deep Water Group Questioning
- Evidence Peter John William Clough ENV-2011-CHC-95,97
- Economics – ENV-2011-CHC-095 and ENV-2011-CHC-097
- Transcript 5/11/12 pg 440 - 496
1034
3.56pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 1045
5
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
4.33pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 1060
4.36pm Dr Ganesh Nana CRP Evidence Summary of Evidence 1062
4.53pm DMC Questioning 1067
5.12pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 1075
5.17pm DMC House Keeping 1077
5.19pm Adjourned 1077
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 10 Wednesday 16th
October 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) Mr David Hill (Member) Mr Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Ms Gen Hewett
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.00am DMC House Keeping 1078
9.01am Aleksandr Sundakov
Deepwater Group, Ngai Tahu, Ngati Kahungunu & Te Ohu Kaimoana
Evidence Summary of Evidence 1078
9.16am DMC Questioning 1084
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.48am James Winchester CRP Questioning 1097
10.19am Morning Break 1110
10.36am James Winchester CRP Questioning continued
1110
11.38am Morgan Slyfield EPA House Keeping 1136
11.39am Kieran Murray DMC Evidence 1136
12.01pm DMC Questioning 1142
12.13pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 1146
12.24pm Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 1150
12.27pm James Winchester CRP House Keeping 1152
12.29pm Lunch Break 1152
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
1.31pm Dr Richard O'Driscoll
CRP Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 1153
2.02pm DMC Questioning 1163
2.26pm Jo Appleyard Deep Water Group Questioning 1174
2.34pm Susan Baird CRP Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 1177
2.49pm DMC Questioning 1182
2.56pm Adjourned 1185
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 11 Friday 17th
October 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) Mr David Hill (Member) Mr Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Ms Gen Hewett
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.01am DMC House Keeping 1186
9.03am
Dr Jeremy Helson Deepwater Group,
Ngai Tahu,
Ngati Kahungunu
Te Ohu Kaimoana &
Fisheries Inshore New
Zealand
Evidence 1186
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.11am DMC Questioning 1189
9.40am James Winchester CRP Questioning Email between Chris Castle & Richard Wells CRP
1199
10.08am DMC Questioning 1210
10.11am James Winchester CRP Questioning continued
1211
10.13am David Middleton
Deepwater Group,
Ngai Tahu,
Ngati Kahungunu, Te Ohu
Kaimoana &
Fisheries Inshore New
Zealand
1212
10.36am Morning Break 1219
10.52am DMC Questioning 1219
11.09am Hamish Harwood CRP Questioning 1225
11.54am Alistair Dunn CRP Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 1241
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
12.10pm DMC Questioning 1247
12.25pm Amy Hill Deep Water Group Questioning 1255
12.34pm DMC Questioning 1258
12.37pm Lunch Break 1260
1.32pm Morgan Slyfield EPA House Keeping 1260
1.33pm Dr Johanna Pierre DMC Evidence 1261
1.37pm DMC Questioning 1262
2.23pm Hamish Harwood CRP Questioning
- MSC Fisheries Certification Requirements and Guidance. Version 2.0, 1st October, 2014
- MSC Fishery Assessment Report – No. 2012-0016, Revision No. 04
- Hamish Harwood Crp - MSC Fisheries certification
1283
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
requirements version 2.0 Amended
- 11 04 Maps Development Wellbores CRP
- Global Trust MSC Pre-Assessment Report Louisiana State CRP
- MSC Public Certification Record Louisiana Blue Crab Fishery CRP
3.14pm Morgan Slyfield EPA Questioning 1303
3.21pm DMC House Keeping 1306
3.23pm Adjourned 1306
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 12 Wednesday 20th
October 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) Mr David Hill (Member) Mr Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Ms Gen Hewett
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.03am DMC House Keeping 1307
9.04am James Dorherty Ngā Kaihautū Tikanga
Taiao Karakea 1307
9.06am Nick Roskruge Ngā Kaihautū Tikanga Taiao
Ngā Kaihautū Tikanga Taiao Report
1307
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.21am DMC Questioning 1312
9.50am DMC House Keeping 1321
9.55am Turoa Karatea Evelyn Tuuta Evidence Evelyn Tuuta Spiral Bound Book
1322
10.20am Morning Break 1331
10.37am Evelyn Tuuta Evelyn Tuuta Evidence
Statement of Evelyn Tuuta - Whanau o Evelyn Tuuta and Mokopuna, Te Moananui a Kiwa Erueti-Newman
1331
11.06am DMC Questioning 1340
11.37am Greg Summerton Ngai Tahu long lining commercial fisherman on Chatham Rise.
Evidence
- Greg Summerton Presentation Material for Okains Bay Seafood for Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu
- Whiteboard Picture - Okains Bay Longline Fishing Company
- Wild Ling Packaging - Okains Bay Longline Fishing Company
1352
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
- Deep Sea Breeded Cod Packaging - Okains Bay Longline Fishing Company
- Okains_Bay_Longline_Fishing_Company_Booklet
12.06pm Lunch 1361
1.02pm Greg Summerton Ngai Tahu long lining commercial fisherman on Chatham Rise.
Evidence continued 1361
1.03pm DMC Questioning 1362
1.32pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 1374
1.46pm Kauahi Ngapora Kaikoura Whale Watch Evidence Kauahi Koroneho Ngapora - Whale Watch Kaikoura Ltd
1381
1.54pm DMC Questioning 1383
2.10pm Hamish Harwood CRP Questioning 1390
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
2.17pm Rodney Tribe Ngai Tahu Seafoods Evidence Rodney Louis Tribe - Ngai Tahu Seafood
1394
2.28pm DMC Questioning 1398
2.40pm Hamish Harwood CRP Questioning 1403
2.44pm Stephen Christensen
Ngai Tahu Questioning 1405
2.46pm Maria Bartlett Ngai Tahu Evidence Maria Bartlett Summary of Evidence - Ngai Tahu
1405
3.05pm Afternoon Break 1414
3.28pm DMC Questioning 1414
3.41pm James Winchester CRP Questioning
- Decision thwarts Ngai Tahu dairy plans - Stuff.co.nz Article
- Ngai Tahu in bind over impact of intensification - Newspaper Article
1419
5
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
4.14pm Kirsty Woods/Laws Lawson
Te Ohu Kai Moana Trustee Ltd
Evidence Kirsty Woods - Te Ohu Kaimoana - PowerPoint Presenatation
1430
4.32pm DMC Questioning 1436
4.45pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 1441
4.47pm Adjourned 1442
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 13 Wednesday 21st
October 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) Mr David Hill (Member) Mr Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Ms Gen Hewett
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.00am DMC House Keeping 1443
9.01am Ngahiwi Tomoana Ngati Kahungunu Iwi
Incorporated Evidence 1443
9.09am DMC Questioning 1445
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.15am
Associate Professor Liz Slooten
Deep Sea Conservation
Coalition Incorporated Evidence
- Supplementary
Evidence
- Animation
1448
9.25am DMC Questioning 1452
10.04am James Winchester CRP Questioning 1467
10.44am Tara Ross Watt
Deepwater Group, Ngai
Tahu, Ngati Kahungunu &
Te Ohu Kaimoana
Evidence Evidence 1484
11.03am Morning Break 1492
11.18am DMC Questioning 1492
11.42am James Winchester CRP Questioning 1500
11.54am Duncan Currie
Greenpeace New Zealand
Incorporated, Deep Sea
Conservation Coalition
Incorporated, KASM
Questioning 1506
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
11.56am Dr Darlene Ketten CRP Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 1508
12.40pm Lunch Break 1522
1.41pm DMC Questioning 1523
2.15pm Duncan Currie
Greenpeace New Zealand
Incorporated, Deep Sea
Conservation Coalition
Incorporated, KASM
Questioning 1535
2.42pm Jeremy Prebble The Crown Questioning 1546
2.56pm
Dr Simon Childerhouse
The Crown
Evidence
Summary of Evidence
PowerPoint Presentation 1552
3.22pm Afternoon Break 1561
3.39pm DMC Questioning 1561
3.58pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace New Zealand
Incorporated, Deep Sea Questioning 1569
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
Conservation Coalition
Incorporated, KASM
4.16pm Hamish Harwood CRP Questioning
New Zealand marine
mammals and commercial
fisheries – MPI - ISSN 1179-
6480
1572
4.37pm Stephen Christensen
Ngai Tahu Questioning 1585
4.42pm Martin Cawthorn CRP Evidence 1586
4.48pm DMC Questioning 1588
5.03pm Duncan Currie
Greenpeace New Zealand
Incorporated, Deep Sea
Conservation Coalition
Incorporated, KASM
Questioning 1593
5.08pm Eleanor Jamieson The Crown Questioning 1597
5.11pm Stephen Christensen
Ngai Tahu Questioning 1598
5
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
5.15pm DMC Questioning 1599
5.16pm DMC House Keeping 1600
5.17pm Adjourned 1600
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 14 Wednesday 22nd
October 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) Mr David Hill (Member) Mr Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Ms Gen Hewett
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.02am DMC House Keeping 1601
9.05am Jeremy Prebble The Crown House Keeping 1601
9.06am Darran Humpheson
The Crown Evidence - Summary of Evidence
- PowerPoint 1602
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
Presentation
9.11am Jeremy Prebble The Crown House Keeping 1604
9.12am DMC Questioning 1604
9.16am Darran Humpheson
The Crown Evidence continued 1606
9.24am DMC Questioning
continued 1609
9.33am Duncan Currie
Greenpeace New Zealand
Incorporated, Deep Sea
Conservation Coalition
Incorporated, KASM
Questioning 1613
9.45am James Winchester CRP Questioning 1620
9.48am Dr Mike Huber DMC Evidence 1622
10.02am DMC Questioning 1627
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
10.31am
Ruby Haazen Greenpeace New Zealand
Incorporated, Deep Sea
Conservation Coalition
Incorporated, KASM
Questioning 1637
10.38am James Winchester CRP Questioning 1640
11.04am Morning Break 1649
11.24am Stephen
Christensen Ngai Tahu Questioning 1649
11.34am Eleanor Jamieson The Crown Questioning 1651
11.50am Daryl Sykes CRA 6 Rock Lobster
Industry Association PowerPoint Presentation 1657
12.08pm DMC Questioning 1664
12.24pm Break 1671
12.26pm DMC House Keeping 1671
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
12.27pm Gen Hewett 1672
12.29pm Adjourned 1672
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 15 Friday 23rd
October 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) Mr David Hill (Member) Mr Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Ms Gen Hewett, Andrew Crosland
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
11.00am DMC House Keeping 1601
11.01am Robert Goodden Robert Goodden Evidence 1601
11.12am DMC Questioning - 1604
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
11.27am Mac Beggs Mac Beggs Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 1608
11.37am DMC Questioning 1611
11.42am Gareth Hughes Green Party of Aotearoa Evidence 1613
11.57am DMC Questioning 1619
12.01pm DMC House Keeping 1622
12.04pm Adjourned 1622
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 16 Wednesday 29th
October 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) Mr David Hill (Member) Mr Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Ms Gen Hewett, Andrew Crosland
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.24am DMC House Keeping 1624
9.25am Mihi 1624
9.37am Break for Tea and Coffee
- 1624
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.50am DMC House Keeping 1625
9.56am Ray Wood CRP Overview PowerPoint Presentation 1626
10.20am
Ruby Haazen
KASM, Joan Haveman,
Clean Earth, Christopher
Wilkes, DSCC, Greenpeace
New Zealand Incorporated
Evidence
- Legal Submissions
KASM, Greenpeace
and Deep Sea Coalition
- Report of the
Secretary-General of
the International
Seabed Authority under
article 166, paragraph 4
1634
10.57am DMC Questioning 1649
11.04am Phil McCabe Phil McCabe Evidence
- KASM Moratorium
- Phil McCabe Summary
of Evidence
1652
11.19am DMC Questioning 1657
11.23am Morning Break 1659
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
11.46am John Paul Martin John Paul Martin Evidence Evidence 1659
12.07pm DMC Questioning 1667
12.14pm Vera Van der Voorden
Vera Van der Voorden Evidence Evidence 1670
12.48pm DMC Questioning 1682
1.01pm Nora van der Voorden
Nora van der Voorden Evidence Evidence 1687
1.11pm Lunch Break 1691
2.06pm DMC House Keeping 1691
2.10pm Vera Van der Voorden
Swakopmund Matters Evidence Submission with Annexures 1691
2.33pm DMC Questioning 1699
2.41pm Paul Havemann Paul Havemann Evidence Evidence 1701
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
3.04pm DMC Questioning 1708
3.15pm
June Penn on
behalf of Nora Van
der Voorden
Felipe Bonfanti de Barros Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 1713
3.28pm Denise Davis Denise Davis Evidence
- Take the poison from
our water
- Rekohu Rock
Phosphate
1717
3.43pm Timoti Daymond Apirana Daymond Evidence 1722
3.56pm DMC Questioning 1726
4.01pm Adjourned 1727
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 17 Wednesday 30th
October 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) Mr David Hill (Member) Mr Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Ms Gen Hewett, Andrew Crosland
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.04am DMC House Keeping 1729
9.06am Nicole Hancock Nicole Hancock Evidence Evidence 1729
9.23am DMC Questioning - 1736
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.33am Tui Allen Tui Allen Evidence Evidence 1740
9.48am DMC Questioning 1744
9.49am June Penn Linda Silvester Evidence Evidence 1744
9.52am June Penn June Penn Evidence
- Evidence
- Appendix One
- Revenue in Budget
2014 - Executive
Summary Managing a
Growing Economy —
The Treasury - New
Zealand
1746
10.27am DMC Questioning 1758
10.31am Morning Break 1760
11.43am Christine Rose Christine Rose Evidence The TPPA and capital controls 1760
11.47am DMC Questioning 1762
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
11.59am Lennie Johns Closing prayer 1766
12.01 Adjourned 1766
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 18 Tuesday 3 November 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
2.00pm Chair DMC House Keeping 1768
2.08pm Richard Johnson EPA Staff Report House Keeping 1770
2.10pm James Winchester CRP Questioning Topic:
Assessment of available information
1771
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
and adequacy of information
2.27pm DMC EPA
Questioning Topic:
Effects on benthic communities and ecology, including cumulative effects
1774
2.36pm James Winchester CRP
Questioning Topic:
Effects on benthic communities and ecology, including cumulative effects
1779
2.51pm DMC EPA
Questioning Topic:
Sedimentation and plume modelling
1783
2.54pm James Winchester CRP
Questioning Topic:
Sedimentation and plume modelling
1787
2.56pm DMC EPA Questioning Topic: 1788
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
Toxicology and water quality, including radiological risk and microbial groups
2.58pm James Winchester CRP
Questioning Topic:
Toxicology and water quality, including radiological risk and microbial groups
1789
3.07pm DMC EPA
Questioning Topic:
Questioning effects
on marine mammals
1792
3.08pm DMC EPA Questioning Topic:
Sea Birds 1792
3.011pm James Winchester CRP Questioning Topic:
Sea Birds 1793
3.13pm DMC EPA Questioning Topic: 1794
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
Recovery and recolonisation issues
3.22pm James Winchester CRP
Questioning Topic:
Recovery and recolonisation issues
1797
3.23pm DMC EPA
Questioning Topic:
Economic impact on fisheries, including effects on the BPA
1798
3.25pm DMC EPA Questioning Topic:
Effects on Māori and Morori interests
1798
3.32pm James Winchester CRP
Questioning Topic:
Effects on Māori and Morori interests
- 1800
3.39pm Ngai Tahu Amy Hill Questioning Topic:
Effects on Māori and Morori interests
1803
3.42pm DMC EPA Questioning Topic:
Conditions and
1805
5
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
adaptive management
3.52pm James Winchester CRP
Questioning Topic:
Conditions and adaptive management
1808
3.57pm DMC EPA
Questioning Topic:
Any other specific or general questions not covered by those headings
1810
4.02pm Amy Hill Deep Water Group
Questioning Topic:
Any other specific or general questions not covered by those headings
1812
4.04pm James Winchester CRP
Questioning Topic:
Any other specific or general questions not covered by those headings
1812
6
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
4.06pm Adjourned 1814
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 19 Tuesday 4 November 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.01am Chair DMC House Keeping 1817
9.02am John Lawson John Lawson Evidence 1817
9.17am DMC EPA Questions 1821
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.19am Jo Appleyard Deepwater Group and Sanford Limited
House Keeping 1822
9.20am George Clement Deepwater Group Evidence
- Statement of Evidence - Summary of Changes –
Fisheries Certification Requirements version 2.0 – Marine Stewardship Council
1823
9.47am DMC EPA Questions 1832
10.21am James Winchester CRP Questions 1845
10.48am Morning Break 1854
11.06am James Winchester CRP Questions continued 1854
11.36am Hamish Harwood CRP Questions continued
- NZ HOKI surveillance report 120213
- Progress Report on NZ Hoki Action Plan 2013
- MPI-2014 Annual Review Report for Deepwater Fisheries
1865
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
12.02pm Jo Appleyard Deepwater Group Questions 1874
12.06pm Morgan Slyfield EPA House Keeping 1876
12.08pm Doug Paulin Deepwater Group Evidence 1877
12.14pm DMC EPA Questions 1879
12.27pm James Winchester CRP Questions 1884
12.35pm Peter Connolly Deepwater Group Evidence 1887
12.38pm DMC EPA Questions 1889
12.49pm James Winchester CRP Questions 1893
1.00pm DMC EPA Questions 1898
1.01pm Lunch Break 1898
2.01pm Darryn Shaw Deepwater Group Evidence Summary of evidence of Darryn John Shaw
1899
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
2.16pm Jo Appleyard Deepwater Group Questions 1904
2.17pm DMC EPA Questions 1905
2.34pm James Winchester CRP Questions 1912
2.41pm Shane Walls Deepwater Group Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 1914
2.47pm DMC EPA Questions 1916
2.53pm James Winchester CRP Questions 1919
2.57pm Chris Patrick Deepwater Group Evidence 1922
3.07pm DMC EPA Questions 1925
3.14pm James Winchester CRP Questions 1927
5
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
3.15pm Andy Smith Deepwater Group Evidence 1928
3.33pm DMC EPA Questions 1934
3.44pm Hamish Harwood CRP Questions 1939
3.48pm Jo Appleyard Deepwater Group and Sanford Limited
House Keeping 1941
3.49pm Chair DMC House Keeping 1941
3.52pm Adjourned 1942
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 20 Tuesday 5 November 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.01am Chair DMC House Keeping 1944
9.06am Brian Sandle Brian Sandle Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 1945
9.28am DMC EPA Questions 1952
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.34am Break 1954
11.25am Joseph Hassell Joseph Hassell Evidence 1954
11.32am DMC EPA Questions 1956
11.39am Adjourned 1959
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 21 Tuesday 6 November 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Mrs Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.00am Chair DMC House Keeping 1961
9.01am Campbell McKenzie
CRP Evidence Summary of Evidence 1961
9.11am DMC EPA Questions 1965
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.35am Stephen Christensen
Ngai Tahu Questions 1974
9.51am Jo Appleyard Deepwater Group Questions 1981
9.52am James Winchester CRP Questions 1982
9.56am DMC EPA Questions 1983
9.58am Dr Ashley Rowden CRP Evidence
- PowerPoint Presentation
- Dr Rowden Comments on the benthic ecology joint statement
1984
10.47am Morning Break 2000
11.06am Dr Ashley Rowden CRP Evidence continued 2001
11.31am DMC EPA Questions 2010
12.17pm Ruby Haazen DSCC, Greenpeace & KASM
Questions 2028
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
12.27pm Stephen Christensen
Ngai Tahu Questions 2033
12.44pm Jo Appleyard Deepwater Group Questions 2040
12.51pm Lunch Break 2043
1.43pm Eleanor Jamieson The Crown Questions Ocean Survey 20/20 Chatham Benthos
2043
2.40pm James Winchester CRP Questions 2068
2.51pm Dr Paul Krause Deepwater Group, Ngai Tahu, Ngati Kahungunu & Te Ohu Kaimoana
Evidence 2072
2.52pm DMC EPA Questions 2073
3.13am Hamish Harwood CRP Questions 2079
3.26pm Afternoon Break 2084
3.42pm Michael Page CRP Evidence PowerPoint Presentation 2084
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
3.55pm DMC EPA Questions 2088
4.09pm Jo Appleyard Deepwater Group Questions 2093
4.12pm Jeremy Prebble The Crown Questions 2094
4.13pm James Winchester CRP House Keeping 2095
4.15pm Barry Weeber/ Catherine Wallace
Environment and Conservation Organisations of NZ Inc
Evidence Summary of Evidence 2096
4.28pm DMC EPA Questions 2102
4.35pm James Winchester CRP House Keeping 2105
4.37pm Adjourned 2106
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 22 Monday 10 November 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Laraine Thomson
EPA Staff: Andrew Crosland
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
2.46pm DMC Housekeeping 2108
2.48pm Maui Solomon Hokotehi Moriori Trust (HMT)
Representation/ Evidence
Opening Representation on behalf of Hokotehi Moriori Trust
Hokotehi Moriori Trust Presentation and Legal
2108
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
Submission - Appendices
Power Point Presentation
3.57pm DMC Questioning 2131
4.12pm Adjourn 2136
4.28pm Ruby Haazen Environmental Defence Society
Calling Dr Marie Brown
2136
4.28pm Dr Marie Brown Environmental Defence Society
Conditions Summary of Evidence 2136
4.34pm DMC Questioning 2138
5:00pm Mr Harwood Chatham Rock Phosphate Questioning 2149
5.18pm Mr Harwood Chatham Rock Phosphate Housekeeping 2157
5.19pm Adjourn 2157
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 23 Monday 10 November 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Laraine Thomson
EPA Staff: Andrew Crosland
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.40am Ward Kamo Ngati Mutunga o Wharekauri Iwi trust
Welcome 2159
9.58am Break 2159
10.11am Sharon Goodall House Keeping 2160
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
10.13am Chair House Keeping 2160
10.17am Linda Sanders CRP Application overview PowerPoint Presentation 2161
10.40am Gary Cameron PauaMAC4 Industry Association Inc
Questions 2170
10.43am Paula Page & Ward Kamo
Ngati Mutunga o Wharekauri Iwi trust
Evidence 2170
11.05am DMC Questions 2177
11.23am Jeff Clarke Chatham Islands Council Evidence
- Chatham Islands Council
Agenda from July 2014
- Evidence
2184
11.31am DMC Questions 2186
11.39am Gary Cameron PauaMAC4 Industry
Association Inc Evidence 2190
11.48am DMC Questions 2193
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
12.05pm Phillip Ross Christiansen
Phillip Ross Christiansen Evidence 2199
12.07pm DMC Questions 2200
12.11pm Jack Daymond Jack Daymond Evidence 2202
12.23pm Power cut & Lunch 2205
1.28pm Jack Daymond Jack Daymond Evidence continued 2205
1.31pm DMC Questions 2206
1.39pm Jeff Clarke
CRA 6 Rock Lobster Industry
Association Inc.
(CRAMAC 6)
PowerPoint Presentation 2209
1.48pm DMC Questions 2211
1.56pm Ian Maxwell Ian Maxwell 2215
1.58pm DMC Questions 2216
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
2.03pm Gary Cameron PauaMAC4 Industry
Association Inc Questions Evidence 2218
2.05pm DMC
House Keeping 2218
2.07pm Karakea
2219
2.30pm Adjourned
2220
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 24 Monday 17 November 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett, Andrew Crosland
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.00am DMC House Keeping 2222
9.05am Paul Kennedy CRP Evidence - Evidence - PowerPoint
Presentation 2224
9.27am DMC Questioning 2230
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
10.18am Duncan Currie Greenpeace, KASM, DSCC Questioning 2246
10.46am Morning Break 2257
11.05am Stephen Christensen
Ngai Tahu Questioning 2257
11.50am DMC Questioning 2271
11.51am Jeremy Prebble The Crown Questioning 2272
11.57am Andrea Rickard
Deepwater Group,
Ngai Tahu,
Ngati Kahungunu &
Te Ohu Kaimoana
Evidence Supplementary Statement of Evidence
2275
12.36pm Lunch break 2286
1.28pm Andrea Rickard Deepwater Group,
Ngai Tahu, Evidence continued
Supplementary Statement of Evidence
2286
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
Ngati Kahungunu &
Te Ohu Kaimoana
2.22pm DMC Questioning 2300
2.48pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 2309
3.29pm Afternoon Break 2325
3.46pm Christopher Rendall
The Crown Evidence - Statement of Evidence - Attachment One (Table
of conditions) 2325
4.02pm DMC Questioning 2331
4.12pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 2335
4.22pm Urs Signer Urs Signer Evidence 2338
4.32pm DMC Questioning 2341
4.33pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace New Zealand Incorporated, Deep Sea Conservation Coalition
Closing Statement - Closing Statement - Royal Forest and Bird
Protection Society of
2341
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
Incorporated, KASM
NZ Inc v Buller CIV-2013-409-683
5.31pm DMC Questioning 2366
5.39pm DMC House Keeping 2370
5.41pm Adjourned 2370
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 25 Tuesday 18 November 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
9.00am James Winchester CRP House Keeping 2372
9.01am Carmen Taylor CRP Summary of Evidence 2372
9.40am DMC Questioning 2386
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
10.21am Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu Questioning 2402
10.59am James Winchester CRP House Keeping 2415
11.00am Morning Break 2416
11.19am Jo Appleyard Deep Water Group Closing Statement Closing Submission 2416
12.04pm DMC Questioning 2434
12.08pm Peter Anderson Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated
Questioning Carmen Taylor continued.
2436
12.30pm Nicola de Wit EDS Questioning 2447
12.33pm Duncan Currie Greenpeace, KASM, DSCC Questioning 2448
12.35pm James Winchester CRP Questioning 2450
12.37pm DMC House Keeping 2451
3
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
12.41pm Peter Anderson Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated
Questioning Closing Submission 2452
1.21pm DMC Questioning 2469
1.28pm Lunch Break 2474
2.28pm Jeremy Prebble The Crown Closing Statement Closing Submission 2474
3.10pm DMC Questioning 2490
3.22pm Peter Anderson Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Incorporated
House Keeping 2494
3.24pm
Stephen Christensen
Te Runanga o Ngai Tahu
- Closing Submission Attachments
- CRP's Mining Proposal - What Will We Get
2495
4.11pm DMC Questioning 2512
4.14pm Afternoon Break 2512
4
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
4.29pm Nicola de Wit EDS Closing Statement 2513
4.47pm DMC Questioning 2519
4.51pm Adjourned 2521
1
Chatham Rock Phosphate – Marine Consent Application Hearing Proceedings
Day 26 Wednesday 19 November 2014
Decision Making Committee - Mr Neil Walters (Chairperson) Dr Nicki Crauford (Member) David Hill (Member) Lennie Johns (Member) Dr Greg Ryder (Member)
Hearing Manager: Sharon Goodall
EPA Staff: Gen Hewett
Venue: Wellington, Basin Reserve - Norwood Room
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
8.59am DMC House Keeping 2523
9.00am James Winchester CRP Closing Statement Closing Submission 2523
10.21am Morning Break 2553
2
Time Name Representing Topic Exhibit
Ref No#
Documents Submitted / Presented
Transcript Ref.
Page no’s
10.37am Hamish Harwood CRP Closing Statement continued
2553
11.42am Break 2576
11.51am James Winchester CRP Closing Statement continued
2576
12.40pm DMC Questioning 2594
12.49pm DMC House Keeping 2597
12.52pm Mihi & Waiata 2598
12.54pm Peter Jackson June & Peter Jackson Closing 2598
12.58pm Adjourned 2598