new state of the art brt systems - nyu wagner graduate ... · new state of the art brt systems....

46
New State of the Art BRT systems Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP NYU, February 2010

Upload: others

Post on 20-Jun-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

New State of the Art BRT systemsWalter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP

NYU, February 2010

Page 2: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Guangzhou is the highest capacity ‘direct service’ BRT in the world, TransMilenio is the highest trunk and feeder

system.

Both can be optimized. Depends on local circumstances

Page 3: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Flexible Operation

优点: 专用走廊,走廊内Guangzhou and Cali, Colombia, are the first BRT systems to combine full BRT features with ‘direct’ routes

210

560 Route using corridor /route length more than 30%

BRT Vehicle,can leave corridorDon’t need feeder

296

561 242

Presenter
Presentation Notes
广州市的系统是特别针对广州客流条件而提出的系统(专用走廊+灵活车辆),乘客既可以享有封闭式系统的优点,又免却多次换乘。
Page 4: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Guangzhou’s Zhongshan BRT Corridor Before. (it was already congested...)

Page 5: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Ridership is today over 21,000 pphpd, making it #2 after TransMilenio in terms of capacity and ridership

Page 6: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

It was a huge fight to get this much space for stations and required intervention of the Mayor himself

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Page 7: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Karl Fjellstrom, ITDPs Guangzhou Representative. Mayor agreed in part because of need for a showcase for Asia Games

Page 8: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

We didn’t have control over bus programming or traffic signals, so they included too many routes and gave us only about 33% green time but we asked for 45%. Should be fixed soon.

Page 9: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

New 12 meter LPG buses with at level boarding. We wanted 18 meter artics but there’s a local LPG ordinance and LPG too weak for artics

Page 10: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid
Page 11: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

First bike lane on a major arterial since the early 1990s

Page 12: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

They are not yet what we wanted…Another $200 million in pipeline for corridor improvements

Page 13: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Bike parking and new passenger information kiosks

Page 14: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

The Bus Routes are the same as some old routes, but now they are“B” routes.

Page 15: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Shopping malls already building connections to the walkways.

Page 16: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Full integration with 4 metro stops. Station connections not finished yet.

Page 17: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

When finished, it will be the first BRT fully integrated with Metro, at 4 stations.

Page 18: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

GPS control room under testing

Page 19: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Lots of nice space in the stations for bike parking or Coca Cola machines

Page 20: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Senior Engineer Duan Xiaomei inspecting the new bike sharing program

Page 21: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

More bike parking

Page 22: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid
Page 23: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Disabled access. Guard lowers the ramp and changes the traffic signal.

Page 24: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Real time bus location information actually works

Page 25: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Places to sit that don’t take up too much space.

Page 26: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

At level boarding. Gap only about 4 inches. Day One.

Page 27: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Transit oriented development. This station had no demand when project started so had to redesign stations.

Page 28: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

What’s happening at the next station down…

Page 29: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

TransJakarta is the longest BRT system in Asia

8 corridors now operational. Harmony Station nicely rebuilt after 5 year fight.Inter-corridor routes operating after 5 year fight.

Page 30: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Just a leetle gap issue…

Page 31: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Lane enforcement: it’s a problem on 4 corridors

Page 32: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

At least Corridor I of TransJakarta still slips past the traffic.

Page 33: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Delhi debacle: Direct service system led to 6 phase signals and consumed 6 lanes at every intersection

Page 34: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Ahmedabad Bus Rapid Transit System

• 9 Oct 2009

Page 35: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

• Construction complete on about 45 km of planned 90 km network

• Free service since mid-July- 14 buses- 26,000 passengers / day- 27% of riders from private

vehicles• Competitive bidding for bus

operations and fare collection• Trunk service with no feeders. • We argued for ‘direct’ services’ but

Delhi scared everyone off.

Page 36: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Segregated median bus lanes

Page 37: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Median stations

Page 38: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Level boarding 900 mm

Page 39: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Two-phase junctions

Page 40: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Difficult to get traffic police to impose short enough signal phases, so operating unsignalized…

Page 41: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Johannesburg: Trunk, Feeder and Complimentary

Corridor length: 63 km

Number of stations: 78

Corridor length: 63 km

Number of stations: 78

Page 42: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Station designed for specific boarding and alighting (Orlando Football stadium)

Page 43: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Vehicles are World Class: Low-Emission Engines, High Quality• Euro IV diesel engine with particulate traps

• (Bogota is Euro II, so Rea Vaya is much cleaner!)

Need to check if fuel spec is consistent with the warranty

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Very political decision to push the envelope for clean technology. Financial ramifications but courageous. First time Euro IV in country. Can they maintain? Is fuel ready?
Page 44: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Innovative Complementary Routes

• Doors on both sides

• Facilitates bigger service range while trunk infrastructure is being expanded

•Initial downtown circulator didn’t work and was discontinued.

Presenter
Presentation Notes
“expands the reach of the system before the system has been built” –AG Inner city circulator and “trunk lite”
Page 45: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

The Taxi Transition:

•Involving the taxi industry to become owners of the new system is moving forward but its been a year long negotiating process and not every interest can be protected or bought off.

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Social equity aims, not as clear-cut as a technical project. 1970’s gov’t stopped providing public transit; these guys started on the gray market, few entrepeneurships to operate in the townships (black and color-owned); today seen as a black african business – pride; formed with the idea of protection – protect routes, mafia mentality. Chance to revolutionize industry Politicians promised that “No taxi operator will be worse off” Weak internal governance of taxi associations responsible for hold-up, “no mechanism for making a decision on behalf of the whole “ Interim operations mean some taxi routes are being affected already
Page 46: New State of the Art BRT systems - NYU Wagner Graduate ... · New State of the Art BRT systems. Walter Hook, Executive Director, ITDP. NYU, February 2010. ... Ahmedabad Bus Rapid

Thank You!

www.itdp.org