crm buyers guide 2013 - crmsearch.comcrmsearch.com/dwn/crm_buyers_guide.pdfcrm buyers guide a...

CRM Buyers Guide

A Comparative Analysis of the Top CRM Vendor Solutions

An independent and objective examination of the Top 10 CRM software systems

delivered via the cloud or software as a service (SaaS) deployment.

Expert analysis by Vantive Media that delivers a balanced review to business and

IT leaders seeking practical and transparent CRM software evaluation.

CRMsearch.com The CRM Software Buyers Guide 2

Table of Contents

Executive Summary ................................................................................. 3

Vantive Assessment ................................................................................. 4

Microsoft Dynamics CRM ........................................................................... 5

NetSuite CRM+ ........................................................................................ 8

Oracle CRM on Demand ........................................................................... 11

RightNow Technologies ............................................................................ 14

Sage CRM .............................................................................................. 17

Salesforce.com ....................................................................................... 20

Salesnet ................................................................................................ 23

SAP Business ByDesign ............................................................................ 26

SugarCRM .............................................................................................. 29

Zoho CRM .............................................................................................. 32

About The Sponsor Vantive Media ............................................................. 35

Additional Analysis, Interim Releases & Reader Comments

This CRM Buyers Guide is published annually.

Due to document size limitations, this advisory is limited to the primary CRM categories of sales,

marketing, service and social CRM. For additional CRM vendor analysis—including categories such

as mobile, hosting, technology, integration, customization, deployment, best fit and alternative

products—visit the CRMsearch.com Vendor Directory and explore the deep dive analysis reviews.

To view the interim updates between releases and as well as the reader questions and

conversations regarding each vendor solution, visit http://www.facebook.com/crmsearch, and

join the Discussion.

A Research Report by Vantive Media exclusively for CRMsearch.com.

© Vantive Media LLC, All Rights Reserved.


Executive Summary

The CRM Buyers Guide is designed to help business and IT managers strike a balance between

the significant time and effort of a formal software selection project and the speed and benefit of

quickly identifying a short-list of CRM solutions most aligned with an organization’s top strategic

objectives.

Generic CRM software rankings identify market share leaders, but are less helpful in procurement

decisions as they provide little to no alignment with any particular company’s objectives or

business situation. However, the purchase process can be accelerated if top CRM solutions are

broken out by differing key criteria, the examination highlights both positive and negative points,

and buyers can self identify with those vendors most tailored to their needs for further

examination.

By identifying the most strategic differences among top rated CRM products, buyers can down

select a manageable group of competing solutions to review in greater depth while balancing the

incremental benefits of deeper evaluation with the costs associated to delayed deployment.

There is little doubt that the cloud CRM industry is in store for some changes. Industry

competition is significantly intensifying, market leaders are no longer matching the growth rates

now achieved by challengers and industry stalwarts that previously sat on the sidelines are now

fully committing.

In fact, while the number of CRM software solutions is increasing, and several vendors are

steadily increasing their market share, careful industry review quickly denotes that there are no

runaway market leaders and no particular vendor dominates in a majority of evaluation

categories. In fact the market is becoming increasingly competitive with a wide array of

impressive solutions delivered from start-ups, stalwarts and software giant’s who have finally

(sometimes reluctantly) embraced the cloud market.

Undeniable market forces, such as social media and social CRM, are creating a new customer

relationship paradigm that forward thinking organizations are taking advantage of. They are

effectively facilitating the organizational transformations from operating as product centric to

customer centric businesses. But make no mistake, companies need to do more than claim they

are customer-centric to be rewarded by customers.

This is no easy change and requires a revamp of business strategy as well as reorganizing

resources, processes and systems. Companies must make customers their focal point and identify

measures that deliver the highest value to customers; from the customers’ perspective. While not

easy, the upside is immeasurable and businesses that can achieve competitive advantages based

on how well they serve their customers will clearly outperform competitors who cling to their

inward structures and product focus.

Organizations that fail to adopt customer centric business strategies will simply lose market share

to those competitors who excel at CRM.

The payback from making an informed purchase decision is significant. When done right, these

technology systems improve marketing campaign performance, increase sales win rates and

boost customer retention.


Vantive Assessment

The CRM Software Cloud Market—A Competitive Landscape Positioning

Mic

ros

oft

CR

M

Ne

tSu

ite

CR

M+

Ora

cle

C

RM

on

D

em

an

d

Rig

htN

ow

Sa

ge

CR

M

Sa

les

forc

e

Sa

les

ne

t

SA

P B

yD

Su

ga

rCR

M

Zo

ho

CR

M

Vendor Cloud � � � � � � � � � � Public Cloud � � � � � � � � � �

Private Cloud � � � � � � � � � �

Hybrid Cloud � � � � � � � � � �

Social CRM � � � � � � � � � �

Quote to Cash � � � � � � � � � �

Workflow Engine � � � � � � � � � �

PaaS Tools � � � � � � � � � �

App Store � � � � � � � � � �

Offline Edition � � � � � � � � � �

BI & OLAP � � � � � � � � � �

SLA � � � � � � � � � �

SAS70 & ISO 27001 � � � � � � � � � �

Price Low High Mid High Low High Mid High Low Low


Microsoft Dynamics CRM

Despite being a late entrant to the on-demand CRM software market, Microsoft has acquired

more CRM customers than any other vendor in its limited period and is using its momentum to

alter the market in terms of platform capabilities, ubiquitous deployment and subscription pricing.

Dynamics retains 8% CRM market share with a trajectory for continued increase. By 2009

Microsoft Dynamics amassed over 1 million users in just over six years; an accomplishment that

took top rivals eight years to achieve. In April 2011, the company announced it has over 27,000

CRM customers making up 1.4 million users. We estimate Dynamics Online has approximately

25,000 subscribers—a low figure but one that is increasing at an accelerated pace.

Microsoft’s product strategy is to deliver a complete CRM suite with accompanying platform

support in a variety of delivery models and at an aggressive price point. For software-as-a-service

(SaaS) CRM, Microsoft has raised the bar by lowering subscription pricing and backing on-

demand software delivery with solid Service Level Agreements (SLAs) complete with financial

guarantees.

The company is clearly on its way to achieving its strategy, but seemingly likes to take the long

way. Even with all its resources and might, the company’s innovation in the CRM industry is not

impressive. The company lags much smaller competitors in key areas such as user experience,

social CRM, mobile CRM, platform as a service (PaaS) and analytics. While Dynamics CRM is a

serious step up and a competitive product, it’s likely that competitors will continue to out-

innovate Microsoft leaving the software giant a follower in many CRM growth areas.

Or perhaps Microsoft will find the will to lead. Microsoft discovers its best innovation when

seriously threatened. Think back to Netscape or Linux or the current threat from Google. Now

consider CRM threats from cloud leaders such as Salesforce.com and open source pioneers such

as SugarCRM.

When seriously threatened, Microsoft shows the ability to rally the troops around a clear vision

and come out on top. The company now shows that type of motivation for the cloud—primarily

with Azure, a cloud platform as a service (PaaS) used to deliver scalable compute, storage and

hosting of web applications from Microsoft datacenters. Whether the company’s traction in the

cloud will carry over to online CRM solutions and market share growth remains to be seen.

Sales Force Automation

Sales Force Automation (SFA) is Microsoft’s core competency and the strongest module in the

CRM suite. Unique ease of use facilitators include a familiar and contextual Windows ribbon bar

for simplified and intuitive navigation, record pinning of key accounts for quick access, a

bookmark of favorites, a listing of recent records accessed, simple user personalization, and an

Outlook client that reduces the need for staff to switch back and forth from their CRM and their

email or groupware programs.

Dynamics most recent CRM release has brought comparable levels of functionality and feature

sets with direct rivals such as Oracle CRM on Demand, Salesforce.com and SugarCRM. Highlights

of the current version which eliminate prior gaps include improved information visualization

(extensive use of rich graphics and inline animation), stepped up business intelligence (including

customizable dashboards built with SQL Reporting Services and delivering real-time display and

drill-down viewing), competitive intelligence analysis (tracking of strengths, weaknesses,

opportunities and threats), and code parity between the on premises and on demand versions.


Marketing Software

Marketing is the weakest module in the Dynamics CRM suite. It provides basic campaign

management, straight-forward integration with SFA and simple reporting. For more advanced

lead management requirements—such as digital marketing, lead acquisitions, lead scoring,

nurture campaigns and rich marketing analytics—a third party product will be necessary.

Fortunately, several Microsoft partners such as Aprimo, Eloqua and Pardot offer integrated lead

management and marketing automation solutions at reasonable costs.

Customer Service

Customer service is advancing with each new version release. Service has also received boosts

from MS Unified Communications Manager, which routes calls and displays inbound caller pop-up

windows as well as accelerators—freely available add-on solutions—such as eService or the

Customer Care Accelerator which aggregates data across disparate applications into a single

desktop view for agents. Interesting from a Microsoft perspective, the Customer Care Accelerator

and other add-ons are freely delivered as open source software solutions from the CodePlex Open

Source Project Community. Unfortunately, support for Accelerator products is a question mark.

Dynamics service is best suited for help desk type environments looking for basic asset control

and case or ticket tracking. Dynamics should be considered for simple call centers; however, with

only basic functionality in areas such as web self service and knowledge management,

sophisticated or high volume contact centers will likely find the service solution limited.

Social CRM

Like many traditional enterprise software publishers who don’t seem to have truly figured out

social CRM, Microsoft is much more talk than walk when it comes to taking advantage of social

media and social CRM. With CRM version 4, the company released a social networking accelerator

to monitor social streams, engage sources and convert social incidents to leads or cases. It was a

start, but limited in scope and social network coverage. Further, it appears accelerators do not

come with support and have questionable implications during upgrades. For its inherit

weaknesses, the social network accelerator provided the beginnings of social listening and follow-

up. Unfortunately, at the time of this writing, an updated version of the social network accelerator

was not yet available. It is expected relatively soon, but no dates are provided.

Mobile CRM

Dynamics Mobile CRM solution is optimized for, and somewhat limited to, the Windows Mobile

platform. To support other mobile devices and platforms, such as the popular Android, BlackBerry

or iPhone, Microsoft takes a lowest common denominator web browser approach. The user

experience for these non-Windows mobile devices is functional but may not satisfy users seeking

a more native Android or iPhone experience.

Offline Operation

To provide SaaS CRM users information when not connected to the Internet, Microsoft uses the

Outlook client as an offline edition. The offline Outlook client functionality is made possible by

utilizing Outlook, a SQL Express database to store the offline CRM data and IIS on the laptop to

render the web pages. The sync process is flexible and permits users to setup local data groups,

apply filters and choose which CRM records should be available offline. The synchronize process

then updates contact CRM data, tasks and appointments.


Dynamics CRM Strengths

Dynamics key differentiators include choice (on-demand or on-premise), value (total cost of

ownership), productivity (seamless integration with other commonly used desktop programs) and

its partner ecosystem. Dynamics customers frequently choose this product for its native Outlook

user experience, quick deployment, flexible tools and affordability. Other key advantages include

the following:

• A top Dynamics CRM strength is its feature rich yet easy to use SFA module. The SFA software optionally operates within an Outlook client and mimics an MS Office

environment promoting a consistent look and feel and increasing ease of use for Windows savvy users.

• Strong Business Intelligence. Flexible wizard-driven inline visualization workspaces, support for PowerPivot and Excel cubes, time-based queries, and easy to create dashboards empower business users to analyze information without IT support.

• Dynamics CRM offers the most flexibility among software delivery alternatives—including

on premises, SaaS or partner hosted. The Dynamics online and on-premise versions

share the same code base thereby also permitting customers to change delivery models.

Further, Dynamics is hosting agnostic, permitting customers to choose among a plethora

of hosting providers or bring the software in house.

• Dynamics includes robust customization and deep platform software integration tools

which collectively increase product flexibility and extensibility while delivering technology

efficiencies. Dynamics CRM highly leverages the MS SQL Server stack, including Reporting

Services for reports, Analysis Services for data warehousing, Windows Workflow

Foundation for business process automation and the .NET framework for integration.

SharePoint integration offers a powerful and integrated content management solution.

Such top to bottom leverage tends to facilitate straight-forward IT efforts in terms of

reducing complexity, time and cost.

• A global CRM solution that provides localized functionality in 40 regions, 41 languages

and covers all the ‘multi’s’ – such as multiple company, multiple currency, multiple

languages and multiple time zones.

• With a combination of impressive features sets and the lowest subscription pricing among

all short listed CRM vendors, Dynamics offers the best value proposition in the market.

Dynamics CRM Weaknesses

� Microsoft’s mobile CRM strategy is to support all devices which can render HTML pages.

This lowest common denominator approach provides wide support, but fails to take

advantage of the unique strengths of any particular device.

� The marketing and customer service modules are improving however do not keep pace

with the SFA module. Fortunately for Microsoft, with the exception of Oracle CRM on

Demand and RightNow, most competitors also do not possess impressive marketing and

customer support functions.

� Microsoft also offers four market leading accounting and enterprise resource planning

(ERP) applications—Dynamics AX, NAV, GP and SL. While front to back office integration

is powerful in delivering company-wide visibility of the customer relationship, such vision

has been hampered. None of the ERP systems are native cloud applications and

integration among Microsoft’s ERP and CRM software systems is available, however, has

always been clunky and unnecessarily complex.

� Microsoft does not provide Dynamics Online coverage for several prominent countries,

such as Argentina, China and Taiwan.

� Dynamics CRM does not provide ubiquitous browser support. CRM only runs on Internet

Explorer 7, 8 or 9, with Windows XP or later.

� The company does not provide sandbox environments for testing or QA.


NetSuite CRM+

NetSuite's product portfolio includes NetSuite (accounting, ERP and CRM suite), NetSuite

OneWorld (multi-company financial consolidation), NetSuite CRM+ and various platform products

such as NS-BOS (a platform as a service development framework).

The NetSuite CRM+ suite includes the traditional CRM pillars of sales, marketing and service, as

well as extended software functionality for sales order processing, incentive management, project

tracking and partner relationship management (PRM). NetSuite’s CRM+ is available as a

standalone front office suite or as part of NetSuite’s integrated e-commerce, accounting and ERP

solution.


The core tenants of Sales Force Automation—account, contact and opportunity management—

cover the basics and are largely undifferentiated from SaaS CRM competitors in terms of feature

sets or flexibility. Where NetSuite does begin to break out from the pack is with capabilities such

as up-sell and cross-sell, quoting, sales order processing and commissions. These capabilities tap

into NetSuite’s back office accounting and ERP software to provide benefits that cannot be

matched by CRM-only solutions.

Back office integration also contributes to one of the most cited objectives for Customer

Relationship Management—the 360 degree view of the customer relationship. When CRM is

integrated with ERP, sales reps view of the customer relationship grows dramatically to include

payment terms, credit limits, available credit, outstanding receivables, purchase history as well as

visibility to transactions such as sales orders, invoices, returns, credits and payments.

NetSuite delivers very strong order to cash process functionality within the context of the CRM

solution. Sale opportunities can be extended to quotes, which can be extended into sale orders.

Back office staff then convert sale orders to invoices. The entire process is seamless, automated

and gives the sales rep complete visibility throughout the order fulfillment stages so that he or

she can close deals, set customer expectations, or take action to avoid disappointing customers.

Customer purchase history can be mined in order to provide highly relevant up-sell and cross-sell

promotions.

Partner Relationship Management (PRM) is tightly integrated to SFA. PRM accommodates joint

campaigns, lead distribution and registration, sales forecasting, sales order processing, and

partner commissions and royalties. Partners are empowered to submit their own sales orders and

the brand owner can automate partner commissions based on the same parameters as employee

commissions, including calculating commission based on sales, quantity, inventory, profitability,

inventory total profit, and more.

Marketing Management

Marketing is too often the weakest of modules with cloud CRM solutions, and NetSuite is no

exception. NetSuite Marketing is largely a tracking function that provides little in the way of

automation. It supports the setup of traditional campaigns, attributes leads by source, distributes

leads based on rules, tracks status and resolution of marketing derived leads, and delivers basic

campaign reporting.

Three marketing functions that are worth mention are NetSuite’s ability to base campaigns on

customer purchase history for up-selling and cross-selling, its ability to leverage expense data

and revenues to calculate ROI for campaigns, and its keyword/PPC (pay per click) tracking. For

this last item, NetSuite campaigns can be integrated with Google adwords to track paid search


campaigns at the keyword level in order to measure leads, conversion rates, conversion costs,

customers, revenue and payback by keyword and search engine.

Customer Service

The customer service module delivers the customary case management functionality of incident

creation, assignment, escalation and closure. Continuing NetSuite’s core strength of back office

integration, customer service representatives (CSRs) can investigate order fulfillment issues,

escalate customer cases to non-customer facing staff such as warehouse or accounting personnel

and use the customers purchase history to improve up-sell and cross-sell opportunities.

Service escalation rules can be configured to make sure that most valued customers receive

prioritized support. Service also tracks time so managers can understand how CSRs are

apportioning their time.

CSRs have access to a basic knowledgebase and customers can access a self service portal which

permits case creation, existing case status and visibility to customer transactions such as sales

order status, shipment tracking or returns processing.

For simple call centers or help desks, service includes basic routing and computer telephony

integration (CTI) with inbound screen pops. More sophisticated contact centers requiring multiple

channel support and advanced contact center functionality such as unified communications,

hosted automated call distribution (ACD), interactive voice response (IVR), call routing based on

workflow rules, call recording and interaction tracking and various other tools essential for contact

center operations will likely not find this service suite adequate.

Social CRM

NetSuite continues to find its way with social media tools. So far the company’s social strategy

has been to integrate with third parties. NetSuite created SuiteSocial, a tool that works with

Yammer and permits users to subscribe to activity streams occurring within NetSuite. For

example, a user can subscribe to a customer, contact, opportunity or other record, and when

those records are updated, the updates will display on the user’s personal landing page. This

solution is of course a replica of Salesforce.com’s Chatter, but at this early stage lacks some

capabilities such as filtering streams in order to separate the ambient noise from the critical

updates. The SuiteSocial solution also doesn’t do anything to engage prospects and customers

who regularly communicate on social networks, thereby missing the potential of social CRM

(SCRM) and failing to contribute to an overarching social strategy objective.

Business Intelligence

NetSuite has strengths and weaknesses when it comes to business intelligence (BI) and analytics.

The dashboards are best in class. They are very configurable, role-based and permit drill-down

for more investigative analysis. The packaged reports are middle of the road. There are plenty of

canned reports and like most systems, customers will likely use a few and ignore the rest. The

company offers a custom report writer. It works for the basics however falls short in terms of

creating reports beyond simple column displays, such as cross-tab or multi-dimensional

reporting. NetSuite does not offer data warehousing or OLAP (online analytical processing), which

is unfortunate as this last form of information analysis is by far the most helpful in terms of

interrogating and modeling volumes of data as well as developing predictive analytics.

Online third party ecosystems are a critical success factor for business apps cloud or SaaS

players. NetSuite’s SuiteApp.com is an evolving marketplace of cloud products, development

tools and services to help NetSuite customers simply and quickly extend their solution and

investment. It doesn’t yet have the momentum of competitors such as Salesforce.com or

Microsoft Dynamics, but it clearly gaining traction.


NetSuite Strengths

• NetSuite’s tight ERP integration delivers a comprehensive 360 degree view of customer

data and interactions, including visibility into financial transactions. Giving sales or

support staff visibility to quotes, orders, invoices, credits, credit limits and outstanding

receivables separates NetSuite from the CRM-only software crowd.

• NetSuite’s order to cash process is second to none in the SaaS industry. The order

fulfillment processes are feature rich and extend throughout the front office CRM suite.

This is particularly helpful for sales teams engaged in order processing as well as making

sure orders get delivered correctly and timely.

• While the majority of NetSuite’s vertical market solutions are largely re-configurations of

the horizontal product, NetSuite’s acquisition of OpenAir in 2007 gives it a very strong leg

up in the highly competitive professional services market. This solution is uniquely strong

and should be considered by IT consultants, legal and accounting firms, government

contractors and other professional services workers.

• The NetSuite OneWorld product provides global business management and financial

consolidation to mid-sized companies with multinational and multi-subsidiary operations.

This solution can be configured to manage multiple subsidiaries, business units and legal

entities from a single NetSuite account and handle the issues such as varying currencies,

languages, tax jurisdictions and global financial reporting requirements. From a CRM

perspective, parent organizations can consolidate or view multi-entity customers, quotas,

forecasts, revenues, campaigns and cases.

• While still a small company, NetSuite is driven by talented management, is fiscally sound

and is growing. Continued execution will make this company a midmarket global player.

NetSuite Weaknesses

� A rather bland user interface doesn’t engage users and contributes to a reputation that

does not include ease of use.

� NetSuite’s offline edition is weak and in need of an upgrade.

� The system incurs high customer support costs. Charging additional recurring fees of

22.5% to 37.5% for users who need to email or speak with help desk representatives is

significantly higher than competitor cloud systems.

� NetSuite gets very mixed reviews in customer service. Customer churn has gotten better,

but remains an issue. Moving customer support to Manila incurred quality issues and it’s

unclear if these have been resolved. NetSuite’s evolution from small business to middle

market, and now to enterprise, has necessitated the publisher to leave smaller, less

profitable or unprofitable customers behind. However, retiring those customers in an

amicable fashion has not been easy.

� An area of frequent customer frustration is NetSuite’s pricing and licensing structure. The

number of product add-ons which require additional fees, and knowing when add-ons are

required, is less than straightforward.

� NetSuite’s emphasis on enterprise-wide software and broad end to end business

processes dilutes product depth, particularly in CRM. The product does not possess the

same level of feature sets and deep functionality as many competing CRM solutions. In

fact, NetSuite often declines to participate in “CRM only” sale opportunities choosing

instead to focus on deals which involve the complete enterprise-wide suite.


Oracle CRM on Demand

With nearly 5 million users and over 5,000 customers in 145 countries using 27 language sets,

Oracle makes its claim as the top CRM software provider. Of course that top position claim is also

made by rival SAP. However, despite their competing claims they both recognize the days of CRM

software mega-purchases are in decline, the enterprise software market is largely saturated and

they must advance to new markets and new revenue streams to keep their growth plans alive.

To continue growth and find new competitive differentiation, Oracle is using its Sun acquisition to

deliver tightly integrated and optimized hardware and software products as well as continuing to

expand its vertical market solutions and its applications business with the long awaited Oracle

Fusion Applications—all of which offer the flexibility to run on-premises, on-demand or both.

When it comes to software as a service CRM, the market has watched Oracle exhibit a near

schizophrenic position regarding the validity and opportunity for software as a service (SaaS) in

the business software marketplace. In fact even after inheriting the Siebel on Demand solution as

part of the 2005 Siebel Systems acquisition, the SaaS product languished with no major upgrades

for 18 months. Nonetheless, despite some initial reservations, Oracle has made up lost time,

secured market share and advanced their Oracle CRM on Demand solution to earn a competitive

leadership position in the cloud marketplace.


CRM on Demand’s sales capabilities are fairly traditional when it comes to account, contact and

opportunity management as well as administrative functions such as calendar and task

management. Forecasting does deliver somewhat advanced functionality in that multiple

simultaneous forecasts can be created using up to four different forecast types across products

and services. However, where the sales force automation software delivers unique value is with

its sales coaching, closed loop lead management and embedded analytics.

The Sales Process Coach is a simple tool to embed process support and even best practices at the

point of execution. At any point in the sales cycle, the application can present relevant

information, enforce the collection of salient data, or automatically create activities for a member

of the sales team. The coaching tool permits sales managers to improve process consistency,

replicate the activities of top performers and deliver virtual sales-stage specific coaching.

Quota management is another effective sales management tool. Sales managers can design

quotas with real time performance visibility to keep sales pros focused on their personal goals.

Quotas can be defined as monthly, quarterly, or yearly goals and managers can prorate quotas

for sales pros joining a plan already in progress. Quota performance visibility includes plan

progress to date compared to closed revenue, expected revenue, and forecasted revenue.

Partner Relationship Management (PRM) is a natural extension to SFA for businesses with indirect

sales channels. The Partner Portal supports key PRM features such as unique themes and layouts

for different partner types, a Solutions repository for content sharing, a tabulation of training and

certifications, deal registration and an approval process for special pricing requests.

The co-op or MDF (Marketing Development Funds) financial management permits brand owners

to budget and approve funds for partners. Based upon configured business rules, partners may

draw down those funds pursuant to automated requests or an approval process. Partners may

then submit claims with proof-of-performance to be reimbursed for approved expenditures. Brand

owners have the ability to control approvals at each step in the process.

Lead management functionality permits brand owners to route leads to internal sales reps,

channel reps or partners. Leads routed to partners can be sent to a named user, an entire partner


organization, or a lead pool consisting of multiple partners that claim leads on a first-come, first-

served basis. Brand owners can monitor distributed leads for follow-up actions or reassign if no

action takes place. Once leads are qualified, partners can convert them to registered deals.

Marketing Software

Marketing is a key strength for Oracle CRM on Demand. As published in separate Vantive Media

advisories, with the exception of RightNow Technologies, most SaaS CRM suites give little

credence to marketing automation making this the weakest component among CRM suites. Oracle

has elevated the marketing function to keep pace with sales and service as well as outpace the

rest of the cloud CRM competitors in this category.

Release 18 delivered advanced lead management and integrated sales and marketing not found

in other on demand CRM suites. In fact for SaaS CRM competitors to achieve comparable lead

acquisition and management capabilities requires a third party product such as Aprimo, Eloqua,

Marketo or Pardot. In reality, these third party lead management solutions may exceed Oracle’s

standard marketing capabilities in some areas so customers must determine just how much

marketing automation is right for them.

Oracle’s lead management stems from its 2010 Market2Lead acquisition and includes tools for

landing pages and microsites, digital prospect tracking, progressive profiling, lead scoring, email

marketing, nurture campaigns, automated distribution of sales-ready leads to the sales team and

marketing analytics. With a single vendor SFA and lead management solution customers achieve

cost savings, tighter integration, a unified revenue pipeline and a single data repository for sales

and marketing reporting.

Customer Service

Service accommodates incident resolution with traditional case or ticket management

functionality. Flexible assignment rules route service requests to designated agents who can then

use scripts or knowledge base access to retrieve solutions. Incident escalations can be flexibly

configured using the workflow tool.

The knowledge base uses search and a solution scoring feature to rank relevance among multiple

answers and help ensure the most useful responses gravitate to the top for future inquiries.

Service pros can add their own solutions to the knowledge base in order to expand the breadth

and depth of the repository over time. Service includes customer satisfaction surveys to monitor

customers’ service experience and ensure that managers receive early warnings to take

corrective actions when necessary.

Social CRM

Oracle has diverse social CRM tools but developing a holistic social strategy and equipping its

various CRM products with social tools is a slow process. CRM on Demand social CRM capabilities

include contact integration with social network streams such as Facebook or LinkedIn through

feeds and RSS subscriptions. This is useful for sales pros that want to keep current with the

online activities of their prospects. The company has released Fusion social apps as well as apps

that run on its enterprise social networking platform. Separate from the CRM On Demand solution

for now, these apps are purpose-built to help salespeople within a company collaborate and close

deals based on shared information. For example, Oracle Sales Prospector searches reams of

sales-data and purchase-history information to guide sales pros to the most likely prospects for a

product or service. It informs salespeople with a graphical view on those potential deals most

likely to close within specific time frames, and estimates the likelihood to close, time to close, and

the expected revenue. It’s an impressive component, but not part of the CRM on Demand suite.

Comparatively speaking, the CRM on Demand product lags other SaaS CRM solutions in the social

category.


Oracle CRM on Demand Strengths

• Oracle is the first SaaS CRM player to embed sophisticated marketing and lead

management automation, including landing pages, digital tracking, lead scoring,

progressive profiling, nurture campaigns and distribution of sales ready leads. Campaign

automation permits marketers to schedule multiple-channel, lights-out campaigns using a

visual business process design tool.

• Similar to Microsoft Dynamics CRM, Oracle On Demand uses Microsoft Outlook or a

mobile device as an offline client to accommodate sales staff who are not in the office or

without Internet connectivity.

• CRM on Demand delivers the best Business Intelligence (BI) suite in the SaaS CRM

industry. Dashboards are configurable and offer drill down for investigative analysis. In

addition to role-based dashboards there are industry editions, such as Insurance and Life

Sciences, as well as Partner Relationship Management (PRM). The Answers on Demand

ad-hoc analysis tool provides users with a solution for creating custom reports, and

includes capabilities such as interactive charts and pivot tables. But where Oracle CRM on

Demand leaves the competition behind is with its data warehousing and OLAP (online

analytical processing). Volumes of data can be reviewed among many dimensions,

manipulated and analyzed in real time for learning and insight that just isn’t going to be

derived from packaged reports.

• Oracle offers choices when it comes to hosting its CRM on demand product. Customers

can take the default multi-tenant option or can elect an upgrade to a single-tenant option

for an increase in price. Further choices among multiple single-tenant versions give

customers flexibility to determine planned maintenance windows and software upgrades

in order to minimize risk and business interruption.

• CRM on Demand offers the best enterprise information security in the cloud CRM industry.

Nearly all cloud CRM solutions employ reasonable security for data in motion, most

notably using the maximum level of SSL encryption permitted by the user’s browser or

geographical location. However, Oracle leverages its database roots in order to add

security layers to data at rest—and permits encryption down to specified columns and

rows or an entire table space. Oracle’s hosting IT infrastructure—including its security

governance, people, processes and tools—is one of the most impressive we’ve reviewed.

These added levels of security will be appreciated by security and data privacy conscience

organizations and industries such as financial services, government and public sector.

• Oracle on Demand offers a compelling total cost of ownership (TCO). Its subscription cost

is one of the lowest in the on demand CRM industry.

Oracle CRM on Demand Weaknesses

� The user interface (UI) and user experience doesn’t compete favorably with SaaS CRM

competitors who have more creatively embraced consumer technologies. While the UI is

efficient and satisfactory, it’s far from engaging.

� The On Demand product lags competitors in social CRM capabilities.

� The Oracle CRM on Demand business partner channel is small and it lacks a mature

ecosystem of third party plug-in solutions. While Oracle is steadily growing their indirect

partner channel, it remains a fraction of what competitors offer to the marketplace.

� Mobile solutions are good, however, support limited devices. The Mobile Sales Assistant

operates on RIM Blackberry and iPhone, while the Mobile Sales Forecast only operates on

the iPhone.

� Certain functions (i.e. Email Marketing) only support the IE browser while others support

only IE and Firefox browsers.


RightNow Technologies

Founded in 1997 and headquartered in Bozeman, Montana, RightNow Technologies (NASDAQ:

RNOW) is the maker of SaaS CRM and customer experience solutions. The company aspires to

help organizations deliver great customer experiences, and in fact, lives by a compelling mantra

to 'rid the world of bad experiences one consumer interaction at a time, 8 million times a day.'

RightNow is recognized as a CRM manufacturer who practices what it preaches. The company

pioneered the concept of a Customer Success Indicator (CSI) in order to measure customer

utilization and then advance and optimize each customer's usage and value from their CRM

software investment.

Interestingly, the company is gravitating away from the ‘CRM’ moniker in favor of ‘customer

experience solutions’. It’s an interesting tact driven by the company’s CEO and supported by a

line of impressive products which run along a continuum from CRM software (including its

traditional pillars of sales force automation, marketing and service) to social CRM tools to

customer experience management (CEM).

Whether this messaging is designed as a positioning statement to find unique ground in a

crowded market or marks an authentic product evolution and positions them to become a new

category leader is not totally clear. However, what is apparent is that while much of the industry

at large would like to evolve to a new moniker, for the good or bad, the customer marketplace

takes comfort with the CRM acronym, the growing $14 billion CRM industry is not a bad place to

be and RightNow continues to play a direct and significant role.


CRM software suites are often born from either sales force automation (SFA) or customer

service—and that origin application becomes the manufacturer’s hallmark —with other modules

arriving later and without the same strength and competitiveness. RightNow was born from

customer service and that aspect of its software is clearly its core competency.

RightNow has a varying history with SFA software. The company developed an SFA system with

mixed results. After failing to gain traction, the company acquired Boston-based SaaS SFA

company Salesnet in May 2006 for $9 million in order to bolster its SFA capabilities. However, a

change in product strategy that deemphasized sales in favor of customer support ultimately

jettisoned Salesnet to become an independent operating unit—headquartered far from Bozeman

in the Atlanta area. Today, Salesnet and RightNow are separate entities with separate

applications that are not integrated. Each company stands on its own and targets its slice of the

CRM software market.

RightNow Sales Automation (SA) is an SFA-like product that accommodates basic account/

contact/activity/opportunity management and delivers standard reporting such as pipelines and

forecasts. Not surprisingly, Sales Automation is closely linked with the contact center. While the

basics of SFA are covered, RightNow is not known for its SFA software, and in fact rarely pursues

software opportunities where SFA is a driver. The RightNow CX application is better positioned

where SFA is a component of a larger customer service or customer experience engagement.

Contact Center Experience

As the software name suggests, the Contact Center Experience is a case driven application

designed to consistently deliver superior customer experiences across phone and multi-channel

interactions. However, the Contact Center Experience is not your typical case driven customer

support application. Sure, it’s designed to record, track, escalate and resolve customer issues,

and as importantly to increase agent productivity, lower costs, and drive revenue through up-sell


and cross-sell opportunities. But while the tactics and mission resemble competitor products and

address management objectives, the methods and tools are much more unique.

Multi-channel support is more than simply creating an incident record from differing channel

sources. Prospects and customers use varying channels and even cross channels mid-stream—

and agents must be able to sync these records, view them in a holistic fashion and leverage all

available information to provide accurate responses. RightNow is particularly strong in its core

capability to assemble all customer interactions in a unified thread to ensure a consistent cross-

channel customer experience.

With a comprehensive customer view, the RightNow technology aids agents with a SmartGuide

troubleshooting tool, SmartAssistant keyword searching, decision-tree style scripts, a rich

knowledgebase, customizable workflow processes and contextual menus and forms. Also, scripts

and guided agent solutions are not just for resolving customer issues, but can be dynamically

applied to facilitate up-selling and cross-selling.

RightNow’s Computer Telephony Integration (CTI) and Interactive Voice Response (IVR) tools are

among the best in the contact center software industry—and are tightly integrated with the

Dynamic Agent Desktop. The Communications Enabled Desktop offers packaged integration to

popular call center tools (such as Avaya, Cisco, Genesys, Interactive Intelligence) for desktop call

control, screen pops, and multi-channel queuing and routing.

Social CRM

RightNow brands their social CRM solutions under the Social Experience product banner. Social

Experience consists of social monitoring and online communities.

The RightNow Cloud Monitor scans social networks and online channels to identify conversations

about your company or its products taking place on Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, your RightNow

online community, and other RSS feeds from the blogosphere, so you can listen, join the

conversation and engage customers.

Sometimes called social listening, the Cloud Monitor permits brand owners to discover where their

prospects and customers are talking about them—and what they’re saying. With this information,

businesses can learn from customer sentiment and then respond intelligently. Social monitoring is

also helpful for voice of the customer (VOC) programs. The social web spurs many conversations

that can help or harm your brand. Only when you know of these conversations can you influence

the outcomes.

RightNow online communities consist of Support Communities and Innovation Communities. Support Community is an online peer-to-peer community tool to help customers help each other.

The Support Community includes important functions such as a reputation engine to reward

customer participation and expertise, Q&A pairs, moderation intervention, escalation rules and

single sign on. Integration points with RightNow's Agent Desktop and Customer Portal, and

syndicated widgets, contribute to a smooth transition across channels.

Innovation Community harnesses the ideas of your most vocal, loyal and opinionated customers

into organized ideation and innovation processes. Customers are both knowledgeable and critical

about the products and services they buy and use. Channeling their enthusiasm and opinions in a

jointly constructive manner can help you prioritize and refine ideas, improve your products,

identify new products or business opportunities, guide your product roadmap and maybe lead you

to the next breakthrough product—all while reducing R&D time and cost.

The missing social component for RightNow is an internal collaboration platform that brings

together social streams in a secure, private environment.


RightNow Strengths

• RightNow is a market leader for B2C and B2B companies seeking customer service and

support CRM applications. The company’s products excel in multi-channel support, case

management, knowledge management and overall customer experience management.

• Strong social and collaborative tools permit businesses to create customer and partner

communities, promote user to user engagement, attain information from social networks

and social streams, and configure mash-ups to merge data from multiple sources.

• The dynamic agent desktop steps agents through tasks and customer interactions to

deliver guided assistance through a series of progressively more detailed questions and

answers which systemically direct agents to the most appropriate resolutions in the

shortest time. If resources become exhausted, very flexible escalation and routing rules

aid seamless transitions to successive tiers of support. When complete, satisfaction

surveys can conclude the process automation, or flag an incident believed to be closed as

dissatisfied and escalate the issue as appropriate.

• Despite a weak sales force automation (SFA) function, the marketing software is

impressive with deep functionality and notable predictive analytics.

• The Natural Language Search gained from the Q-go acquisition offers a unique best-in-

class semantic search technology. The natural language search applies algorithms against

industry specific linguistic dictionaries and local language sets to decipher query intent

and return more relevant responses.

• The application offers unique voice enablement capabilities. A suite of voice-enabled CRM

products include a voice interface to knowledge base, incident management, locator,

status applications, password reset, survey, and one number routing. This has particular

value for government and public sector section 508 disabilities compliance.

• Multi-national companies concerned with global online performance (i.e. latency, jitter,

packet loss, etc.) or data at rest location may find advantages as RightNow hosts its CRM

software from five data centers in four countries and three continents. From a

performance standpoint alone, customers in areas such as Australia and New Zealand

suggest data center location is influential in their decision making.

RightNow Weaknesses

� An uneven CRM software suite. Sales force automation (SFA) is not nearly as strong as

service.

� No offline client is available to access the application or at least limited data while

disconnected from the Web.

� No third party ecosystem or online marketplace of integrated third party products.

� A smart/fat client technology and heavy client side downloads are not conducive to thin

client, browser-based, software maintenance-free computing.

� RightNow’s messaging to throw CRM under the bus does a disservice to the industry and

customers. Citing high CRM software failure rates and trying to carve out a new category

confuses the market. Yes, CRM software failure rates have been historically high and

they’re not coming down fast enough or far enough, but they are coming down and the

CRM industry is a growing $14 billion industry in large part because of the immense value

it providers in building customer relationships.


Sage CRM

Sage CRM is used by over 10,000 organizations and 3.1 million users in 70 countries in both on-

demand and on-premise deployments, making it a strong contender in the small and midsize

business CRM market. Sage Group, with its broad portfolio of CRM, ERP and business software

products, retains over 6.3 million customers worldwide.


The SFA user interface is comprehensive without being intimidating. It’s a classic browser-based

interface with tabs across the header, navigation menus with images down the left margin and

good use of flexible panels to display key metrics such as account lists, opportunities, tasks or

calendar appointments. The dashboard panels are better than many CRM competitors—they are

customizable by user, display a mix of table and chart views, permit in-panel navigation (such as

searching, page sequencing or taking record actions) and most permit drill-down to view

expanded data sets. The UI clearly maximizes ease of use and minimizes user learning curves.

Unfortunately, there is a functional gap between the CRM on-demand and on-premise editions.

The Sage CRM on-demand Advanced Edition is missing useful feature sets such as the interactive

dashboards, keyword search, customer self service, importing and exporting from Excel, and user

administrative management capabilities such as user password policies, field level scripts, table

scripts, and the component manager used for adding new entities.

The CRM on-demand Standard Edition is further missing the marketing and customer service

modules—limiting this edition to contact management and standalone departmental use.

Customers can grow from the Standard Edition to the Advanced Edition when they are ready to

achieve cross-departmental or organizational CRM objectives such a 360 degree customer view.

As Sage is one of the top two SMB accounting and Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) software

vendors, it’s no surprise that its CRM software offers advantages in sharing back-office data with

customer facing staff. Both the on-premise and on-demand software versions support quotes and

sale orders with integration to product management. The On-Premise CRM edition displays

additional customer information such as orders, invoices and receivable agings as well as

inventory information. Unfortunately, these back-office data points are not delivered with the On-

Demand CRM software.

Marketing Software

As is common in the SaaS CRM software industry, the Sage CRM marketing software is light. It

includes basic campaign management functionality such as campaign profiles with various

attribute information, simple budgeting, customer segmentation, list management and target list

generation, dynamic and static group management, broadcast email distributions, mail merging,

document drop capabilities, outbound call handling and basic campaign reporting.

The release of Sage CRM version 7.1 upped the marketing capabilities, to include enhanced email

marketing, such as email campaigns with a new 3 step marketing wizard, new web forms for

collect reader feedback, over 90 email templates to draw from, advanced scheduling of email

distributions and a results tab for displaying email delivery metrics such as emails opened,

clicked-through and bounced.

The marketing software is largely a campaign tracking function that provides little in the way of

marketing process automation. The marketing application is missing some fundamental

functionality such as PPC (Pay Per Click) integration and flexible lead distribution.


Customer Service

The customer support software provides customary case management functionality of incident

creation, assignment, escalation and closure. Case listings display incident severity along with a

color coded indicator signifying conformance or risk of non-compliance with service level

agreements. The case management process is streamlined for heads down data entry efficiency,

permits flexible escalation rules and includes a keyword-based knowledge base for search and

resolution assistance. A customer self-service portal is available for incident creation, status

monitoring and access to pre-defined content.

For simple call centers or help desks, the On Premise edition includes basic routing and computer

telephony integration (CTI) with inbound screen pops. More sophisticated contact centers

requiring multiple channel support and advanced contact center functionality such as unified

communications, automated call distribution (ACD), interactive voice response (IVR), call routing

based on workflow rules, call recording and interaction tracking and various other tools routinely

used in contact center operations will likely not find this customer support software adequate.

Social CRM

The Sage CRM dashboards include a panel to retrieve LinkedIn contact information for prospects

or customers. Sage uses simple social feeds to display social content such as contact information

from Twitter and LinkedIn profiles embedded in an I-Frame. More advanced social CRM tools such

as social monitoring, peer to peer online communities, internal or private social networks and

flexible social networks integration are not available with Sage CRM.

SageCRM versus Sage SalesLogix

Sales prospects continue to have some difficulty in deciphering the target market and product

differences between SageCRM and Sage SalesLogix, and determining which product is better

suited for their needs. Both products address an overlapping small and midsize business (SMB)

customer market and are available on premise or in the cloud, so identifying more specific

criterion are necessary.

SageCRM.com is a more globally friendly CRM solution. It’s offered in more languages and

outsells SalesLogix on a global basis. It’s also more cloud friendly, with a multi-tenant

architecture, native thin client delivery and an underlying develop environment using multiple

web languages including Java/JavaScript.

SageCRM possesses a smaller functional footprint than SalesLogix, and therefore often caters to

the smaller half of the SMB market, while SalesLogix steps up to accommodate larger middle

market businesses. SageCRM is also positioned as part of an integrated suite which includes

Sages ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) products. In fact, SageCRM offers packaged integration

with Accpac ERP, Sage MAS90 ERP, MAS200 ERP, Sage 100 (France), Sage 1000 (UK), Classic

Line (Germany) and Office Line (Germany). For Sage customers with these ERP software

solutions, SageCRM should be the first CRM system to review.

SalesLogix is the North America flagship product and outsells Sage CRM in the U.S.—Sage’s

largest market. SalesLogix typically targets middle market customers with 50 to 500 user seats,

and is also a popular choice for divisions of enterprise companies. The product is known for

deeper functionality, more configuration options and is more readily adaptable to software

customization. While SalesLogix CRM integration to back office ERP software products can be

accommodated, it is not delivered with the same near seamless bundling as is SageCRM.

SalesLogix can be delivered in the software as a service model, as a single-tenant CRM

application hosted on the Amazon EC2 public cloud. However, SalesLogix is more ‘cloud-enabled’

than cloud native. SalesLogix is better suited for companies seeking best of breed CRM

functionality without needed integration to back office Sage ERP products.


Sage CRM Strengths

• Sage Group plc is a strong and viable company with a 30 year track record, making it a

relatively safe buy.

• SageCRM.com is a low cost, low risk and quick to deploy CRM solution.

• The SageCRM user interface is easy to learn and easy to use. Information and feeds from

within Sage CRM, other websites and integrated Sage ERP systems can be displayed in

real-time in a single workspace or through dashboards.

• Sage CRM offers choice in both hosted and on-premise deployment models. Because both

deployment models use the same CRM code set, customers can also migrate from one

delivery option to the other.

• Packaged integration between SageCRM.com and Sage ERP products enables cross-

departmental and end to end business process support. This is particularly helpful for

sales reps and CRM staff that generate quotes, take sale orders or require access to back-

office customer or financial information.

• The Solo offline synchronization solution works well for users who travel or reside in

locations with sketchy Internet connections. With Solo, the user can download their

SageCRM.com database, work offline, and synchronize with their updates when they re-

establish Web connectivity.

• The product suite includes a useful Workflow Management function, however, only the

On-Premise CRM edition grants the more powerful workflow functions such as the ability

to run escalation rules, SQL statement executions, stored procedure actions, custom

scripts or workflow previews. Without these capabilities in the On-Demand CRM editions,

workflow is very limited.

Sage CRM Weaknesses

• Narrow feature sets, particularly in the marketing and customer support software

modules, limit the CRM application to small and midsize businesses.

• A lack of social CRM tools will hinder companies looking to leverage social monitors and

engage prospects and customers in social networks and other online social channels.

• The Sage CRM brand is not well marketed and is not a strong brand—particularly in the

U.S. This may result in Sage CRM continuing to fall behind cloud CRM competitors such as

Microsoft Dynamics CRM, Oracle CRM on Demand, Salesforce.com and SugarCRM.

• A single data center location in Dublin inherits risk of downtime. Most SaaS CRM vendors

operate multiple, live production data centers in parallel, with active/active data exchange

between them for real-time fail-over in the event of disaster or business interruption.

• Sage mobile CRM takes a lowest common denominator approach which only delivers

HTML and JavaScript to the user's web browser. This facilitates usage across mobile

devices, however, fails to take advantage of any particular mobile operating system or

device. This approach may be helpful to IT shops wanting to support multiple mobile

devices for their staff, however, will likely result in push back from users who have

become accustomed to the native user experiences provided by their Blackberrys,

iPhones and Androids.


Salesforce.com

Salesforce.com is both the pioneer and poster child for the SaaS CRM movement. Founded in

1999 in a small San Francisco apartment, the company has become the category leader that

other on-demand CRM providers seek to challenge. Because of its current size, it no longer leads

the industry in terms of revenue growth, however, in absolute terms of SaaS revenues, customer

acquisitions and user subscriptions the company is the clear market share leader.

Salesforce.com has steadily been transitioning from a best of breed sales force automation (SFA)

software as a service (SaaS) provider to an application development platform as a service (PaaS)

company. The cloud company leads the combined SaaS and PaaS markets with a consolidated

offering that includes a SaaS CRM application, an online storefront (AppExchange) of integrated

third party applications and a suite of platform development tools and technologies. The company

has markedly been successful in both strategy and execution for over a decade.

Sales Cloud

This cloud most notably includes the sales force automation (SFA) module—the company’s

namesake solution which was its first product introduction and continues to represent the highest

revenue contribution. SFA functionality is not materially different than other SaaS CRM products.

In fact, in many areas it has fewer feature sets than several competitors. However, what makes

this solution competitive and gives it differentiation in a crowded market is its simple and

rewarding user experience. The application user interface (UI) is uncomplicated, intuitive and

leverages consumer technologies. This is an innovative UI that was designed to satisfy users, and

not data management goals. Several CRM competitors are steadily mimicking the Salesforce.com

user experience in their own CRM applications, however, nobody has matched the original at this

point.

Sales includes traditional account/contact/activity/opportunity management along with basic

marketing campaign management. Unfortunately, marketing is limited to basic subsets of SFA.

Marketing includes simple campaign capabilities such as account segmentation, target list

generation, lead source tracking and packaged reports. Salesforce.com marketing is competitively

weak in the SaaS CRM industry. To achieve lead management or marketing software capabilities

such as digital prospect tracking, lead scoring, progressive profiling, nurture campaigns or rich

marketing analytics requires a separate product acquisition. Many Salesforce.com customers

revert to third party marketing automation software products from vendors such as Aprimo,

Eloqua, Marketo or Pardot.

Sales Cloud also includes basic Partner Relationship Management (PRM). This application sync’s

communication between brand owners and indirect channels and gives brand management

performance visibility into both direct and indirect channels. PRM includes routine process support

for lead distribution, deal registration, content sharing, partner attribute data tracking and

partner portals. Unfortunately, more advanced PRM functions such as partner capacity planning,

lead routing based on partner scoring, approval processing for special pricing requests,

automated partner approved discount thresholds, co-op or MDF (Marketing Development Funds)

financial management, partner reimbursement for approved expenditures, configure/price/quote

(CPQ), partner sales order processing and the like are not available.

While PRM delivers process consistency, automation and information in largest part for brand

owners, actual implementation is a double edged sword. Delivering PRM through the cloud

removes the need for partners of varying sophistication and resources to deploy hardware,

software and staffing simply to communicate with their brand providers. Nonetheless, getting

partners to actually use the brand owners PRM system, particularly when they already have their


own CRM system, is a significant cultural challenge that often trumps good intentions.

Salesforce.com PRM is therefore ideally suited for partners who already use Salesforce.com.

Service Cloud

As the growth of online SFA has slowed, Salesforce.com looks to customer service as the next

billion dollar opportunity. This cloud focuses on customer service delivery, is designed around

traditional case management processes and includes key support features such as live chat,

knowledge base, customer portal, online communities and industry-best social tools.

The Service Cloud allows agents to answer questions on a company’s Facebook page as well as

convert Facebook wall posts and comments into cases within Service Cloud. The same

functionality exists for Twitter and allows agents to create cases and share knowledge from

Tweets and conversations. Service Cloud 3 allows companies to embed the Social Agent into their

web site for live chat between agents and customers.

Service Cloud best fits B2B (Business to Business) contact centers seeking to reduce labor

intensive human services with more diversified—and more timely and less expensive—channels

such as customer self service, online communities, public knowledge-bases and crowdsourcing.

Social tools such as Chatter, Ideas, Answers and social network integration provide new methods

and channels for engagement between agents and customers. The soon to be included Radian6

will add additional value in social monitoring and give Salesforce.com uplift in more automated

social customer engagement over more channels.

Service contracts and entitlement capabilities can align customers with designated levels of

service. However, this functionality will generally fall short for inventory-carrying organizations

whose service contracts must specify product SKUs or who require serial and lot tracking, product

registration, warranty management or service level agreements.

Social CRM

Salesforce.com continues to demonstrate innovation with its social media and social CRM

releases.

Salesforce.com’s approach to social media is to embed tools and capabilities within its platform

and application software. The result is that social is both synergistic and indistinguishable from

the core applications. Making social integral to core systems, as opposed to linking or integrating

to third party social products, delivers a more seamless user experience and avoids the risk of

layered complexity.

Chatter was released in June 2010 as a real-time internal collaboration platform that brings

together people and data in a secure, private social environment. Rather than making people

search for data and documents, information is proactively fed to them via a real-time activity

stream. Users can subscribe to follow important sale opportunities, top customer accounts, open

support cases and other coworkers to receive broadcast updates as they occur. Users can form

groups and post messages on each others' profiles to collaborate on projects and even subscribe

to Twitter and Facebook feeds to track comments about the company or a prospect.

Salesforce.com Ideas is an online community application that allows members to submit, discuss

and promote ideas and empowers the community organizer with the frequently cited but seldom

achieved wisdom of the crowds. Participants can comment, share, rank and vote on ideas. What

Ideas lacks in collaboration and functionality when compared to standalone ideation tools, it

makes up in integrating the experience with the rest of the CRM suite. This is useful tool for

companies which seek to harvest user generated content for innovation and other purposes.


Salesforce.com Strengths

• The company is a proven innovator. This strength alone separates Salesforce.com from

much of its competition and provides increased payback for customers.

• Salesforce.com promotes a vibrant user community. The company uses its own Ideas

solution to solicit community input, actively monitors social networks and provides online

venues for customers to make themselves heard. Too often CRM companies don’t actually

practice the Customer Relationship Management they speak of; however, Salesforce.com

clearly walks the walk.

• The Salesforce.com UI maximizes consumer technologies to deliver a simple and

rewarding user experience. This has delivered a profound effect in achieving user

adoption.

• The company’s combination of Force.com, PaaS tools and AppExchange lead the SaaS

CRM industry in terms of cloud integration, software customization and third party

extensibility.

• The Visual Process Manager creates workflows and approvals to deliver greater control

over routine activities, eliminate redundant tasks, automate approvals, and encourage

widespread adherence to your business processes. This is a useful tool to reduce manual

activities and improve process consistency.

Salesforce.com Weaknesses

� As Salesforce.com continues its transition from a CRM company to a platform company,

several CRM competitors have superseded Salesforce’s CRM features, functions and

capabilities.

� Salesforce.com marketing is competitively weak in the SaaS CRM industry. To achieve

lead management or marketing capabilities such as digital prospect tracking, lead

scoring, progressive profiling, nurture campaigns and rich marketing analytics requires a

separate product acquisition. Many Salesforce.com customers turn to third party

marketing automation software products from vendors such as Aprimo, Eloqua, Marketo

or Pardot. Salesforce has haphazardly tried to position Radian6 as the basis for a

Marketing Cloud, but such positioning is not credible and satisfies few or none of the

previously listed lead management or marketing automation requirements.

� Salesforce.com is also without sophisticated business intelligence (BI). Customers seeking

data warehousing, data mining, online analytical processing (OLAP) or predictive analytics

will be required to procure third party solutions from AppExchange or elsewhere.

� Despite an initial thrust in the small business market, small business customers

repeatedly opine that professional services options are few and extremely costly. For

small businesses that require software customization, system integration or other

professional services, the lack of channel options, combined with the lack of desire for

smaller projects by the few partners available, leave this segment without many options.

� When reviewing features to features its apparent that Salesforce.com is the highest

priced product in the SaaS CRM industry.

� Salesforce.com becomes less competitive when looking beyond CRM as a point solution.

For companies seeking broader business software suites, including back office accounting

or ERP systems, the inconsistency and relatively shallow integrations delivered with third

party AppExchange vendors do not stand up well to single vendor solutions from

competitors such as NetSuite and SAP Business ByDesign.

� Surprisingly, Salesforece.com generally doesn’t provide a Service Level Agreement (SLA)

unless the customer negotiates it. Even then, the SLAs are inconsistent from customer to

customer and fall below uptime guarantees of primary SaaS CRM competitors.


Salesnet

Salesnet is a RightNow Technologies (Nasdaq: RNOW) independent operating unit and provider of

cloud CRM software solutions for small and midsize businesses.

Founded in 1997, and beginning production operations in 1999, Salesnet was one of the original

SaaS CRM pioneers that has since taken an unconventional company evolution. In May 2006,

Salesnet was acquired by RightNow Technologies for $9 million in an effort to shore up

RightNow's sales force automation offering. However, a waning interest in the B2B market and a

steady change in product strategy by RightNow that de-emphasized SFA in favor of customer

support and customer experience jettisoned Salesnet in September 2008 to become an

independent operating unit—headquartered far from Bozeman, Montana in the Atlanta area.

Salesnet was transitioned to a new joint venture to be managed by a prior Salesnet partner, SFA

Strategies. The partner turned publisher had been a Salesnet VAR since 2003, and was clearly

one of the most credible and largest distribution partners for the former Salesnet.

Since the change in management, the new Salesnet continues to stand out for delivering powerful

sales force automation software but has also placed new emphasis on an enhanced user interface

(UI) and improved user experience. Combined with additional upgrades delivered in the most

recent release, such as enhanced analytics, workflow improvements and a revamped Outlook

integration, the company is better positioning its solution for more mature sales users and

organizations—that is customers who are looking to go deep within sales and marketing as

opposed to staying broad across a wider software suite.


Sales force automation is the single greatest core competency of Salesnet. The SFA product is

feature rich and designed to facilitate and enhance effective sales processes and best practices.

Salesnet SFA strikes a good balance between ease of use and a wide suite of features, and in turn

is clearly one of the more well received SFA applications by sales people. A 'Keep It Simple'

approach enables good configuration selection while at the same time permits much of the

unused functionality for a particular customer to remain out of sight, and consequently out of

mind.

The Process Builder workflow automation tool is particularly strong for ensuring consistent sales

processes are applied to each account and sale opportunity. This tool is also quite flexible and

allows administrators or sales managers to define different processes for different sales reps or

mix processes based on the sale opportunity. Process Builder also allows managers to grant

usage based on workflows specific to each position, team or user. Applying best practices and

consistent sales processes to every sale opportunity is often the single greatest method sales

staff and sales managers can do to increase the sales win rate. Salesnet's strong facilitation in

this area makes it a clear SFA leader.

On the downside, win/loss analysis is light and competitive analysis is missing. The only other

functional component missing in the SFA software is the ability to create quotes.

The sales reporting is more deep than broad but covers all the basics and provides good pipeline

and forecast reporting. A unique and helpful feature that we don't see in other CRM systems is

the Report Snapshots—which record point in time snapshots of your subtotal report outputs and

make the comparison to prior periods or historical data a whole lot easier. In fact, the

comparisons viewing can contrast two report snapshots in a color-coded comparison report to

gain an easy visual perspective on how your sales pipeline is changing.


Offline access to CRM information is achieved with an offline client. This permits users to access

and update their CRM records while offline and then synchronize to the central system when

Internet connectivity is re-established. Users have full flexibility to add, edit, and delete accounts,

contacts, opportunities (including opportunity steps), notes, appointments and tasks. The offline

client uses a lightweight MSDE database; however, a scheduled upgrade plans to convert to the

SQL compact/express database. This next version upgrade also plans to encrypt the CRM data on

the laptop or mobile device.

Marketing Software

Like most SaaS CRM marketing software modules, the marketing application revolves around

campaign management with campaign profiles including user-defined attributes, target list

generation with account segmentation, broadcast email distributions, mail merging and basic

campaign reporting. Simple budgeting and actual cost data provide the basis for campaign level

financial performance and ROI calculations while response rates and conversion factors deliver

campaign effectiveness reporting.

Campaign list generation can be applied to leads, contacts or opportunity record sets. Email

documents may be created from templates and a rich text HTML editor within the application. For

compliance with the CAN-SPAM act, users can create unsubscribe forms for opt-out responses.

The Salesnet XDC (eXternal Data Capture) can be used as a flexible web-to-lead form to

automatically transfer website inquiries into the leads database. This tool also permits

configurable lead routing, client redirection and assignment options. Campaign generated leads

can be maintained in a queue and assigned to sales reps via round robin or other sequencing.

The marketing software is missing some fundamental functionality such as PPC (Pay Per Click) or

Adwords integration and email response metrics such as open, click and bounce rates.

Salesnet Pricing

The Salesnet CRM product is bundled in two editions—Standard and Enterprise.

The Salesnet Standard edition is priced at $30.00 per user per month. This bundle includes the

flagship sales force automation product along with most tools, including the Process Builder,

Outlook integration, dashboards, reporting and more. Software feature sets not included in the

Standard Edition, but offered in the Enterprise Edition, can be individually purchased with the

Standard Edition if desired.

The Salesnet Enterprise edition is priced at $70.00 per user per month, and offers additional

feature sets such as the leads database, marketing software, offline client, mobile CRM, external

forms to capture and insert records and the API. The Enterprise edition also includes telephone

support.


Salesnet CRM Strengths

• An easy to use sales force automation (SFA) system with impressive business process

automation, mobile CRM support and reporting.

• A feature rich CRM system capable of supporting business requirements of middle market

companies.

• Business process automation is uniquely strong in Salesnet. The Sales Process Workflow

System is perhaps the most impressive workflow design tool among SaaS CRM solutions.

It's also distinctive enough that it's backed by its own patent. Workflow processes can be

created by non-technical staff using a simple structure of steps and activities. This is a

powerful tool for both tailoring and automating business processes in order to achieve

improved consistency, reduced cycle times and better staff productivity.

• Mobile CRM permits users to access their sales and marketing data regardless of location.

Salesnet mobile CRM helps remote staff manage leads, accounts, contacts, opportunities,

appointments and tasks using their smart phone with any standards-compliant browser.

• Offline access to CRM information is achieved with an offline client. This permits users to

access and update their CRM records while offline and then synchronize to the central

system when Internet connectivity is re-established. Users have full flexibility to add,

edit, and delete accounts, contacts, opportunities (including opportunity steps), notes,

appointments and tasks.

• A quick to deploy CRM software system.

• A unique alternative when your CRM requirements go beyond data management and

focus on business process automation.

• A flexible CRM software company, willing and able to accommodate customer requests

and deliver packaged or custom professional services.

Salesnet CRM Weaknesses

• A lack of social CRM and social media tools.

• No support for quotes or sale order processing.

• No customer service module.

• No data center hosting service level agreement (SLA).

• Salesnet faces significant competition from large and mature CRM software technology

companies such as Salesforce.com, Microsoft Dynamics CRM, Oracle and SugarCRM.

Carving out the unique space or niche markets where it will surpass these competitors

remains a work in progress.


SAP Business ByDesign

With its on-premise SAP CRM product, SAP is arguably the CRM software industry leader. Of

course, Oracle would take that argument as the two companies point to differing criteria and

sources for each to assert their top leadership position. Something else these two software titans

have in common—they both delayed their entry into the software as a service market, however

are now moving full steam ahead to make up lost ground. SAP seeks to expand CRM market

share in the cloud with its on-demand solution, Business ByDesign.

SAP Business ByDesign is an enterprise-wide ERP and CRM system that facilitates end to end

integration for key business functions such as financials, human resource management, supply

chain management, project management, compliance management and customer relationship

management.

Whether hedging its bets or accommodating diverse customer interests, SAP demonstrates a split

vision when it comes to the cloud. With Business ByDesign, SAP is showing it is fully committed

to multi-tenant, enterprise-wide apps delivered over the Web, consumed with a browser and

purchased with a subscription pricing model. No cloud ambiguity here. However, with its more

recent Sales On Demand solution, and the expanding On Demand line of business applications,

SAP is delivering cloud extensions to on-premise business software systems. The hybrid

environment can certainly make sense for many organizations, but how the two cloud strategies

come together and impact the longer-term product road map for each as well as Business Suite 7

remains unclear.

Most SaaS CRM solutions originate from either SFA or service and subsequently build out the

remaining suite. If born from SFA, they often possess strong sales process support, however,

customer service is an after-thought and comparatively weak—or vice versa if the CRM suite

originated with service. Business ByDesign bucks this trend by providing a more balanced CRM

suite. This should serve well for customers seeking CRM across all of their customer facing

departments.


Core sales processes such as account/contact/activity/opportunity management are straight-

forward and in line with nearly all competitors CRM solutions. However, SAP leverages its back

office ERP capabilities to enhance sales functions that cannot be matched by CRM-only

competitors. Sales staff can create quotes, verify product availability, process sales orders,

identify up-selling and cross-selling opportunities and review customer invoices. Clearly having

visibility to more customer information such as terms, credit utilization and outstanding

receivables delivers a more comprehensive customer view to the sales team.

System support functions such as approval processing can be linked to transactions such as

quotes, orders and invoices in order to manage customer pricing and permitted discounts—tasks

that can consume many hours of sales management time and contribute to longer process cycles

when left to manual methods. The sales module does a good job in dynamically linking

communications channels such as the phone, email or instant messaging with context-related and

task-oriented business activities.


Marketing is broadly divided into the two management functions of market development and

campaign management. Market development facilitates market information management,

competitor intelligence and project management for marketing programs. The market

development functionality is not particularly deep, but nonetheless delivers useful marketing

management tools that are largely absent in even the SaaS CRM-only competitors. Campaign


management includes account attributes, segmentation, target list development, campaign

measurement and integration with sales force automation. It covers the basics.

An unfortunate reality in the SaaS CRM competitive landscape is that marketing generally lacks

sophistication and gets the short stick when compared to sales and service. Business ByDesign

doesn’t show such an obvious disregard for marketing and delivers solid functionality. If SAP

chooses to advance marketing, with functions such as automated lead management, lead scoring,

nurture campaigns and improved analytics, is could compete for category leadership in this area.

Customer Service

Customer service is organized around customer care, field service and entitlement management.

Customer care is primarily a case management function with basic incident assignments,

escalation rules and some knowledge management. Field service is unique among SaaS CRM

service solutions and includes service and repair tracking, spare parts handling and customer

confirmations. This is another function facilitated by strong back office integration; however,

unless and until it incorporates technician dispatch and at least some level of workforce

management, it is limited to simple field service shops. Entitlement management is another

somewhat unique feature and quite useful for inventory carrying organizations, particularly those

will serial and lot tracking, product registration, warranty management or service level

agreements.

The collaboration window is the central communications hub that links Business ByDesign with

desktop applications, instant messaging and telephone systems. While helpful throughout the

CRM suite, it is particularly useful for customer service representatives (CSRs). With computer

telephony integration, customer calls are routed and deliver inbound screen pops, complete with

caller identification and customer data points, to the receiving CSR. The service representative

can initiate a case, service order or communication such as email or meeting request directly

from the collaboration window without having to navigate elsewhere in the application.

Business ByDesign has quickly matured from a single-tenant sales focused module to a broad

multi-tenant CRM and ERP suite. The company’s on-demand target market is in largest part the

company’s existing middle market customer base. However, with its enterprise-wide suite, the

product is competitively strong in a near greenfield market with few on-demand competitors.

With proper execution is appears likely SAP’s Business ByDesign will establish a semi-early global

market share position in the combined hosted CRM and ERP space.

SAP delivers plenty of cross module capabilities. The Work Center is a central design element that

pulls together related business activities, permitting an employee to focus on a set of tasks that

naturally belong together.

Similarly, the Collaboration Window is a desktop component that centralizes quick access to

frequently used functions and Microsoft Office applications.

Software Pricing

ByDesign uses a per user per month subscription pricing model and is most often contracted on

an annual basis. Pricing for ByDesign starts at US$149 per user per month subject to a 10 user

minimum. The subscription includes the entire CRM suite of sales, marketing and service.


SAP Business ByDesign Strengths

• ByDesign is one of a few enterprise-wide SaaS business systems. The product delivers

fully integrated ERP and CRM functions designed to meet the objectives, requirements

and budget constraints of its SME (small and midsize enterprise) target market.

• The SAP brand carries weight in a vendor selection process. The company is a global

leader and benefits from over four decades of building and supporting sophisticated

business applications.

• Business ByDesign is strong in business process automation. Its visual process

walkthrough and process design empower customers to automate highly repetitive as well

as exception condition processes. Workflow definitions and approvals processing are

inherent throughout the application.

• The Corporate Performance dashboard delivers flexible analytics with one click access to

dynamic report lists. Subsequent drill down as well as mixing variables and applying

filters permits deeper analysis.

• The SAP Cloud App Store is a marketplace where apps and other add-ons can be

purchased to enhance the functionality of Business ByDesign services. It is a work in

progress and has yet to match the depth or maturity of competitors such as

AppExchange, however, it has the potential to exceed competitor offerings in terms of

breadth and support for a much wider range of SaaS business applications.

• SAP has created a database from the experiences of 4,000 clients which shares revealing

processes, best practices and benchmarks. While most of these are attributable to SAP’s

Business Suite solution, many are applicable to Business ByDesign as well.

• The application supports ubiquitous browsers, mobile devices and tablets.

• Business ByDesign is a global solution, including support for several countries, multiple

languages, multiple currencies, and compliance with local or regional regulations.

SAP Business ByDesign Weaknesses

� Social CRM capabilities are largely weak or absent in Business ByDesign.

� While broad suite solutions deliver efficiencies and one vendor accountability, they also

pose risk of vendor lock-in.

� Companies seeking industry specific and vertical market SaaS solutions may have to wait

for the Business ByDesign ISV channel and ecosystem to take form and mature. This is a

wait that may take months to years depending upon the particular vertical market. SAP

does provide a few industry templates, but they are limited to reconfiguration and high

level industry adaptation.

� The customer service functionality is best aligned for help desk and light field service

operations. High volume contact centers may find the service capabilities under-powered.

� ByDesign has adopted Microsoft’s Silverlight presentation layer for an improved user

interface (UI). However, while the UI is satisfactory it doesn’t incorporate the consumer-

like technologies that deliver a stimulating user experience. SAP’s use of Silverlight fails

to take advantage of many of the technology’s capabilities such as in-place animation,

dynamic workspace configurations, favorites and more. Perhaps a subsequent version will

more fully leverage this presentation technology. Or on the flip side, many believe

Silverlight is an at-risk technology that may lose support from Microsoft for all but mobile

platforms—as much of Silverlight’s capabilities and purpose for being are now available in

HTML5 and can be accomplished without a browser heavy plug-in.

� Business ByDesign was built on the NetWeaver platform. While NetWeaver is an

impressive framework, its future is uncertain. Further, some IT pros frown on the idea of

having to learn yet another proprietary development environment in order to perform

system integration, software customization and application extension development.


SugarCRM

In an industry of innovators or fast followers, SugarCRM is one of the few innovators. The

company was born with the SaaS incarnation and has since pioneered commercial open source

within the CRM software industry. SugarCRM has become one of the highest growth CRM software

publishers in the world, and as of May 2012 has amassed over 11M downloads, 1M users in over

80 countries, 170K paid subscriptions, 30K registered developers, 1K projects on SugarForge,

400 VARs on five continents and 100 products on the new SugarExchange.

The company is showing traction in both customer acquisitions and business performance.

Revenue growth continues high double digit figures. In addition to its business performance,

SugarCRM's brand and reputation are unique in the CRM industry. The company has built a

passionate and loyal following of partners and customers. In addition to its business performance,

SugarCRM’s brand and reputation are unique in the CRM industry. The company has built a

passionate and loyal following of partners and customers.


Effective dashboards, with integrated feeds (such as news or social streams) and good use of

visuals (such as the pipeline funnel) make it blatantly simple for sales staff to know what to do

next and where to spend their time.

A helpful and user-definable short cut bar is positioned on the header for common actions such as

finding a contact, recording a call, making a calendar appointment or sending an email. This easy

access for routine activities is further bolstered by permitting users to perform these functions on

the fly and without having to navigate away from a prior working location. For example, a sales

rep working in his opportunities can take a call and update the activity record without having to

navigate away from his opportunity view.

The search function is also uniquely strong, displaying dynamic search results in dropdown list for

quick viewing and fast access. While the pages are bit bland (fewer buttons replaced with more

illustrative images and more color might make the user interface more enticing), the logical

combination of menus, tabs, shortcuts, forms and one-click accelerators are very well thought

through, and enable users to get where they want quickly and without much if any training. The

menu navigation takes advantage of Ajax technology, renders efficient dynamic displays and is

clearly one of the most simple menu navigation schemes available.

While opportunity management associates activities, meetings, contacts and virtually all history

associated with the opportunity in a single view, it lacks some of the more advanced functionality

such as including product inventory items or multiple period sale events.

The ‘Get Data’ button is a simple and automated function to retrieve contact information from

multiple data providers such as Hoovers, Jigsaw and ZoomInfo and merge that data into the

contact record. This is one of those features that is extremely helpful in winning user adoption.

Overall, SFA is very sales-process oriented. The natural account sales stage progression—from a

suspect to a lead to a contact to an opportunity and to a win or a loss—can be accomplished with

one or very few clicks and from single instance page views.

The user interface is uncluttered, simple and gets the job done in a minimum number of

keystrokes, but as mentioned it lacks the inviting user experience of a Web 2.0 or consumer

technologies application.


Marketing Automation

Campaigns cover the basics, such as flexible target list creation, HTML or text emails from

templates, designated leads by source, distribution of leads based on rules, real-time status and

resolution of marketing derived leads, and campaign effectiveness reporting.

Beyond campaign basics, Sugar also delivers budget currency designation, budget amount with

expected revenue forecast, assignment of flexible tracker URL designations (to know what

recipients clicked through the email receipts), test message distributions and quick view of

delivery metrics, such as messages sent, bounced, clicked-through, viewed and opted out as well

as conversion metrics such as leads created, contacts created and opportunities generated. These

metrics further permit drill-down to see the actual records for each metric category.

An easy to use drag and drop web-to-lead form builder allows non-technical marketers to create

landing pages. From there the system can automatically forward new website registrants into

Sugar as leads and can assign lead distribution to sales staff based on rules and criteria such as

territory, team or specialty, and also send email notifications of new leads to the sales staff.

Customer Support

Sugar customer support facilitates the traditional case management processes of incident entry,

tools based resolution, routing or escalation and closure. The customer support software

centralizes case management across channels and permits some basic social media inclusion. The

customer self service portal enables customers to submit their tickets online, search the

knowledgebase or FAQs, track case status and update their account information. When

implemented as a supplemental channel and kept fresh with content this is a very effective tool in

both satisfying a growing customer segment and defraying customer support costs for the

company.

The inbound email processing function facilitates customer support request assignments through

automated sharing and routing. Contact center or help desk staff can create rules for in-bound e-

mails and automatically assign cases to designated customer support representatives.

The knowledgebase allows users to create frequently asked questions (FAQs), manage files, and

search and rate content. Customer support representatives can create searchable content

through full-text search, tagging, categorization and approvals. Actual knowledgebase content

includes authoring, posting, and rating of FAQs for internal and external viewing.

Taking case management a step further into the software world, the customer support module

offers a specific function for Bug Tracking. The Bug Tracker captures the more innate detail

around software issues, applies case management to closure and recycles fixes and feedback for

product R&D and next generation solutions.

Social CRM

Social CRM is accommodated by a mix of internal tools, partnerships and of course the

SugarExchange community add-ons. Activity Streams (formerly called Sugar Feeds) is a flexible

integration routine which taps into the Twitter and Facebook social networks and returns feed

results within the CRM app. Users can subscribe to team activities for leads, cases, contacts, and

opportunities, subscribe to favorites, and reply to or delete specific Activity Streams.

SugarCRM originally used Connector tools for integration to Twitter, Facebook and LinkedIn.

However the Cloud Connectors are much more extensible. Leveraging the Sugar Cloud

Connectors for data providers such as Hoovers, Jigsaw, ZoomInfo or other social networking

utilities allows customers to import demographic or social profile data about their contacts directly

into Sugar 6. Cloud Connectors operate with a framework which permits API calls to external

systems and programmed actions (i.e. onload/getdata/mergedata).


SugarCRM Strengths

• Sugar’s development framework, customization tools and open source foundation offer

the most flexible software customization in the CRM industry. Customers can choose to

customize Sugar at various levels, including the data models, objects, columns, fields and

user interface. The Module Builder is a helpful graphical tool which leverages building

blocks and workflow patterns to facilitate the development of new extensions or

applications.

• SugarCRM is one of the few cloud CRM vendors to offer SaaS CRM application portability.

Users have the choice to select the cloud that best serves their reliability, performance

and service level agreement (SLA) objectives. Customers can choose to run on Amazon

EC2, Microsoft Azure, Rackspace or other public clouds—or change clouds on-demand if a

superior provider becomes available.

• The SugarCRM development community, SugarForge, is the strongest open source

community in the business applications industry. There are more than 250,000

community members, 25,000 developers and nearly 1,000 extension projects. The

strength of this community is responsible for a wide portfolio of add-on solutions and

delivers local support anywhere in the world.

• As a commercial open source company Sugar benefits from the capabilities of both

industries. On the open source side, the company’s move to abandon a more restrictive

attribution-style license in favor of the AGPL license demonstrates commitment to open

source ideals and encourages greater community engagement from which Sugar and its

customers benefit. On the commercial side, the vendor’s vision, transparency,

partnerships, customer support and continued innovation are comparable in strength and

delivery to any other non-open source vendor.

• SugarCRM offers an unbeatable acquisition cost and one of the lowest total cost of

ownership (TCO) CRM systems in the marketplace.

SugarCRM Weaknesses

� Sugar’s four paid editions require a minimum 5 user count. This can result in a higher

total cost of ownership for some small businesses.

� Sugar's Service Level Agreement for its On-Demand hosting service is competitively

weak.

� Sugar lacks the public visibility of its much larger competitors. Similarly, despite a

compelling story, the company suffers from limited market awareness outside the open

source community. This is steadily improving as the company demonstrates continued

business performance and growth, but remains an issue which holds back the company’s

customer acquisitions and market share objectives.

� Like nearly all cloud CRM providers, Sugar is somewhere between weak and absent when

it comes to business intelligence (BI), customer analytics, data mining and predictive

analytics. This void can be satisfied with SugarExchange partner solutions from IBM

Cognos, GoodData Sales Analytics or Jaspersoft.

� Being a commercial open source product comes with a level of buyer hesitation or

reluctance among some middle market and enterprise organizations. While there are

legitimate concerns about open source software solutions that must be reviewed, most

don’t actually apply to Sugar. Nonetheless, there are many sale opportunities where

Sugar simply isn’t invited to participate. Again, increased promotion and more focused

messaging could chip away at this perception dilemma.


Zoho CRM

Zoho Corporation is not your average business applications company. This vendor focuses on the

small business market, uniquely positions its CRM product among a broad suite of adjacent

productivity applications and uses a freemium pricing model.

Zoho CRM delivers the traditional customer relationship management software pillars of sales,

marketing and service as well as several complimentary business software modules. The

company’s target market is clearly the small and midsize business (SMB) market and Zoho CRM

is delivered in three separate editions in order to reduce barriers to acquisition and then provide

simple upgrade options to progressive versions.

Throughout the CRM suite the user interface is extremely simple and takes a lesson from

consumer technologies ease of use. Software modules are organized in a tab metaphor and CRM

record pages for leads, accounts, contacts, potentials (aka opportunities) and the like are simple

columnar forms which use JavaScript to dynamically display expanded data set views.

Interestingly, the forms highly resemble Salesforce.com pages. Zoho places a premium on

balancing web design with simplicity.


Like several competing SaaS CRM systems, Zoho maintains a separate leads database to retain

raw data about potential prospects. These are often the leads that are garnered from trade

shows, seminars, advertisements and other marketing campaigns. Zoho CRM functionality to

support lead management includes capabilities to associate leads with other leads, convert leads

to accounts, approve leads as qualified or setup lead assignment rules to automatically designate

leads to sales staff—however, this last function only works when inserting lead records to the

system, such as during an import process or when leads are captured on a website form.

Sales reps typically land on a Zoho splash or dashboard page which includes the standard metrics

of top accounts, weighted sale opportunities, prioritized activities and the like. The dashboards

are well organized, and graphically display key metric comparisons, patterns, and trends in sales,

marketing and support. Dashboard visualizations display two-and-three dimensional charts which

are built with Adobe Flash technology.

For a reason we can’t surmise, Zoho has renamed opportunity management to potentials

management. Potential records support a 360-degree view of the opportunity and display

associated details, such as open activities, history of the completed activities, contacts, products,

sales stage history, attachments, and notes.

The opportunity record also permits associating competitors. The competitive analysis identifies

competitor name, product name, product code, manufacturer, support start and expiry dates, and

strengths and weaknesses. Including competitor information at the opportunity record is a simple

and helpful process, but amazingly very few cloud CRM vendors choose to support any type of

competitive analysis. Another unique feature is the Big Deal Alert. This is an automated alert

notification based on the value of the opportunity record and configured using the Zoho workflow

tool.

For sales reps which create quotes and take orders, Zoho sales force automation includes quotes

and sale order processing with integrated inventory management, item prices lists based on

customer segmentation, line item and document discounting and tax calculations.



Zoho marketing software supports basic marketing management with campaign profiles

identifying various attributes, target list generation with account segmentation, simple budgeting,

broadcast email distributions with response metrics (i.e. open, click and bounce rates), mail

merging and basic campaign reporting.

The marketing software supports multi-distribution drip campaigns, in part using auto-

responders. The method is a bit unusual when compared to the traditional nurture campaign

approach used by competing CRM software systems, but works as advertised. Email distributions

can be scheduled in advance, however, Zoho limits the volume of email distributions to 250

outbound emails per day.

The web to lead form automatically transfers website inquiries into the leads database. Using

either an approve leads function or configuring routing rules in advance can then automatically

forward leads to the right sales resources. Simple campaign revenue forecasting and budgeting

along with manual cost tracking permits basic variance analysis and ROI reporting.

As with many other SaaS CRM solutions in which marketing software does not receive the same

focus as either SFA or service, the Zoho marketing software is largely a campaign tracking

function without any type of marketing process automation. The marketing application is missing

some fundamental functionality such as PPC (Pay Per Click) or Adwords integration.

Customer Service

Integration between sales and post-sales support clearly helps internal teams in both

departments stay apprised of customer status while at the same time providing information and

automation to enhance customer satisfaction and promote cross-selling and up-selling

opportunities.

Zoho CRM delivers support and service features which include case management, resource

assignment, solutions lookup, incident escalation and customer service reporting.

Case entry is streamlined and limited to the basics along with inventory identification and

comment threading. Cases can be automatically created using the web-to-case form or from

customer e-mails in Microsoft Outlook using the Zoho CRM Outlook Edition plug-in. While product

inventory is integrated to customer service, more advanced inventory-based service processes

such as product defect tracking, serial and lot tracking, warranty verification, service level

agreement (SLA) compliance and return merchandise authorizations (RMAs) are not offered out

of the box, but can be accomplished with relatively simple software customization.

Incident escalation offers some configuration flexibility using the workflow tool; however, there is

a limitation that only one escalation rule can be active at a time. This could prove difficult for

companies that define escalation routing by multiple dimensions such as product, territory or

customer type.

The knowledgebase is a useful tool to apply lessons learned and discovered solutions to repetitive

problems. The Zoho Solutions tab offers a simple keyword based Knowledgebase lookup function.

Knowledgebase solutions are categorized by titles, products, and status and deliver records of

prior questions and answers.


Zoho CRM Strengths

• A low cost and quick to deploy CRM solution.

• The most recent release really stepped up the UI and user experience. The UI has

leveraged consumer technologies and navigation has been streamlined to reduce the

number of clicks required to perform the most common tasks.

• For business process automation, Zoho’s workflow tool can create automated business

process sequences across marketing, sales and support.

• A strong breadth of integrated online productivity applications. Zoho encompasses a wide

product scope of complimentary services with integration to over 20 other Zoho apps.

• Zoho’s quote and sales order processing, with integrated inventory management module,

and one-click function to convert a quote to an order or an order to an invoice is helpful

for both inside sales and field sales that go beyond the opportunity record and actually

take the order.

• Mobile CRM can be accessed using a standard browser from any mobile device. For

BlackBerry users, Zoho offers a native application to be locally installed on the blackberry,

and permits local data storage and synchronization. Mobile CRM is limited to SFA

functions of leads, contacts, accounts, potentials and tasks.

• A project management module may be useful for companies which incur an

implementation and service delivery project after the sale, and before typical customer

support issues begin. Because Zoho project management is integrated with the CRM

software, it further adds relevant information to maintain a complete picture of the

customer relationship.

• Zoho’s unique freemium model provides users with a thorough trial or starting solution.

• The company operates within redundant (Equinix) data centers in New York and

California. The facilities are impressive Tier 4 infrastructures; however, occasional short

duration system interruptions remain a recurring issue.

Zoho CRM Weaknesses

� The Zoho vision is unclear, and the business applications direction is even more vague.

We would like to see Zoho put more definitive stakes in the ground supported by market

strategy, planned go-to-market execution and product blueprints.

� Like most cloud CRM solutions, Zoho remains behind the curve in key areas such as social

CRM, business process automation (i.e. a workflow engine) and analytics.

� There is no offline client or offline access to CRM information other than the Android and

Blackberry mobile CRM options.

� The Zoho CRM, Zoho Books and Zoho Invoice products possess reasonable forms and

seemingly a reasonable data model, however, the design is not intuitive and appears to

come from programmers and not practitioners (or even well versed project managers).

� While Zoho accommodates small business customers well, it doesn't offer the feature sets

or configuration flexibility required of most middle market or enterprise organizations.

� The company offers a diverse product portfolio, but much of those products lack features

sets found in competitor products and lack meaningful integration among each other.

� The company faces significant competition from many types of mature technology

companies. From Microsoft and Google in the desktop apps space to Salesforce.com and

SugarCRM in the CRM market. Carving out the niche markets where it will surpass these

competitors remains a work in progress.


About The Sponsor Vantive Media

This CRM Buyers Guide is a work in progress, and updated annually.

Each year we reexamine the business challenges as well as the strategies and software

innovation that collectively advance customer relationship performance. To deliver the best

research and recommendations possible, we call on the community to solicit ideas and feedback.

We want to know what you like about the CRM Buyers Guide, what you don’t like, what’s missing

and how we can improve this annual report.

To view the interim updates between releases and contribute to the conversation, visit

http://www.facebook.com/crmsearch, and join the Discussion.

The CRM Buyers Guide is part of a document series. Additional related advisories include:

� The CRM Software Selection Methodology | A Best Practices Approach

� The CRM Software Procurement and Negotiation Playbook

Each advisory is released annually and free of charge, however, only available for a limited

period. Visit http://www.crmsearch.com or subscribe to the RSS feed at

http://feeds.feedburner.com/crmsearch to be notified when new advisories become available.

This research advisory is independently produced by Vantive Media. Vantive Media research does

not permit vendor funding, advertising or sponsorship. The content is free of direct or indirect

influence by third parties.

DISCLAIMER. The facts of this advisory are believed accurate at the time of the publication

however cannot be guaranteed. All findings, comments, recommendations and content are based

on information gathered in good faith from both primary and secondary sources, whose accuracy

cannot always be guaranteed. This document is subject to the Terms and Conditions available at

the CRMsearch.com website. This document is also subject to copyright protection. Vantive is a

registered trademark. All other trademarks and products mentioned in this report are registered

trademarks or trademarks of their respective holders.

© Vantive Media LLC, All Rights Reserved.

crm buyers guide 2013 - crmsearch.comcrmsearch.com/dwn/crm_buyers_guide.pdfcrm buyers guide a...

Documents