cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r - stanford universitycgates/persi/papers/longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576...

30

Upload: others

Post on 12-May-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

����������� ��������������������������� �"!#���$�����$�"%'&�����( )*�+��,�$�-�.������/��,���0��1�2��034���,576�89�$�;:<�6�=��>2-�?��� �����A@B2��$�����$(

C�DFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q�RCLSFT�DVUXWZY[SF\�W7N^]7_�W`DVWZGMQ�WZGMaFQ

b/c�dfe EPDV\.Q�g�DVKhKiL\jGhE�S�U<Q�GkW,lmNV]#n#DVKhGo]pN/UZ\jGMDq7SFUZr�SFKhS�l[n#J0s^t dvu/w

DVKMH�N/O.Q<x�Q,W<D^WFy{z.SFUZr�SFKhS�l�y{S^H�O|}SFU`Q�G+CLGID/a~NP\jGMQ

CLS�T.DVUZWXY[SF\�W<Q�NV]#��D^WX�jS�Y'DVWZGMaFQ�DV\�H�_�W`DVWXGIQ�WZGMaFQ_�W<DV\�]pN/U<H�i�\jGhE�SFU`Q�GkW�l�n#J�sVt bPw/�

��DFl�� d�� ��s/s/s

���.���Z�<�/�<��m���F�,�����p���P���L�p�����^���? ¢¡V�;£I�/�,�¤�p ¢¡����<����¥F�<�L�¢¦/§v¨`©Iªk«�¬P­;«7®Z¯±°;©Iª²¬F³`´>µM¶p�

�±¡P�<��·F�p���+���Z�~�F��¶¤ ¸�L�^�¤ ��~�m�;�����;���� <¹$�º�v�Z�<������¡^»F��¡^¥�¼$ ¢½^¡^¥L¶��±�^���Z�<½F¾�¿"�À¶¤Á¶¤Á^���� ¢¡^¥~�,�p¶7��¡P�;�p�X�<�p��¡^¥��p½^�^�¤�ZÂ~½^�,¡P���- <¹+�����±¡P�F ~�Ã�/�,�p��½^¶;�<¶¤�À ~¡ÅÄF�o�L¶pÁ^�Æ �¤Á^��¡^�p¶¤�Z�Å�� ¢�p�¤�,�p�/ ¢¡/�F�,¡P�;�~´?Ç��p�Z�;��¡�¶?Á^��¥~Á^���À¥~ÁF¶ ±¹�¶¤Á^���+�<�¤�Z�����"¶pÁV��¿ ~�p» ±¹�È�±��»¢£pÉ}�,�{¹k¶M£MÊ¢ ~ÁP�<¡V�p�p ~¡�¿"Á^�o�¤Á�·F���,�o�F�j�À���L�À¶¤��¡^¥.�^�¤ ¢�P�±�^���À��¶M·}�º�X¿"� ÄF�º��ÁP�<�;��±¡P�<��·F�p���$ <¹ÌËj F�,�^����¶pÍ��F��¶p�,�¤����¡P�<¡F¶¤�Z´

Î^Ï^ÏVÎ>ÐÒÑ^ÓhÔPÕ~Ö�Ñ^ÓM×kرÙ+ÚjÛ�ÜIÝ`ÕXØ¢ÓßÞ+à�ÑFÙZÙ<× á�ØXÑ^ÓM×kâVã�Ù¢ä�å�æ;çoèÅéFæ,ê�ë^ì/í�ìVî�ï<ì^î^ð�ñ~ì�ï^ñ¢îFò�î^ó�ïë^ì^ô"ì^î�õ

ö�÷jø;ùMø,ú�ûMüpý�ùMþ¢ÿ~ÿ��Zû��Mø������ ����� �����$ûpú����������������� ��! "��ñ

Page 2: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

# $&%�')(�*�+-,/.0'21 *�%354 ç76�6�8�æ:9<;<ê�=�é�=>;<æ2?,æ�;¢é@? 6�?BA5CD? 4 ;<èE;F6 çHGI=�éFæZéKJLJH;�Jpõ5MDGN;O? 4 ;<èP;"ç76éQ=N8�æ�;�Joê�èÅé�? 4NR;<èÅé�?;ç7S<éKJ�TU8N;F6�?;çHC<GWVOXY;F6�SXæ�ç[Z�;�? 4 ;�é<6;ê/èE=N?�CU?;ç7S5JkéKA]\^=�æ:C<Z�é�Z/çLJ�ç[?;ê_XVç76�?,æ�ç[ZN8N?�ç[CUG&`OC�a? 4 ;�JH;GNb<? 4 C�aO? 4 ;�JHC<GNb<;F6�?>çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6¤çHGNbc6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;EC�a+é-æZé@G>XYC^èd=�;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?;çHC<G.õ354 ç76�TU8N;F6�?;çHC<G 4 é<6�Z>;;Ge6�?�8>XVçH;FXfZPê[é-9�éFæ;çH;?;êcC�a+çHG>SXæ�;¢éU6¤çHGNb�Joêg?�;FS 4 G/ç7S<éKJLJoêh6�C R= 4 çi6j?;ç7S<é�?�;FX�èP;? 4 CkXN6lC�9<;<æI? 4 ;PJké<6�?nm^ì ê<;¢éFæ 6±õcop;qC<8N?�J�çHGN;q? 4 æ�;;^ï+é@=N=�éFæ�;GY?�JoêT<8/çH?�;�8NG�æ�;�Jké�?:;FXjï�èE;? 4 CNXN6�ç[G_6j;FS�?;çHC<G>6�ó R r õ 3Q4 ;�C<? 4 ;<æs? 4 ;<èE;�ç76�élS<éFæ XPbPéFèE;^ï=�é�?;çH;G>S�;_6�C^æ�?�ç[GNb õ 3Q4 çi6lbPévèE;E=�æ�C�9VçiXY;F6�é�Gt;�JH;<èE;GY?ZéFæ,êgS�CUGu?�;�vN?�çHGtA 4 ç7S 4 ? 4 ;J[CUGNb<;F6�?>ç[G>SXæ:;¢é<6¤çHGNb_6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;-éFæ;ç76�;F6<õ5wxC^æ�;�æ�;<èÅévæ�y�é�ZYJoê^ï�çH?#æ�;�Jké�?:;F6?çHGzXVçL{W;<æ R;Gu?DA�é~êN6O?:CE?�AsClC�a ? 4 ;�?�;FS 4 G/çiS<é|J èE;? 4 CkXN65A 4 çiS 4_4 éK9<;�Z�;;G_8>6�;FXjõQ}<C^èE;�GN;Aæ�;F6�8YJH? 6DS�C<G>S�;<æ:G/ç[GNb-C<? 4 ;<æ7é<6�=>;FS�?�65C�a�=�é�?�ç[;G>S�;I6�C^æ�?�ç[GNb-éFæ:;�XY;F6�SXæ;çHZ>;FXfç[Gc6�;FS�?;çHC<Gî�õ

~W�^~ �����<�^���O�N�����W���<���O�MDGN; R =>;<æ 6�CUGzS<éFæ X-b/éFèE;F6?éFæ�;�S<éKJLJH;FX'Ù<â^à�×hÓMÑ^×7�;Õ5bPévèE;F6�ç[Gmò7èE;<æ;ç7S<é�G[é�G>X���Ñ^ÓM×hÕ¢ã ØZÕbPéFèE;F6>çHGg�}æ;çH?;ç76 4 õPop;E6�?ZéFæ�?�Z/êzXY;F6:SXæ;çHZ/ç[GNb'é-=�éFæ:?;ç7S�8YJ²évæ�6j8>S 4 bPéFèP;^ï���Ñ^ÓM×hÕ¢ã ØZÕÙ`â<�XÓM×hãu�^ï±çHGu9U;Gu?�;FX�é<6ßéD=�æZéUS�?;ç7S<éKJ�èP;? 4 CkX�C�a�6�C^æ:?;çHGNb�æ�;¢éKJ>XY;FS�yN6�C�a�S<évæ XN6<õ �?ç76�?:C^æ,êC�aO? 4 ç76Db/éFèE;�é�G>X æ�;<èÅéFæ�yN65C<Gc6�C�J�çH?Zé~çoæ�;IbPéFèP;F65A 4 ç7S 4 éFæ�;l?,æZé<XVçH?;çHC<G�éKJLJoê_=YJké~ê<;FXé<6?æ�;FSXæ�;¢é@?;çHC<GqA?çLJLJ�Z�;�bFçH9<;G�J²é@?�;<æ¢õ3 é�y<;�é�XY;FS:yEC�aWS<éFæ XN62Jké�Z�;�JH;FX[ñ<�ZóN��mN�F���:� �$õ 354 ;�XY;FS�y�ç76�6 4 8Y�-;FXjïkS<évæ XN6+éFæ:;?�8�æ�GN;FXx8N=_C<GN;�é�?�éI?;çoèE;-é�G>X_XY;¢é|J[?>çHGu?:Cn=/çLJH;F6�C<Gx? 4 ;�?Xé�ZYJH;^ï.é<SS�C^æ XVçHGNb-?�CE? 4 ;æ�8YJH;

� ò�JHC�A�S<éFæ X èÅé~ênZ�;I=YJ²éUS�;FX_CUGÒé 4 ç[b 4 ;<æ S<éFæ�Xc\^;^õ�b õ�ó�èÅé~ênZ�;�=YJké<S�;FXcCUG¡<`XïuCVæ�èÅé~êEZ>;l=N8N??çHGu?:CfélGN;A�=/ç¢JH;I?�CI? 4 ;Læ;çHb 4 ?£C�a�? 4 ;l;�vPç76�?;çHGNb-=/çLJ[;F6±õòD?I;¢é<S 4 6�?Zé@b<;nA5;q6�;;-? 4 ;n?:C<=hS<évæ XpCUGe;¢é<S 4 =/çLJH;^õg¤¥a�? 4 ;-?�8�æ�GN;FXt8N=¦S<éFæ�X[ç764 ç[b 4 ;<æ�? 4 é�Gf? 4 ;ES<éFæ XN6�6 4 C�A?çHGNb�ï�? 4 ;G[çH?-Ö�Û^Ù<Ó Z>;P=N8N?�çHGu?:C�é-GN;A§=/çLJH;n?�C-? 4 ;æ;çHb 4 ?�C�aO? 4 ;IC<? 4 ;<æ 6<õq¨ßÔPÕ-âPÜIÝ`ÕXØ¢Ó?â�©�ÓhÔPÕ/�VÑ^Ö�Õ-ײÙ�ÓMâ�á?ã�ײÙZÔqª"×hÓhÔÒÑFÙ�©`ÕKªp�j×kà�Õ<Ù�ÑFÙ��âFÙXÙ`×MÜ<à�Õ�«3 C�çLJ¢JH8>6�?�æZé�?�;^ï&6�8N=N=>CY6�;�éI6 4 8Y�n;FX_XY;FS:yqC�a�ñ~ìES<éFæ XN6}ç76 çHG_? 4 ;�C^æ�XY;<æ

¡ ó­¬ ñ§m r ñ¢ì0ë­®�î354 ;�?�C<=qS<éFæ Xjï&¡/ï^ç76DXY;¢é|J[?Qa é<S�;�8N=qCUGq? 4 ;�?Zé�ZYJH;^õ 354 ;�GN;�vN?�S<éFæ�Xjï�ó�ïkS<é@GqZ>;�=N8N?C<Gq?�C<=qC�a ? 4 ;I¡Põ��O8N?£? 4 ;�¬ 4 é<65?:CIa¯CVæ,è�éIGN;A�=/çLJH;^ï�bFçH9^çHGNb

¡ó ¬ó

Page 3: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

354 ;Òñ-S<é�GtZ>;-=YJ²éUS�;FXpC<Gt;XçH? 4 ;<æI? 4 ;Åó�C^æ�? 4 ;q¬�õ-¤�a>ç[?IA5;<æ�;E=YJké<S�;FXfC<Gt? 4 ;n¬�ïé�G>X ç¢a�é�G/êqC�a�°|m�� r �XîN�,ëN��¡<±�As;<æ:;/?:C²S�C^èP;�GN;�vN?¢ï&? 4 ;IGN;�vk?�S<éFæ XxA5C<8YJ7X 4 éK9<;�?�Ca¯C^æ�è élGN;A³=/ç¢JH;^ïNA 4 ;<æ�;¢é<6$çLa ? 4 ;�ñ�A5;<æ�;D=YJké<S�;FX-C<G-? 4 ;�ó�ï<? 4 ; ¬ çi6£6�?;çLJLJ)CU=>;GPa¯C^æ? 4 ;F6�;nS<éFæ�XN6<õ 3Q4 ;n�<�;ÕXÕ ´<µl6�?,æZé�?:;b^ê�ç76�?�C�éKJHA�é~êk6£=YJké<S�;méqS<éFæ XxC<Gc? 4 ;IJH;�a�?,èECu6�?=>Cu6�6�ç[ZYJH;-=/çLJ[;^õLò�XYC<=N?;çHGNb_? 4 ;Ib^æ:;;FX/êz6�?,æXé�?�;b^êx\^A 4 ç7S 4 A5;/XYCq8NGYJH;F6�6�CU? 4 ;<æ�A?ç76�;6�?Zé�?�;FX�`&JH;¢é<XN60?�C�? 4 ;5a�C�JLJHC�A?çHGNb/6�;FTU8N;G>S�;�C@a)S�C<GY¶>b<8�æXé�?;çHC<G>6<ïUA 4 ;<æ�;�é�? ;¢é<S 4 6�?�;=.ï? 4 ;�?�C<=_S<éFæ�X�ç[Gx;¢é<S 4 =/çLJH;�ç76}çHGxZ>C�J7XUapé<S�;^õ

¡ó ·�¸ ¡ó · ¬¹ ¡ó · ¬¹Iº ¡ó · ¬¹lº ·u» ¡ó · ¬¹lº�ñ¢ì¼ ¡ó · ¬¹lº�ñ¢ì

¼ ½ ¡ó · ¬¹Iºmñ¢ìë ½¾

¤^?�ç76�;¢é<6�êz?:C²6�;;¸ç[G>XY8>S�?�ç[9U;�Jºêt? 4 é�?~ï&8NG>XY;<æ�? 4 ;Ib^æ�;;FX/êp6�?�æZé�?�;b^ê^ïjé�?�;¢é<S 4 6�?Zé�bU;? 4 ;DJké�Z�;�J765C<G-? 4 ;�?:C<=nS<éFæ XN6Q\Mçpõ�;^õ ? 4 ;�9Vçi6�ç[ZYJH;IS<éFæ XN6�`"éFæ�;?çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6�ç[GNb�aIæ�CVè¿JH;�a¯?5?�Cæ;çHb 4 ?~õ�of;�èP;Gu?;çHC<GN;FXl? 4 é@?�? 4 ;5C<Z�ÀB;FS�?2C�a�? 4 ;sb/éFèE;"ç762?�C�¶>G/ç76 4 A?çH? 4 é<6&a�;Ae=/çLJH;F6é<6�=>Cu6�6�ç[ZYJH;^õ5Á&;<è-èÅé�ñ£A?çLJ¢J S�C<GY¶�æ,èÂC<GN;<ÃÄ6 ç[GY?�8/çH?;çHC<Gq? 4 é@?s? 4 ;�b^æ:;;FX/êÅéKJHb<C^æ;çH? 4 èçi6£C<=N?;çoèÅé|J õ3 Cz=YJké~êeA?çH? 4 æ�;¢é|J£S<évæ XN6IC<GN;qGN;;FXN6P?�CcJ�çHGN;¢éFæ�JoêeC^æ XY;<æP? 4 ;�î^ópS<éFæ�XN6<ï ;^õ�b�õZPêq=N8N?�?�ç[GNb-6�8/çH? 6?çHGx? 4 ;�Z�æ;ç7XYb<; R Z/ç7XNXVçHGNb_CVæ XY;<æDÅEÆ�Ç�È�õ 354 ç76>è�çHG>XUJ[;F6:6£a¯C^æ�è­C�a6�C�J�çH?Zé~çoæ�;�ç76£? 4 ;G_TU8/ç[?:;�=YJké~êPé�ZYJH;^ï>=�;<æ 4 é�=>6£A 4 çLJH;/A�é�?�S 4 çHGNbI?�;�JH;9^ç76¤çHC<G.õ¤^? çi6QG�é�?�8�æZéKJW?�C-é<6jynA 4 é@? élA?çHGNG/çHGNbqbPéFèP; 6 4 CU8YJiX�Z>;^õOwxC<GY?�;Lí�éFæ�JHCn6�çºèI8 RJ²é@?;çHC<G>6�6 4 C|A 4 C|A³? 4 ;�GY8�èIZ>;<æ�C�a =/ç¢JH;F6�9FéFæ;çH;F6�a�C^æ#é�GqC^æ�XVç[G�évæ,ê�î^ó R S<éFæ�XnXY;FS:yÌõ

GY8�è/Z�;<æ�C@a�=/çLJH;F6 ¬ ® ñ¢ì ñ^ñ ñ¢ó ñFm ñ r ñ¢î ñ¢ë ñ@¡ ñF¬aMæ�;FTU8N;G>SXê î r î^ó^î ñ�¡ r ë óY¡|®�ñ ó^î^ì<m ñ¢î�ñF¬ ë<m^ó ñF¬^ë m<m ñVñ ñÉ�Ê>Ë�ÌiÍ · õhΣ8�èIZ>;<æEC@a�¶>G�éKJ�=/ç¢JH;F6PA?çH? 4 �ÐÏAî^ó'é�G>X ñ¢ì��Zì^ì^ì�?,æ;çkéKJ76<õ 354 ;

éF9U;<æZé�b<;�Gu8�èIZ�;<æ�C�a2=/ç¢JH;F6>ç76Lñ^ñ<� ë�õ}<C�8>6�8�éKJLJoê/? 4 ;<æ�;�éFæ�;�ñ¢ì R ñKm5¶>G�éKJ>=/çLJH;F6<ï/é�G>XlAs;?è�çHb 4 ?OS�C<8NGY?�? 4 ;Q6jC�J�ç[?Xé~çoæ�;DbPéFèP;én6�8>SS�;F6:6?çLaOA5;�;G>X�A?çH? 4 ®P=/çLJ[;F6�CVæDa�;A5;<æ¢õ 3Q4 çi6QJH;¢é<XN6�?�CÅé@GÒé�=N=�æ�CKv/çoèÅé�?�;�îYÑS 4 é�G>S�;lC�a A?çHGNG/ç[GNb õ~W��Ò �����<�^���O�N�tÓ|�����<�^�O�Ô�&�OÕ¿Ö^���O�W��ÓF�_���O�N�<���&Ó|���O�ÔÓ|×�ØOÓ��>Ù ×��>���N�>ÓòÚ=�;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?;çHC<GpÛtC�a�°Pñ<�XóN�F�K��B����±nS<é�GpZ>;¸çiXY;GY?;çL¶>;FXfA?çH? 4 é�G évæ,æZé�GNb<;<èP;Gu?�C�aé�Gz� R S<éFæ XxXY;FS�yjï�ZPê_6�=�;FS�çLaIêVçHGNb_? 4 é�?�Û2\BÜ�`�Z>;�? 4 ;�Jké�Z>;�JOC@a�? 4 ;IS<éFæ X é�?D=>CY6¤çH?;çHC<GÜ,õ 354 8>6£a�C^æ��tÏ�ñ¢ìP? 4 ;ÅéFæ,æXé�GNb<;<èE;GY? XVç76�=YJké~ê<;FXcZ�;�JHC|A ç767ç7XY;Gu?�碶>;FXfA?çH? 4 ? 4 ;=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?�ç[CUGhÛ2\Xñ�`�ÏÝ¡u�IÛ2\�óY`lÏ óN��Û2\BmY`�Ïd¬N�K�F�F����Û2\Zñ¢ìY`�Ï�î�õ ò�G ×hã�ØK�;ÕZÑFÙ<×hãu�

m

Page 4: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

Ù`Û�ÜXÙ<Õ Þ~ÛPÕ~ã�ØXÕ�\BÜ^ßK� Ü�à�F�K�F����Ü^áK`OC@a0Û ç76�éP6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;�6�é�?;ç76�aMê^çHGNbÜ ß�â Ü à�â �F�K� â Ü á<ã Û�\BÜ ß ` â Û2\BÜ à ` â �F�F� â Û2\BÜ á ` �

ôNC^æ?çHG>6�?Xé�G>S�;^ïN? 4 ;l=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?�ç[CUG¡ ó­¬ ñ m r ñ¢ì0ë ® î

4 é<6�é�G�çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6�ç[GNb_6j8NZ>6�;FT<8N;G>S�;ñ�m r ëE® \Zñ�`

C�a5J[;GNbU? 4 î�ï$é�G>Xc? 4 é�?7ç76l? 4 ;IJHC<GNbU;F6�?�=�Cu6�6¤çHZYJH;Ea�C^æ�? 4 ;P=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?�ç[CUG.õEop;n6�éFA? 4 é�?O=�é@?;çH;G>S�;�6�C^æ�?;çHGNbI=YJké~ê<;FXEA ç[? 4 ? 4 ç76O=�;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?;çHC<G-;G>XY;FX-A?çH? 4 îl=/ç¢JH;F6<õ 354 ç76çi6PGNCeS�CFçHG>S�çiXY;G>S�;^õåä�;�¶>GN;zæ�\BÛ2`�?�CfZ>;c? 4 ;qJH;GNb<? 4 C�a�? 4 ;qJHC<GNbU;F6�?-çHG>SXæ�;¢éU6¤çHGNb6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;/C@a�éI=�;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?;çHC<G_Û�õç Í�ègècÊ ·­é ×hÓhÔ]´^ÕZØëêzÛ2ì���Ñ^ÓM×hÕ¢ã�ØXÕ[Ù<â<�XÓM×kãY�c�Ìà�Ñ<µFÕ�´¦ª"×hÓhÔ ÓhÔPÕc�<�;ÕXÕ ´Uµ'Ù<Ó��;Ñ^ÓMÕB�UµÕ¢ã>´vÙnª"×kÓhÔ Õí�ÑVØ¢ÓMàLµnæ�\BÛ�`D�Ì×hà�Õ<ÙF«cî.ÛY�ZÓhÔPÕK�ZÖ�â<�;Õëì ÓhÔPÕ-�^Ñ^Ö�Õ��Ìà�Ñ<µFÕ ´cª"×hÓhÔ Ñ^ã>µ[à�Õ��^Ñ^àÙ`Ó��;Ñ^ÓMÕ��<µ-Õ~ã>´FÙ�ª"×hÓhÔÒÑVÓ�à�ÕXÑFÙ<Ó�æ�\BÛ2`0�Ì×kà�Õ±Ùë«>ÚjâmÓhÔPÕ��<�;ÕXÕ ´Uµ�Ù`Ó��;Ñ^ÓMÕ��<µ�×oÙ�â��jÓM×kÖ�Ñ^àïì�Ñ^ã>´ØZÑ^ã ã�â^Ó?Ü,ÕL×kÖ£���;â<ð~Õ ´�Üëµ-Ñ^ã�µ-à�â¢â�êKñ�ÑFÔPÕXÑ<´�Ù<Ó��;Ñ^ÓMÕB�Uµ<«ò �;â¢â�©F«I¤¥a�S<éFæ XN6�óYß â óYà â �F�K� â óuô"é@=N=>;¢éFæ ç[G*ç[G>SXæ:;¢é<6¤çHGNbcC^æ XY;<æ¢ï�? 4 ;Gp8NG>XY;<æé�GPêxJH;bPéKJD6�?,æZé@?�;b^ê_;¢éUS 4 óUõ?èI8>6�?�Z�;E=YJké<S�;FX çHGh6�CVèE;I=/ç¢JH;q?�Cx? 4 ;-æ;çHb 4 ?�C@as? 4 ;=/ç¢JH;nS�CUGu?Zé�ç[G/çHGNb_óUõ÷ö�ßVï>Z�;FS<é�8>6�;I? 4 ;ES<éFæ X�Gu8�èIZ�;<æ�C<G_?�CU=_C�aO? 4 é@?D=/çLJ[;-S<é�GcC<GYJoêXY;FSXæ�;¢é<6�;^õ 3Q4 8>62? 4 ;Q¶>G�éKJ�GY8�èIZ>;<æOC@a�=/çLJH;F6"ç76?é�?2JH;¢é<6�?5æ;ï^é�G>X 4 ;G>S�;�é�?2JH;¢é<6�?5æ�\BÛ2`ZõíOC<GY9<;<æ 6�;�Joê^ï<8>6�ç[GNbI? 4 ;£b^æ�;;FX/êE6�?,æZé@?�;b^ê^ï�A 4 ;GÅé�S<évæ XEø}ç76 =YJké<S�;FX¸çHGfé�=/çLJH;�C<? 4 ;<æ? 4 é�Gp? 4 ;�¶�æ 6�?�=/çLJH;^ï =N8N?�é-=�CFçHGu?�;<ælaMæ�C^èù? 4 é@?�S<éFæ Xc?�Cq? 4 ;nS�8�æ,æ�;GY?�Joêc?�C<=gS<éFæ�Xø�ú â ø7çHGc? 4 ;�=/çLJH;E?�CE? 4 ;�JH;�a¯?~õ�òD?�? 4 ;�;G>XxC�a ? 4 ;IbPéFèP;^ïYJH;?�ó ô Z>;l? 4 ;ES<éFæ XqCUG?�C<=qC�a ? 4 ;�æ;çHb 4 ?,èECu6j?s=/çLJH;Eæ;õ 354 ;/6�;FTU8N;G>S�;

óYß�ûüóYà�ûý�F�F�YûþóYôLö>ß�ûÿóYôC<ZN?Zé~çHGN;FXlZPê�a¯C@J¢JHC�A?çHGNb�? 4 ;5=>Cvç[GY?�;<æ 6ßç76"é�G çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6¤çHGNb/6j8NZ>6�;FT<8N;G>S�;£A 4 Cu6�;�JH;GNb<? 4çi6£? 4 ;�GY8�èIZ>;<æ�C�a�=/çLJH;F6<õ��¤^Gx? 4 ;�;�v�éFèE=YJH;^ïN? 4 ;l=>CFçHGY?�;<æ 6�JHCYC<y-J�ç[yU;

¡ó

ñ

¬m

r ñ¢ì

ë

®

î

���������� �

�� � ��� ��� ��r

Page 5: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

é�G>XpA5;-æ:;FS�C|9U;<æ/? 4 ;n6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�; ñ-m r ë_®xC�a�\Zñ�`Xõ²Î£C<?�;-? 4 é�?l? 4 ;I¶>G�éKJD?�CU=S<éFæ XN6�éFæ:;7ç[Gxb<;GN;<æZéKJ?ã�â^Ó.é�G�çHG>SXæ�;¢éU6¤çHGNb²6�8NZ>6j;FT<8N;G>S�;<V}çHG_? 4 ;�;�v�éFèP=YJ[;^ïjîES<éFèP;éKa¯?:;<æ�®�ç[Gt? 4 ;EXY;FS:yÌõ-ÎDC<?:;¸é|Ji6jC_? 4 é�?�? 4 ;�è�éKvPçoèÅé|Js6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;-ç76 çHGpb<;GN;<æZéKJGNC<?D8NG/ç7T<8N;<V�A5;�S�C<8YJ7Xx?Zé�y<; �<ó�� çHG_=YJké<S�;IC�a��vñ��LçHGp\Zñ@`Zõ~W��� �q�����>�x�����D�>�&�<�&���N�>Óq�������! �"354 çHGNy^çHGNbIC�a�é�=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé@?;çHC<GEÛ�é<6"é�G-éFæ�æZé�GNb<;<èE;GY? C�a.é�XY;FS�yIC�a�S<éFæ XN6±ï^é�G�é�?�8�æZéKJèE;?,æ;ç7S$#�\BÛ>ßK� Û�à`�C<Ge=�;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?;çHC<G>6PS<é�G¦Z�;_XY;�¶>GN;FX éU6�a�C�JLJHC�A�6<õ³}Pé~ê�é Ö�â<ð~ÕS�C<G>6¤ç76�? 60C�aÌèEC�9VçHGNb�é�6¤çHGNb�JH; S<éFæ�X�?:C�6�C^èE;5C<? 4 ;<æ =�Cu6¤çH?;çHC<G-A?çH? 4 çHGE? 4 ;�XY;FS:y ã ? 4 ;G#�\BÛ�ßF��Û>àë`jçi60? 4 ;?è�çHG/çoè/8�èåGu8�èIZ�;<æ C�aÌèEC�9<;F6ßæ�;FTU8/çoæ�;FXI?�C�b<C£aMæ�C^èÃéFæ,æXé�GNb<;<èE;GY?Û ß ?�CÅévæ,æZé�GNb<;<èP;Gu?DÛ à õ�w_CVæ�;#è�é�? 4 ;<èÅé�?�çiS<é|J¢Joê^ï�a¯CVæ#é�G/ê²6�;?&%¿C�a b<;GN;<æZé�?:C^æ 6�C�a? 4 ;s6;ê/è-èE;?�æ;ç7SObVæ�C<8N= ')(�ï�A5;OS<é�GEXY;�¶>GN; é�XVç76�?Zé�G>S�;5C^æ}àÀÕ~ãu�VÓhÔ ©`Û/ã�Ø~ÓM×kâ^ã�*�\BÛ>ßK� Û�à`?�CEZ>;

è�çHG�°+*EV<Û�ß-,Uß-,uà��F�F�.,0/�Ï Û�à5a�C^æ�6�CVèE;&,<õ213%�±u�354 ;G4#�\BÛ>ßK� Û�à`"ç76£? 4 ;�XVç76�?Zé�G>S�;�é<6�6�CNS�çké�?�;FX�A?çH? 4 ? 4 ;�bU;GN;<æZé�?�C^æ�6D°�ø65 ßõ87 �~ñ�9¦Ü â: 9���±Pï&A 4 ;<æ�;Eø�õ;7�ç76�? 4 ;ESXêNS:J[;�\BÜ���Ü)< ñU�F�F�K��� : `Zõ�¤^?7ç76�GNC<? 4 éFæ�X_?:C²6 4 C�A¿? 4 é@?¢ïA�æ;çH?;çHGNb>=�a¯CVæD? 4 ;7ç7XY;Gu?�ç[?;êq=�;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?;çHC<G.ï

#�\�=:� Û2`2Ï �@?gæ�\�Û2` �354 ç76A# ç76CBà�Ñ^ÖED Ù¸Ö�Õ~Ó��Z×hØAF²ñ¢ì/ïî<mHG¤õAIQJ²évè \^=�;<æ 6�C<G�éKJDS�C^è-èI8NG/ç7S<é�?;çHC<G&`7æ�;�Jké�?�;F6? 4 é�? 4 ;I? 4 C<8Nb 4 ?DC@a�? 4 ç76>èE;?,æ;ç7S�A 4 çLJ[;P? 4 çHGNy^çHGNb�é�Z�C<8N?�? 4 ;�apé<6�?�;F6�?5A�é~ên?:Cn6�C^æ�?éIZ�æ;ç7XYb<; 4 é@G>XqC�a�? 4 çºæ:?�;;GzS<éFæ�XN6<õΣC<?�; ? 4 é�?�? 4 ;OXY;�¶>G/çH?;çHC<GEC�a>æ�\BÛ2`�èÅé�yU;F6 çH? 6�S�CVèE=N8N?Zé�?;çHC<G�JHCYC<y�J�çHy<;�é5=�æ�C<ZYJH;<èç[GcS�C^èIZ/çHG�é�?�C^æ;çkéKJWC<=N?�çºè¸çKJ¢é@?;çHC<G.ï�é�¶>;�J7X�çHGqA 4 ç7S 4 èÅé�G/êE=�æ�C<ZYJH;<èn6>éFæ�;�éKJHb<C^æ;çH? 4NRè�ç7S<éKJLJºê 4 éFæ Xjõ¦��8N?nÁ);<è-èÅé�ñ_6 4 C|A�6I? 4 é�?I=�é�?;çH;G>S�;p6�C^æ:?;çHGNb[ç76LçoèE=YJ�çiS�çH?�Joê9é@GéKJHb<C^æ;çH? 4 èüa�C^ænS�CVèE=N8N?;çHGNbgæ�\BÛ2`�é�G>Xt;�v 4 çHZ/çH?;çHGNb é[èÅéKv/çoèÅéKJ R JH;GNb<? 4 çHG>SXæ�;¢éU6¤çHGNb6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;^õ�ô�æ�;FX/è�é�GLFoñ¢ëMG 4 é<6l6 4 C�ADGp? 4 ç76LéKJHb<C^æ;çH? 4 èüS<é�GpZ>;�çoèE=YJH;<èE;GY?�;FX8>6¤çHGNb��£JHC<bD�N?q�£J[CUb JHC<bs�O<3PI\B��` S�C^èE=�éFæ;ç76�CUG>6"çHG-? 4 ;DA5C^æ 6j?sS<é<6�;^ï/é�G>XP? 4 é�?OGNCéKJHb<C^æ;çH? 4 è 4 éU65Z>;?�?:;<æ�A5C^æ 6j? R S<é<6�;�Z>; 4 éK9Vç[CVæ¢õ~W��Q RA���gØ£�S�O�UTO���W�_�V� ���! �"W���W�cÖ����U�W�4Xå"é�?;çH;G>S�;�6�C^æ�?�ç[GNb�é�G>XAIQJkéFè_ÃÄ6 èE;?,æ;ç7S�=�æ�C�9VçiXY;�?�A5C�;�JH;<èE;GY?ZéFæ�êÅèECU?;çH9�é�?;çHC<G>6sa¯C^æ6�?�8>X/êVç[GNb�æ�\BÛ2`Xï¢é�G>X�èPC^æ�;O6�C<= 4 ç76�?�çiS<é@?�;FX�èECU?;çH9�é�?;çHC<G>6$éFæ;ç76�;0aIæ:C^è]? 4 ;5S�C<GNGN;FS�?;çHC<G>6?�CnZ�;EXY;F6�SXæ;çHZ>;FXcZ�;�JHC|ALõ�of;/6�;;yx?�C²6j?�8>X/êq? 4 ;>� ?�êY=/ç7S<éKJ��-9�éKJH8N;F6�C�asæ�\�Û2`OA 4 ;G� ç76lJkéFæ�b<;^õx¤^Ge? 4 ;EJké�GNb<8�é@b<;nC@a�=�æ�C<Z�é�Z/çLJ�çH?;êg? 4 ;CVæ,ê^ï A5;E?Zé�yU;fé ÛPã × ©<â<�XÖ �;Ñ^ãNñ´^â^Ö���ÕF�XÖ�Û/ÓMÑ^ÓM×hâ^ãnÛY(IC�aO°Pñ<�XóN�F�K���� ��± é�G>Xq6j?�8>X/êE? 4 ;£JkéFA³C�aW? 4 ;7çHGY?�;b<;<æ R 9FéKJH8N;FX

î

Page 6: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

æZé�G>XYC^èÝ9�éFæ�ç²é@ZYJ[; Z[(²V[Ï æ�\BÛY(N`ZïNA 4 çiS 4 S<é�G_Z�;E6�8�è-èÅéFæ�çKJ;FXxZ/ê�çH? 6�èP;¢é�G]\@F8Z[(+Gé�G>Xg6j?Zé�G>X�éFæ XfXY;9^çké�?;çHC<GL^[F8Z_(�G¤õc\�å"æ:C<Z�é�Z/çLJ�çi6j? 6l8>6�8�éKJLJoêeA�æ;çH?�;Åé�Z�C<8N?I? 4 ;-9�éFæ;ç Ré�G>S�;`^ à çHG>6�?�;¢éUX-C�a�? 4 ;�6�?Zé�G>X�évæ XnXY;9Vçké�?;çHC<G3^"ïUZN8N?D? 4 ;£Jké�?�?�;<æ}ç76�? 4 ;7çHGu?�8/çH?;çH9<;�Joêç[GY?�;<æ�=�æ:;?Zé�ZYJH;�èE;¢éU6�8�æ�;�C�aO6�=�æ�;¢é<Xjõ[`

òÔa¯8NG>X�évèE;Gu?XéKJ�? 4 ;<èP;�C�aW? 4 ç7656�8�æ�9U;<ê�ç765? 4 é�? ? 4 ;<æ�;�éFæ�;D? 4 æ�;; XVç76�?�ç[G>S�?£A é~êN6?�C-æ�;�Jké�?�;`Z ( ?:C�6jC^èE;�é�=N=�éFæ:;Gu?�Joê_TU8/çH?�;�XVçL{);<æ:;Gu?�C<ZNÀ�;FS�? 6<õ� 354 ;f}uS 4 ;G>6j?�;FX]S�C^æ,æ:;F6�=>C<G>XY;G>S�;t\B6j;FS�?;çHC<G ó�õoñ�`�bvç[9U;F6Åé a¯CVæ,èI8YJ²é�\BmY`�a¯C^æa \�Z ( Ï æ�`$çHG_?:;<æ,èn65C�a ? 4 ;�6 4 é@=>;�C@a æZé@G>XYC^ècb C<8NGNbn?Xé�ZYJH;¢é�8Yv�õ� íOCVæ�C�JLJkéFæ,êmî�çHGz6j;FS�?;çHC<Gpm�õ óLæ�;=�æ�;F6�;GY? 6&Z_(mé<65? 4 ;lGu8�èIZ�;<æ�C�a =�éFæ�?�çiS:JH;F6�é�??;çoèE;��Òç[G[éES�;<æ�?Zé�ç[G�çHGY?�;<æZé<S�?�ç[GNb-=�éFæ�?�çiS:JH;I6;êk6j?�;<è­C<Gq? 4 ;�æ:;¢éKJWJ�çHGN;^õ� å�æ�C<=>CY6¤çH?;çHC<G ë�çHGh6j;FS�?;çHC<G r bFçH9<;F6Lé-a�C^æ,èI8YJkéPa¯C^æ a \!Z_($9§æ�`}çHGg?�;<æ�èn6�C�aé�G*ç[GY?�;b^æXéKJOA?çH? 4 æ�;F6j=>;FS�?I?�C_�7é^éFæ�èE;¢é<6j8�æ�;EC<Gp? 4 ;E8NG/çH?ZéFæ,êcb^æ�CU8N=.ïé�G>Xå�æ�C<=>CY6¤çH?;çHC<Gc¡�æ�;XçHGY?�;<æ�=�æ�;? 6£? 4 ç76}çHG_?:;<æ,èn65C�a+é 3 Cu;=YJ�çH?dJIXY;?�;<æ,è�çHG�é�GY?¢õ

¤^Gq;¢é<S 4 S<éU6�;�çH?}ç76�=>Cu6�6�ç[ZYJH;P\^? 4 C<8Nb 4 GNC<?�;¢é<6;ê�`�?:C�=>;<æja¯C^æ�è é@GÅé<6;ê/èE=N?�C<?�çiS7é�G�éKJ Rêk6¤ç76lC�aD? 4 ;�æ�;�Jké�?�;FXt6�?,æ�8>S�?:8�æ�;fé@G>XpXY;<æ;çH9<;�çHGYa¯CVæ,èÅé�?;çHC<G�é�Z�C<8N?�? 4 ;mé<6;ê/èE=N?�CU?;ç7SZ>; 4 éK9^çHC^æ-C�aeZ[(Ìõtop;_6 4 éKJLJ C<8N?jJÀçHGN;x? 4 ;F6�;mæ�;�Jké�?;çHC<G>6�é�G>Xt? 4 ;�é@G�éKJoêk6¤ç76¸çHG 6�;FS R?;çHC<G>6?ó R2r ïYZN8N? 4 ;<æ�;>çi6>é/6j8�è-èÅéFæ,ê^õ �7éFè-èE;<æ�6�JH;<ê3FoñF®MG&bPéK9<;D? 4 ;£¶�æ 6�?5;�vN?�;G>6¤çH9<;XVçi6:S�8>6�6¤çHC<G.ïé@G>X_? 4 ;G�çHG>XY;=�;G>XY;Gu?�Joê$f ;<æ�6 4 çHy*é@G>X3g�;<æ�C�9$F î^îMG"é�G>XcÁ&C<bPé@GÒé�G>X} 4 ;=N=hF{ó<®MG�b/éF9U;�æ�;F6�8YJH? 6D6 4 C�A?çHGNbE;F6:6�;Gu?�ç²é|J¢JoêÉji&Í0k�lFÍ�ènmpo Ù��rqts ª"Õ�Ô/Ñ<ð¢Õ�\@F8Z_(HGvu ó<� ßdw�à Ñ^ã�´x^[F8Z_(�G&Ïzy<\�� ß-w�à `«}<8NZ>6�;FT<8N;GY?�Joê�ç[?�A�é<6 S�C<G�À�;FS�?�8�æ�;FX|{�As;Q¶�æ 6�? 4 ;¢éFæ X�? 4 ;�S�C<G�À�;FS�?�8�æ�;£aIæ:C^è}g�;F6�?�;G\^=>;<æ 6jC<G�éKJ>S�C^è-èI8NG/ç7S<é�?;çHC<G&`Zï~çHG>6�=/çoæ�;FXPZPê�é@G�éKJHC<b<C<8>62S�C<G�À�;FS�?�8�æ�;F6ßçHGl¶�æ 6�?2=�é<6�6,é�bU;=>;<æ S�C�Jké�?�ç[CUGg\~F ó^îMG�=�é@b<;�ó<®U¬Y`�é�G>Xc�7éFè-èE;<æ 6BJ[;<ê&ÃÄ6>æ�;=�æ�;F6�;GY?Zé�?�ç[CUGp\�ëY`�{fé�G>Xx;G RXYC^æ 6�;FXIZ/ênwxC<GY?�;7í�éFæ�JHCI6¤çoè/8YJké�?�ç[CUG_\^?Xé�ZYJH;#óY`ZïU? 4 é�?"èEC^æ:;�XY;?Zé~çLJH;FXmé<6;ê/èE=N?�C<?�çiS6As;<æ:;

\@F8Z_(HGWÏ ó<� ßdw�à ?E�V�P� ß-w!� <�yU\B� ßdw!� ` �p^_F8Z[(�G&Ï�^S�I� ßdw!� <hyU\B� ßdw�� ` \�óY`a¯C^æ5S�C<G>6�?Zé@Gu? 6[���Ãé�G>X@^S��õ�g>çoè�F ó^ëMG>=�æ:C|9U;FXE? 4 ;&PI\B� ßdw!� ` Z>C<8NG>XPC<G-? 4 ;�8N=N=>;<æ?Zé~çLJWC�a�? 4 ;�XVç76�?,æ�ç[ZN8N?�ç[CUG_C�a�Z[(�ï�é�G>X-9<;<æ,ê�æ�;FS�;Gu?5A5C^æ�yIC�a ��é�ç[y R ä�;XçLa¯? R�� C 4 é�G>6�6jC<GFÄmHG&bFçH9<;F67é�æ;çHb<C^æ�CU8>65=�æ�CYC�a�C@as\�ók`�A ç[? 4 GY8�èE;<æ;ç7S<éKJ 9�éKJH8N;F6��V� Ï9ñ<�L¡/ñ^ñ<�H�H�i��^S�åÏìN�Ä®^ì^ó��H�H�oï�é@G>XÒé|Ji6jCq=�æ�C�9^ç7XY;F6�? 4 ;ÅéU6;êPèP=N?�C<?;ç7S�JkéKA�ï&?�CqA 4 çiS 4 A5;/6 4 éKJLJ�æ�;?�8�æ:G�çHG6�;FS�?;çHC<G r õoñ^õ

ë

Page 7: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

� ñ¢ì�� ñ¢ì�� ñ~ì � ñ~ì�� ñ~ìH� ñ~ìH� ñ¢ì ß!�6,éFèP=YJ[;I6¤ç�J; ñ¢ì � ë��^ñ¢ì � ñ~ì � ñ~ì � ñ~ì � ó^ìVì^ì r ìVì^ì;F6�?;çoèÅé@?�;FX���� ñ<� ë^ë^ì ñ<�{ë<®Y¡ ñU�L¡�ó^ì ñU�L¡|m<m ñU�L¡|m<¬ ñU�L¡|m^î ñ<�L¡<¡ r;F6�?;çoèÅé�?:;FX�^S� ìN�ĬY¡Pñ ìN�ï¬<¬^î ì��Ĭ<®^ë ì��Ä®^ì^ì ì��Ĭ<®<¬ ì��Ä®^ì^ó ìN�Ĭ<®VîÉ�Ê>Ë2ÌHÍ�m��5w_CUGu?�;Lí�éFæjJ[CE6¤çoèI8YJké�?;çHC<Gmæ�;F6j8YJ[?�6OZ/êxM�XUJºêUJy<CÅé@G>XA��é�ç[G>6FÄmk¡�G¤ï bFçH9^çHGNbca�C^æI;¢é<S 4 �Ô? 4 ;q9FéKJH8N;F6IC�a�? 4 ;F6�;_S�C<G>6�?Zé@Gu? 6l;F6�?�çºè�é�?�;FXaMæ�C^èÂ? 4 ;I6,éFèE=YJH;F6<õ

354 ;-é<6;ê/èE=N?�C<?;ç7SLé�=N=�æ�CKvPçoèÅé@?;çHC<Gt\�óY`}çi6�TU8/çH?�;-é<SS�8�æZé�?:;�a�C^æ �hÏ9î^ó�ï�=�æ�;FXVç7S�?;çHGNbéI9�éKJH8N;�ñ^ñ<�oñ¢ó�a�C^æW\@F8Z � à!GWA 4 ;<æ:;�? 4 ;�6¤çoèI8YJ²é@?;çHC<G ç[Gx?Zé�ZYJH;-ñ�bPéK9<;�ñ^ñ<�{ë�õ~W��� �g��ÓK�@���H�]���x���>�<���>�O�N�tÓ��W���<�^���354 ;cG�éFèE;q��Ñ^ÓM×hÕ¢ã�ØXÕ Ù`âU�ZÓM×hãu�cS�C^èE;F6�aMæ�C^è wÒé|J¢JHC�A�6rFÄm^óMGpï5A 4 C çHG�FÄm�ñ~G�SXæ�;FXVçH? 6ò�õL}�õºí#õ��5Cu6:6Ia�C^æ�ç[?�6�çHGY9<;Gu?�ç[CUG A ç[? 4 ? 4 ;qa�C�JLJ[C�A?çHGNb�èECU?;çH9�é�?;çHC<G.õBòD?-? 4 ;_;G>XC�aD? 4 ;EbPéFèP;^ï�S<évæ X�ñ�ç76�éKJHA�é~êk6�C<Gt?�C<=fC�as? 4 ;PJH;�a¯?�èECu6�?l=/ç¢JH;^õE�5;<èEC�9Vç[GNbpS<éFæ�Xñ^ïOS<éFæ X ó ç76IGNC�A é�?I? 4 ;-?�C<=tC�a 6�CVèE;n=/çLJH; ã æ�;<èEC�9VçHGNb S<évæ X�ó�ï S<éFæ Xtm çi6�GNC|Aé�?�? 4 ;P?�C<=pC�a�6�CVèE;E=/çLJH;^ï+é�G>Xt6�C_A5; 4 éK9<;Åé-G�é@?�8�æZéKJ�éKJHb<C^æ;çH? 4 è a¯C^æLèÅé�GY8�éKJLJoê6�C^æ�?;çHGNbqS<éFæ XN6<õ£o 4 ;? 4 ;<æ�? 4 ç76?ç76�? 4 ;lapé<6�?�;F6j?D=�æZé<S�?;ç7S<éKJ"èE;? 4 CNX�a¯CVæ�6�C^æ�?�ç[GNb�æ�;¢éKJS<éFæ XN6l\^C^æ�é|J[= 4 é@Z>;?;ç�JXçHGNbx¶>G�éKJO;�v�évèn6�`?ç76�é�G çHGY?�;<æ�;F6�?;çHGNbx?�C<=/ç7Sla�C^æ S�C@{);; R æ:CuC^èS�C<Gu9U;<æ 6,é�?;çHC<G.õw[éKJLJHC|A�6Ãé�G�é|JºêN6¤ç76�FÄmVó�G�A�é<6�XYC<GN;�çHG ñF®^ë^ì�ZN8N?IGNC<?�=N8NZYJ�ç76 4 ;FXÔ8NGu?�ç¢J?èI8>S 4J²é@?�;<æ5\B6�;;D6�;FS�?;çHC<G-ó�õïm5a�C^æ$èEC^æ�;?æ�;<èÅévæ�yk6 `ZõW¤�G>XY;=>;G>XY;GY?�Joê^ïN=�é�?;çH;G>S�;�6�CVæ�?;çHGNb�A�é<6XVçi6:S�C|9U;<æ�;FXEZ/ê/S�CVèE=N8N?�;<æs6:S�ç[;GY?;ç76�?D��C<ZÅô�JHCFêkX�ç[G ñF®^ë r é�G>XPXY;9<;�JHC<=>;FX-Z�æ;çH;~��ê�çHGJ[;?:?�;<æ 6�Z>;?�A5;;Gfô�JHCFêNX-é�G>X@g�Gu8N? 4 ïYZN8N?5? 4 ;Xçoæ5A5C^æ�y�é@=N=�éFæ�;GY?�Joê 4 é<6�GN;9<;<æOZ�;;G=N8NZYJÀç76 4 ;FXjõI�7éFè-èE;<æ 6BJ[;<ê$F²ñF®MG�=.õ�m^ë^ó¸ç[G>XY;=�;G>XY;Gu?jJºê æ�;FS�C<b<G/ç�J;FX çH? 6�8>6�;�é@G*é@GéKJHb<C^æ;çH? 4 èÂa�C^æ�S�CVèE=N8N?;çHGNb²æ�\�Û2`Zõ�  ¢¡x£¥¤³*�,E%j¦ü'�§©¨@ª«£¬§�,`­¯®°£�'�¡/*�+354 ;-}uS 4 ;G>6�?:;FXpS�C^æ,æ�;F6j=>C<G>XY;G>S�;�ç76�é�æ�;<èÅéFæ:y�é�ZYJH;EZ/ç�À�;FS�?;çHC<GpZ>;?�A5;;Gc=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé R?;çHC<G>6�é�G>Xx=�é~çoæ 6�C�as6�?Xé�G>X�éFæ X±b C<8NGNbq?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8Yv.õ�¤^?�A�é<6 çHGu9U;Gu?�;FXxZ/êp}uS 4 ;G>6�?�;FXF r îMG�?:Cg6�?�8>X/êt? 4 ;qJH;GNb<? 4 C�a�? 4 ;-JHC<GNbU;F6�?-çHG>SXæ�;¢éU6¤çHGNb¦6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;^õ]op; 4 éF9U;a¯C<8NG>X ? 4 é�?�? 4 ;E6�C�J�çH?Zé~çoæ�;EbPévèE;IC�as6�;FS�?;çHC<G ñVõoñ�bvç[9U;F6�é�Gc;¢é<6;ê^ïWS:JH;¢éFæ�A�é~ê_C@aO;�v R=YJ²é�ç[G/çHGNbp? 4 ;nS�C^æ,æ�;F6j=>C<G>XY;G>S�;^õP¤^Ge6�;FS�?;çHC<G ó�õ²ñIAs;IbFçH9<;PZ�é<S�yYb^æ�CU8NG>XcC<GEb C<8NGNb?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8Yv.õ ¤^Gq6�;FS�?;çHC<Gmó�õ ó�A5;�6 4 C�AÔC<GN; S<é@GE8>6�; 4 C|AÔ? 4 ;�S�C^æ,æ�;F6�=�C<G>XY;G>S�;�?�C�b<;?é<6;ê/èE=N?�C<?;ç7S>çHGYa�C^æ,èÅé�?�ç[CUG�é�Z>C<8N?&Z_(jõ

¡

Page 8: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

Ò��^~ ²E�W×O���¦�<�&ØOÖ��>�&×_³�����Õ¿���O�����´�O�>��ÓK�@��Õ��N���<�<�>ÓH�D���OÕO���O�N��D;<æ�;lA5;/6�?Zé@?�;�6�C^èE;I6�?Zé�G>X�évæ X-apé<S�? 65?Xé�y<;G-aMæ�C^èÝ? 4 ;�8NG>XY;<æ�bVæZé<XY8�é�?�;l?�;�vN?�Z>CYC<y}<?Zé�GY?�C<G'é�G>Xfo 4 çH?�;rF r ®MGpï�6j;FSFõ²m�õ î R m�õL¡/õEw_CVæ�;E6�C<= 4 ç76�?;ç7S<é�?�;FXf?,æ�;¢é@?,èE;GY? 6<ï&;<è R= 4 é<6¤ç�JXçHGNb'æ�;=�æ�;F6�;GY?Zé�?�ç[CUGg? 4 ;CVæ,êxa¯C^æ�? 4 ;²6;ê/è-èE;?�æ;ç7SEb^æ:C<8N=.ï�S<é�GtZ>;Pa�C<8NG>X[çHG}Pé�bPé�G$F rUr G¤ïkw[é<Sä�CUG�éKJ7X$FÄm^ìMG � éFèP;F6#é�G>X�g�;<æ:Z>;<æjF ó^ìMGpï&}<?Zé@GYJ[;<êEF r ¡MGpõ

òÝ��ÑU�ZÓM×hÓM×kâVãzµ¿Ï \-µ�ßK�F�K�F���¶µU7 `IC�a�é�G4çHGY?�;b<;<æ_�¸· ñ çi6mét6�;FTU8N;G>S�;pA?çH? 4µ ß ·¹µ à ·§�K�F��· ñ-é�G>XEº õ µ õ Ï �$õ�of;-èÅé~ê�ç7XY;Gu?;çLaMê é-=�éFæ�?�ç[?�ç[CUG4µcA?çH? 4 çH? 6é<6�6�CNS�çké�?�;FXxî.ÕF���;ÕF��Ù ´^×hÑF�U��ÑVÖ�C@a0�cS�;�JLJ76DA?çH? 4 µNõ S�;�JLJi6 çHG�æ�C�A]Ü,ïNX/æZéKADGmé<6D6 4 C|A£GZ>;�JHC�A�õ 354 ;-Ô/â¢â�ê-à�Õ¢ãY�^ÓhÔx»)¼5C�a�éES�;�JLJOø>ç[G'é-ô�;<æ,æ�;<æ 6£XVç²é@b^æZéFè ç76£? 4 ;�GY8�èIZ>;<æ�C�aS�;�J¢J76LçHGp? 4 ;n6�;?/S�CUG>6¤ç76�?;çHGNbcC�as? 4 ;-S�;�J¢J76l?�Cx? 4 ;-æ;çHb 4 ?�C�a�ø ç[G çH? 6�æ:C|ALï&? 4 ;nS�;�JLJ76Z>;�JHC�A ø>çHGmçH? 6£S�C�JH8�èEG.ïÌé@G>XqS�;�J¢JOø>çH? 6�;�JLa,õ

µnÏ]\;îN� r ��mN��mN�<ñ�`»S¼�Ï rS

òd\�6�?Zé�G>X�éFæ�X�`>½ â^ÛPãY�mÓMÑPܱàÀÕXÑ^Û-C�aD6 4 é�=>;@µ ç76�émôN;<æ�æ�;<æ 6�XVçké�b^æZévèùA?çH? 4 ? 4 ;ES�;�JLJ76CkSS�8N=/çH;FX-Z/ê�? 4 ;DGY8�èIZ>;<æ 6>ñ<�Zó��F�F�������ç[G-6�8>S 4 é�A é~êl? 4 é�? ? 4 ;DGY8�èIZ>;<æ 6 çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6�;éKJHC<GNbn;¢éUS 4 æ�C�A é�G>XxXYC|A£Gq;¢é<S 4 S�C@J[8�èPG.õ�ð2v�éFèE=YJH;F6�éFæ�;7çHGc? 4 ;�=/ç7S�?�8�æ�;lZ>;�JHC�A�õ354 ;IGu8�èIZ>;<æ�C@a�b C<8NGNbq?Xé�ZYJH;¢é�8YvzC�a�éPbFçH9<;Gp6 4 é�=�;@µmç76�XY;GNC<?�;FXqZ/ê]*U¾-é�G>X ç76bFçH9<;GnZ/êE? 4 ;LÔPâ~â�êO©<â<�XÖ�Û/à�Ñ�C�a ô�æXéFèE; R �5C<Z/çHG>6�C<GWV�6�;;�}<?Xé�Gu?:C<GÅé�G>XPo 4 ç[?:;xF r ®�G354 ;C^æ�;<è î�õ r õç Í�ègècÊ ¹C¿ É|i�ÍCi�k�k�À�ÁÂk�lUè$ÃWÌHÊ�Ä* ¾ Ï �2ÅÆ ¼ »S¼ �

354 ;7ÚÌرÔPÕ¢ã�Ù`ÓMÕ�´5\^CVæ��5CUZ/ç[G>6jC<G R }uS 4 ;G>6j?�;FX R g�Gu8N? 4 `#ØZâU� �;Õ<Ù���âVã>´^Õ~ã�ØXÕ çi6}éDZ/ç�À�;FS R?;çHC<GIZ>;?�A5;;G�=>;<æ�è/8N?Xé�?;çHC<G>62C�a��ES<évæ XN6"é�G>X�CVæ XY;<æ�;FXl=�é~çoæ 62C�aSb C<8NGNb�?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8YvIC�a6¤ç�J;��-A?çH? 4 ? 4 ;D6,évèE;�\^8NG>6�=>;FS�çL¶>;FX�`O6 4 é�=�;�µ.õ 354 ;5;�vPç76�?�;G>S�;�C�a�6�8>S 4 é�Z/ç�À�;FS�?;çHC<GçºèP=YJÀçH;F6�? 4 ;�a¯CVæ,èI8YJ²é ��ÅNÏÈǾMÉ�( * à¾A 4 ;<æ�; µ@Ên� ç76�é�G�é@ZNZ�æ�;9^çké�?�ç[CUGqa�C^æx�Mµ�çi67éI=�éFæ:?;çH?;çHC<G_C�a ����õ354 ;l?BA5CE?Xé�ZYJH;¢é�8YvÒéFæ�;IS<éKJLJ[;FX ? 4 ; a�R ?Zé@ZYJ[;¢é@8*é@G>Xq? 4 ;jË R ?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8.õ>ò 6£A?çH? 4=�é�?;çH;G>S�;�6�C^æ:?;çHGNb�ïF? 4 ;QS�CVæ,æ�;F6�=�C<G>XY;G>S�;�S<é�GlZ>;�S�C<G>6j?,æ�8>S�?�;FX ç[G>XY8>S�?�ç[9U;�JºêPZPêI6�=>;FS Rç¢aMêVç[GNbfA 4 ;<æ�;q?�Cx=YJ²éUS�;q? 4 ;qGN;�vk?ES<éFæ�Xjõ]�5CU8Nb 4 Joê¦6�=>;¢é�yVçHGNb�ï+éx?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8 ç76IS�C<G R6�?,æ�8>S�?�;FXPZ/ê¸é æ�;FS�8�æ 6¤çH9<;�8>6j;DC�a�=�é�?�ç[;G>S�;�6�C^æ:?;çHGNb�õ2o 4 ;Gmé�S<évæ X�ç765S�C�9<;<æ�;FXjïvç[?}ç76

¬

Page 9: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

èEC�9<;FX�é�bPé~çHG-é<SS�C^æ XVçHGNb�?�C�=�é@?;çH;G>S�;�6�C^æ�?�ç[GNb�é�=N=YJ�çH;FXE?:C�? 4 ;DS<éFæ XN6"é�?2? 4 ;D6�;FS�C<G>XJ[;9U;�J ïjé�G>Xx6�CEC<G.õ2¤^G èEC^æ�;�XY;?Xé~çLJ¥Vå�J²éUS�;�? 4 ;�GN;�vN?QS<évæ X�çHGq? 4 ;�?�C<=�æ�C�A¦C�a�? 4 ; a�R ?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8.ï/çHGq? 4 ;�=>CY6¤ç R?;çHC<GqC@a�? 4 ;�6�èÅéKJLJH;F6�? 4 çHb 4 ;<æ R GY8�èIZ>;<æ�;FXcS<éFæ X�çLa+é�G/ên;�v/ç76�? 6�\^? 4 ;<æ�;ZPê��ZN8�èP=/ç[GNbU��? 4 é�?5S<éFæ X�`Zï�CVæ�é�=N=�;G>XE?�C�? 4 ;�æ;çHb 4 ?O;G>XPC�a�? 4 ;£?�C<=-æ�C�AçLa�GNC�6�8>S 4I4 ç[b 4 ;<æ R Gu8�èIZ�;<æ�;FXnS<évæ X�;�v/ç76�? 6<õ2¤�a.é�S<éFæ X çi62ZN8�èP=>;FXjïNS�C<G R6¤ç7XY;<æ�? 4 ; a�R ?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8EA?çH? 4 ?�C<=�æ:C|A¦XY;�JH;?�;FXjï/é�G>X�æ�;FS�8�æ�6¤çH9<;�Joê/8>6j;D? 4 ;6,évèE;�æ�8YJH;�?�C�çHG>6�;<æ�?5? 4 ;�ZN8�èE=�;FXqS<éFæ XLçHGY?�CI? 4 ;�æ�;<èÅé�ç[G/çHGNbE?Xé�ZYJH;¢é�8.õ354 ç76�;9<;GY?�8�éKJLJoê�êVçH;�J7XN6�éPGN;A a�R ?Zé@ZYJ[;¢é@8zA 4 Cu6�;E6 4 é�=�;�ç76�? 4 ;I=�æ�; R9VçHC<8>6�?Zé@ZYJ[;¢é@8pA?çH? 4 C<GN;P;�vk?,æXé_S�;�JLJpõ²w[é�yU;/? 4 ;EGN;AÌË R ?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8pZ�;? 4 ;£=�æ�;9^çHC<8>6�Ë R ?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8-A?çH? 4 ? 4 ç76�;�vk?,æXé�S�;�JLJé�G>XEA ç[? 4 ? 4 ;�GY8�è/Z�;<æÍ çHG_? 4 é�?DS�;�J¢Jpï&A 4 ;<æ:;�? 4 ;�é<XNXY;FXqS<évæ X�ç765? 4 ; Í Ã ? 4 S<éFæ XqXY;¢éKJH?¢õ

354 ;�¶>b<8�æ:;7ç¢JLJH8>6�?,æXé�?�;F6£? 4 ;�S�C<G>6�?,æ:8>S�?;çHC<G_C<GqCU8�æ�æ�8NGNG/çHGNbn;�v�éFèE=YJH;^õó ¡ñó

óI¬¡ñ�mó

ñ�¬ó ¡ñ�mór

ñ�móI¬¡ñ�mó�îr

ñ�m róI¬¡ñ�m-ëó�îr

ñ�m r ñ¢ìóE¬¡ñ�m�ë-¡ó-îr

ñ�m r ëóE¬�ñ¢ì¡ñ�m�ë-¡ó-îI¬r

ñ�m r ëI®óE¬�ñ¢ì¡ñ�m�ë-¡�®ó-îI¬r

ñ�m r îE®ó�ëmñ¢ì¡�¬ñ�m-ëP¡/®ó�îE¬r ñ~ì

å

ÎÏ©ÐÒÑ Ã�lKÍ · �7íOC<G>6�?,æ:8>S�?;çHGNb�? 4 ;l}uS 4 ;G>6j?�;FXnS�CVæ,æ�;F6�=�C<G>XY;G>S�;�a¯CVæO? 4 ;�=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé R?;çHC<Gp¡ ó ¬Añ§m r ñ~ì�ë­®�î�õ

¤^?�çi6-GNCU? 4 éFæ X�?�Ch6j;;_? 4 é�?P? 4 ;zS�C^æ�æ�;F6�=>CUG>XY;G>S�;gS<é�G¦Z�;_A5C^æ�yU;FXeZ�é<S:yuA�éFæ�XN6<õ354 8>6�aMæ�C^èù? 4 ;P¶>G�éKJ a é�G>XCË ç[Gt? 4 ;-;�v�évèE=YJH;fé�Z�C�9<;^ï2? 4 ;E=>CY6¤çH?;çHC<GeC�a�ñ¢ì�çHG? 4 ; Ë R ?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8*ç[G>XVç7S<é�?:;FXpA 4 ;<æ:;/? 4 ;�Jké<6j?�Z>CKvzA�é<67é<XNXY;FXjõIÁ&CuCUy^çHGNb�é�?�? 4 ; a�R?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8.ïN? 4 ç76 4 é�=N=>;GN;FXxZ/ên? 4 ;�ëIZN8�èE=/çHGNbq? 4 ;�¬�ïYA 4 ç7S 4 A�é<6DS<é�8>6j;FX-ZPêq? 4 ;�îZN8�èE=/çHGNbq? 4 ;�ë�ïN6�CnÛ2\Xñ¢ìY`2Ï î�õΣC<?�;7çHG_=�éFæ:?;ç7S�8YJ²évæ� 354 ;I?�CU=Òæ:C|ABçHGp? 4 ; a�R ?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8*çi6�? 4 ;�6�éFèE;-é<6�? 4 ;�æ�C�A�C�aO?�C<=pS<éFæ XN6>çHG=�é�?�ç[;G>S�;I6�C^æ�?�ç[GNb õ

}<C/? 4 ;DJH;GNb<? 4 C@a)? 4 ;�?�CU=Åæ�C�A�ç[G-? 4 ;&b C<8NGNbE?Zé@ZYJ[;¢é@8fé<6:6�CkS�çké�?:;FXEA?çH? 4 él=>;<æ,èI8 R?Zé�?;çHC<GcÛ[ç76�? 4 ;lJH;GNb<? 4 æ�\BÛ2` C�aO? 4 ;�JHC<GNbU;F6�?�çHG>SXæ�;¢éU6¤çHGNbz6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;EC�asÛ�õ 354 ;

®

Page 10: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

;�vPç76�?�;G>S�;qC@aQ? 4 ;nZ/ç�À�;FS�?;çHC<GeGNC�A éKJLJHC�A�6�8>6l?�CxA�æ;çH?�;mé-a�C^æ,èI8YJké-a�C^æ�? 4 ;-=�æ�C<Z�é RZ/ç¢J�çH?;ê a \�Z_(qÏ�æ�`5? 4 é�?�? 4 ;�J[CUGNb<;F6�?7çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6¤çHGNb_6�;FTU8N;G>S�;EC�a�éP8NG/çLa¯CVæ,èAæZé�G>XYC^è=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?�ç[CUGqC�as°/ñ<�ZóN�K�F���� ��± 4 éU6�JH;GNb<? 4 æ;õÓ lMk�Ô�k�Õ ÐÒÖ�Ð kvצº a \!Z_(Eϳæ�` Ï ñ��Å Ç ØdÙ�Ú¾�Û!Ü&ô *ྠ� \BmY`

Ò���Ò Ýc�O�&Ö��OÓ��^Óq�V�����O�t�&Ó���Þß� �<�&�<�^�NÓ3 CIb<;?�é<6;ê/èE=N?�CU?;ç7S6 a�C^æ©Z_(�aIæ�CVèÚ? 4 ;�}uS 4 ;G>6�?�;FXqS�C^æ�æ�;F6�=>CUG>XY;G>S�;^ï>A5;�S�C<G>6¤ç7XY;<æ¢ïç[G>6j?�;¢é<XeC@aOÀB8>6j?E? 4 ;q?�C<=�æ:C|ALï�? 4 ;z6 4 é�=�;qC�a�? 4 ;qA 4 C�JH;q?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8.õÔÁ&;? à&á (Hâ Ï\�à á (Hâõ ã Ü_· ñ@`�Z�;�é-\�GNC<G R 8NG/çLa¯C^æ�èq`+æZé�G>XYCVè­=�éFæ�?;çH?;çHC<GxC�aO�_A ç[? 4 XVçi6j?,æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<G

a \�à á (Hâ Ïpµ&`OVLÏL* à¾äã ��ÅYÏ ��Å ã \�å ¼ »)¼�` àS�C^æ,æ�;F6�=�C<G>XVçHGNbn?:C/? 4 ; 4 CuC<yPa�C^æ,èI8YJké-\BÁ&;<è-è�éEmY`Zõ 354 C<8Nb 4 ? 4 ;�6 4 é�=�;F6�\�é�G>Xq6�C? 4 ;n=�æ:C<Z�é�Z/çLJ�ç[?�ç[;F6 `�C�a�XVçL{);<æ:;Gu?I=�éFæ�?�ç[?�ç[CUG>6�9FéFæ,êcA?ç7XY;�Joê^ï"çH? çi6lG�é�?:8�æZéKJs?:C_b<8N;F6�6\^ZPê�é�G�éKJHC<b^êEA ç[? 4 S:J²éU6�6¤ç7S<éKJæ�;F6j8YJ[?�6}çHG_6�?Zé�?;ç76�?�çiS<é|J)= 4 êN6¤ç7S65C^æ`�:JkéFæ�b<;�XY;9Vç²é@?;çHC<G>6d�ç[Gx=�æ�C<Z�é�Z/çLJ�çH?;ê_? 4 ;C^æ�ê>` ? 4 é�?Qa¯C^æ�JkéFæ�bU;��c? 4 ;�XVç76�?,æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<G ç76�S�C<G>S�;Gu?�æZé�?�;FX-GN;¢éFæ? 4 ;ÅèPCu6�?lJ�ç[yU;�Jºêe6 4 é�=�;^õp¤�?�ç76l;¢é<6;êf?�CcC<8N?�J�çHGN;�é�G éU6;êPèP=N?�C<?;ç7S�é�G�éKJoêk6�çi6�A 4 ç7S 4S�C<GY¶�æ,èn6�? 4 ç76<õ 354 ; 4 CYC<yqJH;GNb<? 4 a¯C^æ�éqS�;�JLJ�\BÜ:� : `5\^? 4 ; : Ã�? 4 S�;�J¢J}çHG'æ�C�A Üj`+çHG é=�éFæ�?;çH?;çHC<G�µnÏ]\-µkõ¥` 4 é<6 » á õçæ 7�â[è µNõS? : <Lµ ö>ß7 ?tÜA 4 ;<æ�;rµ ö>ß XY;GNCU?�;F6�? 4 ;�çHGu9U;<æ 6�;Pa¯8NG>S�?;çHC<G�é�G>XfA 4 ;<æ�; è çHG>XVç7S<é�?�;F6-é 4 ;8�æ;ç76�?;ç7Sé�=N=�æ�CKvPçoèÅé@?;çHC<G.õ��5;F6�S<é|J[;l? 4 ;�æ:C|A R J[;GNbU? 4 65C�a¬µn?�C-XY;�¶>GN;

é ¾ \!ê&` Ï � ö>ßdw�à µ_ë ( ÛÂì�í!î~ï ã êr· ìN�354 ;G J[CUb å ¼ »S¼ è ß à �£JHC<bs�@< ��ðf\ é ¾Y`A 4 ;<æ�;

ðp\!ñW` VLÏ�ò �� òró á î â� JHC<b ô«ñ�\�ê)`V?Cõ�<4ñ ö>ß \!õN`�?$ê÷ö¢*0õ@*0ê��354 ç765JH;¢é<XN6£?�C a \�à á (Hâ Ïpµ&` è ;�vN= ô ?�ó<��\�ðf\ é ¾U`�< ßà <�y<\Xñ�`�` ö \ r `

ñ¢ì

Page 11: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

354 ;Åé�=N=�æ�CKv/çoèÅé�?;çHC<Ge\ r `�6�8Nb<b<;F6j? 6�? 4 é�?�? 4 ;�æZé�G>XYC^è ?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8Yv$à á (Hâ XYC 4 éK9<;ÅéJÀçoè�çH?�XY;?�;<æ,è�çHG/ç76�?;ç7SI6 4 é�=�; ã èPC^æ�;�=�æ�;FS�ç76�;�Joê^ï&? 4 é�?5? 4 ;�æZé�G>XYCVè­=�æ�CNS�;F6�6&ø2(�\�ê&` Ï� ö>ßdw:à à á (+âë ( ÛÂìçí�î~ï C�aæ�;F6�S<é|J[;FX æ�C�A R JH;GNb<? 4 6DS�CUGu9<;<æ:b<;F6�?�CE? 4 ;�a�8NG>S�?;çHC<G3ñ R \�ê&`�A 4 ç7S 46�C�JH9<;F65? 4 ;IS<éKJ7S�8YJH8>6�C�a�9�évæ;çké�?;çHC<G>6£=�æ�C<ZYJH;<èè�çHG/çºè¸çKJ;@ðp\!ñW` C�9<;<æ5GNC<G/çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6�ç[GNb3ñcVY\;ìN�6se`�qùF ìN�¶se` A?çH? 4 ò �� ñ�\�ê&`�*Uê-Ï9ñU�¤^?5?�8�æ�G>6�C<8N?�? 4 é�?5? 4 ;7è�çHG/çºè¸çKJXçHGNbPa¯8NG>S�?�ç[CUG3ñ R \!ê&`.ç76�J;<æ�CIC<8N? 6�çiXY; F{ìN�ZóHG¤ï�é�G>X-CUGF ìN�Zó�G�ç76�6j=>;FS�çL¶>;FXx9^çké

ñ R \�ê&` Ï óUÛ ö>ß \B6�ç[G&ú�?4ú S�Cu6÷úU` �&ê-Ï�ñ R \�ê)`�< óOS�Cu6÷úY� ìj9Lú 9¦Û0�¤^G-=�éFæ�?;ç7S�8YJkéFæ¢ï÷ñ R \�ìY`2Ï ó�õ�}FçHG>S�;`Z ( çi6�? 4 ;QJ[;GNbU? 4 C@a)? 4 ;D?�C<=-æ:C|AeC@a)? 4 ;D?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8é<6�6�CNS�çké�?�;FXqA ç[? 4 à á (+â ïYC<GN;�ç76�JH;FXx?�CIZ>;�J�çH;9<;

� ö>ßdw:à Z_(EÏßø2(�\�ìY`�q°ñ R \�ìY` Ï óN�354 ç76�évæ�b<8�èE;GY?OA�é<6�XY;9<;�JHC<=>;FX�æ;çHb<CVæ�C<8>6�JoêEZ/êEÁ&C<bPé�Gmé�G>X�} 4 ;=N=]F{ó<®MG�A 4 C�8>6�;FXç[?�?�CES�C<G>S:JH8>XY; \AF;Z_(HG�·³\�ó&<4yU\Zñ@`�`B� ßdw�à �f ;<æ 6 4 çHy é�G>X$g�;<æ:C|9CF î^î/ïó r ï.îVëHG$çHG>XY;=>;G>XY;GY?�JoêeC<8N?�J�çHGN;FXp? 4 ;-6,éFèE;-éFæ�bU8�èE;Gu?a¯C^æl? 4 ç76�JHC�A5;<æ�Z>CU8NG>X'é�G>X é�G éFæ�bU8�èE;Gu?�a�C^æ�? 4 ;P8N=N=>;<æIZ>C<8NG>XC\@F8Z_(HG©9Â\;ó�<y<\Xñ�`�`B� ßdw�à õ 354 ç76£=�æ�C�9^ç7XY;FXx? 4 ;�¶�æ 6�?D=�æ�CYC�a C�a 354 ;C^æ�;<èAó�õ5}<8NZ>6�;FTU8N;GY?�JoêmçH?�A�é<6=�æ�C�9<;FX�çHG*å çLJ[=�;�JWF r ìMGW? 4 é@?+çHGxapé<S�?W\@F8Z_(HG�9 ó<� ßdw�à a�C^æ�éKJLJ0� ã A5; 4 éK9<;�éKJ76�Cn6�;;Gé�Gc\�é�=N=�éFæ:;Gu?�Joê-8NGN=N8NZYJ�çi6 4 ;FX&`�6¤çoèE=YJH;I=�æ�CYC�a�C@a�? 4 ç765Z/ê@f ;<æ 6�yVç[y R g�;<æ�C�9ÌõÒ���� û­�W�<�C�O��ÓK�@���H�����j�O���<�^�>���N�pÓ��W���<�^���wÒé|J¢JHC�A�6&FÄm^óMGjæ�;FS�C^æ�XN6 4 C�A 4 ; XVç76�S�C�9<;<æ�;FX-? 4 é�?O? 4 ;�GY8�è/Z�;<æDC�aW=/çLJH;F6?çHG-=�é�?;çH;G>S�;6�C^æ�?;çHGNbmæ�;�Jké�?:;F6�?�C�b C<8NGNbq?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8Yv.õI��évæ�?�C<G�FÄm�ñ~G2=>CFçHGY?�;FXcC<8N?�? 4 ;�S�CUGNGN;FS�?;çHC<GA?çH? 4 ? 4 ;-}uS 4 ;G>6�?�;FXpS�C^æ�æ�;F6�=>CUG>XY;G>S�;^õ I�6¤çHGNbx? 4 ;F6�;^ï�w[éKJLJHC�A�6�=�æ�C�9<;FXx? 4 é�?�? 4 ;S 4 é�G>S�;£? 4 é�?2=�é�?;çH;G>S�; 6jC^æ�?;çHGNb�êVç[;�J7XN65æN=/çLJH;F6?é�G>X�éKJ76�C�êVçH;�J7XN6ýüQ=/ç¢JH;F6�A 4 ;GE=YJké~ê<;FXA?çH? 4 ? 4 ;pXY;FS�y�ç[GBæ�;9<;<æ 6�;FX�C^æ XY;<æq;FTU8�éKJ76-? 4 ;p6�8�è \BmY`la�8�æ�? 4 ;<æ�æ�;F6�?,æ;ç7S�?�;FXÔ?�C?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8Yv$µnA ç[? 4 üLæ�C�A�6<õÒ���Q �����<�^���O�N�tÓ|�����<�^�O�þ���W�cÕO�>�´ÿ Ó��_�����¿�<�S�£�>���<�>ÕzTW�&Ö^×��>Ó¤^Gc=YJké¢êVçHGNbn=�é@?;çH;G>S�;n6�C^æ�?�ç[GNbPA?çH? 4 æ�;¢é|J0S<éFæ�XN65A5;/S�C<8YJ7X æ�;bPéFæ�XméKJLJ0S<éFæ�XN6DC�a ? 4 ;6,éFèE;LæZé�GNyp\�;^õ�b�õ#é|J¢J a�C<8�æ�¬NÃÄ6�`?é<6�;FT<8�é|J õ�op;I? 4 ;G 4 éK9<;l?BA5CE=�Cu6�6¤çHZYJH;�æ�8YJH;F6£a¯C^æ

ñ^ñ

Page 12: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

=YJ²é~êVçHGNb>V�;XçH? 4 ;<æ�ÓM×kÕ±Ù-Ñ^àkà�â<ª"Õ�´^ï�;^õ�b�õ-é�Gp¬mè�é¢êxZ>;E=YJké~ê<;FXcCUGp?�C<=cC�a�é�GNC<? 4 ;<æ�¬�ïC^æ�ÓM×hÕ<Ù ©<â<�<Ü<×÷´<´^Õ~ã�õ�Á);?�8>6>çHG>XVç7S<é�?�; 4 C�A�? 4 ;>��?;çH;F6Qa¯CVæ�Z/ç7XNXY;GS�qbPéFèP;�=>;<æ,è�çH? 6�éXY;9<;�JHC<=�èE;GY?#æ�;�Jké�?:;FXq?�CI? 4 ;P}uS 4 ;G>6�?:;FX_S�C^æ,æ:;F6�=>C<G>XY;G>S�;^õw[é�? 4 ;<èÅé@?;ç7S<éKJLJºê^ï�S�C<G>6�çiXY;<æ[é�G]� R S<éFæ X]XY;FS:y¦A?çH? 4 ó<õIS<éFæ XN6PJké�Z>;�JH;FX�Ü,ïQa¯C^æñ`9³Ü_9��Lõ?ôNC^æ?çHG>6�?Xé�G>S�;^ïÌéPXY;FS�yqA?çH? 4 � Ï ®-é�G>Xxóuß Ï óYà£Ï ó���Ï m�è¸ç[b 4 ?�Z>;ç[GxC^æ XY;<æ

ó m ñ�óEm ñ�ó ñ�må2Jké~ê^çHGNb-A?çH? 4 ?;çH;F65a�C^æ�Z/ç7XNXY;G æ�;F6�8YJH? 6 ç[Gx? 4 ;�¶>G�éKJ�S�CUGY¶>b<8�æZé�?;çHC<G

óñ móñ

mómm354 ;<æ�;�éFæ�;£a¯C<8�æ5=/çLJH;F6<ï�é�G>XPC<GN;�S<é�G_S 4 ;FS�yE? 4 é�?"çHGq? 4 ;�C^æ;çHbFçHG�éKJ�XY;FS:yE? 4 ;£J[CUGNb<;F6�?As;¢é@y<Joê çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6¤çHGNbz6j8NZ>6�;FT<8N;G>S�; 4 é<6 J[;GNbU? 4 a�C<8�æ¢õ 354 ç76�S�C<GNGN;FS�?;çHC<G*çi6�b<;GN;<æZéKJ

é�G>Xjï^é�G�éKJHC<b<CU8>6�Joê�?�C�=�;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?;çHC<G>6±ïFbFçH9<;F6"é£Z/ç�ÀB;FS�?�ç[CUG/Z�;?�As;;GI? 4 ;�� (� Û�� � ��� XY;FS:yC^æ XY;<æ 6}é�G>XE=�é�çºæ�6D\ a �«ËI`WC@aVb CU8NGNb�?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8Yv-C�aW? 4 ; 6�éFèE;�6 4 é@=>;NµEA?çH? 4 Ë�6�?Zé@G RX�éFæ X�é�G>X a Ù<Õ¢Ö�×iñpÙ<ÓMÑ^ã>´VÑ<��´I\^? 4 é�?�ç76<ï/æ�C�A�6?éFæ�;DA5;¢é�yUJoê-çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6�ç[GNb�é�G>XqS�C�JH8�èEG>6éFæ�;D6�?,æ;ç7S�?�JoêLçHG>SXæ�;¢é<6¤çHGNb�ïY? 4 ;£;Gu?,æ�ç[;F60Z>;XçHGNbEó<õ æ�;=>;¢é@? 6 C�aWÜ�`Zõ 354 ;DGY8�èIZ>;<æOC@a)S�;�JLJ76ç[Gc? 4 ;l¶�æ 6j?#æ�C�A]C@aO? 4 ;ES�C^è-èEC<Gc6 4 é�=�;Aµ çi6�? 4 ;�JH;GNb<? 4 C�aO? 4 ;lJHC<GNb<;F6j?�A5;¢é�yUJoêç[G>SXæ:;¢é<6¤çHGNb_6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;^õ�ô�C^æD? 4 ;�XY;FS:yqC^æ XY;<æ�é�Z�C�9<;^ï

åñ-ñ�ñ�mó-ó�ómEm Î ñ�ó�îE®m r ¡

ëE¬ò�6;êPèP=N?�C<?;ç7S6)a¯C^æ bU;GN;<æZéKJ&\Bó<õ�` 4 éF9U;sGNCU?�Z�;;Gn6�?�8>XVçH;FXjõO�£C�As;9U;<æ¢ïF? 4 ;Q6j=>;FS�çkéKJS<é<6�;n�ÔÏ��&��ó ß ÏÚó à Ï�� ã óc\�a�C^æ�;9<;G���`�ç76 çºèP=YJÀç7S�çH?�ç[GeS:Jké<6�6¤ç7S<éKJ5=�æ�C<Z�é�Z/çLJ�çH?;ê^õo'æ;çH?�; � á@\BÜ�` ÏÐ\OGu8�èIZ�;<æDC�a�ñ<ÃÄ6}çHG_=�Cu6¤çH?;çHC<G>6Lñ�? 4 æ�CU8Nb 4 Ü�`2? õà ��O;FS<é@8>6�; étA5;¢é�yUJºê�çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6¤çHGNb]6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;hS�CUG>6¤ç76�? 6-C�aI? 4 ;�ñ<ÃÄ6-8N=³?�C¦6�C^èP;=>Cu6¤çH?;çHC<GpÜ?é�G>Xx? 4 ;�óNÃÄ65? 4 ;<æ:;¢éKa¯?:;<æ¢ï�çH?>ç76�;¢é<6;êq?�Cn6j;;/? 4 é�?D? 4 ;�J[;GNbU? 4 ZOáIC�a ? 4 ;J[CUGNb<;F6�?DA5;¢é�yUJoê�ç[G>SXæ:;¢é<6¤çHGNb²6j8NZ>6�;FT<8N;G>S�;Lç76ZOá�Ï áà < ó"èÅéKvõ

� á@\BÜ�`��}<CÅé<6��@q sa \�Z á 9 á à < ó�� ßdw:à ê)`OÏ a \�� ö>ßdw�à è�éKvõ � á \BÜj`�9Lê&`_q ñ©?�� ö�à î íZPêeS:Jké<6�6¤ç7S<éKJ#æ:;F6�8YJH? 6IC<GtA5;¢é�ygS�C<GY9<;<æ�b<;G>S�;qC@a 6,éFèE=YJ�çHGNbp=�æ�CNS�;F6�6�;F6�?�Cp�+æ:C|A£G Rç²é@GeZ�æ;ç7XYb<;c\«FL¡6G�\Zñ^ñ^õ r ìY`#é�G>X 354 ;CVæ�;<è ó r õoñ�`XõzwxC^æ�;-6�C<= 4 ç76�?;ç7S<é�?�;FX�æ�;F6�8YJH? 6ICUGé�G�éKJHC<b<C<8>6Q=�æ�C<ZYJH;<èn67éFæ�;�èE;GY?;çHC<GN;FX�é@?s? 4 ;�;G>X-C�aO6�;FS�?;çHC<G r õoñ^õ

ñ¢ó

Page 13: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

� Õ~Ö�Ñ<��ê<«�MDGN;�S�C<8YJ7X�éKJ76�C�é�G�éKJoêUJ;�? 4 ;O� ?;çH;F6+éKJLJHC�As;FX÷��bPéFèE;}çHGn6¤çoèE=YJH;�S<é<6�;F6<õ�O8N?�? 4 ;<æ�;?ç76�GNC�Z/ç�À�;FS�?;çHC<GqZ>;?�A5;;GE? 4 ç76Q\^C^æ�é@GPêlC<? 4 ;<æs6jC�J�ç[?Xé~çoæ�;�b/éFèE;DA5;5yuGNC�A�`é�G>Xq=�é~çoæ 6QC�a�b CU8NGNbE?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8Yv_A?çH? 4 Z�C<? 4 ?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8Yv_6�;<è�ç R 6�?Zé�G>X�évæ Xjõ� �¦(W*W¨�§©¨-16ª1���'21 .c®°£�'�¡/*�+��� �^~ ��×�ØO�&ÕOÕ����<��TO�¥�6��#éFè�èE;<æ 6�JH;<ê$FoñF®MGWb/éF9U;�é�æ�;=�æ�;F6�;GY?Zé�?�ç[CUG_C�a�Z_(�çHG_?�;<æ,è-65C�a+éÅå2CFç76�6jC<GmæZé�G>XYC^è=�æ�CkS�;F6:6IC�a�=�CFçHGu? 6�ç[GÔ? 4 ;qT<8�é<X/æXé�Gu?�F ì��6se` à {e6�;;c\�ëY`Zõ 3Q4 ;q=N8�æ�=>Cu6j;qC�a�? 4 é�?æ�;=�æ�;F6�;GY?Zé�?;çHC<G ç76-éc6�8N=>;<æXé<XNXVçH?;çH9^çH?;êe=�æ�C<=�;<æ�?;êpA 4 ç7S 4 ;¢éU6¤çLJºê çoèE=YJ�çH;F6A\@F8Z ( G&uø� ß-w�à a¯C^æ_6jC^èE;c8NG>6�=>;FS�çL¶>;FXåøFõ­�#éFè�èE;<æ 6�JH;<ê&ÃÄ6qS�C<G>6�?,æ:8>S�?;çHC<G ç76xGNC|A�é<X�é~êN6Åé?�;�vk?:Z>CYC<y�é�=N=YJ�ç7S<é�?;çHC<Gq\«F²ñFmMG�ð�v�éFèP=YJ[;?ë�õL¡Põ{óY`>C�a>? 4 ;>Ù`Û�Ü�Ñ<´<´^×hÓM×7ð~Õ#ÕK���^âF´V×kØ�ÓhÔ/ÕZâ<�;Õ~Ö�ïA 4 ç7S 4 ç[GxC<8�æ�S�C<GY?�;�vN??çoèE=YJ�çH;F6

a \! �� ö>ßdw�à Z_(j?pø� �"�#U`�q ìN�$#%" ìN��O8N?£? 4 ;F6�;�èE;? 4 CNXN6DXYCEGNCU?QXVçoæ�;FS�?jJºêc6�=>;FS�çLaMêq? 4 ;�9�é|J[8N;lC�a�øFïNA 4 çiS 4 aMæ�C^è 354 ;C Ræ�;<è óIA5;�yYGNC|AÐ;FT<8�éKJ767ó�õ� ��Ò Ýc�¿�^���@���<�&�Y�<�^�O� �O�&���<�^�NÖ��$�O�U� �N�>Ó�Ó¤^G>6�?�;¢éUXIC�aW? 4 çHGNy^çHGNbIC�a&? 4 ;�S<éFæ XN6 çHGfé�G-� R S<évæ XEXY;FS:y/Z�;XçHGNb�Jké�Z�;�JH;FXx°Pñ<�Zó��F�F������W±é�G>Xc6 4 8Y�-;FX çHGu?�CmæXé�G>XYC^èÝC^æ XY;<æ¢ï&A5;ES<é�Gc;FT<8/çH9FéKJH;Gu?�Joêp? 4 ç[GNycC�aO? 4 ;�Jké�Z�;�J76�CUG6�8>SS�;F6�6¤çH9<;gS<évæ XN6-Z>;XçHGNb�çHG>XY;=�;G>XY;Gu?[æZé�G>XYCVè æ�;¢éKJ�Gu8�èIZ>;<æ�6<ï�8NG/ç¢a�C^æ,è�Jºê]XVç76 R?,æ;çHZN8N?�;FXcC<G F ìN�¢ñ¶Gpõ 354 ;E=�CFçHGu?lC�as? 4 çi6 æ�;�a�C^æ,èI8YJké�?;çHC<G[ç76�? 4 é�?�A5;�S<é@GgS�C^èE=�éFæ:;S�C<GY¶>b<8�æZé�?�ç[CUG>6�é<6O�x9FéFæ;çH;F6<õ+ô�C^æ5;¢é<S 4 �cS�C<G>6¤ç7XY;<æD? 4 ;£Jké�Z>;�J76£C<G-? 4 ;�?�C<=qS<éFæ XPC�a;¢é<S 4 =/ç¢JH;méKa�?�;<æ��gS<évæ XN6 4 éK9<;IZ>;;Gf=YJ²é~ê<;FXjï$é�G>X çHGY?�;<æ�=�æ�;?l? 4 ;F6�;lJké�Z>;�J76�é<6�? 4 ;=>Cu6¤çH?;çHC<G>6lC�a`��=�éFæ�?�çiS:JH;F6d��C<G�F ìN�~ñ6Gpõ 354 ;�æ�8YJH;Ia¯CVæ�=YJ²é~êVçHGNbz=�é@?;çH;G>S�;n6�C^æ�?�ç[GNbxZ>; RS�C^èE;F65? 4 ;�a�C�JLJHC�A?çHGNbÅæ�8YJH;�a¯C^æ5? 4 ;l;9<C�JH8N?;çHC<GxC�a é�G'×hã�ÓMÕK��ÑVØ¢ÓM×hãu����Ñ<�XÓM×kØ~àÀÕ£���;â~ØZÕ±ÙZÙ<õ¤^G/çH?;çkéKJLJoêz? 4 ;<æ�;�éFæ�;�J;<æ�CP=�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;F6<õ

òD?�;¢é<S 4 6�?:;=.ïPé�=�évæ�?;ç7S:JH;�é�=N=>;¢éFæ�6�é@?�é�8NG/çLa�C^æ,è æZé�G>XYCVè§=>Cvç[GY?�#4çHGF ì��¢ñ6G ã 6�çºèI8YJH?Zé�GN;CU8>6�Joê_? 4 ;�GN;¢éFæ:;F6�?5=�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;E\MçLa+é�G/ê>` ?�CE? 4 ;�æ;çHb 4 ?5C�a#�XVçi6�é�=N=>;¢éFæ�6<õ}<CnÁ&;<è-èÅé ñ>çoèE=YJ�ç[;F6& k�lMk�Ì÷ÌiÊSl(' ¾ ¨ßÔPÕ�ã ÛPÖ-Ü�ÕF��âj©5��Ñ<�XÓM×kØ~à�Õ<Ù�Ñ�©<ÓMÕF�D��Ù`ÓMÕj��Ù�×oÙ�´^ײÙ<Ó��Z×MÜ<Û/ÓMÕ ´mÑvÙWZ_(�«

ñFm

Page 14: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

¤^G>S�ç7XY;Gu?jJºê^ïLíOCVæ�C�JLJkéFæ,ê�î_=�æ:C|9Vç7XY;F6Åéza é~çoæ�Joêe; )²S�çH;GY?fé|J[bUC^æ;çH? 4 èüa�C^æE6¤çoèI8YJ²é@?;çHGNbZ_(jõ �7éF9VçHGNb/6�A ç[?�S 4 ;FX�aIæ:C^èÚXVç76�SXæ�;?:;�?�CIS�C<GY?;çHGu8NC<8>60Jké�Z�;�Ji6±ïNA5;DGN;�vk?D6�A ç[?�S 4 aMæ�C^èXVçi6:SXæ�;?�;-?�CzS�C<GY?;çHGY8NC<8>6�ÓM×kÖ�Õ¢õ 354 é@?�ç76<ï A5;E? 4 çHGNypC@aQGN;Aå=�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;F6-é�=N=�;¢éFæ;çHGNbé�?E? 4 ;q?;çoèE;qC@a é'å2Cvçi6:6�C<Gt=�æ�CkS�;F6:6EC�a7æZé�?�;'ñ<V�çHGYa�C^æ,èÅéKJLJoê^ï}çHG éc?�çºèP;�ç[GY?�;<æ�9FéKJF�* �*©<È*�*�G�étGN;Aþ=�évæ�?;ç7S:JH; é�=N=>;¢évæ 6qA?çH? 4 S 4 é�G>S�;$*�*Zõ¤�G]? 4 ;'æ�8YJH; é@Z>C�9<;cA5;6�=>C<yU;�C�a él=�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;�é�=N=�;¢éFæ;çHGNbÅé�G>Xmé�GNCU? 4 ;<æD6¤çoè/8YJH?Zé@GN;C<8>6�Joê_XVç76,é�=N=>;¢évæ;çHGNb�ïNZN8N?ç[?}ç765G�é�?:8�æZéKJ�?:C�æ�;= 4 æZéU6�;�? 4 çi6�çHGq?�;<æ,è-6OC@aßél=�éFæ:?;ç7S:J[;7çHG>6�?Xé�Gu?Xé�GN;C<8>6�JoênS 4 é�GNbFçHGNb=>Cu6¤çH?;çHC<G.õ 354 ç76�æ:;= 4 æZé<6¤çHGNbpbFçH9<;F6l? 4 ;-a�C�JLJHC�A?çHGNbp;9<C�JH8N?;çHC<G�æ�8YJH;�a¯C^æ�éx=�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;=�æ�CkS�;F6:6?çHGzS�CUGu?;çHGY8NC<8>65?;çoèE;�é�G>Xq6�=�é<S�;^õ

ô�C^æO;¢é<S 4 ç[GY?�;<æ�9FéKJ�F8êW�~ê&<3*0êYG�é�?O?�çºèP;+*XïNA?çH? 4 =�æ�C<Z�é�Z/çLJ�çH?�ê�*UêA*�* ? 4 ;GN;¢éFæ:;F6�?D=�éFæ�?�çiS:JH;l?�CE? 4 ;�æ;çHb 4 ?DC�a�ê�ç76?èPC|9U;FX-?�CAêqZ/ê-?;çoèE;,*�<4*�*Xõ¤^G>6�?�;¢éUX-C�a�?Zé�yVçHGNbI? 4 ; 6j=�é�?;çkéKJjçHGu?�;<æ:9�éKJW?�CIZ>; F{ìN�¢ñ6GNA5;�S<é�Gq?Zé�yU;?çH?D?�C�Z�; F ìN�¶se` ã6�C^èE;A 4 é@?O=�éFæZéUXYCFv/ç7S<éKJLJoêE? 4 ;<æ�;?ç76?é�8NG/ç7TU8N;�A�é¢êl?�C/6j?ZéFæ�? ? 4 ;£=�æ�CkS�;F6:6OA ç[? 4 J;<æ�C=�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;F6Åé@?/?�çºèP;�J;<æ�CpZN8N?�çHGY¶>G/çH?�;�Joê èÅé@GPêp=�évæ�?;ç7S:JH;F6Åé�?I;¢é<S 4 =>CY6¤çH?;çH9<;_?;çoèE;^õop;�S<éKJLJ�? 4 çi6.- ÑVÖ�Ö�ÕK�,Ù<à�ÕFµ�D Ù2���;â~ØZÕ±ÙZÙ \^? 4 C<8Nb 4 çH?FÃÄ62apéFæ2aMæ�C^è¿;�vN=YJ�çiS�çH??çHG3F²ñF®MG�`Zï^é�G>XA�æ;çH?�;0/ZQ\�êW�*�`Na�C^æ2? 4 ;OGY8�èIZ>;<æ2C�a>=�éFæ�?�çiS:JH;F6"é�?2?;çoèE;1*�çHGI? 4 ;�ç[GY?�;<æ�9FéKJ2F ìN�~ê÷GpõjôßçHb<8�æ�;ó�çi6�éqwxC<GY?�;�í�éFæ�JHC_6¤çoèI8YJké�?;çHC<G.ïjçHGpA 4 çiS 4 ;¢é<S 4 =�é�? 4 6 4 C�A�6£? 4 ;I=>Cu6�ç[?�ç[CUGpC�a ébFçH9<;Gc=�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;-é<6D?�çºèP;�çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6�;F6l\�9<;<æ�?;ç7S<éKJO6�S<éKJH;�`Zï�C^æD;FTU8/çH9�éKJH;GY?�Joêp? 4 ;�Jké�Z�;�JOC�a? 4 ;�?:C<=nS<éFæ X�ç[G�é�bFçH9<;G-=/ç¢JH;7çHG-=�é�?;çH;G>S�;�6�C^æ�?�ç[GNb�éKa�?�;<æs6�A ç[?�S 4 çHGNbI?�C/S�CUGu?;çHGY8NC<8>6?;çoèE;^õ 354 ;l;�v�é<S�?�S�C<GNGN;FS�?;çHC<G_A ç[? 4 Z_(¸çi6£9Vç²é ò â^ײÙZÙ<â^ã ×32<Ñ^ÓM×hâ^ã>V/ZQ\Zñ<�*�` Ï�Z54 á76 â �DA 4 ;<æ:;98p\:*�` 4 é<6>å2CFç76�6�C<G�\;*�`0J²éKA \�îY`? 4 é�??ç76 a \�8f\;*:` Ï ��` Ï�� ö 6 * ( ã ��ÅH�D�xÏ ì��¢ñ<�XóN�F��K�� Õ~Ö�Ñ<��ê<« 354 ;nS�C<GNGN;FS�?;çHC<GtA?çH? 4 �7éFè-èP;<æ 6�JH;<ê�Ãï6�6�8N=�;<æZé<XNXVçH?;çH9<;mæ�;=�æ�;F6j;Gu?Zé R?;çHC<G�ç76mé<6la�C�JLJHC�A�6<õpI£G>XY;<æ�Joê^çHGNb¦? 4 ;_;9<C�JH8N?;çHC<G4æ�8YJH; çi6�ét6�=�é<S�; R ?;çoèE;'å2CFç76�6�CUG=�æ�CkS�;F6:6E\�C�a�æZé�?�;�ñ@`�C�a�æZé�G>XYCVèþ=>Cvç[GY? 6P\�ê�ú¯�*^úi`�çHGe? 4 ;nTU8�é<X/æZé�GY?AF{ìN�6se` à õcMDGN;S<é�G_S 4 ;FS:y /Z5\!êW�<*:` Ï èÅéKv/çoèÅéKJ�GY8�èIZ>;<æDC�aO6�8>S 4 =�CFçHGu? 6C<G�é�G/ên8N= R æ�ç[b 4 ?�=�é�? 4 aMæ�C^èÝ\�ìN�XìY` ?�C-\�êW�*�`�� \�ëY`\pò�G Û��ñB�X×¢�vÔPÓW=�é�? 4 Z>;XçHGNbqC<GN;�? 4 é�?�S<é�GxZ>;�A>æ;çH?�?�;GÒéU6�\�\�ê)\�=&` �*�\�=)`�` �<=@· ìY`0a¯C^æGNC<G>XY;FSXæ�;¢é<6¤çHGNbAê)\«�L`é�G>X>*�\«�L`:`Zõ 354 ç76O=�æ:;F6�;Gu?�6 ? 4 ;WZ[( R =�æ:C<ZYJH;<è éU6+é�S�CUGu?;çHGY8NC<8>6 R6�=�é<S�;�é@G�éKJHC<bnC@a�¶�æ 6j?�=�é<6:6,é�b<;�C^æ�ç[;GY?�;FX�=>;<æ S�C�Jké�?�ç[CUGhF²ñ¢óMGpï�é�G[é�G�éKJHC<b^ê-? 4 é�?DA�é<6G�é�?�8�æZéKJW?�CI�#évè-èE;<æ 6�JH;<êmé<6?é�a¯C<8NG>XY;<æ£C�a�? 4 ;�èÅé@? 4 ;<èÅé�?;ç7S<éKJ&? 4 ;C^æ,ê-C�a�=�;<æ S�C�Jké R?;çHC<G4FoñK¬�G¤õ

ñ r

Page 15: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

ì ì�õoñ ì�õ ó ì�õÄm ì�õ r ì�õ{î ì�õ ë ì�õL¡ ì�õĬ ì�õÄ® ñ^õ{ì

ñ¢ì

ó^ì

m^ìr ìî^ì

ë^ì

¡�ì¬^ì®^ìñ¢ì^ì

? Jké�Z>;�J76

Ö?;çoèE;

Ï©ÐÒÑ Ã�lKÍLmjõnÁ.é�Z�;�J76�CUGp? 4 ;E?�CU= S<évæ XN6�C�a5;¢é<S 4 =/çLJ[;�çHGg=�é@?;çH;G>S�;²6�CVæ�?;çHGNb�ïjçHGS�C<Gu?�ç[GY8/ç�J;FXx?;çoèE;^õ

� ��� Ýc�O�&Ö��OÓ��^Óq�V�����O�t�&Ó���Þß� �<�&�<�^�NÓòDJ7XYC<8>6�é�G>Xpä>çké<S�CUG/çi6�Foñ~GO8>6�;FX ? 4 ;�çHGu?:;<æZé<S�?;çHGNb_=�évæ�?;ç7S:JH;Åæ�;=�æ:;F6�;Gu?Xé�?;çHC<Gc?�Cmæ�; R=�æ�C�9<; 354 ;C^æ�;<è1ó�õ �D;<æ�; ç76#é�GqCU8N?�J�ç[GN;lC�a ? 4 ;�éFæ�b<8�èP;Gu?¢õ

ÚÌÛë�<��âFÙ`Õ£? 4 ;/6j=�é�?;çkéKJ�=�æ�CNS�;F6�67éFæ�C<8NG>X�=>Cu6�ç[?�ç[CUG ê é�?D?;çoèE;%*�é�=N=�æ�CKv/çoèÅé�?�;F6�éå2CFç76�6�C<Gq=�æ�CNS�;F6�6£C�a�6�CVèE;�æZé�?�;jµ&\�ê��<*:`Zõ"í JH;¢éFæjJºê**�* \@/ZQ\�êW�*�`2Ï�\%A î æ 6

ñ¢î

Page 16: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

A 4 ;<æ�;,A î æ 6 çi6�? 4 ;�XVçi6j?Zé�G>S�;£aIæ�CVèÌêP?�C�? 4 ;£GN;¢éFæ�;F6�?�=�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;�?:C�? 4 ;5JH;�a�?5C�a2ê.õ"ôNC^æé-å2CFç76�6�C<Gq=�æ:CkS�;F6�6&\%A î æ 6 A5C<8YJ7XqZ�;-ñ ã \B6j=�é�?;çkéKJ.æZé�?�;�`Xïk6jC

\%A î æ 6 è ñµ&\�êW�*�` è ñ// î \ /Z5\!êW�<*:` �¤^G_CU? 4 ;<æDA5C^æ XN6<ïCB�\�êW�*�`2Ï�\ /Z�\�êW�*�`O6,é�?�çi6B¶>;F6#é�=N=�æ:CFv/çoèÅé�?�;�Joê-? 4 ;�åOä�ð*�B*�* Ï ñ/ED/ î ã B�\�ìN�~ê&`WÏ�B�\;*��ZìY`2Ï ì \�¡<`A 4 Cu6�;�6�C@J[8N?�ç[CUGmç76 B�\!êW�<*:` Ï ó�F *�ê2� \B¬Y`ÎDC<?:;�? 4 é�?e�±ó�� çi6£GNC<?�é�GméFæ�Z/çH?,æZévæ,ênS�C<G>6�?Xé�Gu?KV�GNCPC<? 4 ;<æDS�C<G>6�?Zé@Gu?5A?çLJLJ�6�;<æ�9U;^õ ¤^GC<? 4 ;<æDA5C^æ XN6 \@F8Z[(+G è \ /Z�\Xñ<� ��`2Ï�B�\����~ñ�` è ó<� ßdw�à �¤^Gp? 4 ;�J²é@GNb<8�é�b<;IC�aD6�?Zé�?;ç76�?�çiS<é|JO= 4 êN6¤ç7S6<ï2A 4 é�?�A5; 4 éK9<;IC<8N?�J�çHGN;FX[ç76�é ÔYµ|´U��âK´<µKñã�Ñ^Ö�×hØ-à�×kÖ�×hÓ évæ�b<8�èE;GY?¢õ�}<;;EXY;Ew[é<6¤ç�;?�éKJ©Foñ^ñ~G�a¯C^æ�é-6�8�æ�9<;<ê^õ 354 ;-é�G�éKJoêN6¤ç76�C�a�#éFè�èE;<æ 6�JH;<ê&ÃÄ6�=�æ�CkS�;F6:6 bFçH9<;G�çHG$Foñ~G�S:JHCu6�;�Joê-=�éFæZéKJLJH;�J765? 4 ;�;¢éFæ�J�çH;<æ é@G�éKJoêk6¤ç76�C�aW? 4 ;\BXVç76�SXæ�;?�;D6�=�é<S�;^ï<S�CUGu?;çHGY8NC<8>62?;çoèE;�`W6¤çoèE=YJH;#é<6;ê/è-èE;?�æ;ç7S ;�v>S:J[8>6�ç[CUGE=�æ�CNS�;F6�6jçHGIC<GN;XVçºèP;G>6¤çHC<G.ï XY8N;E?�C3�5Cu6j? F r mMG�{z6�;;ÅéKJ76�C_ÁÌç[bUb<;?�? F ó<¬MGO6�;FSFõE¬�õ î�õI}<8NZ>6�;FTU8N;GY?�Joê^ïf ;GNy�é�? 6j8NZ�æZéFèÅé�G/çjF î r GD6�?�8>XVçH;FXe? 4 ;mé�G�éKJHC<bfC�a �7éFè-èE;<æ 6BJ[;<ê&ÃÄ6l=�æ�CNS�;F6�6IC<Gt? 4 ;S�çºæ�S:J[;^ï$é�G>Xf}<;=N=HGéKJ;Gé~çHGN;GLF r ëMG XY;9<;�JHC<=>;FX ? 4 ; 4 êNX/æ�CNX/êuG�éFè¸çiS<é|J�éFæ:b<8�èE;GY?�C�aWF²ñ«Gç[G[é�èEC^æ:;�é�Z>6�?,æZéUS�?Q6j;?�?;çHGNbEA 4 ;<æ�; çH?�S<é�GqZ>;�é�=N=YJ�çH;FX_?:CEC<? 4 ;<æDbVæ�C�AD? 4 èECkXY;�J76<õI  ¢¡x£ù(�§ %/+E*O® ®°§5'W(21d­ .O*�%E%x£5. '21 *�%354 ;ÅèPCu6�?�æ�;FS�;GY?-é�G>XpXY;;=>;F6j?n6�?�8>X/êcC�aWZ ( ;�vN=YJHCFçH? 6�é_S�C<GNGN;FS�?;çHC<GeA ç[? 4 æZé@G RXYC^è è�é�?,æ;ç7S�;F6<ïNZ�éU6�;FXqC<Gq? 4 ;�a�C�JLJ[C�A?çHGNbPa¯CVæ,èI8YJ²éPXVçi6:S�C|9U;<æ�;FXqZ/ê3��é~çHG>6NF r óMGé�G>XM�XUJºêUJy<C-;?#éKJýFïm^ëMGpõÓ lMk�Ô�k�Õ ÐÒÖ�Ð kv× ¼

a \�Z ( 9¦æ�` Ï ñ��Å ò�J�K 3 æ � à!( * � � \B®Y`�D;<æ�;`* � XY;GNC<?:;F6OGNCVæ,èÅéKJ�ç�J;FX_�7é^éFæ?èE;¢é<6j8�æ�;�CUGn? 4 ;�8NG/çH?Zévæ,êEb^æ�CU8N=]# ô C�a�æMLqæèÅé�?,æ;ç7S�;F6 � õ

ñ¢ë

Page 17: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

354 ç767æ�;F6�8YJH?>ç76�6�8�æ�=�æ;ç76¤çHGNb�ï&ZN8N?�GNC<?�XVçN)qS�8YJ[?l?�Cq6�;;�C<G>S�;E6�CVèE;C<GN;�?:;�J¢J767ê<CU8ç[?>ç765?,æ�8N;^õ 354 ;�éK9<;<æZé@b<;�C@a�? 4 ;�?�æZé<S�;>çi6£? 4 ;7çHGNGN;<æ�=�æ�CNXY8>S�?

ò J K 3 æ � à�( * � ÏPO a (ß a (ß1QA 4 ;<æ�; a ßK\�ê�ßF�K�F�K���«ê�ôH`lÏ̺ ôõKÜ&ß êNõ çi6l? 4 ;�¶�æ 6�?�=�C�As;<æI6�8�èÿ6�êPè-èP;?,æ;ç7SIa�8NG>S�?;çHC<Gé�=N=YJ�ç[;FXf?�C-? 4 ;I;XçHb<;Gu9FéKJH8N;F6�C�a � õ�ò�GPêc6;ê/è-èE;?,æ;ç7S 4 C^èEC<b<;GN;CU8>6�=>C�JoêYGNC^è�çkéKJC�a0XY;bVæ�;;�� ç[GcæW9FéFæ;çké�ZYJH;F6�S<é�GqZ�;�;�vk=�æ�;F6:6�;FX�é<6?élJ�çHGN;¢éFæ�S�C^èIZ/çHG�é�?;çHC<G_C@aO}uS 4 8�æa¯8NG>S�?;çHC<G>6±õ�ô�C^æ a (ß ? 4 ç76£A�é<6DXYC<GN;�Z/êfô�æ�C<Z�;G/ç[8>6±õ 354 ;Læ�;F6�8YJH??ç76a (ß Ï Ç R É�ôTS R \Zñ ô `EU RA 4 ;<æ�;p°VU R V���Ê]��±ÒéFæ�;q? 4 ;p}uS 4 8�æIa�8NG>S�?;çHC<G>6<ï5A 4 çiS 4 évæ�;q? 4 ;_S 4 éFæZé<S�?�;<æ�6IC�a? 4 ;p8NG/çH?ZéFæ,ê³b^æ:C<8N=�#�ôMõ 354 ;WU R 6�é�?;ç76�aMêPO;U R �U(X Q ÏZY R X�é@G>X[U R Ï ì çLaE? 4 ;S�C<G�ÀB8Nb/é�?�;I=�éFæ�?;çH?;çHC<GE�M\ 4 é<6&�M\ ß "�æ;õ 354 ;IGY8�è/Z�;<æ 6 S R \-µ�`�éFæ�;l? 4 ;ES 4 évæZé<S�?�;<æ 6C�a�? 4 ;q6;ê/è-èE;?,æ;ç7SPb^æ�C<8N=.õc¤�Ge? 4 ;mé�=N=YJ�çiS<é@?;çHC<GpµeÏ ñ ô é�G>Xt6�C S R \-µ�`lÏ * R ç76? 4 ;nXVçoèE;G>6¤çHC<GeC�aD? 4 ;���à ? 4 çoæ,æ:;FXY8>S�ç[ZYJH; æ�;=�æ�;F6�;GY?Zé�?;çHC<G.õ�å 8N?�?�ç[GNbc? 4 ;F6j;E=/çH;FS�;F6?�C<b<;? 4 ;<æ£bFçH9<;F6

ò�J�KC 3 æ � à!( * � Ï ÇR ÉM(´æ R(]Û_^ ô ô S R \Zñ ô `�öà �

I�6¤çHGNbq? 4 ;-}uS 4 ;G>6�?�;FXcS�C^æ,æ:;F6�=>C<G>XY;G>S�;�\�å"æ�CU=>Cu6¤çH?;çHC<G r é�Z>C�9<;�`5A5;/6�;;I? 4 ;I6�8�è;FT<8�éKJ76�? 4 ;IGY8�èIZ>;<æ�C�aO=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé@?;çHC<G>6�ÛpC@as°PñU�F�F�K��� ��±�A ç[? 4 æ�\�Û2`ý9]æ;õ�ä>ç[9Vç7XVçHGNbZ>C<? 4 6�çiXY;F6�Z/êq�2Å�;F6�?Zé�ZYJ�ç76 4 ;F6�\B®Y`Zõ¬�ô�æ:C^è§? 4 ;�XY;�¶>G/çH?;çHC<GxC�a��7é^éFæ}èE;¢é<6�8�æ�;�A5;�S<é�G�æ�;A�æ;çH?�;�? 4 ;7æ;çHb 4 ?D6¤ç7XY;�C�a \B®Y`

é<6ñ�2Å[\�ó<Û2` ô ò àa`� �F�K� ò àE`� b� õ3c�Û < �K�F�6<�� õ3c K à!( åß ^ 7�d>á ^ ô b� õ3cfe ?g� õ3c;h à *UúFß2�F�K��*UúFô��l\Zñ~ìY`

354 ;�GN;�vN?s6j?�;=�ç76�?�C�æ�;�Jké�?�;l\Zñ¢ìY`&?�C�é�a�C^æ,èI8YJké7çHGu9UC�JH9^çHGNb 3 CY;=YJ�çH?dJ�XY;?�;<æ,è�çHG�é�GY? 6<õôNC^æ#é/a¯8NG>S�?;çHC<GEñ�\�úU`sC<Gq? 4 ;�8NG/çH? S�çoæ S:JH;IA?çH? 4 ô�C<8�æ;çH;<æ S�CY; )²S�çH;GY? 6 /ñ�\ : `Zï<A5;�S<é�GS�C<G>6�?,æ�8>S�??é�Gnæ_L/æ 3 CY;=YJ�ç[?-J�èÅé�?,æ;çLvEA?çH? 4 ;GY?,æ;çH;F6£\ /ñ�\���? : ` �¢ñ&9 : ���@9¦æ�`Zõ�o'æ;çH?�;AEôLö>ßK\�ñ�\«�L`:`�a�C^æ}çH? 6DXY;?�;<æ�è�çHG�é�Gu?~õ+ò¿S:Jké<6�6¤ç7S<éKJ$ç7XY;Gu?;çH?;ê_XY8N;�?�Cn�£;XçHGN;/6,é~êN6

ñ\�ó<Û�` ô æ!Å ò �K�F� ò ñ�\�úKß`&�F�F�ÂñW\!úFô÷` åß ^ 7�d>á ^ ô �� õ3cfe ?g� õ3c h à *0úKß2�F�F�!*UúFô�Ï�AEô[ö>ßK\�ñ�\«�L`�` �íOC^èE=�éFæ�ç[GNbP? 4 ç765A?çH? 4 \Zñ¢ìk`�A5;�6�;;�A5; 4 éK9<;�é�Gq;�vN=�æ�;F6�6¤çHC<G�a¯C^æ5? 4 ;�XVç76�?�æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<GC�a�? 4 ;�å2CFç76�6�C<G/ç�J;FXcT<8�é@Gu?;çH?;êAZ 4 á76 â é�?�\�îY`Zõ

ñ�¡

Page 18: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

Ó lMk�Ô�k�Õ ÐÒÖ�Ð kv×[ia \!Z 4 áN6 â 9Ôæ�` Ï Ç ( � ö 6;* (��Å a \�Z[(A9¦æ�` Ïj� ö 6 AEôLö>ß ô � àak 6 l;m<npo ö � \ZñVñ�`

354 ç76Lç7XY;Gu?;çH?;êeS<é�GeZ>;_6�;;G éU6�éc6�=�;FS�çkéKJ�S<éU6�;nC@a é æ�;F6�8YJH?EC�a9q�;F6�6�;�J`Foñ�¡6Gpõf¤^G RS�çiXY;GY?�Joê^ï2? 4 ;EXY;G>6¤çH?;êz;�vN=&\�rIS�Cu6�\~�L`�`OC<Gf? 4 ;ES�çºæ�S:J[;¸çi6�? 4 ;ES:Jké<6�6¤ç7S<éKJ�ð¢â^ã ÐÒײÙ`Õ±Ù�ñî+×oÙXÔPÕF��C^æ�Ø¢×÷�;Ø¢Û/à�Ñ<�,s�â<�XÖ�ÑVàkXVç76�?�æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<Gt\«F ó<mMG"í 4 é@=N?�;<æDm<mY`ZõQ �^~ ÝcÓ���Þß� �<�&�<�^�x�����&Ö��OÓ��^ÓMD9<;<æn? 4 ;q=�é<6�?Åî^ì*ê<;¢éFæ 6I? 4 ;<æ�; 4 é<6PZ>;;G¦CUGNb<CFçHGNbh6j?�8>X/êgC@a ? 4 ;[é<6;ê/èE=N?�C<?�çiS6C�a 3 Cu;=YJ�çH?dJqXY;?�;<æ,è�çHG�é�GY? 6<õ 3 C²6�?:8>X/êz? 4 ;¸éU6;êPèP=N?�C<?;ç7S�JkéFA¿C@aýZ ( 9Vçkéx\Zñ^ñ�`5C<GN;GN;;FXN6O?�A5C R =�éFæXéFèE;?�;<æ"é<6;ê/èE=N?�C<?�çiS6±ïu6¤çHG>S�;t*$çi6�C�a&C^æ XY;<æ5��é�G>XEæ�ç76�C�aWC^æ XY;<æ5� ß-w�à õ��é�ç[y R ä�;XçLa¯? R�� C 4 é�G>6�6jC<G3FÄmMG>S�C^èIZ/çHGN;D;�v/çi6j?;çHGNb�èE;? 4 CNXN6 A?çH? 4 6�C^èP;O=�æ�C�a�C<8NG>XlGN;Aé�G�éKJoêk6�çi6£?�Cn6 4 C|AÉji&Í0k�lFÍ�è ¸vu

Õ¢ÓxwU\�ê)`¸Ü�ÕÅÓhÔ/Õ ò Ñ^×hã�à�ÕFð$yÕ%z<z�©`Û/ã�Ø~ÓM×kâ^ã Ù<â^àLð¢×hãu��wFú�úi\�ê&`�Ï}ê{wU\�ê)`2<ó�w � \�ê&`N©<â<�5ª$ÔP×hØ<Ô|wU\�ê)`_u ò>ç^\�ê&`+ÑvÙ�ê±qtseì�ª$ÔPÕK��Õ¬o�× ×oÙ�o�×÷� µ�D Ù>©<ÛPã Ø¢ÓM×hâ^ã�« é �Z×hÓMÕ

} \�ê&`�Ϧ;�vk=�~÷?3ò �î \!ê ?0*�`Ew à \:*�`�*�*;�_�¨.ÔPÕ¢ã

a�� Z ( ?'ó<� ßdw:à� ßdw!� 9 êC�zq } \�ê)` ÑvÙ��rqts¦�j?&s â ê â s¦��5;<èÅévæ�y�é�ZYJoê^ï5? 4 ;_6�éFèE;PJÀçoè�çH?PJkéFA1éFæ�Cu6�;-;¢éFæ�J�çH;<æ¢õ 3 æZé<SXê�é�G>Xto4ç7XYC^ènF îVì�G6�?�8>XVçH;FXc? 4 ;I6¤ç�J;/C@aO? 4 ;�JkéFæ�bU;F6�?�;XçHb<;GY9�é|J[8N;x\dµ R( ï�6�é¢ê�`5C�a�é-æXé�G>XYC^èd��Lz�p�£;<æ R

è�çH?;çké�GÅè�é�?,æ;çLv.ïPé�G>XICUZN?Zé~çHGN;FXE? 4 ;�æ�;F6�8YJH?5C�a 3Q4 ;C^æ�;<èÚ¬�A?çH? 4 µ R( çHGn=YJké<S�;�C�a2Z_(�õ¤^?>çi6£8NGNyYGNC|A£GqA 4 ;? 4 ;<æ�? 4 ;<æ�;�ç76�6�C^èE;A� ¶>G/ç[?:;/���Lç7XY;Gu?�ç[?;êxA 4 ç7S 4 ;�vk=YJké~çHG>6�? 4 ç76S�CFçHG>S�çiXY;G>S�;^õ354 ;E�?é~çHy R ä�;XçLa�? R�� C 4 é@G>6�6�C<Gp? 4 ;C^æ�;<è 4 é<6�6�;?�C�{ é�G'éK9�éKJké�G>S 4 ;IC�a�æ�;F6j;¢éFæ S 4é<S�?;çH9^çH?;ê^õ 3 æZé<SXê�é�G>Xto4ç7XYC^è F{î�ñ~G�æ:;�J²é@?�; 354 ;CVæ�;<è ¬x?�Cp? 4 ;q;�v/ç76�?;çHGNb æ�;F6�8YJH? 6C<G�æZé@G>XYC^è�èÅé�?�æ;ç7S�;F6#é�G>X�? 4 ;�é�=N=�;¢éFæZé�G>S�;IC�a+å"é~çHGYJH;9x�;�a�8NG>S�?;çHC<G>6<õD��C^æ�CNXVçHGhFï¬�G8>6�;FXLçH?O?�C�=�æ:C|9U;Q6�çºè¸ç¢JkéFæ}æ�;F6�8YJH? 6�a¯C^æ A>æ�;¢é�? 4 =�æ�CNXY8>S�? 6<õ � C 4 é@G>6�6�C<G3F{ó^óMGY¶>G>XN6 ? 4 ;6,éFèE;£J�çºè¸ç[?QJ²éKA } \�ê)`çHGq? 4 ;�a�C�JLJHC�A?çHGNb�XVç76�SXæ:;?�;�é�G�éKJHC<bIC�aO\;ëY` V�6j;?+çHG>XY;=�;G>XY;Gu?æZé�G>XYC^è 9FéFæ;çké�ZYJH;F6qA?çH? 4 b<;CVèE;?,æ;ç7ScXVç76�?,æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<G]CUG ? 4 ;z9U;<æ�?;ç7S�;F6-C�a�? 4 ;cb^æ;ç7XF ìN� �)GML�F ìN���SG¤ï�é@G>X-JH;? � (qZ�;I? 4 ;�èÅé|vPçoèI8�è�ï�C|9U;<æD8N= R æ;çHb 4 ?�=�é�? 4 6QaIæ�CVèþ\�ì��ZìY`?�CI\B�2� ��`ZïUC�a�? 4 ;�6�8�è§C�a&? 4 ;D9FéFæ;çké�ZYJH;F65C<GI? 4 ;D=�é@? 4 õ ��é�ç[y�é�G>X ��é~çHG>6&F ë/ïPîMG 4 éF9U;

ñF¬

Page 19: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

6 4 C�ADGc? 4 é�?7è/8>S 4 C�aO? 4 ;�èÅé<S 4 çHGN;<æ,êzS<évæ,æ;çH;F6�C�9<;<æ�?:C²6�8NZ>6j;? 6�C�as=�;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?;çHC<G>66�8>S 4 é<6 çHGY9<C�JH8N?;çHC<G>6<ï^é�G>X 4 éK9<; bvç[9U;G/S�C^èIZ/çHG�é�?�C^æ�ç²é|Ju=�æ�CYC�a¥6)C�a�é@=N=�éFæ�;GY?�Joê�=N8�æ�;�Joêé�G�éKJoêu?�çiS�;FT<8/çH9FéKJH;G>S�;F6<õMDGN;-C�aD? 4 ;nyU;<ê�ç76�6j8N;F6�ç76I6�;;XçHGNbg6 4 évæ�=YJoêpA 4 êz? 4 ;<æ�;²6 4 C<8YJ7XpZ�;fécS�C<GNGN;FS R?;çHC<G¦Z�;?BA5;;GÔ=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?�ç[CUG>6-é�G>X�æXé�G>XYC^è èÅé@?,æ;ç7S�;F6<õ³MDy<CU8NGNy<C�9�FÄmU¬�G£bFçH9<;F6Åé6�8�æ�=�æ;ç76¤çHGNb¦S�C<GNGN;FS�?;çHC<GÔ9^çkéC�}çH;<èÅé�GNG]6�8�æ�apé<S�;F6<õ 354 ;z6�;?PC�a ?�æ;çké�GNb<8YJké�?;çHC<G>6PC�aéz6j8�æ�a éUS�;²S<é�GeZ�;_XY;F6�SXæ;çHZ>;FX�? 4 æ�C<8Nb 4 çHGY?�;b^æZéKJ76IC�9<;<æLèÅé�?,æ�ç¢vt;G>6�;<èIZYJ[;F6P8>6¤çHGNbAsCVæ�ypC�aeg�CUGu? 6j;9^ç7S 4 õ å2;<æ�è/8N?Xé�?;çHC<G>6l;Gu?:;<æ�çHG³XY;F6�SXæ;çHZ/çHGNbg? 4 ;mèPC<GNCkX/æ:C^è�êpC�a6¤çoèE=YJoêpZ�æZé�G>S 4 ;FXpS�C�9<;<æ 6<õ�MDy<C<8NGNy<C�9_8>6j;FXc? 4 ;F6�;�ç7XY;¢é<6�?�Cq6 4 C�A¿? 4 é�?�? 4 ;lJ�çoè Rç[?�ç[GNbtXVçi6j?,æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<Gta�C^æ�? 4 ;-GY8�è/Z�;<æIC�a�S�;�J¢J76¸çHGg? 4 ;qÜ�à ? 4 æ�C�A§C@aQ? 4 ;_}uS 4 ;G>6�?�;FX?Zé�ZYJH;¢é�8'é�b^æ�;;F6£A?çH? 4 ? 4 ;lJ�çoè�çH?;çHGNb XVç76�?�æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<Gca�C^æ�? 4 ;�Ü:Ã�? 4 JkéFæ�bU;F6�?�;XçHb<;Gu9FéKJH8N;C�a�é7æZé@G>XYC^è§�D;<æ�è�çH?;çké�G-èÅé�?�æ;çLv�õ 354 ;5Jké�?�?�;<æOXVç76�?�æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<Gq\BXVçL{W;<æ�;GY? aMæ�C^è } \�ê&`�`A éU65;¢éFæ�J�çH;<æ/XY;?�;<æ�è�çHGN;FX_Z/ê 3 æZé<SXê�é�G>X�o ç7XYC^ètF{î^ìMGpõ?ò§XVçL{);<æ:;Gu?�=�æ�CYC�a C�aO? 4 ç76é<6;ê/èE=N?�C<?;ç7S£;FT<8/ç7XVç76�?,æ�ç[ZN8N?�ç[CUG�ç76?é�GNGNC<8NG>S�;FXfçHG_�OCVæ�CkXVçHGq;?�éKJ_FÄ®MG�\;é�G>XIa�C^æDÜ2Ï óbFçH9<;G_Z/ê²�?é~çHy R ä�;XçLa¯? R�� C 4 é�G>6�6�CUG4F r G¥`Zõ}<C^èE;A 4 é�?"æ�;�Jké�?�;FXI?:C�æZé�G>XYC^è¿=�;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?;çHC<G>60C�a�él� R 6j;?$çi6�? 4 ;D6�?:8>X/ê/C@a�8NG/ç Ra¯C^æ�è æZé@G>XYC^è ª"â<��´FÙ�C@aOJH;GNb<? 4 �$ï&A?çH? 4 JH;?�?�;<æ�6�aMæ�C^è °Pñ<�Zó��F�F���� ��±Põ 3 æZé<SXê�é�G>Xo ç7XYC^è F îVó�G56�?�8>X/êp? 4 ;EJH;GNb<? 4 Z_(´æ á-C�a�? 4 ;�J[CUGNb<;F6�?IA5;¢é�y<Joê[çHG>SXæ�;¢éU6¤çHGNbg6�8NZ>6�; RT<8N;G>S�;�é�G>X_6 4 C�A

a ~ Z[(�æ á©?t� ã �� ß-w�à 9Lê_��q a ~Uµ á á«â�x�<� 9Lê�� � ã ó(�Aé<65�rqtsýa¯C^æQ¶Nvk;FX��A 4 ;<æ�;Eµ á á~â�x�<� çi6�? 4 ;EJkéFæ:b<;F6�?I;XçHb<;Gu9FéKJH8N;xa¯C^æ-é æZé�G>XYCVè è�é�?,æ;çLv'çHGe? 4 ;_�£;<æ,è�çH?�;;G>6�;<èIZYJ[;cC�a9��L��Ô�D;<æ,è¸ç[?�ç²é@G èÅé�?�æ;ç7S�;F6<õ¦¤�?-ç76¸çHGu?,æ�ç[bU8/ç[GNbt?�Cg6j=>;FS�8YJké�?�;c? 4 é�?? 4 ;<æ�;?èÅé~ê�Z>;DS�C<GNGN;FS�?;çHC<G>60A?çH? 4 ? 4 ;D6�8NZNÀ�;FS�?�C@a�6�;FT<8N;G>S�;�S�C^èE=�éFæ;ç76�CUG�6j?Zé�?;ç76�?;ç7S6<ïèEC<?;çH9�é@?�;FXxZPêcä�Î�òÂ6�;FT<8N;G>S�;�èÅé�? S 4 çHGNbc\^;^õ�b�õ�o é�?�;<æ,èÅé@GÒé�G>Xrf>ç[GNbVæ�C<GLF îk¡�G¥`ZïA 4 ;<æ�;�é@G�éKJHC<b<C<8>6?é<6;ê/èE=N?�CU?;ç7S�XVçi6j?,æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<Gc? 4 ;C^æ,ê�ç765JH;F6�6QAs;�JLJOXY;9<;�JHC<=>;FXjõ� � *�(v£ §©¨q*�,�'�� §5'21«££%/.�£��&*�(&'21%x¦ô�æ�C^èÂ? 4 ;l9^çH;AD=�CFçHGu?�C�a�=�é@?;çH;G>S�;/6�C^æ:?;çHGNbEA?çH? 4 �cS<éFæ�XN6<ïY? 4 ;�Gu8�èIZ�;<æ�C�a2=/ç¢JH;F6>ç76ÀB8>6�?5C<GN;�é<6�=�;FS�?5C�a�? 4 ;£¶>G�éKJ�S�C<GY¶>b<8�æZé@?;çHC<G.õ 354 ;<æ�;�éFæ�;£C<? 4 ;<æ5G�é�?�8�æZé|J)TU8N;F6�?;çHC<G>66�8>S 4 éU6O? 4 ;�GY8�èIZ>;<æDC�a�S<éFæ�XN6}çHGq? 4 ; XVçL{W;<æ�;GY?5=/ç¢JH;F6<õ 3Q4 ;F6�; TU8N;F6�?;çHC<G>6 4 éF9U;�GNC<?Z>;;Gz6j?�8>XVçH;FXq;�vN=YJÀç7S�çH?�Joê çHG_? 4 ;�J�çH?�;<æZé�?:8�æ�;^ï>ZN8N?7é<6�? 4 ;�a¯C@J¢JHC�A?çHGNb-C<8N?�J�çHGN;�6 4 C|A�6<ï? 4 ;Xçoæ é@G�éKJoêk6¤ç76?éKJ76�CLæ�;�Jké�?�;F6 ?:C/XVçH9<;<æ 6�;£?�C<=/ç7S6�ç[G-=�æ�C<Z�é@Z/ç¢J�çH?;êÅé�G>X-S�C^èIZ/çHG�é�?�C^æ;ç7S6<õä�;?Zé~çLJ76�èÅé~êEZ�;�=N8NZYJ�ç76 4 ;FXc;�J76�;A 4 ;<æ:;^õ}FçoèI8YJ²é@?;çHC<G>6l\B6�;;�¶>b<8�æ�;/mk`+æ�;9<;¢éKJ"éEXY;�¶>G/çH?�;n6 4 é�=�;�a�C^æD=/çLJH;n6¤ç�J;F6<ï�a¯CVæ5JkéFæ�b<;�õ0op;�6 4 éKJLJWC<8N?�J�çHGN;�6�;=�éFæXé�?�;#é�G�é|JºêN6�;F60a�C^æO? 4 ;£JH;�a¯?�èECu6�?�=/ç¢JH;F6<ï�? 4 ; S�;GY?,æZé|J�=/çLJH;F6

ñF®

Page 20: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

é�G>Xq? 4 ;�æ�ç[b 4 ?,èPCu6�?5=/çLJ[;F6±õ

îñ¢ìñ¢îó^ìó^î

ñ ñ¢ì ó^ì m^ì r ì î^ì ë^ìÔ Ð ÌiÍ4×vÃ�èzË2Í÷l

èzÍYÊ�×hÕ Ð3� Í

Ï©ÐÒÑ Ã�lKÍ ¹ �¿w_;¢é@Ge=/ç¢JH;p6¤ç�J;F6Pa�C^æn� Ï ñ~ì^ì^ì�ï ;F6j?;çoèÅé�?�;FXhaIæ�CVè ñ¢ì � wxC<Gu?:;í�éFæ�JHCE?,æ�ç²é|Ji6±õ���^~ RA���W�5�<ÓK�]���^Ö^�354 ;ES<éFæ XN6�A 4 ç7S 4 ;GY?�;<æ�? 4 ;l¶�æ 6�?�=/çLJ[;méFæ�;l;�v�éUS�?�Joê_? 4 ;q�;ÕZØXâ<��´IS<éFæ XN6<ï�çpõ�;^õ�? 4 Cu6j;A 4 Cu6�;�Jké�Z�;�Jç76�6;èÅéKJLJH;<æ�? 4 é�G�é�G/ên=�æ�;9VçHC<8>6�S<éFæ Xjõ 354 8>6?çHG_CU8�æD;�v�évèE=YJH;

¡ ó ¬ ñ m r ñ¢ì0ë­®�î? 4 ;�æ�;FS�CVæ XN6#évæ�;E¡u�XóN�¢ñVõ�o æ;çH?;çHGNb��Dõ2a�C^æD? 4 ;I;9<;GY?x��? 4 ;/Ü�à ? 4 S<éFæ Xfçi6�é¸æ�;FS�C^æ X÷��ïç[?�ç76O;�JH;<èE;GY?ZéFæ�ê/? 4 é�? a \��£õ�` Ï9ñ ã Ü.é@G>XE? 4 é@? ? 4 ;D;9<;GY? 65\E��ßK�F�K�F��� �©(N`évæ�;?çHG>XY; R=>;G>XY;GY?¢õ 3Q4 8>6�'S(>\Xñ�`Zï<? 4 ;D?�C<?Zé|J�GY8�è/Z�;<æ5C�a.æ�;FS�C^æ XN6�çHG�é�æZé@G>XYC^è§=�;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?;çHC<GC�a0�cS<éFæ�XN6�\�é�G>X-? 4 ;lGu8�èIZ�;<æDC�aOS<éFæ XN6}çHG_=/çLJH;mñ7çHG_=�é�?�ç[;G>S�;I6�C^æ�?�ç[GNb�`s6,é�?;ç76�¶>;F6

\�'S(�\Zñ�`2Ï (Ç õKÜ&ß ñ Ü ueJHC<b5� \Zñ~óY`^_F 'S(Y\Zñ@`�G>Ï (Ç õ�Ü&ß ñ Ü ~�ñ©? ñ Ü ��ueJHC<bs�2�

ó^ì

Page 21: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

ò�G>X'éP?�;�vN?�Z>CYC<y[é�=N=YJ�çiS<é@?;çHC<G¦\�;^õ�b�õjFoñFmMG =.õ-ñ¢ìVóY`sC@aO? 4 ;ES�;Gu?,æXéKJ�J�çoè�çH?I? 4 ;C^æ�;<èa¯C^æ ç[G>XY;=�;G>XY;Gu?�GNCUG R çiXY;GY?;ç7S<éKJLJoê R X�ç76�?,æ;çHZ>8N?:;FX[æZé�G>XYC^è 9�éFæ;çké�ZYJH;F6�6 4 C�A�6a ~ 'S(�\Zñ�`�?xJHC<bD�F JHC<bs� 9Lê_��q��D\�ê)` �&?&s â ê â s \ZñKmY`

a¯C^æ��D\�ê&`OV[Ï�� îöS� \;ó<Û2` ö>ßdw�à � öC� í w�à *Uõ�õop;�æ�;<èÅévæ�yq? 4 é�?7æ�;FS�C^æ XN6Qa�C^æ,èAé-As;�JLJO6�?�8>XVçH;FXpS:Jké<6�6�çiS<é|JO?�C<=/ç7SLçHGc=�æ�C<Z�é�Z/çLJ Rç[?;êe? 4 ;CVæ,ê�Vc6�;;x;^õ�b�õ ò7æ�GNC�J7Xe;?méKJxF óMGpõ 3Q4 ;<æ�;ÒéFæ:;zS�C<GNGN;FS�?;çHC<G>6-A ç[? 4 b^æ�CU8N=? 4 ;C^æ,ê^ï)a¯C^æ7çHG>6�?Xé�G>S�;n? 4 ;�ÀBCvç[GY?�XVç76�?,æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<GeC@a+çHGu?:;<æ R æ�;FS�C^æ X ?;çoèE;F67ç76l? 4 ;�À�CFçHGu?XVçi6j?,æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<G-C�a)SXêNS:JH;DJH;GNb<? 4 6 çHGÅé�8NG/çLa¯C^æ�èÃæZé�G>XYCVè¿=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?�ç[CUGn\~F r ¬MGjí 4 é�=N?�;<æñ�`Zõ����Ò RA���gÖ��÷����Þ]�WÓK���O�^Ö��>Óop;sS<é�GI6�?�8>X/ê�? 4 ;?é�G�éKJHC<b<CU8>6WT<8N;F6j?;çHC<G>6&a�C^æ�' ( \BÜj`Zï? 4 ;�Gu8�èIZ�;<æ�C�a�S<évæ XN6 çHGI=/ç¢JH;DÜ,õ¤^GÅé�S�;<æ�?Zé~çHGn6j;G>6�;5? 4 ;DS<éFæ XN6ßçHGE=/çLJH;�Ü.éFæ�;`�Ü:Ã�? 4 æ�;FS�CVæ XN6d�NV�ç¢aW? 4 ;?æ�;FS�CVæ Xl9�éKJH8N;F6$çHGé�æZé�G>XYCVè¿=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?�ç[CUG¸évæ�;�XY;�JH;?�;FXjïY? 4 ;D? 4 ;7óNÃ�G>XLæ�;FS�C^æ XN6}éFæ�;5? 4 ;�æ:;FS�C^æ Xl?;çoèE;F6éFèEC<GNbu6j?�? 4 ;-æ�;<èÅé�ç[G/çHGNbc9�é|J[8N;F6±ï+é�G>Xp6�CxC<G.õnΣC<?�;P? 4 ç767çHGu?:;<æ�=�æ�;?Zé�?�ç[CUGgC�aDÜ�Ã�? 4æ�;FS�C^æ XLç76�XVç¢{W;<æ�;GY? aMæ�C^èå? 4 ;�èECVæ�;5;�J[;<èP;Gu?Zévæ,êLç[GY?�;<æ�=�æ:;?Zé�?;çHC<Gq\;é�S<éFæ XLç76?é�GEÜ�Ã�? 4æ�;FS�C^æ Xfç¢aO;�v�é<S�?�Joê_Üv? ñ�;¢éFæjJÀçH;<æ�S<éFæ�XN6 4 é<X-JHC�A5;<æ�æZé�GNy�`O8>6�;FX çHG_? 4 ;�æ�;<èÅévæ�y�é�ZYJH;¤^b<G�é�?:C|9&ÃÄ6�? 4 ;C^æ�;<è¸F²ñ r Gpï<A 4 ç7S 4 é<6�6j;<æ�? 6$é�S�;<æ�?Zé�ç[GLçHG>XY;=>;G>XY;G>Së;�=�æ�C<=�;<æ�?;ê�çHGE? 4 ;J²é@?�?�;<æ�S�C<GY?�;�vN?¢õ¤^?�ç76 GNC<? 4 éFæ�XI?�C�æ�;�Jké�?�;£? 4 ;D;�vN=>;FS�?Zé�?�ç[CUGA\�'S(N\BÜj`W?�C�? 4 ;�XVç76�?,æ�ç[ZN8N?�ç[CUG>6OC@a�? 4 ;Z_(jõÓ lMk�Ô�k�Õ ÐÒÖ�Ð kv× ½ î.â<�5�2� Ü_·Bñ

\ ' ( \BÜ�`2Ï (Çá~Ü&ß a \�Z áö>ß Ï Üv? ñ�` (Ç7�Ü&á ñ:ª$ÔPÕF�;ÕEª"Õ�×hã�ÓMÕF�¥���;Õ¢Ó�Z_��ÑFÙ#ì>«Qî�âU�$áOí�Õ�´IÜ_· ñ�ì\ ')(N\BÜ�`2Ï øK\BÜj`<JHC<bO�¥<�PI\Zñ@`#ÑFÙ��rqts \Zñ r `ª$ÔPÕF�;Õ

øK\BÜj`�VLÏ �Çá«Ü�õ a \!ZOáëö�ß�ϦÜ�?4ñ�` â s¦�o�ã>´IøK\Zñ�`2Ï9ñ<�§øK\;óY`�Ïj�©? ñ@ì

øK\BmY`2Ï �Çá«Ü&ß ñ��Å ��� ó��� � ñ�N< ñ ?4ñ � è óN�Ämk¡�ó r �ó�ñ

Page 22: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

op;�XYCEGNC<? 4 éK9<;�éI8>6�;�a�8YJ�S:JHCu6�;FX R a�C^æ,è ;�vk=�æ�;F6:6¤çHC<Gqa�C^æ5? 4 ;�b<;GN;<æZé|J�øK\�Ü�`ZïY? 4 C<8Nb 4é�G�çoèE=YJ�çiS�çH?�a¯C^æ�è/8YJkéla�C�JLJHC�A�6�aMæ�C^èÝ\BmY`�é@G>X-? 4 ;�XY;�¶>G/çH?;çHC<GcC�a0øK\�Ü�`Zõ

å"æ:C<=>Cu6�ç[?�ç[CUG_®�ç76�é��S�CVè/Z/çHG�é�?:C^æ;çkéKJ���æ�;F6�8YJH?5Z�é<6�;FX-8N=�C<Gq;�v�é<S�?5a�C^æ,èI8YJké<6<õ2¤^GS�C<Gu?�æZé<6�?¢ïëAs;5S<é�GI;�vk?:;G>X�? 4 ;DS�;GY?,æZéKJ<J�çoè�çH?O? 4 ;C^æ�;<è¿\ZñKmY`>Z/ê�6�C�a�?���=�æ:C<Z�é�Z/çLJ�çi6j?;ç7S6�éFæ�b<8�èE;GY? 6<õ&�5;FS<éKJLJO? 4 ; ç[GY?�;<æZéUS�?;çHGNbq=�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;E=�æ�CNS�;F6�6�6�;?�8N=cC�as6�;FS�?;çHC<Gpm�õ{ó�õD�}ê8>6¤çHGNb écXVç¢{W;<æ�;GY?�æ�;F6�S<éKJ�çHGNbpC�a5Jké�Z�;�Ji6±ï�a¯C^æ�¶Nvk;FX��fA5;nS<é�GeXY;�¶>GN;Òé�� R =�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;=�æ�CkS�;F6:6"æ�;=�æ�;F6j;Gu?;çHGNbLæ�;F6�S<éKJH;FXlJké�Z�;�Ji6�C�a>? 4 ;D?�C<=ES<éFæ XN62CUG/? 4 ;O¶�æ�6�?x�l=/ç¢JH;F6<õ 354 ç76?�8�æ�G>65C<8N?£?�CIZ>;�éIS�C<GY?;çHGY8NC<8>6 R ?;çoèE;�- Ñ<���X×oÙ5��âFÙ`×hÓM×÷ð¢Õñ��;ÕZØ~Ûu���;Õ¢ã�Ó&w[éFæ�y<C�9I=�æ�CNS�;F6�6\�égS�CUGu?;çHGY8NC<8>6 R 6�=�éUS�;*é@G�éKJHC<bpC�a�¶>G/çH?�; R 6�?Xé�?�;mçoæ,æ:;FXY8>S�ç[ZYJH;ew[éFæ�y<C�9eS 4 é~çHG>6�`-é�G>Xb<;GN;<æZéKJO? 4 ;CVæ,êp\BS:a,õEwx;<êuG é�G>X 3 A5;;FXVçH;3FÄm r G2a�C^æ�? 4 ;nXVç76�SXæ:;?�; R ?;çoèE;qS<é<6�;�`�S<é�GZ>;I8>6�;FXx?�C-C<ZN?Zé~çHG'énS�;GY?,æZé|J�J�çoè�çH?�? 4 ;CVæ�;<è�ïjéKJHZ>;XçH?�A?çH? 4 CU8N?�;�vk=YJ�ç7S�çH?�9�é|J[8N;F6�C�aS�C<G>6�?Zé�GY? 6<õÓ lMk�Ô�k�Õ ÐÒÖ�Ð kv× ·u» î.â<��á�í�Õ�´pÜE· ñ�ìÅÓhÔPÕK��Õ Õí�ײÙ<ÓhÙfì â ^2\BÜj` â s Ù`Û/Ø<Ô ÓhÔPÑ^Ó^_F 'S(N\�Ü�`�G)u�^2\BÜj` F JHC<bD��ÑVã>´

a ~ ')(N\BÜ�`�?tøK\BÜ�`UJ[CUb��^�\BÜ�` F JHC<bD� 9Lê � q��D\�ê&`���?&s â ê â s¦������ ÝcÓ���Þß� �<�&�<�^�NÓ����W�q���O�t�N�>���<�<�&Ö��O��Ö^�>Óop; 4 éK9<;_6�;;Ge? 4 é�?P? 4 ;-JH;�a¯?,èPCu6�?I=/çLJ[;F6 4 éK9<;qCVæ XY;<ælJ[CUbQ�³S<éFæ�XN6<õÔ}Fç[G>S�;x? 4 ;<æ�;éFæ�;�CVæ XY;<æ � ßdw:à =/ç¢JH;F6<ï$éE?;êY=/ç7S<éKJ�=/çLJH;n6 4 CU8YJiX 4 éK9<;lC^æ XY;<æ�� ß-w�à S<éFæ XN6<õ�wxC^æ�;�=�æ�; RS�çi6j;�Jºê^ï&? 4 ;<æ�;7ç7659<;<æ,ê-b<CYCkX�æ�;¢éU6�C<Gq?�CIZ>;�J�çH;9<;I? 4 é�?5? 4 ;�S�;GY?,æZé|J�=/çLJ[;I6¤ç�J;F6 4 éK9<;�éXY;?�;<æ,è�çHG/ç76�?;ç7SI6 4 é�=�;�çHG_? 4 ;�J�çoè�çH?¢õ�ôßçHb<8�æ�;�m�ç¢JLJH8>6�?,æXé�?�;F6£? 4 ;�6 4 é�=�;^õ& k�×��ÍC� Ö Ã�lFÍ ·�· o ÙQ�rq s ÑVã>´IÜ�u�ú�� ßdw�à ©`âU��ì â ú â ókì\�'S(Y\BÜj` Ï \�ú)JHC<b àc `�� ß-w�à <�yU\B� ßdw�à `^ à F 'S(N\BÜj`�GùÏ yU\B� ßdw�à ` �o 4 é@? S<é�GcZ�;/;¢éU6¤çLJºêcXY;FXY8>S�;FXxaMæ�C^èÝyuGNC�ADG æ�;F6�8YJH? 6>ç76�é�GL��çHGu?:;b^æZé�?�;FX÷��9<;<æ 6¤çHC<GC�a�? 4 ;�é<6�6�;<æ�?�ç[CUGqC�a�í�C^æ�C�JLJkéFæ,ê[ñ^ñ^õÉji&Í0k�lFÍ�è · m�î.â<�$á�í�Õ�´�ì â r â óYì+ÑFÙ��rqts

\���>� ö>ß Çõ ^ ëN� ( ÛÂì�í ï ' ( \BÜ�`: ¡�q r àr ~ ñ¬< rr à �a���1¢¢¢¢¢¢

� ö>ß Çõ ^ ëN� ( ÛÂì�íÂï 'S(N\BÜj`V? r àr ~ ñ�< rr à � ¢¢¢¢¢¢"�#  ¡}q ìN��#%" ìN�

ó^ó

Page 23: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

¤^?7ç76�GNC<? 4 éFæ Xx?�CqXY;FXY8>S�; 354 ;C^æ�;<è ñ¢ó�aIæ:C^èd? 4 ;�çHGY?�;<æZé<S�?�ç[GNbq=�évæ�?;ç7S:JH;E=�æ�CYC�aOC�a\AF;Z_(HG_u óU� ß-w�à C<8N?jJÀçHGN;FX çHGp6�;FS�?;çHC<Gtm�õÄm�õ£¤^GpZ�æ;çH;�a,ï2\B¬Y`D6,é~êk6£? 4 é�?�é�?�?;çoèE;%*D? 4 ;Gu8�èIZ>;<æ C@a�=/çLJH;F6OA 4 Cu6�;5?�C<=IS<éFæ X 4 é<6�Jké�Z>;�J�JH;F6�62? 4 é�G êLç76+é@Z>C<8N?"ó F ê_*Zõ 354 8>6�a¯C^æ=/ç¢JH;�Ü2Ϥ£¥r�� ßdw�ঠïU? 4 ;D=/çLJH;�é�=N=>;¢évæ 6+é�?+é@Z>C<8N?�?;çoèE; � í� �mé@G>XI? 4 ;5Jké�Z�;�J)CUG�çH? 6 ?�CU=S<éFæ X-é�?O6j8NZ>6�;FT<8N;GY?5?;çoèE;F6§*$ç76}é�=N=�æ�CKvPçoèÅé@?�;�Joê/? 4 ; 6�C@J[8N?�ç[CUGAêEC@aßó F ê_*OÏjr�� ßdw�à õ354 ;IGu8�èIZ>;<æ�C@asS<éFæ XN6�é�?�?;çoèE;E�[çHGc=/çLJH;F6�?�C-? 4 ;lJH;�a¯?�C�aO=/çLJH;qÜ"ç76�? 4 ;<æ:;�a¯C^æ:;�? 4 ;Gu8�èIZ>;<æ�C@as=>Cvç[GY? 6�C�aO? 4 ;�6j=�é<S�; R ?;çoèE;Åå2CFç76�6jC<G_=�æ�CNS�;F6�6 ç[Gc? 4 ;�æ�;bvç[CUG 6 4 C|A£G�çHG¶>b<8�æ�; r ïYA 4 ç7S 4 ç76?é�=N=�æ�CKv/çºè�é�?�;�Joên? 4 ; éFæ:;¢é�C�a�? 4 é�?+æ�;bvç[CUG.ïuA 4 çiS 4 A5C^æ�yN6 C<8N?�é<6� í� ô ñ�< �� í ö �$õ

ì ñ

� í� ?� í (�Ö ¨¨¨¨©

ó F *�ê è r2� ßdw�à

Ï©ÐÒÑ Ã�lKÍcº2�íOC<G�À�;FS�?�8�æ�;�ñVñ$ç76W? 4 ; G�é@?�8�æZéKJ��:JHCNS<éKJ���S�C<8NGY?�;<æ�=�évæ�?W?�C 354 ;C^æ:;<è ñ¢ó�õ&¤�a�çHG>XY;;FX\ ')(N\BÜ�`�u@ª \Er `B� ßdw:à a�C^æs6jC^èE;�S�C<G>6�?Zé�GY? 61ª \�r0` ? 4 ;G-8>6¤çHGNbE? 4 ;�¶�æ 6�?�é<6:6�;<æ�?;çHC<G-C�a354 ;C^æ�;<è ñ~ó ª \�r0` Ï **«r � í� ô ñ¬< �� í ö Ï�r�JHC<b à� �

3 Cc=�æ�C�9<;-? 4 ;qS�C<G�ÀB;FS�?:8�æ�;q9^çkéc? 4 ;n=�æ�CUZ�é�Z/çLJÀçH?;ê�èE;? 4 CNXN6lC�a 6�;FS�?�ç[CUG¦m�õÄmqA5C<8YJ7Xç[GY9<C�JH9<;-é�G�é|JºêN6¤ç76�C�aO? 4 ;LçHGY?�;<æZé<S�?;çHGNb-=�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;n6;êN6�?�;<èAé<6�6�;;GcZPê�éP?Zé�bUb<;FXq=�éFæ R?;ç7S:J[;^õ?å"æ:;F6�8�èÅé�ZYJoêq? 4 ç76DS<é�GqZ�;/S<éFæ�æ;çH;FX-C<8N?DZ/êÅèECNXVçLaIêVçHGNbn? 4 ;�éFæ�b<8�èE;GY? 6�8>6�;FXFoñ¢îMGjçHG_? 4 ;�S�CUGu?�;�vN?DC�a ? 4 ;�6¤çoèE=YJH;-é<6;ê/è-èE;?�æ;ç7S�;�v�S:JH8>6¤çHC<Gc=�æ�CNS�;F6�6<õ����Q ÝcÓ���Þß� �<�&�<�^�NÓ����W�q���O�t�<�����W��Þ]��ÓF�3���^Ö��o'æ;çH?�;�¬&(pÏ¥'{­ Ú \Zñ�`5a�C^æ�? 4 ;-GY8�è/Z�;<æIC�a�S<éFæ XN67çHGt? 4 ;�æ;çHb 4 ?�èECu6�?l=/ç¢JH;^ï ? 4 é�?�ç76=/ç¢JH; Z_(jõ ¤¥aOAs;�å2Cvçi6:6�C<G/ç�J;^ï�çpõ�;^õ?æ:;=YJ²éUS�;/�cZ/êfé@GmçHG>XY;=>;G>XY;GY?�å2CFç76�6jC<GmæZé�G>XYC^è9�éFæ;çké�ZYJH;%8p\:*�` A?çH? 4 èE;¢é�G�*XïN? 4 ;G�çH??ç765GNC<? 4 éFæ X-?�CEXY;FXY8>S�;�? 4 ;�a¯C�JLJHC�A?çHGNbIJ�çoè�çH?

ó<m

Page 24: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

æ�;F6�8YJH?WaMæ�C^èÐ? 4 ;"çHGY?�;<æZé<S�?;çHGNb�=�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;5=�æ�CYC�a>C�aS\AF;Z_(HG�u ó<� ßdw�à CU8N?�J�ç[GN;FX çHGE6�;FS�?;çHC<Gm�õÄm�õÉji&Í0k�lFÍ�è · ¹ o Ù�*�qts

a \�¬t4 áN6 â Ïzü<`�q a \�¬ � Ï�üU` �WülÏ ñ<�ZóN��mN��F��ª$ÔPÕF�;Õ-ÓhÔPÕ�à�×hÖ�×hÓ®¬�� ØZÑ^ã'Ü�ÕI´^Õ<Ù<ØF�X×IÜ�Õ�´-ÑFÙ ©<â^àkà�â<ª$ÙF«¬�� Ï�¬l\Zñ�<W¯E\;°Fß°Fà`:`ª$ÔPÕF�;Õ,°Fß�Ñ^ã�´%°FàÅÑU��Õ�×kã�´^Õ���Õ¢ã>´VÕ¢ã�Ó�ª"×kÓhÔ�Õëí���â^ã�Õ~ã�ÓM×hÑ^ಱ�γn´V×oÙ<Ó��Z×MÜ<Û/ÓM×hâ^ãNì´¯E\dµ&`�´^Õëñã�â^ÓMÕ±ÙfÑ ò â^ײÙXÙ`â^ãÔ� «ið|«Ðª"×hÓhÔ Ö�ÕXÑ^ã µ�ì�ÑVã>´0¬l\ Í `EÏ '¶µ�\Zñ�`ÅײÙ�ÓhÔPÕ[ã�Û/Ö-Ü,ÕK�Åâj©��ÕXØXâ<��´FÙ ×hã[Ñq�;Ñ^ã>´^âVÖ���ÕK�ZÖ�Û/ÓMÑ^ÓM×kâVã'â�© Í ØZÑU�B´vÙë«354 8>6 × ©�¬&(nS�C<GY9<;<æ�b<;F6�çHGzXVç76�?�æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<G_? 4 ;Gq? 4 ;�JÀçoè�çH?�èI8>6�?5Z>;%¬��-ïNZN8N?£As;�XYCGNC<?�6�;;�é�Gq;¢é<6;ê-A�é¢êP?�CE;�v>S:J[8>XY;I? 4 ;P\^9<;<æ,ê¸çºèP=YJ²é@8>6¤çHZYJ[;�`�=>Cu6:6¤çHZ/ç¢J�çH?;êcC�a�éU6;êPèP= R?�C<?;ç7SDSXêNS:J�çiS£Z>; 4 éK9VçHC^æ¢õ5MD8�æ�=�æ�C<Z�é�Z/çLJ�ç76�?;ç7S�XY;F6�SXæ;çH=N?;çHC<G-C�a·¬��¿XYCY;F6 GNCU? ?,æZé�G>6�Jké�?:;?�CÅéE6¤çoèE=YJH;l;�vk=YJ�ç7S�çH?�a�C^æ,èI8YJké�ïYZN8N?#éETU8/çiS:y_6¤çoèI8YJké�?;çHC<G_bvç[9U;F6

ü ñ ó m r î · ëa \�¬��åÏ�üU` ìN�L¡ rUr ìN�oñF¬U® ìN� ì^îVì ìN� ì�ñKm ìN� ì^ìUm ìN� ì^ì�ñ¸ ¹p1%x§&ª_(�£�®°§£(Hº9�» �^~ �q�����>�xÓ|��Ö^���<�&�^�U�p�W��Þ]�>Ó}<;9<;<æZéKJOZ�CuC<yN6jFÄm^î/ïWm<®�G+é�G>XxAs;Zp6¤çH?�;F6�\�é<SS�;F6�6�ç[ZYJH;-9^çké é�GPêc6�;¢éFæ S 4 ;GNbFçHGN;�` éFæ:;XY;9<C<?�;FX�?�Cp6�C�J�çH?Zé~çoæ�;^õ å"é�?;çH;G>S�;_6�CVæ�?;çHGNbe\^C<G>S�;xC<GN; 4 é<6�æ�;¢éKJ�ç�J;FXÔ? 4 ;qC<=N?;çoèÅéKJ6�?,æZé�?:;b^ê>`}ç76�é�?;êu=/ç7S<éKJ"çHGp? 4 é@?�GNC_=YJké~ê<;<æ/S 4 CFç7S�;-ç76 ç[GY9<C�JH9<;FX ã çHGt? 4 ç76�æ�;F6�=�;FS�?�çH?æ�;F6�;<èIZYJH;F67í JHCkS:yE6�C�J�çH?Zé~çoæ�;^õ�¤^G í JHCkS:yn6�C@JÀçH?Zé�çºæ:;�çH?}ç76O;�JH;<èE;GY?ZéFæ�êE? 4 é�?�? 4 ; S 4 é�G>S�;C�aOA?çHGNG/çHGNb_A?çH? 4 é�GcC^æ XVçHG�éFæ�ê�î^ónS<évæ XcXY;FS�y çi6�ñ½¼PñFmNV56�;; � ;GNy/êuG>6Lé�G>X_wx8YJLJH;<æF ó�ñ~G&a�C^æ5a�8�æ�? 4 ;<æD;�JH;<èE;GY?ZéFæ,êmé�G�éKJoêN6¤ç76<õ354 ;<æ�; 4 é<60Z>;;G_6�8�æ�=�æ�çi6�ç[GNb@JºêPJ�çH?�?�JH;�6�;<æ;çHC<8>6�;�{WC^æ�?�?�C�é�G�é|JºêUJ;�C<? 4 ;<æD6�C�J�çH?Zé~çoæ�;bPéFèE;F6<õ 354 ;[èECY6�?²S�CVè-èEC<GÔbPéFèE;t\^C�a�?�;G³S<éKJLJ[;FXhÀB8>6�? Ù<â^à�×kÓMÑ^×÷�;ÕqC^æP��Ñ^ÓM×hÕ¢ã ØZÕë`çi6�=�æ�C<=>;<æjJºêeS<éKJLJH;FXj¾�à�â^ã�´^×HêFÕ�CVæ¿z�´^×kâVÓ6D Ù�À Õ~à�×¢�vÔPÓMõ 354 ç76 çi6�? 4 ;qbPéFèE;¸ç[GY9<C�JH9VçHGNb=YJ²éUS�ç[GNb[énS<évæ XxC�a+æZé�GNycÜOCUGÒéqS<éFæ X�C�a+æZé�GNycÜ�< ñlC�aOC<=N=>CY6¤çH?�;nS�C�JHC^æ�6�8/çH?¢ï.é�G>Xç[? ç76�? 4 ;I9�évæ;çké�Gu? çHG>S:J[8>XY;FXtA ç[? 4 w ç7SXæ�Cu6jC�a¯?�o4çHG>XYC�A�6<õ�å"é�?;çH;G>S�;n6�CVæ�?;çHGNb_S�C<8YJ7XZ>;I9^çH;A5;FX'é<67éq6¤çoèE=YJ�çL¶�S<é�?;çHC<GtC�aýg£JHC<G>XVçHy<;^õjg£J[CUG>XVç[yU;�çHGu9<C@J[9U;F6�=YJ²é~ê<;<æ�S 4 CFç7S�;^ïèÅé�yVç[GNbLçH? 4 éFæ XY;<æ5?�C�é�G�éKJoê0J;^ï�C^æO;9<;G-?�CLèECkXY;�JW9Vçké/S�CVèE=N8N?�;<æD6¤çoèI8YJ²é@?;çHC<G.õ op;

ó r

Page 25: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

XYCnGNC<?£yuGNC�A]? 4 ;IS 4 é@G>S�;�C�a A?çHGNG/çHGNb�ï&C^æ�? 4 ;�;�vk=�;FS�?�;FXx9�éKJH8N;IC�a ? 4 ;�9FéFæ;çké�GY?�çHGA 4 ç7S 4 ? 4 ;-=YJ²é~ê<;<æI6�?Zé�yU;F6�Á�î^ó�é@G>X[æ�;FS�;XçH9<;F6�Á�î-a�C^æl;¢é<S 4 S<éFæ Xc=YJké~ê<;FX a¯C^æ:A évæ Xjõ��é�ZNZ4F r ñ~G�6¤çoèI8YJ²é@?�;FX�éES�CVè-èEC<G-a�C^æ,èÂC�a�g£JHC<G>XVçHy<;Lç[GxA 4 ç7S 4 S<éFæ XN6�évæ�;�?�8�æ�GN;FXC|9U;<æ�? 4 æ�;;mé�?�éq?;çoèE;x\^A?çH? 4 C<GYJoêp? 4 ;E?�CU=gS<éFæ Xc;�vN=>CY6�;FX�` é�G>XfA 4 ;<æ�;PC<GN;nS<é�GSXêkS:JH;�? 4 æ�C<8Nb 4 ? 4 ;�XY;FS:y�çHG>XY;�¶>G/çH?�;�Joê^õ�} 4 ;£a¯C<8NG>X�? 4 é�? ? 4 ;�S�CVèE=N8N?�;<æOA5C<G�é�Z>C<8N?¬YÑ­C�aObPéFèP;F6�A 4 ;<æ�;¢é<6�6 4 ;IA5C<G'é�Z�C<8N?-ñ¢îYÑÅõ�¤�GpA5C^æ�y�çHGp=�æ�C<bVæ�;F6�6<ïWä>çké<S�C<G/ç76 R�DC�JoèE;F6 R g�C�JLJH;<æ�6�?�8>X/ê�èECkXY;<æ:GnbPévèE;�=YJké~êVç[GNb 4 ;8�æ;ç76�?;ç7S6#é@=N=YJÀçH;FX�?�C g£J[CUG>XVç[yU;^õå"æ�;�J�çoè�çHG�éFæ,ê�æ�;F6�8YJH? 6 6j8Nb<b<;F6�?"é�A?çHGI=�æ�C<Z�é�Z/çLJ�çH?�ê-éFæ:C<8NG>X-ñ¢îkÑÅõW¤¤æ�9^çHGNbjg�é�=YJké�G>6�y/ê\^=>;<æ 6jC<G�éKJ�S�C^è-èI8NG/ç7S<é�?;çHC<G&`+æ:;=>C^æ�?�6O=YJké~êVç[GNb�ó^ì^ì^ìlbPéFèP;F6 C�a�g£JHC<G>XVçHy<;IA?çH? 4 ? 4 ;æ�8YJH;F6�é@Z>C�9<;^ï<ZN8N?�éKJ76�ClA?çH? 4 éKJLJ�S<éFæ XN6�a éUS�;D8N=WV 4 ; 4 é<X-m^ë�õ{ëYÑ]A?çHG>6<õ�g�8�êYy<;G>X�éKJLJF óY¡6GW=�æ�;F6�;GY? 6�é�g£J[CUG>XVç[yU;¸éÂ)²S�çHC<G�é<XYC>ÃÄ6Q9^çH;AD=�CFçHGu?�C<Gq? 4 ;F6�;LèÅé�?�?:;<æ 6<õIQJ²évè é�G>Xqw[é�8YJ7XVçHGhFïm<mMG�çHGY9<;F6�?;çHbPé@?�;�C<=N?;çoèÅéKJ 6�?,æZé�?:;bFçH;F6"çHGcXVç¢{W;<æ�;GY?�;�v�éFè R=YJ[;F6£C�aW�S�C^èIZ/çHG�é�?�C^æ�ç²é|J�bPéFèE;F6�;�vN?,æZé<S�?:;FXPaIæ�CVè­=YJké¢êVçHGNb²S<évæ Xq6�C�J�çH?Zé~çoæ�;F6d��õ

à �HÀ�×�kCÄnÌHÍCÅ Ñ Í�èzÍ)× Ö Õ��2op;�? 4 é�GNy²��C<Z�ô�JHCFêNXÅé�G>X í�C�J�ç[Gcw[éKJLJ[C�A�60a�C^æ�XVç76 RS�8>6�6¤çHC<G>65C�a2? 4 ;XçoæDA5C^æ�yjïPé�G>X-w[éFæ�ynÎ çH?dJZ>;<æ�b�a¯C^æ�? 4 ;�6¤çoèI8YJké�?;çHC<G>65Z�; 4 ç[G>X²¶>b<8�æ�;m�õ

ó^î

Page 26: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

Æ £$ÇM£s(v£D%I.�£$�Foñ6G�ä�õ � õ¢ò£J7XYC<8>6?é�G>X-å$õ<ä>çké<S�C<G/ç76<õ&�#éFè�èE;<æ 6�JH;<ê&ÃÄ6$çHGY?�;<æZé<S�?;çHGNbl=�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;D=�æ�CNS�;F6�6

é�G>X�JHC<GNb<;F6�?}çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6�ç[GNbq6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;F6<õ ò �;âPÜ,Ñ/ÜF«Q¨.Ôk« � Õ¢àH«)î+×kÕ~àL´FÙ`ï ñ¢ì<mNV²ñF®<®M{ó�ñKm�ïjñF®<®^î�õ

F óHG��7õ�í#õ$ò7æ�GNC�J7Xjï5Î�õO�?éKJké�y/æ;ç76 4 G�é�G.ï�é@G>Xe��õÄÎLõOÎ7é�bPéFæXé�À�C�õ � ÕXØZâU�B´vÙ`õfo çLJH;<ê^ïñF®U®<¬�õ

FÄmHG � õD�?é~çHyjï�åõ ò�õDä�;XçLa�?¢ï�é�G>Xpg�õ � C 4 é@G>6�6�C<G.õÝMDG]? 4 ; XVç76�?�æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<G�C@a/? 4 ;JH;GNb<? 4 C�a5? 4 ;lJHC<GNb<;F6�?7çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6�ç[GNbc6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;nC@a+æZé�G>XYC^èù=�;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?;çHC<G>6<õ3 ;FS 4 G/ç7S<éKJ��5;=�C^æ�?�èÅé@? 4 õ�íDM,¼|®U¬�ñ¢ì�ñ¢ìVî�ïVÈ+Ètȧw[é�? 4 ò#æ�S 4 çH9<;^ï.ñK®<®<¬�õF r G � õD�?é~çHyjï�åõ ò�õDä�;XçLa�?¢ï�é�G>Xpg�õ � C 4 é@G>6�6�C<G.õÝMDG]? 4 ; XVç76�?�æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<G�C@a/? 4 ;JH;GNb<? 4 C�a>? 4 ;Q6j;FS�C<G>XLæ�C�AgC�aÌé�b�C<8NGNb�XVçké�b^æZéFè�8NG>XY;<æ�å�Jké�G>S 4 ;<æ:;�J�èE;¢é<6�8�æ�;^õ3 ;FS 4 G/ç7S<éKJ��5;=�C^æ�?�èÅé@? 4 õ�íDM,¼|®U®^ì�ñ^ñ^ñK¬�ïVÈ+Ètȧw[é�? 4 ò#æ�S 4 çH9<;^ï.ñK®<®<®�õF îHG � õ���é�ç[ymé�G>Xmð>õÄw õä�>é~çHG>6<õ+ò£JHb<;Z�æZé~ç7SLé<6�=>;FS�?�65C�a$ç[G>SXæ:;¢é<6¤çHGNb²6j8NZ>6�;FT<8N;G>S�;F6±õ3 ;FS 4 G/ç7S<éKJ��5;=�C^æ�?�èÅé@? 4 õ�íDM,¼|®U®^ì^î^ì<¬Um�ïVÈ+Ètȧw[é�? 4 ò#æ�S 4 çH9<;^ï.ñK®<®<®�õF ëHG � õ���é�ç[ymé�G>X ð�õÄw õ÷��é~çHG>6<õÉq�;GN;<æZé|JÀç�J;FX çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6¤çHGNbq6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;I=�æ�C<ZYJH;<èn6¤�¤Zõ é<6;ê/èE=N?�C<?;ç7S7æ�;F6j8YJ[?�6<õ 3 ;FS 4 G/ç7S<éKJ+æ�;=�C^æ�?¢ï íOCU8�æZé�GY?s¤�G>6�?;çH?�8N?�;^ï$ñF®<®U®�õFL¡�G�å$õ>��çLJLJÀçHGNbu6BJ[;<ê^õ�Þ+â^ã�ð¢ÕF���VÕ¢ã�ØXÕ�â�© ò ��â/Ü,ÑPܱ×kà�×hÓ�µ�ÐÒÕXÑFÙ<Ûu�;Õ±Ù`õ2o4çLJ[;<ê^ï$ñF®^ëU¬�õFĬHG�ò�õ���C^æ�CNXVçHG.õzÁ)C<GNb<;F6�? ç[G>SXæ:;¢é<6¤çHGNbg6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;F6IC�a7æZé�G>XYC^èüS�C�JHC^æ�;FXf=>;<æ R

èI8N?Zé�?�ç[CUG>6<õ 3 ;FS 4 G/ç7S<éKJ©�5;=>C^æ:?�èÅé�? 4 õ�í£M,¼|®<®^ì^óVì^ì�ñ^ï�ÈtÈ+È­w[é�? 4 ò#æ S 4 çH9<;^ïñF®U®<®�õFÄ®HG�ò�õz��C^æ:CkXVçHG.ï4ò�õfMDy<C<8NGNy<C�9jï é�G>X�q�õfM5J76 4 é�G>6�yVçpõ MDG é<6;ê/èE=N?�C<?�çiS6C�a å2Jké�G>S 4 ;<æ�;�J�èE;¢é<6�8�æ:;F6Ôa¯CVæ�6;ê/è-èE;?,æ;ç7S�b^æ:C<8N=>6<õ 3 ;FS 4 G/ç7S<éKJL�5;=�C^æ�?èÅé@? 4 õ�íDM,¼|®U®^ì^î^ì<mVó�ïVÈ+ÈtÈ¿wÒé@? 4 ò7æ S 4 çH9<;^ïñK®<®<®�õ

Foñ¢ìHG�ä�õ$í+æ�ç[?�S 4 JHC�A�õAIQJkéFè_ÃÄ6 èE;?,æ;ç7SFõP¤^G�Ê?ã�ØFµFØ~àÀâ ��Õ�´^×kÑ â�©-ÚjÓMÑ^ÓM×oÙ<ÓM×hØZÑ^à$ÚjØ¢×hÕ¢ã ØZÕ±Ù`ï9<C@J[8�èP;�®�ïN=�é�b<;F6£mY¡|®M{kmU¬^ì�õ<o4çLJH;<ê^ïñK®<¬<¬�õFoñ^ñ6G�ò�õsä�;cw[é<6¤çpï�ÎLõO¤;é�G/çoæ�C�ï7ò�õ�å2;�JLJH;b^æ;çHGNC<?�?�ç ï�é�G>X ð>õ�å�æ�;F6�8N?�?;çpõ òÿ6j8�æ�9<;<êC�aE? 4 ; 4 êNX/æ�CNX/êuG�éFè¸çiS<é|J�Z�; 4 éK9^çHC^æcC�a-èÅé�G/ê]=�éFæ:?;ç7S:J[;e6;êN6�?�;<èn6±õd¤�G � õÄÁ"õÁ&;Z�C�A?çH?dJfé@G>X ð>õ�o õ�wxC<GY?,æ�;�JLJpï ;FXVçH?�C^æ 6<ï1s�â^ã�Õ�Þ¢Û/×hàÀ×MÜ�X×hÛPÖ ò ÔPÕ~ã�â^Ö�Õ¢ã Ñ0z<z`äîW�;â^Ö ÚjÓMâ¢Ø±ÔPÑFÙ<ÓM×kرÙ#ÓMâ%-�µ|´U��âK´<µFã�Ñ^Ö�×hØ<Ù<ïY9<C�JH8�èE;�ñ^ñDC�a"ÚjÓMÛu´^×hÕ<Ù�×hãmÚÌÓMÑVÓM×oÙ<ÓM×kØXÑ^àÐ[ÕZرÔPÑ^ã�×hØ<Ù<ï<=�é@b<;F6�ñ¢ó<m+{�ó<® r õYÎDCVæ�? 4NR �£C�JLJ²é@G>Xjï�ò7èn6�?�;<æ�X�éFè�ïjñF®<¬ r õ

ó^ë

Page 27: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

Foñ¢óHG`��õ ä�8�æ,æ:;?�?¢õeM�æ�ç[;GY?�;FX�=>;<æ S�C�Jké�?�ç[CUG�çHGe?�AsCpXVçoèE;G>6¤çHC<G>6±õ¨.ÔPÕ@o�ã�ã Ñ^à{Ù¸âj©ò ��â/Ü,ÑPܱ×kà�×hÓ�µFïÌñ~óNVÄ®<®<®e{Òñ¢ì r ì�ïjñF®<¬ r õFoñFmHG`��õ�ä�8�æ,æ�;?�?¢õ ò �;âPÜ�ÑPܱ×kà�×hÓ�µvä ¨.ÔPÕXâ<��µ'Ñ^ã�´WÊ�í�Ñ^Ö£�Ìà�Õ<Ù<õÔo é<XN6�A5C^æ�? 4 ï�å"é<S�çL¶�Sq7æ�C�9<;�í}ò�ïjñF®<®�ñ^õFoñ r G`��õ�ð0GNb<;�JH;G.ï�å$õ 3 C^è-è�é<6�6�;G.ï�é�G>XPo õ�f ;<æ�9Fé^é�?¢õ2¤^bUG�é�?�C�9�Ãï6 ? 4 ;C^æ:;<è ã élGN;A

é�G>Xq6 4 C^æ�?D=�æ�CYC�a,õ1Ë�«�oQ�<�ÌàH« ò �;âPÜ�ÑPÜK«oï�ó^îFòIV ó^óU®M{�ó<m^ë�ï�ñF®<¬<¬�õFoñ¢îHG�å$õ ò�õ#ô�;<æ,æZéFæ;ç-é�G>X�Á"õ8��õ7q�õ�ôNC<GY?�;F6<õ å2Cvçi6:6�C<G/çké�GÃé�=N=�æ�CKv/çoèÅé�?;çHC<GÐa¯CVæ_? 4 ;?Zé@b<b<;FXÐ=�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;4ç[G é<6;ê/è-èE;?,æ�çiSÔ6¤çoèE=YJH;³;�v�S:JH8>6¤çHC<G.õ Ë>«jo5�U�ÌàH« ò ��â/Ü,ÑPÜK«oïm<m�V r ñ^ñ~{ r ñF®�ï�ñF®U®^ë�õFoñ¢ëHG�w õÄÁ"õ�ô�æ�;FX/èÅé�G.õÝMDG�S�C^èE=N8N?;çHGNb³? 4 ;cJH;GNb<? 4 C�a/? 4 ; J[CUGNb<;F6�?mçHG>SXæ�;¢éU6¤çHGNb6�8NZ>6j;FT<8N;G>S�;^õÉÀ ײÙ<ØF�;Õ¢ÓMÕLÐÒÑVÓhÔk«oïßñ^ñ<V ó<®+{km^î�ï�ñF®k¡�î�õFoñ�¡�G�¤XõÄw õ�q�;F6�6�;�JpõÂ}^ê/è-èE;?,æ;ç7S�a�8NG>S�?;çHC<G>6mé�G>X a�R æ�;FS�8�æ 6¤çH9<;GN;F6:6<õ�Ë>«�Þ}â^Ö-Ü<×hã�«¨.Ô/ÕZâ<��µ�ÚjÕF�«�o�ï�î<mNV{ó^îY¡6{�óU¬^î�ï�ñF®<®Vì�õFoñF¬HG � õïw õW�7éFè-èP;<æ 6�JH;<ê^õÅôßçoæ 6�? R =�é<6�6,é�bU;E=>;<æ S�C@J²é@?;çHC<G.õ�Ë�« � â<µ<«�ÚÌÓMÑ^ÓMײÙ`Ó^«�ÚÌâ¢Ø�«5Ì ï

ó<¬�V r ®�ñ~{ r ®^ë�ï�ñF®Vë^ë�õFoñF®HG � õïw õN�7éFè-èE;<æ�6�JH;<ê^õòÐa�;A 6j;;FXUJÀçHGNbu6�C@aæ�;F6�;¢éFæ�S 4 õ2¤^G ò �;â¢Ø|«�ÚÌ×ií�ÓhÔ�Ì�ÕF�:ê�Õ~àÀÕKµ

Ú&µ�Ö£�)«�ÐÒÑ^ÓhÔk« ÚÌÓMÑVÓM×oÙ<Ó^«?Ñ^ã�´ ò �;âPÜ,Ñ/Ü<×hàÀ×hÓ�µKìÎÍ â^à�ÛPÖ�Õ�ÎFï0=�é�b<;F6�m r îM{km<® r õ�I£G/ç R9<;<æ�6¤çH?�êPC�a�í?éKJ�ç¢a�C^æ�G/çké�å"æ�;F6:6<ï.ñF®Y¡Fó�õF ó^ìHG%q�õ � éFèE;F6?é�G>X-ä�õ�g�;<æ�Z>;<æ~õ�¨.ÔPÕ � Õj���;Õ<Ù<Õ¢ã�ÓMÑVÓM×kâ^ã�â�©�ÓhÔPÕ�Ú&µFÖ�Ö�Õ~Ó��Z×hØÐÏD�;â^Ûë�Ìõò�XNXVç76�C<G R op;F6�JH;<ê^ï��5;¢éUXVç[GNbqw ò�ïßñF®<¬�ñ^õ

F ó�ñ6G 3 õ ò�õ � ;GNy/êYG>6�é@G>X'ð�õ8� õ�wx8YJLJ[;<æ~õÅòÂ=�æ�CUZ�é�Z/çLJÀç76�?�çiSmé@G�éKJoêk6¤ç76lC�a�S:JHCkS:yp6�C�J�ç R?Zé�çºæ:;^õ+Ð[Ñ^ÓhÔk« ÐÒÑF�VÑV2`×hã�Õ~ï�î r V ó^ìVóM{�ó^ì<¬�ï�ñF®<¬�ñ^õF ó^óHG`g�õ � C 4 é�G>6�6�C<G.õ } 4 é�=�;E�>8>S�?�8�é�?;çHC<G>6 é�G>X4æZé�G>XYC^è è�é�?,æ;ç7S�;F6<õ 3 ;FS 4 G/ç7S<éKJ

æ�;=�C^æ�?¢ï÷�5CFêPé|J)¤�G>6�?¢õ 3 ;FS 4 GNC�JHC<b^ê^ï�}<?�CkS:y 4 C�Joè�ï.ñF®<®U®�õF ó<mHG�ÎLõ>Á"õ � C 4 G>6�CUGÒé�G>X }�õ�g�C<?-J^õ�Þ+â^ã�ÓM×hã�Û/â^ÛVÙ3Bã ×7ð~Ñ<�X×kÑ^ÓMÕ>À ײÙ`Ó��X×MÜ<Û/ÓM×kâ^ã�Ù ì5ð¢â^àïñ

Û/Ö�ÕÒÑVõ o4ç¢JH;<ê^ï$ñF®Y¡�ì�õF ó r GI}�õ f�õSg�;<æ�C�9�é�G>X ò�õïw õYf ;<æ 6 4 çHyÌõ7ò�6;ê/èE=N?�C<?;ç7S�? 4 ;C^æ,êqC�a ? 4 ;ES 4 éFæZé<S�?�;<æ�65C�a? 4 ;�6�êPè-èP;?,æ;ç7S�b^æ�C<8N=.õQî�Û/ã�Ø~ÓM×kâVã�Ñ^à÷o�ã Ñ^àH«SoQ�<�ÌàH«²ï.ñ¢îNV ó r ëM{�ó^îVî�ï�ñF®<¬�ñVõF ó^îHG��Lõ2g�;F6�?:;G.õtMDGe? 4 ;²6j=>;;FXtC�a�S�C<GY9<;<æ�b<;G>S�;�çHGt¶�æ 6j? R =�é<6�6,é@b<;E=>;<æ�S�C�Jké�?;çHC<G.õo�ã ã�«)o5�U�ÌàH« ò �;âPÜ�ÑPÜF«²ïNmNV ó<®^ë+{km<m<¬�ï�ñK®<®<m�õ

óY¡

Page 28: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

F ó^ëHG � õ �Lõ_g>çºè õeMDG çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6¤çHGNbe6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;F6EC@a#æZé�G>XYC^èü=�;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?;çHC<G>6<õgË>«Þ+âVָܱ×kã&«5¨ßÔPÕZâU� µ�ÚjÕF�«�o�ï)¡�ëNVoñ r ¬M{Ìñ¢î^î�ï�ñF®<®^ë�õF óY¡�G�í#õUg�8�êuyU;G>X�éKJLJ õ$ò�G�éKJoê0JXçHGNbn6jC�J�ç[?Xé~çoæ�;^õ"ÚjØ¢×hÕ¢ã�ØXÕ¢ï^óU¬<mY\�î r ì<mY` VL¡F® r {>¡F®^î�ï¢ô�;Z.õ�îñF®U®<®�õF ó<¬HG 3 õïw õYÁ çHb<b<;?�?~õ$zZã�ÓMÕK�;Ñ^Ø¢ÓM×hãu� ò Ñ<�XÓM×kØ~à�Õ�Ú&µ~Ù`ÓMÕ~Ö�Ù<õ�}<=�æ;çHGNb<;<æ R f ;<æ�Jké�b ïñF®U¬^î�õF ó<®HG��7õ ô?õNÁ&C<b/é�Gfé@G>X_Á"õ ò�õ�} 4 ;=N=.õ+ò�9�évæ;çké�?;çHC<G�éKJ�=�æ:C<ZYJH;<è­a�C^æ?æZé�G>XYC^è b�C<8NGNb?Zé@ZYJ[;¢é@8Yv�õ�o�´<ð~Ñ^ã�ØXÕ<Ù�×hãmÐÒÑVÓhÔk«oï ó^ëNV ó^ìVëM{�ó^ó^ó�ï�ñF®Y¡<¡PõFÄm^ìHG�¤XõOw[é<Sä�C<G�éKJ7XjõBÚ�µFÖ�Ö�Õ~Ó��Z×hØxî.ÛPã Ø¢ÓM×hâ^ã�ÙmÑ^ã>´g-�Ñ^àhà ò â^àLµFã�â^Ö�×hÑ^à{Ù`õÐM5vYa¯C^æ�XI£G/çH9<;<æ 6¤çH?;êfå�æ�;F6�6<ïßñF®Y¡|®�õFÄm�ñ6G�í#õïÁ"õWw[éKJLJ[C�A�6±õfå�æ�C<ZYJH;<è ëVó R ó�ïW=�é@?;çH;G>S�;²6�CVæ�?;çHGNb�õ Ú{z�o Ð � ÕFð¢×hÕFª"ï$îNVÄmY¡FîM{mY¡Fë�ïjñF®^ë<m�õFÄm^óHG�í#õïÁ"õ wÒé|J¢JHC�A�6<õ4å"é�?;çH;G>S�;_6�C^æ�?�ç[GNb õ@Ì�Û/àkàH«ÉzZã�Ù`Ó^« ÐÒÑVÓhÔk«¬o5�U�ÌàH«oïO®�V ó�ñ¢ëM{�ó^ó r ïñF®k¡|m�õFÄm<mHG`��õ�ä�õ�w[é�8YJ7XVçHG é�G>XÔ}�õÄw õ_I5JkéFè õ¦w[é�? 4 ;<èÅé�?�çiS<é|JQ=�æ:C<ZYJH;<èn6Åé@G>XtbPéFèE;F6<õo�´<ð�«SoQ�<�ÌàH«ßÐÒÑVÓhÔk«oï&¬NV óU¬�ñ~{km rUr ï�ñF®<¬Y¡/õFÄm r GI}�õ å$õ>wx;<êYG�é�G>X3� õÄÁ"õ 3 A5;;FXVçH;^õ>ÐÒÑ<�:ê�â<ð Þ"ÔPÑ^×hã�Ù�Ñ^ã>´�ÚjÓMâ¢Ø±ÔPÑFÙ<ÓM×kØ ÚÌÓMÑPܱ×kà�×hÓ�µ�õ}<=�æ;çHGNb<;<æ R f ;<æ�Jké�b�ï$ñF®<®<m�õFÄm^îHG�ò£JHZ>;<æ�?���õ�w_CVæ�; 4 ;¢é<Xmé�G>XÓq�;C�{.æ�;<ênwxC<?:? R }^è�çH? 4 õP¨.ÔPÕ�Þ+â^Ö£�Ìà�Õ¢ÓMÕ�Ì�â¢â@ê¸âj©Újâ^à�×kÓMÑ^×÷�;Õ�Ñ^ã�´ ò Ñ^ÓM×hÕ¢ã ØZÕ�Ï�Ñ^Ö�Õ<Ù<õO�?é�GY?ZéFè�ïjñF®Y¡�m�õFÄm^ëHG�ò�õÄw õWM�XUJoêUJy<C�ï �7õ.å2CuCUGN;G.ï��Lõ&o ç7XYC^è ïé�G>Xp�Lõ&o4çLJ¢a,õ-MDGp? 4 ;-XVçi6j?,æ;çHZN8 R?;çHC<GÔC�a�J[CUGNb<;F6�?�ç[G>SXæ:;¢é<6¤çHGNb¦6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;F6�çHG æZé�G>XYC^èý=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?�ç[CUG>6<õ³¤^Gå�æ�;=�éFæZé�?�ç[CUG.ïÌñK®<®<¬�õFÄmY¡�G�ò�õÄw õ�M�XUJºêUJy<C�é�G>X ð�õÄw õ÷��é~çHG>6<õ�MDGxJHC<GNb<;F6j??çHG>SXæ�;¢é<6¤çHGNb_6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;F67çHGæZé@G>XYC^èÂ=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé�?�ç[CUG>6<õ 3 ;FS 4 G/ç7S<éKJ"æ�;=>CVæ�?¢ï�ò 3�Ô�3 Á.é�Z>6<ï.ñK®<®<¬�õFÄm<¬HG�ò�õ&MDy<C<8NGNyUC|9jõ���é@G>XYC^è è�é�?,æ;ç7S�;F67é�G>XmæZé@G>XYC^è­=>;<æ�è/8N?Xé�?;çHC<G>6<õ 3 ;FS 4 G/ç7S<éKJ�5;=�C^æ�?�è�é�? 4 õ�íDM,¼�®<®^ì<m�ñ@¡�ë�ïVÈtÈ+È¿w[é�? 4 ò7æ S 4 çH9<;^ïßñF®<®<®�õFÄm<®HG�ä�éK9VçiX å"éFæ�?�JH;?�?~õ�Újâ^à�×kÓMÑV×7�;Õ�äOo#ØXÕ<Ù3B�� ÑVã>´�Õ/Ï^Ï0Ö�ÓhÔPÕK��Þ+Ñ<��´WÏ�Ñ^Ö�Õ±Ù`õ�å"é@G R? 4 ;CUG.ïÌñK®Y¡|®�õF r ìHGI}�õ�å çLJ[=�;�Jpõ�ä�;F6�S�;G>XVçHGNb_6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;F6�C�a+æZé�G>XYCVè­=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé@?;çHC<G>6<õtË>«}Þ+â^Ölñܱ×kã Ñ^ÓMâ<�X×kÑ^àQ¨.Ôk«�oLï�îUmNVÄ®^ëM{jñ^ñ¢ë�ï ñF®<®^ì�õ

ó<¬

Page 29: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

F r ñ6G�ò�õ���é�ZNZ.õ�òÂ=�æ�C<Z�é@Z/ç¢J�ç76�?;ç7Smé�G�é|JºêN6¤ç76�C@as? 4 ;Eb/éFèE;IC�aQ6jC�J�ç[?Xé~çoæ�;^ï+ñF®U¬<®�õjIDG RXY;<æ�bVæZé<XY8�é�?�;��£C<GNC^æ 6 3Q4 ;F6¤ç76<ï��7éFæ�9FéFæ XjõF r óHG�ð>õFw õ���é~çHG>6<õU¤^G>SXæ�;¢é<6�ç[GNb�6j8NZ>6�;FT<8N;G>S�;F6}é�G>X�? 4 ;OS:J²éU6�6¤ç7S<éKJ>b^æ�CU8N=>6<õ�Ê�à�ÕXØ¢Ó��;â^ã�«Ë>«}Þ+â^Ö-Ü<×hã�ÑVÓMâ<�Z×hØ<Ù<ï�îNV8��ñ~ó�ïjñF®<®<¬�õF r mHG��LõS�5Cu6j?¢õ ÎDC<GN;FTU8/çLJ�ç[Z�æ�ç[8 èþZ�; 4 éF9VçHC^æDC�a+é�èÅé@GPê-=�éFæ�?;ç7S:JH;�=�æ:CkS�;F6�6ëVOä�;G>6¤çH?;ê=�æ�C@¶NJ[;[é�G>XtJHCNS<éKJ�;FT<8/çLJ�çHZ�æ;çH8�è�õØ×�« é ÑFÔu��Ù`رÔk«�Í ÕF��ªO«�Ï�Õ�ܱ×kÕ~ÓMÕ¢ï?î<¬NV r ñ�{�î<m�ï

ñF®U¬�ñ^õF r<r G��7õ ð>õO}Pé@bPé�G.õ¿¨ßÔPÕ Ú�µFÖ�Ö�Õ~Ó��Z×hØWÏD�;â^Ûë��ä � Õ����;Õ<Ù<Õ¢ã ÓMÑ^ÓM×hâ^ã�Ù�ì�Þ}â^Ö-Ü<×hã�Ñ^ÓMâ<�X×hÑ^ào�à��Vâ<�Z×hÓhÔPÖLÙ�Ñ^ã>´�Ú&µ�Ö�Ö�Õ¢Ó��X×hØ�î.Û/ã�Ø~ÓM×kâ^ã�Ù`õ�o é<XN6�A5C^æ:? 4 ïjñF®<®�ñ^õF r îHG�í#õ�}uS 4 ;G>6j?�;FXjõ�Á&CUGNb<;F6�?"çHG>SXæ�;¢éU6¤çHGNbÅé�G>X-XY;FSXæ�;¢é<6¤çHGNbE6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;F6<õ7Þ+Ñ^ã Ñ<´u«Ë>«ßÐÒÑ^ÓhÔN«oï.ñKmNVoñ�¡|®+{ÌñF®�ñ^ï�ñK®^ë�ñ^õF r ëHG 3 õ�}<;=N=HGéKJ;Gé~çHGN;G.õO�>êkX/æ�CNX/êYG�éFè�ç7S�6�S<éKJ�çHGNb�ïNS�C<GY9<;�v²XY8�éKJ�çH?;êfé�G>X�é<6;ê/èE=N?�CU?;ç7S6 4 é@=>;F6 C@a�b^æ�C�AD? 4 èECNXY;�J76<õ$ÐÒÑ<�:ê�âUð ò �;â¢ØXÕ<ÙXÙë« � Õ~àÀÑVÓMÕ ´�î+×kÕ~ࢴvÙ`ï r V²ñ~{�ó^ë�ï/ñF®<®U¬�õF r ¡�G`��õ�}<?Zé@GYJ[;<ê^õ1Ê?ã�Û/Ö�ÕK�;Ñ^ÓM×7ð~Õ-Þ+âVָܱ×kã Ñ^ÓMâ<�X×kر٠ì,Í�âVà[«�Ñ^õ}í�éFèIZ�æ;ç7XYb<;�I£G/ç[9U;<æ 6¤çH?;ê

å�æ�;F6�6<ïjñF®<®U®�õF r ¬HG`��õLåõl}<?Zé@GYJ[;<ê^õÙÊ�ã�Û/Ö�ÕF�;Ñ^ÓM×÷ð¢ÕBÞ+â^Ö-Ü<×hã�Ñ^ÓMâU�Z×hØ<Ù�ì�Í â^à�z «ýo é<XN6�A5C^æ�? 4ÚÔ�}æ�CYC<yN6 ¼^íOC�JH;^ïNwxC<GY?�;<æ�;<ê^ï í�éKJ�çLa¯CVæ�G/çké�ïñK®<¬^ë�õF r ®HG�ä�õU}<?Zé�GY?�C<G-é�G>XEä�õ�o 4 çH?�;^õ}Þ+â^ã�Ù`Ó��XÛPØ~ÓM×7ð~Õ�Þ}â^Ö-Ü<×hã�Ñ^ÓMâ<�X×hØ<Ù<õSIDG>XY;<æ:b^æZé<XY8�é�?:;3 ;�vk?�6}çHGzw[é�? 4 ;<èÅé@?;ç7S6<õ�}<=�æ;çHGNb<;<æ R f ;<æ�Jké�b�ï$ñF®<¬Vë�õF î^ìHG�í#õ ò�õ 3 æZé<SXê'é�G>Xt��õ�o4çiXYCVè�õqÁ&;9<;�J R 6�=�é<S�çHGNbgXVç76�?,æ�ç[ZN8N?�ç[CUG>6-é�G>Xf? 4 ;-ò>çºæ�êy<;<æ:GN;�J õ Þ+â^Ö�ÖE«ßÐÒÑ^ÓhÔk« ò Ôuµ~ÙF«oïjñ¢îU®NVoñ¢î�ñ�{Ìñ�¡ r ï�ñK®<® r õF î�ñ6G�í#õ ò�õ 3 æZé<SXê é�G>X§�LõIo4ç7XYC^è�õ ��é�G>XYC^è 8NG/çH?Zévæ,êÃèÅé@?,æ;ç7S�;F6<ï-=>;<æ,èI8N?Zé R?;çHC<G>6Lé�G>X'å}é~çHGYJ[;91�;^õ 3 ;FS 4 G/ç7S<éKJ©�5;=>CVæ�?�èÅé�? 4 õ�í£M,¼|®<¬�ñ^ñVñ¢î r ïCÈtÈtÈ w[é�? 4

ò7æ S 4 ç[9U;^ï.ñF®<®<¬�õF î^óHG�í#õ ò�õ 3 æXé<SXê'é�G>Xc��õ&o4ç7XYC^è�õ-MDGt? 4 ;EXVç76�?,æ;çHZN8N?;çHC<GtC�aD? 4 ;lJH;GNb<? 4 6�C@as? 4 ;JHC<GNb<;F6j?ÅèECUGNC<?�C<GN;c6�8NZ>6�;FTU8N;G>S�;F6�ç[G æZé@G>XYC^è A5C^æ�XN6<õ 3 ;FS 4 G/ç7S<éKJx�5;=�C^æ�?

èÅé@? 4 õ�íDM,¼|®U®^ì r ì r ó�ïVÈ+ÈtÈ¿wÒé@? 4 ò7æ S 4 çH9<;^ïñK®<®<®�õF î<mHGI}�õÄw õ�I5JkéFè õ-}<C^èE;Lç7XY;¢é<6�é�G>Xx=�æ�Cu6�=�;FS�? 67çHGpZ/çHC^èÅé@? 4 ;<èÅé�?;ç7S6<õ o ã�ã�« � ÕKð|«Ì�×hâ���Ôuµ~ÙF«�Ì ×hâ¢Õ~ãu�Y«oïjñ<V ók¡<¡6{�ó<®Vó�ï�ñF®Y¡�ó�õ

ó<®

Page 30: CDFE GIH'JLKMH NPO.Q R - Stanford Universitycgates/PERSI/papers/Longest.pdf · ,0 1 2 034 ,576 89$ ;:< 6 = >2- ? a@b2 $ $(cdfe gih'jlkmh npo.q r clsft dvuxwzy[sf\ w7n^]7_ w`dvwzgmq

F î r G`��õ)f ;GNy�é@? 6�8NZ�æZéFè�é�G/çpõ9-�µ�´<�;âF´<µFã Ñ^Ö�×kØ u ×hÖ�×hÓ�©`âU��ÓhÔ/Õ`o�ÙµFÖ�Ö�Õ~Ó��Z×hØ%Ê�í�Ø¢à�ÛUñÙ<×kâVã ò �;â~ØZÕ±ÙZÙ�ª"×hÓhÔ�À Õ~ÓMÕF�XÖ�×hã�ײÙ<ÓM×kØ�zZã ×kÓM×hÑ^àCÀ�Ñ^ÓMÑmÑ^ã�´ÅÓhÔ/Õ9-�Ñ^Ö�Ö�ÕF��Ù`à�ÕKµ ò �;â�ñØXÕ<ÙXÙ âVã3' ß õ}å 4 ä�? 4 ;F6¤ç76<ï�ÎD;Apb CVæ�y>I£G/çH9<;<æ 6¤çH?;ê^ï$ñF®<®^î�õ

F î^îHG�ò�õÄw õUf ;<æ 6 4 çHyÒé�G>X }�õ f�õSg�;<æ�C�9Ìõ}ò�6;êPèP=N?�C<?;ç7S65C�aO? 4 ;�å2Jké�G>S 4 ;<æ�;�J+èE;¢é<6�8�æ:;C�a ? 4 ;I6;êPè�èE;?,æ;ç7Slb^æ�C<8N=�é@G>X_? 4 ;�J�çoè�çH?;çHGNbqa�C^æ,è­C�a�b�C<8NGNb-?Zé�ZYJH;F6<õ ÚÌâ<ð~×kÕ~ÓÐ[Ñ^ÓhÔk«¶À�â�ê�àH«²ï�ñF¬�V î^óY¡6{�î<m�ñ^ï^ñK®Y¡<¡Põ 3 æZé�G>6BJ²é@?;çHC<GnC@a)ä�C<yUJpõ^ò�S<é<XjõuÎ7é�8NyjõY}N}N}0�ó<mUmE\XñF®Y¡<¡<`?ñ¢ì^ó rUR ñ¢ì^óY¡Põ

F î^ëHG�ò�õÄw õSf ;<æ�6 4 çHy*é@G>Xt}�õ f�õ�g�;<æ�C�9ÌõLò 6�êPèE=N?:C<?;ç7SlZ>; 4 éK9^çHC^ælC�as? 4 ;-èÅéKv/çoè/8�èé�G>X-bU;GN;<æ;ç7S�XVçoèE;G>6¤çHC<G>6£C�a.çoæ,æ�;FXY8>S�çHZYJH;-æ�;=�æ:;F6�;Gu?Xé�?;çHC<G>65C�a2? 4 ;�6;ê/è-èE;?,æ;ç7Sb^æ:C<8N=.õ�î�Û/ã�Ø~ÓM×kâVã�Ñ^à÷o�ã Ñ^àH«SoQ�<�ÌàH«²ï.ñF®NV ó�ñ~{km�ñ^ï�ñK®<¬^î�õ

F îY¡�G�w õL}�õKo é�?�;<æ�èÅé�G�é@G>X/w õMf�çHGNb^æ:C<G.õ�}<;FT<8N;G>S�;�S�C^èE=�éFæ�çi6jC<GE6¤çHb<G/çL¶�S<é�G>S�;#é�G>Xå0CFç76�6�C<G�é�=N=�æ:CFv/çoèÅé�?;çHC<G.õ ÚÌÓMÑ^ÓMײÙ`Ó^«�ÚÌØ~×kÕ~ã�ØXÕ¢ïN®NVÄmVëY¡6{km<¬�ñ^ï�ñF®<® r õ

m^ì