multi-family market · spokane!cap!rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) quarter average...

25
Presented by COLIN CONWAY, BROKER KIEMLE & HAGOOD COMPANY MULTI-FAMILY MARKET

Upload: others

Post on 26-Sep-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

Presented  by  COLIN  CONWAY,  BROKER  

KIEMLE  &  HAGOOD  COMPANY  

MULTI -FAMILY MARKET

Page 2: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

“One  out  of  three    Americans  rent;  One  out  of  three    renters  lives  in    an  apartment.      

That’s  35  million  residents.”  

*Source:    The  Trillion  Dollar    Apartment  Industry    

KHCO.COM  

Page 3: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

Na:onal  Apartment  Associa:on  and  Na:onal  Mul:-­‐Family  Housing  Council  partnered  with  Stephen  Fuller  and  George  Mason  University’s  Center  for  Regional  Analysis  to  determine  the  economic  impact  of  the  35  million  resident  of  apartment  communi:es.        

Page 4: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

*Source:    The  Trillion  Dollar  Apartment  Industry  

In  2011,    apartments    and  their  residents    generated  an    esRmated    $1.1  trillion    contribuRon  to  the  naRonal  economy  and  supported  25.4  million  jobs.    

Page 5: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

As  many  as  7  million  new  renter  households  could  be  created  this    decade  –  about  half  of  all  new    households  likely  to  be  formed.    

*Source:    The  Trillion  Dollar  Apartment  Industry  

Page 6: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

*Source:    US  Census  Bureau  

62%  

64%  

66%  

68%  

70%  

4Q2004  

3Q2012  

69.2%  

65.5%  

NaRonal  Homeownership  

Page 7: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

*Source:    US  Census  Bureau  

Each  percentage    point  decline  in    home  ownership  =  approximately    1.1  million    households  to    the  rental  market.  

Page 8: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

$650    

$660    

$670    

$680    

$690    

$700    

$710    

$720    

2010   2011   2012  2013  

$665    

$683    $678    

$720    

Spokane  Average  Rental  Rates  –  All  Units  

*Source:      Washington  Center  for  Real  Estate                                        University  of  Washington  

Page 9: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

$0    

$200    

$400    

$600    

$800    

$1,000    

Studio   1bd/1ba   2bd/1ba   2bd/2ba   3bd/1ba   3bd/2ba  

$539    $622    

$700    

$812    $769    

$912    

Spokane  Market  Rental  Rates  -­‐  Unit  Type  

*Source:      Washington  Center  for  Real  Estate                                        University  of  Washington  

Page 10: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

According  to  Apartment  Guide,  what  market  currently  has  the  highest  rent    in  the  naRon  for  a    700  square  foot,    1  bedroom    apartment?   *Source:    Apartment  Guide  and  Spokesman  

Review  

Page 11: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

$0    

$500    

$1,000    

$1,500    

$2,000    

$2,500     $2,394    

$622    

Average  Monthly  Rent  –  1  Bedroom  

Page 12: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

NaRonal  Overall    CapitalizaRon  Rate    Trends    Spokane  Cap  Rates  are    100-­‐150  points  higher    (high  6  to  low  7)  

Quarter AverageChange

(Basis  Points)1Q08 5.79% 42Q08 5.75% -­‐43Q08 5.86% 114Q08 6.13% 271Q09 6.88% 752Q09 7.49% 613Q09 7.84% 354Q09 8.03% 191Q10 7.85% -­‐182Q10 7.68% -­‐173Q10 7.12% -­‐564Q10 6.51% -­‐611Q11 6.29% -­‐222Q11 5.93% -­‐363Q11 5.77% -­‐164Q11 5.80% 31Q12 5.83% 32Q12 5.76% -­‐73Q12 5.74% -­‐24Q12 5.72% -­‐21Q13 5.73% 12Q13 5.70% -­‐33Q13 5.61% -­‐94Q13 5.80% 19

Source:  PwC  Real  Estate  Investor  Survey®    

2Q11  is  average  of  3  reg ions3Q11  is  average  of  3  reg ions

Q4  2009 8.03%Q3  2013 5.61% -­‐242

OVERALL  CAPITALIZATION  RATE  TRENDS    National  Apartment  Market    

*Source:    PwC  Real  Estate  Survey©  

Page 13: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

5%  

6%  

7%  

8%  

1Q11   2Q11   3Q11   4Q11   1Q12   2Q12   3Q12   4Q12   1Q13   2Q13   3Q13   4Q13  

NaRonal  Overall  Cap  Rate  Trends  

*Source:    PwC  Real  Estate  Survey©  

Page 14: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

ü  50%  of  U.S.  Renters  pay  1/3  or  more  of  their  income  on  rent  

 ü  Up  12%  points  from  

a  decade  ago  

30%  Rent  

*Source:  Harvard  University  Joint  Center  for  Housing  Studies  &  Journal  of  Business  

AFFORDABILITY  

All  Other  Expenses  

Page 15: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

ü  27%  of  renters  pay            ½    of  their  income              on  rent.      ü A  decade  ago  it    

was  19%.    

*Source:  Harvard  University  Joint  Center  for  Housing  Studies  &  Journal  of  Business  

50%    Rent  

All  Other  Expenses  

Page 16: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

*Source:  Harvard  University  Joint  Center  for  Housing  Studies  &  Journal  of  Business  

“The  shornall  in  the  number  of  units  affordable  to  extremely  low-­‐income  renters  in  the  U.S.  –  those  earning  no  more  that  30%  of  the  area  median  –  more  than  doubled  from  1.9  million  in  2001  to  4.9  million  in  2011.”  

2001  

2011  

1.9  million  

4.9  million  

Page 17: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

MICRO  UNITS  ü  Trending  in  major  

metropolitan  areas  ü  In  response  to  limited                          

supply  and  increasing  costs.  ü  As  small  as  200  square  feet  ü  Targets  the  millennial  

populaRon  and  empty  nester.  

Page 18: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

DEMAND    ü  NaRonally,  mulR-­‐family  starts  in  2009  hit  

a  low  of  97,300  new  units    ü  The  esRmated  number  of  units  needed  

annually  is  300,000  to  meet  new    demand.  

Page 19: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

SPOKANE  What  is  under  construcRon  right  now?      

Page 20: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T Complete  2011The  Reserve  at  Shelley  Lake Spokane  Valley 256 Permitted  2010,  Complete  2011Pine  Valley  Ranch Spokane  Valley 256 Permitted  2010,  Complete  2011East  Nora Northeast  Spokane   14 Permitted  2010,  Complete  2011Ridge  at  Midway North  Spokane   180 Permitted  2010,  Complete  2011Alki  Street Cheney   16 Permitted  2011,  Complete  2011North  Sullivan  Road Spokane  Valley 12 Permitted  2011,  Complete  2011

734Complete  2012Montrose  Townhouses South  Spokane 8 Permitted  2011,  Complete  2012Affinity  at  South  H ill  (  55+ ) South  H ill 150 Permitted  2011,  Complete  2012Affinity  at  Mill  Road  (62+ ) North  Spokane 150 Permitted  2011,  Complete  2012Eag le  Point  II Cheney 132 Permitted  2011,  Complete  2012Copper  H ill South  Spokane 232 Permitted  2011,  Complete  201255th  Avenue  on  the  South  H ill* South  Spokane 120 Permitted  2012,  Complete  2012Father  Bach  Haven* CBD  Spokane 51 Permitted  2012,  Complete  2012Sylvan  Place* North  Spokane   15 Permitted  2012,  Complete  2012

858Complete  2013Orchards  Townhouses Spokane  Valley 27 Permitted  2012,  Complete  2013,  lease-­‐upHomestead  Apartments  (Phase  I) Spokane  Valley 120 Permitted  2012,  Complete  2013,  lease-­‐upRiver  House  Apartments  (Phase  I) Spokane  Valley 216 Permitted  2012,  Complete  2013,  lease-­‐upCourtyard  at  River  District Liberty  Lake 47 Permitted  2012,  Complete  2013,  lease-­‐upCanyon  Bluff  Apartments Southwest  Spokane   48 Re-­‐Permitted  2013,  Complete  2013,  lease-­‐upSprague  Union  Terrace* CBD  Periphery 37 Permitted  2012,  Complete  2013,  lease-­‐upBridgeway  Apartments CBD  Periphery 84 Permitted  2012,  Complete  2013,  lease-­‐upAlki  Street  Townhouses Cheney   16 Permitted  2010,  Complete  2013,  lease-­‐upBroadWing  Apartments* Liberty  Lake 51 Permitted  2013,  Complete  2013,  lease-­‐upC lare  View  Apartments* South  Spokane 61 Permitted  2013,  Complete  2013,  lease-­‐up

707Complete  2014  to-­‐dateNorth  C incinatti  Street North  Spokane   24 Permitted  2012,  Complete  2014Appleway  Court  (Phase  II)* Spokane  Valley 24 Permitted  2013,    Complete  2014

48Permitted/Under  ConstructionCedar  C rossing North  Spokane   36 Permitted  2012,  nearing  completion  Mirabolante   Spokane  Valley 234 Permitted  2013,  g round  work  startedCottages  at  River  Run  (Phases  I  &  II) Spokane 130 Permitted  2013,  g round  work  startedWandermere  Glen North  Spokane 48 Permitted  2013,  under  constructionH ighline  West  Apartments CBD  Periphery 56 Permitted  2013,  inactive  site  workBroadway  Villas Spokane  Valley 42 Permitted  2013,  g round  work  started  (phased  project)Homestead  Apartments  (Phase  II) Spokane  Valley 128 Permitted  2013,  under  constructionCopper  Landing  Apartments* Airway  Heights 216 Permitting  NOT  required  (Tribal  Land),  under  constructionGranite  Pointe  (Phase  II) Spokane  Valley 236 Permitted  2013,  inactive  site  work

1126Proposed,  LikelyHomestead  Apartments  (Phase  II) Spokane  Valley 140 Proposed  -­‐ status  unknown  (Likely)River  House  Apartments  (Phases  II  &  III) Spokane  Valley 120 Proposed  -­‐ status  unknown  (Likely)

260Proposed,  OtherVistas  at  Beacon  H ill East  Spokane 256 Proposed  -­‐  status  unknownCanyon  Pointe West  Spokane 144 Proposed  -­‐  status  unknownNaccarato  Project Airway  Heights 216 Proposed  -­‐  project  currently  "shelved"Eag le  Point  Remainder Cheney 204 Proposed  -­‐  status  unknown

820

Total 4,553*  Subsidized/Low-­‐ Income    Ridpath  Hotel CBD  Spokane 200+ /-­‐ Envisioned

Spokane  County:    New,  Permitted  and  Proposed  Apartment  Construction  

Completed  and    Under    ConstrucRon    Projects  in    Spokane    2011-­‐2014  

*Source:    Valbridge  Property  Advisors  

Page 21: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

0  

500  

1000  

1500  

2011  2012  

2013  2014  

734   858  707  

1174  

Completed  and    Under  ConstrucRon  Projects  (by  Units)  

*Source:    Valbridge  Property  Advisors  

Page 22: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

Proposed    and  Under    ConstrucRon    Projects  in    Kootenai  County    

PROPOSED PROPERTIES - KOOTENAI COUNTY, IDAHO Units Anticipated

Completion Date Name Total Market Restricted Telerico Apartments 14 un 14 un Proposed Fall 2013 Proposed 20-Unit - Martin Lane 20 un 20 un Proposed Fall 2013 Riverview Apts, Phase 2, Seltice Way 94 un 94 un Under Construction Carrington at Waterford, Phase 1 60 un 60 un Rent-Up Carrington at Waterford, Phase 2 72 un 72 un Proposed Residence at Mill River 93 un 93 un Under Construction John O'Brien House 14 un 14 un Proposed Fall 2013 Fairway Meadows 80 un 80 un Under Construction Glacier Trail 30 un 30 un Proposed Riverstone Place 114 units Riverstone West III 38 un 8 un 30 un Under Construction Hudson Park Apartments 60 un 7 un 53 un Proposed Montrose Condos 18 un 18 un Proposed Affinity at CDA, Senior 102 un Proposed/Hold Totals 575 un 478 un 97 un

Page 23: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

TRANSACTIONS  OF  NOTE  Sale  Date   Property   Address   #  of  

Units  Sale  Price   Price/Unit  

2/2013   Park  Place   916  N  Ella  Rd   60   $3,365,000   $56,083  

2/2013   Amberwood   3030  S  Clinton  Rd     51   $2,672,000   $52,392  

4/2013   Park  Place  (CDA)  

3825  Ramsey  Rd   150   $8,600,000   $57,333  

6/2013   Willow  Brook   12202  E  Maxwell   110   $6,850,000   $62,273  

7/2013   Whispering  Pines  

3002  E  30th  Ave   55   $2,560,000   $46,545  

10/2013   32  Pines   3010  S  Pines  Rd   72   $3,500,000   $48,6111  

12/2013   Big  Trout  Lodge   22809  E  Country  Vista  Rd  

297   $29,819,000   $100,403  

Page 24: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

M U LT I - FA M I LY M A R K E T

TRENDS    ü  Apartments  remain  a  stable  

investment.    ü  It  will  remain  a  seller’s  market  for  the  

next  year.    

Page 25: MULTI-FAMILY MARKET · Spokane!Cap!Rates!are!! 100150pointshigher!! (high6tolow!7) Quarter Average Change (Basis1Points) 1Q08 5.79% 4 2Q08 5.75% 4 3Q08 5.86% 11 4Q08 6.13% 27 1Q09

THANK YOU